Quantum Computing for Entanglement Asymmetry and the Quantum Mpemba Effect in Field Theory
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Lattice. The day in lattice field theory: what the simulations put on the table.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Quantum Computing for Entanglement Asymmetry and the Quantum Mpemba Effect in Field Theory".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We construct a quantum measurement protocol for estimating the second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry by combining the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations The required number of measurements scales as Nshot = O(ϵ−2) without explicit dependence on the total system size This protocol provides a measurement-efficient framework for investigating anomalous symmetry-restoration dynamics in quantum many-body systems and quantum field theories.
Kai: Quantum Measurement Protocol The protocol combines the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations The second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry is estimated by combining the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations For a fixed additive accuracy ϵ, the number of measurements required by our protocol scales as Nshot = O(ϵ−2) without explicit dependence on the total system size The complete quantum circuit of the protocol is shown in Fig.
Mira: 6 By repeating STEPS 1–4 Nshot times, we obtain the expectation value ⟨Z⟩S,ancilla The second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry is then estimated as ∆S(2)A = log ⟨Z⟩ancilla / ⟨Z⟩S,ancilla Application to Lattice Schwinger Model We demonstrate the application of the protocol in a concrete interacting quantum field theory, namely the Schwinger model Using classical state-vector simulations, we investigate the real-time dynamics of the second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry and examine the quantum Mpemba effect for several classes of symmetry-breaking initial states We consider two families of initial states as benchmark examples for demonstrating the proposed measurement protocol and for developing an intuitive understanding of the symmetry-restoration dynamics Quantum Mpemba Effect in Benchmarks The study investigates the quantum Mpemba effect in spin-product initial states as a benchmark Among the three states considered here, the state with the largest initial R´enyi entanglement asymmetry, ϕ = 0.5π, restores the symmetry faster than those with smaller initial asymmetries The crossing of the curves therefore provides a signature of the quantum Mpemba effect The initial charge distribution provides an intuitive, although not complete, explanation of the observed quantum Mpemba effect Quantum Resource Estimation The required number of measurements scales as Nshot = O(ϵ−2) without explicit dependence on the total system size The algorithmic error associated with the circuit implementation of the time evolution is ϵalg = e−iHt − Ucirc(t) The statistical error associated with the SWAP-test measurement is bounded by (2.16) (or equivalently (2.23)) and, for a fixed additive accuracy, does not explicitly depend on the quantum state or the total system size The required number of Trotter steps Mworst = O N5/2 t3ϵ1/2 alg!
Kai: Early-FTQC Resource Estimation We estimate the resources required to implement the protocol on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, fault-tolerant quantum computers (FTQCs), and a representative early-FTQC architecture For an early-FTQC architecture based on STAR ver.
Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper, "Quantum Computing for Entanglement Asymmetry and the Quantum Mpemba Effect in Field Theory." Basically, they build this quantum measurement protocol to estimate something called the R´enyi entanglement asymmetry.
Mira: That asymmetry is a way to measure symmetry breaking at the level of a subsystem, and they use it to probe what they call the quantum Mpemba effect. It’s about how fast a system relaxes back toward equilibrium when it’s started in an asymmetric state.
Lev: So, the core claim here is that this protocol combines a standard SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure using randomized symmetry rotations to get this estimate.
Kai: And what's interesting about the method is how efficiently it scales; they say the number of measurements needed only depends on an accuracy parameter epsilon squared, which means it doesn't explicitly depend on the total size of the system.
Mira: That’s a big deal for applying this to complex systems because measurement complexity usually explodes with system size. They claim this leads to a measurement-efficient framework for looking at symmetry restoration dynamics in quantum many-body systems and quantum field theories.
Lev: From an engineering side, they estimate the required resources on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, fault-tolerant quantum computers, and even early fault-tolerant architectures. The runtime estimation involves terms like tshot times e to the power of two times q to the fourth times p of two divided by epsilon squared over alg.
Kai: So they’re giving us a concrete idea of what it would take to actually run this on hardware right now, which is helpful for anyone looking at implementing such protocols. What they show is that for the lattice Schwinger model, which is a real field theory example, the L1 norm scales as N cubed.
Mira: And they connect this measurement protocol to the quantum Mpemba effect in spin-product initial states as a benchmark. They find that a state with the largest initial R´enyi entanglement asymmetry, phi equal to zero point five pi, restores symmetry faster than those with smaller asymmetries.
Lev: That crossing of the curves provides what they call a signature of the quantum Mpemba effect, and they suggest the initial charge distribution gives an intuitive explanation for this observed effect.
Kai: They also looked at fermion-parity-preserving initial states for this effect, and within their considered system sizes, lattice spacings, and evolution times, they didn't see a big qualitative change in the symmetry restoration dynamics when they varied the fermion mass or the theta angle.
Mira: That finding suggests that the systematic decrease of residual entanglement asymmetry with increasing N means that any nonzero late-time value they observed for fermion-parity-preserving states is at least partly a finite volume effect.
Lev: They also looked at energy expectation values for these fermion-parity-preserving initial states, and for the infinite temperature state, the energy expectation value is zero.
Kai: And they tie that zero result to an effective temperature interpretation where phi equal to zero point five pi and phi equal to zero point three pi correspond to the smallest and largest effective temperatures among those three representative values.
Mira: That connection between the effective temperature and the symmetry restoration dynamics is what they discuss in their main text, suggesting a possible link there.
Lev: Moving toward implementation, they derived an analytical bound for the second-order product using locality of individual interaction terms, which gives them a one-step scaling of alpha cubed times delta t cubed.
Kai: They also show how to decompose the initial state preparation and real-time evolution into elementary gates, showing that the total number of CNOT gates required for Suzuki–Trotter time evolution is proportional to M times N squared.
Mira: So, the paper provides a complete picture connecting this measurement protocol to a concrete field theory application and gives quantitative estimates for running it on quantum hardware.
Lev: The main limitation they state is that while they've looked at three representative values for the effective temperature, the exact connection between that temperature and symmetry restoration dynamics isn't fully settled in their work.
Kai: Overall, this paper puts together a quantum measurement protocol for estimating entanglement asymmetry using a technique based on randomized symmetry rotations, which is really useful for studying symmetry restoration in these kinds of systems.
Mira: It connects the abstract concept of the quantum Mpemba effect to measurable quantities within a specific field theory model.
Lev: And it provides resource estimates that are transparent and give a reference point rather than just an optimized fault-tolerant compilation for implementing this protocol on quantum hardware.
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at "Quantum Computing for Entanglement Asymmetry and the Quantum Mpemba Effect in Field Theory."
Mira: It’s a paper that takes something abstract—entanglement asymmetry—and puts it into a concrete quantum protocol you can actually build.
Lev: And what they did was apply this to the lattice Schwinger model, which is a real interacting quantum field theory problem.
Kai: The authors are using this combination of the SWAP test and those randomized symmetry rotations to estimate that asymmetry.
Mira: They found that it scales really nicely, meaning you don't need an infinite number of measurements just because your system gets bigger.
Lev: That's the measurement efficiency part, which is huge for any real quantum hardware we're trying to build right now.
Kai: It connects this measurement technique directly to studying the quantum Mpemba effect in that Schwinger model.
Mira: The Mpemba effect shows how fast a system returns to its normal state when it starts somewhere weird, and they used this asymmetry as a ruler for that speed.
Lev: They even looked at different initial states, like spin-product states and fermion-parity-preserving ones, to see how the dynamics change.
Kai: And they found that in their tested scenarios, the way symmetry restores doesn't really change much when you tweak the fermion mass or the theta angle.
Mira: That suggests some of those late time values they saw might just be because the system is too small for perfect behavior.
Lev: Yeah, and I gotta point out that they did give us resource estimates for running this on different types of quantum computers, which is always valuable.
Kai: So it’s a paper that bridges the gap between theoretical field theory concepts and practical quantum measurement tools.
Mira: It shows how we can use these measurements to probe fundamental dynamics in many-body systems without needing to simulate every single detail perfectly.
Lev: Now, if this protocol works as they say, what does that mean for exploring those non-equilibrium dynamics in more complex field theories?
Keisuke Fujii, Harunobu Fujimura, Masazumi Honda, Duc Truyen Le
Graduate School of Engineering Science, The University of Osaka · Center for Quantum Information and Quantum Biology, The University of Osaka · Graduate School of Informatics, Kyoto University · Center for Quantum Computing, RIKEN Center for Interdisciplinary Theoretical and Mathematical Sciences (iTHEMS), RIKEN Center for Interdisciplinary Theoretical and Mathematical Sciences (iTHEMS), Graduate School of Science and Engineering, Saitama University
hep-lat, hep-th, quant-ph
Submitted: 2026-11-04
Updated: 2026-11-04
Comments: 38 Pages plus appendix, 18 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 84/100
The gist: We construct a quantum measurement protocol for estimating the second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry by combining the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry…
Key concepts
- Second R´enyi Entanglement Asymmetry ($\Delta S(2)A$)
- This is a measure used to quantify how much the entanglement in a quantum system changes as it evolves in time, specifically looking at the second Rényi order. It helps researchers track the dynamics of symmetry restoration in complex quantum systems.
