The retirement party of GRS 1915+105: the radio fading to quiescence of the archetypal microquasar

arXiv:2611.07039 · astro-ph.HE · Submitted 2026-11-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The retirement party of GRS 1915+105".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The radio emission of GRS 1915+105 has declined to levels never recorded before, i.e., several times below the faintest radio levels recorded before the current decline, so that the source is now, for the first time, faint in every band in which it has been observed The radio decline has been steady and essentially monotonic over the ∼14 months since the end of the last flaring episode (2025 January–May), with no re-brightening at any point Characterizing the Fading Trend The study aims to characterize the descent of GRS 1915+105 from its long-lived obscured radio plateau, and to establish whether the fading marks the end of the outburst that began in 1992 or a temporary switch-off The radio emission, the only band among those monitored that is unaffected by the local absorption, has declined to levels never recorded before, i.e., several times below the faintest radio levels recorded before the current decline This decline is consistent with hydrodynamic and disc-instability modelling of the system which predicted that the outburst that began in 1992 would exhaust the disc mass reservoir after a total duration of ∼20–100 yr, followed by a quiescence of order 104 yr Constraints from Multi-Wavelength Data The authors present long-term MeerKAT monitoring and deep dual-band observations to trace the source's evolution Key findings include: The 2026 July deep dual-band MeerKAT observations detect the source at ∼150 µJy in L band and ∼90 µJy in S band, the lowest radio flux densities recorded from the system since its discovery, corresponding to LR ≃ 2 × 1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz The corresponding spectral index is α = −0.67 ± 0.41 across 1.28–2.62 GHz, the first measured for this source in this regime The X-ray flux has declined slowly, and the radio behavior was markedly different, in that the source remained formally detected at the 3σ level at every pointed monitoring epoch until 2026 February, that is, for several months after the X-rays had vanished The source has faded to the luminosities expected of a quiescent black-hole binary of its 33.85 d orbital period: the measured radio luminosity and the X-ray upper limit are both consistent with the LR–Porb, LX–Porb and LR–LX relations traced by the quiescent population Inferring Intrinsic Luminosity The radio measurements allow for an independent estimate of how much X-ray flux the obscurer removed while the source was still detectable By adopting the black-hole and black-hole-candidate correlation of Crook-Mansour et al.

Vera: (2026) drawn in Fig.

Jocelyn: 2 (Sect.

Vera: 3.3), together with the 2026 July L-band measurement LR = (2.0±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz, we obtain an intrinsic LX(1–10 keV) ≈ 7 × 1034 erg s−1 This estimate is consistent with the quiescent population even in the absence of absorption Nature of the Radio Spectrum The stacked α = −0.67±0.36(stat)±0.20(sys) across 1.28–2.62 GHz is consistent with optically thin synchrotron emission, as would be expected from expanding ejecta A compact core of up to ∼100 µJy may hide beneath the steep spectrum, although the best fit prefers a negligible core for thin slopes of −0.6 to −0.7 Consistency with Quiescent Systems The measured radio luminosity, (2.0±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz (1028.3), lies about 4% above the best-fitting relation, 1.9 × 1028 erg s−1 The measured radio luminosity and the X-ray upper limit are both consistent with the LR–Porb, LX–Porb and LR–LX relations traced by the quiescent population The measured native L-band luminosity, (2.0±0.5)×1028 erg s−1, lies about 4% above the best-fitting relation, 1.9 × 1028 erg s−1 The radio emission, the only monitored band unaffected by the local absorption, is at present the only accessible tracer of the accretion activity since the obscuration prevents us from observing the latter directly in the X-rays The radio decline has been steady and essentially monotonic over the ∼14 months since the end of the last flaring episode (2025 January–May), with no re-brightening at any point The disc mass reservoir predicted by hydrodynamic and disc-instability modelling should be running out at about this time, the predicted outburst duration of ∼20–100 yr being consistent with the thirty-four years elapsed The alternative, an undiminished central engine hidden behind a thicker absorber, appears disfavoured because it would require the column to increase by more than an order of magnitude, to NH ≳ 2×1025 cm−2 for a fully covering absorber The switch-off of the core provides a rare test of the origin of the very-high-energy emission associated with GRS 1915+105 Implications for Future Studies The fading of the accretion-driven emission enables studies of the evolved donor largely free of the disc contamination and the obscuration that have hampered such work since discovery, allowing its spectral type and wind to be constrained more precisely The switch-off of the core provides a rare test of the origin of the very-high-energy emission associated with GRS 1915+105 Data Availability The MeerKAT visibilities are stored in the SARAO archive (https://archive.sarao.ac.za) under the project codes SCI-20180516-PW-01 (ThunderKAT), SCI-20230907-RF-01 (X-KAT) and DDT-20260703-SM-01 (DDT) The Einstein Probe/FXT data will become public through the ESA Einstein Probe Science Archive (https://ama.esac.esa.int) and the Chinese National Astronomical Data Centre after the proprietary period The MAXI/GSC and Swift/BAT light curves are public (http://maxi.riken.jp and https://swift.gsfc.nasa.gov/results/transients/) Acknowledgements The authors thank the anonymous referee, whose comments helped to improve the clarity of the manuscript SEM thanks SARAO for approving the DDT request DDT-20260703-SM-01, and acknowledges support from the INAF Fundamental Research Grant (2022) EJECTA RF acknowledges support from the UKRI, European Research Council Synergy Grant ’Blackholistic’ (grant agreement number 101071643) and The Hintze Family Charitable Foundation AM acknowledges support from the Fund Vera Rubin/Chile 2024, under the project DIA 1736 “Silent black holes around red supergiants”, the H2020 ERC Consolidator Grant “MAGNESIA” under grant agreement No.

Title and authors: Jocelyn: Now let's talk about who wrote this. We have Vera, Jocelyn, Subrahmanyan, and a whole team listed—it’s quite a group of experts pulling together the data analysis and the theory.

Vera: I like that diversity in expertise because we need people who understand both the observational data constraints we get from surveys and what those constraints actually mean for the physical process happening at the black hole.

Subrahmanyan: I’m interested in how they connect this specific radio fading to the larger picture of accretion flow physics, especially since they mention ADAF models or synchrotron jet emission as potential explanations for that emission.

Jocelyn: I’m focused on what the observations themselves reveal about the source's state right now, particularly those deep MeerKAT and Einstein Probe observations they used.

The paper's summary: Vera: The core finding of "The retirement party of GRS one thousand nine hundred fifteen plusone hundred five: the radio fading to quiescence of the archetypal microquasar" is that this source is indeed settling into quiescence, and the current radio emission is now primarily traced by radiatively inefficient processes <ref:2611.07039#pg1,The retirement party of GRS 1915+105: the radio fading to quiescence>.

Jocelyn: They show that this fading aligns with predictions from models suggesting that after an outburst of about twenty to one hundred years, we get a long period of quiet activity before it truly shuts down.

Subrahmanyan: They also noted that the measured radio luminosity at one point was about four percent above the best-fitting relation for quiescent black hole binaries, which is interesting because it’s right on the edge of what we expect for these settled systems.

Vera: They used deep MeerKAT and dual-band observations to get a specific measurement: they found a radio flux density of approximately one hundred fifty microjanskys in the L band and about ninety microjanskys in the S band during their July two thousand twenty-six observations.

Jocelyn: And they also measured a spectral index of alpha equal to negative zero point six seven plus or minus zero point four one across the frequency range from one point two eight gigahertz to two point six two gigahertz, which is a new measurement for this source in that regime.

The paper's improvements: Subrahmanyan: One of the key things they suggest improving is how we estimate the intrinsic luminosity. They propose using the black-hole and black-hole candidate correlation drawn in Figure two to get an independent estimate of how much X-ray flux the obscurer removed while the source was still detectable.

Vera: That’s important because without that correction, our direct measurement of radio power wouldn't tell us much about what’s actually happening inside the system once we account for all that intervening material.

Jocelyn: They also mentioned improving the X-ray data processing by creating a more rigorous uncertainty assessment for upper limits. They want to explicitly account for the ambiguity whether a non-detection is due to intrinsic fading or if there was just a further rise in local obscuration.

Vera: That’s good because it addresses that fundamental problem we always have when we look at X-rays; is the source dimming because the accretion flow itself cooled down, or is something else blocking the view?

Conclusion: Jocelyn: So to wrap up, this paper on "The retirement party of GRS one thousand nine hundred fifteen plusone hundred five: the radio fading to quiescence of the archetypal microquasar" strongly suggests that we are seeing this system finally transition into a quiescent state <ref:2611.07039#pg1,The retirement party of GRS 1915+105: the radio fading to quiescence>.

Subrahmanyan: The evidence they use—the radio emission being the only monitored band unaffected by local absorption, and the disc mass reservoir running out according to their models—points toward this conclusion being sound.

Vera: They conclude that the alternative, an undiminished central engine hidden behind a thicker absorber requiring a column density greater than two times ten to twenty five centimeters squared, is disfavored because of how much obscuration it would need.

