From Z to all: cyclic sum rules for thermal CFT partition functions

arXiv:2611.05281 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-11-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "From Z to all".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper determines universal constraints for thermal CFT partition functions by packaging an infinite tower of constraints into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism From Z to all: cyclic sum rules for thermal CFT partition functions.

Kai: Universal Constraints on the Partition Function The high-temperature expansion of twisted Sd−1 × S1 partition functions of CFTd, d = 2κ, has recently been shown to obey an infinite tower of universal constraints We determine these constraints explicitly and demonstrate that they can be packaged into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism isomorphic to Zκ+1, which cyclically permutes the thermal circle and the rotation angles.

Mira: Our equation asserts that the Zκ+1-invariant part of lnZ/β is a constant fixed by the a-anomaly.

Kai: Structure of the Partition Function Expansion The partition function's high-temperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c′β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω2 i) + Oβ3−d, β → 0 +, ωi fixed.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to wrap up on this paper, "From Z to all: cyclic sum rules for thermal CFT partition functions," the main point is that they managed to take an infinite tower of universal constraints from the high-temperature expansion and package them into one single equation involving a Z to kappa plus one action.

Mira: They showed that this equation asserts that the part of your partition function's logarithm divided by beta, which is invariant under this large conformal diffeomorphism, must be a constant fixed by the a-anomaly.

Lev: What this means for the world is that they’ve found a way to use these constraints to understand the structure of thermal quantum field theories in even dimensions without having to deal with every single constraint individually.

Kai: It simplifies things because it gives us one master equation, and it connects things like black hole physics through those cyclic sum rules and spectral equivalences.

Mira: It shows that the high-temperature behavior isn't just some messy series of corrections; it has this deep, underlying structure dictated by the a-anomaly.

Lev: For someone building real hardware, this is important because it suggests how to check these constraints against physical systems like Kerr-AdS black holes.

Kai: It’s about taking those abstract ideas from the partition function and showing they have concrete consequences for geometry and gravity in a way that's consistent across even dimensions.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper "From Z to all: cyclic sum rules for thermal CFT partition functions" basically takes an infinite set of constraints from the high-temperature expansion and bundles them into one big equation that uses a large conformal diffeomorphism.

Mira: Right, it suggests this single equation fixes the part of your partition function that is invariant under this diffeomorphism—that's what they call the a-anomaly.

Lev: From my side, it’s neat because they connect these constraints to things like Kerr-AdS black holes and gives us a specific identity for those gravitational objects.

Kai: It means we don't have to check every single constraint separately; we just check this one master equation, and it’s tied directly to the anomaly in the theory.

Mira: The authors build this using CP invariance and locality of the thermal effective action, which is a big assumption for them, but they show how it works algebraically from an embedding space.

Lev: If we were trying to run this on real hardware, we'd be looking at how much error correction overhead it takes to enforce this type of symmetry across all those dimensions.

Kai: It’s about taking something abstract in the partition function and showing it has concrete consequences for geometry and gravity in a way that holds for every even dimension.

Mira: The paper strongly implies that the structure of thermal quantum field theories is incredibly rigid, dictated by these universal sum rules.

Lev: It gives us a new way to look at these constraints, linking them to spectral equivalence between different types of spacetime geometries.

Kai: So, the big picture here is that this infinite tower collapses down to one powerful statement about the anomaly in the theory.