- Quantum Mpemba Effect
- This effect describes how certain initial states in a quantum system restore their symmetry faster than others when evolving over time. The paper uses this phenomenon to understand the non-trivial dynamics observed in the lattice Schwinger model.
- SWAP Test with Charge-Resolving Procedure
- The protocol uses a SWAP test combined with randomized symmetry rotations to estimate the asymmetry. This combination allows for an efficient measurement that scales favorably, requiring fewer measurements ($N_{shot} = O(\epsilon^{-2})$) regardless of the system size.
- Quantum Resource Estimation
- The paper quantifies the computational resources needed to run this protocol on quantum computers. It estimates both algorithmic error and physical qubit requirements for implementing the measurement, providing a practical roadmap for future quantum simulations.
Terminology
Summary
We construct a quantum measurement protocol for estimating the second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry by combining the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations The required number of measurements scales as Nshot = O(ϵ−2) without explicit dependence on the total system size This protocol provides a measurement-efficient framework for investigating anomalous symmetry-restoration dynamics in quantum many-body systems and quantum field theories. p. 3 In this work, we construct a quantum measurement protocol for estimating the second
R´enyi entanglement asymmetry by combining the SWAP test [60] with a charge-resolving
procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations. For a fixed additive accuracy ϵ, the
number of measurements required by our protocol scales as Nshot = O(ϵ
−2
), without explicit
dependence on the total system size.Where the paper says it
Quantum Measurement Protocol
The protocol combines the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations The second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry is estimated by combining the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations For a fixed additive accuracy ϵ, the number of measurements required by our protocol scales as Nshot = O(ϵ−2) without explicit dependence on the total system size The complete quantum circuit of the protocol is shown in Fig. 6 By repeating STEPS 1–4 Nshot times, we obtain the expectation value ⟨Z⟩S,ancilla The second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry is then estimated as ∆S(2)A = log ⟨Z⟩ancilla / ⟨Z⟩S,ancilla
Application to Lattice Schwinger Model
We demonstrate the application of the protocol in a concrete interacting quantum field theory, namely the Schwinger model Using classical state-vector simulations, we investigate the real-time dynamics of the second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry and examine the quantum Mpemba effect for several classes of symmetry-breaking initial states We consider two families of initial states as benchmark examples for demonstrating the proposed measurement protocol and for developing an intuitive understanding of the symmetry-restoration dynamics
Quantum Mpemba Effect in Benchmarks
The study investigates the quantum Mpemba effect in spin-product initial states as a benchmark Among the three states considered here, the state with the largest initial R´enyi entanglement asymmetry, ϕ = 0.5π, restores the symmetry faster than those with smaller initial asymmetries The crossing of the curves therefore provides a signature of the quantum Mpemba effect The initial charge distribution provides an intuitive, although not complete, explanation of the observed quantum Mpemba effect
Quantum Resource Estimation
The required number of measurements scales as Nshot = O(ϵ−2) without explicit dependence on the total system size The algorithmic error associated with the circuit implementation of the time evolution is ϵalg = e−iHt − Ucirc(t) The statistical error associated with the SWAP-test measurement is bounded by (2.16) (or equivalently (2. p. 2 To quantify symmetry breaking on
a subsystem, the entanglement asymmetry was introduced in Ref. Let ρA denote the
reduced density matrix of a subsystem A, and let ρA,S denote its symmetrized counterpart
obtained by averaging over the symmetry transformation, or equivalently by removing coherences between different symmetry sectors. For a fixed
additive accuracy ϵ, the required number of measurements scales as O(ϵ
−2
) without explicit dependence on the total system size, making the protocol particularly attractive
for quantum many-body systems and lattice quantum field theories. As a representative application, we study the quantum Mpemba effect in the lattice Schwinger model
with a θ term using classical state-vector simulations.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Early-FTQC Resource Estimation
We estimate the resources required to implement the protocol on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, fault-tolerant quantum computers (FTQCs), and a representative early-FTQC architecture For an early-FTQC architecture based on STAR ver. 3, the total runtime required to estimate the two-copy observable to additive precision ϵalg is then estimated as ttotal = tshot e2Qe4P(2)totalϵ2/alg This estimate provides a transparent reference point rather than an optimized fault-tolerant compilation The resulting physical-qubit requirement is estimated as Nphys ≃ 2d2N(2)patch For the two-copy protocol, the total runtime required to estimate the two-copy observable to additive precision ϵalg is then estimated as ttotal = tshot e2Qe4P(2)totalϵ2/alg The total runtime required to estimate the two-copy observable to additive precision ϵalg is then estimated as ttotal = tshot e2Qe4P(2)totalϵ2/alg For the lattice Schwinger model considered here, the L1 norm is given by λ = O(N3). Since the second-R´enyi protocol requires two independently evolved copies, we independently sample a TE-PAI circuit for each copy The total expected gate count is therefore 2N(1)gate, while the combined TE-PAI sampling overhead is e2Q The total runtime required to estimate the two-copy observable to additive precision ϵalg is then estimated as ttotal = tshot e2Qe4P(2)totalϵ2/alg The total runtime required to estimate the two-copy observable to additive precision ϵalg is then estimated as ttotal = tshot e2Qe4P(2)totalϵ2/alg
Parameter Dependence of Symmetry-Restoration Dynamics
We examine the dependence of the symmetry-restoration dynamics on the fermion mass, the θ angle, and the total system size Within the system sizes, lattice spacing, and evolution times considered here, we do not observe a pronounced qualitative change in the symmetry-restoration dynamics as either m or θ is varied The systematic decrease of the residual entanglement asymmetry with increasing N suggests that the nonzero late-time value observed for the fermion-parity-preserving states is at least partly a finite-volume effect
Energy Expectation Values
For completeness, we examine the energy expectation values of the fermion-parity-preserving initial states introduced in (3.27) The energy expectation value of the infinite temperature state is ⟨H⟩β=0 = TrH dim H = 0 Under the thermal interpretation above, this corresponds to a decrease in βeff, with ϕ = 0. p. 1 3 Early-FTQC resource estimation . 33
5 Summary and Discussion 36
A Decomposition into Elementary Gates 38
B Parameter Dependence of the Symmetry-Restoration Dynamics 41
C Energy Expectation Values of the Fermion-Parity-Preserving Initial States 42
D An Analytical Bound for the Second-Order Product Formula 44
1Where the paper says it
Analytical Bound for Second-Order Product
We derive an analytical bound used in (4.13) by exploiting the locality of individual interaction terms For a Hamiltonian composed of interactions acting on at most k sites, the second-order product formula admits the locality-based bound (D. p. 1 3 Early-FTQC resource estimation . 33
5 Summary and Discussion 36
A Decomposition into Elementary Gates 38
B Parameter Dependence of the Symmetry-Restoration Dynamics 41
C Energy Expectation Values of the Fermion-Parity-Preserving Initial States 42
D An Analytical Bound for the Second-Order Product Formula 44
1Where the paper says it
Decomposition into Elementary Gates
The following decompositions are useful for implementing the initial-state preparation and real-time evolution For the initial states, we consider the spin-product and fermion-parity-preserving states ψ1(ϕ)⟩ = e−i ϕ2 P N n=1 Yomega⟩ = "Y N n=1 R(n)Y(ϕ) omega⟩ For the real-time evolution, we employ the second-order product formula The odd-bond and even-bond blocks are implemented 2M and M times, respectively Counting the elementary gates in these blocks gives the CNOT and RZ counts quoted in (4.22) and (4.28) of the main text The total number of CNOT gates required for the second-order Suzuki–Trotter time evolution is G(1)CNOT = O(MN2)
Summary and Discussion
In this work, we constructed a quantum measurement protocol for estimating the second R´enyi entanglement asymmetry by combining the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations This favorable measurement complexity makes the protocol particularly attractive for studying symmetry-restoration dynamics in quantum many-body systems and lattice quantum field theories As a representative application, we investigated the quantum Mpemba effect in the lattice Schwinger model for both spin-product benchmark states and fermion-parity-preserving initial states using classical state-vector simulations We further estimated the circuit resources required to implement the protocol on noisy quantum devices, fault-tolerant quantum computers (FTQCs), and a representative early-FTQC architecture Taken together, these results connect the proposed measurement protocol to a concrete nonequilibrium field-theory application and provide quantitative resource estimates for its implementation on quantum hardware Several directions for future work are worth exploring The protocol can be generalized to higher integer orders ∆S(n)A by introducing n copies of the system and implementing the corresponding cyclic-permutation measurements Hamiltonian-simulation algorithms beyond product formulas can provide more favorable asymptotic complexity for suitable Hamiltonians and access models From the field-theory perspective, it would be valuable to investigate the quantum Mpemba effect in the lattice Schwinger model at larger system sizes and toward the continuum limit ag → 0 Exploring the real-time dynamics of entanglement asymmetry in lattice models with anomalous or more general symmetry structures would be an interesting direction for future work The paper provides a measurement protocol that connects the proposed measurement protocol to a concrete field-theory application and to quantitative resource estimates for its implementation on quantum hardware The paper is organized as follows.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Quantum measurement protocol for estimating R´enyi entanglement asymmetry: The protocol can be generalized to higher integer orders Delta S (n) A by introducing n copies of the system and implementing the corresponding cyclic-permutation measurements.