Jocelyn: And they leave us with implications for future studies: this fading allows us to study the evolved donor system more clearly, and the core switch-off provides a rare test for the origin of that very high energy emission we see in GRS one thousand nine hundred fifteen plusone hundred five <ref:2611.07039#pg1>.

Vera: It’s a lot of work to pin down these things, but this paper gives us a solid anchor point on where this archetypal microquasar is heading now.

S. E. Motta, R. P. Fender, A. Marino, P. Atri, F. Carotenuto, D. Williams-Baldwin, M. C., Jun-Ping Chen, Wei Chen, F., , , , , ,

ESO

astro-ph.HE

Submitted: 2026-11-04

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures, 4 tables. Accepted for publication in A&A

Code: https://github.com/IanHeywood/oxkat

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: The radio emission of GRS 1915+105 has declined to levels never recorded before, i.e., several times below the faintest radio levels recorded before the current decline…

Key concepts

Radio Fading to Quiescence
This refers to the steady, monotonic decline in radio emission from GRS 1915+105 over several months. This trend suggests the accretion outburst is ending and the system is settling into a quiescent state, rather than being a temporary switch-off.
Disc-Instability Modelling
These models predict that the disc mass reservoir in GRS 1915+105 will be exhausted after about 20 to 100 years of outburst activity. The observed fading is consistent with this depletion timescale, suggesting the system is running out of fuel.
LR–Porb and LX–Porb Relations
These are established relationships between a black hole's radio luminosity (LR) and its X-ray luminosity (LX) for quiescent black hole binaries. By comparing GRS 1915+105's measured values to these relations, researchers can estimate its intrinsic luminosity, confirming it behaves like other quiescent systems.

Terminology

Summary

The radio emission of GRS 1915+105 has declined to levels never recorded before, i. p. 7e., several times below the faintest radio levels recorded before the current decline, so that the source is now, for the first time, faint in every band in which it has been observed The radio decline has been steady and essentially monotonic over the ∼14 months since the end of the last flaring episode (2025 January–May), with no re-brightening at any point

Characterizing the Fading Trend

The study aims to characterize the descent of GRS 1915+105 from its long-lived obscured radio plateau, and to establish whether the fading marks the end of the outburst that began in 1992 or a temporary switch-off The radio emission, the only band among those monitored that is unaffected by the local absorption, has declined to levels never recorded before, i.e., several times below the faintest radio levels recorded before the current decline This decline is consistent with hydrodynamic and disc-instability modelling of the system which predicted that the outburst that began in 1992 would exhaust the disc mass reservoir after a total duration of ∼20–100 yr, followed by a quiescence of order 104 yr

Constraints from Multi-Wavelength Data

The authors present long-term MeerKAT monitoring and deep dual-band observations to trace the source's evolution Key findings include:

** The 2026 July deep dual-band MeerKAT observations detect the source at ∼150 µJy in L band and ∼90 µJy in S band, the lowest radio flux densities recorded from the system since its discovery, corresponding to LR ≃ 2 × 1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz The corresponding spectral index is α = −0. p. 067 ± 0.41 across 1. p. 028–2.62 GHz, the first measured for this source in this regime **

** The X-ray flux has declined slowly, and the radio behavior was markedly different, in that the source remained formally detected at the 3σ level at every pointed monitoring epoch until 2026 February, that is, for several months after the X-rays had vanished **

** The source has faded to the luminosities expected of a quiescent black-hole binary of its 33.85 d orbital period: the measured radio luminosity and the X-ray upper limit are both consistent with the LR–Porb, LX–Porb and LR–LX relations traced by the quiescent population **

Inferring Intrinsic Luminosity

The radio measurements allow for an independent estimate of how much X-ray flux the obscurer removed while the source was still detectable By adopting the black-hole and black-hole-candidate correlation of Crook-Mansour et al. (2026) drawn in Fig. p. 9 2 (Sect. 3.3), together with the 2026 July L-band measurement LR = (2. p. 90±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 028 GHz, we obtain an intrinsic LX(1–10 keV) ≈ 7 × 1034 erg s−1 This estimate is consistent with the quiescent population even in the absence of absorption

Nature of the Radio Spectrum

The stacked α = −0.67±0.36(stat)±0. p. 520(sys) across 1. p. 528–2.62 GHz is consistent with optically thin synchrotron emission, as would be expected from expanding ejecta A compact core of up to ∼100 µJy may hide beneath the steep spectrum, although the best fit prefers a negligible core for thin slopes of −0. p. 06 to −0.7

Consistency with Quiescent Systems

The measured radio luminosity, (2.0±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz (1028. p. 53), lies about 4% above the best-fitting relation, 1. p. 69 × 1028 erg s−1 The measured radio luminosity and the X-ray upper limit are both consistent with the LR–Porb, LX–Porb and LR–LX relations traced by the quiescent population The measured native L-band luminosity, (2. p. 60±0.5)×1028 erg s−1, lies about 4% above the best-fitting relation, 1. p. 99 × 1028 erg s−1

Conclusions on Quiescence

The radio emission, the only monitored band unaffected by the local absorption, is at present the only accessible tracer of the accretion activity since the obscuration prevents us from observing the latter directly in the X-rays The radio decline has been steady and essentially monotonic over the ∼14 months since the end of the last flaring episode (2025 January–May), with no re-brightening at any point The disc mass reservoir predicted by hydrodynamic and disc-instability modelling should be running out at about this time, the predicted outburst duration of ∼20–100 yr being consistent with the thirty-four years elapsed The alternative, an undiminished central engine hidden behind a thicker absorber, appears disfavoured because it would require the column to increase by more than an order of magnitude, to NH ≳ 2×1025 cm−2 for a fully covering absorber The switch-off of the core provides a rare test of the origin of the very-high-energy emission associated with GRS 1915+105

Implications for Future Studies

The fading of the accretion-driven emission enables studies of the evolved donor largely free of the disc contamination and the obscuration that have hampered such work since discovery, allowing its spectral type and wind to be constrained more precisely The switch-off of the core provides a rare test of the origin of the very-high-energy emission associated with GRS 1915+105

Data Availability

The MeerKAT visibilities are stored in the SARAO archive (https://archive.sarao.ac.za) under the project codes SCI-20180516-PW-01 (ThunderKAT), SCI-20230907-RF-01 (X-KAT) and DDT-20260703-SM-01 (DDT) The Einstein Probe/FXT data will become public through the ESA Einstein Probe Science Archive (https://ama. p. 0 p. 0esac.esa.int) and the Chinese National Astronomical Data Centre after the proprietary period The MAXI/GSC and Swift/BAT light curves are public (http://maxi. p. 3 p. 3riken.jp and https://swift. p. 1 p. 1gsfc.nasa.gov/results/transients/)

Acknowledgements

The authors thank the anonymous referee, whose comments helped to improve the clarity of the manuscript SEM thanks SARAO for approving the DDT request DDT-20260703-SM-01, and acknowledges support from the INAF Fundamental Research Grant (2022) EJECTA RF acknowledges support from the UKRI, European Research Council Synergy Grant ’Blackholistic’ (grant agreement number 101071643) and The Hintze Family Charitable Foundation AM acknowledges support from the Fund Vera Rubin/Chile 2024, under the project DIA 1736 “Silent black holes around red supergiants”, the H2020 ERC Consolidator Grant “MAGNESIA” under grant agreement No. 817661 (PI: Rea) and the National Spanish grant PID2023-153099NA-I00 (PI: Coti Zelati) CS acknowledges funding from the Italian Space Agency, contract ASI/INAF n. p. 0 I/004/11/6, and financial support from the Bando Ricerca Fondamentale INAF 2024 Large Grant “Timing the Ultra Luminous X-ray Pulsars (TULiP)” MCB acknowledges support from the INAF Fundamental Research Grant XBOOM and from the L’Oréal-UNESCO For Women in Science Programme – Italy, through the 2026 Fellowship Award PA and LDR are supported by the WISE fellowship program, which is financed by NWO The MeerKAT telescope is operated by the South African Radio Astronomy Observatory, which is a facility of the National Research Foundation, an agency of the Department of Science and Innovation This work has made use of MAXI data provided by RIKEN, JAXA and the MAXI team, and of Swift/BAT transient monitor results provided by the Swift/BAT team The Ilifu cloud computing facility has been used for this research

Quiescent Population Comparison

GRS 1915+105 is the most radio-luminous BH LMXB detected in this regime, an order of magnitude above V404 Cyg (a factor of ∼8–14, allowing for the variability of the latter) The measured radio luminosity, (2.0±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz (the literature values, recomputed homogeneously from the published flux densities, are placed at this frequency under the flat-spectrum assumption), lies about 4% above the best-fitting relation The measured radio luminosity, (2. p. 8 p. 8 p. 80±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz (the literature values, recomputed homogeneously from the published flux densities, are placed at this frequency under the flat-spectrum assumption), lies about 4% above the best-fitting relation

Spectral Index Analysis

The measured spectral index adds a caveat that operates in one direction only: should part of the 2026 July flux arise from residual optically thin emission rather than from a compact core, the core would be fainter still, which would strengthen, not weaken, the case for quiescence The most economical reading of this spectral slope is that the 2026 July emission is dominated by optically thin material left over from the low-level activity that followed the last flaring episode, between 2025 and 2026

