Cumulative protons and pions at the intermediate energies in the FRAGM experiment

arXiv:2611.04854 · nucl-ex · Submitted 2026-11-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Cumulative protons and pions at the intermediate energies in the FRAGM experiment".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. One of the important research objectives of the FRAGM experiment operating at the TWAC heavy-ion accelerator-storage complex was the study of particle production in the cumulative region The parameterization of cumulative effect used in experiments investigating nucleus-nucleus interactions is discussed Experimental Setup and Measurements The FRAGM experiment was performed at the TWAC heavy-ion accelerator storage complex, designed for accelerate ions from 0.3 to 4.0 GeV/nucleon The experimental setup included a two-stage magneto-optical channel that captured fragments of interactions of accelerator beam ions with an internal target, producing at an angle of 3.5◦ Fragments were registered by a system of scintillation detectors and identified by measuring ionization losses (fragment charge function) and time of flight (fragment mass number function) Fragment momentum spectra were measured by scanning the magneto-optical channel rigidity with a step of 50–100 MeV/c and normalized to the monitor readings of a monitor, which for calculating fragment production cross sections was normalized to known proton production cross section at the fragmentation peak maximum Proton Momentum Spectrum Analysis The differential cross section d2σ/(dpdomega) for proton yield in the fragmentation of carbon nuclei at T0 = 300 MeV/nucleon measured in the FRAGM experiment The peak of this distribution is located in the region 0.8 GeV/c, corresponding to the momentum per nucleon of the incident nucleus Near the maximum, the peak is well described by a Gaussian distribution Extrapolation of this description to a wider region of proton momenta indicates a large deviation from Gaussian dependence and a transition to exponential dependence exp(−x/x0), typical of cumulative processes, where x = p/p0 is the ratio of the proton momentum to the momentum per nucleon of the incident nucleus, and x0 is the cumulative parameter equal to 0.105 Invariant Cross Section Behavior The distribution of the invariant cross section Ed2σ/(p2dpdomega) for proton yield versus their kinetic energy is shown in Fig.

Kai: 2 The data are given for fragmentation of carbon nuclei with initial energy from 300 to 2000 MeV/nucleon

8–11: and are well described by the sum of two exponential functions, where the parameter TC characterizes the cross section decrease in the cumulative region The TC dependence for proton yield in nucleus-nucleus interactions at different incident nucleus energies is shown in Fig.

Mira: 3 together with similar data for proton-nucleus interactions It is seen that the FRAGM experiment data demonstrate growth of the TC parameter in the energy range from 300 to 2000 MeV/nucleon, similar to that observed in proton-nucleus interactions Pion Production Characteristics Experimental data on charged pion yields were measured in the fragmentation of carbon nuclei on a beryllium target at 3.2 GeV/nucleon Pion spectra are well described by an exponential dependence, where the slope parameter TC is close to 50 MeV The results of TC measurements obtained in the FRAGM experiment supplement existing data on the study of cumulative pions and protons in nucleus-nucleus interactions Scaling Behavior and Conclusion The behavior of this parameter for proton-nucleus reactions demonstrates an increase in the energy range from 700 MeV to several GeV, as well as a plateau at high energies, which is called nuclear scaling Nucleus-nucleus interactions exhibit similar behavior of the parameter TC The measurement at maximum energy was performed in the FODS experiment in carbon-carbon interactions at 19.6 GeV/nucleon, with value TC = 48.4 ± 0.7 MeV The FRAGM data significantly supplement world data and demonstrate an increase of this parameter in the intermediate energy range of the incident nucleus, close to that observed in nucleon-nucleus interactions The estimate of the cumulative effect magnitude was made within the phenomenological description of the energy spectrum of cumulative particles as a sum of two exponential functions Acknowledgments and Funding The authors are grateful to the staff of the TWAC accelerator complex and the technical staff of the FRAGM experiment for their great contribution to the measurements The work was performed within the state assignment of NRC «Kurchatov Institute» The funding is listed under Funding References

1: B.

Kai: M.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper titled "Cumulative protons and pions at the intermediate energies in the FRAGM experiment". It looks like one of its main goals was studying particle production in that cumulative region.

Mira: Right, so this paper is diving into how particles are made when you smash heavy ions together, specifically focusing on protons and pions at intermediate energies. The authors discuss how they characterized the cumulative effect used in those kinds of experiments.

Lev: So, what's the main claim here? What are they actually trying to tell us about these interactions?

Kai: Well, they measured differential cross sections for both pion production and proton production from carbon nuclei at an energy of three point two GeV per nucleon when hitting a beryllium target, as well as protons in the range from three hundred MeV to two thousand MeV per nucleon at an angle of three point five degrees <ref:2611.04854#pg1,carbon nuclei at an energy of 3.2 GeV>.

Mira: And they show that the parameterization used for cumulative effects has energy dependencies that are similar to what we see in experiments involving just proton-nucleus interactions, which points towards some nuclear scaling behavior.

Lev: That’s interesting because when you talk about cumulative processes, you're often looking at things kinematically forbidden in simple free nucleon collisions. So linking it back to proton-nucleus data gives a baseline for what we might expect in these heavier systems.

Kai: Exactly, and they use a specific mathematical model for the invariant cross section, showing it can be represented as the sum of two exponential functions with parameters T sub S and T sub C.

Mira: That sum describes both the statistical part, which is related to evaporation nucleons, and the cumulative part itself through those slope parameters T sub S and T sub C.

Lev: I wonder what that means for us in terms of what we need to actually build or run on real hardware? If we're trying to model this, are those two exponential components always the right way to go?

Kai: The paper shows that for proton yield, the differential cross section at T sub0 equals three hundred MeV per nucleon has a peak around zero point eight GeV per nucleon for the momentum per nucleon of the incident nucleus <ref:2611.04854#pg3,the momentum per nucleon of the incident nucleus>.

Paper summary: Mira: Near that peak, they describe it well with a Gaussian distribution, but when you extrapolate that description to wider regions of proton momenta, they see a big deviation from Gaussian dependence and a transition to an exponential dependence described by exp minus x over x sub zero <ref:2611.04854#pg3,deviation from Gaussian dependence and a transition to>.

Lev: So the cumulative parameter is defined as x equals the proton momentum divided by the momentum per nucleon of the incident nucleus, and x sub zero is that cumulative parameter equal to zero point one zero five. That's a concrete number for how they define it there.

Kai: They also show that for proton yield versus kinetic energy, across an initial energy range from three hundred MeV per nucleon up to two thousand MeV per nucleon, the distribution is well described by the sum of those two exponential functions we just talked about <ref:2611.04854#pg1>.

Mira: And they present data on how that parameter T sub C changes with incident nucleus energies from three hundred to two thousand MeV per nucleon, and this dependence is similar to what they see in proton-nucleus interactions <ref:2611.04854#pg1,from 300 to 2000 MeV>.

Lev: It sounds like the key experimental finding is that these cumulative effects follow a pattern similar to simpler proton-nucleus data across a wide range of incident energies. Where does that leave us regarding the physics of these dense nuclear systems?

Kai: They also looked at pion production, measuring charged pion yields from carbon nuclei at three point two GeV per nucleon on a beryllium target, and those spectra are well described by an exponential dependence with a slope parameter T sub C close to fifty MeV.

Mira: That measurement helps supplement the existing data we have on studying cumulative pions and protons in nucleus-nucleus interactions, giving us another constraint on those parameters.

Lev: So, if we translate this into terms for real hardware error correction, what does it mean for the noise floor when you try to model these cumulative effects?

Kai: It means that the model requires a sum of two exponentials to capture the spectrum of cumulative particles accurately. The estimate for the magnitude of that cumulative effect was made by using that phenomenological description.

Mira: So, what does this mean for us when we look at the title, "Cumulative protons and pions at the intermediate energies in the FRAGM experiment"?

Kai: It suggests that understanding these particle yields in this specific energy range is important because it helps us map out how those cumulative effects behave when moving from simpler proton interactions to heavier nucleus-nucleus interactions.

Paper summary: Lev: So, if we take what they found about the scaling behavior—that T sub C increases over the energy range from seven hundred MeV up to several GeV, and then plateaus at high energies—what does that imply for our error correction overhead on future experiments?

Kai: It implies that if you were to design a system based on this understanding, the required complexity of the correction might not increase indefinitely at very high energies; it might level off.

Mira: So, in simple terms, these results confirm that the way we describe cumulative particle production using a sum of two exponentials works consistently across different energy regimes and between different types of nuclear interactions.

Lev: It gives us a reliable structure to test against when we try to apply these models to more complex systems where the assumptions about density fluctuations or rescattering might be even trickier.

Kai: The paper itself notes that they used this sum of two exponential functions for the phenomenological description of the energy spectrum of cumulative particles.

Mira: So, while this isn't a fundamental theory explaining *why* those cumulative effects happen—like multiquark clusters or density fluctuations—it provides a solid, measurable way to describe them experimentally.

Lev: It’s useful for validating the input parameters that we might feed into error correction algorithms when building something like an AI-driven simulation of these processes.

Kai: The paper's limitation is that they rely on this phenomenological description, which is a sum of two exponentials, to estimate the magnitude of the cumulative effect.

Mira: So the method itself is based on assuming that form holds true for describing those particle spectra at intermediate energies.

Lev: And where it stops working, I guess, is when we try to push far beyond that energy range or when the nuclear system becomes much more complex than carbon and beryllium targets.

Kai: So, to wrap up this discussion on the paper "Cumulative protons and pions at the intermediate energies in the FRAGM experiment", we see a consistent behavior for these cumulative particle yields across different experiments at intermediate energies.

Mira: It confirms that nuclear scaling behavior is present in how these cumulative parameters evolve with energy, linking nucleus-nucleus interactions to proton-nucleus ones.

Lev: This gives us a specific functional form to work with when designing error correction schemes for simulations of these nuclear phenomena.

Kai: So, the big picture here is using experimental data to build a reliable phenomenological description for cumulative particle production in these collisions.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've looked at how they modeled cumulative particle production from carbon nuclei in this FRAGM experiment.

Mira: Right, so it boils down to them fitting those particle yields—protons and pions—using a specific mathematical description called a sum of two exponential functions.

Lev: From my side, that means we have a functional form to test against when we try to build error correction for real hardware.

Kai: The paper is about the cumulative protons and pions at intermediate energies. It lays out how they characterized the cumulative effect in those interactions.

Mira: What's important is that they show this behavior—the way these parameters change with energy—is similar to what you see in simpler proton-nucleus reactions.

Lev: That similarity suggests some kind of nuclear scaling is happening, which is a big thing for us when we try to model these complex systems.

Kai: So the main implication is that the method they used provides a consistent way to describe these cumulative particle yields across different energy ranges.

Mira: It gives us a solid tool to check if our assumptions about how particles are produced are holding up at intermediate energies.

Lev: But it's just a phenomenological description, so we have to be careful because the method itself has limits on what it can really describe.

Kai: Exactly, they used that sum of two exponentials to estimate the size of the cumulative effect, but that estimation is based on that specific model fitting.

Mira: So while it doesn't tell us the deep physics behind *why* these effects happen, it gives us a measurable way to understand their magnitude in this energy regime.

Lev: If we want to run this on real hardware simulations, we need to make sure the noise floor isn't overwhelming that specific functional form.

Kai: So, what this means for the world is that we have a better benchmark for studying these dense nuclear collisions using established experimental data.

M.A. Martemianov, *B.M. Abramov, S.A. Bulychjov, I.A. Dukhovskoy, V.V. Kulikov, A.A.Ä Kulikovskaya, M.A.Ä Matsyuk

NRC Kurchatov Institute · EANPO HE Moscow Technological Institute

nucl-ex

Submitted: 2026-11-03

Updated: 2026-11-03

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 69/100

The gist: One of the important research objectives of the FRAGM experiment operating at the TWAC heavy-ion accelerator-storage complex was the study of particle production in the cumulative region The…

Key concepts

Cumulative Region
This refers to the region in particle production where the observed yields are not explained by simple independent particle interactions. Instead, it signifies effects arising from multiple nucleon-nucleon collisions occurring within a single nucleus, leading to enhanced production of particles like protons and pions.
Gaussian Distribution
In the proton momentum spectrum near its peak, the distribution of particles closely follows a Gaussian shape. This suggests that at these specific momenta, the particle emission process can be reasonably described by statistical models where fluctuations are relatively small.
Exponential Dependence (Cumulative Process)
At higher proton momenta, the distribution deviates from Gaussian and transitions to an exponential dependence ($exp(-x/x_0)$). This indicates that as particles gain more momentum, they are influenced by cumulative effects, suggesting a more complex mechanism involving multiple interactions within the nucleus.
TC Parameter
The TC parameter characterizes the decrease in the invariant cross section in the cumulative region. Its dependence on incident energy reveals nuclear scaling behavior, showing an increase from 300 to 2000 MeV/nucleon, which is similar to observations in proton-nucleus interactions.

Terminology

Summary

One of the important research objectives of the FRAGM experiment operating at the TWAC heavy-ion accelerator-storage complex was the study of particle production in the cumulative region The parameterization of cumulative effect used in experiments investigating nucleus-nucleus interactions is discussed

Experimental Setup and Measurements

The FRAGM experiment was performed at the TWAC heavy-ion accelerator storage complex, designed for accelerate ions from 0.3 to 4.0 GeV/nucleon The experimental setup included a two-stage magneto-optical channel that captured fragments of interactions of accelerator beam ions with an internal target, producing at an angle of 3. p. 15◦ Fragments were registered by a system of scintillation detectors and identified by measuring ionization losses (fragment charge function) and time of flight (fragment mass number function) Fragment momentum spectra were measured by scanning the magneto-optical channel rigidity with a step of 50–100 MeV/c and normalized to the monitor readings of a monitor, which for calculating fragment production cross sections was normalized to known proton production cross section at the fragmentation peak maximum

Proton Momentum Spectrum Analysis

The differential cross section d2σ/(dpdomega) for proton yield in the fragmentation of carbon nuclei at T0 = 300 MeV/nucleon measured in the FRAGM experiment The peak of this distribution is located in the region 0.8 GeV/c, corresponding to the momentum per nucleon of the incident nucleus Near the maximum, the peak is well described by a Gaussian distribution Extrapolation of this description to a wider region of proton momenta indicates a large deviation from Gaussian dependence and a transition to exponential dependence exp(−x/x0), typical of cumulative processes, where x = p/p0 is the ratio of the proton momentum to the momentum per nucleon of the incident nucleus, and x0 is the cumulative parameter equal to 0. p. 2105

Invariant Cross Section Behavior

The distribution of the invariant cross section Ed2σ/(p2dpdomega) for proton yield versus their kinetic energy is shown in Fig. 2 The data are given for fragmentation of carbon nuclei with initial energy from 300 to 2000 MeV/nucleon [8–11] and are well described by the sum of two exponential functions, where the parameter TC characterizes the cross section decrease in the cumulative region The TC dependence for proton yield in nucleus-nucleus interactions at different incident nucleus energies is shown in Fig. p. 3 3 together with similar data for proton-nucleus interactions It is seen that the FRAGM experiment data demonstrate growth of the TC parameter in the energy range from 300 to 2000 MeV/nucleon, similar to that observed in proton-nucleus interactions

Pion Production Characteristics

Experimental data on charged pion yields were measured in the fragmentation of carbon nuclei on a beryllium target at 3.2 GeV/nucleon Pion spectra are well described by an exponential dependence, where the slope parameter TC is close to 50 MeV The results of TC measurements obtained in the FRAGM experiment supplement existing data on the study of cumulative pions and protons in nucleus-nucleus interactions

Scaling Behavior and Conclusion

The behavior of this parameter for proton-nucleus reactions demonstrates an increase in the energy range from 700 MeV to several GeV, as well as a plateau at high energies, which is called nuclear scaling Nucleus-nucleus interactions exhibit similar behavior of the parameter TC The measurement at maximum energy was performed in the FODS experiment in carbon-carbon interactions at 19.6 GeV/nucleon, with value TC = 48. p. 54 ± 0.7 MeV The FRAGM data significantly supplement world data and demonstrate an increase of this parameter in the intermediate energy range of the incident nucleus, close to that observed in nucleon-nucleus interactions The estimate of the cumulative effect magnitude was made within the phenomenological description of the energy spectrum of cumulative particles as a sum of two exponential functions

Acknowledgments and Funding

The authors are grateful to the staff of the TWAC accelerator complex and the technical staff of the FRAGM experiment for their great contribution to the measurements The work was performed within the state assignment of NRC «Kurchatov Institute» The funding is listed under Funding

References

[1] B. M. Abramov, P N. p. 0 Alekseev, Yu. p. 7 A. Borodin, S. p. 7 A. Bulychjov, I. p. 0 A. Dukhovskoi, A P Krutenkova, V V Kulikov, M A Martemianov, M A Matsuk and E N Turdakina EPJ Web Conf 66 03001 (2014)

[2] A V Efremov, A B Kaidalov, G I Lykasov, N V Slavin Phys At Nucl 57 874 (1994)

[3] V B Kopeliovich JETP Lett 23 313 (1976)

[4] T Odeh ALADIN Collaboration Phys Rev Lett 84 4557 (2000)

[5] B M Abramov P N Alekseev Yu A Borodin S A Bulychjov I A Dukhovskoi A P Krutenkova V V Kulikov S G Mashnik M A Martemianov M A Matsyuk E N Turdakina Phys At Nucl 79 1419 (2016)

[6] B M Abramov Yu A Borodin S A Bulychjov I A Dukhovskoi A P Krutenkova V V Kulikov A A Kulikovskaya M A Martemianov M A Matsyuk E N Turdakina Phys At Nucl 85 1541 (2022)

[7] N N Alekseev G N Akimov P N Alekseev V N Balanutsa B I Bulykin B A Volkov S V Gaponenko V V Gachurin Yu M Goryachev V N Evtikhovich A S Zhuravlev V P Zavodov V S Zavrazhnov P R Zenkevich N E Ivanov M M Kats et al Phys Part Nucl Lett 1 156 (2004)

[8] B M Abramov Yu A Borodin S A Bulychjov I A Dukhovskoi A B Kaidalov A I Khanov A P Krutenkova V V Kulikov M A Martemianov M A Matsyuk E N Turdakina J Phys Conf Ser 381 012037 (2012)

[9] B M Abramov P N Alexeev Yu A Borodin S A Bulychjov K K Gudima I A Dukhovskoi A P Krutenkova V V Kulikov M A Martemianov M A Matsyuk S G Mashnik E N Turdakina Phys At Nucl 79 700 (2016)

[10] B M Abramov P N Alexeev Yu A Borodin S A Bulychjov K K Gudima I A Dukhovskoi A P Krutenkova V V Kulikov M A Martemianov M A Matsyuk E N Turdakina Phys At Nucl 81 330 (2018)

[11] B M Abramov M Baznat Yu A Borodin S A Bulychjov I A Dukhovskoi A P Krutenkova V V Kulikov M A Martemianov M A Matsyuk E N Turdakina Phys At Nucl 82 623 (2020)

[12] A G Afonin M Yu Bogolyubsky A A Volkov D K Elumakhov V N Zapolsky A A Ivanilov A Yu Kalinin A N Krinitsyn V I Kryshkin N V Kulagin D I Patalakha K A Romanishin V V Skvortsov V V Talov L K Turchanovich and Yu A Chesnokov Nucl Phys A 997 121718 (2020)

[13] J Ero Z Fodor J Franz J Kecskemeti P Koncz Z Kovacs E Rossle C Sauerwein H Schmitt Z Seres and H L Woolverton Nucl Phys A 472 733 (1987)

[14] S Frankel W Frati O Van Dyck R Werbeck and V Highland Phys Rev Lett 36 642 (1976)

[15] N A Burgov M K Vlasov L S Vorobev S A Gerzon Yu T Kiselev G A Leksin A N Martemyanov N A Pivnyuk V L Stolin Yu V Terekhov V I Ushakov and M M Chumakov Sov J Nucl Phys 30 720 (1979)

[16] A Budzanowski M Fidelus D Filges F Goldenbaum H Hodde L Jarczyk B Kamys M Kistryn St Kistryn St Kliczewski A Kowalczyk E Kozik P Kulessa H Machner A Magiera B Piskor-Ignatowicz et al Phys Rev C 82 034605 (2010)

[17] B M Abramov M Baznat Yu A Borodin S A Bulychjov I A Dukhovskoi A P Krutenkova V V Kulikov M A Martemianov M A Matsyuk E N Turdakina Phys At Nucl 84 467 (2021)

[18] D H F Cochran P N Dean P A M Gram E A Knapp E R Martin D E Nagle R B Perkins W J Shlaer H A Thiessen and E D Theriott Phys Rev D 6 3085 (1972)

[19] L S Schroeder S A Chessin J V Geaga J Y Grossiord J W Harris D L Hendrie R Treuhaft and K Van Bibber Phys Rev Lett 43 1787 (1979)

[20] S A Chessin Preprint LBL-14262 (1983)

[21] N A Burgov M K Vlasov L S Vorobev S A Gerzon Yu T Kiselev G A Leksin A N Martemyanov N A Pivnyuk V L Stolin Yu V Terekhov V I Ushakov and M M Chumakov Sov J Nucl Phys 32 423 (1980)

[22] I M Belyaev O P Gavrishchuk P I Zarubin L S Zolin V F Peresedov P A Rukoyatkin A Yu Sukhanov and S V Frolov Sov J Nucl Phys 49 473 (1989)

[23] N A Nikiforov Y D Bayukov V I Efremenko G A Leksin V I Tchistilin Y M Zaitsev S Frankel W Frati M Gazzaly and F C Perdrisat Phys Rev C 22 700 (1980)

[24] E Moeller L Anderson W Bruckner S Nagamiya S Nissen-Meyer L Schroeder G Shapiro and H Steiner Phys Rev C 28 1246 (1983)

[25] I M Belyaev N V Vlasov O P Gavrishchuk L S Zolin and V F Peresedov JINR-P1-90-551 (2611.04854)

[26] Yu D Bayukov V I Efremenko S Frankel W Frati M Gazzaly G A Leksin N A Nikiforov C F Perdrisat V I Chistilin and Yu M Zaitsev Phys Rev C 20 764 (1979)

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved particle production modeling for heavy-ion collisions by incorporating nuclear scaling behavior observed in cumulative processes, as indicated by the energy dependencies of these parameters are analogous to those observed in nucleon-nucleus interactions and indicate the presence of nuclear scaling behavior.

  2. Enhanced ability to predict the energy dependence of the cumulative temperature parameter TC across different incident nucleus energies by utilizing the trend shown in Figure 5, which demonstrates that Nucleus-nucleus interactions exhibit similar behavior of the parameter TC. It increases from 33 to 51 MeV in the energy range from 1 to 3.2 GeV/nucleon.

  3. Better discrimination between particle production mechanisms by using a sum of two exponentials for phenomenological descriptions, specifically by applying the formula Ed3σ/d3p ∼ AS exp(−T/TS) + AC exp(−T/TC) to distinguish between statistical and cumulative terms.

Related papers