All Order Gravitational Wave Tails from Classical Soft Theorem for Subleading Post-Newtonian Expansion
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "All Order Gravitational Wave Tails from Classical Soft Theorem for Subleading Post-Newtonian Expansion".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper determines the complete tower of late- and early-time tail terms in classical gravitational waveforms emitted during scattering processes at first subleading post-Newtonian order by extending universal results to include corrections from the first subleading term in the velocity expansion 3.
Kai: Leading Logarithmic Tail Determination The leading-logarithmic tails are determined to all orders in Newton’s constant G at the retained order in the velocity expansion, and this determination extends to the first subleading order in the post-Newtonian expansion of the asymptotic states 3.
Mira: The correction arises from the first subleading term in the retardation expansion and is determined by the asymptotic Newtonian trajectories of massive particles 4.
Kai: For two → 2 scattering, the leading-logarithmic series can be summed in closed form, and these results agree with a relativistic conjecture proposed in earlier work 3.
Title and authors: Kai: So we’re looking at this paper now, "All Order Gravitational Wave Tails from Classical Soft Theorem for Subleading Post-Newtonian Expansion." It covers how to get the full set of late and early time tail terms in classical gravitational waveforms from scattering processes.
Mira: What that means is they are taking what was known about those universal Newtonian limits and extending it to include corrections from the first subleading term in the velocity expansion. It’s about getting a complete tower of these tail terms at this new order.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we think about running this on real hardware, we're dealing with these complex corrections that depend on where you are in space and how fast things are moving.
Kai: The paper says they determine the leading-logarithmic tails to all orders in Newton’s constant G at the retained order in the velocity expansion, and it extends that to the first subleading order in the post-Newtonian expansion of those asymptotic states.
Mira: That extension comes from looking at how things behave during retardation, which is determined by the asymptotic Newtonian trajectories of massive particles. This correction arises from that first subleading term in the retardation expansion.
Lev: I wonder how much overhead this adds when you try to map this onto actual detector noise, because tracking those trajectories over long distances introduces velocity dependence that we have to handle carefully.
Kai: For two to two scattering, they found they can sum up the leading-logarithmic series in a closed form, and these results actually agree with a relativistic conjecture that was proposed earlier.
Mira: That agreement is interesting because it suggests the structure of these tails is more robust than we might have thought, even when moving into those next-to-Newtonian corrections.
Lev: If this holds up in a closed form, it means there's a cleaner way to compute the waveform structure rather than having to sum up an infinite series term by term.
Kai: Then there’s this part about source moment dependence, where the correction to the Newtonian waveform at order alpha cubed depends on the mass octupole moment and on the angular momentum density.
Mira: The source is evaluated on the past light cone of your detector, which introduces an extra power of velocity into that waveform, creating this alpha cubed correction they are looking at.
Lev: So that means if we were building a detector sensitive to these higher-order effects, we'd need to account for how the mass distribution moments affect the signal in those specific high-velocity regimes.
Kai: They give a specific expression for this leading correction to the Newtonian waveform, written as e ij equals G R d squared u squared over three d u nk I kij plus two over three nk J ki j plus J kj i.
Mira: That expression clearly shows how the octupole moment and angular momentum density feed into that specific correction term at order alpha cubed.
Title and authors: Lev: Looking at that, the real challenge for me is figuring out how to measure those moments accurately enough to see this effect above the noise floor in a real experiment.
Kai: Now they spend a lot of time analyzing error terms E1, E2 and E3, and they argue that these terms can be ignored at the order derived for the waveform.
Mira: They point out that for example, error term E1 encountered in equation two point seven actually contributes to an order higher than what we are focusing on here.
Lev: That’s helpful because it tells us exactly where we stop needing to worry about those specific terms if we only care about the leading-logarithmic behavior at this order.
Kai: They also look at error term E3 in equation two point two eight, which captures the correction to the Newtonian gravitational force due to additional forces.
