Partially Massless Condensates and Reentrant NUT/Bolt Phase Transitions in Conformal Gravity

arXiv:2611.05787 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-11-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Partially Massless Condensates and Reentrant NUT/Bolt Phase Transitions in Conformal Gravity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We study non-Einstein Bach-flat Taub-NUT/Bolt instantons with weakened AdS boundary conditions to explore how additional holographic degrees of freedom enrich the thermodynamic phase structure The additional holographic degrees of freedom enrich the thermodynamic phase structure, allowing the conventional NUT/Bolt transition to disappear or give way to reentrant transitions Conformal Gravity Framework Conformal gravity is a theory invariant under Weyl rescalings of the metric, and its action is given by the square of the Weyl tensor It has been considered an ultraviolet completion of Einstein gravity, and it provides a suitable ground for studying holography from a topdown viewpoint In four dimensions, conformal gravity reduces to Einstein-AdS gravity at the level of classical solution space and on-shell action by imposing Neumann boundary conditions on the Fefferman–Graham expansion The classical solution space contains Einstein branches with dynamically generated cosmological constants Holographic Responses and Condensates The next-to-leading-order coefficient in the Fefferman–Graham expansion is nonvanishing, and it sources the partially massless response in the dual conformal field theory The holographic stress tensor of these instantons represents a perfect fluid with vorticity Remarkably, we identify a non-Einstein Taub-Bolt branch supporting a nonvanishing partially massless response at zero source, while preserving the full symmetry of the squashed conformal boundary The additional holographic degrees of freedom enrich the thermodynamic phase structure Phase Structure and Thermodynamics The additional deformation parameter b significantly enriches the phase structure, including two new regimes: one in which the Hawking-Page-type transition is absent and another one with reentrant transitions The vanishing derivatives of the action difference do not intersect the action-equality curves within the numerical range considered, implying a discontinuity in the first derivatives of the dominant actions In particular, for suitable fixed values of the partially massless source, varying the squashing parameter leads to a Bolt-NUT-Bolt sequence, establishing the reentrant character of the phase structure Stability and Volume Analysis We find that there are no negative eigenvalue modes of a conformally coupled probe scalar fields on regular Bach-flat Taub-NUT geometries, extending the results of Ref.

Paper summary: Kai: So looking at the "Partially Massless Condensates and Reentrant NUT/Bolt Phase Transitions in Conformal Gravity" paper, the main point is that weakening those AdS boundary conditions opens up new physics. These extra holographic degrees of freedom are what allow for those reentrant phase transitions and can even make the usual Hawking-Page transition disappear.

Mira: Essentially, they found that in conformal gravity, these condensates aren't just side effects; they are central to generating a richer thermodynamic phase structure than we see in standard models like Einstein gravity.

Lev: From an engineering view, it means that if you were designing a system based on this theory, the phase diagram isn't as simple as expected; you have these looping transitions that require very careful control to navigate.

Kai: It’s about seeing how a specific mathematical structure—conformal gravity with those non-Einstein geometries—can host such complex thermodynamic behavior when you introduce these higher-order corrections.

Mira: And the implication is that we can use these results to explore more exotic states of matter or spacetime configurations where the conventional phase boundaries break down.

Lev: It gives us a concrete mathematical structure to test against, even if building it for real hardware would require tackling those complex stability issues they mentioned in their work.

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at that paper, "Partially Massless Condensates and Reentrant NUT/Bolt Phase Transitions in Conformal Gravity." Basically, they found that those extra holographic degrees of freedom actually change the phase diagram a lot.

Mira: Yeah it's about how these new things—these condensates—let you get those reentrant transitions where you go back and forth between phases. It means the standard way of thinking about NUT or Bolt geometry is not the whole story there.

Lev: From my side, it's interesting because it suggests that if we look at these kinds of gravity theories, the vacuum isn't as rigid as we thought when we simplify things down to just Einstein gravity.

Kai: Exactly. The authors are using conformal gravity and looking at how those boundary conditions affect the thermodynamics of the spacetime itself. It’s about seeing how adding a layer of freedom—that non-Einstein stuff—complicates, in a good way, the physics they're modeling.

Mira: What this means is that we can have more complex states of matter in these gravitational systems than we could predict before when we only looked at the simplest Einstein branches. It's about enriching the phase structure itself.

Lev: I gotta say, if you were trying to build a real quantum system based on this, you’d be looking at how those extra degrees of freedom would affect the noise and error rates in your hardware. That's where it gets from paper to practical stuff.

Kai: Right, so the authors are pointing toward these new thermodynamic regimes that aren't there before. It’s showing that these extra fields are playing a real role in determining what happens at the boundary of different phases.

Mira: And for us theorists, it means we need to account for those non-Einstein terms if we want an accurate picture of how spacetime behaves under extreme conditions. The complexity is intentional, not accidental.

Lev: It makes me think about the stability analysis they did later on; they checked if those geometries are stable against small perturbations, and that’s a key hurdle for any physical model.

Kai: It certainly is. But for now, this work sets up a much richer map of what's possible in these types of gravity models than we had before. Next up, we should look at how those specific phase transitions actually behave numerically when you start changing the squashing parameter.

Cristóbal Corral, Felipe Diaz, Borja Diez, Eleftherios Papantonopoulos, Per Sundelle

Departamento de Ciencias, Facultad de Artes Liberales, Universidad Adolfo Ib¡nez · Facultad de Ingeniería, Universidad San Sebastián · Departamento de Fca, Cinvestav · Physics Division, School of Applied Mathematical and Physical Sciences, National Technical University of Athens · Instituto de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales, Universidad Arturo Prat

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-11-04

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: 35 pages, 2 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: We study non-Einstein Bach-flat Taub-NUT/Bolt instantons with weakened AdS boundary conditions to explore how additional holographic degrees of freedom enrich the thermodynamic phase structure The…

Key concepts

Conformal Gravity
This is a theory where physics is invariant under Weyl rescalings of the metric, meaning it doesn't care about uniform stretching or shrinking of space. It's considered a way to complete Einstein gravity in four dimensions and serves as a foundation for studying holography from the top-down perspective.
Holographic Stress Tensor
In this context, the holographic stress tensor describes the instanton as a perfect fluid that possesses vorticity. Crucially, researchers found a non-Einstein Taub-Bolt branch that supports this response even at zero source, maintaining full boundary symmetry.
Reentrant Transitions
These are unusual phase transitions where a system moves through different states and then returns to an earlier state. In this paper, varying the squashing parameter leads to a sequence of Bolt-NUT-Bolt transitions, demonstrating this reentrant behavior in the thermodynamic phase structure.

Terminology

Summary

We study non-Einstein Bach-flat Taub-NUT/Bolt instantons with weakened AdS boundary conditions to explore how additional holographic degrees of freedom enrich the thermodynamic phase structure The additional holographic degrees of freedom enrich the thermodynamic phase structure, allowing the conventional NUT/Bolt transition to disappear or give way to reentrant transitions

Conformal Gravity Framework

Conformal gravity is a theory invariant under Weyl rescalings of the metric, and its action is given by the square of the Weyl tensor It has been considered an ultraviolet completion of Einstein gravity, and it provides a suitable ground for studying holography from a topdown viewpoint In four dimensions, conformal gravity reduces to Einstein-AdS gravity at the level of classical solution space and on-shell action by imposing Neumann boundary conditions on the Fefferman–Graham expansion The classical solution space contains Einstein branches with dynamically generated cosmological constants

Holographic Responses and Condensates

The next-to-leading-order coefficient in the Fefferman–Graham expansion is nonvanishing, and it sources the partially massless response in the dual conformal field theory The holographic stress tensor of these instantons represents a perfect fluid with vorticity Remarkably, we identify a non-Einstein Taub-Bolt branch supporting a nonvanishing partially massless response at zero source, while preserving the full symmetry of the squashed conformal boundary The additional holographic degrees of freedom enrich the thermodynamic phase structure

Phase Structure and Thermodynamics

The additional deformation parameter b significantly enriches the phase structure, including two new regimes: one in which the Hawking-Page-type transition is absent and another one with reentrant transitions The vanishing derivatives of the action difference do not intersect the action-equality curves within the numerical range considered, implying a discontinuity in the first derivatives of the dominant actions In particular, for suitable fixed values of the partially massless source, varying the squashing parameter leads to a Bolt-NUT-Bolt sequence, establishing the reentrant character of the phase structure

Stability and Volume Analysis

We find that there are no negative eigenvalue modes of a conformally coupled probe scalar fields on regular Bach-flat Taub-NUT geometries, extending the results of Ref.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform holographic analysis by explicitly computing coefficients in the Fefferman–Graham expansion for non-Einstein Bach-flat Taub-NUT/Bolt instantons to determine if they take a perfect fluid form and identify nonvanishing vorticity, as shown in Section 5.

  2. Improved AI can distinguish between different thermodynamic regimes of NUT/Bolt systems by analyzing the normalized difference in Euclidean on-shell actions as a function of the boundary squashing parameter ν and the deformation parameter b, revealing conventional, absent, and reentrant first-order phase transitions.

  3. Improved AI can verify that regular non-Einstein NUT geometries admit no negative modes for a conformally coupled probe scalar field by analyzing the eigenvalue problem of the conformal Laplacian on regular Bach-flat Taub-NUT backgrounds.

  4. Improved AI can determine the thermodynamic volume in conformal gravity, finding that it can have either sign or be trivial, and specifically identify that the non-Einstein Taub-Bolt configurations supporting the partially massless condensate can also have negative thermodynamic volume.

  5. Improved AI can compute the conserved charges associated with a Killing vector using the modified holographic current and verify that these charges are proportional to rho, as shown in Eq. (3.37).

Abstract

We study non-Einstein Bach-flat Taub-NUT/Bolt instantons with weakened AdS boundary conditions. In particular, the next-to-leading-order coefficient in the Fefferman--Graham expansion is nonvanishing, and it sources the partially massless response in the dual conformal field theory. As in the Einstein case, the holographic stress tensor of these instantons represents a perfect fluid with vorticity. Remarkably, we identify a non-Einstein Taub-Bolt branch supporting a nonvanishing partially massless response at zero source, while preserving the full symmetry of the squashed conformal boundary. The additional holographic degrees of freedom enrich the thermodynamic phase structure, allowing the conventional NUT/Bolt transition to disappear or give way to reentrant transitions. We further show that non-Einstein Bolts can possess negative thermodynamic volume and establish the absence of negative modes of a conformally coupled probe scalar on regular Bach-flat NUT backgrounds.

Sources

Related papers