Arnav Advant, Harsh Anand, Nathan Benjamin, Abhijit Gadde, Vipul Kumar, Shiraz Minwalla, Jyotirmoy Mukherjee, Sridip Pal, Asikur Rahaman, Pabitra Ray

Indian Institute of Technology Bombay Department of Physics, Powai, Mumbai 400076, India · Tata Institute of Fundamental Research Department of Theoretical Physics, Homi Bhabha Road, Mumbai 400005, India · University of Southern California Department of Physics and Astronomy

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-11-03

Updated: 2026-11-03

Comments: 40 pages: 8 pages main Letter (including references), 2 pages appendices, and 30 pages Supplemental Material; 5 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: The paper determines universal constraints for thermal CFT partition functions by packaging an infinite tower of constraints into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism From Z…

Key concepts

High-temperature expansion
This refers to how a physical system's partition function behaves when its temperature is very high. The paper studies this behavior for twisted CFTs, showing that it always follows a specific hydrodynamic form involving $\omega_i$ and $\beta$, which is remarkably universal across different scenarios.
$\mathbb{Z}_{\kappa+1}$ large conformal diffeomorphism
This is a mathematical transformation that cyclically permutes the thermal circle and the rotation angles of the system. The paper uses this specific symmetry to package an infinite number of constraints into one simple equation, simplifying complex relationships between different physical quantities.
a-anomaly ($a_{2\kappa}$)
The 'a-anomaly' is a specific mathematical quantity that arises in conformal field theories and is related to the structure of the theory. The paper shows that the $\mathbb{Z}_{\kappa+1}$-invariant part of the partition function's logarithm is precisely determined by this anomaly, providing a concrete link between thermal properties and this fundamental CFT concept.

Terminology

Summary

The paper determines universal constraints for thermal CFT partition functions by packaging an infinite tower of constraints into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism From Z to all: cyclic sum rules for thermal CFT partition functions. p. 0

Where the paper says it

TIFR/TH/26-34 From Z to all: cyclic sum rules for thermal CFT partition functions Arnav Advant , 1, ∗ Harsh Anand , 2, † Nathan Benjamin , 3, ‡ Abhijit Gadde , 2, § Vipul Kumar , 2, ¶ Shiraz Minwalla , 2, ∗∗ Jyotirmoy Mukherjee , 2, †† Sridip Pal , 2, ‡‡ Asikur Rahaman , 2, §§ and Pabitra Ray 2, ¶¶ 1Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Technology Bombay, Powai, Mumbai 400076, India 2Department of Theoretical Physics, Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Homi Bhabha Rd, Mumbai 400005, India 3Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA (Dated: November 4, 2026) The high-temperature expansion of twisted S d−1 × S 1 partition functions of CFTd, d = 2κ, has recently been shown to obey an infinite tower of universal constraints. We determine these constraints explicitly and demonstrate that they can be packaged into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism isomorphic to Zκ+1, which cyclically permutes the thermal circle and the rotation angles.

Universal Constraints on the Partition Function

The high-temperature expansion of twisted Sd−1 × S1 partition functions of CFTd, d = 2κ, has recently been shown to obey an infinite tower of universal constraints We determine these constraints explicitly and demonstrate that they can be packaged into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism isomorphic to Zκ+1, which cyclically permutes the thermal circle and the rotation angles. Our equation asserts that the Zκ+1-invariant part of lnZ/β is a constant fixed by the a-anomaly. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We determine these constraints explicitly and demonstrate that they can be packaged into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism isomorphic to Zκ+1, which cyclically permutes the thermal circle and the rotation angles. Our equation asserts that the Zκ+1-invariant part of lnZ/β is a constant fixed by the a-anomaly.

Structure of the Partition Function Expansion

The partition function's high-temperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c′β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω2 i) + Oβ3−d, β → 0 +, ωi fixed. This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4]. p. 0

Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

The analysis of subleading corrections to Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

(2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5]. A systematic analysis of subleading corrections to Eq.

(2) was presented in the recent paper [6]. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A systematic analysis of subleading corrections to Eq. (2) was presented in the recent paper [6].

The Central Universal Equation

The entire infinite tower of constraints is encapsulated, at every κ ≥ 2, by a strikingly simple universal equation involving a Zκ+1 action, generated by omega, which cyclically permutes the thermal circle and angular directions on S2κ−1 × S1. Our central equation asserts the vanishing of the Zκ+1-invariant part of lnZ rot β, 1 + omega + omega2 +. p. 1

Where the paper says it

(6) Our central equation asserts the vanishing of the Zκ+1- invariant part of ln Z rot β , 1 + Ω + Ω2 + . + Ωκ ◦ lnZ rot β = 0 .

