Running Couplings in CP Violating Abelian Theories

arXiv:2611.07016 · hep-th, hep-ph · Submitted 2026-11-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Running Couplings in CP Violating Abelian Theories".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We calculate the one- and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, including CP violating couplings.

Kai: The electric and magnetic source vertices form a real coupling matrix C, while the current-current interaction depends on CT and the quantized determinant C.

Mira: These quantities determine, respectively, the continuously running Coulombic interactions and the fixed antisymmetric Dirac–Schwinger–Zwanziger charge quantization condition, which also fixes pairwise helicity.

Kai: The running preserves C, indicating that electric and magnetic couplings run inversely while every pairwise helicity remains constant.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to summarize this paper on "Running Couplings in CP Violating Abelian Theories," they are calculating both one-loop and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, specifically including those CP violating couplings.

Mira: The thesis is that the electric and magnetic source vertices create a real coupling matrix C, and the current-current interaction depends on CT C and the determinant of C. These two things determine how these Coulombic interactions run continuously, while they fix the antisymmetric Dirac–Schwinger–Zwanziger charge quantization condition, which also fixes pairwise helicity.

Lev: So what matters is that this running keeps the determinant of C preserved, meaning electric and magnetic couplings run inversely while every single pairwise helicity remains constant.

Kai: They also comment on how the running of the CP odd coupling theta relates to physical CP violation, which they state depends on things like the spectrum, mass phases, and threshold corrections.

Mira: And they mention that an invertible field redefinition exists where you can move the CP odd term between source vertices and photon kinetic terms, which is just two different ways of describing the same local interaction.

Lev: So from an error correction side, if you're trying to build something, this suggests that certain constraints on the system, like this fixed charge quantization condition, are robust against renormalization group flow.

Kai: It sounds like they are tying together the running of gauge interactions with fundamental quantization conditions in a way that's quite specific to these dyonic theories.

Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about the title, "Running Couplings in CP Violating Abelian Theories," it really points to how these interactions evolve when you introduce those CP violating terms into the standard abelian theory framework.

Mira: The authors are showing that the way these couplings run is highly constrained; specifically, they show that the one-loop running preserves the determinant of C, meaning electric and magnetic couplings run inversely while every pairwise helicity stays fixed.

Lev: From a hardware view, this means if we were to implement something based on these interactions, we wouldn't have to worry about a whole bunch of things changing at every scale beyond what's dictated by this flow.

Kai: And the two-loop running confirms that the determinant of C is preserved all the way through two loops, which reinforces that Coulombic couplings run while everything else stays fixed.

Mira: The main implication for us is how they link the running of a CP odd term, theta, to actual physical CP violation in terms of spectrum and mass phases.

Lev: It's a statement about the structure of these theories: the constraints imposed by gauge symmetry and quantization are quite rigid even when you add these new terms.

Center for Quantum Mathematics and Physics (QMAP) · Department of Physics, University of California, Davis · Department of Physics and Astronomy, Brigham Young University

hep-th, hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-04

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: 75 pages, 2 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: We calculate the one- and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, including CP violating couplings.

Key concepts

Coupling Matrix C
This matrix describes the real couplings between electric and magnetic source vertices. Its determinant, $\det C$, is crucial because it fixes the quantized Dirac–Schwinger–Zwanziger charge condition and determines pairwise helicity.
Running Couplings ($eta$-functions)
These functions describe how the physical couplings change as energy scales vary. The one-loop running shows that electric and magnetic couplings run inversely, while $\det C$ is preserved, meaning the Coulombic interaction runs while other properties stay constant.
CP-odd Coupling ($ heta$)
The running of this coupling relates to physical CP violation in the theory. The paper notes that coordinate running of $\theta$ is not physical CP violation; true CP violation depends on the spectrum, mass phases, and threshold corrections.

Terminology

Summary

We calculate the one- and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, including CP violating couplings. p. 0

Where the paper says it

com verhaaren@physics. edu Abstract We calculate the one- and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, including CP violating couplings.

