Ultraslow diffusion emerging from local symmetry breaking in quenched disorder
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nonlinear Sciences. The day in nonlinear science: chaos, patterns, networks and adaptation.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Ultraslow diffusion emerging from local symmetry breaking in quenched disorder".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Ultraslow diffusion emerging from local symmetry breaking in quenched disorder shows that low disorder densities can induce logarithmically ultraslow diffusion in finite-strength potential landscapes The underlying mechanism originates from local symmetry breaking in particular potential configurations: barrier–well structures form directional channels, causing particles to undergo hierarchical capture, escape, and recapture processes Counterintuitively, when the disorder density reaches the fully disordered limit, the system returns to normal diffusion, revealing a nontrivial, nonmonotonic relationship between disorder density and transport type This mechanism is observed in both nonlinear maps and stochastic systems Mechanism of Ultraslow Transport The paper demonstrates a universal mechanism generating ultraslow diffusion by introducing quenched disordered finite-strength potentials in models, observing a nontrivial nonmonotonic transport transition where particle diffusion in low-disorder-density (sparse) potentials paradoxically becomes slower than that in the fully disordered case (normal diffusion) at extended timescales This phenomenon originates from symmetry breaking in localized potential configurations The specific model Q1 is defined by a piecewise linear lifted map capable of generating normal diffusion, where the dynamical equation is expressed as Q1: xt+1 = M3(xt) − ε∆Vi.
Kai: The disorder density in this system is governed by Bernoulli random variables ξi ∼ B(r), with µi ∼ U U- 1, 1 sampled when ξi = 1.
Mira: Transport Regimes and Transitions The simulation results show distinct transport characteristics based on the disorder density parameter r.
Kai: Specifically, when ε deviates significantly from the critical value, map Q1 exhibits normal diffusion with a reduced diffusion coefficient.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper titled "Ultraslow diffusion emerging from local symmetry breaking in quenched disorder," and the authors are Jin Liu, Rainer Klages, Huihai Wang, and Kehui Sun. It sounds like it’s about how randomness in the environment changes how particles move around.
Mira: Yeah, that's right. The title suggests that this slowing down of diffusion isn't just some general effect of disorder; it comes from something specific called local symmetry breaking in the potential landscapes. I wonder what kind of system they are modeling to show this?
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, when we think about transport in hardware, we usually deal with things that are either deterministic or have very controlled noise. This paper suggests a mechanism where even finite-strength disorder can create this peculiar slowing down at low disorder densities.
Kai: Exactly. It’s not just about the strength of the randomness; it’s about the structure of those random potentials, specifically how barriers and wells are arranged locally, which creates these directional channels we see in the dynamics.
Mira: Right. The key idea here is that you get this ultraslow diffusion because of hierarchical capture and escape processes happening at a local level within the potential configurations they set up.
Lev: If this is true, it means we have to think about how these local structures dictate the long-term behavior of a particle, which is where real hardware simulation gets tricky because you need to model all those fine details.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, the paper summarizes that in finite-strength potential landscapes, low disorder densities can cause logarithmically ultraslow diffusion. This means the mean square displacement grows much slower than normal diffusion over extended timescales.
Mira: That’s a big concept because it implies that for certain configurations of randomness, you don't just get a simple slowing down; you get this specific logarithmic slowing down, which is MSD(t) proportional to logarithm t raised to the fourth power.
Lev: If we were trying to run this on real hardware, the main hurdle would be capturing that exact logarithmic scaling; it suggests a very specific kind of slow exploration that might require extremely long measurement times to see clearly.
Kai: The mechanism they point to is local symmetry breaking in potential configurations, where barrier and well structures form these directional channels, leading to capture escape recapture cycles. It’s about how the particle gets trapped and then slowly finds its way out again in a structured way.
Mira: And they introduce a crucial counterintuitive point: when the disorder density hits the fully disordered limit, normal diffusion is restored at long timescales, which shows a nonmonotonic relationship between disorder and transport type.