.. + omegaκ◦ lnZ rot β = 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

d = 2κ is presented below. One finds lnZ = lnZ rot + lnZ sh , lnZ rot = − 1 β d−1x1x2 .

This, together with a conjectured expression for lnZ shβ, implies a relation involving the a anomaly a2κ. p. 1
Where the paper says it

+ Ωκ ◦ lnZ rot β = 0 . (7), together with our (conjectured) expression for lnZ sh, then implies 1 + Ω + Ω2 + .

Derivation and Verification

The derivation of the central equation in d = 4 is performed by simplifying the measure and using Cauchy’s theorem to show that S◦ lnZ rot β = 0. The exact verification from the Kerr-AdS2κ+1 black hole confirms Eq. p. 4

Where the paper says it

As a consequence, the integral over each of the Ha vanishes, so the same is true of the sum of integrals over appropriately oriented Da, implying Eq. Checks Exact verification from the Kerr-AdS2κ+1 black hole Consider Kerr–AdS in (2κ + 1) bulk dimension with horizon radius r+ and independent rotation parameters ai .

(8) as an exact non-perturbative identity between functions of b20, b21,. p. 1
Where the paper says it

As a highly nontrivial check on the results of this paper, we verify that the partition function of KerrAdS2κ+1 black holes5 obeys the central equation Eq. (8) as an exact non-perturbative identity between functions of b 2 0 , b2 1 , .

.., b2k. The generalization to arbitrary even dimensions is shown by expressing local EFT terms using a common set of scalar variables in the embedding space R2κ,2. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Generalization to d = 2κ dimensions for arbitrary κ The generalization of our discussion to arbitrary even dimensions (see SM, between (S63) and (S157) for all details) proceeds in two steps. We first express all local EFT terms using a common set of scalar variables.

Constraints and S3 Representation Theory

The analysis shows that the condition I(κ)q = 0, ∀q ≥ κ, is equivalent to the constraint Eq. (7). The study views this condition from the lens of S3 representation theory, where the constraint equation (S52) is rewritten as (P1S + P1A)◦ lnZ rot β = 0. p. 2

Where the paper says it

3 we find (see around (S1) in SM) √g4 (v 2) 2 dθ Z β 0 dτ Z 2π 0 dϕ1 Z 2π 0 dϕ2 = βP dz , where P := 2π 2 (b 2 0 − b 2 1 )(b 2 1 − b 2 2 )(b 2 2 − b 2 0 ) . (12) can thus be rewritten as lnZ rot β = P Z b 2 2 b 2 1 dz Ib0,b1,b2 (z) .

This implies that the nontrivial condition is P1S◦ lnZ rot β = 0, lnZ rot β ∈ 2M. p. 1
Where the paper says it

+ Ωκ ◦ lnZ rot β = 0 . (7), together with our (conjectured) expression for lnZ sh, then implies 1 + Ω + Ω2 + .

Physical Interpretation and Generalization

The paper discusses the physical interpretation of Eq. (7) and its relation to bulk terms in the all-orders expansion of lnZ around rational points. p. 5

Where the paper says it

[25–28] for relevant discussion). Relatedly, it was explained in [29] that all ‘bulk’ terms (see [29] for terminology) in the all-orders expansion of lnZ around the rational point (b0, b1 .

The integral over the integration domain D is shown to vanish in arbitrary even dimensions, leading to S◦ lnZ rot β = 0 as claimed. p. 0
Where the paper says it

(2) was presented in the recent paper [6]. The analysis of [6] was largely performed in d = 4; the generalization to CP-preserving1 CFTs in arbitrary even dimensions ∗ 23b1824@iitb.

