Estimating cosmogenic backgrounds in nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Estimating cosmogenic backgrounds in nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Estimating cosmogenic backgrounds in nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA is a detailed evaluation of expected cosmogenic background rates for nEXO if placed at its preferred underground host site, SNOLAB, comparing results from Geant4 and FLUKA Monte Carlo simulations The only isotope of concern for nEXO is 137Xe, produced by neutron capture on the xenon target Cosmogenic backgrounds are those due to muon-induced interactions with local material leading directly or indirectly to energy deposits in detector media Here we refer to nuclides produced via mechanisms other than muon induced neutron capture as spallation products, for instance, those arising from nuclear fragmentation, isotopes of I and Te produced by removing nucleons from Xe, or those from charge-exchange interactions like 136Xe(p, n)136Cs Backgrounds of concern to nEXO are those which contribute events with energies in the EROI that appear as single-sited (SS) deposits occurring throughout the LXe thereby being indistinguishable in their event topology from 0νββ Simulation Setup and Muon Flux The simulations were performed with dedicated Geant4 v10.7 and FLUKA v4-5.0 Monte Carlo (MC) implementations that were run with nEXO in the SNOLAB Cryopit The muon energy distribution at SNOLAB is assumed to follow that described by Lipari and Stanev in
24: which is a function of the zenith angle via the slant-depth, h = h0/ cos θ, where h0 is the approximately 6 km water equivalent vertical depth of SNOLAB Muon energies were sampled up to 25 TeV, producing a mean energy of 363 GeV The procedure for simulating the muon flux at SNOLAB followed similar work done for EXO-200
12: Radionuclide Selection and Filtering Of all the isotopes produced through cosmogenic activation, only a subset are “radionuclides of concern” (ROCs) ROCs are defined as the cosmogenic radionuclides that result in more than 0.01 SS-like events in the EROI, within the central 2 000 kg of LXe, per year The prompt muon veto rejects signals from neutron capture cascades and very-shortlived radioisotopes with half-lives shorter than 100 ms A fiducial volume cut can entirely eliminate their β-decay background contribution as electrons with MeV energies are strongly attenuated by the LXe with sub-cm mean ranges Mitigation Strategy and Sensitivity Impact A light-only veto scheme using 137Xe as a case study is proposed to mitigate the negative effect of ROCs on nEXO sensitivity This scheme achieves a rejection efficiency of (92.4 ± 4.0)% for 137Xe events The total fraction of false tags is ∼ 9%, resulting in the average amount of deadtime due to false coincidences being ≈ 30 min yr−1 Using the sensitivity-vs-137Xe-rate scaling relation calculated for nEXO in Ref
4: , we find that the veto improves the sensitivity by ∼20% This work supports the previously published assumptions in
4: on the cosmogenic backgrounds to nEXO, post-veto Consequently we report no change to the forecasted sensitivity of nEXO The overall expected veto efficiency is predicted to be (92.4 ± 4.0)% using this veto scheme TABLE II: Production rates of ROC in both FLUKA and Geant4 listed with statistical and systematic uncertainties, respectively.
Kai: Nuclide Half-life Region Energy
keV: FLUKA Rate
yr−1: Geant4 Rate
yr−1: TABLE IV: Full isotope production rates from Geant4 and FLUKA.
Mira: Nuclide Half-life Decay energy (keV) FLUKA yearly FLUKA error G4 yearly G4 error TABLE V: Post-neutron capture γ-ray de-excitation energies as reconstructed only from light yields in the TPC.
Kai: Light-only reconstructed energy
MeV: dN/dE
MeV: FIG.
Paper summary: Kai: So, looking at this paper "Estimating cosmogenic backgrounds in nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA," the main thrust is establishing the expected background rates for nEXO when it's placed at SNOLAB by comparing Geant4 and FLUKA simulations.
Mira: They conclude that of all the isotopes produced through cosmogenic activation, only one hundred thirty-sevenXe is really a radionuclide of concern for nEXO, defined by having more than zero point zero one single sided events in the energy region of interest per year within the central two thousand kilograms of liquid xenon <ref:2611.00529#pg2>.
Lev: The overall implication they draw from this work is that their proposed light-only veto scheme using one hundred thirty-sevenXe as a case study achieves a rejection efficiency of ninety point two four plus or minus four point zero percent, and this results in an improvement in sensitivity by about twenty percent <ref:2611.00529#pg2>.
Kai: So to summarize the title "Estimating cosmogenic backgrounds in nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA," it's basically showing how you model the cosmic ray environment at that specific site using two different physics codes and then proposing a practical filter to reduce the most important background source.
Mira: It supports the previous assumptions about cosmogenic backgrounds for nEXO, which means they report no change to their forecasted sensitivity for nEXO based on these calculations.
Lev: That's interesting because it means that despite building this veto strategy, the paper is confirming what they thought was already there in their earlier work regarding these background estimates.
Kai: It confirms that the filtering method works as expected with a ninety point two four plus or minus four point zero percent efficiency for one hundred thirty-sevenXe events, based on their simulation framework <ref:2611.00529#pg2>.
Mira: And the final prediction is that the overall expected veto efficiency using this scheme is ninety point two four plus or minus four point zero percent.
Lev: So for someone listening, it means that if you're planning an nEXO experiment at SNOLAB, you can expect a background reduction of about twenty percent by implementing this specific filtering technique.
Kai: That's the core message of this work: modeling the environment with Geant4 and FLUKA leads to a concrete prediction about how much you can actually improve your sensitivity for searching for zero nu beta beta <ref:2611.00529#pg2>.
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at estimating cosmogenic backgrounds for nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA.
Mira: Basically, they compared the results from both simulation codes to see what kind of noise we expect if we put nEXO there.
Lev: The main thing they focus on is the isotope one hundred thirty seven xenon, which comes from neutron capture on that xenon target.
Kai: And they get pretty specific about how many single sided events per year you need to worry about for that background to be an issue.
Mira: They define a radionuclide of concern as anything producing more than zero point zero one single sided events in the energy region of interest per year within the central two thousand kilograms of liquid xenon.
Lev: That filtering process they use, it's a light only veto scheme using one hundred thirty seven xenon as an example.
Kai: And that veto scheme works pretty well; it achieves a rejection efficiency around ninety two point four plus or minus four point zero percent for those one hundred thirty seven xenon events.
Mira: So the authors are saying this supports what they thought was already true about the cosmogenic backgrounds for nEXO.
Lev: They actually report no change to their forecasted sensitivity because of these calculations.
Kai: It means if you're planning an experiment, the expected background noise level remains as predicted before this analysis.
Mira: The whole point is that this gives us a solid estimate of what we are fighting against before we even start building things.
Lev: What’s interesting for me is seeing how much overhead that veto adds; it introduces about thirty minutes per year of dead time due to false coincidences, which you have to factor in when you look at real hardware constraints.
Kai: So the next thing we need to figure out is how this background estimate changes if we consider other isotopes besides one hundred thirty seven xenon.
R. Ross, S. Al Kharusi, T. Brunner, S. Sangiorgio, E. Caden, U. Wichoski, B. G., Lenardo B., Mng D., A Odian A., A Piepke S., S Thibado A., A Pocar R., R Saldanha L J Kaufman, E. A. Allen E, A Amy, I. J. Arnquist A, A Atencio V Belov A, A Bolotnikov J Breslin P A Breur J Brodsky E Brown E van Bruggen B Burnell D Cesmecioglu M Chiu R Collister E Coulthard T Daniels L Darroch X Defay R DeVoe Y Ding M J Dolinski B Eckert A Emara W Fairbank J Farine B T Foust D Gallacher N Gallice A Gaur W Gillis F Girard R Gornea G Gratta C Hardy J Hasi M Heffner E Hein J D Holt A Iverson T V John A K Karelin D K Keblbeck P Knauss A Kuchenkov K S Kumar T Lange A Larson M B Latif S C Lavoie K G Leach A Lennarz D S Leonard H Lewis X Li G Li C Licciardi R Lindsay R MacLellan S Majidi C Malbrunot M Marquis J Masbou M Medina-Peregrina S Mngonyama D C Moore X E Ngwadla K Ni I Nitu A Nolan J C Nzobadila Ondze J L Orrell G Ortega C Overman L Pagani H Peltz Smalley A Pena-Perez J.-F. Pratte R Rai H Rasiwala D Ray A Remnant S Rescia F Reti`ere G Richardson S Rottoo S J Sekula T Shetty L Si V Stekhanov X Sun Tanmay A Todd M Yvaine T Totev S Triambak O A Tyuka S Viel M P Watts M Wehrfritz S Wilde M Worcester H Xu L Yang M Yu O Zeldovich J Zhao
Physics Department, McGill University · TRIUMF · Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory · SNOLAB · School of Natural Sciences, Laurentian University · Department of Physics, Carleton University · SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory · Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Alabama · Amherst Center for Fundamental Interactions and Physics Department, University of Massachusetts Amherst · Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Richland WA · SUBATECH Nantes Universit´e IMT Atlantique CNRS/IN2P3 Nantes · Department of Physics, Drexel University Philadelphia PA
nucl-ex
Submitted: 2026-10-31
Updated: 2026-10-31
Comments: 11 Pages (20 with appendices), 8 Figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
Importance score: 82/100
The gist: Estimating cosmogenic backgrounds in nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA is a detailed evaluation of expected cosmogenic background rates for nEXO if placed at its preferred underground host site…
Key concepts
- Cosmogenic backgrounds
- These are unwanted signals in a detector caused by interactions with cosmic rays, specifically muons. They include spallation products or charge-exchange reactions that create isotopes within the detector material, which can mimic the signal of interest.
- Radionuclides of Concern (ROCs)
- ROCs are specific cosmogenic isotopes that produce more than 0.01 single-sided events per year in a central region of the LXe. These are considered problematic because they look like genuine neutrino signals and can obscure the true physics measurement.
- Light-only veto scheme
- This is a proposed method to reduce background noise by only looking at light signals reconstructed from the TPC, rather than using a full veto system. For $^{137}$Xe, this scheme achieves about 92.4% rejection efficiency and reduces false coincidences to about 30 minutes per year.
- Sensitivity improvement
- The proposed veto strategy is shown to enhance nEXO's sensitivity by approximately 20%. This means that with the veto in place, the experiment can exclude a wider range of neutrino oscillation parameters for a given level of background noise.
Terminology
Summary
Estimating cosmogenic backgrounds in nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA is a detailed evaluation of expected cosmogenic background rates for nEXO if placed at its preferred underground host site, SNOLAB, comparing results from Geant4 and FLUKA Monte Carlo simulations The only isotope of concern for nEXO is 137Xe, produced by neutron capture on the xenon target
Background Sources and Identification
Cosmogenic backgrounds are those due to muon-induced interactions with local material leading directly or indirectly to energy deposits in detector media Here we refer to nuclides produced via mechanisms other than muon induced neutron capture as spallation products, for instance, those arising from nuclear fragmentation, isotopes of I and Te produced by removing nucleons from Xe, or those from charge-exchange interactions like 136Xe(p, n)136Cs Backgrounds of concern to nEXO are those which contribute events with energies in the EROI that appear as single-sited (SS) deposits occurring throughout the LXe thereby being indistinguishable in their event topology from 0νββ
Simulation Setup and Muon Flux
The simulations were performed with dedicated Geant4 v10.7 and FLUKA v4-5. p. 0 Estimating cosmogenic backgrounds in nEXO at SNOLAB using Geant4 and FLUKA
R. Al Kharusi,1, a T.Where the paper says it
Radionuclide Selection and Filtering
Of all the isotopes produced through cosmogenic activation, only a subset are “radionuclides of concern” (ROCs) ROCs are defined as the cosmogenic radionuclides that result in more than 0.01 SS-like events in the EROI, within the central 2 000 kg of LXe, per year The prompt muon veto rejects signals from neutron capture cascades and very-shortlived radioisotopes with half-lives shorter than 100 ms A fiducial volume cut can entirely eliminate their β-decay background contribution as electrons with MeV energies are strongly attenuated by the LXe with sub-cm mean ranges
Mitigation Strategy and Sensitivity Impact
A light-only veto scheme using 137Xe as a case study is proposed to mitigate the negative effect of ROCs on nEXO sensitivity This scheme achieves a rejection efficiency of (92.4 ± 4.0)% for 137Xe events The total fraction of false tags is ∼ 9%, resulting in the average amount of deadtime due to false coincidences being ≈ 30 min yr−1 Using the sensitivity-vs-137Xe-rate scaling relation calculated for nEXO in Ref [4], we find that the veto improves the sensitivity by ∼20%
Conclusion
This work supports the previously published assumptions in [4] on the cosmogenic backgrounds to nEXO, post-veto Consequently we report no change to the forecasted sensitivity of nEXO The overall expected veto efficiency is predicted to be (92.4 ± 4.0)% using this veto scheme
TABLE II: Production rates of ROC in both FLUKA and Geant4 listed with statistical and systematic uncertainties, respectively.
Nuclide Half-life Region Energy [keV] FLUKA Rate [yr−1] Geant4 Rate [yr−1]
TABLE IV: Full isotope production rates from Geant4 and FLUKA.
Nuclide Half-life Decay energy (keV) FLUKA yearly FLUKA error G4 yearly G4 error
TABLE V: Post-neutron capture γ-ray de-excitation energies as reconstructed only from light yields in the TPC.
Light-only reconstructed energy [MeV] dN/dE [MeV]
FIG. 7: True, accidental, and total trigger counts per year estimated using the light-only de-excitation γ cascade veto scheme described herein. p. 8 35
Probability per bin
Total: ¹ = 4:38/yr
Accidental: ¹ = 1:13/yr
True Xe-137: ¹ = 3:25/yr
FIG. True, accidental, and total trigger counts per year
estimated using the light-only de-excitation γ cascade veto
scheme described herein.Where the paper says it
Total: 1 = 4:38/yr Accidental: 1 = 1:13/yr True Xe-137: 1 = 3:25/yr
FIG. 8: Median nEXO sensitivity to the 0νββ half life as a function of the number of 137Xe atoms in the full LXe volume shown pre- and post-veto. p. 8 s
e
n
sitivit
y
t
o
T
0º
1=2
[£
1
0
28 y
r]
Geant4 pre
Geant4 post
FLUKA pre
FLUKA post
FIG. Median nEXO sensitivity to the 0νββ half life as a
function of the number of 137Xe atoms in the full LXe volume shown pre- and post-veto.Where the paper says it
The grey curve indicates the median exclusion sensitivity from 5000 simulated datasets for a given 137Xe background level, while the band indicates 1σ coverage obtained by bootstrapping 50% of the datasets and recalculating the median in 20,000 trials
**TABLE IV: Full isotope production rates from Geant4 and FLUKA.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved background modeling by using combined Geant4 and FLUKA rates to estimate activation rates, as this is done by taking
the simple mean of both the Geant4 and FLUKA rates when there are nonzero production rates from both simulations.
-
Enhanced cosmogenic background rejection capability through a light-only veto scheme, which can achieve an
anticipated 92.4 ± 4.0% efficiency
for removing 137Xe signals using only the TPC response from neutron capture de-excitations. -
Refined sensitivity evaluation by quantifying the impact of the veto on nEXO's performance, as this analysis
improves the sensitivity by 20%
and enables reaching a projected half-life sensitivity of(1.35 ± 0.02) · 10 28 yr.
-
Development of a refined muon veto strategy by analyzing the
combinatorial effect
shown in Figure 3, which shows that "> 99 % of muons producing ROC have impact parameters ≤ 3.5 m," allowing for rejection of most background-inducing muons.
Abstract
The nEXO experiment was designed to search for neutrinoless double beta decay in the isotope 136 Xe, using a five-tonne, isotopically-enriched liquid xenon time projection chamber (TPC). To meet nEXO's sensitivity goal, significant effort is placed on background mitigation strategies. Here, we evaluate the expected cosmogenic background rate for nEXO if placed at its preferred underground host site, SNOLAB. A comparison of results from Geant4 and FLUKA Monte Carlo simulations are presented. We perform detailed Monte Carlo simulations of muons reaching the underground SNOLAB environment using both Geant4 and FLUKA to study the production of radioactive isotopes from both direct spallation reactions or subsequent neutron-induced reactions. We find that, of the isotopes produced, the only one of concern for nEXO is 137 Xe, produced by neutron capture on the xenon target. We develop a veto strategy that achieves an anticipated 92% rejection efficiency while keeping dead time to less than 1 day over a 10 year exposure.
Sources
- The Monte Carlo Event Generator DPMJET-III
- Event Reconstruction in a Liquid Xenon Time Projection Chamber with an Optically-Open Field Cage
- Cosmogenic Neutron Production in Water at SNO+
Related papers
- Regularity of core coupled high-spin structure in neutron-rich 196-202 Au isotopes approaching N =126
- Precise and accurate nuclear electric quadrupole moment of 223 Ra from molecular spectroscopy
- A pathway towards decentralized studies of radioactive post-lead elements and their applications in beyond standard model physics
- Analysis of Xe-131 Prompt Gammas
- Probing the initial geometry and the onset of collectivity with anisotropic flow in light-ion collisions with ALICE at the LHC
- Heavy-Quark Dynamics from D 0-Meson Anisotropy-Response Scaling Violations