Anti-successors and anti-replicators, Manin products and Koszul duality

arXiv:2610.21365 · math.RA, math-ph, math.AT, math.MP · Submitted 2026-10-15 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Anti-successors and anti-replicators, Manin products and Koszul duality".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. ANTI-SUCCESSORS AND ANTI-REPLICATORS, MANIN PRODUCTS AND KOSZUL DUALITY is a paper that develops an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads, relating these anti-structures to Manin black and white products through Koszul duality.

Ada: The central finding is that the anti-successor construction splits operations into negative sums, yielding structures like AntiPreLie • P and AntiPostLie • P for binary quadratic operads The paper introduces anti-bisuccessors ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessors ATSu(P) for a binary operad P, which are defined such that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations yielding canonical operad morphisms Conceptually, the anti-successor construction has two complementary structural features: first, the term anti-splitting is intrinsic where the negative total operation encodes the splitting Second, for binary quadratic operads these constructions fit into the successor/replicator–Manin-product picture, specifically ABSu(P) AntiPreLie • P and ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P.

Emmy: Characterization of Anti-Successors The anti-successors are defined for labeled planar binary trees and then generalized to binary operads, where the anti-bisuccessor ABSux(τ) is obtained by replacing vertex decorations according to specific rules based on whether the vertex is on the path from the root to a leaf x.

Ada: The anti-trisuccessor ATSuJ(τ) involves labeling vertices based on whether paths turn left, right, or if some paths turn left and some turn right.

Paper summary: Ada: We've just talked about the high-level idea, which is that this paper develops an operadic theory for anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads. The authors introduce the anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and the anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P).

Emmy: They show that these constructions have two complementary structural features. First, there's the intrinsic term called anti-splitting, which is encoded in a negative total operation.

Ada: And then they have this dual concept related to replication, introducing the anti-duplicator ADup(P) and the anti-triplicator ATrip(P).

Emmy: The crucial link is that they prove ADup(P!) and ABSu(P)! are Koszul duals, and ATrip(P!) and ATSu(P)! are also dual. This forces the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions to be dual to each other.

Ada: The central claim they make is that this framework recovers known anti-splittings like anti-dendriform, anti-pre-Lie, and anti-pre-Poisson operads in a uniform context. This is the main result for binary quadratic operads.

Kolya: The paper also explores how these relate to Manin white products through Koszul duality. Specifically, they show that the anti-duplicator ADup(P) can be related to the Manin white product of P and AntiDupliCom via a theorem involving T(V)/(R).

Emmy: So, the implication is that this framework gives us a new way to characterize Manin white products. It’s not just about finding one type of product, but having these two perspectives—the black product from splitting and the white product from replicating.

Ada: But they also show that the anti-duplicator relates to the anti-successor construction via the dual operad. This is a very specific connection between these seemingly different constructions.

Kolya: The paper also mentions results for examples, like AntiDend encoding anti-dendriform algebras as the anti-bisuccessor of Ass, and AntiPostCom being the anti-trisuccessor of Com. These examples show how this general machinery works on specific structures.

Conclusion: Ada: So, looking at the whole paper titled "Anti-successors and anti-replicators, Manin products and Koszul duality," it sets up a very systematic way to look at nonassociative structures. The authors use anti-successors and anti-replicators to handle operations that split or replicate in a specific way.

Emmy: They establish that this isn't just about sign changes; it requires these extra compatibility relations for the duality to hold up, which is what makes the constructions work as expected.

Ada: The paper shows how this connects Manin black products on one side and Manin white products on the other side through Koszul duality. It gives us a powerful tool for computing these products of binary quadratic operads with AntiPreLie or AntiPostLie.

Kolya: What this means for the world is that it gives a new way to characterize Manin white products using anti-duplicators and anti-successors. It’s an efficient computational method that works well on structures like AntiDupliCom and Lie algebras.

Emmy: It provides a uniform operadic form for dealing with anti-pre-Lie and anti-dendriform algebras, showing they belong to a larger family of structures defined by these anti-structures.

Ada: The authors confirm that the framework is very robust because it produces examples and dual pairs, which solidifies the idea that this approach is a reliable way forward for studying these kinds of algebraic objects.