The electric and magnetic source vertices form a real coupling matrix C, while the current-current interaction depends on CT and the quantized determinant C. p. 0
Where the paper says it

edu Abstract We calculate the one- and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, including CP violating couplings. The electric and magnetic source vertices in the most general theory form a real coupling matrix C, while a current-current interaction depends on CT C and the quantized determinant det C.

These quantities determine, respectively, the continuously running Coulombic interactions and the fixed antisymmetric Dirac–Schwinger–Zwanziger charge quantization condition, which also fixes pairwise helicity. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The electric and magnetic source vertices in the most general theory form a real coupling matrix C, while a current-current interaction depends on CT C and the quantized determinant det C. These determine, respectively, the continuously running Coulombic interactions and the fixed antisymmetric Dirac–Schwinger–Zwanziger charge quantization condition which also determines pairwise helicity.

The running preserves C, indicating that electric and magnetic couplings run inversely while every pairwise helicity remains constant. p. 0
Where the paper says it

These determine, respectively, the continuously running Coulombic interactions and the fixed antisymmetric Dirac–Schwinger–Zwanziger charge quantization condition which also determines pairwise helicity. The running preserves det C, showing that the electric and magnetic couplings run inversely while every pairwise helicity remains constant.

The running of the CP-odd coupling theta is related to physical CP violation, which depends on the spectrum, mass phases, and threshold corrections. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The running preserves det C, showing that the electric and magnetic couplings run inversely while every pairwise helicity remains constant. We comment on how the running of the CP-odd coupling θ relates to physical CP violation, which also depends on the spectrum, mass phases, and threshold corrections.

Furthermore, an invertible field redefinition allows the CP-odd term to move between current source terms and photon kinetic terms; these are two descriptions of the same local interaction. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We comment on how the running of the CP-odd coupling θ relates to physical CP violation, which also depends on the spectrum, mass phases, and threshold corrections. We also show that an invertible field redefinition moves the CP-odd coupling between the current source terms and the photon kinetic terms; these are two descriptions of the same local interaction.

The results agree with the Argyres–Douglas beta function ansatz. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We also show that an invertible field redefinition moves the CP-odd coupling between the current source terms and the photon kinetic terms; these are two descriptions of the same local interaction. Finally, we show that the result agrees with the Argyres–Douglas β function ansatz.

The one-loop running of G is given by beta G = 1 over 6 pi squared X over G q q dagger G + delta squared epsilon q q dagger epsilon. p. 0

Where the paper says it

com verhaaren@physics. edu Abstract We calculate the one- and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, including CP violating couplings.

This is equivalent to beta tau = -i N 3 pi X(q + g tau) squared, and G = delta squared is preserved by one-loop running, ensuring that the electric and magnetic couplings run inversely while every DSZ pairing and pairwise helicity remain fixed. p. 6
Where the paper says it

(25) We also show that det G = ∆2 is preserved by one-loop running. This ensures that the electric and magnetic couplings run inversely, while eb, every DSZ pairing, and every pairwise helicity remain fixed.

The two-loop running of G is given by beta G = 1 over 32 pi 4 X over G q q dagger G + delta squared epsilon q q dagger epsilon. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The different normalizations are employed to map a theory with rational charges to an equivalent description with integer charges. While a given charge lattice contains infinitely many possible particle charge combinations, only charges realized as dynamical states enter loop sums.

This shows that G = delta squared is preserved by the RG flow through two loops. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The two-loop running of G, and the fact that ∆ does not run at two loops, is also expressed in terms of the holomorphic coupling τ and the more familiar e, b, and θ. We also show that the two-loop RG flow preserves the CP symmetry if it is already present.

The mixed propagator is the only internal photon part that could change the antisymmetric electric–magnetic coupling, and its charge factor vanishes. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The electric and magnetic source vertices in the most general theory form a real coupling matrix C, while a current-current interaction depends on CT C and the quantized determinant det C. These determine, respectively, the continuously running Coulombic interactions and the fixed antisymmetric Dirac–Schwinger–Zwanziger charge quantization condition which also determines pairwise helicity.

The Coulombic couplings run, while every DSZ pairing and every pairwise helicity remain fixed. p. 6
Where the paper says it

(25) We also show that det G = ∆2 is preserved by one-loop running. This ensures that the electric and magnetic couplings run inversely, while eb, every DSZ pairing, and every pairwise helicity remain fixed.

The running of theta modifies the Witten-shifted electric charge carried by a monopole in a fixed charge basis; this coordinate running is not physical CP violation. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The electric and magnetic source vertices in the most general theory form a real coupling matrix C, while a current-current interaction depends on CT C and the quantized determinant det C. These determine, respectively, the continuously running Coulombic interactions and the fixed antisymmetric Dirac–Schwinger–Zwanziger charge quantization condition which also determines pairwise helicity.

The RG running through two loops does not introduce CP violation, and exact CP constrains fermion mass phases, masses, multiplicities, interactions, thresholds, and the vacuum. p. 6
Where the paper says it

One must also consider the spectrum of states, their masses and mass phases and multiplicities, their interactions, threshold corrections, and the vacuum. We show explicitly that if a theory exhibits CP symmetry at tree-level then the one-loop running preserves that symmetry.

Within the one-photon class of theories considered here, moving the CP-odd term between source vertices and quadratic kinetic terms is an invertible field redefinition that does not define independent couplings. p. 5
Where the paper says it

We show that, within the Lagrangian, the CP-odd coupling can be confined to the photon kinetic terms, only appear in the photon source term, or be shared between the two. Invertible field redefinitions relate these Lagrangians.

The main results are the charge-covariant flows at one loop: beta(1)G = 1 over 6 pi squared X over G q q dagger G + delta squared epsilon q q dagger epsilon = 1 over 6 pi squared X over beta(G), and at two loops: beta(2)G = 1 over 32 pi 4 X over G q q dagger G + delta squared epsilon q q dagger epsilon. The matrix G = CT C converts integral charge labels into physical photon couplings. p. 7

Where the paper says it

A helicity rephasing F ′µν + = e −iϕF µν + changes the real coordinates used to display the same one-photon amplitude. However, the currents, charge labels, and theory parameters are fixed.

The RG flow preserves C = delta = eb, meaning the Coulombic interaction runs while eb, every DSZ pairing, and every pairwise helicity remain fixed. p. 6
Where the paper says it

(25) We also show that det G = ∆2 is preserved by one-loop running. This ensures that the electric and magnetic couplings run inversely, while eb, every DSZ pairing, and every pairwise helicity remain fixed.

The two-loop running of tau is given by beta(2) tau = -i N 28 pi squared X q + g tau squared Im tau(q + g tau) squared. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The different normalizations are employed to map a theory with rational charges to an equivalent description with integer charges. While a given charge lattice contains infinitely many possible particle charge combinations, only charges realized as dynamical states enter loop sums.

This depends on both tau and tau bar, as expected in a nonsupersymmetric theory, but the factor q + g tau squared / Im tau is duality invariant, giving it the same modular weight as the one-loop result. p. 0
Where the paper says it

edu Abstract We calculate the one- and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, including CP violating couplings. The electric and magnetic source vertices in the most general theory form a real coupling matrix C, while a current-current interaction depends on CT C and the quantized determinant det C.

The component beta-functions are:

beta e = e 1 over 2 pi squared X e 2q + g 1 over 2 pi squared - b g squared,

beta b = -b 1 over 2 pi squared X e 2q + g 1 over 2 pi squared - b g squared, and

beta theta = b squared / 8 pi cubed X e 2q + g cubed.

Under a general CP transformation U CP, the CP-invariant couplings obey U CP beta G U CP = G. p. 3

Where the paper says it

(14) This is exactly the oriented area obtained from taking the wedge product of the two charge vectors. The rationalized electric and magnetic couplings obey eb = 2πN, where N ∈ Z>0 is the normalization of the charge lattice.

Since U CP = -1, Eq. p. 5
Where the paper says it

In the Witten basis and the electric duality frame3 the holomorphic coupling is τ = θ 2π + i b e = θ 2π + i 2πN e 2 , (22) which relates to G according to G = ∆ Im τ 1 Re τ Re τ |τ | 2 . (23) Since G and ∆ are independent of helicity basis we see that C is constrained.

(135) implies U CP epsilon U CP = -epsilon. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In this case ∂µ ⋆F µν = bKν , (6) where b is the magnetic coupling. This implies that Fµν ̸= F A µν, but following Dirac [1], one can still define a vector potential because ∂µ ( ⋆F µν − bΣ µν K ) = 0 , (7) where the Dirac surface Σµν K [1, 5, 6] satisfies ∂µΣ µν K = Kν .

This leads to the conclusion that the two-loop term transforms as U CP beta(2)G U CP = 1 over 32 pi 4 X over h U-1 CPq dagger G U-1 CPq = beta(2)G, confirming that the one-loop running preserves CP symmetry if it is already present. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The two-loop running of G, and the fact that ∆ does not run at two loops, is also expressed in terms of the holomorphic coupling τ and the more familiar e, b, and θ. We also show that the two-loop RG flow preserves the CP symmetry if it is already present.

The two-loop vacuum polarization confirms that G = delta squared is preserved by the RG flow through two loops, meaning Coulombic couplings run while eb, every DSZ pairing, and every pairwise helicity remain fixed. p. 6
Where the paper says it

(25) We also show that det G = ∆2 is preserved by one-loop running. This ensures that the electric and magnetic couplings run inversely, while eb, every DSZ pairing, and every pairwise helicity remain fixed.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. The AI system can perform one-loop running calculations for dyon couplings, specifically calculating beta functions like beta G and beta tau, which are given by equations (106) and (107).

  2. The system can analyze the preservation of duality invariants, showing that the Coulombic interaction runs while eb, every DSZ pairing, and every pairwise helicity remain fixed as stated in Section 6.2.

  3. The AI can determine the exact two-loop running of G and tau in terms of e, b, and theta as given by equations (167).

  4. The system can verify the preservation of CP symmetry under one-loop running by checking if the one-loop running preserves that symmetry if it is already present as mentioned in Section 6.2.

  5. The AI can calculate the ultraviolet divergent part of the one-loop surface current correlator using the prescription that isolates local, momentum independent terms, resulting in equation (268).

  6. The system can derive a single photon condition by solving for the zeroes of the determinant of Kh and showing that the only pole is then the light cone, k squared = 0 under specific conditions.

  7. The AI can perform a detailed analysis of two-potential kinetic terms, specifically deriving equation (310) which shows how every entry is a polynomial in k mu.

  8. The system can determine the propagators for different helicities by solving the dispersion relation derived from the determinant of Kh, resulting in equation (319).

  9. The AI can evaluate the two-loop QED correction to the unit-current correlator, showing that the Coulombic couplings run while eb, every DSZ pairing, and every pairwise helicity remain fixed as per equation (164).

  10. The system can analyze the dependence of the running on different renormalization schemes by showing how a finite redefinition of G shifts the two-loop beta function through a commutator calculation.

Abstract

We calculate the one- and two-loop running couplings for a massless photon coupled to dyons, including CP violating couplings. The electric and magnetic source vertices in the most general theory form a real coupling matrix C, while a current-current interaction depends on C T C and the quantized determinant C. These determine, respectively, the continuously running Coulombic interactions and the fixed antisymmetric Dirac--Schwinger--Zwanziger charge quantization condition which also determines pairwise helicity. The running preserves C, showing that the electric and magnetic couplings run inversely while every pairwise helicity remains constant. We comment on how the running of the CP-odd coupling θ relates to physical CP violation, which also depends on the spectrum, mass phases, and threshold corrections. We also show that an invertible field redefinition moves the CP-odd coupling between the current source terms and the photon kinetic terms; these are two descriptions of the same local interaction. Finally, we show that the result agrees with the Argyres--Douglas β function ansatz.

Related papers