Actions in varieties of non-associative algebras: a survey

arXiv:2610.18302 · math.CT, math.RA · Submitted 2026-10-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: I'm Ada.

Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Actions in varieties of non-associative algebras: a survey".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. ACTIONS IN VARIETIES OF NON-ASSOCIATIVE ALGEBRAS: A SURVEY This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field The paper discusses action representability, weak action representability, and action accessibility, along with constructions for the universal strict general actor and the external weak actor Categorical Framework and Action Notions Semi-abelian categories were introduced to provide a categorical setting capturing common algebraic properties shared by groups, rings, and algebras Internal actions are particularly well behaved when the functor Actp´, Xq or equivalently SplExtp´, Xq is representable for every object X Action representability requires an actor rXs such that there is a natural isomorphism SplExtp´, Xq – HomC p´,rXsq We have the implications action representability ñ weak action representability ñ action accessibility Action accessibility is defined by requiring that every object of SplExtpXq be accessible, meaning it admits a morphism into a subterminal or faithful object Weak Representation and Derived Actions A weak representation of SplExtp´, Xq involves an object T such that there is a natural monomorphism of functors τ: SplExtp´, Xq ↣ HomC p´, Tq The category C is weakly action representable if SplExtp´, Xq admits a weak representation for every object X Derived actions are defined in any category of groups with operations and can be used to describe split extensions The bijections ηB extend to a natural isomorphism of functors between SplExtp´, Xq – DActp´, Xq Varieties of Non-Associative Algebras The main algebraic setting is that of varieties of non-associative algebras over a fixed field F determined by a fixed set of polynomial identities Varieties are classified based on their defining identities, such as the variety Lie or the variety AbAlg For example, in characteristic different from 2, Lie is the only non-abelian action representable variety External Weak Actor and Conclusions The external weak actor E pXq is constructed for every object X of an action accessible, operadic variety V The construction yields a natural monomorphism of functors τ: SplExtp´, Xq ↣ HomPAlgpUrp´q, E pXqq The results show that for certain varieties like Assoc and Leib, the external weak actor is isomorphic to the associative algebra of multipliers or the Leibniz algebra of biderivations, respectively The survey concludes by summarizing known results in Table 1 and outlining open questions for future research Table 1 collects the known results on the representability of actions in the varieties considered in this survey, over a field F with charpFq ≠ 2 For the weakly action representable varieties, it also indicates a weak representing object TpXq of an object X The table shows that AbAlg, Lie, Assoc, and NilkpAssocq are action accessible (AA), while others like JJord and ACAAssoc remain open for weak action representability (WRA) Categorical and Algebraic Properties of PAlg The category PAlg of partial algebras over a field is pointed, and its zero object is Urp0q, the zero algebra viewed as a partial algebra A natural direction for future work is to investigate its categorical and algebraic properties, with particular attention to the description of internal actions in PAlg Converse to Point (iii) of Theorem 5.14 The criterion provided by Theorem 5.14(iii) is sufficient, but not necessary, for weak action representability of a variety For instance, Leib is weakly action representable, but with the second choice of the λµ-rules in Example 5.9, the external weak actor of a Leibniz algebra need not be a Leibniz algebra External Weak Actors for Varieties of Algebras with Two Bilinear Operations The construction of the external weak actor E pXq can be extended to arbitrary action accessible, operadic varieties of algebras with two bilinear operations For instance, in ACAAssoc, its external weak actor is EndpXq with multiplication xf, gy “ ´f ˝ g The survey concludes by summarizing the known results and collecting some open questions for future research The paper suggests seeking additional hypotheses under which the failure of E pXq to satisfy the defining identities of V implies that V is not weakly action representable The construction of E pXq gives an alternative characterisation of split extensions in V References

1: M.

Ada: Barr, Exact categories, in: Exact Categories and Categories of Sheaves, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 236, Springer, Berlin, 1971, 1–120

2: F.

Emmy: Borceux, G.

Ada: Janelidze and G.

Paper summary: Ada: So, thinking about the title of "Actions in varieties of non-associative algebras: a survey," it really captures the breadth of what this paper covers across all those different algebraic structures they looked at. They weren't just looking at one thing, but mapping out the landscape of how actions behave in these kinds of systems.

Emmy: And what matters is that they connect action representability, weak action representability, and accessibility through these categorical tools. It’s not just a list of algebras; it’s a unified way to study the underlying structure that allows for those actions to exist in the first place.