NSFC · Central Government-Guided Fund Project for Local Science and Technology Development in Tianjin · Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities · Nankai Zhide Foundation

math.RA, math-ph, math.AT, math.MP

Submitted: 2026-10-15

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: comments are welcome

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: ANTI-SUCCESSORS AND ANTI-REPLICATORS, MANIN PRODUCTS AND KOSZUL DUALITY is a paper that develops an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads…

Key concepts

Anti-Successor (ABSu(P))
This construction defines an operation in a binary operad as a negative sum of other operations. Conceptually, it captures 'anti-splitting,' where the total operation encodes how the original operation splits into two or three components.
Anti-Replicator (ADup(P))
Dually, this construction relates to Manin white products. It is defined by intersections of relation spaces and is crucial for understanding 'anti-replication,' which describes how structures replicate themselves in a dual sense.
Koszul Duality
This mathematical tool establishes a relationship between two operads, P and Q, such that the structure of one dictates the structure of the other's dual. The paper uses this duality to link anti-successors with anti-replicators and characterize Manin products.
Manin Products (Black/White)
These are algebraic structures derived from operads that describe how operations combine or replicate. The paper shows that the splitting side relates to black products via anti-successors, while the replicating side relates to white products via anti-replicators.

Terminology

Summary

ANTI-SUCCESSORS AND ANTI-REPLICATORS, MANIN PRODUCTS AND KOSZUL DUALITY is a paper that develops an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads, relating these anti-structures to Manin black and white products through Koszul duality. p. 0

Where the paper says it

ANTI-SUCCESSORS AND ANTI-REPLICATORS, MANIN PRODUCTS AND KOSZUL DUALITY CHENGMING BAI, LI GUO, YUNHE SHENG, AND YOU WANG Abstract. We develop an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads.

The central finding is that the anti-successor construction splits operations into negative sums, yielding structures like AntiPreLie • P and AntiPostLie • P for binary quadratic operads

Introduction to Anti-Structures

The paper introduces anti-bisuccessors ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessors ATSu(P) for a binary operad P, which are defined such that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations yielding canonical operad morphisms Conceptually, the anti-successor construction has two complementary structural features: first, the term anti-splitting is intrinsic where the negative total operation encodes the splitting Second, for binary quadratic operads these constructions fit into the successor/replicator–Manin-product picture, specifically ABSu(P) AntiPreLie • P and ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P.

Characterization of Anti-Successors

The anti-successors are defined for labeled planar binary trees and then generalized to binary operads, where the anti-bisuccessor ABSux(τ) is obtained by replacing vertex decorations according to specific rules based on whether the vertex is on the path from the root to a leaf x. The anti-trisuccessor ATSuJ(τ) involves labeling vertices based on whether paths turn left, right, or if some paths turn left and some turn right. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The anti-trisuccessor ATSuJ(τ) is obtained by relabeling each vertex of τ according to the following rules: (a) We replace the label ω of each vertex on at least one of the paths from the root to the leaves in J by (i) ω ≺ ! , if all such paths turn left at this vertex; (ii) ω ≻ !

Theorem 2.16 expresses the intrinsic nature of anti-splitting by showing that the morphism P → ABSu(P) sends each generator ω to ω⋆ = −(ω≺ + ω≻). p. 2
Where the paper says it

First, the term anti-splitting is intrinsic: if ω is a generating operation of P, then the negative total operation ω⋆ = −(ω≺ + ω≻) in the anti-bisuccessor, and respectively ω⋆ = −(ω≺ + ω≻ + ω·) in the anti-trisuccessor, satisfies the original relations of P. Equivalently, there are canonical operad morphisms P → ABSu(P) and P → ATSu(P).

Anti-Replicators and Duality

Dually, the paper introduces the anti-duplicator ADup(P) and anti-triplicator ATrip(P), which are related to Manin white products. The central quadratic-duality theorem states that ADup(P! p. 2

Where the paper says it

Dually, we introduce the anti-duplicator ADup(P) and anti-triplicator ATrip(P). Their defining intersections are explained by the central quadratic-duality theorem (2) ADup(P !

) = ABSu(P)! p. 0
Where the paper says it

We develop an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads. For a binary operad P, we define its anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P), with the property that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations, yielding canonical operad morphisms P → ABSu(P) and P → ATSu(P).

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We develop an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads. For a binary operad P, we define its anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P), with the property that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations, yielding canonical operad morphisms P → ABSu(P) and P → ATSu(P).

and ATrip(P! p. 0
Where the paper says it

For binary quadratic operads, the process gives Manin black products, ABSu(P) AntiPreLie • P, ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P. Dually, we introduce the anti-duplicator ADup(P) and anti-triplicator ATrip(P) and prove ADup(P !

) = ATSu(P)! p. 0
Where the paper says it

We develop an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads. For a binary operad P, we define its anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P), with the property that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations, yielding canonical operad morphisms P → ABSu(P) and P → ATSu(P).

This duality forces the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions to be dual, as the additional relations are precisely what makes them dual. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The latter feature is forced by the elementary duality (U +W) ⊥ = U ⊥ ∩W⊥ . Thus the additional relations are not auxiliary: they are precisely what makes the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions dual.

Manin Product Characterization

The paper establishes a central duality result showing that taking the anti-successor of a binary operad is in Koszul dual with taking the anti-replicator of the dual operad. Specifically, Theorem 3. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Dually, we introduce the anti-duplicator ADup(P) and anti-triplicator ATrip(P). Their defining intersections are explained by the central quadratic-duality theorem (2) ADup(P !

2 proves the isomorphism ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For a binary operad P, we define its anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P), with the property that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations, yielding canonical operad morphisms P → ABSu(P) and P → ATSu(P). For binary quadratic operads, the process gives Manin black products, ABSu(P) AntiPreLie • P, ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P.

Furthermore, Theorem 3. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Dually, we introduce the anti-duplicator ADup(P) and anti-triplicator ATrip(P). Their defining intersections are explained by the central quadratic-duality theorem (2) ADup(P !

3 shows that ABSu(P) AntiPreLie • P is an isomorphism of operads. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For a binary operad P, we define its anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P), with the property that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations, yielding canonical operad morphisms P → ABSu(P) and P → ATSu(P). For binary quadratic operads, the process gives Manin black products, ABSu(P) AntiPreLie • P, ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P.

Koszul Duality and White Products

The section on Koszul duality demonstrates that the anti-duplicator ADup(P) can be related to the Manin white product of P and AntiDupliCom via Theorem 5.7. This leads to Corollary 5. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Thus the additional relations are not auxiliary: they are precisely what makes the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions dual. This leads simultaneously to Manin black-product descriptions on the splitting side and Manin white-product descriptions on the replicating side.

8, which states that the Manin white product of AntiDupliCom and Lie is isomorphic to the operad AntiDupliLie. p. 2
Where the paper says it

, AntiDupliLie AntiZinbiel! As a further consequence, the anti-duplicator is described by a Manin white product: (3) ADup(P) AntiDupliCom ⃝ P.

This provides a new characterization of the Manin white product. p. 0
Where the paper says it

) ATSu(P) ! Consequently, the anti-duplicator gives a new way to calculate Manin white products.

Examples and Applications

The paper provides several examples of anti-successors, including AntiDend encoding anti-dendriform algebras as the anti-bisuccessor of Ass and AntiPreLie encoding anti-pre-Lie algebras as the anti-bisuccessor of Lie. Additionally, AntiPostCom is shown to be the anti-trisuccessor of the operad Com and AntiTriDend is the anti-trisuccessor of Ass. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We develop an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads. For a binary operad P, we define its anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P), with the property that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations, yielding canonical operad morphisms P → ABSu(P) and P → ATSu(P).

These results extend to various algebraic structures including anti-pre-Poisson algebras and anti-post-Lie algebras. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We introduce its anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P). These constructions recover the known anti-dendriform, anti-pre-Lie and anti-pre-Poisson operads and lead, in particular, to anti-post-Lie algebras.

Anti-Replicators and Anti-Post Structures

The paper also explores the anti-replicators, showing that AntiPostLie is the anti-trisuccessor of Lie and AntiTriDend is the anti-trisuccessor of Ass. These constructions lead to new structures such as the antidupli-com algebra and anti-dupli-Lie algebra. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Section 3 identifies them with Manin black products with the anti-pre-Lie algebra and anti-post-Lie algebra. Section 4 introduces anti-duplicators and anti-triplicators and resulting new structures, such as the antidupli-com algebra and anti-dupli-Lie algebra.

The relationship between these structures is further clarified by Corollary 5. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Consequently, the anti-duplicator gives a new way to calculate Manin white products. The framework recovers known anti-splittings, including anti-dendriform, anti-pre-Lie, and anti-pre-Poisson structures, in a uniform operadic form and produces further examples and dual pairs.

4, which states that the operad AntiDupliCom is the Koszul dual of the operad AntiPreLie. p. 2
Where the paper says it

) ATSu(P) ! In particular, we introduce the notions of anti-dupli-com algebras and anti-dupli-Lie algebras, and the following properties hold at the operadic level: AntiDupliCom AntiPreLie!

Summary of Key Results

The key results establish a uniform framework for anti-splitting and anti-replication using antisuccessors and anti-replicators. These constructions are not merely sign changes but require additional compatibility relations that enforce Koszul duality. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Motivated by the recent appearance of anti-pre-Lie and anti-dendriform algebras, we develop an operadic anti-version of this picture, introducing antisuccessors and anti-replicators and relating them to Manin black and white products. A central point is that the anti-theory is not obtained by merely changing signs: additional compatibility relations, and their dual intersections, are essential—and it is precisely these extra relations that force the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions to be Koszul dual to each other.

The framework simultaneously produces Manin black-product descriptions on the splitting side and Manin white-product descriptions on the replicating side. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Thus the additional relations are not auxiliary: they are precisely what makes the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions dual. This leads simultaneously to Manin black-product descriptions on the splitting side and Manin white-product descriptions on the replicating side.

The results provide efficient ways to compute Manin products of binary quadratic operads with AntiPreLie or AntiPostLie. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For a binary operad P, we define its anti-bisuccessor ABSu(P) and anti-trisuccessor ATSu(P), with the property that an operation of P splits into a negative sum of two or three operations, yielding canonical operad morphisms P → ABSu(P) and P → ATSu(P). For binary quadratic operads, the process gives Manin black products, ABSu(P) AntiPreLie • P, ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P.

The paper concludes by showing that the anti-duplicator ADup(P) is isomorphic to the Manin white product P ⃝ Q when P = T(V)/(R) and Q = T(W)/(S). p. 2
Where the paper says it

, AntiDupliLie AntiZinbiel! As a further consequence, the anti-duplicator is described by a Manin white product: (3) ADup(P) AntiDupliCom ⃝ P.

Final Duality Relations

The paper proves that the anti-duplicator ADup(P!) is Koszul dual to the anti-successor ABSu(P)! p. 1

Where the paper says it

Motivated by the recent appearance of anti-pre-Lie and anti-dendriform algebras, we develop an operadic anti-version of this picture, introducing antisuccessors and anti-replicators and relating them to Manin black and white products. A central point is that the anti-theory is not obtained by merely changing signs: additional compatibility relations, and their dual intersections, are essential—and it is precisely these extra relations that force the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions to be Koszul dual to each other.

Furthermore, Corollary 5. p. 8
Where the paper says it

It gives rise to a bijection T T/ ∼. Furthermore, for any planar binary tree t in T which represents t ∈ T, we have t[V] t[V] according to [19, Section 2.

4 establishes that AntiDupliCom is the Koszul dual of AntiPreLie. p. 2
Where the paper says it

) ATSu(P) ! In particular, we introduce the notions of anti-dupli-com algebras and anti-dupli-Lie algebras, and the following properties hold at the operadic level: AntiDupliCom AntiPreLie!

The operad AntiDupliLie is shown to be the Koszul dual of the operad AntiZinbiel. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In particular, we introduce the notions of anti-dupli-com algebras and anti-dupli-Lie algebras, and the following properties hold at the operadic level: AntiDupliCom AntiPreLie! , AntiDupliLie AntiZinbiel!

These results provide a new characterization of the Manin white product of AntiDupliCom and an operad P in terms of anti-duplicators. p. 2
Where the paper says it

, AntiDupliLie AntiZinbiel! As a further consequence, the anti-duplicator is described by a Manin white product: (3) ADup(P) AntiDupliCom ⃝ P.

The final result is that the Manin white product of AntiDupliCom and Lie is isomorphic to the operad AntiDupliLie. p. 2
Where the paper says it

, AntiDupliLie AntiZinbiel! As a further consequence, the anti-duplicator is described by a Manin white product: (3) ADup(P) AntiDupliCom ⃝ P.

Conclusion on White Products

The paper concludes by showing that the Manin white product of AntiDupliCom and Lie is isomorphic to the operad AntiDupliLie. This result is achieved through a chain of isomorphisms involving anti-duplicators, anti-successors, and Koszul duality. p. 0

Where the paper says it

ANTI-SUCCESSORS AND ANTI-REPLICATORS, MANIN PRODUCTS AND KOSZUL DUALITY CHENGMING BAI, LI GUO, YUNHE SHENG, AND YOU WANG Abstract. We develop an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replication for binary operads.

The work provides an efficient way to compute the white Manin product of a binary quadratic operad with the operad AntiDupliCom. p. 2
Where the paper says it

As a further consequence, the anti-duplicator is described by a Manin white product: (3) ADup(P) AntiDupliCom ⃝ P. Thus the anti-replicator supplies, as in the ordinary theory [17, 34], an effective way to compute a class of Manin white products.

References

[1] K. Abdurasulov, J. Adashev, Z. Normatov and Sh. Solijonova, Classification of three dimensional antidendriform algebras, Comm. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Examples of anti-replicators of binary operads 24 5. Koszul duality between anti-successors and anti-replicators 28 References 34 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification.

Algebra 53 (2025), no. p. 0
Where the paper says it

18M70, 17B60, 18M60, 17B63, Key words and phrases. Operad, successor, replicator, Manin product, Koszul duality, post-Lie algebra, pre-Lie algebra.

5, 1887-1903

[2] M. Aguiar, Pre-Poisson algebras, Lett. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Splitting and replicating operations. A basic example of splitting is provided by dendriform algebras: two binary operations are combined to recover an associative product, and related constructions lead to tridendriform, pre-Lie, pre-Poisson and other structures; see, among many sources, [2, 5, 13, 27, 28].

Math. Phys. 54 (2000), 263-277

[3] C. Bai, O. Bellier, L. Guo and X. Ni, Splitting of operations, Manin products, and Rota-Baxter operators, Int. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Subsequently, authors of [3] introduced the bisuccessor and trisuccessor of a binary operad and showed, for binary quadratic operads, that these constructions are governed by Manin black products and Rota–Baxter operators. The splitting procedure was later extended from binary operads to general algebraic operads through the configuration formalism [32].

Math Res Not (2013), no 3

[4] C. Bai and D. Gao, Graded anti-pre-Lie algebraic structures on Witt and Virasoro algebras, J Geom Phys 214 (2025), Paper No 105525

[5] C. Bai, L. Guo and X. Ni, Nonabelian generalized Lax pairs, the classical Yang-Baxter equation and PostLie algebras, Comm Math Phys 297 (2010), 553-596

[6] K. Basdouri and S. Benabdelhafidh, Generalized anti-dendriform algebras and anti-NS-algebras, São Paulo J Math Sci 19 (2025), Paper No 36

[7] M. Bershtein, V. Dotsenko and A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The theory of operads provides a natural framework for understanding such constructions in a unified manner. In this direction, Dotsenko and his collaborators made important contributions to the study of compatible operations, quadratic operads and Koszul duality, as well as to the development of Gröbner basis methods for operads [10, 12, 7, 11].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The theory of operads provides a natural framework for understanding such constructions in a unified manner. In this direction, Dotsenko and his collaborators made important contributions to the study of compatible operations, quadratic operads and Koszul duality, as well as to the development of Gröbner basis methods for operads [10, 12, 7, 11].

Khoroshkin, Quadratic algebras related to the bi-Hamiltonian operad, Int Math Res Not (2007), no 24

[8] Z. Chen, Wells sequences for abelian extensions of anti-pre-Lie algebras by their modules, J Geom Phys 229 (2026), Paper No 105962

[9] Z. Chen and H. Liu, Geometric structures of anti-pre-Lie algebras, J Geom Phys 225 (2026), Paper No 105818

[10] V. Dotsenko, Compatible associative products and trees, Algebra Number Theory 3 (2009), no 5

[11] V. Dotsenko, A Quillen adjunction between algebras and operads, Koszul duality, and the Lagrange inversion formula, Int Math Res Not (2019), no 14

[12] V. Dotsenko and A. Khoroshkin, Gröbner bases for operads, Duke Math J 153 (2010), 363-396

[13] K. Ebrahimi-Fard, Loday-type algebras and the Rota-Baxter relation, Lett Math Phys 61 (2002), 139-147

[14] K. Ebrahimi-Fard and L. Guo, On products and duality of binary, quadratic, regular operads, J Pure Appl Algebra 200 (2005), 293-317

[15] D. Gao, G. Liu and C. Bai, Anti-dendriform algebras, new splitting of operations and Novikov-type algebras, J Algebraic Combin 59 (2024), no 3

[16] V. Ginzburg and M. M. Kapranov, Koszul duality for operads, Duke Math J 76 (1995), 203-272

[17] V. Yu Gubarev and P. S. Kolesnikov, Embedding of dendriform algebras into Rota–Baxter algebras, Cent Eur J Math 11 (2013), no 2

[18] V. Yu Gubarev and P. S. Kolesnikov, Operads of decorated trees and their duals, Comment Math Univ Carolin 55 (2014), no 4

[19] E. Hoffbeck, A Poincaré-Birkhoff-Witt criterion for Koszul operads, Manuscripta Math 131 (2010), 87-110

[20] P. S. Kolesnikov, F. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The splitting procedure was later extended from binary operads to general algebraic operads through the configuration formalism [32]. The theory of splitting of operations has been extended to alternative and Malcev structures by Madariaga [30], and further explored in connection with derived operations and Manin products of operads by Kolesnikov, Sartayev and Orazgaliev [22].

Mashurov and B. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The theory of splitting of operations has been extended to alternative and Malcev structures by Madariaga [30], and further explored in connection with derived operations and Manin products of operads by Kolesnikov, Sartayev and Orazgaliev [22]. Subsequently, Kolesnikov, Mashurov and Sartayev [20] investigated pre-Novikov algebras and derived Zinbiel varieties, while Kolesnikov and Sartayev [21] studied the behavior of the Dong property under various operadic constructions, including dendriform splitting and Manin products.

Sartayev, On pre-Novikov algebras and derived Zinbiel variety, SIGMA 20 (2024), no 017

[21] P. S. Kolesnikov and B. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The splitting procedure was later extended from binary operads to general algebraic operads through the configuration formalism [32]. The theory of splitting of operations has been extended to alternative and Malcev structures by Madariaga [30], and further explored in connection with derived operations and Manin products of operads by Kolesnikov, Sartayev and Orazgaliev [22].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The splitting procedure was later extended from binary operads to general algebraic operads through the configuration formalism [32]. The theory of splitting of operations has been extended to alternative and Malcev structures by Madariaga [30], and further explored in connection with derived operations and Manin products of operads by Kolesnikov, Sartayev and Orazgaliev [22].

K. Sartayev, On the Dong Property for a binary quadratic operad, J Algebra 691 (2026), 428-452

[22] P. S. Kolesnikov and B. K. Sartayev and A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The splitting procedure was later extended from binary operads to general algebraic operads through the configuration formalism [32]. The theory of splitting of operations has been extended to alternative and Malcev structures by Madariaga [30], and further explored in connection with derived operations and Manin products of operads by Kolesnikov, Sartayev and Orazgaliev [22].

Orazgaliev, Gelfand-Dorfman algebras, derived identities, and the Manin product of operads, J Algebra 539 (2019), 260-284

[23] P. S. Kolesnikov and V. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The splitting procedure was later extended from binary operads to general algebraic operads through the configuration formalism [32]. The theory of splitting of operations has been extended to alternative and Malcev structures by Madariaga [30], and further explored in connection with derived operations and Manin products of operads by Kolesnikov, Sartayev and Orazgaliev [22].