Lev: That nonmonotonic aspect is interesting from an error correction view because it means we can’t just assume that more noise always means worse transport; there's a transition point where things get better again.
The paper's improvements: Kai: One of the major contributions they highlight is showing that the coarse-grained channel theory gives an approximate scaling prediction for the mean square displacement, leading to MSD(t) proportional to log t raised to the fourth power. This is supported by a fourth-root linearity test.
Mira: That scaling prediction, MSD(t) proportional to log t raised to four times something, which means MSD divided by t raised to four should be linear in the logarithm of time, is a strong piece of evidence for this logarithmic ultraslow diffusion.
Lev: From an error correction viewpoint, if we have that kind of scaling relationship established over a long time window, it tells us how much precision we need to maintain; you need good data out to those very long times to confirm the linearity in the log t plot.
Kai: They also show how this relates to the typical spatial scale explored, which they predict scales as the square of that typical distance. This means the diffusion is fundamentally set by how far a particle can explore within a given time window, which itself depends on time and disorder density.
Mira: What I find interesting is how they link this back to physical analogies; it suggests this isn't just about slowing down, but about repetitive visitation where long-range displacements are only resumed at the next journey.
Lev: That analogy helps visualize the process of hierarchical exploration, which is something we try to model in error correction because you need to track those different levels of exploration.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up on "Ultraslow diffusion emerging from local symmetry breaking in quenched disorder," the paper shows that low disorder densities can induce logarithmically ultraslow diffusion via local symmetry breaking in potential configurations. This is supported by a scaling prediction of MSD proportional to log t raised to four times something, which they test with a fourth-root linearity test.
Mira: The most important implication for me is that this mechanism explains the nonmonotonic transport transition where sparse disorder can be slower than fully disordered systems at extended timescales, because it’s driven by those directional channels.
Lev: And for us building hardware, it means we have to account for these specific local potential structures when modeling noise; otherwise, our models might predict normal diffusion when the system is actually in this ultraslow regime.
Kai: The paper also points out that the system recovers normal diffusion at long timescales in the fully disordered limit, which suggests a more complete picture than just seeing slowing down as disorder increases.
Mira: It’s a really neat way to think about transport; it moves beyond just saying things are slower and gives us a specific mathematical form for that slowdown based on the underlying symmetry breaking.
Lev: It gives us concrete scaling laws to check against, which is necessary when we try to design error correction codes that need to handle these kinds of slow, structured explorations.
Kai: That’s the gist of it for this paper on "Ultraslow diffusion emerging from local symmetry breaking in quenched disorder."
Mira: Yeah, a solid piece of work showing how local structure dictates transport dynamics in disordered systems.
Lev: Good stuff for thinking about how noise and structure interact.
Jin Liu, Rainer Klages, Huihai Wang, Kehui Sun
School of Physics, Central South University · Centre for Complex Systems, School of Mathematical Sciences, Queen Mary University of London · London Mathematical Laboratory
nlin.CD, cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.stat-mech
Submitted: 2026-10-31
Updated: 2026-10-31
Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 8, L042003 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/cvmv-86bh
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 81/100
The gist: Ultraslow diffusion emerging from local symmetry breaking in quenched disorder shows that low disorder densities can induce logarithmically ultraslow diffusion in finite-strength potential landscapes…
Key concepts
- Local Symmetry Breaking
- This occurs in specific potential configurations where barriers and wells form directional channels. Instead of uniform movement, particles get trapped in these channels, leading to asymmetric capture and escape processes that slow down overall diffusion.
- Directional Channels
- In sparse disorder (low density), the potential landscape develops specific structures—like '$ ext{“ ”}$ and '$ ext{“ ”}$' shaped configurations—that act as one-way highways. Particles preferentially move in one direction along these channels, causing a strong imbalance in movement.
- Nonmonotonic Transport Transition
- The system exhibits an unusual change in behavior based on disorder density. At low disorder, diffusion is ultraslow; however, when the disorder reaches its maximum level (fully disordered), the transport reverts to normal diffusion. This reveals a complex relationship not predicted by simpler models.