The final result demonstrates that lnZ rot has the analytic structure expressed in the second of (3) for every even dimension. p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

Cyclic Sum Rules for Black Holes

The cyclic sum rules are evaluated for Kerr-AdS2κ+1 black holes, yielding Eq. (S36) which is our cyclic identity for the anomalous part. p. 0

Where the paper says it

(3) lnZ sh, the universal ‘anomalous shift’ of the partition function, is proportional to the a anomaly a2κ. 2 The ‘non-anomalous’ part, lnZ rot, is non-universal.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

(3) lnZ sh, the universal ‘anomalous shift’ of the partition function, is proportional to the a anomaly a2κ. 2 The ‘non-anomalous’ part, lnZ rot, is non-universal.

This result is in perfect agreement with our general prediction Eq. p. 4
Where the paper says it

G2κ+1 = (−1)κκ! a2κ (38) in perfect agreement8 with our general prediction Eq.

(8). The spectral equivalence between S3 × R and AdS3 × S1 is established, showing that the energy of a scalar on AdS3 × S1 matches that of a conformally coupled scalar on S3 × R. p. 9
Where the paper says it

In SM, we check this equivalence for a free conformally coupled scalar. Analytic continuation to S 3 × R The complex variable change (τ, ϕ1, ϕ2) = iϕ˜ 2, −iτ, ˜ ϕ˜ 1 (C6) turns the AdS3 × S 1 metric in (C4) to ds2 = − dτ˜ 2 + d ˜l 2 4 ˜l(1 − ˜l) + ˜l dϕ˜2 1 + (1 − ˜l) dϕ˜2 2 !

p. 9
Where the paper says it

In SM, we check this equivalence for a free conformally coupled scalar. Analytic continuation to S 3 × R The complex variable change (τ, ϕ1, ϕ2) = iϕ˜ 2, −iτ, ˜ ϕ˜ 1 (C6) turns the AdS3 × S 1 metric in (C4) to ds2 = − dτ˜ 2 + d ˜l 2 4 ˜l(1 − ˜l) + ˜l dϕ˜2 1 + (1 − ˜l) dϕ˜2 2 !

General Even Dimensions

The final result demonstrates that (7) holds for any CP invariant CFT2κ for κ ≥ 2. The integration domain D is given by D = D0 − D1 + D2 −. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Its six corners are labeled by the six unordered pairs (a, b). The four blue shaded triangular faces constitute the domain of integration, while the other four triangular faces are the ‘holes’ Ha.

.. + (−1)κDκ. The topological analysis of the integration domain shows that the integral over any closed κ− 1 dimensional surface vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. p. 4
Where the paper says it

As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes. However, we demonstrate around (S157) of SM that in our physical set up, the ‘holes’ Ha can be chosen to lie in a (κ − 2) dimensional hyperplane, and so are of one lower dimension than the integration regions Da.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes. However, we demonstrate around (S157) of SM that in our physical set up, the ‘holes’ Ha can be chosen to lie in a (κ − 2) dimensional hyperplane, and so are of one lower dimension than the integration regions Da.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes. However, we demonstrate around (S157) of SM that in our physical set up, the ‘holes’ Ha can be chosen to lie in a (κ − 2) dimensional hyperplane, and so are of one lower dimension than the integration regions Da.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes. However, we demonstrate around (S157) of SM that in our physical set up, the ‘holes’ Ha can be chosen to lie in a (κ − 2) dimensional hyperplane, and so are of one lower dimension than the integration regions Da.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes. However, we demonstrate around (S157) of SM that in our physical set up, the ‘holes’ Ha can be chosen to lie in a (κ − 2) dimensional hyperplane, and so are of one lower dimension than the integration regions Da.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes. However, we demonstrate around (S157) of SM that in our physical set up, the ‘holes’ Ha can be chosen to lie in a (κ − 2) dimensional hyperplane, and so are of one lower dimension than the integration regions Da.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes. However, we demonstrate around (S157) of SM that in our physical set up, the ‘holes’ Ha can be chosen to lie in a (κ − 2) dimensional hyperplane, and so are of one lower dimension than the integration regions Da.

Evaluation of the Cyclic Sum

The evaluation of the cyclic sum for Kerr-AdS2κ+1 black holes yields Eq. (S36) which is our cyclic identity for the anomalous part. The contour integration method confirms that the residues sum to zero, leading to Eq. p. 4

Where the paper says it

However, we demonstrate around (S157) of SM that in our physical set up, the ‘holes’ Ha can be chosen to lie in a (κ − 2) dimensional hyperplane, and so are of one lower dimension than the integration regions Da. As a consequence, the integral over each of the Ha vanishes, so the same is true of the sum of integrals over appropriately oriented Da, implying Eq.

(S36). The resulting equation is in perfect agreement with Eq. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In particular, at lowest nontrivial order in xi , both methods yield the single constraint Eq. (S17) in SM, in perfect agreement with Eq.

(8).

Spectral Equivalence

The spectral equivalence between S3 × R and AdS3 × S1 is established, showing that the energy of a scalar on AdS3 × S1 matches that of a conformally coupled scalar on S3 × R. The energy EAdS3×S1 = n + m + 2p + 1 exactly agrees with ES3×R in Eq. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In Appendix B we demonstrate that Eq. (21) simplifies at the special angular velocities ω 2 1 , ω2 2 = e 2πi 3 , e 4πi 3 , where it exactly reproduces Eq.

(S172). The paper concludes that the analytic structure of lnZ rot has the analytic structure expressed in the second of (3) for every even dimension.

Final Constraint Equation

The final constraint equation is S◦ lnZ rot β = 0. This is obtained by summing over p in Eq. (S21), which leads to the cyclic identity for the anomalous part. p. 0

Where the paper says it

(3) lnZ sh, the universal ‘anomalous shift’ of the partition function, is proportional to the a anomaly a2κ. 2 The ‘non-anomalous’ part, lnZ rot, is non-universal.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

(3) lnZ sh, the universal ‘anomalous shift’ of the partition function, is proportional to the a anomaly a2κ. 2 The ‘non-anomalous’ part, lnZ rot, is non-universal.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

(3) lnZ sh, the universal ‘anomalous shift’ of the partition function, is proportional to the a anomaly a2κ. 2 The ‘non-anomalous’ part, lnZ rot, is non-universal.

The derivation of our central equation in every even dimension is demonstrated. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In the rest of this paper, we first present details of our derivations for the simplest nontrivial dimension d = 4, and then sketch generalizations to arbitrary dimensions. Derivation of the central equation Simplifying the measure As explained in [6], the most general local thermal effective action for a d = 2κ dimensional CFT takes the form Eq.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In the rest of this paper, we first present details of our derivations for the simplest nontrivial dimension d = 4, and then sketch generalizations to arbitrary dimensions. Derivation of the central equation Simplifying the measure As explained in [6], the most general local thermal effective action for a d = 2κ dimensional CFT takes the form Eq.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In the rest of this paper, we first present details of our derivations for the simplest nontrivial dimension d = 4, and then sketch generalizations to arbitrary dimensions. Derivation of the central equation Simplifying the measure As explained in [6], the most general local thermal effective action for a d = 2κ dimensional CFT takes the form Eq.

The Role of Integrands

The integrand I, of the thermal effective action, is shown to be a polynomial in the Er and mi. The integral over S2κ−1 for κ ≥ 2 vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. p. 4

Where the paper says it

In the case d = 6, the relative arrangement of the Da and the holes Ha is depicted in Fig. As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In the case d = 6, the relative arrangement of the Da and the holes Ha is depicted in Fig. As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In the case d = 6, the relative arrangement of the Da and the holes Ha is depicted in Fig. As I(Er, m(a) ) is polynomial in m(a) , it follows from Stokes’ theorem and the exactness of the polynomial top form Υ, that the integral of Υ over the closed oriented surface consisting of all Da plus Ha vanishes.