Yu Voronin, On special identities for dialgebras, Linear Multilinear Algebra 61 (2013), no 3

[24] G. Liu and C. Bai, Anti-pre-Lie algebras, Novikov algebras and commutative 2-cocycles on Lie algebras, J Algebra 609 (2022), 337-379

[25] G. Liu and C. Bai, New splittings of operations of Poisson algebras and transposed Poisson algebras and related algebraic structures, Algebra without Borders-Classical and Constructive Nonassociative Algebraic Structures, Springer Cham (2023), 49-96

[26] G. Liu and C. Bai, A bialgebra theory for transposed Poisson algebras via anti-pre-Lie bialgebras and anti-preLie Poisson bialgebras, Commun Contemp Math 26 (2024), No 8

[27] J.-L. Loday, Dialgebras, in Dialgebras and related operads, Lecture Notes in Math 1763 (2002), 7-66

[28] J.-L. Loday and M. Ronco, Trialalgebras and families of polytopes, in Homotopy Theory: Relations with Algebraic Geometry, Group Cohomology, and Algebraic K-theory, Comtep Math 346 (2004), 369-398

[29] J.-L. Loday and B. Vallette, Algebraic Operads, Grundlehren Math Wiss 346, Springer Heidelberg 2012

[30] S. Madariaga, Splitting of operations for alternative and Malcev structures, Comm Algebra 45 (2017), no 1

[31] Z. Normatov, Compatible anti-pre-Lie algebras, J Algebra Appl 25 (2026), 2650220

[34] J. Pei, C. Bai and L. Guo and X. Ni, Replicators, Manin white product of binary operads and average operators New trends in algebras and combinatorics World Scientific Publishing Co Pte Ltd Hackensack NJ (2020), 317-353

[37] B. Vallette, Manin products, Koszul duality, Loday algebras and Deligne conjecture J Reine Angew Math 620 (2008), 105-164

How the training signal is built

The relationship between anti-successors and anti-replicators is forced by additional compatibility relations, which are essential for Koszul duality. These extra relations force the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions to be Koszul dual to each other. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Motivated by the recent appearance of anti-pre-Lie and anti-dendriform algebras, we develop an operadic anti-version of this picture, introducing antisuccessors and anti-replicators and relating them to Manin black and white products. A central point is that the anti-theory is not obtained by merely changing signs: additional compatibility relations, and their dual intersections, are essential—and it is precisely these extra relations that force the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions to be Koszul dual to each other.

This leads simultaneously to Manin black-product descriptions on the splitting side and Manin white-product descriptions on the replicating side. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Thus the additional relations are not auxiliary: they are precisely what makes the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions dual. This leads simultaneously to Manin black-product descriptions on the splitting side and Manin white-product descriptions on the replicating side.

Where the gains come from

The anti-replicator ADup(P) is defined by intersections of relation spaces, specifically ADup(P):= T(V)/(ADup(R)) ∩ (comp(R)). The proof of Theorem 5. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Dually, we introduce the anti-duplicator ADup(P) and anti-triplicator ATrip(P). Their defining intersections are explained by the central quadratic-duality theorem (2) ADup(P !

2 shows that ADup(P! p. 0
Where the paper says it

For binary quadratic operads, the process gives Manin black products, ABSu(P) AntiPreLie • P, ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P. Dually, we introduce the anti-duplicator ADup(P) and anti-triplicator ATrip(P) and prove ADup(P !

) = ABSu(P)! This implies that the anti-duplicator relates to the anti-successor construction via the dual operad. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Consequently, the anti-duplicator gives a new way to calculate Manin white products. The framework recovers known anti-splittings, including anti-dendriform, anti-pre-Lie, and anti-pre-Poisson structures, in a uniform operadic form and produces further examples and dual pairs.

The work provides an efficient way to compute the white Manin product of a binary quadratic operad with AntiDupliCom. p. 2
Where the paper says it

As a further consequence, the anti-duplicator is described by a Manin white product: (3) ADup(P) AntiDupliCom ⃝ P. Thus the anti-replicator supplies, as in the ordinary theory [17, 34], an effective way to compute a class of Manin white products.

Conclusion on Duality

The paper proves that the anti-duplicator ADup(P!) is in Koszul dual with the anti-successor ABSu(P)! p. 1

Where the paper says it

Motivated by the recent appearance of anti-pre-Lie and anti-dendriform algebras, we develop an operadic anti-version of this picture, introducing antisuccessors and anti-replicators and relating them to Manin black and white products. A central point is that the anti-theory is not obtained by merely changing signs: additional compatibility relations, and their dual intersections, are essential—and it is precisely these extra relations that force the anti-successor and anti-replicator constructions to be Koszul dual to each other.

The operad AntiDupliCom is shown to be the Koszul dual of the operad AntiPreLie. p. 2
Where the paper says it

) ATSu(P) ! In particular, we introduce the notions of anti-dupli-com algebras and anti-dupli-Lie algebras, and the following properties hold at the operadic level: AntiDupliCom AntiPreLie!

Similarly, the operad AntiDupliLie is shown to be the Koszul dual of the operad AntiZinbiel. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In particular, we introduce the notions of anti-dupli-com algebras and anti-dupli-Lie algebras, and the following properties hold at the operadic level: AntiDupliCom AntiPreLie! , AntiDupliLie AntiZinbiel!

The final result confirms that the Manin white product of AntiDupliCom and Lie is isomorphic to the operad AntiDupliLie. p. 2
Where the paper says it

, AntiDupliLie AntiZinbiel! As a further consequence, the anti-duplicator is described by a Manin white product: (3) ADup(P) AntiDupliCom ⃝ P.

The entire framework provides a new characterization of the Manin white product. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Consequently, the anti-duplicator gives a new way to calculate Manin white products. The framework recovers known anti-splittings, including anti-dendriform, anti-pre-Lie, and anti-pre-Poisson structures, in a uniform operadic form and produces further examples and dual pairs.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can compute Manin black products of binary quadratic operads using anti-post-Lie algebras by relating them to anti-trisuccessors, as shown in Theorem 3.2: We have the isomorphism of operads ATSu(P) AntiPostLie • P.

  2. Improved AI can compute Manin white products by using anti-duplicators, as stated in Theorem 5.7: Let P = T(V)/(R) be a binary quadratic operad with R, 0. Then we have the isomorphism of operads ADup(P) AntiDupliCom ⃝ P.

  3. Improved AI can establish Koszul duality between anti-successors and anti-replicators by proving that taking the anti-successor of a binary operad is in Koszul dual with taking the anti-replicator of the dual operad (Theorem 5.2).

  4. Improved AI can characterize specific algebraic structures by relating them to known operads, such as showing that AntiDend encoding anti-dendriform algebras is the anti-bisuccessor of the nonsymmetric operad Ass (Proposition 2.19).

  5. Improved AI can compute the structure of AntiPreLie products on other operads, as indicated by Corollary 3.5: We have AntiPreLie • Com AntiZinbiel, AntiPreLie • Ass AntiDend and AntiPreLie • Poisson AntiPrePoisson.

  6. Improved AI can relate anti-duplicators to specific algebraic operads, such as showing that AntiDupliCom is the Koszul dual of the operad AntiPreLie (Corollary 5.4).

Abstract

We develop an operadic theory of anti-splitting and anti-replicating for binary operads. For a binary operad, we define its anti-bisuccessor and anti-trisuccessor. Each generating operation is recovered as the negative sum of two or three split operations, yielding canonical operad morphisms to and to. For binary quadratic operads, these constructions are described by Manin black products:,. Dually, we also introduce the canonical quadratic anti-duplicator and anti-triplicator, together with their combinatorial counterparts defined by labeled planar binary trees. We show that they coincide precisely under a full-support condition. As applications, we obtain anti-dupli-com and anti-dupli-Lie algebras. We also display an example in which the two constructions differ. Furthermore, we establish the Koszul duality relations (!) !, (!) !, providing an effective description of the canonical quadratic anti-duplicator in terms of the Manin white product. The framework recovers known constructions, including anti-dendriform, anti-pre-Lie and anti-pre-Poisson algebras, and produces further examples and Koszul dual pairs.

Related papers