The Alpha--Omega Problem in the Assessments of Atmospheric Power

arXiv:2610.38522 · physics.ao-ph · Submitted 2026-10-28 · Read on arXiv

physics.ao-ph

Submitted: 2026-10-28

Updated: 2026-10-28

Comments: 19 pages, 2 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

The gist: Atmospheric power is commonly assessed with two Lorenz-cycle formulations treated as equivalent: the αω formulation, yielding gas expansion power W ω, and the v times grad z formulation…

Abstract

Atmospheric power is commonly assessed with two Lorenz-cycle formulations treated as equivalent: the αω formulation, yielding gas expansion power W ω, and the v times grad z formulation, yielding kinetic-energy generation by horizontal pressure gradients, W K. We show that, for a statistically stationary global moist atmosphere, W ω=W K+W P+W nh, where W P is the power of lifting precipitating water and W nh is power associated with departures from gas-phase hydrostatic balance. Since W P 1 W m-2 globally, equality would require W nh-W P<0, so the associated vertical force imbalance would have to do negative work globally. Using six-hourly ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2 fields for 2025, we find that resolved W ω varies by a factor of 1.7 (1.9--3.2 W m-2), versus 1.2 for W K (2.4--2.8 W m-2). Zonal-mean αω profiles have area-weighted contributions near plus or minus50 W m-2, making global W ω a cancellation residual, whereas v times grad z profiles vary much less with latitude. The difference W ω-W K ranges from-0.61 to +0.87 W m-2. Thus reanalysis-derived W ω cannot provide an independent constraint on atmospheric power. Two treatments of the omitted surface layer give cross-reanalysis mean W K of 2.8 and 3.1 W m-2, with corrected values spanning 2.6--3.5 W m-2. Both exceed the observation-based Lorenz available-potential-energy generation estimate of 1.2 W m-2. Assuming W nh at least0, adding W P 1 W m-2 gives total atmospheric power of about 3.8--4.1 W m-2, motivating investigation of additional power-generation mechanisms.

Related papers