This implies that the RHS of (S38) vanishes when the integration domain D is generalized to D + H where H = Xκ a=0 Ha. p. 3
Where the paper says it

As the integral on the RHS of Eq. (18) vanishes when b1 = b2, it follows that the RHS of Eq.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

As the integral on the RHS of Eq. (18) vanishes when b1 = b2, it follows that the RHS of Eq.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

As the integral on the RHS of Eq. (18) vanishes when b1 = b2, it follows that the RHS of Eq.

The final result is lnZ rot β ∝ 1 Qκ b=1(c0 − cb) × Q. p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

The Role of the Anomalous Shift

The cyclic identity for the anomalous part is S◦ lnZ rot β = (−1)κκ!a2κ. This is our cyclic identity for the anomalous part. p. 0

Where the paper says it

(3) lnZ sh, the universal ‘anomalous shift’ of the partition function, is proportional to the a anomaly a2κ. 2 The ‘non-anomalous’ part, lnZ rot, is non-universal.

The a anomaly a2κ in d = 2κ dimensional holographic CFT is a2κ = π/ (κ−1) 4π! p. 0
Where the paper says it

a2κ     (−1)κ + 1 2 2κ−1 Xκ i=1 Z 1 0 ds Yκ j=1 j̸=i (sxi − 2xj ) 2 xj (xi − xj )     . (3) lnZ sh, the universal ‘anomalous shift’ of the partition function, is proportional to the a anomaly a2κ.

G2k+1.

The Role of the Conformal Factor

The spectral equivalence between S3 × R and AdS3 × S1 is established, showing that the energy of a scalar on AdS3 × S1 matches that of a conformally coupled scalar on S3 × R. The final result is lnZ rot β = (−1)κπ/ (κ−1) 4(κ − 1)! p. 0

Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

G2k+1 = (−1)κκ! p. 1
Where the paper says it

(7), together with our (conjectured) expression for lnZ sh, then implies 1 + Ω + Ω2 + . + Ωκ ◦ lnZ β = (−1)κκ!

p. 1
Where the paper says it

(7), together with our (conjectured) expression for lnZ sh, then implies 1 + Ω + Ω2 + . + Ωκ ◦ lnZ β = (−1)κκ!

a2k.

The Role of the Integration Domain

The integration domain D is given by D = D0 − D1 + D2 −... + (−1)κDκ. The topological analysis of the integration domain shows that the integral over any closed κ− 1 dimensional surface vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. The final result is Z D0 Υ = 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

The Role of the Constraints

The final constraint equation is S◦ lnZ rot β = 0. This is obtained by summing over p in Eq. (S21), which leads to the cyclic identity for the anomalous part. The derivation of our central equation in every even dimension is demonstrated. The final result is S◦ lnZ rot β = 0 as set out to prove. p. 0

Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

The Role of the Integrand Polynomiality

The integrand I, of the thermal effective action, is shown to be a polynomial in the Er and mi. The integral over S2κ−1 for κ ≥ 2 vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. This implies that the RHS of (S38) vanishes when the integration domain D is generalized to D + H where H = Xκ a=0 Ha. The final result is Z D+H Υ = 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the detailed structure of Z(β; ωi) depends sensitively on the particular CFT, it was shown almost two decades ago [1] that its hightemperature behavior always takes the hydrodynamic form lnZ = c ′ β d−1 Yκ i=1 (1 − ω 2 i ) +O β 3−d , β → 0 + , ωi fixed . (2) This remarkably universal result was subsequently rederived using the formalism of ‘equilibrium partition functions’ [2–4], an approach that was further developed and named thermal effective theory in [5].

The Role of the Integrand Structure

The integrand I, of the thermal effective action, is shown to be a polynomial in the Er and mi. The integral over S2κ−1 for κ ≥ 2 vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. This implies that the RHS of (S38) vanishes when the integration domain D is generalized to D + H where H = Xκ a=0 Ha. The final result is Z D+H Υ = 0.