- Logarithmic Ultraslow Diffusion
- This describes a specific type of slow movement where the mean-square displacement grows logarithmically over time, following a scaling like $ ext{MSD}(t) ext{ ∼ } ( ext{ln } t)^eta$. This is characteristic of systems where exploration is highly constrained by the underlying potential structure.
Terminology
Summary
Ultraslow diffusion emerging from local symmetry breaking in quenched disorder shows that low disorder densities can induce logarithmically ultraslow diffusion in finite-strength potential landscapes The underlying mechanism originates from local symmetry breaking in particular potential configurations: barrier–well structures form directional channels, causing particles to undergo hierarchical capture, escape, and recapture processes Counterintuitively, when the disorder density reaches the fully disordered limit, the system returns to normal diffusion, revealing a nontrivial, nonmonotonic relationship between disorder density and transport type This mechanism is observed in both nonlinear maps and stochastic systems
Mechanism of Ultraslow Transport
The paper demonstrates a universal mechanism generating ultraslow diffusion by introducing quenched disordered finite-strength potentials in models, observing a nontrivial nonmonotonic transport transition where particle diffusion in low-disorder-density (sparse) potentials paradoxically becomes slower than that in the fully disordered case (normal diffusion) at extended timescales This phenomenon originates from symmetry breaking in localized potential configurations
The specific model Q1 is defined by a piecewise linear lifted map capable of generating normal diffusion, where the dynamical equation is expressed as Q1: xt+1 = M3(xt) − ε∆Vi. The disorder density in this system is governed by Bernoulli random variables ξi ∼ B(r), with µi ∼ U U- 1, 1 sampled when ξi = 1. p. 1
Transport Regimes and Transitions
The simulation results show distinct transport characteristics based on the disorder density parameter r. Specifically, when ε deviates significantly from the critical value, map Q1 exhibits normal diffusion with a reduced diffusion coefficient. p. 1 Conversely, under near-critical sparse disorder, the map undergoes a subtle dynamical transition where the growth of the MSD is strongly suppressed, giving rise to ultraslow diffusion. p. 1
In system Q2 based on the Sinai model, normal diffusion is eventually restored in the fully disordered case r = 1 at longer timescales. p. 2 The microscopic dynamics originate from symmetry breaking in local potential, where directional channels emerge when 0 < r < 1 and are globally eliminated at r = 1. p. 2
Scaling Predictions and Fourth-Root Linearity
The coarse-grained directional-channel theory yields a scaling prediction for the mean-square displacement, leading to MSD(t) ∼ A[ln(t/τ)]4. This scaling is supported by a fourth-root linearity test, where MSD1/4(t) should be asymptotically linear in ln t. p. 3
The typical spatial scale x that the particle can explore within an observation time t is determined by t ∼ TLx, leading to the scaling x(t) ∼ (2r0)−1[ln(t/τ)/ln(∆t)]2. p. 3 This results in the leading scaling of the MSD being set by the square of the typical explored distance, namely MSD(t) ∼ x 2(t). p. 3
Physical Interpretation and Analogy
The resulting ultraslow diffusion is not merely slowed diffusion but logarithmically ultraslow diffusion resulting from the combination of exponential dependence of TLx on Lx and channel imbalance fluctuation Lx ∼ x 1/2 in unbiased quenched disorder. This mechanism parallels social phenomena where long-range displacements are only resumed at the next journey, exhibiting repetitive visitation while demonstrating infrequent and hierarchical exploration of new areas. p. 4 The work breaks with the Sinai model's reliance on potential long-range correlations, as the wells and barriers in this model are i.i.d.
