Unrectifiable surfaces with intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups

arXiv:2610.15851 · math.MG · Submitted 2026-10-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Unrectifiable surfaces with intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups".

Title and authors: Ada: To summarize what we've heard about this paper, the main thrust of "Unrectifiable surfaces with intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups" is proving that we can construct surfaces in these groups that are unrectifiable by standard Euclidean distance, yet they still maintain a certain level of C1 alpha Hölder continuity.

Emmy: They do this by looking at step-two Carnot groups and using a specific construction involving a subset Fg where a C1 function g has a gradient with nonvanishing curl. At each characteristic point, they attach the level set of a highly irregular one plus alpha squared Hölder function psi along a vertical direction.

Kolya: So what this means for us in practical terms is that we can generate sets that are topologically complex but geometrically "rough" in Euclidean space, yet their roughness is controlled by the alpha exponent.

Ada: And they establish a key result: the upper bound for the Hausdorff dimension of any C1 alpha H hypersurface is q minus one plus alpha squared. This bound is achieved by the specific surface they built in theorem one point two.

Emmy: They also noted that this result extends earlier work done in the first Heisenberg group, showing that this kind of unrectifiability isn't a new thing, but it can be generalized to more complex Carnot groups.

Kolya: It’s also worth remembering the specific finding for step-two groups: the two minus one over two dimensional Euclidean Hausdorff measure of every C1 H hypersurface is zero. That's another strong piece of information about their geometric size.

Ada: So, in short, this paper shows that intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups doesn't guarantee rectifiability by Euclidean distance when alpha is less than one.

Emmy: And the construction hinges on the interplay between the group operation and these vector fields with nonvanishing curl to create those irregular level sets. This structure is what allows them to push the dimension up.

The paper's summary: Ada: The paper itself points out some improvements, which are really about sharpening those results and making sure we understand the sharpness of the bounds we're seeing. For instance, they mention that when alpha equals one, we get classical rectifiability.

Emmy: That sharpness is crucial because it means that alpha equals one is the point where things transition from being unrectifiable to being classically rectifiable in a very specific way within this context.

Kolya: And they also explore how they can use functions with irregular level sets, like those constructed using Rajala's method, to understand the dimension of those level sets. They show that for every alpha and beta less than one, there exists a function psi such that the Hausdorff dimension of its level set is at least one minus alpha.

Ada: That's an improvement because it gives us a concrete lower bound on the dimension we can expect from these irregular functions, which helps us pinpoint exactly where the construction is strongest.

Emmy: It connects the construction of these functions back to their regularity properties, showing that while they are highly irregular in one sense, they still have some controlled structure in another.

Kolya: And when looking at the level sets of those functions, there's a limitation they state: almost every level set of the functions constructed using Rajala's method cannot have a positive one minus alpha dimensional Hausdorff measure.

Ada: So they are showing that even though the dimension can be high, it doesn't mean that every single level set achieves that maximum dimension in terms of measure.

Emmy: It adds a layer of nuance to the picture, moving beyond just the existence of a surface with maximal dimension to understanding how those surfaces actually behave geometrically on a finer scale.

The paper's improvements: Ada: Wrapping up this discussion on "Unrectifiable surfaces with intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups," the main implication is that we can construct C1 alpha H surfaces in these groups that are unrectifiable by Euclidean distance for any alpha less than one.

Emmy: And the key takeaway is understanding the upper bound q minus one plus alpha squared, which tells us the maximum Euclidean dimension this irregularity can reach. This limit is achieved by their specific construction in theorem one point two.

Kolya: From a probabilistic standpoint, it reinforces that even at this maximal dimension, there's a constraint on the measure of those surfaces for step-two groups where the two minus one over two dimensional measure is zero.

Ada: So we can build these complex structures, and the final piece is using this paper to show that any C1 alpha H hypersurface in a step-two Carnot group is also a one plus alpha squared Hölder manifold.

Emmy: It's important because it connects the regularity back to the intrinsic geometry of the group structure itself. This suggests that these surfaces aren't just arbitrary constructions but are intrinsically tied to how those groups operate.

Kolya: I think what this work really tells us is that the behavior of these surfaces is governed by those algebraic structures, which is a crucial insight for anyone looking at applications in dynamical systems or geometric analysis.

Ada: So we've covered the main points of "Unrectifiable surfaces with intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups" and we’ve established that for step-two groups, the behavior of these surfaces is tightly controlled by their intrinsic structure.

Conclusion: Ada: So we've been looking at the paper "Unrectifiable surfaces with intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups," and the main thing is that they show you can construct surfaces in these noncommutative groups that are unrectifiable by Euclidean distance while still keeping a certain level of C1 alpha Hölder continuity.

Emmy: That construction relies on step-two Carnot groups, where they use a subset Fg with a gradient vector field that has nonvanishing curl to build level sets of very irregular functions along vertical directions.

Kolya: And the key result there is the upper bound q minus one plus alpha squared for the Euclidean Hausdorff dimension of these surfaces, and they show that this bound is sharp because when alpha equals one, you get classical rectifiability.

Ada: And they also proved that for step-two groups, every C1 H hypersurface has a zero two minus one over two dimensional Euclidean Hausdorff measure. That's a pretty strong statement about the geometric size of these things.

Emmy: It's interesting how this ties into the structure of those Carnot groups; it suggests that the intrinsic regularity you see in step-two groups is what allows them to achieve that higher dimension bound compared to their topological dimension.

Kolya: From a probabilistic view, this tells us about the tail behavior of these sets; they’re governed by certain measures, and it's interesting how those measures behave when you look at level sets of functions constructed using Rajala's method.

Ada: And they show that for those specific irregular functions, the almost every level set cannot have a positive one minus alpha dimensional Hausdorff measure, which limits how much dimension we can expect on a typical level set.

Emmy: This confirms that while the maximal dimension is achievable in some instances, it's not everywhere you see that full dimension in terms of measure.

Kolya: So yeah, the paper shows us the extent of this regularity and where those bounds actually hold for these step-two groups.

Ada: Exactly. The title "Unrectifiable surfaces with intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups" really captures that tension between the group's internal structure and how it looks in standard Euclidean space.

Emmy: It’s a reminder that the geometry of these spaces dictates what you can expect from their subsets, even when we are talking about things like Hausdorff dimension.

Kolya: I think this work opens up some interesting directions for how we study geometric measure theory on these types of groups, especially when considering the different step numbers.

Ada: Definitely. And that leads us right into the next paper they're working on, which deals with rank-one integrals and multiplicative convolutions.

University of Pisa

math.MG

Submitted: 2026-10-11

Updated: 2026-11-16

Comments: 29 pages. Minor revisions to improve exposition

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: In any noncommutative Carnot group, for every 0 ≤ α < 1, we show the existence of a C1,αH surface that is unrectifiable with respect to the Euclidean distance<ref:2610.15851#pg3>.

Key concepts

Carnot Group
A specific type of noncommutative group structure used in this study, characterized by a stratification (step) and a homogeneous dimension 'q'. These groups are the setting where the surfaces are being studied, allowing for the analysis of intrinsic geometric properties.
C1,αH Surface
A surface that is continuously differentiable up to order 1 with Hölder continuity of order α. This regularity condition dictates how smooth the surface is locally; higher 'α' means better local smoothness, which in turn constrains its Euclidean dimension.
Unrectifiable Surface
A surface whose structure cannot be described or measured using standard rectifiability techniques based on Euclidean distance. The paper shows that certain intrinsically regular surfaces in Carnot groups can possess a positive Hausdorff dimension, meaning they are not rectifiable in the classical sense.

Terminology

Summary

In any noncommutative Carnot group, for every 0 ≤ α < 1, we show the existence of a C1,αH surface that is unrectifiable with respect to the Euclidean distance<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg3>. This paper demonstrates that intrinsic regular hypersurfaces in Carnot groups can exhibit a higher Euclidean Hausdorff dimension than their topological dimension<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg4>.

Existence of Higher Dimensional Unrectifiable Surfaces

The main result establishes the existence of such surfaces, showing that in step-2 Carnot groups, the construction gives hypersurfaces of maximal Euclidean Hausdorff dimension, equal to q−1+α2<ref:2610. p. 0 p. 015851#pg4>. The range of unrectifiability is sharp since for α = 1 the surface is rectifiable in the classical sense<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg4>. Furthermore, in step-2 Carnot groups, it is also possible to prove that the (q − 1/2)-dimensional Euclidean Hausdorff measure of every C1H hypersurface is zero<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg4>.

Construction Techniques for Singularities

The proof of Theorem 1.2 outlines an approach involving a subset Fg in the m-dimensional cube Q on which a C1 function g has a gradient equal to a vector field with nonvanishing curl<ref:2610. p. 215851#pg4>. This vector field arises from the group operation, according to (13) and its nonvanishing curl is precisely characterized by the Lie bracket generating condition of V1, as shown in Remark 3. p. 22<ref:2610.15851#pg5>. At each characteristic point we attach a level set of a highly irregular 1+α2-H¨older function ψ, along a vertical direction of degree 2<ref:2610. p. 215851#pg4>.

Regularity and Upper Bounds for Dimensions

Theorem 1.3 states that let G be a Carnot group of step 2 and let 0 ≤ α ≤ 1, then every C1,αH hypersurface S satisfies dimE S ≤ q − 1+α2<ref:2610. p. 315851#pg5>. For α = 1, if G is of step 2 and S is a C1,1H regular hypersurface, then S is (q−1)-rectifiable in the classical sense<ref:2610. p. 315851#pg5>. This result shows that for any highly irregular hypersurface S constructed in Theorem 1. p. 32 and any 0 ≤ α < 1, S achieves the maximal Euclidean Hausdorff dimension allowed by its C1,αH regularity<ref:2610. p. 315851#pg5>.

Properties of H¨older Functions and Measures

The paper presents Rajala’s construction of special classes of H¨older continuous functions, showing that for every α, β ∈ (0, 1), there exists a function ψ: [0, 1] → [0, 1] such that dimE ψ−1(t) ≥ 1 − α for all t ∈ [0, 1]<ref:2610.15851#pg3>. Lemma 6.6 shows that if an open set Ω′ is given and ψ satisfies the condition (36), then Hn−α(ψ−1(t)) = 0 for a. p. 4e. t ∈ R<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg3>.

Conclusion on Rectifiability in Step-2 Groups

Corollary 5.5 states that let G be a Carnot group of step 2 and let S⊂ G be a C1,1H regular hypersurface, then S is (q−1)-Euclidean rectifiable<ref:2610. p. 315851#pg5>. This implies that any C1,αH hypersurface embedded in a step-2 Carnot group is also 1+α2-H¨older manifold<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg5>.

Further Results on Level Sets

Corollary 5.9 shows that if G is a step-2 Carnot group and S⊂ G is a C1H hypersurface, then Hq− 1/2(S) = 0<ref:2610. p. 315851#pg5>. This result completes the picture in [28] by answering a question left open there<ref:2610. p. 415851#pg5>.

Upper Bound for Hausdorff Dimension

The upper bound for the Hausdorff dimension of C1,αH hypersurfaces is q−1+α2<ref:2610.15851#pg5>. This result is achieved by the hypersurface exhibited in Theorem 1. p. 32<ref:2610.15851#pg5>.

Holder Functions with Irregular Level Sets

Theorem 6.1 shows that for every α, β ∈ (0, 1), there exists a function ψ: [0, 1] → [0, 1] such that dimE ψ−1(t) ≥ 1 − α for all t ∈ [0, 1]<ref:2610. p. 815851#pg3>. The main ideas underlying the proof of Theorem 6. p. 21 are already present in [37]<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg3>.

Construction of Irregular H¨older Function

The construction involves defining a function ψ based on the composition of maps Fm and Fm+1, leading to a graph G that is the graph of a log m log(3m)-H¨older function whose level sets have positive 1−log m log(3m)-dimensional Hausdorff measure<ref:2610.15851#pg3>.

Construction of Measures on Level Sets

The construction of a Borel regular outer measure µ on X is used to transport ν to a measure µ on G∩t, which is supported on G∩t and µ(G∩t) = ν(X) = 1<ref:2610.15851#pg3>. This leads to the conclusion that dimE S ≥ q−k+1/2<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg5>.

Further Results on Level Sets of H¨older Functions

Lemma 6.6 shows that a. p. 3 p. 3e. level set of the functions in Theorem 6. p. 1 p. 11 cannot have positive (1−α)-dimensional Hausdorff measure<ref:2610. p. 2 p. 215851#pg3>. This is obtained by a proper use of Eilenberg’s inequality<ref:2610. p. 815851#pg3>.

Final Observations on Regularity

Remark 6.5 recalls that if f: Ω → R is an α-H¨older continuous function, with Ω⊂ R n of finite Lebesgue measure and 0. p. 1 This can be obtained by a proper use of Eilenberg’s inequality<ref:2610. p. 815851#pg3>.

The functions constructed in [37, Proposition 2.6] and in Theorem 6. p. 11 have a a.e. level set of maximal Hausdorff dimension equal to 1−α<ref:2610. p. 015851#pg3>. Moreover, Lemma 6. p. 26 shows that a.e. level set of the functions in Theorem 6.1 cannot have positive (1−α)-dimensional Hausdorff measure<ref:2610.15851#pg3>.

In step-2 Carnot groups, any C1H hypersurface is also a 1/2-little H¨older manifold<ref:2610.15851#pg5>. This is obtained by taking into account the regularity result (30)<ref:2610. p. 3 p. 315851#pg5>.

Final Observations on Level Sets of H¨older Functions

In step-2 Carnot groups, any C1H hypersurface is also a 1/2-little H¨older manifold<ref:2610.15851#pg5>. This is obtained by taking into account the regularity result (30)<ref:2610.15851#pg5>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved understanding of intrinsic regularity in Carnot groups allows AI systems to construct C 1, alpha H surfaces with Euclidean Hausdorff dimension higher than their topological dimension up to a bound of q - 1 + alpha squared.

  2. AI systems can utilize the construction outlined in Theorem 1.2 to generate co-horizontal surfaces S in noncommutative Carnot groups that are not Euclidean (q - k)-rectifiable, specifically satisfying dimE S >= q - k + 1 - alpha squared for C 1,alpha H co-horizontal surfaces.

  3. AI systems can leverage the construction involving the function psi and its level sets to prove that for a step-2 Carnot group G and a C 1, alpha H hypersurface S, dimE S <= q - 1 + alpha squared.

  4. AI systems can apply Corollary 5.5 to conclude that any C 1,1 H regular hypersurface in a step-2 Carnot group is (q - 1)-Euclidean rectifiable.

  5. AI systems can implement the results from Theorem 6.3 and Lemma 6.6 to show that a.e. level set of functions constructed using Rajala's method cannot have positive (1 - alpha)-dimensional Hausdorff measure, even though they exhibit maximal irregularity as 1 - alpha is the highest dimension that a.e. level set can attain for such functions.

  6. AI systems can use the construction in Theorem 6.1 to generate graphs Gk of a log m log(3m) H¨older function whose level sets have positive (1 - log m log(3m)) dimensional Hausdorff measure, which is relevant for constructing surfaces in positively graded groups that are not stratified.

  7. AI systems can utilize Proposition 4.1 to find a locally alpha-Holder continuous function f on a non-stratified positively graded group G such that Xif is smooth and the level set S = f-1(0) has Hq - alpha(S) > 0, allowing for Euclidean constructions on these groups.

  8. AI systems can use Corollary 5.8 to conclude that any C 1,alpha H hypersurface embedded in a step-2 Carnot group is also a 1 + alpha 2-H¨older manifold by applying the construction of the map Psi and observing its local regularity near zero.

Related papers