Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Violation of Charge-Parity (CP) symmetry is expected in three-body charm decays, and an amplitude analysis is required to understand Final State Interactions (FSI) and CPV mechanisms in the singly Cabibbo suppressed decay process D+ → K-K+π+ CP Violation Context The first observation of CPV in decays of the D meson was from a combined measurement of the CP asymmetry in the D0 → K+K- and D0 → π+π- systems Thus, CPV is expected in D+ → K-K+π+, because the weak vertex is the same as in D0 → K+K-, just as D+ → π-π++ has the same vertex as D0 → π+π-, as seen in Figure 1 However, CPV has not yet been observed in charm three-body decays A full amplitude analysis might be more sensitive to localized CPV in intermediate amplitudes, even in the case of a low integrated asymmetry Amplitude Modeling Methodology The dynamic model proposed here aims at modeling the decay amplitude with a natural inclusion of FSI for SU(3) meson-meson interactions with coupled channels and an isospin decomposition To do so, it factorizes the weak vertex, separated by its different possible topologies The leading order topologies are taken to be just the color allowed (CA) and color suppressed (CS) diagrams The parametrization of the weak vertices is chosen as their CKM content multiplied by a polynomial with free parameters to be fitted to data, with different parameters for vertices with different CKM elements, as in Eq.
Kai: 3 Final State Interaction Formalism The model in
7: departs from extensions of Resonant Chiral Perturbation Theory (ChPTR) to describe, among others, K-K and K-π FSI It defines a kernel K for SU(3) meson-meson interactions as the sum of a contact interaction and resonance exchange(s) The description of the expansion of FSI will be used to introduce the presence of resonances and contact interactions in the model Proof-of-Concept Validation As a proof-of-concept, a toy dataset of the S-wave of the most recent amplitude analysis of D+ → K-K+π+, by the CLEO-c collaboration, was fitted with this model The S-wave model, Eq.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper today titled "Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay". It’s about trying to figure out why charge parity violation is expected in these three-body charm decays, specifically the singly Cabibbo suppressed process D plus to K minus K plus pi plus.
Mira: Right, and this work suggests that we need a proper amplitude analysis because the old Isobar Model just couldn't describe the data well enough for this decay. It points toward Final State Interactions and how charge parity violation might show up in intermediate states.
Lev: I always think it’s about moving beyond just fitting parameters to a simple sum of resonances like in that Isobar Model, which is what they mention on page three of the paper > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay <ref:2611.04915#pg2,inputs for an amplitude analysis of the>.
Kai: Exactly. The paper proposes using inputs from unitary Kaon Kaon and Kaon Pi amplitudes to build a dynamic model instead, which should give us a more complete picture of the decay dynamics.
Mira: It’s interesting because it tries to incorporate Final State Interactions directly into the model, rather than just treating them as external corrections. They factorize the weak vertex based on different topologies, like color allowed and color suppressed diagrams.
Lev: And they use scattering data to constrain those Final State Interaction amplitudes, which then lets them get more precise parameters for the weak vertex itself by fitting it to a toy dataset from a previous analysis of this decay > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
Kai: So, what they did as a proof of concept was fit their model to some S wave data from the CLEO c collaboration, which seems to be a toy dataset based on that most accurate description of this decay we have so far.
Title and authors: Mira: That fit shows that this dynamic model is capable of adequately describing the S wave dynamics in this specific toy sample, which is a good step toward validating the whole approach for analyzing LHCb Run two data <ref:2611.04915#pg2>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, incorporating these two and three body Final State Interactions allows them to dress the weak vertex with all possible interactions, not just some leading ones > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
Kai: That sounds like it gives them a much richer description of how the particles interact after the initial decay happens. So, what do we see from this approach when they apply it to real LHCb data?
Mira: They are hoping this system, which relates the decay rate to invariant masses through equation one > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay, can analyze the dynamics in a way that reveals CPV mechanisms they are looking for.
Lev: The real test is whether this level of detail is actually needed when you run it on real hardware, because we know the overhead really lands somewhere > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
Kai: So, to wrap up, this paper with its title "Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay" shows a way forward by using unitary amplitudes for Kaon Kaon and Kaon Pi interactions in a dynamic model.
Mira: The implication is that we might get a more precise theoretical description of the dynamics, which could help us find any subtle signs of CP violation in these charm decays > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
Lev: And their proof-of-concept validation with that toy dataset suggests this framework is viable, provided the underlying assumptions about those unitary amplitudes hold up when we look at real data > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
Title and authors: Kai: That sets up a clear path forward for how we can use LHCb Run two data to search for CPV in this process, moving beyond the limitations of the Isobar Model > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay <ref:2611.04915#pg2,inputs for an amplitude analysis of the>.