Mira: And they argue that ignoring it is fine because there's a way we can show that the kinetic energies and gravitational potential energy contributions from error term E2 actually fall into a higher order than what we are considering at alpha cubed.
Lev: So they’re essentially saying these specific error terms are just noise relative to the main signal structure we care about right now, which simplifies things for a practical calculation.
Kai: For two particles in each asymptotic state, they give us the late time waveform with equation one point three, which is quite involved.
Mira: In the center-of-mass frame, that second term in the tail coefficient vanishes directly because of spatial momentum conservation, which simplifies things a bit for us.
Lev: That vanishing term is good for us because it means we don't have to worry about those complicated momentum terms when we analyze the simplest case of equal mass particles.
Kai: The first term in that center-of-mass frame can be written in this form, which involves the logarithm of w, the frequency.
Mira: It looks like they’ve managed to write that term in a way that clearly shows it scales with the logarithm of frequency divided by the frequency itself over some combination of velocity and position terms.
Lev: That structure, involving ln w over w cubed, is exactly what we need to see if we want to compare this result against those conjectures from earlier work.
Kai: They compare this derived waveform at order alpha cubed with the conjectured waveform in reference one, showing they agree even when expanding that conjecture into both the Newtonian and next-to-Newtonian limits.
Mira: That comparison confirms that following their conjecture, you can recover the result at order (ln w) squared over w cubed in both those limits.
Lev: It’s good to see that consistency across different ways of approaching the problem validates this calculation method for us when we try to build error correction schemes.
Title and authors: Kai: They also provide the quadratic gravitational vertex, which is given by G ij equals H00 partial i partial j H00 plus half the gradient of H00 times itself minus delta ij H00 times the Laplacian of H00 minus three over four delta ij times the gradient of one one times itself.
Mira: That spatial quadratic tensor shows exactly how the curvature terms feed into that vertex calculation, which is fundamental for understanding how gravity propagates in this context.
Lev: From an engineering view, calculating that full quadratic tensor requires knowing the metric fluctuations to a very high order, so it’s a lot of computational work to implement reliably.
Kai: The angular average of the gravitational contribution is given by e ij H alpha cubed z equals minus two G squared alpha squared w over Xa m a b v iab plus zc iab v jab plus zc jab ⃗vab + z⃗cab cubed plus G squared z alpha cubed w over R Xa < b m a m b d/dz
n dot (va va plus vb va plus z(ca ab + cb ab) v i ab plus zc i ab)(v j ab + zc j ab) ⃗vab + z⃗cab cubed <ref:2610.20770#pg2>. [Mira: This angular average shows how the gravitational contribution spreads out across angles, involving terms that scale with the square of alpha and also terms that scale with alpha cubed.
Lev: The presence of these higher powers of alpha in the angular average is a big deal because it tells us that these effects are not just small perturbations; they have a definite scaling behavior.
Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on "All Order Gravitational Wave Tails from Classical Soft Theorem for Subleading Post-Newtonian Expansion," the leading-logarithmic tail terms for every r greater than or equal to one are determined by the asymptotic masses and velocities.
Mira: This is a significant finding because it means we don't need a specific model of the dynamics in the finite interaction region to get these universal results.
Lev: That universality, where the result only depends on the asymptotic data, is what makes this useful for us when we think about building general simulations rather than just modeling one specific collision.
Kai: So, while there are some caveats about error terms contributing at higher orders, the paper gives us a complete picture of these leading-logarithmic corrections at this order.
Mira: It’s a lot of work to derive this complete tower, but the consistency with earlier conjectures and the clear structure of those coefficients is what makes it compelling for theorists.
Lev: For real hardware, it means we know exactly what scaling we're dealing with when we look at these subtle corrections in our measured signals.
Kai: We’ve looked at how this paper, "All Order Gravitational Wave Tails from Classical Soft Theorem for Subleading Post-Newtonian Expansion," sets the stage for understanding the gravitational field generated during scattering processes.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper is about finding the complete set of late and early time tail terms in gravitational waveforms from scattering processes at first subleading post-Newtonian order by extending universal results to include corrections from the first subleading term in the velocity expansion.
