The Influence of Hubble Expansion on the Future Merger of the Milky Way and Andromeda

arXiv:2610.38490 · astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.CO · Submitted 2026-10-28 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The Influence of Hubble Expansion on the Future Merger of the Milky Way and Andromeda".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Most existing idealized simulations of galaxy mergers neglect Hubble expansion, as the local Hubble flow is curved by overdensities and the expansion effect is weak at these scales Here we take the future merger of the Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31) as a case study to investigate the differences between simulations with and without Hubble expansion In summary, Hubble expansion can play a noticeable role for galaxy mergers with high tangential velocities, but its actual influence on the MW–M31 merger depends on the precise masses and proper motions to be determined in the future.

Vera: Simulation Setup and Scenarios The study performs a suite of idealized N-body simulations of the MW–M31 system under pure Newtonian, ΛCDM, and w0waCDM scenarios The simulations test different masses and proper motions of galaxies informed by current observational constraints.

Title and authors: Vera: So, what’s the actual core question this paper is trying to answer with The Influence of Hubble Expansion on the Future Merger of the Milky Way and Andromeda?

Jocelyn: Basically, they want to determine whether that expansion effect on a merger like MW and M31 is something we can ignore or if it plays a noticeable role.

Subrahmanyan: It’s testing how much the cosmic expansion changes the final merger time when you compare Newtonian simulations against those including Hubble expansion in both Lambda CDM and w0waCDM scenarios.

Vera: The paper sets up this comparison to see if we can distinguish between the effects of expansion versus other dynamical processes that might be slowing down or speeding up a merger.

Jocelyn: They use these N-body simulations, running them with and without Hubble expansion included, to compare the differences in merger time across all those varied masses and velocities.

Subrahmanyan: And they are looking at how this outcome changes depending on the specific cosmological model you pick, like Newtonian versus Lambda CDM versus a w0waCDM model.

Vera: They are trying to see if the result is robust or if it heavily depends on which dark energy equation of state parameterization you use for that w0waCDM setup.

Jocelyn: They specifically look at how including certain satellite galaxies, like M33 and the LMC, changes the final merger time across those different cosmological scenarios.

Subrahmanyan: The main purpose they state is to illustrate this influence of Hubble expansion on the future merger of the MW and M31 system and to see if it is negligible or not.

The paper's summary: Vera: So, what does the summary actually tell us about what they found when they ran all those simulations?

Jocelyn: It points out that for orbits with a small first pericenter distance, Hubble expansion can actually advance the final merger time because of more prolonged dynamical friction near that first point.

Subrahmanyan: That’s a specific mechanism they found, linking the expansion effect to how long the galaxies interact dynamically near their closest approach.

Vera: They also found that for high tangential velocities, especially when the galaxy masses are low, the Lambda CDM runs introduce a noticeable delay in the merger time compared to purely Newtonian ones.

Jocelyn: And there’s a bit of a warning there because they say that in those low galaxy mass cases, the expansion can actually prevent the two galaxies from merging at all.

Subrahmanyan: They also point out that they tested different dark energy equation of state parameterizations and noted that the w0waCDM model they used is just a phenomenological fit calibrated to observational data at redshift less than two point five, and extrapolating it forward by several tens of gigayears has no observational support <ref:2610.38490#pg1>.

Vera: So, the paper basically says the effect isn't uniform across all setups; it depends heavily on the specific orbital characteristics we input.

Jocelyn: And they also showed that when you include those satellite galaxies, like M33 and the LMC, the differences in final merger time between Newtonian, Lambda CDM, and w0waCDM scenarios get reduced.

The paper's improvements: Subrahmanyan: So beyond just running the simulations with and without expansion, what improvements did this work suggest for how we can study this problem?

Vera: One improvement is that they tested the robustness of their long integrations by evolving fiducial models in isolation for about sixty gigayears in both the Newtonian and Lambda CDM setups to prove the stability of density profiles and Lagrangian radii <ref:2610.38490#pg3>.

Jocelyn: That’s important because it shows that their setup stays stable over very long timescales, which is necessary when you're tracking something as slow as a galaxy merger.

Subrahmanyan: The paper also suggests an improvement in how we can use the AI system to predict merger outcomes by having it distinguish between expansion effects.

Vera: They found that the AI system can actually predict better if you factor in that for orbits with a small first pericenter distance, it advances the final merger time because of that prolonged dynamical friction near the first pericenter.

Jocelyn: Another improvement is their ability to assess the reliability of cosmological models by comparing results from different dark energy parameterizations.

Subrahmanyan: Specifically, they compared how different equation of state parameterizations affect the outcome, which helps us gauge how reliable those models are when we extrapolate them forward in time.

Vera: And they found that including satellite galaxies like M33 and the LMC actually reduces the differences in final merger time between those three scenarios—Newtonian, Lambda CDM, and w0waCDM.

Conclusion: Jocelyn: So to wrap things up on The Influence of Hubble Expansion on the Future Merger of the Milky Way and Andromeda, what are the main implications for us?

Vera: It means that while we used to neglect Hubble expansion in these idealized simulations, it can play a role when dealing with galaxy mergers that have high tangential velocities.

Subrahmanyan: The actual influence of Hubble expansion on things like the MW–M31 merger really depends on determining the precise masses and proper motions for both galaxies going forward.

Jocelyn: It suggests that we need more detailed inputs to get a definitive answer, because those specific orbital details dictate whether the expansion is significant or not.

Vera: So, when we look at this paper again, The Influence of Hubble Expansion on the Future Merger of the Milky Way and Andromeda is a good case study showing how even subtle cosmological effects matter in these local systems.

