Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field

arXiv:2610.17787 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-10-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field is calculated by finding an analytic expression for the cross section up to order (eB)2 for heavy quark (Q) production through gluon fusion g + g → Q + Q¯ in a constant weak external magnetic field B having strength eB ≪ m2Q.

Kai: Theoretical Framework The calculation employs the weak-field expansion of the fermion propagator calculated using Schwinger’s proper-time formalism Owing to the hierarchy of scales (m2Q ≫ eB), effects on external lines are neglected since √eB ≪ mQ.

Mira: The magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, making the cross section anisotropic and dependent on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and incoming gluons in the center of mass frame.

Kai: Cross Section Components The total cross-section is decomposed into a leading-order vacuum cross section σ0(s) and a magnetic correction σcor(s, B, θ).

Title and authors: Kai: So, looking at what we just covered, what's the actual substance of this paper? It’s about how heavy quarks, like charm or bottom quarks, are made in these specific conditions.

Mira: They take the gluon fusion process g plus g going into a heavy quark pair and see how that changes when you introduce a weak magnetic field B.

Lev: I mean, it sets up this framework where they use this weak-field expansion of the fermion propagator to get an expression for the cross section in terms of eB squared.

Kai: It’s interesting because they’re not just looking at a simple vacuum rate; they are finding these specific magnetic corrections that scale with eB squared, not linearly with eB.

Mira: That scaling is important because it means the leading magnetic term in the propagator is linear in eB, so squaring it gives you that quadratic dependence on eB.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, that implies the leading magnetic contribution to the amplitude squared scales as (eB) two, which is what they use to get their correction term sigma cor.

Kai: So, if we think about this for heavy-ion collisions later, this paper gives us a way to predict how the anisotropy would manifest based on these fundamental QCD processes.

Mira: It’s setting the stage for seeing how initial magnetic fields might imprint themselves on the resulting heavy quark observables.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what is the core finding they are presenting in this work? They calculate the total cross section by splitting it into a standard vacuum part and a magnetic correction term.

Mira: The main result is that this magnetic correction term scales as (eB) two and it depends on cos two theta and cos four theta, which shows the breaking of rotational symmetry.

Lev: That dependence on cos two theta and cos four theta comes from the terms in the amplitude squared that don't vanish when you integrate over the Mandelstam variable t.

Kai: The paper finds that this anisotropy function A of s B is defined as the difference between cross sections at zero angle and pi over two, which measures how much things change with orientation.

Mira: And they found this asymmetry peaks near the production threshold of sqrt s equal to two times the heavy quark mass, mQ squared.

Lev: It’s also important that they note that this asymmetry scales as eB squared over m four Q, which tells us something about how sensitive it is to different types of quarks.

Kai: That m four Q scaling means it’s much more sensitive for the charm quark than for the bottom quark pair production.

The paper's improvements: Mira: Now, where does this paper suggest things could be improved or what its implications are? They focus on how this calculation affects different heavy quarks.

Lev: The authors point out that the sensitivity to the magnetic field is highly dependent on the quark mass because of that m four Q factor they mentioned earlier.

Kai: So, if we were to study bottom quark production, we expect it to be less sensitive than charm because of that suppression factor.

Mira: That’s right. The paper suggests that experimental searches should focus on the near-threshold kinematic regime where this asymmetry is maximized near sqrt s equal to two times mQ.

Lev: They emphasize that the relative anisotropy, which is defined as the difference between cross sections at zero and pi over two angles, remains approximately constant for both chosen values of sqrt s.

Kai: That constancy across different energy scales suggests that this relative anisotropy might serve as a gauge-invariant measure of the magnetic field effect.

Conclusion: Mira: So, to wrap up what we've heard about "Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field," they conclude that this anisotropy is not just a mathematical artifact.

Lev: They find that at angle theta equal to pi over two, the correction term is negative, which means the magnetic field actually suppresses the cross section compared to vacuum results there.

Kai: But it enhances it when theta equals zero and pi, where the gluons are aligned with the magnetic field direction.

Mira: The total angle averaged cross section correction turns out to be negative for all values of sqrt s, indicating a net suppression of the total cross section when averaged over all angles.

Lev: So, to summarize what we learned about this paper, it calculates how a weak magnetic field causes an anisotropic correction to heavy quark production that scales as eB squared and depends on cos two theta and cos four theta.

Kai: The real implication is that experimental searches for magnetic field-induced anisotropy in heavy quark production should prioritize the near-threshold kinematic regime because that’s where the asymmetry is maximized.

Mira: And specifically, this effect is considerably more visible in the charm quark channel than in the bottom quark channel due to that m four Q suppression factor.

Lev: We're done with this paper for now; it gives us a solid theoretical baseline for what we might look for when searching for initial-stage magnetic fields in heavy-ion collisions.

School of Physics and Technology, Nanjing Normal University · Department of Physical Sciences, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Berhampur · Government General Degree College Kharagpur-II

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-10-13

Updated: 2026-11-06

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field is calculated by finding an analytic expression for the cross section up to order (eB)2 for heavy quark (Q) production through gluon…

Key concepts

Schwinger’s proper-time formalism
This mathematical technique is used to calculate how a particle propagates through an external field, like a magnetic field. It allows physicists to find the quantum mechanical description of the heavy quark's movement in this specific environment. It helps derive the necessary terms for calculating the cross-section corrections.
Anisotropy
Anisotropy means that a physical quantity, like a cross-section, is not the same in all directions. In this context, it means the probability of producing heavy quarks depends on how they are oriented relative to the external magnetic field. The magnetic field breaks rotational symmetry, causing this directional dependence.
Asymmetry function A(s, B)
This function measures the difference in the total cross-section when measured at two different orientations relative to the magnetic field (e.g., parallel versus perpendicular). It quantifies the degree of anisotropy. The paper finds this asymmetry peaks near the production threshold and is a key signature for experimental searches.
Quark Mass Sensitivity
The sensitivity of heavy quarks to external fields is determined by how quickly their mass scales with the magnetic field strength. Because the magnetic effect scales as (eB)2/m^4Q, charm quarks (lighter) show a much stronger dependence than bottom quarks (heavier). This makes charm production more sensitive to the magnetic field effects.

Terminology

Summary

Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field is calculated by finding an analytic expression for the cross section up to order (eB)2 for heavy quark (Q) production through gluon fusion g + g → Q + Q¯ in a constant weak external magnetic field B having strength eB ≪ m2Q. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field Sudeep Saha,1, ∗ Sandeep Chatterjee,2, † Ujjal Kumar Dey,2, ‡ and Snigdha Ghosh3, § 1School of Physics and Technology, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, 210023, China 2Department of Physical Sciences, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Berhampur, Berhampur, Odisha 760003, India 3Government General Degree College Kharagpur-II, Paschim Medinipur- 721149, West Bengal, India (Dated: October 14, 2026) We calculate analytic expression for the cross section up to order (eB) 2 for the heavy quark (Q) production of mass mQ through the gluon (g) fusion process g + g → Q + Q¯ in the presence of a constant weak external magnetic field (B) having strength eB ≪ m2 Q. This is done by the weak-field expansion of the fermion propagator calculated using Schwinger’s proper-time formalism.

Theoretical Framework

The calculation employs the weak-field expansion of the fermion propagator calculated using Schwinger’s proper-time formalism Owing to the hierarchy of scales (m2Q ≫ eB), effects on external lines are neglected since √eB ≪ mQ. The magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, making the cross section anisotropic and dependent on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Owing to the hierarchy of scales (m2 Q ≫ eB), we neglect the effects of the magnetic field on the quark and antiquark spinors in the external lines. Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame.

Cross Section Components

The total cross-section is decomposed into a leading-order vacuum cross section σ0(s) and a magnetic correction σcor(s, B, θ). The correction to the leading-order cross section scales as (eB)2 rather than (eB), arising because the leading magnetic term S1(p) is linear in eB and contributes through S12∝(eB)2. p. 9

Where the paper says it

(48) that the correction to the leading-order cross section scales as (eB) 2 rather than (eB). This arises because the term S1(p) defined in Eq.

The correction terms depend on cos 2θ and cos 4θ, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

Kinematic Dependence and Asymmetry

The kinematic configuration in the presence of a magnetic field involves parallel (∥) and perpendicular (⊥) components of four-vectors, leading to Lorentz scalars that explicitly depend on the orientation angle θ between incoming gluons and the magnetic field. The asymmetry function A(s, B) = [σtot(s, B, 0) − σtot(s, B, π/2)] measures the relative difference between cross sections at extremal orientations. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The total cross-section depends on the Mandelstam variable s, the magnetic field B and the angle θ between the direction of the magnetic field and the incoming gluons momenta, as shown in Fig. The total cross-section σtot(s, B, θ) obtained from the invariant amplitude squared is given by σtot(s, B, θ) = σ0(s) + σcor(s, B, θ) = 1 16πλ(s, 0, 0) Z m2 Q− s 2 [1−β] m2 Q− s 2 [1+β] |M|2 dt,

This asymmetry peaks near the production threshold √s ≈ 2mQ and decreases with increasing invariant mass. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The cross section is maximized when the gluons propagate along the field direction (θ = 0, π) and minimized in the perpendicular configuration (θ = π/2). The resulting asymmetry peaks near the production threshold and falls with increasing center of mass energy, scaling as (eB) 2 /m4 Q with the quark mass.

Quark Mass Sensitivity

The asymmetry scales as (eB)2/m4Q, which makes it more sensitive to the charm quark channel than for the bottom quark pair production. This is expected behavior since the asymmetry [σtot(s, B, 0) − σtot(s, B, π/2)] scales as (eB)2/m4Q. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The total cross-section depends on the Mandelstam variable s, the magnetic field B and the angle θ between the direction of the magnetic field and the incoming gluons momenta, as shown in Fig. The total cross-section σtot(s, B, θ) obtained from the invariant amplitude squared is given by σtot(s, B, θ) = σ0(s) + σcor(s, B, θ) = 1 16πλ(s, 0, 0) Z m2 Q− s 2 [1−β] m2 Q− s 2 [1+β] |M|2 dt,

Heavier quarks are considerably less sensitive to the magnetic field due to the hierarchy eB ≪ m2Q that underlies the weak-field approximation. p. 2
Where the paper says it

FERMION PROPAGATOR IN A WEAK BACKGROUND MAGNETIC FIELD For the process g + g → Q + Q¯ in heavy-ion collisions, we assume that the produced heavy quarks (charm or bottom) with mass mQ satisfy m2 Q ≫ eB, where eB ∼ m2 π ∼ 1018 G is the typical magnetic field strength generated in non-central collisions [8–10, 39, 45]. This scale hierarchy justifies a weak-field expansion of the fermion propagator, treating the magnetic field as a perturbative correction to the free Dirac propagator.

Conclusion and Signatures

The results suggest that experimental searches for magnetic field-induced anisotropy in heavy quark production should focus on the near-threshold kinematic regime, where the asymmetry is maximized. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The resulting asymmetry peaks near the production threshold and falls with increasing center of mass energy, scaling as (eB) 2 /m4 Q with the quark mass. These results provide direct, calculable signatures of the initial-stage magnetic field in relativistic heavy-ion collisions which can, in principle, be imprinted on heavy-flavour observables measured in the final state of heavy-ion collisions.

The charm quark channel is considerably more sensitive than the bottom channel due to the m−4Q suppression of the effect. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The cross-term between S t b and S t a is purely imaginary due to the explicit factor i in S t b , and since the physical amplitude squared must be real, this term vanishes. The final form of the amplitude squared for the t−channel is given by |Mt| 2 = g 4 s Ctt Tr γµ p/1 + mQ γ µS t a (p1 − q1)γ ν p/2 − mQ γνS t† a (p1 − q1) + γµ p/1 + mQ γ µS t b (p1 − q1)γ ν p/2 − mQ γνS t† b (p1 − q1) , (20) where S t a (p1 − q1) = p/1 − /q 1 + mQ t − m2 Q , St b (p1 − q1) = eB p/1 − /q 1 ∥ + mQ γ 1γ 2 (t − m2 Q) 2 .

This anisotropy [σtot(s, B, 0) − σtot(s, B, π/2)], which is solely governed by the coefficient of cos 2θ remains approximately constant across the two chosen values of √s. The relative anisotropy provides a gauge-invariant measure of the magnetic field effect and could in principle serve as an experimental signature of the initial-stage magnetic field in heavy-ion collisions. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The resulting asymmetry peaks near the production threshold and falls with increasing center of mass energy, scaling as (eB) 2 /m4 Q with the quark mass. These results provide direct, calculable signatures of the initial-stage magnetic field in relativistic heavy-ion collisions which can, in principle, be imprinted on heavy-flavour observables measured in the final state of heavy-ion collisions.

The correction at θ = π/2 is found to be negative, meaning that the magnetic field suppresses the cross section in this configuration relative to the vacuum result, while it enhances it at θ = 0 and θ = π. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field. The cross section is maximized when the gluons propagate along the field direction (θ = 0, π) and minimized in the perpendicular configuration (θ = π/2).

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field. The cross section is maximized when the gluons propagate along the field direction (θ = 0, π) and minimized in the perpendicular configuration (θ = π/2).

The total angle-averaged cross section correction is found to be negative for all values of √s, indicating a net suppression of the total angleaveraged cross section in the presence of the magnetic field. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

Summary and Conclusions

In this work, we have calculated the cross section for heavy quark pair production via the gluon fusion process g + g → Q + Q¯ in the presence of a weak external magnetic field, motivated by the intense magnetic fields generated in the early stages of non-central heavy-ion collisions at RHIC and LHC. The calculation is carried out at leading order in perturbative QCD, with the effect of the magnetic field incorporated through a perturbative expansion of the fermion propagator in Schwinger’s proper-time formalism. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field Sudeep Saha,1, ∗ Sandeep Chatterjee,2, † Ujjal Kumar Dey,2, ‡ and Snigdha Ghosh3, § 1School of Physics and Technology, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, 210023, China 2Department of Physical Sciences, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Berhampur, Berhampur, Odisha 760003, India 3Government General Degree College Kharagpur-II, Paschim Medinipur- 721149, West Bengal, India (Dated: October 14, 2026) We calculate analytic expression for the cross section up to order (eB) 2 for the heavy quark (Q) production of mass mQ through the gluon (g) fusion process g + g → Q + Q¯ in the presence of a constant weak external magnetic field (B) having strength eB ≪ m2 Q. This is done by the weak-field expansion of the fermion propagator calculated using Schwinger’s proper-time formalism.

Acknowledgments

S.G. is funded by the Department of Higher Education, Government of West Bengal, India. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Heavy flavour production in the presence of a weak magnetic field Sudeep Saha,1, ∗ Sandeep Chatterjee,2, † Ujjal Kumar Dey,2, ‡ and Snigdha Ghosh3, § 1School of Physics and Technology, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, 210023, China 2Department of Physical Sciences, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Berhampur, Berhampur, Odisha 760003, India 3Government General Degree College Kharagpur-II, Paschim Medinipur- 721149, West Bengal, India (Dated: October 14, 2026) We calculate analytic expression for the cross section up to order (eB) 2 for the heavy quark (Q) production of mass mQ through the gluon (g) fusion process g + g → Q + Q¯ in the presence of a constant weak external magnetic field (B) having strength eB ≪ m2 Q. This is done by the weak-field expansion of the fermion propagator calculated using Schwinger’s proper-time formalism.

Appendix A provides explicit expressions for the amplitude squared in a weak magnetic field The magnetic field introduces a preferred spatial direction — namely, the direction of B along the z-axis — thereby breaking the rotational symmetry of the process. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field. The cross section is maximized when the gluons propagate along the field direction (θ = 0, π) and minimized in the perpendicular configuration (θ = π/2).

As a consequence, the parallel (along B) and perpendicular (transverse to B) components of the momenta enter through magnetic correction to propagator and through kinematic Lorentz scalars. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The last two four-vectors can be replaced by the conservation of four-momentum for the parallel and perpendicular components p2∥ = q1∥ + q2∥ − p1∥, p2⊥ = q1⊥ + q2⊥ − p1⊥. (44) So finally, we list all the possible Lorentz scalars that can be constructed out of these four-vectors q 2 1∥ = s 4 sin2 θ, q2 1⊥ = s 4 sin2 θ, q2 2∥ = s 4 sin2 θ, q2 2⊥ = s 4 sin2 θ, p 2 1∥ = s 4 − s 4 − m2 Q cos2 α, p2 1⊥ = s 4 − m2 Q 1 − cos2 α , q1∥ · q2∥ = s 4 1 + cos2 θ , q1∥ · p1∥ = s 4 (1 − β cos θ cos α), q1⊥ · q2⊥ = − s 4 sin2 θ, q1⊥ · p1⊥ = s 4 β (cos θ ′ − cos θ cos α), q2∥ · p1∥ = s 4 (1 + β cos θ cos α), q2⊥ · p1⊥ = s 4 β (− cos θ ′ + cos θ cos α).

The final expressions for the amplitude squared of different channels are given in Eq. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The total amplitude squared of different channels can be written as |M|2 = |Mt + Mu + Ms| 2 = |Mt| 2 + |Mu| 2 + |Ms| 2 + 2Re|MtM† u + MtM† s + MuM† s |. (16) We first consider the t−channel, the amplitude squared for this channel is given by |Mt| 2 = g 4 s CttTr h γµ p/1 + mQ γ µSw(p1 − q1)γ ν p/2 − mQ γνS † w(p1 − q1) i , (17) where the colour factor is Ctt = P col Tr t a t b t b t a = CAC 2 F = 16 3 , gs is the gauge coupling constant of the SU(3) colour group, and we have taken the fermion propagator up to order eB, i.

A2, A3, and A4. The terms M2(0) and M2(1) yield the leading-order vacuum cross section (Eq. p. 9
Where the paper says it

We first consider the cross-section σ0(s), due to the first term of the propagator in Eq. 18, which is also the leading-order heavy quark production cross-section in vacuum.

47) and the magnetic field correction (Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

48), respectively. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Schwinger proper-time representation The fermion propagator in a constant background field admits an elegant representation via Schwinger’s propertime method [50]. Working in the operator formalism, we denote xµ and pµ as the eigenvalues of the position and the momentum operators, respectively.

The terms M2(2) and M2(3), proportional to sin 2θ and sin 2θ cos 2θ respectively, vanish identically upon integration over the Mandelstam variable t in the cross-section formula. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

Consequently, the magnetic field correction to the total cross section retains only cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, as given in Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

48. The correction at θ = π/2 is found to be negative, meaning that the magnetic field suppresses the cross section in this configuration relative to the vacuum result, while it enhances it at θ = 0 and θ = π. The total cross-section decomposes naturally as σtot(s, B, θ) = σ0(s) + σcor(s, B, θ) where σ0(s) is the standard leading-order vacuum cross section and σcor(s, B, θ) is the magnetic correction. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The total cross-section depends on the Mandelstam variable s, the magnetic field B and the angle θ between the direction of the magnetic field and the incoming gluons momenta, as shown in Fig. The total cross-section σtot(s, B, θ) obtained from the invariant amplitude squared is given by σtot(s, B, θ) = σ0(s) + σcor(s, B, θ) = 1 16πλ(s, 0, 0) Z m2 Q− s 2 [1−β] m2 Q− s 2 [1+β] |M|2 dt,

The correction to the leading-order crosssection scales as (eB)2 rather than (eB). p. 9
Where the paper says it

(48) In the weak-field approximation, the magnetic field acts as a perturbation, and it is evident from Eq. (48) that the correction to the leading-order cross section scales as (eB) 2 rather than (eB).

This arises because the leading magnetic term S1(p) in the propagator is linear in eB and contributes to the amplitude squared through S12∝(eB)2. p. 9
Where the paper says it

This arises because the term S1(p) defined in Eq. (13), is linear in (eB) and contributes to the amplitude squared only through |S1| 2 , since the interference terms between S0(p) and S1(p) are purely imaginary and vanish upon taking the real part of the amplitude squared, as discussed in subsection III A.

Also, interference terms between S0(p) and S1(p) are purely imaginary and vanish upon taking the real part of the amplitude squared. p. 6
Where the paper says it

7 2Re|MtM† s | = 2g 4 s CtsTr p/1 + mQ γ µS t a (p1 − q1)γ ν p/2 − mQ K s† µν , (27) 2Re|MuM† s | = 2g 4 s CusTr p/1 + mQ γ νS u a (p1 − q1)γ µ p/2 − mQ K s† µν , (28) for the cross-channels the colour factors are Ctu = P col Tr t a t b t a t b = − CF 2 = − 2 3 , Cts = P col if cabTr t b t a t c = C 2 ACF 2 = 6 and Cus = P col if abcTr t c t a t b = − C 2 ACF 2 = −6. In ts and us cross-channels, the interference terms between S t(u) b and K† µν are purely imaginary − owing to the explicit factor of i in S t(u) b , and thus vanish upon taking the real part of the amplitude squared.

The presence of the magnetic field breaks rotational symmetry of the process, rendering the cross section anisotropic. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

The magnetic correction depends on orientation angle θ between incoming gluon momenta and B direction through cos 2θ and cos 4θ terms. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

The equality σcor(s, B, 0) = σcor(s, B, π) follows directly from the periodicity of cos 2θ and cos 4θ. p. 9
Where the paper says it

This equality follows directly from Eq. (48), where the θ-dependence enters only through cos 2θ and cos 4θ, both of which takes the same value at θ = 0 and θ = π.

The correction at θ = π/2 is found to be negative. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

The total cross-section exhibits a π-periodic pattern, consistent with the cos 2θ and cos 4θ structure of the σcor(s, θ) in Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the relative orientation angle (θ) between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) 2 and is found to have cos 2θ and cos 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field.

(48). The maximum occurs at θ = 0 and θ = π, corresponding to gluon momenta aligned with the magnetic field, while the minimum occurs at θ = π/2. p. 8
Where the paper says it

In the presence of the magnetic field, however, the parallel and perpendicular projections of the momenta enter independently, introducing explicit dependence on the orientation angle θ between the incoming gluons and the direction of the magnetic field. In the limit θ → π/2 the gluons propagate perpendicular to the magnetic field, while θ → 0, π the corresponding propagation is parallel and anti-parallel to the magnetic field.

The relative anisotropy [σtot(s, B, 0) − σtot(s, B, π/2)] provides a gauge-invariant measure of the magnetic field effect and could in principle serve as an experimental signature of the initial-stage magnetic field in heavy-ion collisions. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The resulting asymmetry peaks near the production threshold and falls with increasing center of mass energy, scaling as (eB) 2 /m4 Q with the quark mass. These results provide direct, calculable signatures of the initial-stage magnetic field in relativistic heavy-ion collisions which can, in principle, be imprinted on heavy-flavour observables measured in the final state of heavy-ion collisions.

The asymmetry peaks nears the production threshold √s ≈ 2mQ and decreases with increasing √s, for both values of the magnetic field. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The resulting asymmetry peaks near the production threshold and falls with increasing center of mass energy, scaling as (eB) 2 /m4 Q with the quark mass. These results provide direct, calculable signatures of the initial-stage magnetic field in relativistic heavy-ion collisions which can, in principle, be imprinted on heavy-flavour observables measured in the final state of heavy-ion collisions.

The asymmetry scales as (eB)2/m4Q, which makes it more sensitive to the charm quark channel than for the bottom quark. p. 1
Where the paper says it

07 fm for charm quark and 0. 02 fm for bottom quark) is much shorter than the QGP formation time (τ0 ∼ 0.

The results suggest that experimental searches for magnetic field-induced anisotropy in heavy quark production should focus on the near-threshold kinematic regime, where the asymmetry is maximized.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can calculate analytic expressions for heavy quark production cross sections up to order (eB)2 for g + g -> Q + Qbar in a constant weak external magnetic field B having strength eB << m2Q by using Schwinger’s proper-time formalism.

  2. Improved AI can determine the anisotropy of the cross section by calculating the correction term sigma cor(s, B, th) which scales as (eB)2 and depends on cos 2theta and cos 4theta terms.

  3. Improved AI can predict that heavy quarks are considerably less sensitive to magnetic fields than lighter quarks because the asymmetry scales as (eB)2/m4Q, making it more sensitive to the charm quark channel than for the bottom quark pair production.

Abstract

We calculate an analytic expression for the cross section, up to order (eB) squared, for heavy quark (Q) production of mass m Q through the gluon (g) fusion process g+g to Q+ Q bar in the presence of a constant weak external magnetic field B with strength eB much less than m Q squared. This is done using the weak-field expansion of the fermion propagator, calculated with Schwinger's proper-time formalism. Owing to the hierarchy of scales (m Q squared much greater than eB), we neglect the effects of the magnetic field on the quark and antiquark spinors in the external lines. Since the magnetic field breaks rotational invariance, the cross section becomes anisotropic and depends on the orientation angle θ between the magnetic field and the incoming gluons in the center of mass frame. The lowest-order magnetic correction to the vacuum cross section scales as (eB) squared and has 2θ and 4θ dependence, reflecting the breaking of rotational symmetry by the magnetic field. The cross section is maximized when the gluons propagate along the field direction (θ= 0, π) and minimized in the perpendicular configuration (θ= π/2). The resulting asymmetry peaks near the production threshold and falls with increasing center of mass energy, scaling as (eB) 2/m Q 4 with the quark mass. These results provide direct, calculable signatures of the initial-stage magnetic field in relativistic heavy-ion collisions, which can in principle be imprinted on heavy-flavour observables measured in the final state.

Sources

Related papers