-
Hamiltonian simulation algorithms beyond product formulas: Alternative methods like linear-combination-of-unitaries methods and approaches based on quantum singular value transformation can provide more favorable asymptotic complexity for suitable Hamiltonians.
-
Large volume and continuum limits of the lattice Schwinger model: Investigating the quantum Mpemba effect in larger system sizes and toward the continuum limit ag -> 0 would clarify finite-size effects observed in late-time entanglement asymmetry.
Abstract
We construct a quantum measurement protocol for estimating the Rényi entanglement asymmetry, which quantifies symmetry breaking at the level of a subsystem and provides a probe of the quantum Mpemba effect. The protocol combines the SWAP test with a charge-resolving procedure based on randomized symmetry rotations. For a fixed additive accuracy ε, the required number of measurements scales as O(ε-2) without explicit dependence on the total system size, making the protocol particularly attractive for quantum many-body systems and lattice quantum field theories. As a representative application, we study the quantum Mpemba effect in the lattice Schwinger model with a θ term using classical state-vector simulations. We further estimate the resources required to implement the protocol on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, fault-tolerant quantum computers (FTQCs), and a representative early-FTQC architecture. Our results provide a measurement-efficient framework for investigating anomalous symmetry-restoration dynamics in quantum many-body systems and quantum field theories.
Sources
- Hot water can freeze faster than cold?!?
- Entanglement asymmetry as a probe of symmetry breaking
- Lack of symmetry restoration after a quantum quench: an entanglement asymmetry study
- The quantum Mpemba effect in free-fermionic mixed states
- Non-equilibrium entanglement asymmetry for discrete groups: the example of the XY spin chain
- Entanglement asymmetry and quantum Mpemba effect in the XY spin chain
- First-Order Phase Transition of the Schwinger Model with a Quantum Computer
- Dynamical symmetry restoration in the Heisenberg spin chain
- Multiple crossing during dynamical symmetry restoration and implications for the quantum Mpemba effect
- Symmetry restoration and quantum Mpemba effect in many-body localization systems
- Non-Abelian entanglement asymmetry in random states
- Quantum Mpemba effect without global symmetries
- A simpler probe of the quantum Mpemba effect in closed systems
- Quantum Mpemba effect in long-range spin systems
- Translation symmetry restoration in integrable systems: the noninteracting case
- Entanglement asymmetry and quantum Mpemba effect in two-dimensional free-fermion systems
- Quenching from superfluid to free bosons in two dimensions: entanglement, symmetries, and quantum Mpemba effect
- Entanglement asymmetry and quantum Mpemba effect for Kramers-Wannier duality
- Entanglement asymmetry in gauge theories: chiral anomaly in the finite temperature massless Schwinger model
- Higher-form entanglement asymmetry. Part I. The limits of symmetry breaking
Related papers
- Heavy-Meson Bag Parameters using Gradient Flow
- Impact of Irrep Truncations on Quantum Simulations of QCD
- Evaluating generative samplers for lattice field theory by scale
- Renormalized symmetry probes for emergent symmetries and non-chiral lattice fermions
- Scalable Generative Sampling and Multilevel Estimation for Lattice Field Theories Near Criticality
- Lattice QCD study of the K*(892) resonance at the physical point