Mira: The paper shows that by including these specific unitary inputs and a dynamic model, we can factorize the weak vertex more completely, which is key to understanding where any CP violation might originate > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
Lev: It's about building a complete description of the dynamics by including all possible two and three body Final State Interactions, which is a big technical lift > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
Kai: So, in short, they’ve built a framework that combines scattering data constraints with a dynamic model to analyze the D plus to K minus K plus pi plus decay using LHCb Run two data > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay <ref:2611.04915#pg2,inputs for an amplitude analysis of the>.
Mira: It opens the door for a more complete description of these charm decays, which is exactly what we need when we're trying to see if CP violation exists in these systems > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
Lev: We just have to make sure that the model doesn't overfit or miss some crucial physics, because that’s always the challenge when you try to build these complex systems from first principles > Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D+ to K-K+ pi+ decay.
The paper's summary: Kai: So we've seen that this paper uses inputs from unitary Kaon Kaon and Kaon Pi amplitudes to build a dynamic model for the D plus to K minus K plus pi plus decay because the old Isobar Model just wasn't good enough.
Mira: Right, it’s essentially saying we need a more complete picture of how these particles interact after they fly apart, incorporating those Final State Interactions directly into the math instead of just adding them on as a correction.
Lev: The authors are factorizing the weak vertex based on different topologies and then dressing those vertices with all possible two and three body Final State Interactions to get a more thorough description of the dynamics.
Kai: What's interesting is how they use scattering data to constrain those Final State Interaction amplitudes, which then lets them get better parameters for the weak vertex by fitting it to a toy dataset from a previous analysis.
Mira: That proof-of-concept fit showed that this dynamic model actually describes the S wave dynamics in that toy sample quite well, which is pretty encouraging for applying it to real LHCb Run two data.
Lev: It means they've got a framework where they can relate the decay rate to invariant masses using an equation, and if things work out, they can use that relationship to look for those CP violation signs in the dynamics.
Kai: So, what this really means for us is that we might get a much more precise theoretical description of these charm decays than we have now because of all this added complexity in the model.
Mira: It opens up a new way to probe charge parity violation because this model is expected to improve the phenomenological description of the amplitude and give us a better result in that amplitude analysis.
Lev: The caveat is that building this kind of complex system means there's still a lot of work ahead, especially getting it ready to run on real hardware without the overhead becoming too much.
Kai: So, they’ve built this framework that combines scattering data constraints with a dynamic model to analyze the D plus to K minus K plus pi plus decay using LHCb Run two data.
Mira: It’s about building a complete description of the dynamics by including all possible two and three body Final State Interactions, which is key to understanding where any CP violation might originate.
Lev: We just have to make sure that the model doesn't overfit or miss some crucial physics because that’s always the challenge when you try to build these complex systems from first principles.
Kai: This paper shows a way forward by using unitary amplitudes for Kaon Kaon and Kaon Pi interactions in a dynamic model.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So we're looking at what this paper suggests we can actually do better than before by using those unitary inputs for Kaon Kaon and Kaon Pi amplitudes in a dynamic model for the D plus to K minus K plus pi plus decay.
Kai: They are proposing incorporating Final State Interactions from unitarized amplitudes and three body effects to fix the limitations of the older Isobar Model, which means we get a model that actually includes those hadronic interactions.
Mira: That's key because it allows the model to include all possible two and three body Final State Interactions by factoring the weak vertex based on different topologies, like color allowed and color suppressed diagrams.
Lev: The authors are using scattering data to constrain those Final State Interaction amplitudes first, which then lets them get more precise parameters for the weak vertex by fitting it to that toy dataset we talked about earlier.
Kai: So they are not just guessing parameters anymore; they’re fixing the FSI amplitudes and deriving the weak vertex parameters from that fit.
Mira: This means we move from a model where you just fit things to a model where you constrain the interactions using known scattering data first, which is much more grounded in physics.
Lev: The improvement here is getting all possible two and three body Final State Interactions included, not just the leading ones they started with.
Kai: It also means we're using inputs from unitary Kaon Kaon and Kaon Pi amplitudes, which should give us a better handle on the dynamics of those meson interactions.
Mira: Ultimately, this whole approach gives us a more complete description of the decay dynamics, which is what we need if we want to find any subtle signs of charge parity violation in these charm decays.
Lev: The caveat with this improvement is that you’re introducing a lot more complexity into the math, so it's going to be computationally demanding when we try to run this on real hardware like our error correction systems.
Kai: It’s about building a framework where we can analyze the decay dynamics by relating the decay rate to invariant masses through an equation and see if that leads us toward CP violation mechanisms.
Mira: So, while it adds significant complexity to the model, it gives us a much more robust tool for probing those subtle CP violation effects in D plus decays.
Lev: The real test is whether this level of detail is actually needed when we run it on real LHCb Run two data, because the overhead really lands somewhere.
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up on this paper, "Unitary KK and K pi inputs for an amplitude analysis of the D plus to K minus K plus pi plus decay," which basically shows how much better we can describe these three body charm decays now.
Mira: It’s a big step because it moves us away from just fitting simple shapes to the data and starts incorporating actual hadronic interactions directly into the model.
Lev: We’ve seen that this framework gives us a more complete description of the dynamics by including all possible two and three body Final State Interactions, which is a huge technical lift.
Kai: It opens up a new way to probe charge parity violation because this model is expected to improve the phenomenological description of the amplitude and give us better results in that amplitude analysis.
Mira: We’re moving toward a more robust tool for analyzing these charm decays, which could help us find those subtle CP violation signs we’ve been looking for.
Lev: The caveat is that building this kind of complex system means there's still a lot of work ahead, especially getting it ready to run on real hardware without the overhead becoming too much.
Kai: So, in short, they’ve built a framework that combines scattering data constraints with a dynamic model to analyze the D plus to K minus K plus pi plus decay using LHCb Run two data.
Mira: It’s about building a complete description of the dynamics by including all possible two and three body Final State Interactions, which is key to understanding where any CP violation might originate.
Lev: We just have to make sure that the model doesn't overfit or miss some crucial physics because that’s always the challenge when you try to build these complex systems from first principles.
Kai: This paper shows a way forward by using unitary amplitudes for Kaon Kaon and Kaon Pi interactions in a dynamic model.
Mira: It opens the door for a more complete description of these charm decays, which is exactly what we need when we're trying to see if CP violation exists in these systems.
Lev: We’ve seen that this framework gives us a more complete description of the dynamics by including all possible two and three body Final State Interactions, which is key to understanding where any CP violation might originate.
Kai: The implications are that we can get a more precise theoretical description of the dynamics, which could help us find any subtle signs of CP violation in these charm decays.
Mira: We’re moving toward a more robust tool for analyzing these charm decays, which could help us find those subtle CP violation signs we’ve been looking for.
Lev: The real test is whether this level of detail is actually needed when we run it on real LHCb Run two data, because the overhead really lands somewhere.
Felipe Cesario Laterza Lopes, Gustavo Alejandro Loachamín Ordo×ñez, Patrícia Camargo Magalhánes
Instituto de F蒕ica Gleb Wataghin, Universidade Estadual de Campinas · Departamento de F蒕ica, Pontifícia Universidade Catolica do Rio de Jeiro
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-11-03
Updated: 2026-11-03
Comments: 43rd International Conference on High Energy Physics (ICHEP 2026). Submitted to Proceedings of Science
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: Violation of Charge-Parity (CP) symmetry is expected in three-body charm decays, and an amplitude analysis is required to understand Final State Interactions (FSI) and CPV mechanisms in the singly…
Key concepts
- Charge-Parity (CP) Violation
- CP violation is a fundamental property where the laws of physics behave differently under charge conjugation (C) and parity inversion (P). In particle decays, observing CPV asymmetries can indicate new physics beyond the Standard Model. This paper explores how this phenomenon might manifest in three-body charm decays like D+ → K-K+π+, which is expected to show CPV.
- Final State Interactions (FSI)
- FSI refers to the interactions between particles after they are produced but before they decay into their final observed state. In this model, FSI are crucial because they describe how mesons like K and π interact with each other. The model incorporates these interactions using unitarized amplitudes to provide a more realistic description of the decay dynamics.
- Amplitude Analysis
- Amplitude analysis is a technique used in particle physics to determine the underlying dynamics of a decay process by fitting theoretical models to experimental data. By relating the decay rate ($ ext{d} ext{ extsc{G}}$) to invariant masses, researchers can extract information about the different contributing amplitudes and their relative strengths, helping to understand the physical processes at play.
- Unitary Amplitudes
- Unitary amplitudes are mathematical descriptions of scattering processes that ensure conservation of probability. The paper uses unitary inputs from K-K and K-π systems to model the FSI. This approach allows the model to accurately describe how mesons interact dynamically, including resonance effects, which is necessary for a complete description of the decay dynamics.
Terminology
Summary
Violation of Charge-Parity (CP) symmetry is expected in three-body charm decays, and an amplitude analysis is required to understand Final State Interactions (FSI) and CPV mechanisms in the singly Cabibbo suppressed decay process D+ → K-K+π+
CP Violation Context
The first observation of CPV in decays of the D meson was from a combined measurement of the CP asymmetry in the D0 → K+K- and D0 → π+π- systems Thus, CPV is expected in D+ → K-K+π+, because the weak vertex is the same as in D0 → K+K-, just as D+ → π-π++ has the same vertex as D0 → π+π-, as seen in Figure 1 However, CPV has not yet been observed in charm three-body decays A full amplitude analysis might be more sensitive to localized CPV in intermediate amplitudes, even in the case of a low integrated asymmetry
Amplitude Modeling Methodology
The dynamic model proposed here aims at modeling the decay amplitude with a natural inclusion of FSI for SU(3) meson-meson interactions with coupled channels and an isospin decomposition To do so, it factorizes the weak vertex, separated by its different possible topologies The leading order topologies are taken to be just the color allowed (CA) and color suppressed (CS) diagrams The parametrization of the weak vertices is chosen as their CKM content multiplied by a polynomial with free parameters to be fitted to data, with different parameters for vertices with different CKM elements, as in Eq. 3
Final State Interaction Formalism
The model in [7] departs from extensions of Resonant Chiral Perturbation Theory (ChPTR) to describe, among others, K-K and K-π FSI It defines a kernel K for SU(3) meson-meson interactions as the sum of a contact interaction and resonance exchange(s) The description of the expansion of FSI will be used to introduce the presence of resonances and contact interactions in the model
Proof-of-Concept Validation
As a proof-of-concept, a toy dataset of the S-wave of the most recent amplitude analysis of D+ → K-K+π+, by the CLEO-c collaboration, was fitted with this model The S-wave model, Eq.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Model improvement for three-body decay amplitude description by incorporating hadronic Final State Interactions (FSI) from unitarized amplitudes and three-body effects to overcome limitations of the Isobar Model. This allows the model to include
hadronic FSI and will, in prospect, introduce three-body effects.
-
Implementation of a dynamic model using inputs from K K and K pi unitary amplitudes to conduct an amplitude analysis using LHCb Run 2 data. This system can analyze decay dynamics by relating the decay rate to invariant masses through equation 1:
dΓ = 1/(2π)3 / (32M3) T squared ds12ds13
. -
Ability to factorize the weak vertex separated by leading topologies and dress these vertices with two and three-body Final State Interactions. This allows for a more complete description of the dynamics by including
all possible two and three-body Final State Interactions.
-
Constraint of FSI amplitudes using scattering data to obtain more precise parametrization of the weak vertex. This enables the model to fix
the parameters of the FSI amplitudes were fixed, and the production parameters of the weak vertex were then obtained from the fit to the toy dataset.
-
Proof-of-concept capability for describing S-wave dynamics in D+ -> K−K+π+ decay using a toy dataset fitted with a model that includes K K and K pi inputs. This demonstrates that
this model is capable of adequately describing the S-wave of this toy sample, obtained from the most accurate description of this decay to date.
-
Potential to indicate signs of Charge-Parity Violation (CPV) in the dynamics of D+ -> K−K+π+ by providing a more precise theoretical description compared to previous models. This is achieved because
this model is expected to improve the phenomenological description of the amplitude and yield a better result in the amplitude analysis.
Abstract
Charge-Parity Violation (CPV) is expected in three-body charm decays. In particular, in the singly Cabibbo suppressed decay process D+ to K-K+π+; in which an amplitude analysis is required to understand the dynamics of Final State Interactions (FSI) and the mechanism that can generate CPV. In this work, we show the prospects of analysing recent data from the Large Hadron Collider beauty (LHCb) experiment at CERN, with a precise theoretical model expected to reveal CPV mechanisms. Previous analyses of the D+ to K-K+π+ decay were unable to satisfactorily describe the data using the Isobar Model. Currently, LHCb has a sample of charmed meson decays with around 100 million events for the D+ to K-K+π+ decay, so a more robust phenomenological model is needed to describe such a large data set. The present model has allowed the inclusion of hadronic FSI and will, in prospect, introduce three-body effects, overcoming some limitations of the Isobar Model, and has all factors necessary to reveal the presence of CPV. To do so, it factorizes the weak vertex separated in leading topologies and relies on extensions of Resonant Chiral Perturbation Theory to describe FSI. As a proof-of-concept, a toy dataset of the S-wave of the most recent amplitude analysis of D+ to K-K+π+, by the CLEO-c collaboration, was fitted with this model. From fits to model-independent parametrizations of scattering amplitudes, the parameters of the FSI amplitudes were fixed, and the production parameters of the weak vertex were then obtained from the fit to the toy dataset, yielding a good agreement between the data and our model.
Sources
- Observation of $C\!P$ violation in charm decays
- Dispersive $\pi\pi\rightarrow K\bar K$ amplitude and giant CP violation in B to three light-meson decays at LHCb
- Multibody decay analyses -- a new phenomenological model for meson-meson subamplitudes
- Global parameterization of $\pi \pi$ scattering up to 2 GeV
- The pion-pion scattering amplitude. IV: Improved analysis with once subtracted Roy-like equations up to 1100 MeV
- Dispersive $\pi K\to \pi K$ and $\pi \pi \to K \bar{K}$ amplitudes from scattering data, threshold parameters and the lightest strange resonance $\kappa$ or $K^*_0(700)$
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses