A VQE simulation of the transverse field Ising model

arXiv:2611.05379 · hep-lat · Submitted 2026-07-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Lattice. The day in lattice field theory: what the simulations put on the table.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A VQE simulation of the transverse field Ising model".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. One of the most promising applications of quantum computing is the ability to simulate quantum systems Here, we present an implementation of a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm known as the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) to estimate the ground state energy of a prototypical quantum spin system Model and Simulation Setup The work focuses on simulating the transverse field Ising model (TFIM), a prototypical quantum spin system that exhibits a quantum phase transition (QPT) at a critical point The TFIM Hamiltonian is given by Hˆ = −J8Xi8σziσzi+1 − h9X10N10i=1σxi Exact diagonalisation was used to calculate the ground state energy for small system sizes N = 2, 4, and 8 The exact ground state energies for N=8 are E0/J = -10.252.

Kai: VQE Implementation Details The Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm used to estimate the ground state energy of a quantum system The VQE process involves four main steps: 1) Prepare an initial parametrised circuit called an ansatz, 2) Calculate the energy expectation value E(θ) = ⟨ψ(θ)Hˆ ψ(θ)⟩, 3) Using a classical optimiser vary the parameters θ in order to minimise E(θ), and 4) Repeat steps 2 and 3 until the energy converges either to a local or global minimum.

Mira: The ansatz used is a fixed-structure hardware efficient ansatz (HEA) which consists of three rotation layers of parametrised Ry rotation gates and two layers of CNOT entanglement gates.

Kai: Optimization and Performance Gains The choice of classical optimiser significantly impacts the VQE performance, with COBYQA achieving the best accuracy among gradient-free optimisers The mean ground state energy obtained using this setup was E VQE0 = −3.92 ± 0.13.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper is presenting an implementation of a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm called the variational quantum eigensolver. The main goal they set out was estimating the ground state energy for a prototypical quantum spin system: the transverse field Ising model.

Mira: Specifically, they use this VQE approach on a four-spin transverse field Ising model and they evaluate its performance using both IBM quantum hardware and a local noise model to estimate the ground state energy and reproduce that phase transition.

Lev: The paper uses an initial configuration called an ansatz, which they describe as a fixed-structure hardware efficient ansatz. This means it's a set of three rotation layers of Ry rotation gates and two entanglement layers using CNOT gates for connecting the qubits.

Kai: They also detail how they calculate the energy expectation value, which involves decomposing the Hamiltonian into a sum of Pauli strings, so you can compute each term on a quantum device.

Mira: The key part is their optimisation process. They use an optimiser called COBYQA, which they found achieved the best accuracy among gradient-free optimisers when trying to minimise that energy expectation value E theta.

Lev: And they show how adjusting the layers in that ansatz helps improve things; for instance, increasing the number of rotation and entanglement layers from four to three actually reduced their relative error from about forty-nine percent down to roughly twenty-five percent.

Kai: So, when you look at this paper's overall message, it’s that by tweaking these specific components—the ansatz structure and the optimiser choice—they can get a significantly more accurate estimate of the ground state energy.

Mira: And they demonstrate that even with these adjustments, their final optimized VQE configuration gives them a mean ground state energy of negative three point nine two plus or minus zero point one three.

Lev: That number is the result they got after ten runs on IBM Fez hardware, and it came from evaluating a mean of five hundred fifty seven Pauli string evaluations.

Kai: And when they ran that final optimized setup, they found the relative error was around twenty-five percent compared to the classical exact diagonalisation benchmarks.

Conclusion: Mira: So, looking at this paper, "A VQE simulation of the transverse field Ising model," it really comes down to using quantum computing as a tool to explore systems that are too complex for classical methods alone.

Kai: It’s about showing that you can apply a specific algorithm like VQE to model these quantum spin systems and observe physical phenomena, like the quantum phase transition, even on limited hardware.

Lev: From an engineering side, the implication is that for actual quantum computation, we need to figure out how to reduce those error rates when we start scaling up beyond just four spins.

Mira: Exactly. The work serves as a proof of concept that these hybrid algorithms can model these types of problems on noisy devices, but it highlights the need for better hardware and more sophisticated error mitigation before we can talk about simulating things that are truly relevant to condensed matter physics.

Kai: So, in simple terms, the paper shows a path forward by proving that we can successfully use a VQE algorithm to model these systems on NISQ devices, which is a solid first step toward building more powerful quantum simulations down the line.

Lev: And what it means for someone who only listens to the show is that even if you're not running this code, this work shows that we can take complex physics problems and start translating them into something a quantum computer can actually touch, which is pretty exciting.

Luke Bennett

University of Liverpool

hep-lat

Submitted: 2026-07-04

Updated: 2026-07-04

Code: https://github.com/Qiskit/qiskit-addon-mthree

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 67/100

The gist: One of the most promising applications of quantum computing is the ability to simulate quantum systems Here…

Key concepts

Transverse Field Ising Model (TFIM)
This is a prototypical quantum spin system used to study quantum phase transitions. The Hamiltonian describes spins interacting with an external magnetic field (transverse field), and it exhibits a sharp change in behavior at a critical point, which is the focus of this simulation.
Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE)
VQE is a hybrid algorithm that uses both quantum and classical computers to find the lowest energy state of a system. It involves preparing a quantum circuit (ansatz), calculating its energy expectation value, and then using a classical optimizer to adjust the circuit's parameters until the energy is minimized.
Quantum Phase Transition (QPT)
A QPT is a critical point in a quantum system where the state of matter fundamentally changes as an external parameter, like the transverse field strength 'h', is varied. Simulating this transition helps test how well quantum computers can model complex physical phenomena.

Terminology

Summary

One of the most promising applications of quantum computing is the ability to simulate quantum systems Here, we present an implementation of a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm known as the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) to estimate the ground state energy of a prototypical quantum spin system

Model and Simulation Setup

The work focuses on simulating the transverse field Ising model (TFIM), a prototypical quantum spin system that exhibits a quantum phase transition (QPT) at a critical point The TFIM Hamiltonian is given by Hˆ = −J8Xi8σziσzi+1 − h9X10N10i=1σxi Exact diagonalisation was used to calculate the ground state energy for small system sizes N = 2, 4, and 8 The exact ground state energies for N=8 are E0/J = -10.252.

VQE Implementation Details

The Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm used to estimate the ground state energy of a quantum system The VQE process involves four main steps: 1) Prepare an initial parametrised circuit called an ansatz, 2) Calculate the energy expectation value E(θ) = ⟨ψ(θ)Hˆ ψ(θ)⟩, 3) Using a classical optimiser vary the parameters θ in order to minimise E(θ), and 4) Repeat steps 2 and 3 until the energy converges either to a local or global minimum. The ansatz used is a fixed-structure hardware efficient ansatz (HEA) which consists of three rotation layers of parametrised Ry rotation gates and two layers of CNOT entanglement gates. p. 2

Where the paper says it

2 Entanglements . 3 Rotation gates .

Optimization and Performance Gains

The choice of classical optimiser significantly impacts the VQE performance, with COBYQA achieving the best accuracy among gradient-free optimisers The mean ground state energy obtained using this setup was E VQE0 = −3.92 ± 0.13. Further optimization involved increasing the number of rotation and entanglement layers from 4 to 3, which increased the parameter space dimension from 12 to 32, leading to a relative error reduction from approximately 49% to about 25%.

Phase Transition Demonstration

The simulation demonstrates the quantum phase transition (QPT) by sweeping the transverse field strength h from 0 to 4 while keeping J = 1 fixed The results, when compared with classical exact diagonalisation, show that matrix-free error mitigation techniques like M3 improve the results, particularly in the ordered ferromagnetic phase.

Hardware Execution and Outlook

Running the VQE configuration on real hardware (ibmq fez) resulted in a relative error of around 70% with and without error mitigation This suggests that the main sources of error are likely coming from the gates and/or classical optimisation process rather than just readout errors. Future work is recommended to implement error mitigation techniques for gate errors such as gate twirling to improve accuracy when using more QPU time.

Conclusion

The paper concludes that while the results serve as a proof of concept, achieving quantum advantage for realistic simulations will require substantial improvements in hardware and error mitigation. The simulation successfully models the TFIM on NISQ devices, providing a stepping stone for future implementations. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Chapter 1 Introduction Quantum computers are one of the most promising future technologies, standing to potentially revolutionise science, finance, cryptography and much more [1, 2]. Current devices are usually classed as noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices [3] and their usefulness for physics simulations is of particular interest.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The work is organised as follows We begin in Section 2 with an introduction to the TFIM before proceeding with solving the model classically We then, in Section 3 introduce the fundamental concepts of quantum computing before analysing the specificities of the VQE in Section 4 Finally we present our simulation results in Section 5 and compare with those found classically before concluding in Section 6 with our final remarks and recommendation for future work.

How the training signal is built

The Hamiltonian representation requires decomposing the Hamiltonian into a sum of Pauli strings consisting only of possible values including I, X, Y, Z The energy expectation value is then re-expressed as E(θ) = Xaωa ⟨0U(θ)†PaU(θ)0⟩. This expression shows that the summands correspond to the expectation value of some Pauli string Pa, which can be computed on a quantum device. p. 5

Where the paper says it

If we first consider the simple case of two spins in the chain, N = 2, and setting J = h = 1 we can expand the Hamiltonian: Hˆ = −σ z 1σ z 2 − (σ x 1 + σ x 2 ). 4) The lower indices in the above expression mean we apply the Pauli operator at that given site within the chain, i.

Where the gains come from

The authors found that COBYQA performs better than gradient-based optimisers due to its use of quadratic approximations instead of linear ones The most efficient entanglement strategy tested was linear entanglement, which only entangles adjacent qubits. Increasing the ansatz expressivity led to a more accurate result, reducing the relative error to approximately 25%. p. 8

Where the paper says it

increasing N. Secondly, it is worth noting is that the conclusion we shall reach below can be reached through more advanced and rigorous methods, however we shall concentrate on perturbative methods.

The final optimized VQE configuration resulted in a mean ground state energy of E VQE0 = −3. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In this work we will first solve the TFIM classically using exact diagonalisation to calculate the ground state energy, as well as predict a QPT. We then apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM, beginning with a simple setup before performing a series of tests to reach a more optimised configuration.

92 ± 0.13.

Table 5.1: Summary of the VQE initialisation and ansatz configuration The three VQE components requiring initialisation are: ansatz, parameters and optimiser. p. 2

Where the paper says it

1 Initialisation . 2 Optimising the VQE .

Component Specification System size 4 qubits Ansatz type Hardware-efficient ansatz (HEA) Rotation gates Ry Entanglement gates CNOT (CX) Entanglement strategy Circular Number of layers 3 rotation layers, 2 entangling layers Parameters 12 parameters, θ ∈ [0, 2π] Optimiser COBYLA Maximum optimiser iterations 750 Backend (noise model) FakeManilaV2 Backend (hardware) ibmq fez (version 1.3.37).

The VQE process involves calculating the energy expectation value E(θ) = ⟨ψ(θ)Hˆ ψ(θ)⟩ The calculation of this expectation value on a quantum computer requires executing the parametrised circuit U(θ) to prepare ψ(θ)⟩, and any non-Z factors in Pa are first rotated into the computational basis before measurement.

The mean number of Pauli string evaluations for this initialisation was NPauli = 557 ± 32. The mean ground state energy across the ten runs was E VQE0 = −2. p. 0

Where the paper says it

A VQE simulation of the transverse field Ising model Luke Bennett Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool L69 7ZL, United Kingdom Abstract One of the most promising applications of quantum computing is the ability to simulate quantum systems. A quantity of particular importance in condensed matter physics is the ground-state energy of a system.

65 ± 0.19. This initialisation yielded a relative error of approximately 49% compared to classical exact diagonalisation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM and evaluate its performance using both a local noise model and IBM quantum hardware to estimate the ground-state energy and reproduce the QPT. The resulting ground-state energy estimates and QPT behaviour are compared with exact-diagonalisation benchmarks.

Table 5.2: Initial VQE energy estimates and corresponding number of Pauli string evaluations over ten runs Energy and Pauli evaluation uncertainties are reported as standard errors of the mean Run E VQE0 Npauli Run E VQE0 Npauli 1 −3. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM and evaluate its performance using both a local noise model and IBM quantum hardware to estimate the ground-state energy and reproduce the QPT. The resulting ground-state energy estimates and QPT behaviour are compared with exact-diagonalisation benchmarks.

17 592 6 −3.25 536 Table A. p. 6
Where the paper says it

N E0/J 2 -2. 252 Table 2.

4 Summary of full noisy VQE results for different classical optimisers Energy and Pauli evaluation uncertainties are reported as standard errors of the mean Mean BFGS −0.154 ± 0.299 2594.4 ± 153.3 L-BFGS-B −0.000 ± 0.308 2558.4 ± 154.4

The mean number of Pauli string evaluations for this initialisation was NPauli = 2600 ± 52. This result corresponds to an increase by approximately a factor of five compared to the initial configuration. p. 9

Where the paper says it

11) the values of σ z i at different sites will be totally uncorrelated [8] as a result of being in the disordered paramagnetic phase, the correlation function will thus be given as ⟨Ω| σ z i σ z j |Ω⟩ = δij . 12) Perturbative corrections in 1/g will build in correlations in σ z , representing spin interactions, that increase in range at each order [8].

The mean ground state energy is given as E VQE0 = −3. p. 5

Where the paper says it

If we first consider the simple case of two spins in the chain, N = 2, and setting J = h = 1 we can expand the Hamiltonian: Hˆ = −σ z 1σ z 2 − (σ x 1 + σ x 2 ). 4) The lower indices in the above expression mean we apply the Pauli operator at that given site within the chain, i.

92 ± 0.13. The relative error for this optimized setup is approximately 25%. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In this work we will first solve the TFIM classically using exact diagonalisation to calculate the ground state energy, as well as predict a QPT. We then apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM, beginning with a simple setup before performing a series of tests to reach a more optimised configuration.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

In this work we will first solve the TFIM classically using exact diagonalisation to calculate the ground state energy, as well as predict a QPT. We then apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM, beginning with a simple setup before performing a series of tests to reach a more optimised configuration.

This improvement was achieved via simple adjustments to the key VQE components without utilising more advanced techniques such as adaptive ansatz or error mitigation. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Although more advanced and efficient techniques exist, such as density-matrix renormalisation group methods [17] for numerical studies and JordanWigner transformations [18] for analytic solutions, the systems considered in this work are limited to small spin chains N = 2, 4 and 8. Consequentially, exact diagonalisation remains computationally feasible and provides a useful benchmark against which the VQE results can be compared.

Table 5.6: Summary of the changes made to the VQE initialisation Rotation gates Ry Ry, Rz Number of layers 4 rotation, 3 entangling Parameters 32 Component Initial specification Current specification Rotation gates Ry Ry, Rz Entanglement strategy Circular Linear Number of layers 3 rotation, 2 entangling 4 rotation, 3 entangling Parameters 12 to a larger space from the initialisation. p. 2

Where the paper says it

3 Rotation gates . 4 Final optimised VQE configuration .

The final VQE energy estimates from the ten independent runs are E VQE0 = −3.92 ± 0.13. The mean number of Pauli string evaluations has increased to NPauli = 2600 ± 52. p. 5

Where the paper says it

If we first consider the simple case of two spins in the chain, N = 2, and setting J = h = 1 we can expand the Hamiltonian: Hˆ = −σ z 1σ z 2 − (σ x 1 + σ x 2 ). 4) The lower indices in the above expression mean we apply the Pauli operator at that given site within the chain, i.

Table 5.8: Ground-state energy estimates from IBM Fez hardware runs for RL = 0 and RL = 1 Run Energy E RL=0 Npauli Run Energy E RL=1 Npauli 1 −2. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM and evaluate its performance using both a local noise model and IBM quantum hardware to estimate the ground-state energy and reproduce the QPT. The resulting ground-state energy estimates and QPT behaviour are compared with exact-diagonalisation benchmarks.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM and evaluate its performance using both a local noise model and IBM quantum hardware to estimate the ground-state energy and reproduce the QPT. The resulting ground-state energy estimates and QPT behaviour are compared with exact-diagonalisation benchmarks.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM and evaluate its performance using both a local noise model and IBM quantum hardware to estimate the ground-state energy and reproduce the QPT. The resulting ground-state energy estimates and QPT behaviour are compared with exact-diagonalisation benchmarks.

56 1 −0.210 Table A. p. 6
Where the paper says it

N E0/J 2 -2. 252 Table 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

N E0/J 2 -2. 252 Table 2.

5 Summary of full noisy VQE results for different ansatz rotation blocks Mean Ry, Rx, Rz −2. p. 2
Where the paper says it

42 A VQE optimisation results i A. 1 Varying ansatz gate repetitions .

451 ± 0.173 1573.6 ± 50.1

The mean ground state energy is given as E VQE0 = −3.92 ± 0.13. The relative error for this optimized setup is approximately 25%.

Figure 5.9: Results of the VQE both with and without error mitigation applied and compared to the result found using classical exact diagonalisation E VQE0 = −3. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Although more advanced and efficient techniques exist, such as density-matrix renormalisation group methods [17] for numerical studies and JordanWigner transformations [18] for analytic solutions, the systems considered in this work are limited to small spin chains N = 2, 4 and 8. Consequentially, exact diagonalisation remains computationally feasible and provides a useful benchmark against which the VQE results can be compared.

92 ± 0.13 NPauli = 2600 ± 52

The overall shape and trend of the QPT plot are present in both results, but M3 mitigation improves the results, particularly in the ordered ferromagnetic phase. This demonstrates the potential upsides of pairing error mitigation techniques with an algorithm being run on NISQ hardware. p. 3

Where the paper says it

A class of algorithms has emerged as a leading candidate for NISQ device physics simulations, known as variational quantum algorithms [4]. A specific variational algorithm of particular use to condensed matter physics is the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) [5, 6, 7].

The noticeable improvements from M3 in the ordered ferromagnetic phase are likely due to the smaller quantum fluctuations. These results serve as proofs of concept that quantum systems can be successfully modelled on NISQ devices. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Chapter 1 Introduction Quantum computers are one of the most promising future technologies, standing to potentially revolutionise science, finance, cryptography and much more [1, 2]. Current devices are usually classed as noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices [3] and their usefulness for physics simulations is of particular interest.

The mean ground state energy is given as E VQE0 = −3.92 ± 0.13.

Table 5.8: Ground-state energy estimates from IBM Fez hardware runs for RL = 0 and RL = 1 Run Energy E RL=0 Npauli Run Energy E RL=1 Npauli 1 −2.56 1 −0.210 Table A.4 Summary of full noisy VQE results for different classical optimisers Mean L-BFGS-B −0. p. 2

Where the paper says it

2 Optimising the VQE . 1 Classical optimisers .

000 ± 0.308 2558.4 ± 154.4

Table 5.7: Final VQE energy estimates and corresponding number of Pauli string evaluations over ten runs Run E VQE0 Npauli 1 −4. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM and evaluate its performance using both a local noise model and IBM quantum hardware to estimate the ground-state energy and reproduce the QPT. The resulting ground-state energy estimates and QPT behaviour are compared with exact-diagonalisation benchmarks.

23 2590 6 −3.97 2500

Table 5.8: Ground-state energy estimates from IBM Fez hardware runs for RL = 0 and RL = 1 Run Energy E RL=0 Npauli Run Energy E RL=1 Npauli 1 −2.56 1 −0.210

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Variational quantum eigensolver application allows estimation of ground state energy for systems like transverse field Ising model (TFIM). This enables hybrid quantum-classical algorithms to estimate ground state energy on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices.

  2. Optimiser selection can be improved by using gradient free optimisers like COBYQA, which the paper suggests achieving the best accuracy compared to gradient based methods on noisy parameter space.

  3. Ansatz selection should focus on balancing expressivity and cost, as a good ansatz must be sufficiently expressive to guarantee that it can appropriately approximate the ground state wave function, however, it must not be so expressive that it renders the search for the target state intractable.

  4. For small systems like the 4-spin TFIM simulation, using a Hardware Efficient Ansatz (HEA) is recommended because the simplicity of the HEA makes it a suitable candidate for the simulations carried out in this work.

  5. To improve results on real hardware, implementing error mitigation techniques like matrix free error mitigation (M3) can be used to improve the results, particularly in the ordered ferromagnetic phase.

  6. Future AI systems can perform more accurate predictions of physical behavior near quantum phase transitions by running error mitigation techniques alongside simulations.

Abstract

One of the most promising applications of quantum computing is the ability to simulate quantum systems. A quantity of particular importance in condensed matter physics is the ground-state energy of a system. Here, we present an implementation of a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm known as the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) to estimate the ground state energy of a prototypical quantum spin system. For this spin system, we use the transverse field Ising model (TFIM) which is known to exhibit a quantum phase transition (QPT) at a critical point. We apply the VQE to a 4-spin TFIM and evaluate its performance using both a local noise model and IBM quantum hardware to estimate the ground-state energy and reproduce the QPT. The resulting ground-state energy estimates and QPT behaviour are compared with exact-diagonalisation benchmarks.

Sources

Related papers