Mira: What that means is they’re taking what was already known about those universal Newtonian limits and adding corrections based on the first subleading term in how fast things are moving.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, we're dealing with these complex corrections that depend on where you are in space and how fast things are moving.
Kai: The paper says they determine the leading-logarithmic tails to all orders in Newton’s constant G at the order they kept for the velocity expansion, and that extends to the first subleading order in how those asymptotic states behave.
Mira: That extension comes from looking at how things behave during retardation, which is determined by the Newtonian paths of massive particles. That correction comes from that first subleading term in that retardation expansion.
Lev: I wonder how much overhead this adds when you try to map this onto actual detector noise because tracking those paths over long distances introduces velocity dependence we have to handle carefully.
Kai: For two to two scattering, they found they can sum up the leading-logarithmic series in a closed form, and these results actually agree with a relativistic conjecture that was proposed earlier.
Mira: That agreement is interesting because it suggests the structure of these tails is more robust than we might have thought, even when moving into those next-to-Newtonian corrections.
Lev: If this holds up in a closed form, it means there's a cleaner way to compute the waveform structure rather than having to sum up an infinite series term by term.
Kai: Then there’s this part about source moment dependence where the correction to the Newtonian waveform at order alpha cubed depends on the mass octupole moment and on the angular momentum density.
Mira: The source is evaluated on the past light cone of your detector, which introduces an extra power of velocity into that waveform, creating this alpha cubed correction they are looking at.
Lev: So that means if we were building a detector sensitive to these higher-order effects we'd need to account for how those mass distribution moments affect the signal in those specific high-velocity regimes.
Kai: They give a specific expression for this leading correction to the Newtonian waveform written as e ij equals G R d squared u squared over three d u nk I kij plus two over three nk J ki j plus J kj i.
Mira: That expression clearly shows how the octupole moment and angular momentum density feed into that specific correction term at order alpha cubed.
Lev: Looking at that the real challenge for me is figuring out how to measure those moments accurately enough to see this effect above the noise floor in a real experiment.
The paper's summary: Kai: Now they spend a lot of time analyzing error terms E1, E2 and E3 and they argue that these terms can be ignored at the order derived for the waveform.
Mira: They point out that for example error term E1 encountered in equation two point seven actually contributes to an order higher than what we are focusing on here.
Lev: That’s helpful because it tells us exactly where we stop needing to worry about those specific terms if we only care about the leading-logarithmic behavior at this order.
Kai: They also look at error term E3 in equation two point two eight which captures the correction to the Newtonian gravitational force due to additional forces.
Mira: And they argue that ignoring it is fine because there's a way we can show that the kinetic energies and gravitational potential energy contributions from error term E2 actually fall into a higher order than what we are considering at alpha cubed.
Lev: So they’re essentially saying these specific error terms are just noise relative to the main signal structure we care about right now which simplifies things for a practical calculation.
Kai: For two particles in each asymptotic state they give us the late time waveform with equation one point three which is quite involved.
Mira: In the center of mass frame that second term in the tail coefficient vanishes directly because of spatial momentum conservation which simplifies things a bit for us.
Lev: That vanishing term is good for us because it means we don't have to worry about those complicated momentum terms when we analyze the simplest case of equal mass particles.
Kai: The first term in that center of mass frame can be written in this form which involves the logarithm of w divided by w cubed over some combination of velocity and position terms.
Mira: It looks like they’ve managed to write that term in a way that clearly shows it scales with the logarithm of frequency divided by the frequency itself over some combination of velocity and position terms.
Lev: That structure involving log w over w cubed is exactly what we need to see if we want to compare this result against those conjectures from earlier work.
Kai: They compare this derived waveform at order alpha cubed with the conjectured waveform in reference one showing they agree even when expanding that conjecture into both the Newtonian and next-to-Newtonian limits.
Mira: That comparison confirms that following their conjecture you can recover the result at order log w squared over w cubed in both those limits.
Lev: It’s good to see that consistency across different ways of approaching the problem validates this calculation method for us when we try to build error correction schemes.
Kai: They also provide the quadratic gravitational vertex which is given by G ij equals H00 partial i partial j H00 plus half the gradient of H00 times itself minus delta ij H00 times the Laplacian of H00 minus three over four delta ij times the gradient of one one times itself.
The paper's summary: Mira: That spatial quadratic tensor shows exactly how the curvature terms feed into that vertex calculation which is fundamental for understanding how gravity propagates in this context.
Lev: From an engineering view calculating that full quadratic tensor requires knowing the metric fluctuations to a very high order so it’s a lot of computational work to implement reliably.
Kai: The angular average of the gravitational contribution is given by e ij H alpha cubed z equals minus two G squared alpha squared w over Xa m a b v iab plus zc iab v jab plus zc jab ⃗vab + z⃗cab cubed plus G squared z alpha cubed w over R Xa < b m a m b d/dz
n dot (va va plus vb va plus z(ca ab + cb ab) v i ab plus zc i ab)(v j ab + zc j ab) ⃗vab + z⃗cab cubed. [Mira: This angular average shows how the gravitational contribution spreads out across angles involving terms that scale with the square of alpha and also terms that scale with alpha cubed.
Lev: The presence of these higher powers of alpha in the angular average is a big deal because it tells us that these effects are not just small perturbations they have a definite scaling behavior.
Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "All Order Gravitational Wave Tails from Classical Soft Theorem for Subleading Post-Newtonian Expansion" the leading-logarithmic tail terms for every r greater than or equal to one are determined by the asymptotic masses and velocities.
Mira: This is a significant finding because it means we don't need a specific model of the dynamics in the finite interaction region to get these universal results.
Lev: That universality where the result only depends on the asymptotic data is what makes this useful for us when we think about building general simulations rather than just modeling one specific collision.
Kai: So while there are some caveats about error terms contributing at higher orders the paper gives us a complete picture of these leading-logarithmic corrections at this order.
Mira: It’s a lot of work to derive this complete tower but the consistency with earlier conjectures and the clear structure of those coefficients is what makes it compelling for theorists.
Lev: For real hardware it means we know exactly what scaling we're dealing with when we look at these subtle corrections in our measured signals.
Kai: We’ve looked at how this paper "All Order Gravitational Wave Tails from Classical Soft Theorem for Subleading Post-Newtonian Expansion" sets the stage for understanding the gravitational field generated during scattering processes.
Mira: This work really confirms that even when you go beyond Newtonian physics, the underlying structure of these signals is still governed by those initial simple asymptotic conditions.
Lev: And it gives us a solid benchmark to test our error correction models against when we look at real detector data.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, this paper suggests some ways to make these results even better by looking at three specific areas.
Mira: What does that mean for the physics of gravitational waves? I need you to explain it simply.
Lev: It means they are trying to clean up the math by showing where the assumptions break down or where we can ignore certain parts.
Kai: They focus on improving the determination of those leading-logarithmic tails by extending previous results into the first subleading order of velocity expansion, which is what we called alpha cubed corrections earlier.
Mira: So they’re essentially refining how much detail we need to keep in our calculation for these high-velocity scattering events.
Lev: The improvement they suggest is that you can analyze the error terms E1, E2 and E3 to prove that they only contribute at higher orders, like alpha four or higher.
Kai: That means for the leading-logarithmic waveform at order alpha cubed we can just ignore those specific error terms because they don't actually affect our main result.
Mira: And another improvement is about how the source moment dependence works, specifically how they determine if the mass octupole moment and angular momentum density are truly enough to describe that correction at order alpha cubed.
Lev: It’s a practical thing because it tells us exactly what physical properties we need to measure from a collision to get a reliable signal.
Kai: They also point out that for the two-body case, they can do something neat: they sum up the entire leading logarithmic series in one closed form, which simplifies things immensely.
Mira: That closed form is cool because it bypasses having to compute an infinite number of terms separately.
Lev: For hardware running this on a real detector that has finite precision, that closed form means you have a much clearer target for what the signal should look like in the long time tail.
Kai: And finally, they compare their derived waveform at order alpha cubed with a conjecture from reference one, showing they match in both the Newtonian and next-to-Newtonian limits.
Mira: That comparison is important because it validates that their method of finding these universal results actually holds up when you push the physics to higher orders.
Lev: It gives us confidence that if we build our error correction models based on this structure, they’ll be sound for those next-to-Newtonian corrections too.
Kai: So what this changes for someone who only listens to the show is that we have a more complete picture of the gravitational signal at these specific high orders, even though some error terms are still there.
Mira: It confirms that following their conjecture allows you to recover the result in both limits, which is a strong structural confirmation of what we’re seeing.
Lev: And it gives us a solid benchmark to test our error correction models against when we look at real detector data.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve covered the complete tower of late and early time tail terms in classical gravitational waveforms from scattering processes at first subleading post-Newtonian order by extending universal results to include corrections from the first subleading term in the velocity expansion.
Mira: This work essentially shows that you can get these universal results just by looking at how fast things are moving and where they are located, without needing a specific model of what happens in the very close interaction region.
Lev: From my side, it’s a bit of an exercise in showing how the error terms behave so we know exactly where to stop worrying about them for real hardware simulations.
Kai: The main implication is that we now have a complete set of leading-logarithmic corrections determined by the asymptotic masses and velocities across every possible order of G.
Mira: It’s a strong structural finding because it means the fundamental way these signals decay doesn't change even when you add those next-to-Newtonian tweaks.
Lev: For running on real hardware, it means we know exactly what scaling we're dealing with when we look at those subtle corrections in our measured signals.
Kai: So, to wrap up this paper "All Order Gravitational Wave Tails from Classical Soft Theorem for Subleading Post-Newtonian Expansion," the leading-logarithmic tail terms for every r greater than or equal to one are determined by the asymptotic masses and velocities.
Mira: This is a significant finding because it means we don't need a specific model of the dynamics in the finite interaction region to get these universal results.
Lev: That universality where the result only depends on the asymptotic data is what makes this useful for us when we think about building general simulations rather than just modeling one specific collision.
Kai: So while there are some caveats about error terms contributing at higher orders the paper gives us a complete picture of these leading-logarithmic corrections at this order.
Mira: It’s a lot of work to derive this complete tower but the consistency with earlier conjectures and the clear structure of those coefficients is what makes it compelling for theorists.
Lev: And it gives us a solid benchmark to test our error correction models against when we look at real detector data.
International Centre for Theoretical Sciences (ICTS-TIFR) · Tata Institute of Fundamental Research
hep-th, gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-10-14
Updated: 2026-11-07
Comments: 29 pages + appendices, small change in the title, references added
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: The paper determines the complete tower of late- and early-time tail terms in classical gravitational waveforms emitted during scattering processes at first subleading post-Newtonian order by…
Key concepts
- Leading Logarithmic Tail Determination
- This involves finding the dominant, long-time decay of gravitational waves. The paper shows these tails can be determined to all orders in Newton's constant G when considering the first subleading correction in the velocity expansion, linking them to asymptotic Newtonian trajectories.
- Source Moment Dependence
- The correction to the Newtonian waveform at order O(alpha³) depends on specific properties of the source, namely the mass octupole moment and angular-momentum density. These moments are found by evaluating the source on the detector's past light cone, which introduces a velocity dependence.
- Error Term Analysis
- The analysis shows that certain error terms (E1, E2, E3) can be ignored at the calculated order O(alpha³). This is because these terms contribute only at higher orders (O(alpha⁴) or greater), justifying their exclusion when calculating the leading-logarithmic waveform.
