QED corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) with amplitude-level resummation

arXiv:2611.07067 · hep-ph, hep-ex · Submitted 2026-11-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "QED corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) with amplitude-level resummation".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. QED corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) with amplitude-level resummation present a new calculation of radiative corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor The first-order fiducial cross sections of SHERPA and KKMC agree to ≲ 0.03% and the differential distributions within the statistical uncertainties across five STRONG2020 scenarios Theoretical Framework The charged pions are treated as point-like scalars, and all corrections are computed in scalar QED (sQED) dressed with the pion form factor The pion electromagnetic form factor Fπ(q2) is parameterized in vector meson dominance (VMD) The calculation employs the Yennie-Frautschi-Suura (YFS) formalism to resum soft photons to all orders, unlike fixed-order calculations Both generators implement the amplitude-level form of equation (2.4) Implementation Details The two independent implementations provide a powerful cross-check of each other, with KKMC implementing the amplitude-level form of eq.

Kai: (2.4) in the coherent exclusive exponentiation (CEEX) method SHERPA implements it with the newly implemented ACRAIC method The pion amplitudes are coded analytically in the CEEX spinor formalism Numerical Results and Comparison At O(α) the pion angles of KKMC CEEX and SHERPA ACRAIC agree to better than 0.1% in every bin with cos θ± < 0.5 At O(α2L) the bands on the fiducial cross sections are ∼ 0.005% for the elastic CMD scenario, ∼ 0.1% at KLOEI and ∼ 0.4% at BESIII and ∼ 0.9% at B, dominated by the radiative-return parameter The GVMD form factor inside the loops, instead of point-like loops, reduces the forward-backward asymmetry for CMD-3 kinematics by up to ∼ 1% near the ρ resonance Uncertainty Estimation Theory nuisance parameters estimate missing higher orders The uncertainty of the generators used in radiative-return and scan measurements has so far been judged from the spread between generators or from the size of the last correction included The next steps are the two-loop boxes, the genuine two-loop scalar-QED pion vertex and the O(α3) photonic corrections, sized by the theory nuisance parameters The limiting factor is the calculation of the amplitudes, and once they are available the implementation in both generators is straightforward as the YFS subtraction scheme is defined to all orders A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO Against BabaYaga@NLO the O(α2L) fiducial cross sections of CMD, KLOE-I and KLOEII agree within 0.01% to 0.1% The angular distributions cos θ± and θavg agree with BabaYaga@NLO to ∼ 0.01% in both generators For the pion-pair mass (fig.

Mira: 24b) we use version 2.1 of BabaYaga@NLO The next-to-leading-order correction reduces the fiducial band from several per cent to ∼ 0.1%, several times smaller than the O(α2L) band of the pi+pi− predictions The GVMD form factor inside the loops, instead of point-like loops, reduces the forward-backward asymmetry for CMD-3 kinematics by up to ∼ 1% near the ρ resonance The O(α) prediction is then effectively the leading order of e+e− → pi+pi−γ, and its missing higher orders are the full next-order correction of that process, which the other templates, ∼ 1–3% at BESIII and B, would not cover because their normalisations assume a well-behaved series in αL The limiting factor is the calculation of the amplitudes The next steps are the two-loop boxes, the genuine two-loop scalar-QED pion vertex and the O(α3) photonic corrections, sized by the theory nuisance parameters The boxes and the two-loop pion vertex are non-logarithmic at second order, and the β˜2L0 parameter sizes them at ∼ 0.005%, relevant only for the elastic CMD scenario The O(α3) photonic corrections are sized at ∼ 0.02% by the one-photon and β˜0 parameters, and by the radiative-return parameter in the radiative-return scenarios The limiting factor is the calculation of the amplitudes The next steps are the two-loop boxes, the genuine two-loop scalar-QED pion vertex and the O(α3) photonic corrections, sized by the theory nuisance parameters The boxes and the two-loop pion vertex are non-logarithmic at second order, and the β˜2L0 parameter sizes them at ∼ 0.005%, relevant only for the elastic CMD scenario References

1: T.

Kai: Aoyama et al., The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the Standard Model, Phys.

Paper summary: Kai: Looking back at "QED corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) with amplitude-level resummation," the authors presented a calculation using two different Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for those radiative corrections involving point-like scalar pions.

Mira: The main point here is that they used amplitude level resummation to handle soft photons to all orders while combining it with exact tree amplitudes and one loop corrections. They found that their first order fiducial cross sections agree within zero point four percent, or zero point zero four percent, and the distributions match across five scenarios.

Lev: The implication is that for processes involving these pions, we have a way to check consistency between two different computational frameworks before diving into the heavy lifting of higher orders.

Kai: What this means in simpler terms is that even with complex QED corrections, when you look at the basic structure of the calculation, KKMC and SHERPA are giving very similar results at first order.

Mira: But they have clearly identified gaps, specifically needing genuine two loop boxes and the genuine two loop scalar QED pion vertex for full precision.

Lev: So while this paper establishes a solid comparison baseline with those cross sections and distributions, the real work ahead is calculating those higher-order amplitudes to get that true precision needed for experimental comparisons.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've gone through the math and the comparison between KKMC and SHERPA for these QED corrections to e plus minus to pi plus minus gamma with amplitude level resummation.

Mira: Yeah, looking at that title, it’s all about making sure our theoretical predictions for those pion processes are as accurate as possible when dealing with photons.

Lev: From my side, the authors are tackling this by using a Yennie Frautschi Suura formalism to resum those soft photons to all orders.

Kai: That means they aren't just looking at one or two corrections; they’re building up the entire correction series for those soft emissions right there.

Mira: But it's important to remember the setup, this isn't just standard point-like pions; they’re treating them as point-like scalars dressed with a pion form factor parameterized by vector meson dominance.

Lev: That VMD part is key because it changes the loop structure inside the calculation, shifting it from simple loops to something more complex.

Kai: The results show that at first order, KKMC and SHERPA match up to three percent or less in the fiducial cross sections across those five scenarios.

Mira: But they point out where things get fuzzy—the next steps involve genuine two loop boxes and the actual two loop scalar QED pion vertex.

Lev: That’s where the real overhead lands; calculating those higher orders is what determines if this theory can actually match what we measure in experiments.

Kai: So, the authors are essentially laying out a roadmap for where theoretical precision needs to go next in this area of e plus minus annihilation physics.

Stéphane Delorme, Charles Earnshaw, Frank Krauss, Alan Price, Nora Salone, Andrzej Siódmok

Institute of Physics, University of Silesia, Katowice, Poland · IPPP, Department of Physics, Durham University · čagiellonian University

hep-ph, hep-ex

Submitted: 2026-11-04

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: 38 Pages + Appendix,

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: QED corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) with amplitude-level resummation present a new calculation of radiative corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators…

Key concepts

Scalar QED (sQED)
This is a specific type of Quantum Electrodynamics applied to particles treated as point-like scalars. The calculation treats the charged pions as simple scalar particles interacting with photons, which simplifies the complex quantum field theory calculations involved in the process.
Pion Form Factor Fπ(q2)
This factor describes how the pion's electromagnetic properties change depending on the momentum (q2) transferred during interaction. In this study, it is parameterized using Vector Meson Dominance (VMD), which is a model used to describe how photons couple to hadrons.
Yennie-Frautschi-Suura (YFS) formalism
The YFS formalism is a mathematical technique used to resum 'soft photons'—photons with very low energy. Resummation means calculating these effects to all orders, which is crucial for accurate predictions in processes involving multiple soft photon emissions.
Amplitude-level resummation
This method involves summing up the contributions from different orders of the interaction amplitude rather than just calculating a fixed order. It allows for a more complete and accurate description of radiative corrections by treating the entire process's amplitude consistently.

Terminology

Summary

QED corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) with amplitude-level resummation present a new calculation of radiative corrections to e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor The first-order fiducial cross sections of SHERPA and KKMC agree to ≲ 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

03% and the differential distributions within the statistical uncertainties across five STRONG2020 scenarios

Theoretical Framework

The charged pions are treated as point-like scalars, and all corrections are computed in scalar QED (sQED) dressed with the pion form factor The pion electromagnetic form factor Fπ(q2) is parameterized in vector meson dominance (VMD) The calculation employs the Yennie-Frautschi-Suura (YFS) formalism to resum soft photons to all orders, unlike fixed-order calculations Both generators implement the amplitude-level form of equation (2.4)

Implementation Details

The two independent implementations provide a powerful cross-check of each other, with KKMC implementing the amplitude-level form of eq. (2.4) in the coherent exclusive exponentiation (CEEX) method SHERPA implements it with the newly implemented ACRAIC method The pion amplitudes are coded analytically in the CEEX spinor formalism

Numerical Results and Comparison

At O(α) the pion angles of KKMC CEEX and SHERPA ACRAIC agree to better than 0.1% in every bin with cos θ± < 0. p. 3

Where the paper says it

We estimate the missing higher orders with theory nuisance parameters [87, 88], as introduced for YFS resummation in Ref. [86], which give an uncertainty for every bin of every distribution tied to identified missing terms (section 2.

5 At O(α2L) the bands on the fiducial cross sections are ∼ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission. At first order their fiducial cross sections agree to ≲ 0.

005% for the elastic CMD scenario, ∼ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The second-order band is ∼ 0. 005% for CMD, ∼ 0.

1% at KLOEI and ∼ 0.4% at BESIII and ∼ 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

5 KLOE-II 23 3. 6 BESIII 24 3.

9% at B, dominated by the radiative-return parameter The GVMD form factor inside the loops, instead of point-like loops, reduces the forward-backward asymmetry for CMD-3 kinematics by up to ∼ 1% near the ρ resonance

Uncertainty Estimation

Theory nuisance parameters estimate missing higher orders The uncertainty of the generators used in radiative-return and scan measurements has so far been judged from the spread between generators or from the size of the last correction included

Conclusion

The next steps are the two-loop boxes, the genuine two-loop scalar-QED pion vertex and the O(α3) photonic corrections, sized by the theory nuisance parameters The limiting factor is the calculation of the amplitudes, and once they are available the implementation in both generators is straightforward as the YFS subtraction scheme is defined to all orders

A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO

Against BabaYaga@NLO the O(α2L) fiducial cross sections of CMD, KLOE-I and KLOEII agree within 0.01% to 0.1% The angular distributions cos θ± and θavg agree with BabaYaga@NLO to ∼ 0. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

01% in both generators For the pion-pair mass (fig. p. 4
Where the paper says it

7) where Γ(q 2 , mv, Γv) is the energy-dependent width of the π +π − channel and f and d are the Gounaris–Sakurai corrections that keep the propagator analytic and normalise it at q 2 = 0. In COMIX the form factor is a vertex factor at the virtuality of the photon current joining the pion pair, so real photons couple point-like and the same currents serve every multiplicity.

24b) we use version 2. p. 4
Where the paper says it

5) with complex amplitudes c = |c| e iφ, free masses and widths, and Pv(0) = 1, so that Fπ(0) = 1. We use the STRONG2020 parametrisation [71] in both generators, with v ∈ {ρ, ρ′ , ρ′′, ρ′′′} in the Gounaris–Sakurai form, ρ–ω and ρ–ϕ mixing on the ρ only, Mρ ′ = Mρ ′′ = Mρ ′′′ = 1, and its auxiliary functions and resonance parameters.

1 of BabaYaga@NLO The next-to-leading-order correction reduces the fiducial band from several per cent to ∼ 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The standard generator for the pion channel, PHOKHARA [53–60], includes the next-to-leading-order (NLO) radiative corrections for both the π +π −γ and µ +µ −γ channels [61, 62], but as a fixed-order prediction it does not include multiple photon emission [63, 64]. For pions, multiple photon emission matched to NLO was first implemented in the BabaYaga@NLO event generator [65, 66] with a parton shower [67], recently extended to the 2 → 3 radiative channel [68].

1%, several times smaller than the O(α2L) band of the pi+pi− predictions The GVMD form factor inside the loops, instead of point-like loops, reduces the forward-backward asymmetry for CMD-3 kinematics by up to ∼ 1% near the ρ resonance The O(α) prediction is then effectively the leading order of e+e− → pi+pi−γ, and its missing higher orders are the full next-order correction of that process, which the other templates, ∼ 1–3% at BESIII and B, would not cover because their normalisations assume a well-behaved series in αL The limiting factor is the calculation of the amplitudes The next steps are the two-loop boxes, the genuine two-loop scalar-QED pion vertex and the O(α3) photonic corrections, sized by the theory nuisance parameters The boxes and the two-loop pion vertex are non-logarithmic at second order, and the β˜2L0 parameter sizes them at ∼ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

005%, relevant only for the elastic CMD scenario The O(α3) photonic corrections are sized at ∼ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The second-order band is ∼ 0. 005% for CMD, ∼ 0.

02% by the one-photon and β˜0 parameters, and by the radiative-return parameter in the radiative-return scenarios The limiting factor is the calculation of the amplitudes The next steps are the two-loop boxes, the genuine two-loop scalar-QED pion vertex and the O(α3) photonic corrections, sized by the theory nuisance parameters The boxes and the two-loop pion vertex are non-logarithmic at second order, and the β˜2L0 parameter sizes them at ∼ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

005%, relevant only for the elastic CMD scenario

References

[1] T. Aoyama et al., The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the Standard Model, Phys. p. 1

Where the paper says it

8 Fixed order Results 27 3. 9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6].

Rept. 887 (2020) 1 [2] Muon g-2 collaboration, Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment to 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6]. The Muon g − 2 experiment (E989) at Fermilab [7], combining its full dataset with the earlier Brookhaven (BNL) measurement [8], recently reached a precision of 124 ppb [4, 9].

46 ppm, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 (2021) 141801 [3] Muon g-2 collaboration, Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment to 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6]. The Muon g − 2 experiment (E989) at Fermilab [7], combining its full dataset with the earlier Brookhaven (BNL) measurement [8], recently reached a precision of 124 ppb [4, 9].

20 ppm, Phys. Rev. Lett. 131 (2023) 161802 [4] Muon g-2 collaboration, Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment to 127 ppb, Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6]. The Muon g − 2 experiment (E989) at Fermilab [7], combining its full dataset with the earlier Brookhaven (BNL) measurement [8], recently reached a precision of 124 ppb [4, 9].

Rev. Lett. 135 (2025) 101802 [5] F. Jegerlehner and A. Nyffeler, The Muon g-2, Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

8 Fixed order Results 27 3. 9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6].

Rept. 477 (2009) 1 [6] P. Athron, K. Möhling, D. Stöckinger and H. Stöckinger-Kim, The muon magnetic moment and physics beyond the standard model, Prog. p. 1
Where the paper says it

8 Fixed order Results 27 3. 9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6].

Part. Nucl. Phys. 148 (2026) 104225 [7] Muon g-2 collaboration, Muon (g-2) Technical Design Report, 1501. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2σ discrepancy, recent updates report aµ(EXP) − aµ(SM) = (38 ± 63) × 10−11 [10], in agreement within current uncertainties. This shift is driven by lattice QCD calculations of the leading-order hadronic vacuum polarisation (HVP) contribution a HVP, LO µ by the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal (BMW) Collaboration [11, 12], since confirmed by other lattice collaborations [13–15].

06858 [8] Muon g-2 collaboration, Final Report of the Muon E821 Anomalous Magnetic Moment Measurement at BNL, Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6]. The Muon g − 2 experiment (E989) at Fermilab [7], combining its full dataset with the earlier Brookhaven (BNL) measurement [8], recently reached a precision of 124 ppb [4, 9].

Rev. D 73 (2006) 072003 [9] Muon g-2 collaboration, Final Report on the Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment at Fermilab to 127 ppb, 2606. p. 1
Where the paper says it

9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6]. The Muon g − 2 experiment (E989) at Fermilab [7], combining its full dataset with the earlier Brookhaven (BNL) measurement [8], recently reached a precision of 124 ppb [4, 9].

17323 [10] R. Aliberti et al., The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the Standard Model: an update, Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

8 Fixed order Results 27 3. 9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6].

Rept. 1143 (2025) 1 [11] S. Borsanyi et al., Leading hadronic contribution to the muon magnetic moment from lattice QCD, Nature 593 (2021) 51 [12] A. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2σ discrepancy, recent updates report aµ(EXP) − aµ(SM) = (38 ± 63) × 10−11 [10], in agreement within current uncertainties. This shift is driven by lattice QCD calculations of the leading-order hadronic vacuum polarisation (HVP) contribution a HVP, LO µ by the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal (BMW) Collaboration [11, 12], since confirmed by other lattice collaborations [13–15].

Boccaletti et al., Hybrid calculation of hadronic vacuum polarization in muon g-2 to 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2σ discrepancy, recent updates report aµ(EXP) − aµ(SM) = (38 ± 63) × 10−11 [10], in agreement within current uncertainties. This shift is driven by lattice QCD calculations of the leading-order hadronic vacuum polarisation (HVP) contribution a HVP, LO µ by the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal (BMW) Collaboration [11, 12], since confirmed by other lattice collaborations [13–15].

48%, Nature 653 (2026) 373 [13] D. p. 0
Where the paper says it

arXiv:2611. 07067v1 [hep-ph] 4 Nov 2026

Djukanovic, G. von Hippel, S. Kuberski, H.B. Meyer, N. Miller, K. Ottnad et al., The hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon g-2 at long distances, JHEP 04 (2025) 098 [14] RBC, UKQCD collaboration, Long-Distance Window of the Hadronic Vacuum Polarization for the Muon g-2, Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2σ discrepancy, recent updates report aµ(EXP) − aµ(SM) = (38 ± 63) × 10−11 [10], in agreement within current uncertainties. This shift is driven by lattice QCD calculations of the leading-order hadronic vacuum polarisation (HVP) contribution a HVP, LO µ by the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal (BMW) Collaboration [11, 12], since confirmed by other lattice collaborations [13–15].

Rev. Lett. 134 (2025) 201901 [15] Fermilab Lattice, HPQCD„ MILC collaboration, Hadronic Vacuum Polarization for the Muon g-2 from Lattice QCD: Long-Distance and Full Light-Quark Connected Contribution, Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2σ discrepancy, recent updates report aµ(EXP) − aµ(SM) = (38 ± 63) × 10−11 [10], in agreement within current uncertainties. This shift is driven by lattice QCD calculations of the leading-order hadronic vacuum polarisation (HVP) contribution a HVP, LO µ by the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal (BMW) Collaboration [11, 12], since confirmed by other lattice collaborations [13–15].

Rev. Lett. 135 (2025) 011901 [16] M. Davier, A. Hoecker, A.-M. Lutz, B. Malaescu and Z. Zhang, Tensions in e+e− → pi+pi−(γ) measurements: the new landscape of data-driven hadronic vacuum polarization predictions for the muon g-2, Eur. p. 1
Where the paper says it

8 Fixed order Results 27 3. 9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6].

Phys. J. C 84 (2024) 721 [17] CMD-3 collaboration, Measurement of the e+e-→pi+pi- cross section from threshold to 1. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

2 GeV with the CMD-3 detector, Phys. p. 0
Where the paper says it

005% for CMD, ∼ 0. 4% at 4 GeV and ∼ 0.

Rev. D 109 (2024) 112002 [18] CMD-3 collaboration, Measurement of the Pion Form Factor with CMD-3 Detector and its Implication to the Hadronic Contribution to Muon (g-2), Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

Rev. Lett. 132 (2024) 231903 [19] KLOE collaboration, Measurement of σ(e+e− → pi+pi−γ(γ) and the dipion contribution to the muon anomaly with the KLOE detector, Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

Lett. B 670 (2009) 285 [20] KLOE collaboration, Measurement of σ(e+e− → pi+pi−) from threshold to 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

85 GeV2 using Initial State Radiation with the KLOE detector, Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

Lett. B 700 (2011) 102 [23] BaBar collaboration, Precise Measurement of the e+e− → pi+pi−(γ) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BABAR, Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

Rev. D 86 (2012) 032013 [24] BaBar collaboration, A New Precise Measurement of the e+e− → pi+pi−(γ) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BaBar, 2611. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

04621 [25] BaBar collaboration, A New Precise Measurement of the e+e− → pi+pi−(γ) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BaBar, 2611. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23]. BaBar has since presented a new measurement with its full initial-state-radiation data set, which separates the pion and muon pairs through their angular distributions [24, 25].

04596 [26] F. Jegerlehner, Lepton Magnetic Moments: What They Tell Us, Acta Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

8 Fixed order Results 27 3. 9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6].

Polon. Supp. 19 (2026) 2 [30] A. p. 0
Where the paper says it

arXiv:2611. 07067v1 [hep-ph] 4 Nov 2026

B. Arbuzov, E.A. Kuraev, N.P. Merenkov and L Trentadue, Hadronic cross-sections in electron - positron annihilation with tagged photon, JHEP 12 (1998) 009 [31] S. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Pion channels are equally crucial for the hadronic contribution to the running coupling α(s), obtained from a dispersion integral over e +e − annihilation data, and for α(M2 Z ), a key input for precision studies of electroweak pseudo-observables at future colliders such as FCC-ee [28, 29]. At low-energy flavour factories, the e +e − → π +π − cross section is measured either by an energy scan, varying the centre-of-mass energy, or by radiative return [30, 31], where an initial-state (ISR) photon gives access to a range of energies at fixed beam energy.

Binner, J.H. Kuhn and K. Melnikov, Measuring sigma(e+ e- —> hadrons) using tagged photon, Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

A substantial tension remains within the HVP sector itself. Lattice calculations disagree with data-driven estimates based on e +e − → hadrons cross sections, and the e +e − datasets disagree among themselves [16], with CMD-3 [17, 18] yielding a higher e +e − → π +π − cross section than KLOE [19–22] and BaBar [23].

Lett. B 459 (1999) 279 [32] E.A. Kuraev and V.S. Fadin, On Radiative Corrections to e+ e- Single Photon Annihilation at High-Energy, Sov. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Pion channels are equally crucial for the hadronic contribution to the running coupling α(s), obtained from a dispersion integral over e +e − annihilation data, and for α(M2 Z ), a key input for precision studies of electroweak pseudo-observables at future colliders such as FCC-ee [28, 29]. At low-energy flavour factories, the e +e − → π +π − cross section is measured either by an energy scan, varying the centre-of-mass energy, or by radiative return [30, 31], where an initial-state (ISR) photon gives access to a range of energies at fixed beam energy.

J. Nucl. Phys. 41 (1985) 466 [33] F.A. Berends, W.L. van Neerven and G.J.H. Burgers, Higher Order Radiative Corrections at LEP Energies, Nucl. p. 0
Where the paper says it

9% at 10 GeV. Theory nuisance parameters estimate missing higher orders, and we construct a new rule for treating radiative return, where first-order corrections are of order one.

Phys. B 297 (1988) 429 [34] O. Nicrosini and L Trentadue, Soft Photons and Second Order Radiative Corrections in e+e− Annihilation, Phys. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Towards full NNLO [74–79], tensor decompositions within the GVMD framework for radiative return have provided the higher-order-in-ϵ real-virtual building blocks needed to add two-loop virtual and double-real photon corrections to Monte Carlo event generators. In this work, we present a new calculation of the radiative corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in the Yennie-Frautschi-Suura (YFS) formalism [42], which resums the soft photons that accompany every event to all orders, unlike fixed-order calculations.

Lett. B 196 (1987) 551 [35] O. Nicrosini and L Trentadue, Second Order Electromagnetic Radiative Corrections to e+e− → µ+µ−, Z. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

Phys. C 39 (1988) 479 [36] F.A. Berends, K.J.F. Gaemers and R Gastmans, Hard photon corrections for Bhabha scattering, Nucl. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Final-state corrections. For point-like pions the FSR correction does not depend on the scattering angle, δFSR = α 2π ( 4 s − 2m2 π s − 4m2 π h B0(m2 π , 0, m2 π ) − B0(s, m2 π , m2 π ) i − 2 s − 2m2 π C ππγ 0 (s) + 4m2 π B ′ 0 (m2 π , 0, m2 π ) ) , (2.

Phys. B 68 (1974) 541 [37] F.A. Berends, R Kleiss and S Jadach, Monte Carlo simulation of radiative corrections to the processes e+e− → µ+µ− and e+e− → qq¯ in the Z0 region, Comput. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Radiative corrections to e +e − processes have a long history [32–52], including the structure-function and parton-shower methods for QED corrections. Today such corrections are implemented in Monte Carlo (MC) event generators, essential tools for experimental analyses, whose precision is often limited by the perturbative order of the radiative corrections.

Phys. Commun. 29 (1983) 185 [38] S. Jadach and Z. Wąs, QED O(α3) radiative corrections to the reaction e+e− → τ+τ− including spin and mass effects, Acta Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Both methods require careful treatment of radiative corrections, which can significantly affect the measured cross section and thus a HVP µ . Radiative corrections to e +e − processes have a long history [32–52], including the structure-function and parton-shower methods for QED corrections.

Polon. B 15 (1984) 1151 [39] S. Jadach and B.F.L. Ward, Multi - Photon Monte Carlo for Bhabha Scattering at Low Angles, Phys. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

Rev. D 40 (1989) 3582 [40] S. Jadach, E. Richter-Was, B.F.L. Ward and Z Was, BHLUMI 4.04: A Monte Carlo event generator for LEP luminosity determination, Comput. p. 0
Where the paper says it

siodmok@uj. pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor.

Phys. Commun. 102 (1997) 269 [41] S. p. 7
Where the paper says it

, χ− = − sin θ 2 e iϕ cos θ 2 ! 3 Virtual Corrections We compute the complete one-loop QED corrections to e +e − → π +π − (momenta as in section 2), also given in [67] and available in tools such as OPENLOOPS [102], in scalar QED, where point-like pions couple to the photon through the three-point and the two-photon seagull vertices, keeping the full electron-mass dependence.

Jadach, B.F.L. Ward and Z Was, The Monte Carlo program KORALZ, version 4. p. 0
Where the paper says it

siodmok@uj. pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor.

0, for the lepton or quark pair production in e+e- collisions, Comput. p. 6
Where the paper says it

In KKMC the pion amplitudes are coded analytically in the CEEX spinor formalism [101]. With the lepton current J µ = ¯v(p2)γ µu(p1), the pion current K = p4 − p3 and s ′ = P 2 X for the s-channel momentum PX of the partition, the Born amplitude and the initial- and final-state eikonal currents of eq.

Phys. Commun. 79 (1994) 503 [42] D.R. Yennie, S.C. Frautschi and H. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Towards full NNLO [74–79], tensor decompositions within the GVMD framework for radiative return have provided the higher-order-in-ϵ real-virtual building blocks needed to add two-loop virtual and double-real photon corrections to Monte Carlo event generators. In this work, we present a new calculation of the radiative corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in the Yennie-Frautschi-Suura (YFS) formalism [42], which resums the soft photons that accompany every event to all orders, unlike fixed-order calculations.

Suura, The infrared divergence phenomena and high-energy processes, Annals Phys. 13 (1961) 379 [43] V.N. Baier and V.A. Khoze, Radiation accompanying two particle annihilation of an electron - positron pair, Sov. p. 2
Where the paper says it

HVP dominates the error budget of aµ, and the two-pion final state accounts for the largest part of the HVP contribution [1, 10]. Pion channels are equally crucial for the hadronic contribution to the running coupling α(s), obtained from a dispersion integral over e +e − annihilation data, and for α(M2 Z ), a key input for precision studies of electroweak pseudo-observables at future colliders such as FCC-ee [28, 29].

Phys. JETP 21 (1965) 1145 [44] V.N. Baier, V.S. Fadin and V.A. Khoze, Photon bremsstrahlung in collisions of high-energy electrons, Sov. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Both electrons and pions are kept massive and the residuals are evaluated at the physical event momenta. Assigning a photon to the initial or final stage fixes the virtuality of the s-channel propagator and the form factor, which COMIX applies as a shift of the propagator momentum without rebuilding the currents.

Phys. JETP 24 (1966) 760 [45] E.A. Kuraev and G.V. Meledin, QED Distributions for Hard Photon Emission in e+e− → µ+µ−γ, Nucl. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

Phys. B 122 (1977) 485 [46] V.N. Baier, E.A. Kuraev, V.S. Fadin and V.A.-Khoeze, Inelastic Processes in Quantum Electrodynamics at High-Energies, Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Both methods require careful treatment of radiative corrections, which can significantly affect the measured cross section and thus a HVP µ . Radiative corrections to e +e − processes have a long history [32–52], including the structure-function and parton-shower methods for QED corrections.

Rept. 78 (1981) 293 [47] F.A. Berends, R Kleiss, P De Causmaecker, R Gastmans and T.T. Wu, Single Bremsstrahlung Processes in Gauge Theories, Phys. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Both methods require careful treatment of radiative corrections, which can significantly affect the measured cross section and thus a HVP µ . Radiative corrections to e +e − processes have a long history [32–52], including the structure-function and parton-shower methods for QED corrections.

Lett. B 103 (1981) 124 [48] M. p. 1
Where the paper says it

9 Theory-nuisance-parameter breakdown 32 4 Conclusion 38 A Comparison with BabaYaga@NLO 39 1 Introduction For decades, a persistent discrepancy existed between theoretical predictions [1] and experimental measurements [2–4] of the muon anomalous magnetic moment aµ [5], motivating extensive searches for new physics [6]. The Muon g − 2 experiment (E989) at Fermilab [7], combining its full dataset with the earlier Brookhaven (BNL) measurement [8], recently reached a precision of 124 ppb [4, 9].

-S. Chen and P.M. Zerwas, Secondary Reactions in electron - Positron (electron) Collisions, Phys. p. 7
Where the paper says it

, χ− = − sin θ 2 e iϕ cos θ 2 ! 3 Virtual Corrections We compute the complete one-loop QED corrections to e +e − → π +π − (momenta as in section 2), also given in [67] and available in tools such as OPENLOOPS [102], in scalar QED, where point-like pions couple to the photon through the three-point and the two-photon seagull vertices, keeping the full electron-mass dependence.

Rev. D 11 (1975) 58 [49] V.M. Budnev, I.F. Ginzburg, G.V. Meledin and V.-G Serbo, The two photon particle production mechanism. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

Physical problems. p. 5
Where the paper says it

In SHERPA every tree-level amplitude in the residuals is generated by COMIX [100], from the charged scalar of the model with its γππ and γγππ vertices and the form factor as a vertex factor. Both electrons and pions are kept massive and the residuals are evaluated at the physical event momenta.

Applications Equivalent photon approximation, Phys. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

Rept 15 (1975) 181 [50] G. Passarino and M. p. 8
Where the paper says it

15) with Σe(p) = p/ Σ V e (p 2 ) + meΣ S e (p 2 ) split into the vector and scalar parts of the electron self-energy and Σπ the pion self-energy. Reduced to Passarino-Veltman master integrals they read δZe = α 4π 1 − A0(m2 e ) m2 e + 4m2 e B ′ 0 (m2 e , 0, m2 e ) , (2.

J.G. Veltman, One-loop corrections for e+e− annihilation into mu+mu− in the Weinberg model, Nucl. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl Abstract: We present QED corrections to e +e − → π +π −(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

Phys. B 160 (1979) 151 [53] G. Rodrigo, H. Czyz, J.H. Kuhn and M Szopa, Radiative return at NLO and the measurement of the hadronic cross-section in electron positron annihilation with tagged photon, Eur. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Pion channels are equally crucial for the hadronic contribution to the running coupling α(s), obtained from a dispersion integral over e +e − annihilation data, and for α(M2 Z ), a key input for precision studies of electroweak pseudo-observables at future colliders such as FCC-ee [28, 29]. At low-energy flavour factories, the e +e − → π +π − cross section is measured either by an energy scan, varying the centre-of-mass energy, or by radiative return [30, 31], where an initial-state (ISR) photon gives access to a range of energies at fixed beam energy.

Phys. J.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved QED correction implementation in Monte Carlo event generators by combining all-order soft-photon exponentiation with exact one- and twophoton tree amplitudes, as done in KKMC and SHERPA. This allows for a complete calculation including exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission.

  2. Enhanced handling of the pion form factor within loop amplitudes by implementing different treatments such as factorised approach, FxSQED and generalized vector-meson dominance (GVMD), with specific details on how the form factor sits on various vertices in both methods.

  3. Robust estimation of missing higher orders using theory nuisance parameters, specifically by constructing a new rule for treating radiative return where first-order corrections are of order one.

  4. Precise calculation of initial-final interference and real-virtual corrections through the amplitude level, ensuring that the initial-final interference at amplitude level is included via the sum over partitions.

  5. Incorporation of resummation techniques for soft and soft-collinear logarithms by truncating the expansion in alpha to second and third order to test convergence, as shown in equation (2.28).

  6. Development of a comprehensive framework for theoretical uncertainty estimation using theory nuisance parameters, including parameters for the two-loop photonic vertices and the incomplete second order, extending previous work by introducing a parameter for the next term in the radiative return series.

  7. Ability to perform detailed comparison with existing NLO parton shower predictions like BabaYaga@NLO across various experimental scenarios (CMD, KLOE-I, BESIII, B) to quantify discrepancies and agreement at different perturbative orders O(alpha) and O(alpha2L).

Abstract

We present QED corrections to e+e-toπ+π-(γ) in two independent Monte Carlo event generators, KKMC and SHERPA, for point-like scalar pions dressed with the pion form factor. All-order soft-photon exponentiation is combined with exact one- and two-photon tree amplitudes, the complete one-loop correction including the initial-final boxes with coherent interference, and at second order the photonic two-loop vertices and the exact one-loop correction to one-photon emission. At first order their fiducial cross sections agree to 0.04% and their distributions within statistical precision. The second-order band is about0.005% for CMD, about0.4% at 4 GeV and about0.9% at 10 GeV. Theory nuisance parameters estimate missing higher orders, and we construct a new rule for treating radiative return, where first-order corrections are of order one.

Sources

Related papers