Organizing Intelligence

arXiv:2611.05417 · econ.TH · Submitted 2026-10-31 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Economics. The day in economics: theory, mechanisms and the evidence beneath them.

Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "Organizing Intelligence".

Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. Agents, whether human or artificial intelligence (AI), sort endogenously into competing firms, and a firm's productivity is contingent upon its agents' capabilities.

Ruth: The paper distinguishes between competence—which shifts productivity levels—and coordination—which dictates how productivity scales with organizational size.

Warren: A key transformation driven by the difference between AI and humans is that AI expertise is reproducible, whereas human expertise is in fixed supply, and AIs may not encounter the same human limitations regarding coordination.

Ruth: The model analyzes how market structure, productivity, employment levels, and wages evolve as AI capabilities advance across four regimes: Minimal AGI, Supercompetent AI, Supercooperative AI, and Artificial Superintelligence (ASI).

Paper summary: Iris: So we covered the basics of "Organizing Intelligence," which develops a model about how intelligence, defined as the ability to achieve goals, affects organizations—the key unit of economic production.

Ruth: The main thesis is that agents, whether human or AI, sort themselves into competing firms based on their capabilities and that a firm's productivity depends directly on those agent capabilities.

Warren: They clearly separate competence from coordination; competence shifts the productivity level up or down based on domain-specific skills like robotics.

Iris: And coordination is about how agents work better together as the organization grows, capturing things like reduced communication costs or better understanding of norms.

Ruth: The paper highlights two key ways AI differs from humans: AI expertise can be reproduced at a cost of compute, while human expertise comes with a fixed supply of people.

Warren: That fixed supply for humans creates what they call Ricardian scarcity rents in the form of higher wages for increasing expertise, which AI doesn't face because copying an AI model doesn't have that compute cost.

Iris: They analyze how equilibrium market structure, employment levels, and wages change as these AI capabilities improve across four stages: Minimal AGI, Supercompetent AI, Supercooperative AI, and Artificial Superintelligence.

Ruth: A key finding is that when the average human agent can't keep up with the AI capability level, organizations with complementary human agents can still achieve superior performance compared to pure AI systems.

Warren: They also show that increases in competence for the AI lead to changes in worker composition within those firms and a reduction in firm size.

Iris: Conversely, improvements in AI coordination seem capable of breaking the Coasean ceiling on firm size, which drives a transition toward very large, highly concentrated AI-heavy firms.

Ruth: The model decomposes wage changes into a technology effect that modifies human labor value and a reorganization effect from changes in firm size and composition.

Warren: Crucially, the authors show that this reorganization effect can even reverse the initial technology effect on wages entirely.

Iris: They conclude by showing that structures based on firm support and active equality are efficient, and under constant returns to scale, the mean capability of the technology corresponds to everyone having equal time allocation across all tasks.

Ruth: This whole study is about mapping out how market structure, productivity, employment levels, and wages evolve when AI advances across these four regimes.

Conclusion: Warren: So looking at "Organizing Intelligence," the authors are essentially proposing a framework that links agent capabilities directly to organizational outcomes like size and employment.

Iris: The paper really gets at how the difference between reproducible AI expertise and fixed human supply creates a unique dynamic for economic transformation.

Ruth: It suggests that simply looking at technology as something that makes workers more productive isn't enough; you have to account for how the organization is structured around those capabilities.

Warren: The implication for us is that we can't just predict a single outcome based on AI skill alone; we need to model the interaction between competence and coordination.

Iris: They’re giving us a way to think about why rapid increases in AI capability might not always result in proportional economic transformation if the organization doesn't adapt its composition or size correctly.

Ruth: The title, "Organizing Intelligence," captures that idea—it’s not just about the intelligence itself, but how it gets organized within a firm.

Warren: It means we need to focus our analysis on those two elements, competence and coordination, because they determine the ultimate market structure and what people actually earn.

Iris: It sets up a clear direction for future work by suggesting specific benchmarks for measuring output scaling with AI copies at fixed compute per copy alongside isolated competence.

Ruth: And we need to track how different worker skill profiles sort across firms to isolate that reorganization effect from the initial technology effect on wages.

Alex Imas, Andrew Koh, Shane Legg

Google DeepMind

econ.TH

Submitted: 2026-10-31

Updated: 2026-10-31

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 100/100

The gist: Agents, whether human or artificial intelligence (AI), sort endogenously into competing firms, and a firm's productivity is contingent upon its agents' capabilities.

Key concepts

Competence
This refers to the specific skills or knowledge agents possess, which directly influences a firm's productivity level. Increasing competence means agents can perform tasks better, thereby shifting the overall output capacity of the organization.
Coordination
This concept describes how productivity scales as a firm grows in size. It focuses on how well agents work together or how effectively organizational structure manages increasing scale, determining whether larger firms become more or less productive.
Technology Effect
This effect measures the change in wages caused by technological advancements that modify the value of human labor within existing firms. It represents how changes in agent capability alter the direct productivity gains for workers already employed.
Reorganization Effect
This effect captures wage changes resulting from adjustments to firm size and composition, rather than just technology. This can reverse initial wage effects by showing how shifts in organizational structure influence worker compensation.

Terminology

Summary

Agents, whether human or artificial intelligence (AI), sort endogenously into competing firms, and a firm's productivity is contingent upon its agents' capabilities. The paper distinguishes between competence—which shifts productivity levels—and coordination—which dictates how productivity scales with organizational size. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Agents (human or AI) with multidimensional capabilities sort endogenously into competing firms. A firm’s productivity depends on its agents’ capabilities; we distinguish competence, which shifts productivity levels, from coordination, which governs how productivity scales with size.

A key transformation driven by the difference between AI and humans is that AI expertise is reproducible, whereas human expertise is in fixed supply, and AIs may not encounter the same human limitations regarding coordination. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A firm’s productivity depends on its agents’ capabilities; we distinguish competence, which shifts productivity levels, from coordination, which governs how productivity scales with size. Two differences between AI and humans drive transformation: AI expertise is reproducible while humans’ are in fixed supply, and AIs may not face the same human limits on coordination.

The model analyzes how market structure, productivity, employment levels, and wages evolve as AI capabilities advance across four regimes: Minimal AGI, Supercompetent AI, Supercooperative AI, and Artificial Superintelligence (ASI). p. 9

Where the paper says it

69 5 9 12 task competence 0. 97 1 coordination Minimal AGI Supercompetent AI Supercooperative AI ASI coder or writer mosaic team coordinator mosaic + coordinator Figure 3: AI capability regimes in task-competence and coordination space.

When AI capability surpasses that of the average human agent, organizations composed of complementary human agents can still achieve superior performance compared to pure AI. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Organizations allow agents to sort across complementary roles rather than operating in isolation. For any collection of agents A—human workers, specialized AI models, or mixed human–AI teams—define its capability envelope as the closed convex hull of individual capability vectors, E(A) = conv{y i : i ∈ A}, which collects all mean capability profiles (y¯1, y¯2, y¯∗) attainable by organizations formed from A.

Increases in AI competence can alter the composition of workers within firms and lead to a decrease in firm size. p. 0
Where the paper says it

When AI is more capable than the average human, organizations of complementary humans can nonetheless outperform AI. Increases in AI competence can change the composition of workers within firms and decrease firm size.

Conversely, improvements in AI coordination can potentially overcome the Coasean ceiling on firm size, driving a phase transition toward large, highly concentrated AI-heavy firms. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Increases in AI competence can change the composition of workers within firms and decrease firm size. As AI coordination improves, however, this can break the Coasean ceiling on firm size and the market structure undergoes a phase transition toward large, concentrated AI-heavy firms.

The model formally characterizes these scenarios by decomposing wage changes into two effects: a technology effect, which modifies the value of human labor within existing firms, and a reorganization effect arising from adjustments in firm size and composition; the reorganization effect can even reverse the initial technology effect on wages. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We decompose wage changes into a technology effect, which changes the value of humans within existing firms, and a reorganization effect as firms adjust size and composition. Reorganization can reverse the technology effect on wages.

The paper establishes that organizational structures determined by firm support and active equality are efficient. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2 AN ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE Before turning to the general model, we build up a simple and concrete economy step-by-step to illustrate the key mechanisms of the paper. 3Our equilibrium concept requires that every industry is competitive: producers and workers take the offered prices and wages as given, active firms break even, no feasible entry is profitable, and markets clear.

Furthermore, under constant returns to scale, the mean-capability technology corresponds to equal time allocation across all tasks. p. 3
Where the paper says it

5The harmonic mean corresponds to a symmetric constant-elasticity-of-substitution aggregator L = 1 2 y¯ ρ 1 + 1 2 y¯ ρ 2 1/ρ with ρ = −1, giving an elasticity of substitution of 1/2. Following Kremer (1993) on complementary O-ring production tasks and Jones (2011) on weak links in intermediate inputs, an elasticity strictly below unity ensures that shortfalls in any essential domain bottleneck output without introducing strict Leontief kinks; see also Aghion et al.

The analysis connects these concepts to existing literature on firm boundaries and limits to organizational scale. The authors suggest specific methodologies for future research: benchmarks should measure output scaling with the number of identical AI copies at fixed compute per copy alongside isolated competence (L), and firm-level datasets must track total organizational scale (m f = nu H f(Y) + nu M f(Y)), encompassing both worker rolls and rented compute expenditures. Finally, tracking employer-employee panels that test how workers with different skill profiles sort across firms would help isolate the technology effect from the reorganization effect and identify which workers are most affected by AI-driven reorganization. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Changes in human employment are gradual when AI displaces workers within mixed human-AI firms, or sudden when AI firms outcompete human firms. We decompose wage changes into a technology effect, which changes the value of humans within existing firms, and a reorganization effect as firms adjust size and composition.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improve AI systems by focusing on coordination capability rather than just task competence to break the Coasean ceiling on firm size, as AI can break the Coasean ceiling and trigger a sudden phase transition toward a giant AI firm when coordination improves.

  2. Develop multi-agent LLM systems with tighter alignment mechanisms to reduce inter-agent misalignment, which currently causes 41–87% of tasks due to inter-agent misalignment, lost context across handoffs, and broken verification.

  3. Design AI agents whose coordination capability is more robust than human capabilities when the system is operating in a regime where AI coordinates better, such that the firm’s preferred size increases as coordination approaches one.

  4. Implement AI systems that can dynamically adjust their workforce composition based on the reorganization effect, specifically by changing firm size, its machine share, and the mix of human skills it employs to maximize total surplus.

  5. Optimize AI agent bids by incorporating a term for human coordination contribution into the bid function to ensure that a worker who improves coordination raises the firm’s bid.

Abstract

When will advances in AI lead to economic transformation? We develop a model of how intelligence, the ability to achieve goals, matters for organizations, the key unit of economic production. Agents (human or AI) with multidimensional capabilities sort endogenously into competing firms. A firm's productivity depends on its agents' capabilities; we distinguish competence, which shifts productivity levels, from coordination, which governs how productivity scales with size. Two differences between AI and humans drive transformation: AI expertise is reproducible while humans' are in fixed supply, and AIs may not face the same human limits on coordination. We analyze how equilibrium market structure, productivity, employment, and wages evolve as AI capabilities improve. When AI is more capable than the average human, organizations of complementary humans can nonetheless outperform AI. Increases in AI competence can change the composition of workers within firms and decrease firm size. As AI coordination improves, however, this can break the Coasean ceiling on firm size and the market structure undergoes a phase transition toward large, concentrated AI-heavy firms. Changes in human employment are gradual when AI displaces workers within mixed human-AI firms, or sudden when AI firms outcompete human firms. We decompose wage changes into a technology effect, which changes the value of humans within existing firms, and a reorganization effect as firms adjust size and composition. Reorganization can reverse the technology effect on wages.

Sources

Related papers