Comparing the fusion of 19 O and 20 O ions with protons at near barrier energies

arXiv:2611.00372 · nucl-ex · Submitted 2026-10-30 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Comparing the fusion of 19 O and 20 O ions with protons at near barrier energies".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Proton capture on 19,20O nuclei was measured in inverse kinematics with the active-target detector MuSIC@Indiana using CH4 as the target gas The excitation function of both (p,n) reactions exhibits an oscillatory behavior A significant suppression of the cross section in 19O compared to 20O is observed, suggesting level-density differences.

Kai: Experimental Setup and Detection The radioactive beam experiment was conducted at the SPIRAL1 facility of the GANIL accelerator complex in Caen, France The 19O (t 1/2 = 26.5 s) and 20O (t 1/2 = 13.5 s) beams were produced by bombarding a graphite target with a 22Ne primary beam at E/A = 80 MeV Multi-Sampling Ionization Chamber (MuSIC) detectors are a powerful tool in investigating nuclear reactions with radioactive beams.

Mira: The key element in the experimental setup was the activetarget detector, MuSIC@Indiana.

Kai: Data Analysis and Identification Identification of the incident beam was accomplished by utilizing the first four anode strips of MuSIC@Indiana for an EA0 vs E(A1+A2+A3) measurement as indicated in Fig.

Paper summary: Mira: So, summarizing this paper titled "Comparing the fusion of nineteen O and twenty O ions with protons at near barrier energies," the core idea is comparing the behavior of proton capture on these two isotopes <ref:2611.00372#pg1,ions with protons at near barrier energies>. They found that both excitation functions exhibit an oscillatory behavior, which they interpret as evidence for one or more short-lived quasibound states decaying by emitting a single neutron >

Kai: That sounds like they are looking for specific structures in the nucleus that aren't immediately obvious, and the comparison between nineteen oxygen and twenty oxygen is key because it shows how these differences manifest in their decay patterns >

Lev: From my side, what I focus on is that the theoretical coupled channel calculations they used, specifically those using the São Paulo potential for the real part of the optical potential and a short-range Woods-Saxon potential for the imaginary part with specific parameters, couldn't reproduce this oscillatory behavior in their model >

Mira: That's significant because it means that while there are some states causing oscillations experimentally, their standard coupled channel calculations based on those potentials aren't capturing the physics correctly right now >

Kai: The paper also hypothesizes that the suppression of the fusion cross section they see for nineteen oxygen compared to twenty oxygen is due to a reduced neutron level density in the evaporation residue, which is nineteen fluorine, as compared to twenty fluorine >

Lev: That's a hypothesis about what's happening after the initial capture; it suggests that the decay stage has fewer available states for neutrons than in the case of twenty oxygen >

Kai: And they actually tried to quantify this by scaling their measured proton fusion cross section for nineteen oxygen by a relative yield predicted by GEMINI plus calculations in Table two and scaling that excitation function shows that the location and magnitude of these oscillations are quite similar in both cases > <ref:2611.00372#pg2>

Conclusion: Mira: So, looking at the title "Comparing the fusion of nineteen O and twenty O ions with protons at near barrier energies," what they actually conclude is that while there are differences in the cross section magnitude, the location and size of these oscillations for nineteen oxygen and twenty oxygen are quite similar > <ref:2611.00372#pg1,ions with protons at near barrier energies>

Kai: And they conclude that this suggests a common underlying origin for these structures, even if the absolute level densities might differ slightly >

Lev: But they also clearly state that their coupled channel calculations for the nineteen oxygen plus proton system simply couldn't reproduce the oscillatory behavior they saw experimentally, which points to a gap in our current theoretical modeling of these specific fusion processes >

Mira: The implication for us is that we need more effort on both the experimental and theoretical fronts to get a better understanding of proton fusion in these light systems because the current models aren't matching what's being measured >

Kai: So, basically, it's a call for more work to see if we can finally pin down what causes those oscillations and why they are different between nineteen oxygen and twenty oxygen >

Rohit Kumar, H. Desilets, R. T. deSouza, S. Hudan, C. Ciampi, A. Chbihi, K. W. Brown, B. Pinheiro

Department of Chemistry and Center for Exploration of Energy and Matter Indiana University · GANIL CEA DRF-CNRS IN2P3 Blvd. · Facility for Rare Isotope Beams and Department of Chemistry Michigan State University East Lansing · Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal Fluminense

nucl-ex

Submitted: 2026-10-30

Updated: 2026-10-30

Comments: 8 pages, 7 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: Proton capture on 19,20O nuclei was measured in inverse kinematics with the active-target detector MuSIC@Indiana using CH4 as the target gas The excitation function of both (p,n) reactions exhibits…

Key concepts

Excitation Function
This measures how the probability of a nuclear reaction (like proton fusion) changes as a function of incident energy. In this study, it was used to find oscillatory patterns that indicate the formation and decay of short-lived nuclear states.
Suppression of Cross Section
The measured fusion cross section for 19O is lower than that for 20O at similar energies. This difference is hypothesized to be caused by a reduced neutron level density in the resulting nucleus (19F) compared to the nucleus formed from 20O.
Quasibound States
These are temporary, unstable nuclear states that exist briefly before decaying. The observed oscillations in the excitation function are interpreted as evidence for these short-lived states forming during the reaction process.
Neutron Level Density
This concept describes how many available energy levels exist for neutrons within a nucleus at a given energy. The paper suggests that the lower level density in 19F compared to 20F explains why the fusion cross section is suppressed.

Terminology

Summary

Proton capture on 19,20O nuclei was measured in inverse kinematics with the active-target detector MuSIC@Indiana using CH4 as the target gas The excitation function of both (p,n) reactions exhibits an oscillatory behavior A significant suppression of the cross section in 19O compared to 20O is observed, suggesting level-density differences. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Henri Becquerel F-14076 Caen France cFacility for Rare Isotope Beams and Department of Chemistry Michigan State University East Lansing MI 48823 USA d Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal Fluminense, Niterói, 24210-340, RJ, Brazil Abstract Proton capture on 19,20O nuclei was measured in inverse kinematics with the active-target detector MuSIC@Indiana using CH4 as the target gas. Direct measurement of the (p,n) cross section was enabled by the intrinsically high efficiency and self-normalizing nature of the measurement.

Experimental Setup and Detection

The radioactive beam experiment was conducted at the SPIRAL1 facility of the GANIL accelerator complex in Caen, France The 19O (t 1/2 = 26.5 s) and 20O (t 1/2 = 13. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Comparing the fusion of 19O and 20O ions with protons at near barrier energies Rohit Kumar a , H. Desilets a , R.

5 s) beams were produced by bombarding a graphite target with a 22Ne primary beam at E/A = 80 MeV Multi-Sampling Ionization Chamber (MuSIC) detectors are a powerful tool in investigating nuclear reactions with radioactive beams. p. 0
Where the paper says it

7 MeV) and selected in Bρ by the ALPHA spectrometer before being transported to the experimental setup. Multi-Sampling Ionization Chamber (MuSIC) detectors are a powerful tool in investigating nuclear reactions with radioactive beams [9; 10; 11; 12].

The key element in the experimental setup was the activetarget detector, MuSIC@Indiana. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The key element in the experimental setup was the activetarget detector, MuSIC@Indiana [9]. This detector is a transverse-field ionization chamber with a segmented anode.

Data Analysis and Identification

Identification of the incident beam was accomplished by utilizing the first four anode strips of MuSIC@Indiana for an EA0 vs E(A1+A2+A3) measurement as indicated in Fig. 1. The locus extending to higher energy deposits from this peak is associated with pileup events in the detector, which occur at the 1% level. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1a, for 20O, a single dominant peak is observed. The locus extending to higher energy deposits from this peak is associated with pileup events in the detector, which occur at the 1% level.

To focus on events in which the incident ion had either reacted or scattered in the detector, the outgoing beam was rejected by examining the characteristic energy loss measured in EA18 vs EA19. p. 1
Where the paper says it

However, when averaging over all the measured dataset 19F is ∼55% and 19Ne remains unchanged. To focus on events in which the incident ion had either reacted or scattered in the detector, the outgoing beam was rejected by examining the characteristic energy loss measured in EA18 vs EA19.

Events were subsequently designated as more “O-like” or “Flike” by calculating the deviation of a given trace from O and F reference traces. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Events were subsequently designated as more “O-like” or “Flike”. This classification was realized by calculating the deviation of a given trace from O and F reference traces.

Cross Section Determination

The fusion cross section, σF is related to the number of proton fusion events, NBeam, and the thickness of an anode strip, ∆x by: σF = NER/(NBeam × ∆x). The MuSIC@Indiana eliminates the need for an efficiency correction. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The beam-scattered events are rejected by a threshold indicated by the vertical (red) line. MuSIC@Indiana eliminates the need for an efficiency correction.

The uncertainty in the measured cross section is largely determined by the statistical uncertainty associated with NER. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Unlike thin-target measurements, which are sensitive to the measured ER angular distribution, MuSIC measurements intrinsically provide an angle-integrated measurement of the cross section. The uncertainty in the measured cross section is largely determined by the statistical uncertainty associated with NER.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Unlike thin-target measurements, which are sensitive to the measured ER angular distribution, MuSIC measurements intrinsically provide an angle-integrated measurement of the cross section. The uncertainty in the measured cross section is largely determined by the statistical uncertainty associated with NER.

Comparison with Theory and Conclusion

The measured excitation functions for 19O and 20O are presented in Fig. 5. The oscillatory behavior of the proton fusion cross section is interpreted as the formation of one or more short-lived quasibound states which subsequently decay by emission of a single neutron. p. 3

Where the paper says it

As the implications of the oscillatory structure were previously described in detail, they are only briefly summarized below. This oscillatory behavior of the proton fusion cross section is interpreted as the formation of one or more short-lived quasibound states which subsequently decay by emission of a single neutron.

The suppression of the fusion cross section is hypothesized to be due to a reduced neutron level density in the evaporation residue 19F as compared with the neutron level density of 20F. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Scaling the 19O excitation function demonstrates that the location and magnitude of the oscillations in both cases are quite similar suggesting a common underlying origin. The suppression of the fusion cross section is hypothesized to be due to a reduced neutron level density in the evaporation residue 19F as compared with the neutron level density of 20F.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

Scaling the 19O excitation function demonstrates that the location and magnitude of the oscillations in both cases are quite similar suggesting a common underlying origin. The suppression of the fusion cross section is hypothesized to be due to a reduced neutron level density in the evaporation residue 19F as compared with the neutron level density of 20F.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

Scaling the 19O excitation function demonstrates that the location and magnitude of the oscillations in both cases are quite similar suggesting a common underlying origin. The suppression of the fusion cross section is hypothesized to be due to a reduced neutron level density in the evaporation residue 19F as compared with the neutron level density of 20F.

CC calculations for the 19O + p system using R-matrix theory could not reproduce the oscillatory behavior of the fusion excitation function observed experimentally. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The predicted cross section from one channel and R-matrix coupled channel calculations for 20O + 1H is also depicted. CC calculations for the 19O + p system using R-matrix theory could not reproduce the oscillatory behavior of the fusion excitation function observed experimentally.

The experimental fusion cross section for the 19O+p system shows oscillatory behavior similar to that observed for the 20O+p system. p. 5
Where the paper says it

This may reflect differences in the level densities of the compound and residual nuclei after neutron evaporation in each reaction. Nevertheless, the experimental fusion cross section for the 19O+p system shows oscillatory behavior similar to that observed for the 20O+p system.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

This may reflect differences in the level densities of the compound and residual nuclei after neutron evaporation in each reaction. Nevertheless, the experimental fusion cross section for the 19O+p system shows oscillatory behavior similar to that observed for the 20O+p system.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper examines proton capture by 19O and determines if it also manifests an oscillatory behavior in its excitation function. A quantitative comparison between the proton capture excitation functions of 20O and 19O is made, and both excitation functions are compared with the predictions of coupled channel calculations. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this work, we examine proton capture by 19O and determine if it also manifests an oscillatory behavior in its excitation function. Moreover, a quantitative comparison between the proton capture excitation functions of 20O and 19O is made, and both excitation functions are compared with the predictions of coupled channel calculations.

The total fusion cross section for 19O is determined by scaling the measured (p,n) cross section by the relative yield predicted by the GEMINI++ calculations in Table2. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Because 19O has other decay channels, extracting the fusion cross section requires either accounting for their influence or measuring them directly. In the case of 19O, the total fusion cross section is determined by scaling the measured (p,n) cross section by the relative yield predicted by the GEMINI++ calculations in Table2.

Scaling the 19O excitation function demonstrates that the location and magnitude of the oscillations in both cases are quite similar suggesting a common underlying origin. p. 5
Where the paper says it

In addition, the overall cross-section for 19O is observed to be suppressed relative to 20O by ∼30%. Scaling the 19O excitation function demonstrates that the location and magnitude of the oscillations in both cases are quite similar suggesting a common underlying origin.

The suppression of the fusion cross section is hypothesized to be due to a reduced neutron level density in the evaporation residue 19F as compared with the neutron level density of 20F. The unfavorability of two-neutron transfer for 20O below its Q-value of-3. p. 4
Where the paper says it

73 MeV, the fusion cross-section is reduced for 19O but not for 20O. The unfavorability of two-neutron transfer for 20O below its Q-value of -3.

08 MeV eliminates two-neutron transfer in the energy range examined. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The unfavorability of two-neutron transfer for 20O below its Q-value of -3. 08 MeV eliminates two-neutron transfer in the energy range examined.

How the training signal is built

The authors performed coupled channel (CC) calculations using the FRESCO code [38]. For the real part of the optical potential, the São Paulo potential (SPP) [39] was used. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The theoretical calculations were performed using the FRESCO code [38]. For the real part of the optical potential, the São Paulo potential (SPP) [39] was used.

The imaginary part used a short-range Woods-Saxon potential, WF(r), for both nuclei with specific parameters. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The same systematic was used for the 20O + p system [8]. For the imaginary part, a short-range Woods-Saxon potential, WF(r), was used for both nuclei with the parameters W0 = 50.

The 1.4717 MeV 1/2+ excited state was considered in the CC calculations. p. 5
Where the paper says it

This short-range potential exclusively accounts for absorption to fusion [40]. 4717 MeV 1/2 + excited state was considered in the CC calculations, as this is the only state for which a considerable quadrupole reduced transition probability (B(E2) = 0.

Where the gains come from

The use of the active target detector MuSIC@Indiana with CH4 gas and incident radioactive beams of 19O and 20O ions enabled efficient extraction of the (p,n) cross section. This approach could be readily applied to investigate (p,n) reactions for other neutron-rich light heavy-ion beams. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Conclusions Use of the active target detector MuSIC@Indiana with CH4 gas and incident radioactive beams of 19O and 20O ions enabled efficient extraction of the (p,n) cross section. This approach could be readily applied to investigate (p,n) reactions for other neutron-rich light heavy-ion beams.

The uncertainty associated with NBeam is negligible, and the uncertainty associated with ∆x is defined by the pressure variation in MuSIC@Indiana. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In addition, a systematic uncertainty of 5% associated with the possible misidentification of fusion events for NER is included. The uncertainty associated with NBeam is negligible, and the uncertainty associated with ∆x is defined by the pressure variation in MuSIC@Indiana.

All these uncertainties are included in the reported error bars. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The uncertainty associated with NBeam is negligible, and the uncertainty associated with ∆x is defined by the pressure variation in MuSIC@Indiana. All these uncertainties are included in the reported error bars.

The finite size of each anode strip results in an uncertainty in the energy at which the reaction occurs. p. 3
Where the paper says it

All these uncertainties are included in the reported error bars. The finite size of each anode strip results in an uncertainty in the energy at which the reaction occurs.

The paper suggests that extending this line of reasoning opens up an interesting possibility if the level density, or relative level density, of the decay stage could be calculated (or measured). p. 4
Where the paper says it

In principle, extending this line of reasoning opens up an interesting possibility. If the level density, or relative level density, of the decay stage could be calculated (or measured), then the level density (or relative level density) of the quasi-bound compound nucleus could be extracted.

The CC result for the fusion cross section remained unchanged even when assuming a different B(E2:2+ → 0+) value for 19O. p. 5
Where the paper says it

This may encourage researchers to seek an explanation for this unresolved issue. Finally, to seek any possible reason for the disagreement between theoretical and experimental fusion cross sections for the 19O+p system, we assumed the B(E2:2+ → 0 + ) value for 20O in the B(E2:1/2 + → 5/2 + ) for 19O, but the CC result for the fusion cross section remained unchanged.

The experimental fusion cross section for the 19O+p system shows oscillatory behavior similar to that observed for the 20O+p system. The theoretical cross section also overestimates the mean experimental value. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Nevertheless, the experimental fusion cross section for the 19O+p system shows oscillatory behavior similar to that observed for the 20O+p system. The theoretical cross section also overestimates the mean experimental value.

Conclusion

To provide a better and comprehensive understanding of proton fusion in such light systems further effort on both experimental and theoretical fronts is clearly necessary. The paper concludes that the measured excitation functions for 19O and 20O are quite similar in location and magnitude of oscillations. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In addition, the overall cross-section for 19O is observed to be suppressed relative to 20O by ∼30%. Scaling the 19O excitation function demonstrates that the location and magnitude of the oscillations in both cases are quite similar suggesting a common underlying origin.

The suppression of the fusion cross section is hypothesized to be due to a reduced neutron level density in the evaporation residue 19F as compared with the neutron level density of 20F. The CC calculations for the 19O + p system could not reproduce the oscillatory behavior of the fusion excitation function observed experimentally. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The predicted cross section from one channel and R-matrix coupled channel calculations for 20O + 1H is also depicted. CC calculations for the 19O + p system using R-matrix theory could not reproduce the oscillatory behavior of the fusion excitation function observed experimentally.

The paper suggests that further effort on both experimental and theoretical fronts is clearly necessary. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Moreover, the theoretical cross section also exceeds the mean experimental fusion cross section. To provide a better and comprehensive understanding of proton fusion in such light systems further effort on both experimental and theoretical fronts is clearly necessary.

The uncertainty in the measured cross section is largely determined by the statistical uncertainty associated with NER.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. More accurately predict quasi-bound states in fusion excitation functions by incorporating level density of states in 20F following neutron emission into coupled channel calculations, as this is necessary to explain observed oscillatory behavior. This improved system can better model near-threshold spectroscopy for light nuclei.

  2. Develop a method to extract the level density of the quasi-bound compound nucleus by comparing the relative level densities of the compound nucleus and the daughter evaporation residue, as suggested by the suppression of the fusion cross section is hypothesized to be due to a reduced neutron level density in the evaporation residue 19F as compared with the neutron level density of 20F. This allows for extracting information about nuclear structure from reaction observables.

  3. Enhance the ability to distinguish proton fusion events from proton two-body scattering by developing a more sensitive measure of average energy deposit, such as a f ter, and using its bimodal nature to select fusion events more reliably across different anodes. This would improve the selectivity of the active target detector in isolating specific reaction channels.

  4. Improve theoretical modeling of fusion cross sections by addressing the discrepancy where coupled channel calculations overestimate the mean experimental value for 19O+p, potentially by seeking explanations for this issue within nuclear structure or coupling mechanisms not fully captured in current models. This would lead to more accurate predictive power for near-barrier fusion cross sections.

Abstract

Proton capture on 19,20 O nuclei was measured in inverse kinematics with the active-target detector MuSIC@Indiana using CH 4 as the target gas. Direct measurement of the (p,n) cross section was enabled by the intrinsically high efficiency and self-normalizing nature of the measurement. The excitation function of both (p,n) reactions exhibits an oscillatory behavior. For the neutron-rich nuclei studied, determining the (p,n) cross section provides access to the proton fusion cross section because the proton's de Broglie wavelength is much larger than that of the heavy ion. A significant suppression of the cross section in 19 O compared to 20 O is observed, suggesting level-density differences. While the coupled channel calculations reproduce the oscillatory behavior observed in the case of 20 O, they fail to predict the oscillatory behavior observed in 19 O or the overall suppression of the fusion cross section.

Related papers