- Two-Body Waveform Result
- For two particles in each asymptotic state, a closed-form expression for the late-time waveform is derived. In the center-of-mass frame, this result simplifies significantly due to momentum conservation, showing that the order O(alpha³) contribution vanishes for equal masses.
Terminology
Summary
The paper determines the complete tower of late- and early-time tail terms in classical gravitational waveforms emitted during scattering processes at first subleading post-Newtonian order by extending universal results to include corrections from the first subleading term in the velocity expansion 3. p. 0 in
Abstract: The low-frequency gravitational waveform emitted in a classical scattering process
contains an infinite tower of late- and early-time tail terms of the form u
−r
(ln|u|)
r−1
, r ≥ 1. In the
Newtonian limit, the coefficients of this entire tower have recently been shown to be universal, i.Where the paper says it
Leading Logarithmic Tail Determination
The leading-logarithmic tails are determined to all orders in Newton’s constant G at the retained order in the velocity expansion, and this determination extends to the first subleading order in the post-Newtonian expansion of the asymptotic states 3. The correction arises from the first subleading term in the retardation expansion and is determined by the asymptotic Newtonian trajectories of massive particles 4. p. 0 We consider scattering of an arbitrary number of incoming and outgoing nonrelativistic
objects interacting only through gravity at long range, and we derive the complete tower of
tail terms at this order. The correction arises from the first subleading term in the retardation
expansion and is determined by the asymptotic Newtonian trajectories of the massive particles. For 2 → 2 scattering, the leading-logarithmic series can be summed
in closed form. Our results agree with a relativistic conjecture proposed in earlier work [1].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Source Moment Dependence
The correction to the Newtonian waveform at order O(α3) depends on the mass octupole moment and on the angular-momentum density 4. The source is evaluated on the past light cone of the detector, which introduces an additional power of velocity into the waveform, producing the O(α3) correction considered here 5. p. 3 The source
is evaluated on the past light cone of the detector, which gives the retarded-time argument u+⃗n·⃗x
at leading order in 1/R. Expanding this argument introduces one additional power of velocity
into the waveform, producing the O(α
3
) correction considered here. 9) we obtain
S
kij =
1
6
∂
2
uI
kij +
1
3
∂u
J
ki|j + J
kj|i
. 15)
Therefore the leading correction to the Newtonian waveform can be written as
e
ij
(1) =
G
R
d
2
du2
1
3
d
du
nkI
kij
+
2
3
nk
J
ki|j + J
kj|i
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Error Term Analysis
The error terms E1, E2 and E3 can be ignored at the order derived for the waveform 3 A analysis of the error terms 5 A.1 Analysis of the error term E ij 1 in this appendix we will argue that the error E ij 1 encountered in eq. p. 7 In appendix
A. 1 we argue that the error E
ij
1
contributes to the correction of the Newtonian waveform at higher
order than what we intend to derive. In appendix
A. 1 we argue that the error E
ij
1
contributes to the correction of the Newtonian waveform at higher
order than what we intend to derive. In appendix
A. 1 we argue that the error E
ij
1
contributes to the correction of the Newtonian waveform at higher
order than what we intend to derive. 3 Combined contribution and matching with the PN waveform 25
5 Conclusion 28
A Analysis of the error terms 29
A. 1 Analysis of the error term E
ij
1
29
A. where E
ij
1
captures the higher order terms due to Taylor expanding T
ij (u + ⃗n · ⃗x). In appendix
A. 3 Combined contribution and matching with the PN waveform 25
5 Conclusion 28
A Analysis of the error terms 29
A. 1 Analysis of the error term E
ij
1
29
A. 17)
Of course, there will be corrections due to the velocity of the particles as well as the gravitational potential energy
that we will ignore for now. Later we will argue that these corrections lead to waveform at higher order than what
we are considering her 17)
Of course, there will be corrections due to the velocity of the particles as well as the gravitational potential energy
that we will ignore for now. Later we will argue that these corrections lead to waveform at higher order than what
we are considering her 3 Combined contribution and matching with the PN waveform 25
5 Conclusion 28
A Analysis of the error terms 29
A. 1 Analysis of the error term E
ij
1
29
A. where E
ij
1
captures the higher order terms due to Taylor expanding T
ij (u + ⃗n · ⃗x). In appendix
A. where E
ij
1
captures the higher order terms due to Taylor expanding T
ij (u + ⃗n · ⃗x). In appendix
A. In appendix
A. 1 we argue that the error E
ij
1
contributes to the correction of the Newtonian waveform at higher
order than what we intend to derive. 3 Combined contribution and matching with the PN waveform 25
5 Conclusion 28
A Analysis of the error terms 29
A. 1 Analysis of the error term E
ij
1
29
A. 3 Combined contribution and matching with the PN waveform 25
5 Conclusion 28
A Analysis of the error terms 29
A. 1 Analysis of the error term E
ij
1
29
A.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Two-Body Waveform Result
For two particles in each asymptotic state, the late time waveform is given by e ij (1)(w) = 2G α cubed / R X a ma (n · va) v ia v ja + m1 m2 γ (m1 + m2) w (n · v squared h(v i1 + v i2)v j + (v j1 + v j2)v i - (r - 1) n · (m1⃗v1 + m2⃗v2) / m1 + m2 v i v j) 3. In the center-of-mass frame, the memory term becomes X 2 a=1 ma(n · va)v ia v ja = m1m2 δm (m1 + m2) squared (n · v)v i v j 3. p. 7 9) can be written in terms
of the mass octupole. Note that to write the second equality we have used integration by parts
under the assumption that the boundary term vanishes at infinity for large |⃗x|. 9) can be written in terms
of the mass octupole. Note that to write the second equality we have used integration by parts
under the assumption that the boundary term vanishes at infinity for large |⃗x|. 9)
In the following we show that the fully symmetric part of S
kij can be written in terms of the
so-called mass octupole, I
kij . And the remaining part can be written in terms of the first spatial
moment of the angular-momentum density, J
ki|j defined as 4
I
kij =
Z
d
3x xkx
ix
jT
00(u, ⃗x), J
ki|j =
Z
d
3x xj
x
kT
0i
(u, ⃗x) − x
iT
0k
(u, ⃗x)
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Comparison with Relativistic Conjecture
The conjecture for the targeted waveform A ij(3) in the next-to-Newtonian order also agrees with the derived waveform in section 2 4. The comparison with the corresponding expansion of the conjecture in [1] provides a further check at order α cubed 3 B Comparison with the conjectured A µν(3) in this appendix we will show that following their conjecture we can recover the waveform at order (lnw) 2/w cubed in both the Newtonian and the next-to-Newtonian limit 4 B. p. 3 It is therefore natural to
ask whether the leading-logarithmic contributions at this order require new information about the
encounter, or whether they are still determined entirely by the asymptotic data. These results also
provide a further check of the arbitrary-velocity conjecture proposed in section 5 of [1], beyond
its leading Newtonian limit.Where the paper says it
Quadratic Gravitational Vertex
The spatial quadratic tensor entering the vertex is given by G ij(2) = H 00∂i∂jH 00 + 1/2 (∂iH 00)(∂jH 00) − δ ijH 00∇ 2H 00 − 3/4 δ ij (∂kH 11)(∂kH 11) 4 C Quadratic gravitational vertex 5
Angular Average Result
The angular average of the gravitational contribution is given by e ij H(α cubed z) = - 2G squared α squared w / X a m a b (v iab + zc iab)(v jab + zc jab) ⃗vab + z⃗cab cubed + G squared z α cubed w / R X a < b m a m b d/dz ([n · (va + vb + z(ca + cb))](v i ab + zc i ab)(v j ab + zc j ab) ⃗vab + z⃗cab 3) 4 D Angular average
Conclusion on Universality
The leading-logarithmic tail terms in the gravitational waveform for every r ≥ 1 are determined by the asymptotic masses and velocities, without requiring a model of the dynamics in the finite interaction region 3.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
The AI system can derive explicit expressions for all universal terms in the soft expansion by extending previous results to first subleading order in the post-Newtonian expansion, as shown by computing corrections at O(alpha 3).
