Holographic Pseudo Entropy from the Rindler Method in AdS and Flat Space

arXiv:2610.17239 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-10-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Holographic Pseudo Entropy from the Rindler Method in AdS and Flat Space".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Via the Rindler method, we study holographic timelike entanglement entropy (TEE) for a general timelike interval in AdS3/CFT2 and flat3/CCFT2 The TEE is the pseudo entropy of a timelike interval In the bulk, the imaginary part of the TEE comes from a timelike geodesic, but in the Rindler picture this geodesic has not been identified After a Rindler transformation to a rotating BTZ black hole, we find that the geometric meaning of the timelike extremal curve is a geodesic stretched between the two horizons Its length, iπl, is independent of the interval, and it alone produces the imaginary part iπc/6 We follow the same procedure in flat space holography, where the spacelike curve sits on the cosmological horizon and the timelike curve lies between the cosmological horizon and timelike infinity Evaluating the holographic TEE for a timelike interval in CCFT2 on the plane, we find that, in contrast with the cylinder, the real and imaginary parts are equal Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in Rindler AdS This section studies timelike entanglement entropy (TEE) through the modular flow of a timelike interval and then gives its extremal curves a geometric meaning in Rindler space We start with a CFT2 on the plane, where we write the boundary and bulk modular flows in Poincar´e and BMS coordinates The AdS3 metric in Poincar´e coordinates reads ds2 = l squared z squared − dt squared + dx squared + dz squared On the conformal boundary we take a timelike interval − lx squared lt ensures that the interval is timelike The boundary modular flows of the timelike interval were found to be ξ b st = π(l 2x lt − l 3t − 8lxxt + 4lt(x squared + t 2)) / 2(l 2x − l 2t) ∂t + π(-l 2t lx + l 3x + 8ltxt − 4lx(x squared + t 2)) / 2(l 2x − l lt) ∂x We also consider the modular flow ξ b ss, which corresponds to a spacelike interval on the boundary and therefore does not enter the computation of the timelike entanglement entropy The bulk extensions of these boundary flows are given by ξ B st = π(-l 2x lt + l 3t + 8lxxt − 4lt(x squared + t squared + z 2)) / 2(l 2t − l 2x) ∂t − 4π(-lxx + ltt)z/l lt - l lt x/l lt ∂z + π(l 2t lx − l 3x − 8ltxt + 4lx(x squared + t squared - z 2)) / 2(l 2t − l lt x) ∂x By comparing the bulk flows ξ B st in (3.7) and ξ B ss in (3.8), we find that these are exchanged under lx ←→ lt Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in Rindler BTZ The Rindler transformation turns the AdS3 flows into Killing vectors of a rotating BTZ black hole The flow of the spacelike branches and the flow of a spacelike interval become constant vector fields, and their extremal curves sit on the inner and the outer horizon, respectively Exchanging lu ↔ l lphi swaps the two, which amounts to a move between horizons The timelike curve is another matter, and this is where our new result lies We find that it is a geodesic in the region between the horizons It leaves the inner horizon, touches the outer one at its midpoint and comes back Its length, iπl, depends neither on the interval nor on the horizon radii, and that explains why the imaginary part is universal Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in Rindler Flat Space We now do the same in flat space and look for the object that each flow and curve corresponds to The spacetime here is a flat-space cosmology (FSC), which has only a cosmological horizon After the Rindler transformation, the spacelike extremal curve lies on this horizon The timelike extremal curve, which is responsible for the imaginary part, stretches from the cosmological horizon to timelike infinity Pruning redundant reasoning tokens For a CFT2 on the plane, we wrote the boundary and bulk flows in Poincar´e and BMS coordinates The flow ξ st vanishes on a spacelike curve with two branches, and ξ tt vanishes on a timelike curve that joins them Their lengths give the real and the imaginary part of the entropy, and the sum agrees with the known result The third flow, ξ ss, belongs to a spacelike interval and does not enter the entropy It still helps with the geometry, because it is exchanged with ξ st under lx ↔ lt Where the gains come from The Rindler part is where the geometry shows up Under the transformation to a rotating BTZ black hole, ξ st and ξ ss become constant Killing vectors Their norms vanish exactly on the inner and the outer horizon respectively, so the spacelike extremal curves lie on the horizons, and the exchange lu ↔ l lphi turns out to be a passage between the inner and the outer horizons The timelike curve is of a different kind It is a geodesic because it is the fixed-point set of the isometry generated by ξ tt It starts on the inner horizon, touches the outer one at its midpoint and returns to the inner horizon Its length is iπl for every interval and every choice of horizon radii, so the imaginary part iπc/6 is fixed by the black hole geometry between the horizons and by nothing else This is the piece that a thermal entropy cannot provide, and it is the gap left in

12, 28: For a CCFT2 on the plane, we built the flows ζ st and ζ tt from the BMS symmetry generators The spacelike and timelike curves have lengths 2lu/lϕ and i 2lu/lϕ, so the real and imaginary parts of the entropy are equal This does not hold on the cylinder Taking l → ∞ in the AdS entropy gives no finite limit when we use the whole curve We followed

29: and kept only the part between r = 0 and rI, and then the flat limit gives the flat space result Pruning redundant reasoning tokens We now examine whether the modular flow admits zeros at any point outside the region between the two horizons To this end, the Rindler transformation corresponding to each of the two regions is considered separately, for the region outside the outer horizon, ρ >˜ ρ˜+ = TU˜TV˜, and for the region inside the inner horizon, ˜ρ < ρ˜− = −TU˜TV˜ Inside the inner horizon, ρ < ρ minus, the Rindler transformation is given by a complex expression in (A.1) The second equation cannot be satisfied, so the flow has no zeros in this region For the outer horizon, in the region ˜ρ > ρ˜+, the Rindler transformation reads a different form How the training signal is built We have found that neither inside the inner horizon nor outside the outer horizon is there a curve on which the modular flow ξ B tt in (2.35) vanishes after the Rindler transformation The timelike extremal curve therefore exists only in the region between the two horizons, as we found in (2.47) The timelike extremal curve is of a different kind It is the line U˜ = V˜ = 0 across the region between the horizons, a geodesic because it is the fixed-point set of the isometry generated by ξ tt It starts on the inner horizon, touches the outer one at its midpoint and returns to the inner horizon Its length is iπl for every interval and every choice of horizon radii, so the imaginary part iπc/6 is fixed by the black hole geometry between the horizons and by nothing else The holographic timelike entanglement entropy is S(T) = c cubed log(q / l 2l lphi − l 2u 2ϵ) + iπc/6 The real and imaginary parts of the TEE for a timelike interval in CCFT2 on the plane are equal This does not hold on the cylinder The flat space entropy is recovered as a limit of the corresponding AdS result The length of the timelike curve is Ltot = (1 + i) 2lu/lϕ Consequently, the holographic timelike entanglement entropy is S(T) = lu 2Gl lphi + i lu 2Gl lphi The real and imaginary parts of the TEE for a timelike interval in CCFT2 on the plane are equal

Title and authors: Kai: Now we look at what they actually did in this paper, "Holographic Pseudo Entropy from the Rindler Method in AdS and Flat Space." They study the TEE for a general timelike interval using modular flow, and they show how this flows into specific geometric objects in different spacetimes.

Mira: The core idea is that you start with a boundary setup, like a CFT two on the plane, define your timelike interval there, and then follow its evolution through the bulk using modular flow to find the entropy.

Lev: But they go further than just finding a number; they try to give that entropy's parts—the real and imaginary—a geometric structure in Rindler space. That's the main improvement we see here.

Kai: Specifically, when you move to the rotating BTZ black hole, they find that the spacelike and timelike flows become constant vector fields, which means their extremal curves sit right on the inner and outer horizons respectively.

Mira: And then they show that swapping those horizon labels—moving from one horizon to another—is equivalent to moving along a specific curve in the bulk.

Lev: That curve is this geodesic stretching between the two horizons, and they confirm its length is i pi l, which directly gives us that universal imaginary part we talked about earlier.

Kai: It solidifies that this geometric description isn't just an artifact of the Rindler transformation; it has a real physical meaning tied to the horizon structure.

Mira: It’s a way to connect the abstract flow dynamics with concrete spacetime geometry, which is always useful when trying to understand entanglement in gravity.

Lev: This whole procedure is what allows us to isolate that part of the entropy that thermal physics just can't give us on its own, right?

The paper's summary: Kai: So, summarizing the main finding of this work on "Holographic Pseudo Entropy from the Rindler Method in AdS and Flat Space," they are using a procedure involving modular flow to calculate timelike entanglement entropy for a general timelike interval.

Mira: The big summary is that they successfully identify the geometric meaning of the timelike extremal curve after applying a Rindler transformation to get to a rotating BTZ black hole.

Lev: They find that this curve is precisely a geodesic located in the region between the two horizons, starting on one and returning to it at its midpoint.

Kai: This geodesic has a length of i pi l, which is independent of the interval you pick or even the specific size of those black hole horizons.

Mira: That length independence is what allows them to isolate the imaginary part of the pseudo entropy as a universal term, specifically i pi c over six.

Lev: They also repeat this logic in flat space holography, where they find that the spacelike curve sits on the cosmological horizon and the timelike curve goes all the way to timelike infinity.

Kai: It’s a unified approach across both AdS and flat space to show how entanglement entropy behaves for timelike regions.

Mira: The paper essentially proves that for these specific setups, you get a real part and an imaginary part that are equal when you look at the CCFT two on the plane case.

Lev: It’s a nice piece of consistency because it links the bulk dynamics back to what we see on the boundary.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out several improvements over previous work, focusing on how they map things onto Rindler space. One key improvement is identifying the specific flow that corresponds to each curve.

Mira: They show that when you compare the bulk flows in AdS and flat space, they are exchanged under a transformation involving l and l prime parameters. This exchange helps them understand the relationship between different types of intervals.

Lev: And this is where they show the real benefit: by mapping these flows onto Killing vectors in the BTZ case, they can precisely identify where the curves are located relative to the horizons.

Kai: They explicitly rule out other possibilities for where these curves might exist. They check regions outside the outer horizon and inside the inner horizon, and find no zeros for that flow there.

Mira: That exclusion is important because it shows that the timelike extremal curve truly exists only in that specific region between the two horizons.

Lev: So, what this means for us on real hardware? It suggests that if you were trying to build something mimicking this physics, you wouldn't find these curves existing outside that horizon gap.

Kai: And for the flat space case, they show that because of their specific setup in CCFT two on the plane, the real and imaginary parts of the TEE are actually equal.

Mira: That equality is a strong statement because it contrasts with what we see in other setups, like on a cylinder.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper "Holographic Pseudo Entropy from the Rindler Method in AdS and Flat Space," the main implication is that you can use Rindler geometry to give a concrete picture of timelike entanglement entropy.

Mira: They show that the imaginary part is fixed by a geodesic between horizons, giving us a universal value of i pi c over six.

Lev: And they also provide a way to handle flat space holography by showing how it relates back to the AdS calculation in a specific limit.

Kai: The main result for the CCFT two on the plane is that the real and imaginary parts of this TEE are equal, which is different from what you see in other geometries like a cylinder.

Mira: This equality is a direct consequence of how they constructed the flows and how those flows map onto Rindler space.

Lev: For my work with error correction, this gives us a clearer idea about where the physical information—the real part versus the imaginary part—is localized in this holographic description.

Kai: We're ready to move on to another paper that might be just as interesting for us next.

Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-10-12

Updated: 2026-11-08

Comments: v2: minor corrections, typos fixed, references added. 36 pages, 4 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Via the Rindler method, we study holographic timelike entanglement entropy (TEE) for a general timelike interval in AdS3/CFT2 and flat3/CCFT2 The TEE is the pseudo entropy of a timelike interval In…

Key concepts

Timelike Entanglement Entropy (TEE)
TEE is a measure derived from the modular flow of a timelike interval in the bulk spacetime. It has both real and imaginary components, which together form the pseudo entropy. The paper aims to geometrically interpret these components by finding specific curves corresponding to these flows.
Rindler Transformation
This transformation maps the AdS geometry onto a rotating BTZ black hole geometry. In this new picture, modular flows become constant Killing vectors, allowing researchers to identify the geometric meaning of different curves within the bulk spacetime.
Geodesic between Horizons
In Rindler space (BTZ), the timelike extremal curve is identified as a geodesic stretched between the inner and outer horizons. This curve's length ($ ext{i} rac{\pi l}{6}$) determines the universal imaginary part of the entropy, linking it directly to the black hole geometry.
Flat Space Holography
This applies the Rindler method to flat space cosmology (FSC), which possesses only a cosmological horizon. Here, the timelike extremal curve is found stretching from this cosmological horizon out to timelike infinity, providing a geometric analogue for the AdS results.

Terminology

Summary

Via the Rindler method, we study holographic timelike entanglement entropy (TEE) for a general timelike interval in AdS3/CFT2 and flat3/CCFT2 The TEE is the pseudo entropy of a timelike interval In the bulk, the imaginary part of the TEE comes from a timelike geodesic, but in the Rindler picture this geodesic has not been identified After a Rindler transformation to a rotating BTZ black hole, we find that the geometric meaning of the timelike extremal curve is a geodesic stretched between the two horizons Its length, iπl, is independent of the interval, and it alone produces the imaginary part iπc/6 We follow the same procedure in flat space holography, where the spacelike curve sits on the cosmological horizon and the timelike curve lies between the cosmological horizon and timelike infinity Evaluating the holographic TEE for a timelike interval in CCFT2 on the plane, we find that, in contrast with the cylinder, the real and imaginary parts are equal

Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in Rindler AdS

This section studies timelike entanglement entropy (TEE) through the modular flow of a timelike interval and then gives its extremal curves a geometric meaning in Rindler space We start with a CFT2 on the plane, where we write the boundary and bulk modular flows in Poincar´e and BMS coordinates The AdS3 metric in Poincar´e coordinates reads ds2 = l squared z squared − dt squared + dx squared + dz squared On the conformal boundary we take a timelike interval − lx squared lt ensures that the interval is timelike The boundary modular flows of the timelike interval were found to be ξ b st = π(l 2x lt − l 3t − 8lxxt + 4lt(x squared + t 2)) / 2(l 2x − l 2t) ∂t + π(-l 2t lx + l 3x + 8ltxt − 4lx(x squared + t 2)) / 2(l 2x − l lt) ∂x We also consider the modular flow ξ b ss, which corresponds to a spacelike interval on the boundary and therefore does not enter the computation of the timelike entanglement entropy The bulk extensions of these boundary flows are given by ξ B st = π(-l 2x lt + l 3t + 8lxxt − 4lt(x squared + t squared + z 2)) / 2(l 2t − l 2x) ∂t − 4π(-lxx + ltt)z/l lt - l lt x/l lt ∂z + π(l 2t lx − l 3x − 8ltxt + 4lx(x squared + t squared - z 2)) / 2(l 2t − l lt x) ∂x By comparing the bulk flows ξ B st in (3.7) and ξ B ss in (3.8), we find that these are exchanged under lx ←→ lt

Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in Rindler BTZ

The Rindler transformation turns the AdS3 flows into Killing vectors of a rotating BTZ black hole The flow of the spacelike branches and the flow of a spacelike interval become constant vector fields, and their extremal curves sit on the inner and the outer horizon, respectively Exchanging lu ↔ l lphi swaps the two, which amounts to a move between horizons The timelike curve is another matter, and this is where our new result lies We find that it is a geodesic in the region between the horizons It leaves the inner horizon, touches the outer one at its midpoint and comes back Its length, iπl, depends neither on the interval nor on the horizon radii, and that explains why the imaginary part is universal

Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in Rindler Flat Space

We now do the same in flat space and look for the object that each flow and curve corresponds to The spacetime here is a flat-space cosmology (FSC), which has only a cosmological horizon After the Rindler transformation, the spacelike extremal curve lies on this horizon The timelike extremal curve, which is responsible for the imaginary part, stretches from the cosmological horizon to timelike infinity

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

For a CFT2 on the plane, we wrote the boundary and bulk flows in Poincar´e and BMS coordinates The flow ξ st vanishes on a spacelike curve with two branches, and ξ tt vanishes on a timelike curve that joins them Their lengths give the real and the imaginary part of the entropy, and the sum agrees with the known result The third flow, ξ ss, belongs to a spacelike interval and does not enter the entropy It still helps with the geometry, because it is exchanged with ξ st under lx ↔ lt

Where the gains come from

The Rindler part is where the geometry shows up Under the transformation to a rotating BTZ black hole, ξ st and ξ ss become constant Killing vectors Their norms vanish exactly on the inner and the outer horizon respectively, so the spacelike extremal curves lie on the horizons, and the exchange lu ↔ l lphi turns out to be a passage between the inner and the outer horizons The timelike curve is of a different kind It is a geodesic because it is the fixed-point set of the isometry generated by ξ tt It starts on the inner horizon, touches the outer one at its midpoint and returns to the inner horizon Its length is iπl for every interval and every choice of horizon radii, so the imaginary part iπc/6 is fixed by the black hole geometry between the horizons and by nothing else This is the piece that a thermal entropy cannot provide, and it is the gap left in [12, 28]

Conclusion

For a CCFT2 on the plane, we built the flows ζ st and ζ tt from the BMS symmetry generators The spacelike and timelike curves have lengths 2lu/lϕ and i 2lu/lϕ, so the real and imaginary parts of the entropy are equal This does not hold on the cylinder Taking l → ∞ in the AdS entropy gives no finite limit when we use the whole curve We followed [29] and kept only the part between r = 0 and rI, and then the flat limit gives the flat space result

We now examine whether the modular flow admits zeros at any point outside the region between the two horizons To this end, the Rindler transformation corresponding to each of the two regions is considered separately, for the region outside the outer horizon, ρ >˜ ρ˜+ = TU˜TV˜, and for the region inside the inner horizon, ˜ρ < ρ˜− = −TU˜TV˜ Inside the inner horizon, ρ < ρ minus, the Rindler transformation is given by a complex expression in (A.1) The second equation cannot be satisfied, so the flow has no zeros in this region For the outer horizon, in the region ˜ρ > ρ˜+, the Rindler transformation reads a different form

How the training signal is built

We have found that neither inside the inner horizon nor outside the outer horizon is there a curve on which the modular flow ξ B tt in (2.35) vanishes after the Rindler transformation The timelike extremal curve therefore exists only in the region between the two horizons, as we found in (2. p. 047)

The timelike extremal curve is of a different kind It is the line U˜ = V˜ = 0 across the region between the horizons, a geodesic because it is the fixed-point set of the isometry generated by ξ tt It starts on the inner horizon, touches the outer one at its midpoint and returns to the inner horizon Its length is iπl for every interval and every choice of horizon radii, so the imaginary part iπc/6 is fixed by the black hole geometry between the horizons and by nothing else

The holographic timelike entanglement entropy is S(T) = c cubed log(q / l 2l lphi − l 2u 2ϵ) + iπc/6

The real and imaginary parts of the TEE for a timelike interval in CCFT2 on the plane are equal This does not hold on the cylinder The flat space entropy is recovered as a limit of the corresponding AdS result

The length of the timelike curve is Ltot = (1 + i) 2lu/lϕ Consequently, the holographic timelike entanglement entropy is S(T) = lu 2Gl lphi + i lu 2Gl lphi The real and imaginary parts of the TEE for a timelike interval in CCFT2 on the plane are equal

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to calculate holographic timelike entanglement entropy for general timelike intervals in both AdS3/CFT2 and flat3/CCFT2 by directly using bulk modular flow fixed points to determine the real and imaginary parts of the pseudo entropy.

  2. Enhanced capability to geometrically interpret bulk modular flows by mapping them onto Rindler space, specifically identifying the timelike extremal curve as a geodesic stretching between horizons in Rindler BTZ and between the cosmological horizon and timelike infinity in flat space cosmology.

  3. Improved capacity to determine the universal imaginary part of the holographic timelike entanglement entropy, which is fixed by a geodesic length i pi l, independent of interval specifics or horizon radii, directly linking it to the geometry between horizons.

  4. Increased precision in calculating TEE for CCFT2 on a plane where real and imaginary parts are equal (S(T) = c 3 log sqrt(Delta t squared - Delta x 2) epsilon + i pi c/6), ensuring accurate reproduction of results from both AdS3 and flat space limits.

  5. Refined understanding of the relationship between different bulk flows, such as the exchange of spacelike and timelike curves under Rindler transformations, allowing the AI to predict how a flow will behave in a transformed spacetime like BTZ.

Sources

Related papers