The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: The Tully-Fisher Relation at z = 4-6
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST survey investigates the stellar and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations at high redshifts, providing crucial insights into how galaxy mass and kinematics evolve from cosmic noon to earlier epochs The measurements reveal that disk galaxies at z = 4−6 lie below local relations for both the stellar-mass TFR and the baryonic TFR, with zero-point offsets indicating an evolution driven by dark matter halo properties Sample Characterization The study analyzes JWST/NIRSpec IFU observations of 18 main-sequence star-forming galaxies belonging to the ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST survey at z = 4−6 These targets span stellar masses of M⋆ ≈ 109−11 M⊙ and intrinsic rotational velocities of 91 − 127 km s−1 The analysis also identifies five disk-like galaxies, representing a survey disk fraction of 0.28 ± 0.11 Kinematic Analysis and Classification The researchers employed a morpho-kinematic disk classification scheme to identify galaxy types The criteria for a "disk galaxy" include having a continuous velocity gradient along a single axis, the ratio between rotational velocity and velocity dispersion being greater than or similar to one, and the kinematic center coinciding with the continuum centroid For disk galaxies, they compute asymmetric drift correction terms to estimate circular velocities using Equation 2 Tully-Fisher Relation Offsets The findings indicate that the ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST disks lie below the local relations for both TFRs For the stellar-mass TFR, zero-point offsets of −0.96±0.18 dex and −0.50±0.18 dex relative to the local Universe and cosmic noon are measured Similarly, for the baryonic TFR, zero-point offsets of −0.57 ± 0.20 dex and −0.30 ± 0.20 dex with respect to the local Universe and cosmic noon are found Cosmic Evolution Modeling The authors extend the empirical model of Übler et al.
Vera: (2017) up to z = 5, finding good agreement with their best-fit zero-points for both TFRs The redshift evolution of both TFR zero-points is driven by the cosmic evolution of dark matter halo properties, modulated by a reduced contribution of dark matter to the dynamical mass on the galaxy scale Disk Settling and Turbulence The kinematic parameters for the disk-like sample span intrinsic V2.2 = 91 − 127 km s−1 and σ0 = 66 − 129 km s−1, suggesting that random motions remain important in these systems The observed velocity dispersion and V2.2/σ0 ratios are consistent with the expectations for marginally stable disks given the average gas fraction of the systems at this cosmic epoch These results suggest that rotating disk-like systems were already in place within the first ∼ 1 Gyr of cosmic time, although their kinematics show high degree of turbulence Overall, the study provides one of the first spatially resolved views of the Tully-Fisher relation for main-sequence galaxies at z = 4−6 Larger JWST/NIRSpec IFU samples, together with deeper ALMA observations for the cold gas and spatially resolved dynamical modeling, will be key for determining whether the offsets reported here are representative of the bulk galaxy population at these redshifts Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The authors note that their inferred zero-point offsets are based on a small number of disk galaxies The scatter in the recovered offsets was ∼ 0.25 dex for five galaxies and ∼ 0.18 dex for nine galaxies, both smaller than the offsets reported here How the training signal is built The analysis involves fitting data cubes pixel-by-pixel to build maps of Hα emission-line intensity, line-of-sight velocity (VLOS), and velocity dispersion (σV) The intrinsic kinematic parameters are inferred using the forward modeling code DYSMALpy to address observational systematics Where the gains come from The authors find that their best-fit zero-points change by only ∆β = +0.11 dex relative to the fit to our sample alone, which is smaller than the 1σ uncertainty of the latter The empirical model of Übler et al.
Jocelyn: (2017) predicts different variations in the bTFR zero-point offset with redshift, highlighting how sensitive these are to the adopted fDM(< Re,z) prescription Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The kinematic tracer used, Hα, could include some contribution from non-circular motions, such as ionized gas outflow or extraplanar regions The full CRISTAL disk sample has a median intrinsic dispersion of ∼ 70 km s−1, consistent with the high gas fractions of systems and turbulence being driven by gravitational instabilities and gas transport How the training signal is built The authors compare their non-parametric measurements with the intrinsic kinematic parameters inferred from the DYSMALpy forward models, which explicitly account for projection effects and convolution with the spatial PSF and spectral LSF The intrinsic V2.2 values inferred with DYSMALpy are systematically larger than the directly measured inclination-corrected values, by a factor of ∼ 1.3 on average (∼ 0.10 dex) Where the gains come from The authors adopt the Burkert et al.
Vera: (2010) correction because it is consistent with their use of a single characteristic dispersion, σ0, and allows a direct comparison with previous high-redshift Tully-Fisher studies The adopted asymmetric-drift prescription gives α = 2, which assumes an exponential gas surface density profile and a constant, isotropic velocity dispersion Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The authors find that the disk galaxies in their sample are offset with respect to the low-z stellar-mass and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations Three sources closely follow the cosmic noon bTFR, while the other two systems are offset from this relation How the training signal is built The authors find that their best-fit zero-points are consistent with the empirical model of Übler et al.
Title and authors: Jocelyn: Moving on to the title itself, "The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: The Tully-Fisher Relation at z = four-six <ref:2611.07064#pg1,The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: The Tully-Fisher Relation at z = 4>." It really tells you exactly what we’re looking at—a specific survey using JWST to measure these relations at a very early cosmic time.
Vera: And the authors listed are a big group, including D. A. Gómez-Espinoza and J. Molina, with collaborators like M. Aravena and P. Cassata involved in getting all this data together from different telescopes and filters.
Subrahmanyan: It’s important to know who is doing the modeling here because the authors mention they are extending existing models, which tells us they are connecting their specific observations to a broader theoretical framework of structure formation.
Jocelyn: The implication there is that this isn't just a snapshot of some random galaxies; it’s an attempt to map out how these relations have shifted over cosmic time using the best available data from JWST.
The paper's summary: Vera: So, the core of what they found in "The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: The Tully-Fisher Relation at z = four-six" is that disk galaxies at redshift four to six lie below local relations for both the stellar mass TFR and the baryonic TFR <ref:2611.07064#pg1,The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: The Tully-Fisher Relation at z = 4>.
Jocelyn: They quantified this by measuring zero point offsets. For instance, they measured a zero point offset of negative zero point nine six plus or minus zero one eight dex for the stellar mass Tully-Fisher relation compared to our local universe and cosmic noon.
Subrahmanyan: Negative offsets mean that at those earlier times, galaxies of the same stellar mass were spinning faster than predicted by local relations, which points toward a change in how gas is converted into stars within those dark matter halos.
Vera: That’s the interpretation they are driving—that this evolution is driven by dark matter halo properties, and they found that their empirical model of Übler et al. two thousand seventeen agrees well with their best-fit zero points for systems at redshift four to five <ref:2611.07064#pg1>.
The paper's improvements: Jocelyn: They also discuss some things they think improve the analysis, which is how they handle the kinematics and the modeling process for these high redshift systems.
Vera: They mention that they used a morpho-kinematic disk classification scheme to identify five disk-like galaxies in their sample, setting a survey disk fraction of zero point two eight plus or minus zero one one.
Subrahmanyan: I’m interested in the kinematic details; they found that while the intrinsic rotational velocities were around nine one to twelve seven kilometers per second, the velocity dispersion values were still quite high, between sixty six and one twenty nine kilometers per second.
Jocelyn: It sounds like their analysis of disk settling and turbulence shows that even these rotating systems had a significant degree of random motion in them at this early cosmic epoch.
Conclusion: Vera: So, to wrap up, the study on "The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: The Tully-Fisher Relation at z = four-six" shows that these disk galaxies are offset from the local relations for both the stellar and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations <ref:2611.07064#pg1,The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: The Tully-Fisher Relation at z = 4>.
Jocelyn: Specifically, they found zero point offsets of negative zero point nine six plus or minus zero one eight dex for stellar mass and negative zero point five seven plus or minus zero two ten dex for baryonic mass when compared to the local universe and cosmic noon.
Subrahmanyan: This evolution in both TFRs is driven by the cosmic evolution of dark matter halo properties, modulated by a reduced contribution of dark matter to the dynamical mass on the galaxy scale, which is what they’re modeling.
Vera: The paper notes that while their inferred zero point offsets are based on a small number of disk galaxies, like five for one set and nine for another, and the scatter in those recovered offsets was smaller than what they reported here.
Jocelyn: They also mention that the best-fit zero points were consistent with the empirical model of Übler et al. two thousand seventeen for systems at redshift four to five, suggesting their modeling approach is robust within that framework <ref:2611.07064#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: It’s a good thing they adopt their analytical prescription for the dark matter fraction because it avoids the high values seen in other parameterizations, which makes sense given how much that term affects the model compared to what Übler et al. two thousand seventeen predicts for redshift evolution, so this is a reasonable choice <ref:2611.07064#pg1>.
Vera: So, in summary, this paper provides one of the first spatially resolved views of the Tully-Fisher relation for main-sequence galaxies at redshift four to six using JWST data and dynamical modeling.
Jocelyn: And they stress that larger JWST/NIRSpec IFU samples combined with deeper ALMA observations are going to be key to confirming whether these offsets are representative of the whole galaxy population at those redshifts.
D. A. Gómez-Espinoza, J. Molina, E. Ibar, M. Aravena, R. J. Assef, M. Boquien, M., Béthermin, P., , , , , , , ,
ESO
astro-ph.GA
Submitted: 2026-11-04
Updated: 2026-11-04
Comments: 13 pages, 6 Figures, 2 Tables, Accepted for Publication in A&A
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST survey investigates the stellar and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations at high redshifts…
Key concepts
- Tully-Fisher Relation (TFR)
- A relationship between a galaxy's intrinsic luminosity or mass and its maximum rotational velocity. It helps astronomers understand how galaxies are structured and how their mass relates to the speed at which they rotate.
- Zero-point Offset
- The difference in the baseline value of a TFR when comparing high-redshift galaxies to local ones. Negative offsets here mean that for a given mass, these early galaxies appear less luminous or have lower rotation speeds than expected from local relations.
- Dark Matter Halo Properties
- The characteristics of the invisible dark matter structures surrounding galaxies. The study suggests that how these halos evolve over cosmic time is the primary driver causing the observed shifts in TFR zero-points at high redshifts.
- Disk Galaxy Classification
- A method used to categorize galaxies based on their shape and kinematics, specifically looking for continuous velocity gradients along one axis and a rotational velocity significantly greater than the random motions (velocity dispersion).
Summary
The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST survey investigates the stellar and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations at high redshifts, providing crucial insights into how galaxy mass and kinematics evolve from cosmic noon to earlier epochs The measurements reveal that disk galaxies at z = 4−6 lie below local relations for both the stellar-mass TFR and the baryonic TFR, with zero-point offsets indicating an evolution driven by dark matter halo properties
Sample Characterization
The study analyzes JWST/NIRSpec IFU observations of 18 main-sequence star-forming galaxies belonging to the ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST survey at z = 4−6 These targets span stellar masses of M⋆ ≈ 109−11 M⊙ and intrinsic rotational velocities of 91 − 127 km s−1 The analysis also identifies five disk-like galaxies, representing a survey disk fraction of 0.28 ± 0.11
Kinematic Analysis and Classification
The researchers employed a morpho-kinematic disk classification scheme to identify galaxy types The criteria for a disk galaxy
include having a continuous velocity gradient along a single axis, the ratio between rotational velocity and velocity dispersion being greater than or similar to one, and the kinematic center coinciding with the continuum centroid For disk galaxies, they compute asymmetric drift correction terms to estimate circular velocities using Equation 2
Tully-Fisher Relation Offsets
The findings indicate that the ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST disks lie below the local relations for both TFRs For the stellar-mass TFR, zero-point offsets of −0.96±0.18 dex and −0. p. 0 By fixing the TFR slope to the z = 0 value, we measure zero-point offsets for the
stellar-mass TFR of −0. 18 dex and −0. 18 dex relative to the local Universe and cosmic noon, respectively. For the baryonic TFR, we
find zero-point offsets of −0. By fixing the TFR slope to the z = 0 value, we measure zero-point offsets for the
stellar-mass TFR of −0. 18 dex and −0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Cosmic Evolution Modeling
The authors extend the empirical model of Übler et al. (2017) up to z = 5, finding good agreement with their best-fit zero-points for both TFRs The redshift evolution of both TFR zero-points is driven by the cosmic evolution of dark matter halo properties, modulated by a reduced contribution of dark matter to the dynamical mass on the galaxy scale
Disk Settling and Turbulence
The kinematic parameters for the disk-like sample span intrinsic V2.2 = 91 − 127 km s−1 and σ0 = 66 − 129 km s−1, suggesting that random motions remain important in these systems The observed velocity dispersion and V2. p. 6 2/σ0 ≃ 0. These values indicate
large random motions and significant asymmetric-drift corrections to be applied for estimating Vcirc.Where the paper says it
Conclusion
Overall, the study provides one of the first spatially resolved views of the Tully-Fisher relation for main-sequence galaxies at z = 4−6 Larger JWST/NIRSpec IFU samples, together with deeper ALMA observations for the cold gas and spatially resolved dynamical modeling, will be key for determining whether the offsets reported here are representative of the bulk galaxy population at these redshifts
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The authors note that their inferred zero-point offsets are based on a small number of disk galaxies The scatter in the recovered offsets was ∼ 0.25 dex for five galaxies and ∼ 0. p. 9 The scatter in the recovered offsets
was ∼ 0. 25 dex for five galaxies and ∼ 0.Where the paper says it
How the training signal is built
The analysis involves fitting data cubes pixel-by-pixel to build maps of Hα emission-line intensity, line-of-sight velocity (VLOS), and velocity dispersion (σV) The intrinsic kinematic parameters are inferred using the forward modeling code DYSMALpy to address observational systematics
