Modular Flow and Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in AdS and Flat Holography
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Modular Flow and Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in AdS and Flat Holography".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Timelike entanglement entropy provides a useful probe of holographic theories, yet an explicit bulk realization of the modular flow underlying its timelike extremal curve construction has so far been lacking The paper constructs modular flows associated with spacelike and timelike intervals in AdS3/CFT2 and extends this framework to flat3/CCFT2 Beginning with the boundary symmetry generators, it explicitly derives the boundary modular flows and extends them into the bulk, providing a systematic procedure that relates bulk modular flows to the extremal curves and holographic (timelike) entanglement entropy For spacelike intervals, the resulting bulk modular flows determine the extremal curves, whose integrated line elements reproduce the standard holographic entanglement entropy It then generalizes this approach to timelike intervals, explicitly constructing the modular flows whose fixed points reproduce the extremal spacelike and timelike curves which gives the holographic timelike entanglement entropy Gauge/gravity duality establishes a profound correspondence between quantum information in the boundary theory and geometric structures in the bulk, with entanglement entropy providing a key manifestation of this relation The most prominent example of gauge/gravity duality is the celebrated AdS/CFT correspondence
1: The AdS/CFT correspondence relates gravity in a (d + 1)-dimensional asymptotically Anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime to a d-dimensional conformal field theory (CFT) living on its boundary According to this proposal, the entanglement entropy of a boundary subsystem A is determined by the area of a codimension-two extremal surface γA in the asymptotically AdS bulk, homologous to A and anchored on the boundary of A, divided by 4G This relation carries broader significance: the geometry of the bulk spacetime directly reflects the entanglement structure of the boundary theory Modular Flow as a Geometric Tool Computing HEE and HTEE requires solving a generically nontrivial extremization problem to identify the correct bulk surfaces An alternative approach to obtaining the extremal curves, and hence computing HEE and HTEE, relies on the modular flow Within the holographic framework, extremal surfaces coincide with the set of fixed points of the bulk modular flow This property offers an elegant way to construct extremal surfaces directly from symmetry considerations, bypassing the extremization procedure altogether Modular flow establishes a link between quantum information and spacetime geometry, simultaneously encoding the quantum entanglement structure of the boundary theory and determining geometric objects in the bulk Construction for Spacelike Intervals In Section 3, modular flows are constructed associated with a spacelike interval in AdS3/CFT2 The boundary modular flow is given by a specific expression involving CFT2 symmetry generators The corresponding bulk modular flow is obtained by extending these generators into the bulk and repeating the boundary construction with these extended generators Imposing the vanishing of the bulk modular flow vector in (3.8) yields x squared + z squared = R squared, t = 0, which is precisely the bulk extremal curve anchored to the corresponding spacelike boundary interval The resulting line element leads to a holographic entanglement entropy calculated as Sss = Lss / 4G Construction for Timelike Intervals In Section 4, the authors generalize the analysis to timelike intervals, where the entanglement entropy is generically complex The real part comes from disconnected spacelike branches anchored at the interval endpoints, while the imaginary part arises from a timelike curve connecting them For a purely timelike interval, the modular flow associated with the timelike geodesic determines the extremal curve T squared = z squared - t squared, x = 0 The imaginary part of the holographic timelike entanglement entropy is found to be a constant, iπc/6 Flat Space Realization and Comparison Section 5 extends the construction to flat3/CCFT2, where the relevant boundary modular flows are constructed from the CCFT2 symmetry generators The flat limit of the AdS3 results in (4.49) reproduces the standard CFT result on a cylinder For timelike intervals, the holographic timelike entanglement entropy is complex, with a real part reproducing the standard logarithmic form and an imaginary part that depends on both lu and lϕ The flat space limit of this effective length reproduces the same result obtained directly from flat space holography In summary, these results provide modular flow as a common geometric formalism for holographic entanglement entropy, applicable to both spacelike and timelike regions in AdS as well as in flat space For spacelike intervals, this construction reproduces the known result in AdS3/CFT2 For timelike intervals, the modular flow associated with the timelike extremal curve had not previously been constructed explicitly, but here it is obtained directly Two directions remain open for future work: extending this method beyond three dimensions and understanding the physical origin of the imaginary contributions Acknowledgments We appreciate Reza Fareghbal’s helpful comments on an earlier version of this paper MHSH was supported in part by Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz under grant no.
Kai: SCU.SP1404.86612 MKZ thanks Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Iran, for supporting this work under research grant no.
Mira: SCU.SP1404.
Paper summary: Kai: To recap the main thrust of this paper, "Modular Flow and Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in AdS and Flat Holography," they're tackling the missing piece in connecting modular flow to timelike extremal curves. The authors construct these flows first for spacelike intervals in AdS three dimensions, which leads directly to finding the standard holographic entanglement entropy through integrated line elements.
Mira: They then take that systematic procedure and generalize it to timelike intervals, where the entanglement entropy is complex. They explicitly derive the modular flows associated with these timelike geodesics and show that their fixed points generate the extremal curves corresponding to this specific timelike entanglement entropy.
Lev: The paper also extends this entire setup from AdS three dimensions over to flat three dimensions in flat3/CCFT2, showing how the boundary modular flows constructed from Carrolli symmetry generators relate to bulk geometry in that setting.
Kai: The key takeaway is establishing a systematic procedure where you start with boundary symmetry generators, derive the modular flow in the bulk, and that flow dictates both the extremal curves and finally yields this holographic timelike entanglement entropy.
Mira: This provides a unified geometric tool for calculating these entropies in both AdS and flat spacetimes, moving beyond just relying on previous results for spacelike intervals.
Lev: It sets up the roadmap for how this kind of flow analysis could be systematically applied to other holographic setups, which is what makes this framework important even if it's just an initial construction.
Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the full picture of "Modular Flow and Holographic Timelike Entanglement Entropy in AdS and Flat Holography," the authors successfully provide an explicit bulk realization of the modular flow that underpins the timelike extremal curve construction.
Mira: What this means is that we no longer just have a way to compute entanglement entropy from area for spacelike regions; they've given us a direct geometric mechanism—the modular flow—to handle the more complex, timelike cases.
Lev: For researchers building real error correction codes, this is significant because it shows how the structure of bulk flows directly dictates the geometry that determines those entanglement properties, which is where you need to be careful about overhead.
Kai: It moves the discussion from an abstract extremization problem to a concrete symmetry-based construction for these specific geometric objects in both AdS and flat space.
Mira: And it extends this concept to flat space, giving us results for timelike intervals there too, even if they are complex, with a real part matching known CFT results.
Lev: The limitation the authors point out is that they haven't yet explored the physical origin of those imaginary contributions in more depth or extended this method beyond three dimensions.
Kai: So, in simple terms, this paper gives us a new geometric formalism—modular flow—that lets us calculate holographic timelike entanglement entropy systematically across AdS and flat spacetimes.
Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz
hep-th
Submitted: 2026-10-12
Updated: 2026-11-08
Comments: v2: minor corrections, typos fixed, references added. 40 pages, 3 figures
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 87/100
The gist: Timelike entanglement entropy provides a useful probe of holographic theories, yet an explicit bulk realization of the modular flow underlying its timelike extremal curve construction has so far been…
Key concepts
- Holographic Entanglement Entropy (HEE/HTEE)
- This is a measure of quantum information in a boundary theory linked to geometry in the bulk. For spacelike intervals, it relates to the area of an extremal surface. For timelike intervals, it can be complex, reflecting different aspects of the entanglement structure.
- Modular Flow
- A geometric concept used here as an alternative to solving extremization problems. It links quantum information structures on the boundary theory directly to specific geometric objects (extremal surfaces) in the bulk spacetime.
- Extremal Curves
- These are specific curves in the bulk geometry that minimize or extremize certain quantities related to entanglement. In this framework, they correspond precisely to the fixed points of the modular flow, allowing for a direct calculation of entanglement entropy.
- AdS/CFT and Flat Space Holography
- These are holographic duality frameworks connecting quantum field theories (like CFT) on a boundary to gravity in a bulk spacetime (like AdS or flat space). The paper applies the modular flow method across both these different geometric backgrounds.
Terminology
Summary
Timelike entanglement entropy provides a useful probe of holographic theories, yet an explicit bulk realization of the modular flow underlying its timelike extremal curve construction has so far been lacking The paper constructs modular flows associated with spacelike and timelike intervals in AdS3/CFT2 and extends this framework to flat3/CCFT2 Beginning with the boundary symmetry generators, it explicitly derives the boundary modular flows and extends them into the bulk, providing a systematic procedure that relates bulk modular flows to the extremal curves and holographic (timelike) entanglement entropy For spacelike intervals, the resulting bulk modular flows determine the extremal curves, whose integrated line elements reproduce the standard holographic entanglement entropy It then generalizes this approach to timelike intervals, explicitly constructing the modular flows whose fixed points reproduce the extremal spacelike and timelike curves which gives the holographic timelike entanglement entropy
Introduction to Holographic Duality and Entanglement
Gauge/gravity duality establishes a profound correspondence between quantum information in the boundary theory and geometric structures in the bulk, with entanglement entropy providing a key manifestation of this relation The most prominent example of gauge/gravity duality is the celebrated AdS/CFT correspondence [1] The AdS/CFT correspondence relates gravity in a (d + 1)-dimensional asymptotically Anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime to a d-dimensional conformal field theory (CFT) living on its boundary According to this proposal, the entanglement entropy of a boundary subsystem A is determined by the area of a codimension-two extremal surface γA in the asymptotically AdS bulk, homologous to A and anchored on the boundary of A, divided by 4G This relation carries broader significance: the geometry of the bulk spacetime directly reflects the entanglement structure of the boundary theory
Modular Flow as a Geometric Tool
Computing HEE and HTEE requires solving a generically nontrivial extremization problem to identify the correct bulk surfaces An alternative approach to obtaining the extremal curves, and hence computing HEE and HTEE, relies on the modular flow Within the holographic framework, extremal surfaces coincide with the set of fixed points of the bulk modular flow This property offers an elegant way to construct extremal surfaces directly from symmetry considerations, bypassing the extremization procedure altogether Modular flow establishes a link between quantum information and spacetime geometry, simultaneously encoding the quantum entanglement structure of the boundary theory and determining geometric objects in the bulk
Construction for Spacelike Intervals
In Section 3, modular flows are constructed associated with a spacelike interval in AdS3/CFT2 The boundary modular flow is given by a specific expression involving CFT2 symmetry generators The corresponding bulk modular flow is obtained by extending these generators into the bulk and repeating the boundary construction with these extended generators Imposing the vanishing of the bulk modular flow vector in (3.8) yields x squared + z squared = R squared, t = 0, which is precisely the bulk extremal curve anchored to the corresponding spacelike boundary interval The resulting line element leads to a holographic entanglement entropy calculated as Sss = Lss / 4G
Construction for Timelike Intervals
In Section 4, the authors generalize the analysis to timelike intervals, where the entanglement entropy is generically complex The real part comes from disconnected spacelike branches anchored at the interval endpoints, while the imaginary part arises from a timelike curve connecting them For a purely timelike interval, the modular flow associated with the timelike geodesic determines the extremal curve T squared = z squared - t squared, x = 0 The imaginary part of the holographic timelike entanglement entropy is found to be a constant, iπc/6
Flat Space Realization and Comparison
Section 5 extends the construction to flat3/CCFT2, where the relevant boundary modular flows are constructed from the CCFT2 symmetry generators The flat limit of the AdS3 results in (4.49) reproduces the standard CFT result on a cylinder For timelike intervals, the holographic timelike entanglement entropy is complex, with a real part reproducing the standard logarithmic form and an imaginary part that depends on both lu and lϕ The flat space limit of this effective length reproduces the same result obtained directly from flat space holography
Conclusion
In summary, these results provide modular flow as a common geometric formalism for holographic entanglement entropy, applicable to both spacelike and timelike regions in AdS as well as in flat space For spacelike intervals, this construction reproduces the known result in AdS3/CFT2 For timelike intervals, the modular flow associated with the timelike extremal curve had not previously been constructed explicitly, but here it is obtained directly Two directions remain open for future work: extending this method beyond three dimensions and understanding the physical origin of the imaginary contributions
Acknowledgments
We appreciate Reza Fareghbal’s helpful comments on an earlier version of this paper MHSH was supported in part by Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz under grant no. SCU.SP1404.86612 MKZ thanks Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Iran, for supporting this work under research grant no. p. 0 SCU.SP1404.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Modular flow construction for timelike intervals allows for direct determination of extremal curves without solving a generically nontrivial extremization problem, providing a systematic procedure relating bulk modular flows to holographic (timelike) entanglement entropy.
-
The framework enables the explicit derivation of boundary and bulk modular flows associated with spacelike and timelike intervals in both AdS3/CFT2 and flat3/CCFT2, establishing a common geometric formalism for holographic entanglement entropy.
-
The analysis reveals that the timelike entanglement entropy splits into a real part, associated with disconnected spacelike branches, and an imaginary part tied to the timelike curve connecting them in the bulk.
-
The construction shows that under coordinate transformations between different spacetime representations, such as AdS Poincaré coordinates and global BMS coordinates, the modular flows transform predictably into each other.
-
The method resolves divergences in flat space holography by restricting the calculation to a specific portion of the length of the AdS extremal curve between rmin and rI, which reproduces the flat space result directly.
Sources
- The Large N Limit of Superconformal Field Theories and Supergravity
- Anti De Sitter Space And Holography
- Gauge Theory Correlators from Non-Critical String Theory
- Holographic superconductivity of a critical Fermi surface
- Quantum Corrections to Holographic Strange Metal at Low Temperature
- Deep learning-based holography for T-linear resistivity
- Holographic Strange Metals for Philosophers and Physicists
- Time-Crystalline Phase in a Single-Band Holographic Superconductor
- Holographic quantum codes with trapped ions
- An Introduction to Gauge Gravity Duality and Its Application in Condensed Matter
- Holographic Derivation of Entanglement Entropy from AdS/CFT
- Aspects of Holographic Entanglement Entropy
- A Covariant Holographic Entanglement Entropy Proposal
- Building up spacetime with quantum entanglement
- Entanglement Renormalization and Holography
- BMS/GCA Redux: Towards Flatspace Holography from Non-Relativistic Symmetries
- Conformal Carroll groups and BMS symmetry
- Carroll versus Newton and Galilei: two dual non-Einsteinian concepts of time
- Symmetries of asymptotically flat 4 dimensional spacetimes at null infinity revisited
- Aspects of the BMS/CFT correspondence
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions