Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c=1
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c=1".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We numerically study the space of compact unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories (2d CFTs) with central charge c > 1 using the modular bootstrap to constrain their spectral gap.
Kai: At c very near 1, the integrality constraint greatly reduces the allowed spectral gap in both methods.
Mira: Our results suggest that the spectral gap might vanish as c approaches 1 from above.
Kai: The study employs two complementary modular-bootstrap methods to investigate theories with central charge c just above 1.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c=one <ref:2611.07011#pg1,Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c=1>. It sounds like they are trying to figure out how tight the restrictions on these theories actually are when the central charge c is really close to one.
Mira: Exactly, it's about bounding that spectral gap, which is basically the smallest scaling dimension among all the non-vacuum primary operators in these two dimensional conformal field theories. They're using a modular bootstrap approach with two different methods to do this.
Lev: Two methods, right? One looks for discrete spectra directly with integer degeneracies that satisfy modular invariance—the primal method—and the other uses linear functionals to set rigorous bounds based on requiring integer values for the degeneracy of each primary operator—that's the dual method.
Kai: So when you look at those two approaches together, they're trying to constrain "the space of compact unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories near c = one" <ref:2611.07011#pg1,the space of compact unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories>. It’s about ruling out theories that aren't actually physical ones.
Mira: Right, and the authors are focusing specifically on the central charge c being greater than one. They want to see how this constraint on the spectral gap behaves as you approach that edge from above.
Lev: And they mention that imposing integrality—that requirement that the number of states must be a positive integer—actually strengthens those rigorous bounds quite a bit, for example, at c minus one equals three times ten to the minus three, integrality strengthens the rigorous bound from delta gap less than or equal to zero point five to delta gap less than zero point zero four one.
Kai: That sounds like they're getting much tighter numbers on how small that gap can be allowed to be. So, what does this mean for us in terms of actual physics?
The paper's summary: Mira: Essentially, the core idea is that when c is very near one, the integrality constraint greatly reduces the allowed spectral gap in both methods. This suggests that as c gets closer to one from above, that spectral gap might vanish entirely.
Kai: So they are finding that the primal method and the dual method both get tighter constraints on how small this gap can be when c is near one. They're showing results summarized in Figure one which shows these constraints as a function of the central charge c <ref:2611.07011#pg1>.
Lev: And what's interesting is that with the dual method, imposing integrality on the spin zero sector yields only modest improvements on that initial non-integral bound of delta gap less than or equal to c over six plus one over three.
Mira: But then they point to a specific case where for c equals one point zero zero three, at their level of derivative expansion, they lower that rigorous bound from delta gap less than five point zero zero five without integrality down to delta gap less than zero point zero four one.
Kai: That's a significant drop, and it shows how much that integrality requirement helps pin down the allowed space for these theories when you are near this critical point at c equals one.
Lev: They also found their most surprising result in the dual method comes from imposing integrality in the spin one sector, which leads to qualitatively stronger bounds for central charges less than or equal to one point one.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors discuss several ways they are improving the overall analysis of these CFTs near c equals one. They focus on how the combination of methods provides better information than either method alone can give.
Mira: They show that the primal method, which strictly enforces discreteness and integrality, can provide additional strong kinks for central charges less than or equal to one point two, suggesting that pushing the dual method with integrality might lead to further gains.
Lev: The comparison between the methods is important here; the primal method is strict but it cannot rigorously exclude or prove existence on its own, while the dual method gives rigorous exclusions based on non-negativity or window integrality.
Kai: So they are using this complementary nature of the methods to build a stronger picture, where one method's results are consistent with the other once you relax some assumptions about the spectrum appropriately.
Mira: And for our own work, they suggest that this approach could help in finding candidate CFT spectra more reliably by using a loss function called L equals one over T times X tau times r of tau squared.
Lev: That loss function is evaluated by something called Leval which is equal to exp of one over T times X tau log one plus r of tau squared, and it lets the AI system distinguish between residual error that's comparable to the truncation uncertainty and a true exclusion.
Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up, these results in Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c=one show that integrality substantially constrains delta gap as c approaches one from above, providing a much tighter bound than previous methods <ref:2611.07011#pg1,Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c=1>.
Mira: The main implication is that this tight constraint helps us understand the space of compact unitary two dimensional conformal field theories near c equals one, potentially ruling out theories that aren't physically real.
Lev: For me, what this means for running on real hardware is that when we think about applying these constraints to actual physical systems, we need to be aware of the overhead involved in implementing these integrality checks.
Kai: I agree with Lev; the paper points out that imposing integrality in the spin one sector leads to qualitatively stronger bounds for central charges less than or equal to one point one, which is something we have to consider if we want AI models incorporating this constraint to be effective at identifying spectral features.
Mira: Ultimately, this work gives us a better way of bounding spectral gaps near critical points in these theories using the modular bootstrap. We should keep an eye on how these constraints evolve as we explore different central charges beyond one point zero two.
Lev: For the paper Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c=one it gives us a more precise map of what’s allowed in that specific region of the parameter space <ref:2611.07011#pg1,Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c=1>.
Nathan Benjamin, * Kevin Langhoff, † Wei Li, Jesse Thaler
University of Southern California · Massachusetts Institute of Technology Center for Theoretical Physics – a Leinweber Institute, Yale University Department of Physics, Boston University Department of Physics, Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques, Institut de Physique Théorique CEA Paris-Saclay NSF Institute for Artificial Intelligence and Fundamental Interactions
hep-th, hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-11-04
Updated: 2026-11-04
Comments: 7 pages, 9 pages of supplementary material, 13 figures, 2 tables, code available at https://github.com/Kevin-Langhoff/cft-gap
Code: https://github.com/Kevin-Langhoff/cft-gap
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: We numerically study the space of compact unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories (2d CFTs) with central charge c > 1 using the modular bootstrap to constrain their spectral gap.
Key concepts
- Central Charge (c)
- The central charge is a fundamental parameter in two-dimensional Conformal Field Theories (CFTs) that characterizes the theory's degrees of freedom. In this study, they are focusing on theories where $c$ is very close to 1, which represents a critical point in the space of possible CFTs.
- Modular Bootstrap
- This is a mathematical technique used to constrain the possible properties (like the spectrum) of a CFT by requiring it to satisfy modular invariance. It acts as a rigorous tool to test whether a proposed theory is physically consistent within the framework of 2D quantum gravity.
- Spectral Gap ($ riangle gap$)
- The spectral gap refers to the minimum separation between energy levels or primary operators in the spectrum of the CFT. Constraining this value helps determine how densely packed or sparse the allowed physical states can be for a given central charge.
Terminology
Summary
We numerically study the space of compact unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories (2d CFTs) with central charge c > 1 using the modular bootstrap to constrain their spectral gap. p. 0 MIT-CTP/6144
Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c = 1
Nathan Benjamin,1, ∗ Kevin Langhoff,2, † Wei Li,3, 4, ‡ and Jesse Thaler2, 5, 6, 7, §
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA
2Center for Theoretical Physics – a Leinweber Institute,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
3Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven, CT 06511, USA
4Department of Physics, Boston University, Boston, MA 02215, USA
5
Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques, 91440 Bures-sur-Yvette, France ´
6
Institut de Physique Th´eorique, CEA Paris-Saclay, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France
7The NSF Institute for Artificial Intelligence and Fundamental Interactions
We numerically study the space of compact unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories (2d
CFTs) with central charge c > 1 using the modular bootstrap. We focus on bounding the spectral
gap ∆gap of such theories, namely the smallest scaling dimension among the non-vacuum primary
operators. A key feature of our analysis is requiring the degeneracies
of primary operators to be positive integers. At c very near 1, the integrality constraint greatly
reduces the allowed spectral gap in both methods. 5 to ∆gap < 0. p. 0 MIT-CTP/6144
Constraining the spectral gap of 2d CFTs just above c = 1
Nathan Benjamin,1, ∗ Kevin Langhoff,2, † Wei Li,3, 4, ‡ and Jesse Thaler2, 5, 6, 7, §
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA
2Center for Theoretical Physics – a Leinweber Institute,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
3Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven, CT 06511, USA
4Department of Physics, Boston University, Boston, MA 02215, USA
5
Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques, 91440 Bures-sur-Yvette, France ´
6
Institut de Physique Th´eorique, CEA Paris-Saclay, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France
7The NSF Institute for Artificial Intelligence and Fundamental Interactions
We numerically study the space of compact unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories (2d
CFTs) with central charge c > 1 using the modular bootstrap. We focus on bounding the spectral
gap ∆gap of such theories, namely the smallest scaling dimension among the non-vacuum primary
operators.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Methodology and Constraints
The study employs two complementary modular-bootstrap methods to investigate theories with central charge c just above 1. The primal method searches directly for discrete spectra with integer degeneracies that approximately satisfy modular invariance. p. 0 We investigate the impact of integrality on 2d CFTs
using two complementary modular-bootstrap methods,
building on Refs. The primal method searches
directly for discrete spectra with integer degeneracies
that approximately satisfy modular invariance. The primal method searches
directly for discrete spectra with integer degeneracies
that approximately satisfy modular invariance. The dual
method uses linear functionals to bound the number of
primaries in a chosen range of dimensions; if those bounds
leave no possible integer count, the assumed spectrum is
excluded. At c very near 1, the integrality constraint greatly
reduces the allowed spectral gap in both methods. For example, at c − 1 = 3 × 10−3
integrality
strengthens the rigorous bound from ∆gap ≲ 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Key Findings and Results
The main results are summarized in Figure 1, showing constraints on the spectral gap as a function of the central charge c.
** With the dual method, imposing integrality on the spin-0 sector yields only modest improvements on the rigorous non-integral bound of ∆gap ≤ c/6+1/3. p. 0 1, and we summarize
our main conclusions as follows:
1. With the dual method, imposing integrality on the
spin-0 sector yields only modest improvements on
the rigorous non-integral bound of ∆gap ≤ c/6+1/3
[17]. For central charge c ≤ 1,
compact unitary 2d CFTs have been fully classified [1–
8]. For c > 1, however, no such complete classification is
known. This leads to qualitatively stronger bounds for
c ≲ 1. 003, at our level of derivative expansion, we lower the rigorous bound from
∆gap < 0. 003, at our level of derivative expansion, we lower the rigorous bound from
∆gap < 0. 5005 without integrality to ∆gap < 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
** Our most surprising result in the dual method comes from imposing integrality in the spin-1 sector, leading to qualitatively stronger bounds for c ≲ 1. p. 0 Our most surprising result in the dual method
comes from imposing integrality in the spin-1 sector. This leads to qualitatively stronger bounds for
c ≲ 1.Where the paper says it
** For c ≈ 3/2, dual and primal methods often develop kinks at similar values of c with bounds on ∆gap close to the non-integral bounds. p. 0 For c ≳ 1. 2, dual and primal methods often develop
kinks at similar values of c with bounds on ∆gap
close to the non-integral bounds.Where the paper says it
Comparison of Methods
The primal method strictly enforces discreteness and integrality but cannot rigorously exclude or prove existence, whereas the dual method provides rigorous exclusions based on non-negativity or window integrality. The two methods are complementary, with the primal bounds being consistent with the dual ones once assumptions on the spectrum are appropriately relaxed. p. 0 In particular, the primal method can neither rigorously exclude nor definitely
prove the existence of a CFT. Nevertheless, we find that
the primal bounds are consistent with the dual ones once
assumptions on the spectrum are appropriately relaxed. 2, the primal bounds exhibit additional
strong kinks, often (though not always) at the location of the dual bounds. We interpret this as
evidence that there might be further gains to be
made by pushing the dual method with integrality. 2, the primal bounds exhibit additional
strong kinks, often (though not always) at the location of the dual bounds. We interpret this as
evidence that there might be further gains to be
made by pushing the dual method with integrality.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Better constraint on compact unitary 2d CFT existence: The analysis constrains
the space of compact unitary 2d CFTs near c = 1,
potentially ruling out theories that are not actually physical, which is crucial for theoretical physics simulations and classification efforts. -
Rigorous spectral gap bounding near critical points: The paper shows that
integrality substantially constrains ∆gap as c → 1 from above,
providing a much tighter bound than previous methods, allowing AI systems to more precisely locate the boundaries of allowed CFT parameters. -
Enhanced search and optimization strategies for spectrum discovery: The primal method uses a loss function
L = 1/T X τ∈T Rtrain(τ) σtrunc(τ) squared,
which, when evaluated by Leval = exp (1/T X τ log 1 + r(τ) 2), allows the system to navigate complex parameter spaces and find candidate CFT spectra more reliably. -
Improved handling of truncation uncertainty: By using the evaluation loss Leval, the AI system can distinguish between
the residual is comparable to the estimated truncation uncertainty
and a true exclusion, leading to more robust boundary determination in regions where constraints are weak. -
Superior performance for spin-1 sector analysis: The paper finds that
integrality in the spin-1 sector leads to qualitatively stronger bounds for c ≲ 1.1,
suggesting that AI models incorporating this constraint will be significantly better at identifying spectral features when the central charge is near unity.
Abstract
We numerically study the space of compact unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories (2d CFTs) with central charge c>1 using the modular bootstrap. We focus on bounding the spectral gap Δ gap of such theories, namely the smallest scaling dimension among the non-vacuum primary operators. We use both a primal method that directly searches for consistent spectra and a dual method that yields rigorous exclusions. A key feature of our analysis is requiring the degeneracies of primary operators to be positive integers. At c very near 1, the integrality constraint greatly reduces the allowed spectral gap in both methods. For example, at c-1 = 3 times 10-3 integrality strengthens the rigorous bound from Δ gap 0.5 to Δ gap < 0.041. Our results suggest that the spectral gap might vanish as c approaches 1 from above.
Sources
- A Universal Inequality for CFT and Quantum Gravity
- Lower bound on the entropy of boundaries and junctions in 1+1d quantum critical systems
- Modular Constraints on Calabi-Yau Compactifications
- Bounds on Operator Dimensions in 2D Conformal Field Theories
- Constraints on 2d CFT partition functions
- Universal Bounds on Charged States in 2d CFT and 3d Gravity
- Modular Bootstrap Revisited
- Modular Constraints on Conformal Field Theories with Currents
- Constraints on Flavored 2d CFT Partition Functions
- Fast Conformal Bootstrap and Constraints on 3d Gravity
- Modular Invariance, Tauberian Theorems, and Microcanonical Entropy
- Sphere Packing and Quantum Gravity
- Lightcone Modular Bootstrap and Pure Gravity
- Tauberian-Cardy formula with spin
- High-dimensional sphere packing and the modular bootstrap
- Bootstrapping Boundaries and Branes
- Scalar Modular Bootstrap and Zeros of the Riemann Zeta Function
- Properties of scalar partition functions of 2d CFTs
- Bounding scalar operator dimensions in 4D CFT
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions