Search for the 229Pa Parity Doublet via Internal-Conversion Spectroscopy at FRIB

arXiv:2611.05494 · nucl-ex, physics.atom-ph · Submitted 2026-11-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Search for the 229Pa Parity Doublet via Internal-Conversion Spectroscopy at FRIB".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The radioisotope 229Pa is predicted to possess a nearly degenerate ground-state parity doublet and this measurement would provide the key nuclear-structure input needed to establish 229Pa as a leading candidate for next-generation atomic and molecular electric-dipole-moment (EDM) experiments.

Kai: Nuclear Structure Context The observed dominance of matter over antimatter in the Universe remains one of the central open problems connecting particle physics and cosmology.

Mira: Permanent electric dipole moments (EDMs) of nucleons, atoms, and molecules are among the most sensitive probes of such physics.

Kai: In near-spherical nuclei such as 199Hg, which currently sets the best limits on nuclear CP-violating phenomena

13: , such opposite-parity states lie at MeV energies, which suppresses S and the induced atomic and molecular EDMs.

Paper summary: Kai: So, this paper we're looking at today, "Search for 229Pa Parity Doublet via Internal-Conversion Spectroscopy at FRIB," it’s really zeroing in on a specific thing <ref:2611.05494#pg1,229Pa Parity Doublet via Internal-Conversion Spectroscopy at FRIB>. The main idea here is that the radioisotope 229Pa is predicted to have this nearly degenerate ground-state parity doublet <ref:2611.05494#pg1,the radioisotope 229Pa is predicted to>.

Mira: That splitting, which we call delta E, is predicted to be around sixty plus or minus fifty electron volts, and if it exists, it could make 229Pa a leading candidate for next-generation electric dipole moment experiments <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Lev: That small splitting is what matters because it would give 229Pa an exceptionally large enhancement of symmetry-violating nuclear moments compared to other isotopes seventeen <ref:2611.05494#pg2>.

Kai: Exactly. The paper suggests that measuring this nuclear structure property with sufficient precision becomes a prerequisite for selecting among candidate species, and 229Pa fits that description because of Chasman's prediction about it being at the edge of the octupole region thirty-five <ref:2611.05494#pg2,a prerequisite for selecting among candidate species>.

Mira: It builds on previous work, like Ahmad et al. who reported a ground-state doublet split by only two hundred twenty plus or minus fifty electron volts based on electron capture from 229U thirty-six <ref:2611.05494#pg2,ground-state doublet split by only>.

Lev: So, what makes this specific measurement so hard to get right? The paper points out that the projected reach of any experiment depends directly on the Schiff moment, S, of the heavy nucleus in the molecule, and that depends entirely on delta E seventeen <ref:2611.05494#pg2,on the Schiff moment, S, of the heavy nucleus in the molecule>.

Kai: And for 229Pa specifically at a splitting around sixty electron volts, they say it would make this isotope the most sensitive nucleus to CP-violating phenomena if that splitting is indeed in that tens to hundreds of eV range <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: It’s interesting because while near-spherical nuclei like 199Hg set the limits for nuclear CP-violating phenomena, those opposite parity states lie at MeV energies, which suppresses atomic and molecular electric dipole moments.

Lev: But when you move to nuclei with octupole deformation, intrinsic reflection asymmetry gives rise to these nearly degenerate parity doublets whose splitting can be much smaller than typical nuclear energies, on the order of tens of electron volts

fourteen–sixteen: .

Paper summary: Kai: This paper describes a measurement strategy where they use trapped 229U plus ions inside a Penning trap at FRIB to look for this doublet via internal-conversion spectroscopy <ref:2611.05494#pg1,doublet via internal-conversion spectroscopy>.

Mira: They propose that if the parity doublet is in that tens to hundreds of electron volt energy range, and the excited state has spin-parity five over two minus, it would decay to the five over two plus ground state through an E one transition three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Lev: And they suggest internal conversion would dominate whenever it's energetically allowed during this process three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Kai: The experiment involves trapping about ten thousand singly charged 229U plus ions inside a Penning trap, and each trap cycle takes about one minute to produce twenty-two ninetyPa ions through electron capture three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: During that decay process, the inner shell of an electron vacancy is typically formed in the Pa daughter, which results in the emission of X rays and Auger electrons three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Lev: The setup uses a retarding field unit and a microchannel plate to detect these prompt particles within about one nanosecond after the initial trigger from nuclear de-excitation cascades three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Kai: Detection of those internal conversion electrons would give them a characteristic signature, the chargedependent line positions and conversion thresholds, which directly determine that delta E splitting three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: They estimate a total expected background at one point is about one point two four counts per day, but if the splitting is set to sixty electron volts, they expect about seventy five signal counts per day Signal Estimation and Background.

Lev: That means for a delta E of sixty electron volts, the signal count rate is roughly forty times higher than the background count rate Signal Estimation and Background.

Kai: So, the core idea is that this internal-conversion spectroscopy of 229Pa produced by electron capture from trapped 229U plus ions in a Penning trap provides a direct route to searching for its candidate groundstate parity doublet three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: The authors are claiming that they can achieve sub-electron volt precision on delta E within about five days of measurement time for splittings greater than twenty electron volts, and even less than two days for splittings greater than sixty electron volts Outlook.

Paper summary: Lev: That level of precision would remove the dominant uncertainty in the size of the 229Pa Schiff moment if it falls in that tens to hundreds of electron volt splitting range Outlook <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Kai: So, they're suggesting that if we can measure this delta E accurately, 229Pa becomes a top candidate because it has this enhanced sensitivity for CP-violating phenomena Outlook <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: The paper is titled "Search for the 229Pa Parity Doublet via Internal-Conversion Spectroscopy at FRIB," and it’s written by Silviu-Marian Udrescu, Aiden Boyer, Lan Cheng, Ronald Fernando Garcia Ruiz, Phay J <ref:2611.05494#pg1,Search for the 229Pa Parity Doublet via Internal-Conversion Spectroscopy at FRIB>. Ho, Ryan Ringle, Jaideep T. Singh, Patrick R. Stollenwerk and Georg Tiebel with Margaret J. Tseng <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Lev: The implication is that this platform can be readily extended to searches for low-lying nuclear states in other isotopes, not just 229Pa Outlook <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Kai: It seems like this work lays out a very direct experimental pathway using existing facilities at FRIB, focusing on the specific nuclear structure of 229Pa three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: The paper sets up a clear path forward by proposing how to measure the energy splitting delta E, which is the key nuclear structure input needed for these EDM experiments sixteen <ref:2611.05494#pg2>.

Lev: We have to remember that this measurement requires trapping and cooling ions at FRIB, which is a big piece of engineering overhead three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Kai: So what we are hearing here today is that we're looking at a specific isotope, 229Pa, because its predicted nuclear structure—this parity doublet—could be the missing link for understanding CP violation in nature one <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: It’s about taking a theoretical prediction about nuclear shape and turning it into an experimental observable through internal conversion spectroscopy three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Lev: The real hurdle, though, is getting that required precision on the energy splitting delta E, which they say would take less than two days for splittings greater than sixty electron volts Outlook.

Kai: So the immediate future here is about building and running this specific measurement strategy to see if that predicted doublet actually shows up in 229Pa three <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at "Search for the 229Pa Parity Doublet via Internal-Conversion Spectroscopy at FRIB <ref:2611.05494#pg1,Search for the 229Pa Parity Doublet via Internal-Conversion Spectroscopy at FRIB>."

Mira: It’s about using a specific nuclear state in 229Pa, this predicted parity doublet, to find evidence for CP violation <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Lev: They are using electron capture from trapped twenty two nine U plus ions inside a Penning trap to make that isotope.

Kai: That’s the core methodology, right? Trapping these ions and watching them decay into the 229Pa daughter <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: Exactly, and they’re measuring how electrons come out during that process, using internal conversion spectroscopy to see the energy splitting between those two states.

Lev: The math shows that if you have a splitting around sixty electron volts, you get seventy five signal counts per day compared to only one point two four background counts per day.

Kai: That contrast is pretty stark; it means the signal is forty times stronger than the noise in that specific energy range.

Mira: And they say if you can get that measurement right, within about five days for splittings above twenty electron volts, or less than two days for splittings above sixty electron volts, it really matters.

Lev: That precision is what removes the main uncertainty in calculating the Schiff moment size for 229Pa when the splitting is in that tens to hundreds of electron volt range <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Kai: So if they nail that splitting measurement, 229Pa becomes a prime candidate for probing those fundamental CP-violating effects we’re looking for <ref:2611.05494#pg1>.

Mira: It’s about turning a prediction about nuclear shape into an experimental testable observable.

Lev: That platform, using the Penning trap and internal conversion, they suggest can be scaled up to look at other isotopes with low lying nuclear states too.

Department of Physics, Princeton University · Department of Physics and Astronomy, Johns Hopkins University · Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University · Facility for Rare Isotope Beams

nucl-ex, physics.atom-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-03

Updated: 2026-11-15

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: The radioisotope 229Pa is predicted to possess a nearly degenerate ground-state parity doublet and this measurement would provide the key nuclear-structure input needed to establish 229Pa as a…

Key concepts

Parity Doublet
This refers to two nearly identical nuclear states in 229Pa that have opposite parity. They are predicted to be close in energy, potentially separated by only tens or hundreds of electron volts. Finding this splitting is the main goal.
Internal Conversion (IC)
When a nucleus de-excites, it can transfer its energy directly to an atomic electron instead of emitting a photon (X-ray). This process creates characteristic X-rays and Auger electrons, which serve as the measurable signal used to identify the nuclear transition.
Schiff Moment
The Schiff moment is a measure of how much a nucleus exhibits electric dipole moments due to CP violation. The paper suggests that if 229Pa's parity doublet splitting ($\Delta E$) is in the tens to hundreds of eV range, this isotope will be extremely sensitive for detecting such fundamental physics.
Octupole Deformation
This describes a specific, pear-shaped shape that some nuclei can take. Nuclei with octupole deformation are predicted to have nearly degenerate parity doublets whose energy splitting is much smaller than usual, significantly boosting their sensitivity to CP-violating effects.

Terminology

Summary

The radioisotope 229Pa is predicted to possess a nearly degenerate ground-state parity doublet and this measurement would provide the key nuclear-structure input needed to establish 229Pa as a leading candidate for next-generation atomic and molecular electric-dipole-moment (EDM) experiments. p. 0

Nuclear Structure Context

The observed dominance of matter over antimatter in the Universe remains one of the central open problems connecting particle physics and cosmology. Permanent electric dipole moments (EDMs) of nucleons, atoms, and molecules are among the most sensitive probes of such physics. p. 0 In near-spherical nuclei such as 199Hg, which currently sets the best limits on nuclear CP-violating phenomena [13], such opposite-parity states lie at MeV energies, which suppresses S and the induced atomic and molecular EDMs. p. 0 The situation changes significantly in nuclei with octupole (pear-shaped) deformation [14–16]. p. 0 Intrinsic reflection asymmetry gives rise to nearly degenerate parity doublets, whose splitting, ∆E, can be significantly smaller than typical nuclear energies, on the order of tens of keV. p. 0 Schiff moments of octupole-deformed nuclei are consequently predicted to exceed those of near-spherical nuclei by two to three orders of magnitude. p. 0

Measurement Strategy

If the parity doublet in 229Pa lies within the expected energy range of tens to hundreds of eV, and the excited state has spin–parity 5/2−, it would decay to the 5/2+ ground state via an E1 transition, with internal conversion (IC) expected to dominate whenever energetically allowed. Electron spectroscopy, combined with knowledge of the initial and final electronic states, enables a direct determination of the parity doublet energy splitting, ∆E. p. 1 The proposed experiment will begin with trapped 229U+ ions inside a Penning trap (Fig. p. 1 1a). During the EC process, an inner-shell electron vacancy is typically formed in the Pa daughter, resulting in the emission of X-rays and Auger electrons. p. 1 The chargedependent line positions and conversion thresholds would provide a characteristic signature of the nuclear transition. p. 1

Experimental Details

The experiment involves trapping ∼ 10 4 singly charged 229U+ ions inside a Penning trap at FRIB. Each trap cycle will be 1 min long, during which approximately 95 EC decays will produce 229Pa. p. 3 The measurement trap will then be ready for the next batch. p. 3 The prompt electron spectrum comprises Auger and shake-off electrons, together with conversion electrons from nuclear de-excitation cascades. p. 3 The IC electrons can be detected using the same setup as the prompt electrons, but their kinetic energies are measured with a retarding-field analyser similar to that used in 229mTh IC spectroscopy. p. 3

Signal Estimation and Background

The signal depends on the fraction fIC of daughters for which IC is energetically allowed. For ∆E = 60 eV, only Paq+ ions with q ≤ 4 can convert from their electronic ground states. p. 4 The total expected background is therefore approximately 1. p. 524 counts/day, compared with approximately 75 signal counts/day at ∆E = 60 eV. p. 5

Outlook

Internal-conversion spectroscopy of 229Pa produced by electron capture of trapped 229U+ in a Penning trap provides a direct route to searching for its candidate groundstate parity doublet, with sub-eV precision within about five days of measurement time for ∆E ≳ 20 eV, and in less than two days for ∆E ≳ 60 eV. A measurement of ∆E would remove the dominant uncertainty in the size of the 229Pa Schiff moment, which, for splittings of tens to hundreds of eV, would make this isotope the most sensitive nucleus to CP-violating phenomena. p. 5 Such a platform can be readily extended to searches for low-lying nuclear states in other isotopes. p. 5

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved system can perform direct search for 229Pa parity doublet by using delayed-coincidence internal-conversion spectroscopy of 229Pa ions produced by electron-capture decay of 229U+ ions stored in a Penning trap at FRIB to measure the splitting with sub-eV precision within a few days.

  2. Improved system can establish whether 229Pa is a viable system for a new generation of searches for time-reversal violation in atoms, ions, and molecules by measuring the energy splitting Delta E and removing the dominant uncertainty in the size of the 229Pa Schiff moment.

  3. Improved system can perform adaptive determination of Delta E by choosing barrier settings to maximize mutual information between Delta E and counts of the next cycle, with a stopping rule based on posterior probabilities to ensure a 68 percent credible interval half-width less than one eV in two consecutive cycles.

Sources

Related papers