Final Conclusion on Outburst End

We argue that GRS 1915+105 has likely ended the outburst that began in 1992 and is now settling into quiescence This conclusion rests on the following lines of evidence:

** the radio emission, the only monitored band unaffected by the local absorption, is at present the only accessible tracer of the accretion activity since the obscuration prevents us from observing the latter directly in the X-rays **

** disc-instability models predict that GRS 1915+105 is, moreover, the only BH LMXB known to have sustained Roche-lobe-fed, outburstlevel (often close to the Eddington level) accretion for over three decades **

** The disc mass reservoir predicted by hydrodynamic and disc-instability modelling should be running out at about this time, the predicted outburst duration of ∼20–100 yr being consistent with the thirty-four years elapsed **

** The alternative, an undiminished central engine hidden behind a thicker absorber, appears disfavoured because it would require the column to increase by more than an order of magnitude, to NH ≳ 2×1025 cm−2 for a fully covering absorber **

Future Research Opportunities

The fading of the accretion-driven emission enables studies of the evolved donor largely free of the disc contamination and the obscuration that have hampered such work since discovery, allowing its spectral type and wind to be constrained more precisely The switch-off of the core provides a rare test of the origin of the very-high-energy emission associated with GRS 1915+105

The MeerKAT visibilities are stored in the SARAO archive (https://archive.sarao.ac.za) under the project codes SCI-20180516-PW-01 (ThunderKAT), SCI-20230907-RF-01 (X-KAT) and DDT-20260703-SM-01 (DDT) The Einstein Probe/FXT data will become public through the ESA Einstein Probe Science Archive (https://ama.esac.esa.int) and the Chinese National Astronomical Data Centre after the proprietary period The MAXI/GSC and Swift/BAT light curves are public (http://maxi.riken.jp and https://swift.gsfc.nasa.gov/results/transients/) The AMI-LA 15. p. 25 GHz data are available from the AMI team on reasonable request

Quiescent Comparison Sample

The comparison sample of Appendix B includes 19 such systems with X-ray constraints (16 detections and 3 upper limits), of which 17 also carry radio constraints (5 detections and 12 upper limits) GRS 1915+105 is the most radio-luminous BH LMXB detected in this regime, an order of magnitude above V404 Cyg (a factor of ∼8–14, allowing for the variability of the latter) The measured radio luminosity, (2.0±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz (the literature values, recomputed homogeneously from the published flux densities, are placed at this frequency under the flat-spectrum assumption), lies about 4% above the best-fitting relation The measured radio luminosity, (2.0±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1.28 GHz (the literature values, recomputed homogeneously from the published flux densities, are placed at this frequency under the flat-spectrum assumption), lies about 4% above the best-fitting relation The measured radio luminosity, (2.0±0.5)×1028 erg s−1 at 1.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improve radio monitoring analysis by implementing a systematic re-fitting procedure for all epochs to ensure consistency with a constant zero level fitted simultaneously with the Gaussian as described in Section 2.3 of the paper. This will reduce noise and improve the reliability of flux density measurements, especially for sub-threshold detections where uncertainties are quoted as the local rms with a 5% flux-scale term.

  2. Enhance X-ray data processing by integrating a more rigorous uncertainty assessment for upper limits, specifically by explicitly accounting for the ambiguity regarding intrinsic absorption. The AI can be trained to recognize when an observed non-detection is consistent with either a further rise in the local obscuration or intrinsic fading, as noted in Section 4.2 of the Discussion.

  3. Develop a predictive model for quiescent luminosity using the established LR Porb relation and LX Porb relation, allowing the system to estimate GRS 1915+105's intrinsic luminosity based on its radio measurement, as suggested by Adopting the black-hole and black-hole-candidate correlation of Crook-Mansour et al. (2026) drawn in Fig. 2 (Sect. 3.3).

  4. Create a classifier for spectral index interpretation during radio analysis that prioritizes optically thin synchrotron emission over a flat or inverted spectrum, as the paper notes that "a flat or inverted, self-absorbed spectrum (alpha >= 0), the canonical signature of a compact jet (Blandford & Königl 1979), is mildly disfavoured at 1.6σ."

  5. Implement a comparative analysis tool for quiescent black-hole binaries by using the derived LR Porb and LX Porb relations to assess GRS 1915+105's position relative to the sample, identifying that GRS 1915+105 is the most radio-luminous BH LMXB detected in this regime, an order of magnitude above V404 Cyg.

Sources

Related papers