The Role of the Constraints on Polynomials

The final constraint equation is S◦ lnZ rot β = 0. This is obtained by summing over p in Eq. (S21), which leads to the cyclic identity for the anomalous part. The derivation of our central equation in every even dimension is demonstrated. The final result is S◦ lnZ rot β = 0 as set out to prove.

The Role of the Spectral Equivalence

The spectral equivalence between S3 × R and AdS3 × S1 is established, showing that the energy of a scalar on AdS3 × S1 matches that of a conformally coupled scalar on S3 × R. The final result is lnZ rot β = (−1)κπ/ (κ−1) 4(κ − 1)!G2k+1 = (−1)κκ!a2k. The spectral equivalence between S3 × R and AdS3 × S1 is established, showing that the energy of a scalar on AdS3 × S1 matches that of a conformally coupled scalar on S3 × R.

The Role of the Integration Domain Topology

The integration domain D is given by D = D0 − D1 + D2 −... + (−1)κDκ. The topological analysis of the integration domain shows that the integral over any closed κ− 1 dimensional surface vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. The final result is Z D0 Υ = 0. The topological analysis of the integration domain shows that the integral over any closed κ− 1 dimensional surface vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. The final result is S◦ lnZ rot β = 0 as set out to prove.

The integration domain D is given by D = D0 − D1 + D2 −... + (−1)κDκ. The topological analysis of the integration domain shows that the integral over any closed κ− 1 dimensional surface vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. The final result is Z D0 Υ = 0.

The integration domain D is given by D = D0 − D1 + D2 −... + (−1)κDκ. The topological analysis of the integration domain shows that the integral over any closed κ− 1 dimensional surface vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem. The final result is Z D0 Υ = 0. The topological analysis of the integration domain shows that the integral over any closed κ− 1 dimensional surface vanishes as a consequence of Stokes’s theorem.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Ability to derive universal constraints from an infinite tower of relations: The AI can explicitly determine universal constraints by packaging them into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism isomorphic to Zkappa+1, which cyclically permutes the thermal circle and rotation angles.

  2. Capability to verify exact non-perturbative identities: The system can verify that the partition function of KerrAdS2kappa+1 black holes obeys the central equation Eq. (8) as an exact non-perturbative identity between functions of b20, b21,... b2kappa.

  3. Integration of semi-universal expansions in small xi: The AI can independently reevaluate constraints by inserting the small xi semi-universal expansion into Eq. (7), Taylor expanding up to the same order in xi, and equating coefficients to yield identical constraint differential equations.

  4. Constraint counting and characterization: The system can perform a counting of constraints, showing that the condition that I(kappa)q = 0 imposes dq constraints on the polynomial Tq in perfect agreement with the predictions of [6].

  5. Generalization across dimensions: The AI can demonstrate that (7) holds for any CP invariant CFT2kappa for kappa ≥ 2, generalizing the d = 4 (kappa = 2) derivation to arbitrary even dimensions.

  6. Topological analysis of integration domains: The system can analyze the topological structure of the integration domain D and show that its integral vanishes when generalized to D + H where H is a set of holes, as in d=6.

  7. Spectral equivalence mapping: The AI can establish spectral equivalence between S3 x R and AdS3 x S1 by deriving the energy expression EAdS3xS1 = n + m + 2p + 1, which exactly agrees with ES3xR in Eq. (S172).

Abstract

The high-temperature expansion of twisted S d-1 times S 1 partition functions of CFT d, d = 2κ, has recently been shown to obey an infinite tower of universal constraints. We determine these constraints explicitly and demonstrate that they can be packaged into a single equation involving a large conformal diffeomorphism isomorphic to Z κ+1, which cyclically permutes the thermal circle and the rotation angles. Our equation asserts that the Z κ+1-invariant part of Z/β is a constant fixed by the a-anomaly. Our derivation assumes CP-invariance and locality of the thermal effective action, whose structure we constrain using an algebraic formalism starting from embedding space.

Sources

Related papers