Kolya: I see why it matters for people in probability or statistics too because they often deal with structures that are related, and understanding these representability conditions tells you when you can reliably use certain tools to analyze those structures.

Ada: Right. It shows that the strength of the action is highly dependent on the algebraic variety itself and the underlying field, which is a crucial piece of context for anyone trying to apply these results elsewhere.

Emmy: The paper suggests that while they have established some firm boundaries—like only Lie or abelian algebras under specific field conditions—the more nuanced notions like weak action representability allow us to explore a wider, though perhaps less constrained, universe of possibilities.

Kolya: It's about finding the right level of rigor for your investigation. If you’re aiming for the most general case, you have to deal with these weaker conditions because they give you more room to maneuver in terms of what kind of actor you might find.

Conclusion: Ada: So we've been looking at how actions work in these non-associative algebras, and now we're wrapping up this survey of "Actions in varieties of non-associative algebras: a survey."

Emmy: It really lays out the main results for action representability, weak action representability, and accessibility. It shows that these concepts are all linked together through this categorical framework.

Kolya: So basically, it's mapping out which algebraic structures can actually support an internal action in a way that we can prove mathematically.

Ada: Exactly. The authors are looking at how different varieties of algebras, like Lie or associative algebras, behave when you try to define an action on them over a field.

Emmy: They provide these constructions for the universal strict general actor and the external weak actor, which is pretty neat because it gives us a concrete way to understand these actions.

Kolya: It’s interesting that they found some specific results, like in characteristic different from two, where Lie is the only non-abelian action representable variety. That's a tight constraint for any system you're trying to build.

Ada: Yeah, it highlights how much the underlying field and the specific identities defining your algebra matter for what kind of actions you can even expect to find.

Emmy: The survey also points toward some open questions, like finding conditions where the external weak actor doesn't have to match a certain identity of its parent variety.

Kolya: That suggests there might be varieties that look representable on paper but don't actually behave that way in practice when you try to build them.

Ada: Right. It leaves us wondering what other specific hypotheses we need before we can definitively say a variety is weakly action representable.

University of Salento · Université catholique de Louvain · Università degli Studi di Palermo

math.CT, math.RA

Submitted: 2026-10-13

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: Revised and expanded version: commutative associative algebras added to the summary table (not weakly action representable, see arXiv:2306.02812v4); algebraic coherence and the property of being a 2-variety added to the characterisation of action accessibility; further references added

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 72/100

The gist: ACTIONS IN VARIETIES OF NON-ASSOCIATIVE ALGEBRAS: A SURVEY This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field The…

Key concepts

Action Representability
This is a property where the internal actions of an algebra are well-behaved. It requires the existence of a specific actor that establishes a natural link between two different functorial constructions related to the action, ensuring consistency across various algebraic contexts.
Weak Action Representability
A weaker condition than full action representability, this involves finding an object (a weak representation) that provides a natural monomorphism between the functor describing the internal actions and another functor. This allows for a description of split extensions in these categories.
External Weak Actor
This is a specific construction designed for action accessible varieties. It yields a natural monomorphism relating the functor of internal actions to a functor involving an external weak actor, which can be isomorphic to known structures like associative or Leibniz algebras in certain cases.

Terminology

Summary

ACTIONS IN VARIETIES OF NON-ASSOCIATIVE ALGEBRAS: A SURVEY This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field The paper discusses action representability, weak action representability, and action accessibility, along with constructions for the universal strict general actor and the external weak actor

Categorical Framework and Action Notions

Semi-abelian categories were introduced to provide a categorical setting capturing common algebraic properties shared by groups, rings, and algebras Internal actions are particularly well behaved when the functor Actp´, Xq or equivalently SplExtp´, Xq is representable for every object X Action representability requires an actor rXs such that there is a natural isomorphism SplExtp´, Xq – HomC p´,rXsq We have the implications action representability ñ weak action representability ñ action accessibility Action accessibility is defined by requiring that every object of SplExtpXq be accessible, meaning it admits a morphism into a subterminal or faithful object

Weak Representation and Derived Actions

A weak representation of SplExtp´, Xq involves an object T such that there is a natural monomorphism of functors τ: SplExtp´, Xq ↣ HomC p´, Tq The category C is weakly action representable if SplExtp´, Xq admits a weak representation for every object X Derived actions are defined in any category of groups with operations and can be used to describe split extensions The bijections ηB extend to a natural isomorphism of functors between SplExtp´, Xq – DActp´, Xq