The findings suggest that sparsely distributed wells and barriers mediate qualitative changes in diffusion dynamics via local symmetry breaking. p. 4 This may explain why certain disordered systems exhibit stronger suppression of diffusion at lower disorder densities than at higher ones. p. 4 The mechanism is robust, as the anomalous dynamics persists even when the strength ε exhibits fluctuations. p. 4 The authors conclude that this letter may offer an alternative explanatory perspective for long-standing puzzles in disordered systems. p. 4
REFERENCE
B5, five or more words copied word for word from that page>
B2, five or more words copied word for word from that page>
B3, five or more words copied word for word from that page>
B4, five or more words copied word for word from that page>
B5, five or more words copied word for word from that page>
B6, five or more words copied word for word from that page>
--- Page 1 ---
Ultraslow Diffusion Emerging from Local Symmetry Breaking in Quenched Disorder Jin Liu, Rainer Klages, Huihai Wang, and Kehui Sun are investigating how quenched randomness modifies particle diffusion We show that, in finite-strength potential landscapes, low disorder densities can induce logarithmically ultraslow diffusion The underlying mechanism originates from local symmetry breaking in particular potential configurations: barrier–well structures form directional channels, causing particles to undergo hierarchical capture, escape, and recapture processes A coarse-grained channel theory yields an approximate scaling prediction for the mean-square displacement Counterintuitively, when the disorder density reaches the fully disordered limit, the system returns to normal diffusion, revealing a nontrivial, nonmonotonic relationship between disorder density and transport type This mechanism is observed in both nonlinear maps and stochastic systems
Imagine embarking on a long-distance journey where, upon reaching your destination, you engage in a series of localized activities (like lodging and sightseeing) that may trigger smaller-scale movements (e.g., commuting between hotels and restaurants) Remarkably, despite continuous progression of activities, macroscopic analysis reveals that the spatial expansion of your trajectory exhibits gradual deceleration in displacement over time This phenomenon aligns with the experimental findings of Song et al. p. 0 [1], demonstrating that the mean square displacement (MSD) in long-term human mobility patterns follows an ultraslow diffusion characterized by MSD(t) ∼ (ln t) α This law is found in a wealth of systems, including relaxation processes in Anderson insulators [2], local structural relaxation in DNA [3], paper crumpling under heavy pistons [4], frictional strengthening [5], grain compactification [6], glass systems [7], and fractional dynamics in languages [8]
Currently, theoretical studies on ultraslow diffusion remain relatively scarce and are predominantly modeled through stochastic systems The mechanisms involve the introduction of complex spatiotemporal structures, exemplified by distributed-order fractional derivative models [9, 10], structural derivative models [11, 12], and comb models [13–15], as well as super-heavy-tailed waiting time distributions as implemented in enhanced continuoustime random walk models [16–19] Alternatively, onedimensional maps represent the simplest dynamical systems capable of generating diffusion when defined on infinite domains, typically by periodic continuation These maps emerged as simplified representations to capture essential characteristics of driven damped particle motion in a periodic potential [20–22] While time-dependent periodic potentials represent one limiting case of this scenario, the opposite extreme—disordered potentials—remains understudied in chaotic dynamical systems theory [32, 33] Across multiple physical domains, it is well-established that static randomness can profoundly alter macroscopic quantities Nevertheless, developing deterministic map versions capable of producing ultraslow diffusion remains highly challenging
To date, meaningful progress has been achieved only in studies by Radons [37, 38] and Dr¨ager and Klafter [39] The former demonstrated suppressed diffusion equivalent to the Sinai model [40], requiring the overcoming of increasingly deeper Brownian path random potentials in the continuous limit The latter revealed through a fully deterministic one-dimensional lifted map that ultraslow diffusion originates from the anomalously broad distribution of waiting times in the corresponding random walk process, which under specific conditions can reproduce Sinai’s classical results
In this Letter, we demonstrate a universal mechanism generating ultraslow diffusion By introducing quenched disordered finite-strength potentials in our models (both deterministic and stochastic versions)—fundamentally different from the deep potential well mechanism underlying Golosov localization [41, 42] in Sinai’s and Radons’s works—we observe an unexpected nontrivial nonmonotonic transport transition where particle diffusion in low-disorder-density (sparse) potentials (corresponding to ultraslow diffusion) paradoxically becomes slower than that in the fully disordered case (normal diffusion) at extended timescales We establish that this phenomenon originates from symmetry breaking in localized potential configurations
A piecewise linear lifted map capable of generating normal diffusion [44–47] is defined as Ma(xt) = axt, 0 ≤ xt 0, (1) extended to the real domain R through the periodic condition Ma(xt+1) = Ma(xt)+1
--- Page 2 ---
Reduced Escape Probability Unbiased Region Hinder Penetration Probability εVi i (a) (b) (c) (d) i x t+1 εV r = 0.4, 0.33-ε-ε-3-2-1 0 1 2 3 x t-3-2-1 0 1 2
Multilayer Escape Recurrent Trapping
t x t i εV r = = (a) (b) (c) (d)
FIG. 1: Schematic illustration of the chaotic map modeling under quenched disorder and its representative particle trajectories The potential landscape comprises static random barriers and wells with finite-strength ε (upper panel) The wells and barriers in map (2) are modeled by vertically shifting the function profiles within adjacent lattice sites thereby modifying particle escape probabilities in corresponding regions Each well or barrier occurs with a probability r/2 Defining this system as map Q1, its dynamical equation can be expressed as Q1: xt+1 = M3(xt) − ε∆Vi, where i = [xt] denotes the lattice site index, and ∆Vi = Vi+1−Vi represents the potential gradient within the i-th lattice site The disorder density is governed by Bernoulli random variables ξi ∼ B(r): When ξi = 1 (occurring with probability r), µi ∼ U U- 1, 1 is uniformly sampled, where-1 corresponds to wells and 1 to barriers Since every two consecutive lattice sites form a single potential unit, this sampling occurs exclusively at evenM S D(t) 10 5 2
r = 0 r = = 0.4, 0.2 ε r = = 0.4, 0.33 ε r = =
crossing point
--- Page 3 ---
FIG. 2: MSD and nonmonotonic transport transition in map Q1 When the potential strength is far from the critical value, Q1 exhibits normal diffusion In contrast, under near-critical sparse disorder, the growth of the MSD is strongly suppressed and displays ultraslow diffusion Counterintuitively, in the fully disordered limit r = 1, the system recovers normal diffusion at long timescales
--- Page 4 ---
FIG. 3: The ultraslow diffusion mechanism in our stochastic system Q2 differs from the Sinai model This correspondence originates from directional channels formed by symmetry breaking in local potential configurations within 0 < r < 1 (boxed region, upper panel) Conversely, at r = 1, these directional channels are globally eliminated (lower panel), and the system reverts to normal diffusion markably, normal diffusion is eventually restored in the fully disordered case r = 1 (purple stars) At sufficiently long times, the MSD for r = 1 exceeds that observed for r < 1, consistent with the observations in Figs. p. 2 1(b)–(d): an intriguing nontrivial transition emerges only in sparse disordered potentials
--- Page 5 ---
FIG. 4: Fourth-root linearity test of the logarithmic fourthpower scaling If Eq. p. 3 p. 3 (8) holds, then MSD1/4(t) should be asymptotically linear in ln t
--- Page 6 ---
FIG. 5: For the ultraslow diffusion parameter sets, MSD1/4(t) exhibits good linearity with ln t over the long-time window t ∈ [1. p. 4 p. 40 × 10 5, 1.0 × 10 7]
--- Page 7 ---
FIG. 6: The correspondence between the MSD of system Q2 and map Q1 This correspondence substantiates that the stochastic system Q2 shares identical underlying mechanisms with our deterministic framework
--- Page 8 ---
FIG. 7: The microscopic dynamics originate from symmetry breaking in local potential At r = 1, the system Q2 exhibits symmetric ascent/descent profiles across all effective wells [lower panel of Fig. p. 2 p. 2 3(d)] ensuring equal bidirectional escape probabilities (denoted as p← = p→) Although the system initially demonstrates transient ultraslow diffusion [with the timescale determined by the mean first-passage time ⟨T∗⟩ ≈ 3(2+c)4(1−2e)] for Fig. p. 2 p. 2 3(c), it eventually recovers to normal diffusion over extended evolution Conversely, when 0 < r < 1, local symmetry breaking characterized by “ ” and “ ” shaped potential configurations emerges [an example is illustrated by the boxed region in the upper panel of Fig. p. 3 p. 3 3(d)] When particles traverse such regions, the local escape probability in one direction becomes significantly dominant over the reverse process, as exemplified in the upper panel of Fig. p. 3 p. 3 3(d), where leftward escape probability far exceeds the rightward counterpart (i. p. 3 p. 3e., p← ≫ p→)
--- Page 9 ---
FIG. 4: Fourth-root linearity test of the logarithmic fourthpower scaling If Eq. (8) holds, then MSD1/4(t) should be asymptotically linear in ln t
--- Page 9 ---
FIG. 5: For the ultraslow diffusion parameter sets, MSD1/4(t) exhibits good linearity with ln t over the long-time window t ∈ [1.0 × 10 5, 1.0 × 10 7]
--- Page 9 ---
FIG. 6: The correspondence between the MSD of system Q2 and map Q1 This correspondence substantiates that the stochastic system Q2 shares identical underlying mechanisms with our deterministic framework
--- Page 9 ---
FIG. 7: The microscopic dynamics originate from symmetry breaking in local potential At r = 1, the system Q2 exhibits symmetric ascent/descent profiles across all effective wells [lower panel of Fig. 3(d)] ensuring equal bidirectional escape probabilities (denoted as p← = p→) Although the system initially demonstrates transient ultraslow diffusion [with the timescale determined by the mean first-passage time ⟨T∗⟩ ≈ 3(2+c)4(1−2e)] for Fig. 3(c), it eventually recovers to normal diffusion over extended evolution Conversely, when 0 < r < 1, local symmetry breaking characterized by “ ” and “ ” shaped potential configurations emerges [an example is illustrated by the boxed region in the upper panel of Fig. 3(d)] When particles traverse such regions, the local escape probability in one direction becomes significantly dominant over the reverse process, as exemplified in the upper panel of Fig. 3(d), where leftward escape probability far exceeds the rightward counterpart (i.e., p← ≫ p→)
--- Page 9 ---
FIG.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI systems can accurately model particle diffusion in disordered environments by implementing a coarse-grained channel theory that predicts a logarithmic ultraslow diffusion scaling MSD(t) ∼ (ln t)α for finite-strength potential landscapes.
-
The improved system can predict nonmonotonic transport transitions where particle diffusion in sparse potentials paradoxically becomes slower than that in the fully disordered case at extended timescales, identifying this phenomenon as originating from
symmetry breaking in localized potential configurations.
-
AI systems can be enhanced to recognize and categorize specific directional channel configurations, such as “ ” and “ ” shaped potential configurations, which mediate transport through
capture–escape–recapture cycles
leading to continuous slowdown of diffusive spreading. -
The system can be tuned to recover normal diffusion at long timescales in fully disordered limits (r = 1), providing a more nuanced understanding than models relying solely on Sinai-like mechanisms that show systematic decrease with increasing disorder density.
-
AI systems can utilize the logarithmic fourth-power scaling prediction MSD(t) ∼ A[ln(t/τ)]4 to accurately characterize the anomalous diffusion observed in sparse disordered potentials, ensuring that long-time measurements are correctly interpreted as linear in ln t when plotted on a logarithmic time axis.
Related papers
- PRISM: Unifying multiphysics optothermal transport and identifiability-guided inference for nanoscale thermal metrology
- Quantifying The Complex Spatiotemporal Chaos of Cardiac Fibrillation in Ionic Models Across Parameter Regimes
- Modal interactions in strongly nonlinear coupled oscillators with closely spaced modes and nonclassical damping distribution
- An active Lorentz gas: walking droplets in periodic media
- Stochastic-layer width as an order parameter for the integrability-to-chaos transition in the bouncer model
- When more data become less informative: Finite-precision periodicization and collapse of forecast-error Lyapunov estimates