In light of the Henneaux-Teitelboim action

arXiv:2611.07180 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-11-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "In light of the Henneaux-Teitelboim action".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U We show that such an action exists only if there is another commuting light-like conformal Killing vector V with properties that can be realized by the Dirac currents of two conformal Killing spinors We extend the action to the (1, 0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet.

Kai: Construction of the Action Framework The paper begins by constructing an action for an abelian selfdual tensor field H = dB in six dimensions where two lightlike directions are separated from the remaining four transverse directions The Lagrangian density is defined as a sum of three terms L = -LI - LII - LIII.

Mira: The Weyl invariance of each term is ensured by appropriate insertions of the normalization function N whose Weyl transformation is the same as that of the metric tensor.

Kai: Geometric Setup with Lightlike Vectors The geometric setup involves introducing a lightlike vector field U and another lightlike vector field V such that they have an everywhere nonvanishing inner product N = gMN UMV.

Title and authors: Kai: We're starting by looking at the title and who wrote this paper. It’s "In light of the Henneaux-Teitelboim action" and it’s by Andreas Gustavsson from the Physics Department at the University of Seoul.

Mira: Yeah, so when you look at that title, it immediately tells you they're connecting their work to that classic setup by Henneaux and Teitelboim from one thousand nine hundred eighty-eight <ref:2611.07180#pg1>. It sets a baseline for what they are trying to do here.

Lev: From my side, I'm interested in the fact that they are working in six dimensions, which is often where things get really tricky when you start with these types of field theories and gauge symmetries like self-duality.

Kai: Right, and it hints that the geometry has to be quite specific for this action to exist. They aren't just looking at any arbitrary six dimensional spacetime; they have to be constrained by these lightlike Killing vectors.

Mira: And that constraint is what makes the whole setup interesting for us theorists. It’s not just a simple action; it’s tied to very specific geometric properties of the background spacetime.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what does the paper actually say they constructed? They build an action for an abelian selfdual tensor field, which is called H equals d B in six dimensions.

Mira: And they define it as a sum of three terms, LI minus LII minus LIII ><ref:2611.07180#pg2>> They ensure that each of those three parts is Weyl invariant by using this normalization function N.

Lev: I see them setting up the geometry with two lightlike vectors, U and V, which have a nonvanishing inner product N equals g M N U M V ><ref:2611.07180#pg3>>. That expansion of the metric into P and Q projections is a key part of how they organize the spacetime.

Kai: Right, so they are using this specific geometric decomposition to define where things live in the four transverse directions versus the two lightlike ones.

Mira: And then they derive these equations of motion by varying the gauge potential, which leads to a total variation that has some specific geometric conditions that have to be met for it all to vanish ><ref:2611.07180#pg2>>

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out some really important things they found regarding the necessary conditions. They find that for the total variation of the Lagrangian to actually vanish under generic gauge transformations, you need very specific geometric conditions.

Mira: And they mention these conditions like LV over the square root of negative g equals Omega V over the square root of negative g and LU over the square root of negative g equals Omega U over the square root of negative g ><ref:2611.07180#pg2>> These aren't just random requirements; they are necessary for consistency.

Lev: On the hardware side, I think that’s where things get hard. For these equations to work out cleanly, you need those geometric conditions on U and V to be really strict, like requiring them to be conformal Killing vector fields ><ref:2611.07180#pg2>>

Kai: And the paper suggests that if you want a purely bosonic theory of a selfdual three-form gauge field in a two plus four formulation, those geometric conditions have to emerge naturally from the setup.

Mira: Exactly. They state that this necessity comes from applying the two plus four formulation to that specific purely bosonic theory ><ref:2611.07180#pg2>> It suggests that finding an action like this in curved spacetime might require restricting the spacetime geometry somewhat, which they find surprising because Maxwell's action works on any Lorentzian six dimensional manifold.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, what’s the big picture here? The paper shows that when you introduce supersymmetry, it naturally explains those geometric conditions they found earlier.

Mira: It does because supersymmetry requires two specific types of spinors called symplectic-Majorana-Weyl conformal Killing spinors ><ref:2611.07180#pg2>> And this is a big piece of the puzzle for understanding why these constraints appear in the first place.

Lev: From a computational standpoint, I see that if you try to run this on real hardware, you have to account for all this constraint checking on U and V because they have to satisfy those Killing vector requirements ><ref:2611.07180#pg2>>

Kai: And finally, they show that the two ways of writing the tensor field equations of motion are actually identical, T MNP I equals T MNP II ><ref:2611.07180#pg1>> which is a nice consistency check.

Mira: This identity leads them to a gauge choice where all those complicated integrated equations simplify down to T equals zero, which gives us the selfduality equation H equals d star H ><ref:2611.07180#pg2>>

University of Seoul

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-11-04

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: 15 pages

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike…

Key concepts

Lightlike Conformal Killing Vector
These are special vector fields in spacetime that have a lightlike inner product with themselves and preserve the conformal structure. In this paper, two such vectors, U and V, are crucial for defining the geometry of the action and imposing necessary constraints on the theory.
2 + 4 Formulation
This is a specific mathematical framework used to describe theories involving self-dual fields in six dimensions. The paper shows that applying this formulation to a purely bosonic theory necessitates strict geometric requirements for the lightlike vectors U and V.
(1, 0) Supersymmetric Extension
This involves adding supersymmetry to the bosonic action by introducing a real scalar field and two symplectic-Majorana Weyl spinors. The paper demonstrates that the consistency of the supersymmetric extension imposes further geometric constraints on U and V, linking them to conformal Killing spinors.
Generalized Gauge Symmetry
This is an extended symmetry where the gauge variation is not simply closed but governed by a specific equation (60). This symmetry allows integration constants in the equations of motion to be treated as gauge parameters, simplifying the complex integrated equations to T = 0.

Terminology

Summary

We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U We show that such an action exists only if there is another commuting light-like conformal Killing vector V with properties that can be realized by the Dirac currents of two conformal Killing spinors We extend the action to the (1, 0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In light of the Henneaux-Teitelboim action Andreas Gustavsson Physics Department, University of Seoul, Seoul 02504 KOREA Abstract We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U. We show that such an action exists only if there is another commuting light-like conformal Killing vector V with properties that can be realized by the Dirac currents of two conformal Killing spinors.

Construction of the Action Framework

The paper begins by constructing an action for an abelian selfdual tensor field H = dB in six dimensions where two lightlike directions are separated from the remaining four transverse directions The Lagrangian density is defined as a sum of three terms L = -LI - LII - LIII. The Weyl invariance of each term is ensured by appropriate insertions of the normalization function N whose Weyl transformation is the same as that of the metric tensor. p. 3

Where the paper says it

3 The action We will make the following ansatz for the action S = Z d 6xL (14) where we take the Lagrangian density to be a sum of three terms L = −LI − LII − LIII (15) where LI = √ −g 24 H2 MNP LII = − √ −g 8N F MN GMN LIII = − √ −g 96 ε MNP RST FMN UP N + GMN VP N HRST (16) Here we define FMN = HMNP V P GMN = HMNPU P (17) We require the action to be Weyl invariant. The action above is constructed so that each term is Weyl invariant by appropriate insertions of the normalization function N whose Weyl transformation is the same as that of the metric tensor, gMN → e 2σ gMN N → e 2σN (18) We will now obtain the equations of motion from this action by varying the gauge potential.

Geometric Setup with Lightlike Vectors

The geometric setup involves introducing a lightlike vector field U and another lightlike vector field V such that they have an everywhere nonvanishing inner product N = gMN UMV. The metric tensor is expanded as gMN = 1/N (UMVN + VMUN) + geMN. p. 2

Where the paper says it

ΩU := ∇MU M (4) Given these two lightlike vector fields, the metric tensor may be expanded as gMN = 1 N (UMVN + VMUN ) + geMN (5) By contracting both sides with V N and using that V is lightlike it follows that geMN V N = 0 and similarly by contracting with U N and using that U is lightlike, we get geMN U N = 0. The inverse metric can likewise be expanded as g MN = 1 N (U MV N + V MU N ) + ge MN (6) and again one can show that geMN VN = 0 and geMN UN = 0.

This expansion leads to the identification of projections P and Q, where P projects onto the four-dimensional transverse space orthogonal to the two lightlike vectors U and V and Q projects onto the space spanned by U and V. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The inverse metric can likewise be expanded as g MN = 1 N (U MV N + V MU N ) + ge MN (6) and again one can show that geMN VN = 0 and geMN UN = 0. We also can show that ge MN geNP = P M P (7) where P M P = δ M P − Q M P Q M P = 1 N (U MVP + V MUP ) (8) Here P projects onto the four-dimensional transverse space orthogonal to the two lightlike vectors U and V and Q projects onto the space spanned by U and V .

Derivation of Equations of Motion

The equations of motion are obtained by varying the gauge potential, resulting in a sum of three variations: δLI, δLII, and δLIII. The vanishing of the total variation requires imposing geometric conditions such as LV/sqrt(-g) = omegaV/sqrt(-g) and LU/sqrt(-g) = omegaU/sqrt(-g), along with LVUPN = 0 and LUVP N = 0. p. 1

Where the paper says it

However, due to certain geometric conditions that we obtain here, we do not expect this approach to be completely straightforward [10]. 2 Two lightlike vector fields We would like to obtain an action for a selfdual three-form tensor field in six-dimensions that is of a similar type as the action that was obtained by Henneaux and Teitelboim [1] on a generic Lorentzian six-manifold, but where we instead of taking time along a timelike direction, will let time be along a lightlike direction.

Under these conditions, the variation reduces to δLI + δLII + δLIII = 1/8 LV/sqrt(-g)6 εMNP RST HMNP UR/N + sqrt(-g)HRSTUR/N + LU/sqrt(-g)6 εMNP RST HMNP VR/N + sqrt(-g)HRST VR/N-2 sqrt(-gPTQ ∇RHRSQ /delta BST.

Supersymmetric Extension and Constraints

The (1, 0) supersymmetric completion involves one real scalar field ϕ and two symplectic-Majorana Weyl spinors λI for I = 1, 2 transforming as a doublet under an SU(2) R symmetry. The supersymmetry variations of the matter part of the action are found to be related to the variation of the tensor field part, leading to δL = δLtensor + δLmatter = 0. p. 6

Where the paper says it

4 Summing up the three variations Let us sum up the three variations that we have got, δLI + δLII + δLIII = " LV √ −g 48 ε MNP RST HMNP UR N + √ −g 8 HRSTUR N +LU √ −g 48 ε MNP RST HMNP VR N + √ −g 8 HRST VR N + √ −g 96 ε MNP RST HMNRLV UP N + HMNRLU VP N − 1 8 LV √ −g − ΩV √ −g GST N − 1 8 LU √ −g − ΩU √ −g F ST N − √ −g 4 P T Q ∇RHRSQ# δBST (33) We now see that in order for this variation to vanish we must impose the following geometric conditions, LV √ −g = ΩV √ −g LU √ −g = ΩU √ −g LV UP N = 0 LU VP N = 0 (34) When these geometric conditions are satisfied, the variation reduces to δLI + δLII + δLIII = 1 8 " LV √ −g 6 ε MNP RST HMNP UR N + √ −g HRSTUR N +LU √ −g 6 ε MNP RST HMNP VR N + √ −g HRST VR N −2 √ −gPT Q ∇RHRSQ# δBST (35) It is also useful to rewrite this variation as δL = 1 4 E ST δBST (36) where E MN = LV √ −g LMNPUP N + LU √ −g LMNP VP N + 2√ −gP[M Q ∇RL N]QR (37) For any tensor XMN we have LV ( √ −gXMN ) = ∇P ( √ −gV P XMN ) + √ −g(XNP ∇P V M − XMP ∇P V N ) (38) By applying this formula, we have obtained after some computations the result E MN = ∇R √ −g 3Q [R P L MN]P − 2L MNR + √ −gL[N|P R UP RV M] + VP RU M] (39) but by the result in appendix B, the second line vanishes identically.

This implies that for a purely bosonic theory, two lightlike vector fields U and V must be conformal Killing vector fields and their curvatures dv and du must be selfdual and anti-selfdual respectively in transverse space. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We also can show that ge MN geNP = P M P (7) where P M P = δ M P − Q M P Q M P = 1 N (U MVP + V MUP ) (8) Here P projects onto the four-dimensional transverse space orthogonal to the two lightlike vectors U and V and Q projects onto the space spanned by U and V . Nothing in this exposition so far requires these vector fields to be conformal Killing vector fields.

Conclusion on Formulation Validity

The paper concludes that the geometric conditions are naturally explained if supersymmetry is present, as it requires two symplectic-Majorana-Weyl conformal Killing spinors. The necessity of the 2 + 4 formulation arises when applying the 2 + 4 formulation to a purely bosonic theory of a selfdual three-form gauge field. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Although these recent developments based on Sen’s approach seem distinct from the PST formulation, it was shown in [9] that two PST actions can be mapped to Hull’s action. By the work of [6] one may obtain the PST action from the Hamilonian of a non-selfdual tensor field that leads to the HT action and the PST action.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Although these recent developments based on Sen’s approach seem distinct from the PST formulation, it was shown in [9] that two PST actions can be mapped to Hull’s action. By the work of [6] one may obtain the PST action from the Hamilonian of a non-selfdual tensor field that leads to the HT action and the PST action.

This suggests that the existence of such an action in curved spacetime requires restricting the spacetime geometry somewhat. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We will examine whether we can construct an analog of the HT action when the time direction is taken to be along a lightlike direction. We follow the spirit of original formulation of Henneaux and Teitelboim where we will accept an explicit breaking of the Lorentz group in flat Minkowski spacetime of the action and proceed to obtain a curved spacetime generalization.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

We will examine whether we can construct an analog of the HT action when the time direction is taken to be along a lightlike direction. We follow the spirit of original formulation of Henneaux and Teitelboim where we will accept an explicit breaking of the Lorentz group in flat Minkowski spacetime of the action and proceed to obtain a curved spacetime generalization.

Equivalence of Equations of Motion

The two expressions for the tensor field equations of motion, T MNP I = 2LMNP - 3Q[M Q L NP]Q and T MNP II = 2L MNP + 3V[ML]NP U + 3U[ML]NP V are shown to be identical. This equivalence is established by expanding the Lagrangian terms and showing that the difference vanishes when components proportional to UMVN are canceled.

Final Result on Self-Duality

By matching the integration constants with generalized gauge parameters, it is shown that a particular gauge choice reduces the integrated equations of motion to T = 0. This leads directly to the selfduality equation of motion L = 0, which is nothing but the selfduality equation of motion H = ∗H. p. 8

Where the paper says it

We will then show that this generalized gauge symmetry variation, which does not have to be infinitesimal but can be arbirarily large because the theory is abelian, enables us to match the integration constants X that can be arbitrarily large with these generalized gauge parameters. In this way we are able to view the integration constants as gauge parameters and see that in a particarly chosen gauge the integrated equations of motion become T = 0 (55) It is then a small step to show that this leads directly to the selfduality equation of motion for H = ∗H (56) It is in this sense with the help of a generalized gauge symmetry, that we can say that we derive the selfduality equation of motion from the action.

Generalized Gauge Symmetry

The action possesses a generalized gauge symmetry δB = Λ where Λ itself is not closed but instead this condition is replaced by equation (60) under which H has a nonvanishing generalized gauge variation. This symmetry allows the integration constants to be viewed as gauge parameters, enabling the reduction of the complicated integrated equations of motion to T = 0. p. 8

Where the paper says it

We will then show that this generalized gauge symmetry variation, which does not have to be infinitesimal but can be arbirarily large because the theory is abelian, enables us to match the integration constants X that can be arbitrarily large with these generalized gauge parameters. In this way we are able to view the integration constants as gauge parameters and see that in a particarly chosen gauge the integrated equations of motion become T = 0 (55) It is then a small step to show that this leads directly to the selfduality equation of motion for H = ∗H (56) It is in this sense with the help of a generalized gauge symmetry, that we can say that we derive the selfduality equation of motion from the action.

Integrated Equations and Constraints

The integrated equations of motion are given by T = 2Le + v LU + u LV = ∗dX. The constraint equation (54), d4Xe + du XV + dv XU = 0, must be satisfied for the left-hand side of the equation of motion T = ∗dX to not have any term that contains u v. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Now we will examine the integration constants. We begin by expanding them as X = Xe + u ∧ XV + v ∧ XU + u ∧ v ∧ XUV (51) Then we expand dX = d4Xe + du ∧ XV + dv ∧ XU +u ∧ (LV Xe − d4XV ) +v ∧ (LUXe − d4XU ) +u ∧ v ∧ (d4XUV − LUXV + LV XU ) (52) Then we take the Hodge dual, ∗dX = −N u ∧ v ∧ ∗4(d4Xe + u ∧ XV + v ∧ XU ) +N u ∧ ∗4(LV Xe − d4XV ) −N v ∧ ∗4(LUXe − d4XU ) −N ∗4 (d4XUV − LUXV + LV XU ) (53) We can now see that we shall constrain these integration parameters such that d4Xe + du ∧ XV + dv ∧ XU = 0 (54) since T on the left hand side of the equation of motion T = ∗dX does not have any term that contains u ∧ v.

This constraint is satisfied by matching all four integration constants with gauge parameters that precisely matches the constraint equation (54) with the generalized closed condition in (60). p. 7
Where the paper says it

Under a generic variation of the gauge potential, the Lagrangian varies as δL = 1 4 E MN δBMN (40) where E MN = ∂R √ −gT RMN (41) with T RMN = 3Q [R P L MN]P − 2L MNR (42) and specifically then, the Euler-Lagrange equations of motion are then given by E MN = 0 (43) 4 The integrated equations of motion We may integrate the equations of motion locally and present them in the integrated form as T MNP = 1 2 √ −gεMNP RST ∂RXST (44) where we will call XMN integration constants. These are not constants in the usual sense, but in a generalized sense where they are parameters that have to satisfy the constraint equation (54), which we will now proceed to show.

Matter Field Variation

The supersymmetry variation of the matter part of the action is given by δLmatter = i/sqrt(-g) 4 λ¯IΓNP εI∇MTMNP = -i/sqrt(-g) 4 ε¯IΓNP λI∇MTMNP. This variation is shown to be equal to the variation of the tensor field part of the action, δLtensor = sqrt(-g) 4 δBNP ∇MTMNP. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Although these recent developments based on Sen’s approach seem distinct from the PST formulation, it was shown in [9] that two PST actions can be mapped to Hull’s action. By the work of [6] one may obtain the PST action from the Hamilonian of a non-selfdual tensor field that leads to the HT action and the PST action.

The sum of these variations yields δL = delta Ltensor + delta Lmatter = 0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

4 Summing up the three variations Let us sum up the three variations that we have got, δLI + δLII + δLIII = " LV √ −g 48 ε MNP RST HMNP UR N + √ −g 8 HRSTUR N +LU √ −g 48 ε MNP RST HMNP VR N + √ −g 8 HRST VR N + √ −g 96 ε MNP RST HMNRLV UP N + HMNRLU VP N − 1 8 LV √ −g − ΩV √ −g GST N − 1 8 LU √ −g − ΩU √ −g F ST N − √ −g 4 P T Q ∇RHRSQ# δBST (33) We now see that in order for this variation to vanish we must impose the following geometric conditions, LV √ −g = ΩV √ −g LU √ −g = ΩU √ −g LV UP N = 0 LU VP N = 0 (34) When these geometric conditions are satisfied, the variation reduces to δLI + δLII + δLIII = 1 8 " LV √ −g 6 ε MNP RST HMNP UR N + √ −g HRSTUR N +LU √ −g 6 ε MNP RST HMNP VR N + √ −g HRST VR N −2 √ −gPT Q ∇RHRSQ# δBST (35) It is also useful to rewrite this variation as δL = 1 4 E ST δBST (36) where E MN = LV √ −g LMNPUP N + LU √ −g LMNP VP N + 2√ −gP[M Q ∇RL N]QR (37) For any tensor XMN we have LV ( √ −gXMN ) = ∇P ( √ −gV P XMN ) + √ −g(XNP ∇P V M − XMP ∇P V N ) (38) By applying this formula, we have obtained after some computations the result E MN = ∇R √ −g 3Q [R P L MN]P − 2L MNR + √ −gL[N|P R UP RV M] + VP RU M] (39) but by the result in appendix B, the second line vanishes identically.

Geometric Conditions for Supersymmetry

When studying the tensor field in the 2 + 4 formulation, a set of geometric conditions emerges: U and V must be lightlike and commute, both U and V have to be conformal Killing vector fields, and their curvatures dv and du have to be selfdual and anti-selfdual in transverse space. These conditions are explained if we assume the Lorentzian six-manifold has two symplectic-Majorana-Weyl conformal Killing spinors. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In light of the Henneaux-Teitelboim action Andreas Gustavsson Physics Department, University of Seoul, Seoul 02504 KOREA Abstract We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U. We show that such an action exists only if there is another commuting light-like conformal Killing vector V with properties that can be realized by the Dirac currents of two conformal Killing spinors.

Discussion on Formulation

The geometric conditions suggest that a curved spacetime generalization for the action could not be found in [10] because we need to restrict the spacetime geometry somewhat. This is surprising in the bosonic theory because Maxwell's action is valid on any Lorentzian six-manifold. The 2 + 4 formulation forces these geometric conditions to emerge. p. 1

Where the paper says it

One may now want to apply the steps in [6] and derive a PST action with a lightlike time direction instead of a timelike time direction. However, due to certain geometric conditions that we obtain here, we do not expect this approach to be completely straightforward [10].

Proof of Identity

The identity H[MP QV N]UP Q = 1/2 εMNP QRSFRSUP Q H[MP QU N]VP Q = 1/2 εMNP QRSRGVP Q is proven by expanding the terms and contracting with UPQ, leading to the desired identity up to a term that vanishes identically. The vanishing of L M[NPUMP V Q] = 0 and L M[NPVMPU Q] = 0 is shown by dualizing the first expression thrice.

Equivalence of Equations

The two expressions for the equations of motion, T MNP I = 2LMNP - 3Q[M Q L NP]Q and T MNP II = 2L MNP + 3V[ML]NP U + 3U[ML]NP V are identical. This is achieved by substituting Q M Q = 1/N (U MVQ + V MUQ) into T MNP I and expanding LMNP. p. 6

Where the paper says it

4 Summing up the three variations Let us sum up the three variations that we have got, δLI + δLII + δLIII = " LV √ −g 48 ε MNP RST HMNP UR N + √ −g 8 HRSTUR N +LU √ −g 48 ε MNP RST HMNP VR N + √ −g 8 HRST VR N + √ −g 96 ε MNP RST HMNRLV UP N + HMNRLU VP N − 1 8 LV √ −g − ΩV √ −g GST N − 1 8 LU √ −g − ΩU √ −g F ST N − √ −g 4 P T Q ∇RHRSQ# δBST (33) We now see that in order for this variation to vanish we must impose the following geometric conditions, LV √ −g = ΩV √ −g LU √ −g = ΩU √ −g LV UP N = 0 LU VP N = 0 (34) When these geometric conditions are satisfied, the variation reduces to δLI + δLII + δLIII = 1 8 " LV √ −g 6 ε MNP RST HMNP UR N + √ −g HRSTUR N +LU √ −g 6 ε MNP RST HMNP VR N + √ −g HRST VR N −2 √ −gPT Q ∇RHRSQ# δBST (35) It is also useful to rewrite this variation as δL = 1 4 E ST δBST (36) where E MN = LV √ −g LMNPUP N + LU √ −g LMNP VP N + 2√ −gP[M Q ∇RL N]QR (37) For any tensor XMN we have LV ( √ −gXMN ) = ∇P ( √ −gV P XMN ) + √ −g(XNP ∇P V M − XMP ∇P V N ) (38) By applying this formula, we have obtained after some computations the result E MN = ∇R √ −g 3Q [R P L MN]P − 2L MNR + √ −gL[N|P R UP RV M] + VP RU M] (39) but by the result in appendix B, the second line vanishes identically.

Final Reduction to Self-Duality

The final step shows that T MNP I = 2L MNP + 3V[ML]NP U + 3U[ML]NP V = T MNP II as advertised. This implies that for a suitable gauge choice, the rather complicated integrated equations of motion T = ∗dX can be reduced down to T = 0. p. 7

Where the paper says it

In conclusion, this rather long computation has led us to the following important result. Under a generic variation of the gauge potential, the Lagrangian varies as δL = 1 4 E MN δBMN (40) where E MN = ∂R √ −gT RMN (41) with T RMN = 3Q [R P L MN]P − 2L MNR (42) and specifically then, the Euler-Lagrange equations of motion are then given by E MN = 0 (43) 4 The integrated equations of motion We may integrate the equations of motion locally and present them in the integrated form as T MNP = 1 2 √ −gεMNP RST ∂RXST (44) where we will call XMN integration constants.

From T = 0, we subsequently obtain the equation L = 0 which is nothing but the selfduality equation of motion H = ∗H. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We will then show that this generalized gauge symmetry variation, which does not have to be infinitesimal but can be arbirarily large because the theory is abelian, enables us to match the integration constants X that can be arbitrarily large with these generalized gauge parameters. In this way we are able to view the integration constants as gauge parameters and see that in a particarly chosen gauge the integrated equations of motion become T = 0 (55) It is then a small step to show that this leads directly to the selfduality equation of motion for H = ∗H (56) It is in this sense with the help of a generalized gauge symmetry, that we can say that we derive the selfduality equation of motion from the action.

Gamma Matrix Conventions

The paper defines the 6d gamma matrices as ΓM and the 6d charge conjugation matrix as C, with T M = -CΓMC-1 C and T = C (90) The anti-commuting supersymmetry parameter εI implies that λ T J CΓMN εI = ε T I CΓMN εJ and consequently λ¯IΓMN εI = -ε IΓMN εI.

References

[1] M. Henneaux and C. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In light of the Henneaux-Teitelboim action Andreas Gustavsson Physics Department, University of Seoul, Seoul 02504 KOREA Abstract We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U. We show that such an action exists only if there is another commuting light-like conformal Killing vector V with properties that can be realized by the Dirac currents of two conformal Killing spinors.

Teitelboim, “Dynamics of Chiral (Selfdual) P Forms,” Phys. p. 7
Where the paper says it

In a form langauge this equation reads T = 2Le + v ∧ LU + u ∧ LV = ∗dX (46) where LU := ιgU L := ιU L − u ∧ ιV ιU L and similarly for LV . Here T and L are viewed as three-forms and L = (H − ∗H)/2 is anti-selfdual off-shell.

Lett. B 206, 650-654 (1988)

[2] M. Perry and J. H. Schwarz, “Interacting chiral two forms,” Nucl. p. 7

Where the paper says it

In a form langauge this equation reads T = 2Le + v ∧ LU + u ∧ LV = ∗dX (46) where LU := ιgU L := ιU L − u ∧ ιV ιU L and similarly for LV . Here T and L are viewed as three-forms and L = (H − ∗H)/2 is anti-selfdual off-shell.

Phys. B 489, 47-64 (1997) [arXiv:hep-th/9611065 [hep-th]]

[3] W. M. Chen and P. M. Ho, “Lagrangian Formulations of Self-dual Gauge Theories in Diverse Dimensions,” Nucl. p. 8

Where the paper says it

We begin by expanding them as X = Xe + u ∧ XV + v ∧ XU + u ∧ v ∧ XUV (51) Then we expand dX = d4Xe + du ∧ XV + dv ∧ XU +u ∧ (LV Xe − d4XV ) +v ∧ (LUXe − d4XU ) +u ∧ v ∧ (d4XUV − LUXV + LV XU ) (52) Then we take the Hodge dual, ∗dX = −N u ∧ v ∧ ∗4(d4Xe + u ∧ XV + v ∧ XU ) +N u ∧ ∗4(LV Xe − d4XV ) −N v ∧ ∗4(LUXe − d4XU ) −N ∗4 (d4XUV − LUXV + LV XU ) (53) We can now see that we shall constrain these integration parameters such that d4Xe + du ∧ XV + dv ∧ XU = 0 (54) since T on the left hand side of the equation of motion T = ∗dX does not have any term that contains u ∧ v. 5 A generalized gauge symmetry We will now show that the action has a rather large gauge symmetry under which H transforms non-trivially.

Phys. B 837, 1-21 (2010) [arXiv:1001. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We extend the action to the (1, 0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet. arXiv:2611.

3608 [hep-th]]

[4] W. H. Huang, “Lagrangian of Self-dual Gauge Fields in Various Formulations,” Nucl. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Let us now expand L in transverse component fields, L = Le + v ∧ LU + u ∧ LV + u ∧ v ∧ LUV (47) Here L, L e U , LV and LUV are assumed to be transverse fields, so that their contractions with U and V vanish. The Hodge dual is ∗L = −N u ∧ v ∧ ∗4Le − N v ∧ ∗4LU + N u ∧ ∗4LV − N ∗4 LUV (48) where we used the rules ∗Le = −N u ∧ v ∧ ∗4Le ∗(u ∧ LV ) = N u ∧ ∗4LV ∗(v ∧ LU ) = −N v ∧ ∗4LU ∗(u ∧ v ∧ LUV ) = −N ∗4 LUV (49)

Phys. B 861, 403-423 (2012) [arXiv:1111. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We extend the action to the (1, 0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet. arXiv:2611.

5118 [hep-th]]

[5] P. Pasti, D. P. Sorokin and M. Tonin, “On Lorentz invariant actions for chiral p-forms,” Phys. p. 1

Where the paper says it

They constructed an action that gives the selfdual equations of motion by utilizing a gauge symmetry of the action. The action is not manifestly Lorentz invariant in flat Minkowski spacetime.

Rev. D 55, 6292-6298 (1997) [arXiv:hep-th/9611100 [hep-th]]

[6] D. P. Sorokin, “The incomprehensible simplicity of PST,” [arXiv:2501. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We extend the action to the (1, 0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet. arXiv:2611.

17918 [hep-th]]

[7] C. M. Hull, “Covariant action for self-dual p-form gauge fields in general spacetimes,” JHEP 04 (2024), 011 [arXiv:2307.04748 [hep-th]]

[8] A. Sen, “Self-dual forms: Action, Hamiltonian and Compactification,” J. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The action is not manifestly Lorentz invariant in flat Minkowski spacetime. It arises naturally in a Hamiltonian framework with a timelike Killing vector field.

Phys. A 53 (2020) no.8, 084002 [arXiv:1903. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We extend the action to the (1, 0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet. arXiv:2611.

12196 [hep-th]]

[9] P. Vanichchapongjaroen, “A Lagrangian relationship between the PST and the Sen formulations of chiral forms,” [arXiv:2410. p. 1

Where the paper says it

By the work of [6] one may obtain the PST action from the Hamilonian of a non-selfdual tensor field that leads to the HT action and the PST action. We can now understand that all these different formulations can be traced back to the HT action in one way or another.

10206 [hep-th]]

[10] S. L. Ko and P. Vanichchapongjaroen, “Towards 2+4 formulation of M5-brane,” JHEP 12, 170 (2015) [arXiv:1511. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We extend the action to the (1, 0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet. arXiv:2611.

05395 [hep-th]]

[11] P. A. M. Dirac, “Forms of Relativistic Dynamics,” Rev. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In light of the Henneaux-Teitelboim action Andreas Gustavsson Physics Department, University of Seoul, Seoul 02504 KOREA Abstract We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U. We show that such an action exists only if there is another commuting light-like conformal Killing vector V with properties that can be realized by the Dirac currents of two conformal Killing spinors.

Mod. Phys. 21 (1949), 392-399

[12] D. Bak and A. Gustavsson, “The (1,0) tensor and hypermultiplets in loop space,” JHEP 08 (2024), 047 [arXiv:2402. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We extend the action to the (1, 0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet. arXiv:2611.

02073 [hep-th]]

[13] A Proof of an identity

[14] C Equivalence of two equations of motion

[D] Our gamma matrix conventions

B Vanishing Expressions

The expressions L M [NPUMP V Q] = 0 and L M [NPVMPU Q] = 0 are shown to be identically zero by dualizing the first expression thrice. The second relation vanishes by permuting U and V and then again finding that it vanishes by antiselfduality of (LU)CD and selfduality of VAB. p. 6

Where the paper says it

4 Summing up the three variations Let us sum up the three variations that we have got, δLI + δLII + δLIII = " LV √ −g 48 ε MNP RST HMNP UR N + √ −g 8 HRSTUR N +LU √ −g 48 ε MNP RST HMNP VR N + √ −g 8 HRST VR N + √ −g 96 ε MNP RST HMNRLV UP N + HMNRLU VP N − 1 8 LV √ −g − ΩV √ −g GST N − 1 8 LU √ −g − ΩU √ −g F ST N − √ −g 4 P T Q ∇RHRSQ# δBST (33) We now see that in order for this variation to vanish we must impose the following geometric conditions, LV √ −g = ΩV √ −g LU √ −g = ΩU √ −g LV UP N = 0 LU VP N = 0 (34) When these geometric conditions are satisfied, the variation reduces to δLI + δLII + δLIII = 1 8 " LV √ −g 6 ε MNP RST HMNP UR N + √ −g HRSTUR N +LU √ −g 6 ε MNP RST HMNP VR N + √ −g HRST VR N −2 √ −gPT Q ∇RHRSQ# δBST (35) It is also useful to rewrite this variation as δL = 1 4 E ST δBST (36) where E MN = LV √ −g LMNPUP N + LU √ −g LMNP VP N + 2√ −gP[M Q ∇RL N]QR (37) For any tensor XMN we have LV ( √ −gXMN ) = ∇P ( √ −gV P XMN ) + √ −g(XNP ∇P V M − XMP ∇P V N ) (38) By applying this formula, we have obtained after some computations the result E MN = ∇R √ −g 3Q [R P L MN]P − 2L MNR + √ −gL[N|P R UP RV M] + VP RU M] (39) but by the result in appendix B, the second line vanishes identically.

The 6d gamma matrices are denoted ΓM and the 6d charge conjugation matrix is denoted C, with T M = -CΓMC-1 C and T = C (90) These imply that for an anti-commuting supersymmetry parameter εI we have λ T J CΓMN εI = ε T I CΓMN εJ and consequently λ¯IΓMN εI = -ε IΓMN εI.

Summary of Findings

The paper demonstrates that the action possesses a generalized gauge symmetry which allows the integration constants to be viewed as gauge parameters, reducing the integrated equations of motion to T = 0. This reduction directly yields the selfduality equation of motion H = ∗H. p. 8

Where the paper says it

We will then show that this generalized gauge symmetry variation, which does not have to be infinitesimal but can be arbirarily large because the theory is abelian, enables us to match the integration constants X that can be arbitrarily large with these generalized gauge parameters. In this way we are able to view the integration constants as gauge parameters and see that in a particarly chosen gauge the integrated equations of motion become T = 0 (55) It is then a small step to show that this leads directly to the selfduality equation of motion for H = ∗H (56) It is in this sense with the help of a generalized gauge symmetry, that we can say that we derive the selfduality equation of motion from the action.

The derivation requires imposing specific geometric conditions on the lightlike vector fields U and V, such as them being conformal Killing vector fields with specific curvature properties. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We also can show that ge MN geNP = P M P (7) where P M P = δ M P − Q M P Q M P = 1 N (U MVP + V MUP ) (8) Here P projects onto the four-dimensional transverse space orthogonal to the two lightlike vectors U and V and Q projects onto the space spanned by U and V . Nothing in this exposition so far requires these vector fields to be conformal Killing vector fields.

This structure is naturally explained if supersymmetry is present, requiring two symplectic-Majorana-Weyl conformal Killing spinors. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In light of the Henneaux-Teitelboim action Andreas Gustavsson Physics Department, University of Seoul, Seoul 02504 KOREA Abstract We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U. We show that such an action exists only if there is another commuting light-like conformal Killing vector V with properties that can be realized by the Dirac currents of two conformal Killing spinors.

The necessity of the 2 + 4 formulation arises when applying the 2 + 4 formulation to a purely bosonic theory of a selfdual three-form gauge field. This suggests that the existence of such an action in curved spacetime requires restricting the spacetime geometry somewhat. The equivalence between two forms of the equations of motion confirms that T MNP I = T MNP II, leading to a consistent result for H=0. p. 7
Where the paper says it

In conclusion, this rather long computation has led us to the following important result. Under a generic variation of the gauge potential, the Lagrangian varies as δL = 1 4 E MN δBMN (40) where E MN = ∂R √ −gT RMN (41) with T RMN = 3Q [R P L MN]P − 2L MNR (42) and specifically then, the Euler-Lagrange equations of motion are then given by E MN = 0 (43) 4 The integrated equations of motion We may integrate the equations of motion locally and present them in the integrated form as T MNP = 1 2 √ −gεMNP RST ∂RXST (44) where we will call XMN integration constants.

This work provides a path to derive the selfduality equation of motion from the action using a generalized gauge symmetry. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We will then show that this generalized gauge symmetry variation, which does not have to be infinitesimal but can be arbirarily large because the theory is abelian, enables us to match the integration constants X that can be arbitrarily large with these generalized gauge parameters. In this way we are able to view the integration constants as gauge parameters and see that in a particarly chosen gauge the integrated equations of motion become T = 0 (55) It is then a small step to show that this leads directly to the selfduality equation of motion for H = ∗H (56) It is in this sense with the help of a generalized gauge symmetry, that we can say that we derive the selfduality equation of motion from the action.

The structure derived in this paper is important for understanding chiral p-forms in various dimensions. p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction In this paper we will construct an action for the abelian selfdual tensor field H = dB in six dimensions where two lighlike direction are separated from the remaining four transverse directions. We are thus asking for an action that upon variation of B gives us the selfduality equations of motion L = 0 (1) where we define L = H − ∗H (2) as an off-shell anti-selfdual tensor field.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction In this paper we will construct an action for the abelian selfdual tensor field H = dB in six dimensions where two lighlike direction are separated from the remaining four transverse directions. We are thus asking for an action that upon variation of B gives us the selfduality equations of motion L = 0 (1) where we define L = H − ∗H (2) as an off-shell anti-selfdual tensor field.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper constructs an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U. The story begins in 1988 when Henneaux and Teitelboim (HT) presented an action for a selfdual tensor field in which the time direction is selected as a special direction [1]. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We are thus asking for an action that upon variation of B gives us the selfduality equations of motion L = 0 (1) where we define L = H − ∗H (2) as an off-shell anti-selfdual tensor field. The story begins in 1988 when Henneaux and Teitelboim (HT) presented an action for a selfdual tensor field in which the time direction is selected as a special direction [1].

We examine whether we can construct an analog of the HT action when the time direction is taken to be along a lightlike direction. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In the original HT action the time direction was assumed to be timelike. We will examine whether we can construct an analog of the HT action when the time direction is taken to be along a lightlike direction.

How the training signal is built

The Lagrangian density is defined as a sum of three terms L = -LI - LII - LIII where LI = sqrt(-g) 2/4 H MNP LII = -sqrt(-g) 8N FMN GMN LIII = -sqrt(-g) 96 εMNP RST FMN UP N + GMN VP N HRST. The action is constructed so that each term is Weyl invariant by appropriate insertions of the normalization function N whose Weyl transformation is the same as that of the metric tensor. p. 3

Where the paper says it

3 The action We will make the following ansatz for the action S = Z d 6xL (14) where we take the Lagrangian density to be a sum of three terms L = −LI − LII − LIII (15) where LI = √ −g 24 H2 MNP LII = − √ −g 8N F MN GMN LIII = − √ −g 96 ε MNP RST FMN UP N + GMN VP N HRST (16) Here we define FMN = HMNP V P GMN = HMNPU P (17) We require the action to be Weyl invariant. The action above is constructed so that each term is Weyl invariant by appropriate insertions of the normalization function N whose Weyl transformation is the same as that of the metric tensor, gMN → e 2σ gMN N → e 2σN (18) We will now obtain the equations of motion from this action by varying the gauge potential.

Where the gains come from

The final result obtained under a generic variation of the gauge potential is δL = 1/4 E MN δBMN where E MN = ∂R/sqrt(-gT RMN. The Euler-Lagrange equations of motion are then given by E MN = 0. p. 7

Where the paper says it

In conclusion, this rather long computation has led us to the following important result. Under a generic variation of the gauge potential, the Lagrangian varies as δL = 1 4 E MN δBMN (40) where E MN = ∂R √ −gT RMN (41) with T RMN = 3Q [R P L MN]P − 2L MNR (42) and specifically then, the Euler-Lagrange equations of motion are then given by E MN = 0 (43) 4 The integrated equations of motion We may integrate the equations of motion locally and present them in the integrated form as T MNP = 1 2 √ −gεMNP RST ∂RXST (44) where we will call XMN integration constants.

This is achieved through a generalized gauge symmetry that matches the integration constants with gauge parameters, ultimately leading to the selfduality equation H = ∗H. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We will then show that this generalized gauge symmetry variation, which does not have to be infinitesimal but can be arbirarily large because the theory is abelian, enables us to match the integration constants X that can be arbitrarily large with these generalized gauge parameters. In this way we are able to view the integration constants as gauge parameters and see that in a particarly chosen gauge the integrated equations of motion become T = 0 (55) It is then a small step to show that this leads directly to the selfduality equation of motion for H = ∗H (56) It is in this sense with the help of a generalized gauge symmetry, that we can say that we derive the selfduality equation of motion from the action.

The structure derived in this paper is important for understanding chiral p-forms in various dimensions.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can derive selfduality equations of motion from an action constructed in six dimensions with a lightlike time direction by analyzing variations of three specific Lagrangian terms (LI, LII, LIII).

  2. Improved AI can identify necessary geometric conditions for the variation of the total Lagrangian to vanish under generic gauge transformations, specifically requiring LV/sqrt(-g) = OmegaV/sqrt(-g) and LU/sqrt(-g) = OmegaU/sqrt(-g).

  3. Improved AI can utilize a generalized gauge symmetry to match integration constants with gauge parameters, allowing the reduction of the complicated integrated equations of motion T = dX to T = 0, which yields the selfduality equation H = ∗H.

  4. Improved AI can determine the specific geometric conditions required for a purely bosonic theory of a two-form gauge field in a two plus four formulation, such as requiring The vector fields U and V must be lightlike and commute and that their curvatures dv is selfdual and du is anti-selfdual in transverse space.

  5. Improved AI can construct the (1, 0) supersymmetric extension of the selfdual tensor field by relating its supersymmetry variations to those of a real scalar field phi and two symplectic-Majorana Weyl spinors lambda I.

Abstract

We construct an action similar to the Henneaux-Teitelboim action on a six dimensional Lorentzian manifold where the time direction is chosen to be lightlike and generated by a conformal lightlike Killing vector U. We show that such an action exists only if there is another commuting light-like conformal Killing vector V with properties that can be realized by the Dirac currents of two conformal Killing spinors. We extend the action to the (1,0) supersymmetric tensor multiplet.

Sources

Related papers