Varieties of Non-Associative Algebras

The main algebraic setting is that of varieties of non-associative algebras over a fixed field F determined by a fixed set of polynomial identities Varieties are classified based on their defining identities, such as the variety Lie or the variety AbAlg For example, in characteristic different from 2, Lie is the only non-abelian action representable variety

External Weak Actor and Conclusions

The external weak actor E pXq is constructed for every object X of an action accessible, operadic variety V The construction yields a natural monomorphism of functors τ: SplExtp´, Xq ↣ HomPAlgpUrp´q, E pXqq The results show that for certain varieties like Assoc and Leib, the external weak actor is isomorphic to the associative algebra of multipliers or the Leibniz algebra of biderivations, respectively The survey concludes by summarizing known results in Table 1 and outlining open questions for future research

Summary of Known Results

Table 1 collects the known results on the representability of actions in the varieties considered in this survey, over a field F with charpFq ≠ 2 For the weakly action representable varieties, it also indicates a weak representing object TpXq of an object X The table shows that AbAlg, Lie, Assoc, and NilkpAssocq are action accessible (AA), while others like JJord and ACAAssoc remain open for weak action representability (WRA)

Categorical and Algebraic Properties of PAlg

The category PAlg of partial algebras over a field is pointed, and its zero object is Urp0q, the zero algebra viewed as a partial algebra A natural direction for future work is to investigate its categorical and algebraic properties, with particular attention to the description of internal actions in PAlg

Converse to Point (iii) of Theorem 5.14

The criterion provided by Theorem 5.14(iii) is sufficient, but not necessary, for weak action representability of a variety For instance, Leib is weakly action representable, but with the second choice of the λµ-rules in Example 5. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Janelidze proved in [20] that every weakly action representable category is action accessible. Thus, one has the implications action representability ñ weak action representability ñ action accessibility.

9, the external weak actor of a Leibniz algebra need not be a Leibniz algebra

External Weak Actors for Varieties of Algebras with Two Bilinear Operations

The construction of the external weak actor E pXq can be extended to arbitrary action accessible, operadic varieties of algebras with two bilinear operations For instance, in ACAAssoc, its external weak actor is EndpXq with multiplication xf, gy “ ´f ˝ g

Conclusion

The survey concludes by summarizing the known results and collecting some open questions for future research The paper suggests seeking additional hypotheses under which the failure of E pXq to satisfy the defining identities of V implies that V is not weakly action representable The construction of E pXq gives an alternative characterisation of split extensions in V

References

[1] M. Barr, Exact categories, in: Exact Categories and Categories of Sheaves, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 236, Springer, Berlin, 1971, 1–120

[2] F. Borceux, G. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Within this framework, F. Borceux, G.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Within this framework, F. Borceux, G.

Janelidze and G. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Introduction Semi-abelian categories were introduced by G. Janelidze, L. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Introduction Semi-abelian categories were introduced by G. Janelidze, L.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Introduction Semi-abelian categories were introduced by G. Janelidze, L.

M. Kelly, Internal object actions, Commentationes Mathematicae Universitatis Carolinae 46 (2005), no. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Kelly introduced the notion of an internal action [2], extending the classical correspondence between actions and split extensions from groups and Lie algebras to arbitrary semi-abelian categories. More precisely, for every object X of a semi-abelian category C , they proved that there is a natural isomorphism Actp´, Xq – SplExtp´, Xq, where ActpB, Xq denotes the set of actions of B on X and SplExtpB, Xq denotes the set of isomorphism classes of split extensions of B by X.

2, 235–255

[3] F. Borceux, G. Janelidze and G. M. Kelly, On the representability of actions in a semi-abelian category, Theory and Applications of Categories 14 (2005), no. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Kelly introduced the notion of an internal action [2], extending the classical correspondence between actions and split extensions from groups and Lie algebras to arbitrary semi-abelian categories. More precisely, for every object X of a semi-abelian category C , they proved that there is a natural isomorphism Actp´, Xq – SplExtp´, Xq, where ActpB, Xq denotes the set of actions of B on X and SplExtpB, Xq denotes the set of isomorphism classes of split extensions of B by X.

11, 244–286

[4] D. Bourn, Normalization equivalence, kernel equivalence and affine categories, in: Category Theory (Como, 1990), Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1488, Springer, Berlin, 1991, 43–62

[5] D. Bourn and G. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The strength of action representability led to the introduction of several weaker conditions. Bourn and G.

Janelidze, Centralizers in action accessible categories, Cahiers de Topologie et Géométrie Différentielle Catégoriques 50 (2009), no. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Janelidze in [5] to calculate centralisers of normal subobjects and of equivalence relations. It encompasses a wider class of categories, including categories that are not action representable, such as CAssoc and Assoc; more generally, every Orzech category of interest is action accessible; see Section 3.

3, 211–232

[6] J. Brox, X. García-Martínez, M. Mancini, T. p. 0

Where the paper says it

ACTIONS IN VARIETIES OF NON-ASSOCIATIVE ALGEBRAS: A SURVEY MANUEL MANCINI Abstract. This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field.

Van der Linden and C. Vienne, Weak representability of actions of non-associative algebras, Journal of Algebra 669 (2025), 401–444

[7] D. Burde and A. Fialowski, Jacobi–Jordan algebras, Linear Algebra and its Applications 459 (2014), 586–594

[8] W. Burnside, Theory of Groups of Finite Order, Cambridge University Press, 2012

[9] J. M. Casas, T. Datuashvili and M. p. 1

Where the paper says it

On the other hand, J. Datuashvili and M.

Ladra, Universal Strict General Actors and Actors in Categories of Interest, Applied Categorical Structures 18 (2010), 85–114

[10] A. S. Cigoli, J. R. A. Gray and T. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Nevertheless, action accessibility does not imply weak action representability in general, as shown by J. Gray in [18].

Van der Linden, Algebraically coherent categories, Theory and Applications of Categories 30 (2015), no. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field. We begin by recalling the general framework of internal actions and split extensions in semi-abelian categories, before specialising to Orzech categories of interest and varieties of non-associative algebras.

54, 1864–1905

[11] A. S. Cigoli, M. Mancini and G. p. 0

Where the paper says it

ACTIONS IN VARIETIES OF NON-ASSOCIATIVE ALGEBRAS: A SURVEY MANUEL MANCINI Abstract. This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field.

Metere, On the representability of actions of Leibniz algebras and Poisson algebras, Proceedings of the Edinburgh Mathematical Society 66 (2023), no. p. 0
Where the paper says it

ACTIONS IN VARIETIES OF NON-ASSOCIATIVE ALGEBRAS: A SURVEY MANUEL MANCINI Abstract. This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field.

4, 998–1021

[12] T. Datuashvili, Cohomologically trivial internal categories in categories of groups with operations, Applied Categorical Structures 3 (1995), no. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Janelidze and G. Kelly introduced the notion of an internal action [2], extending the classical correspondence between actions and split extensions from groups and Lie algebras to arbitrary semi-abelian categories.

3, 221–237

[13] A. Dioguardi Burgio, M. Mancini and T. p. 0

Where the paper says it

ACTIONS IN VARIETIES OF NON-ASSOCIATIVE ALGEBRAS: A SURVEY MANUEL MANCINI Abstract. This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field.

Van der Linden, Weak action representability of 2-nilpotent groups (2026), submitted, preprint arXiv:2604. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Internal action, split extension, weakly action representable category, category of interest, non-associative algebra, external weak actor. 1 arXiv:2610.

22578

[14] V. Dotsenko and X. García-Martínez, A characterisation of Lie algebras using ideals and subalgebras, Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society 56 (2024), no. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We also give a tensor-domain formulation of partial algebras and adapt the construction of the external weak actor to this setting. These notions are illustrated by examples arising from associative, Lie, Leibniz, Jacobi–Jordan, anti-commutative anti-associative, alternative, and 2-nilpotent algebras.

7, 2408–2423

[15] X. García-Martínez and M. Mancini, Action accessible and weakly action representable varieties of algebras, Bollettino dell’Unione Matematica Italiana 19 (2026), no. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Gray in [18]. More recently, it was proved in [15] that the varieties of k-nilpotent and n-solvable Lie algebras over a field are action accessible but not weakly action representable, for every k ě 3 and n ě 2, respectively.

2, 367–374

[16] X. García-Martínez, M. Tsishyn, T. Van der Linden and C. Vienne, Algebras with representable representations, Proceedings of the Edinburgh Mathematical Society 64 (2021), no. p. 0

Where the paper says it

More precisely, a semi-abelian category C is said to be action representable if, for every object X of C , there exists an object rXs of C , called the actor of X, together with a natural isomorphism SplExtp´, Xq – HomC p´,rXsq. The classical examples are the category of groups, where the actor of a group X is the automorphism group AutpXq, and the category of Lie algebras over a field, where the actor of a Lie algebra X is the Lie algebra of derivations DerpXq.

3, 555–573

[17] X. García-Martínez and T. Van der Linden, A characterisation of Lie algebras amongst anticommutative algebras, Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra 223 (2019), no. p. 0

Where the paper says it

More precisely, a semi-abelian category C is said to be action representable if, for every object X of C , there exists an object rXs of C , called the actor of X, together with a natural isomorphism SplExtp´, Xq – HomC p´,rXsq. The classical examples are the category of groups, where the actor of a group X is the automorphism group AutpXq, and the category of Lie algebras over a field, where the actor of a Lie algebra X is the Lie algebra of derivations DerpXq.

11, 4857–4870

[18] J. R. A. Gray, A note on the relationship between action accessible and weakly action representable categories, Theory and Applications of Categories 44 (2025), no. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Gray in [18]. More recently, it was proved in [15] that the varieties of k-nilpotent and n-solvable Lie algebras over a field are action accessible but not weakly action representable, for every k ě 3 and n ě 2, respectively.

8, 272–276

[19] N. Jacobson, Lie Algebras, Dover Publications, New York, 1979

[20] G. Janelidze, Central extensions of associative algebras and weakly action representable categories, Theory and Applications of Categories 38 (2022), no. p. 1

Where the paper says it

For an Orzech category of interest C , if USGApXq is an object of C for every object X of C , then the category is weakly action representable [11]. This applies, for example, to the categories of associative algebras and of Leibniz algebras over a field, with suitable presentations as Orzech categories of interest; see Examples 3.

36, 1395–1408

[21] G. Janelidze, L. Márki and W. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Janelidze, L. Márki and W.

Tholen, Semi-abelian categories, Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra 168 (2002), no. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For any F-algebra X, we write EndpXq for the vector space of F-linear endomorphisms of the underlying vector space of X. One of the notions that can be studied in the context of semi-abelian categories is that of an internal action [2].

2–3, 367–386

[25] J.-L. Loday, Une version non commutative des algèbres de Lie: les algèbres de Leibniz, L’Enseignement Mathématique 39 (1993), no. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We also give a tensor-domain formulation of partial algebras and adapt the construction of the external weak actor to this setting. These notions are illustrated by examples arising from associative, Lie, Leibniz, Jacobi–Jordan, anti-commutative anti-associative, alternative, and 2-nilpotent algebras.

3–4, 269–293

[26] S. Mac Lane, Extensions and obstructions for rings, Illinois Journal of Mathematics 2 (1958), no. p. 0

Where the paper says it

However, action representability is a restrictive condition. For instance, commutative associative algebras are not action representable [3], and it was proved in [16] that, over an 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced action analysis capability by integrating results from Theorem 3.17, which shows that internal actions are in natural bijection with derived actions, allowing AI to compute derived actions directly from split extensions using a functorial approach.

  2. Improved structural classification of algebras by utilizing the characterizations provided in Theorem 4.19, enabling the system to distinguish between action representable varieties (Lie and AbAlg) and their non-representable counterparts based on field characteristics.

  3. Expanded modeling of partial algebraic structures by implementing the construction of the external weak actor E pXq, which allows AI to analyze split extensions in a way that accounts for non-total multiplications using Definition 4.22 and Lemma 4.30.

  4. Deeper understanding of variety properties by allowing the system to check if an algebra satisfies the defining identities of a variety V by verifying the conditions in Corollary 5.2, which links these identities to the λmu-rules and derived actions on objects X in V.

  5. Advanced representation of action accessibility by enabling AI to determine if a category is weakly action representable by checking the existence of an actor or weak representing object, as established in Remark 2.26 and Proposition 3.20.

Abstract

This article surveys the main results on the representability of internal actions in varieties of non-associative algebras over a field. We begin by recalling the general framework of internal actions and split extensions in semi-abelian categories, before specialising to Orzech categories of interest and varieties of non-associative algebras. We discuss action representability, weak action representability, and action accessibility, with emphasis on the relationship between the latter two notions. We then describe the constructions of the universal strict general actor in Orzech categories of interest and the external weak actor in action accessible, operadic varieties of non-associative algebras over a field, as well as their role in the study of weak action representability. We also give a tensor-domain formulation of partial algebras and adapt the construction of the external weak actor to this setting. These notions are illustrated by examples arising from associative, Lie, Leibniz, Jacobi-Jordan, anti-commutative anti-associative, alternative, and 2-nilpotent algebras. We conclude with a summary of the known results and some open questions for future research.

Sources

Related papers