Where the gains come from
The authors find that their best-fit zero-points change by only ∆β = +0.11 dex relative to the fit to our sample alone, which is smaller than the 1σ uncertainty of the latter The empirical model of Übler et al. p. 7 The fitted zero-point changes by only
∆β = +0. 11 dex relative to the fit to our sample alone, which
is smaller than the 1σ uncertainty of the latter.Where the paper says it
The kinematic tracer used, Hα, could include some contribution from non-circular motions, such as ionized gas outflow or extraplanar regions The full CRISTAL disk sample has a median intrinsic dispersion of ∼ 70 km s−1, consistent with the high gas fractions of systems and turbulence being driven by gravitational instabilities and gas transport
The authors compare their non-parametric measurements with the intrinsic kinematic parameters inferred from the DYSMALpy forward models, which explicitly account for projection effects and convolution with the spatial PSF and spectral LSF The intrinsic V2.2 values inferred with DYSMALpy are systematically larger than the directly measured inclination-corrected values, by a factor of ∼ 1. p. 6 The intrinsic V2. 2 values inferred with DYSMALpy are systematically larger than the directly measured inclination-corrected values, by a factor of ∼ 1. 2009; Wisnioski et al. These
galaxies were found, on average, exhibiting larger velocity dispersions and lower rotational support compared to their local
counterparts (Wisnioski et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The authors adopt the Burkert et al. (2010) correction because it is consistent with their use of a single characteristic dispersion, σ0, and allows a direct comparison with previous high-redshift Tully-Fisher studies The adopted asymmetric-drift prescription gives α = 2, which assumes an exponential gas surface density profile and a constant, isotropic velocity dispersion
The authors find that the disk galaxies in their sample are offset with respect to the low-z stellar-mass and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations Three sources closely follow the cosmic noon bTFR, while the other two systems are offset from this relation
The authors find that their best-fit zero-points are consistent with the empirical model of Übler et al. (2017) for z ≈ 5 systems, and are also broadly consistent with their results The redshift evolution of both TFR zero-points is driven by the cosmic evolution of dark matter halo properties, modulated by a reduced contribution of dark matter to the dynamical mass on the galaxy scale
The authors adopt their analytical prescription for fDM(< Re,z) because it does not peak at high values as in the parameterizations of Nestor Shachar et al. (2023) This is because the fDM(< Re,z) parameterization of Nestor Shachar et al. p. 8 6 ≲ z ≲ 2. 5, we consider fDM(Re,z)
values taken from the RC100 sample (Nestor Shachar et al. To account for these effects, we compare our measurements with the
predictions of the empirical model of Übler et al. (2017):
Mbar ∝
V
3
circ
1 − fDM(< Re,z)
3/2
H(z) [md(z)]
1/2
, (4a)
M⋆ ∝
V
3
circ
1 − fDM(< Re,z)
3/2
h
1 − fgas(z)
i
H(z) [md(z)]
1/2
, (4b)
where fDM(< Re,z) is the dark matter fraction within one effective radius.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The authors caution that the inferred zero-point offsets are based on a small number of disk galaxies The results suggest that rotating disk-like systems were already in place within the first ∼ 1 Gyr of cosmic time, although their kinematics show high degree of turbulence
The authors estimate a bTFR intrinsic scatter of 0.28 dex using pymc This value is not particularly driven by the inclusion of any of their targets or the literature data The results obtained with DYSMALpy are presented in Table 2
The authors find that the disk galaxies in their sample are offset with respect to the low-z stellar-mass and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations The zero-point offsets for both TFRs are smaller compared to those measured for the sTFR This suggests that rotating disk-like systems were already in place within the first ∼ 1 Gyr of cosmic time, although their kinematics show high degree of turbulence
The authors note that the inferred zero-point offsets are based on a small number of disk galaxies The results suggest that rotating disk-like systems were already in place within the first ∼ 1 Gyr of cosmic time, although their kinematics show high degree of turbulence
The authors find that their best-fit zero-points are consistent with the empirical model of Übler et al. (2017) for z ≈ 5 systems, and are also broadly consistent with their results The redshift evolution of both TFR zero-points is driven by the cosmic evolution of dark matter halo properties, modulated by a reduced contribution of dark matter to the dynamical mass on the galaxy scale
The authors caution that their inferred zero-point offsets are based on a small number of disk galaxies The results suggest that rotating disk-like systems were already in place within the first ∼ 1 Gyr of cosmic time, although their kinematics show high degree of turbulence
The authors find that their best-fit zero-points are consistent with the empirical model of Übler et al.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Develop a system capable of identifying disk-like galaxies at high redshift by applying a twostep classification scheme based on H alpha velocity fields and JWST/NIRCam F444W images, as described in Section 3.3. This allows the AI to determine if a source is an isolated galaxy, a galaxy pair, or perturbed kinematics.
-
Implement kinematic measurement pipelines that incorporate asymmetric drift correction using the Burkert et al 2010 prescription to estimate circular velocities from ionized gas kinematics, as detailed in Section 3.5 and Figure F.1. This enables the AI to derive intrinsic velocity dispersion values by comparing non-parametric measurements with forward modeling results from DYSMALpy (Section 3.6).
-
Enable the AI to quantify the zero-point offsets for both stellar mass and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations relative to local and cosmic noon relations, specifically reporting offsets of
−0.96 ± 0.18 dex
for stellar mass and−0.57 ± 0.20 dex
for baryonic mass (Section 4). -
Allow the system to perform a forward modeling analysis using DYSMALpy to derive intrinsic kinematic parameters, such as circular velocity at the effective radius, by fitting composite mass models that include bulge, disk, and dark matter halo components. This addresses limitations imposed by limited spectral resolution and spatial resolution (Section 3.6).
-
Implement a framework for modeling the cosmic evolution of the baryonic and stellar Tully-Fisher relations up to redshift z = 5 by adopting an updated empirical model of Übler et al 2017, which accounts for the evolution of dark matter halo properties and gas fractions (Section 4.4).
Abstract
The Tully-Fisher relation provides a fundamental link between galaxy mass and their kinematics. Although its evolution is relatively well constrained up to cosmic noon, observational probes at higher redshifts remain scarce. In this work, we investigate the stellar and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations (TFRs) at z=4-6 by analyzing JWST/NIRSpec IFU observations of 18 main-sequence star-forming galaxies belonging to the ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST survey. We apply a morpho-kinematic disk classification scheme, finding five disk-like galaxies and a survey disk fraction of 0.28 plus or minus0.11. These disk galaxies span stellar masses of 10 9.5-10.5,M, intrinsic rotational velocities of 91-127, km,s-1, and intrinsic velocity dispersions of 66-129, km,s-1. For both versions of the TFR, we find that the ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST disks lie below the local relations and are likely offset from those reported at cosmic noon (z about2.3). By fixing the TFR slope to the z=0 value, we measure zero-point offsets for the stellar-mass TFR of-0.96 plus or minus0.18 dex and-0.50 plus or minus0.18 dex relative to the local Universe and cosmic noon, respectively. For the baryonic TFR, we find zero-point offsets of-0.57 plus or minus0.20 dex and-0.30 plus or minus0.20 dex with respect to the local Universe and cosmic noon relations. Our measurements are consistent with the redshift evolution of the zero-points of both TFRs being driven by the evolution of dark matter halo properties with cosmic time, modulated by a reduced contribution of dark matter to the dynamical mass on the galaxy scale.
Sources
- REBELS-IFU: on the origin of the elevated [OIII]/[CII] ratios in the early Universe
- The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: NIRSpec IFU Data Processing and Spatially-resolved Views of Chemical Enrichment in Normal Galaxies at z=4-6
- GA-NIFS: A post-starburst main sequence disk galaxy undergoing ordered rotation at z=4.26
Related papers
- The Pristine survey XXVIII. Journey to the Galactic outskirts: Mapping the outer halo red giant stars down to the very metal-poor end
- Origins of Extreme Emission-Line Ratios in z > 3 Galaxies: Insights from the Lumen Model
- The Kinematically Hot, Extremely Metal-Poor C-19 Stellar Stream in DESI DR2
- UV slopes of Starforming Galaxies in Strong Lensing fields at the Epoch of Reionization with JWST
- Evolution of Binaries Under Stochastic Perturbations
- The hydrodynamical response of cold circumgalactic clouds to quasar radiation