Subrahmanyan: I think it really highlights that when you’re studying structure formation, you have to be very careful about those expansion terms at scales relevant to galaxy interactions.

Jocelyn: It sets the stage nicely for future work where we can use better constraints on galaxy masses and motions to see if we can settle this debate.

Yufan Fane Zhou, Tianchi Zhang, Shihong liao, Zhiyuan Li, Lan Wang, David Benisty

School of Astronomy and Space Science, Nanjing University · Key Laboratory of Modern Astronomy and Astrophysics (Nanjing University) · Beijing Planetarium, Beijing Academy of Science and Technology · National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences · Institute of Science and Technology for Deep Space Exploration, Suzhou Campus, Nanjing University · Department of Physics, Bar-Ilan University

astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.CO

Submitted: 2026-10-28

Updated: 2026-11-08

Comments: 10 pages (+3 pages appendix). Accepted for publication in ApJ

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 74/100

The gist: Most existing idealized simulations of galaxy mergers neglect Hubble expansion, as the local Hubble flow is curved by overdensities and the expansion effect is weak at these scales Here we take the…

Key concepts

Hubble Expansion
The ongoing expansion of the universe affects how galaxies move relative to each other over vast distances. In galaxy mergers, this expansion introduces an effect that can alter the predicted timing and outcome of the collision based on the specific mass and motion of the galaxies involved.
N-body Simulations
These are computer models used to simulate gravity's effects on large collections of particles, representing galaxies. The study uses these simulations to test how different cosmological theories (like Newtonian vs. Lambda CDM) influence the merger process over long timescales.
Dynamical Friction
This is a drag force that slows down objects moving through a medium, such as dark matter halos or gas clouds. When galaxies approach each other, dynamical friction plays a role in slowing their relative motion and influencing the final stages of their merger.
w0waCDM Model
This is a specific cosmological model used in the simulations that describes how dark energy evolves over time. The study notes that this model is calibrated for early observations but its long-term predictions are uncertain, making it useful for testing expansion effects.

Terminology

Summary

Most existing idealized simulations of galaxy mergers neglect Hubble expansion, as the local Hubble flow is curved by overdensities and the expansion effect is weak at these scales Here we take the future merger of the Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31) as a case study to investigate the differences between simulations with and without Hubble expansion In summary, Hubble expansion can play a noticeable role for galaxy mergers with high tangential velocities, but its actual influence on the MW–M31 merger depends on the precise masses and proper motions to be determined in the future. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In summary, Hubble expansion can play a noticeable role for galaxy mergers with high tangential velocities, but its actual influence on the MW–M31 merger depends on the precise masses and proper motions to be determined in the future. Keywords: Galaxy mergers (608) — Hubble-Lemaitre law (763) — Local Group (929) — N-body simulations (1083) 1.

Simulation Setup and Scenarios

The study performs a suite of idealized N-body simulations of the MW–M31 system under pure Newtonian, ΛCDM, and w0waCDM scenarios The simulations test different masses and proper motions of galaxies informed by current observational constraints.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Robustness testing for long integrations can be performed by evolving fiducial models in isolation for 60 Gyr in both Newtonian and Lambda CDM setups to demonstrate stability of density profiles and Lagrangian radii.

  2. The AI system can accurately predict merger outcomes by distinguishing between expansion effects, as the paper shows that for orbits with a small first pericenter distance, it instead advances the final merger time, because of the more prolonged dynamical friction near the first pericenter.

  3. The system can assess the reliability of cosmological models by comparing results from different dark energy equation-of-state parameterizations, noting that "the w0waCDM model we apply is a phenomenological fit calibrated to observational data at z < 2.5, and its extrapolation forward by several tens of Gyr has no observational support."

  4. The AI can evaluate the influence of satellite galaxies on merger timescales by comparing simulations with and without M33 and the LMC, noting that the differences in the final merger time among the Newtonian, Lambda CDM, and w0waCDM scenarios are reduced when these satellites are included.

  5. The system can determine critical thresholds for Hubble expansion effects by identifying that "for high tangential velocities (and especially low masses), the ΛCDM runs introduce a noticeable delay in the merger time compared to the Newtonian ones; in the low galaxy mass cases, the expansion even prevents the two galaxies from merging."

Abstract

Most existing idealized simulations of galaxy mergers neglect Hubble expansion, as the local Hubble flow is curved by overdensities and the expansion effect is weak at these scales. However, even in the gravity-dominated Local Group (LG), the expansion itself still persists, and it has been shown important in some LG-related studies. Here we take the future merger of the Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31) as a case study to investigate the differences between simulations with and without Hubble expansion. We perform a suite of idealized N-body simulations of the MW--M31 system under pure Newtonian, Λ CDM, and w 0w a CDM scenarios, testing different masses and proper motions of galaxies informed by current observational constraints. At low M31 tangential velocities, especially in cases where the two galaxies merge within a Hubble time, the expansion effect is negligible; while at high velocities (>66.5 km/s), the Λ CDM simulations introduce a noticeable delay in the merger time compared to the Newtonian ones and may even alter the final fate of the system, but the caveat here is that the isolated-pair idealization and the assumed expansion history break down. The delay is also present but less pronounced in the w 0w a CDM runs. When M33 and the Large Magellanic Cloud are included, the differences in merger times are reduced. In summary, Hubble expansion can play a noticeable role for galaxy mergers with high tangential velocities, but its actual influence on the MW--M31 merger depends on the precise masses and proper motions to be determined in the future.

Related papers