-
The system can perform a comparison between its derived waveform and the all-order conjecture proposed in reference [1] by expanding it into small velocity parameter alpha and retaining Newtonian contributions at order alpha 2 and subleading contributions at order alpha 3.
-
The AI can analyze the error terms E1, E2, and E3 to prove that they contribute only at higher orders (O(alpha 4) or higher), justifying their neglect in the calculation of the leading-logarithmic waveform at order O(alpha 3).
-
The system can compute the mass octupole moment and the first spatial moment of the angular momentum density from energy-momentum conservation to determine that these are sufficient to determine eq.(1.1) at order O(alpha 3).
-
The AI can specialize the calculation to two particles in each asymptotic state, yielding a closed-form sum for the leading logarithmic series and showing that in the center of mass frame, the order alpha 3 contribution is proportional to the mass difference and vanishes for equal masses.
-
The system can test proposed relativistic expressions beyond their leading Newtonian limits by comparing its derived waveform at order alpha 3 with those obtained from reference [1] in both the Newtonian and next-to-Newtonian limits.
-
The AI can analyze the contribution of the pure gauge part to the gravitational vertex, showing that it scales as O(alpha-5) and thus can be safely ignored at these orders in alpha.
Abstract
The low-frequency gravitational waveform emitted in a classical scattering process contains an infinite tower of late- and early-time tail terms of the form u-r(u) r-1, r at least 1. In the Newtonian limit, the coefficients of this entire tower have recently been shown to be universal, i.e. fixed by the asymptotic data of the scattering objects alone. At the retained order in the velocity expansion, these leading-logarithmic tails are determined to all orders in Newton's constant G. We extend this result to the first subleading order in the post-Newtonian expansion of the asymptotic states. We consider scattering of an arbitrary number of incoming and outgoing nonrelativistic objects interacting only through gravity at long range, and we derive the complete tower of tail terms at this order. The correction arises from the first subleading term in the retardation expansion and is determined by the asymptotic Newtonian trajectories of the massive particles. Its coefficients are again determined entirely by the asymptotic trajectories and are independent of the details of the interaction. For 2 to2 scattering, the leading-logarithmic series can be summed in closed form. Our results agree with a relativistic conjecture proposed in earlier work arXiv:2610.07134.
Sources
- Logarithmic Terms in the Soft Expansion in Four Dimensions
- Observational Signature of the Logarithmic Terms in the Soft Graviton Theorem
- Classical and Quantum Results on Logarithmic Terms in the Soft Theorem in Four Dimensions
- Subleading Soft Theorem for arbitrary number of external soft photons and gravitons
- Proof of the Classical Soft Graviton Theorem in D=4
- Classical Sub-subleading Soft Photon and Soft Graviton Theorems in Four Spacetime Dimensions
- Classical Soft Graviton Theorem Rewritten
- Spin Dependent Gravitational Tail Memory in $D=4$
- Universality of Loop Corrected Soft Theorems in 4d
- Gravitational Wave Tails from Soft Theorem: A Short Review
- Gravitational Radiation from Massless Particle Collisions
- Soft gravitational radiation from ultra-relativistic collisions at sub- and sub-sub-leading order
- Soft Radiation from Scattering Amplitudes Revisited
- The gravitational eikonal: from particle, string and brane collisions to black-hole encounters
- Comparing One-loop Gravitational Bremsstrahlung Amplitudes to the Multipolar-Post-Minkowskian Waveform
- Post-Newtonian Multipoles from the Next-to-Leading Post-Minkowskian Gravitational Waveform
- Gravitational Waveform: A Tale of Two Formalisms
- 2PM waveform from loop corrected soft theorems
- Amplitudes, Observables, and Classical Scattering
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions