Guidance List for repOrting Bibliometric AnaLyses (GLOBAL): A Reporting Guideline Informed by a Two-Round Modified Delphi Study
cs.DL
Submitted: 2026-10-28
Updated: 2026-10-28
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
The gist: Background: Despite the growth of bibliometric analyses, few studies offer guidance on how to report them, resulting in a lack of research transparency and completeness.
Abstract
Background: Despite the growth of bibliometric analyses, few studies offer guidance on how to report them, resulting in a lack of research transparency and completeness. To address this gap, we developed the Guidance List for the repOrting of Bibliometric AnaLyses (GLOBAL). Methods: An initial list of items for the GLOBAL was generated through a scoping review and refined through a modified two-round Delphi, as recommended by the EQUATOR Network. The guideline was finalized through a pilot test, where participants assessed their manuscripts using the checklist and Elaboration and Explanation (E&E) document, which outlines item expectations and provides examples. Results: The scoping review resulted in 32 items. In Round 1, 24 items reached consensus and thematic content analysis resulted in one additional item. This item, along with the eight items that did not reach consensus, were discussed in detail in Round 2. During the in-person meeting, one item was split into two, totalling ten voting items. Eight out of ten items reached consensus, five for inclusion and three for exclusion. Conclusions: The finalized 28-item GLOBAL (and its accompanying E&E document) provides users with a framework to report bibliometric analyses, aimed at promoting high-quality reporting of bibliometric analyses in scholarly literature.
Related papers
- Persistence Paradox in Dynamic Science: Evidence from the Deep Learning Revolution
- How Deep Do Large Language Models Internalize Scientific Literature and Citation Practices?
- Have Large Language Models Enhanced the Way Civil & Environmental Engineers Write? A Quantitative Analysis of Scholarly Communication over 25 Years
- MTRACE: Multilingual Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Temporally Diverse Text Corpora
- Ending the NIH embargo accelerated public access to funded research, but substantial delays remain
- Entering the Elite, But Remaining Outside Its Core? The Temporal Structure of Gender Inequality in the Global Citation