On the quantum statistical relation and the covariant phase space Hamiltonian
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On the quantum statistical relation and the covariant phase space Hamiltonian".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. On the quantum statistical relation and the covariant phase space Hamiltonian, this paper shows how to construct a covariant phase space Hamiltonian in theories with gauge freedoms and demonstrates that this Hamiltonian gives directly to the quantum statistical relation in black-hole backgrounds Construction of the Covariant Phase Space Hamiltonian The authors show how the covariant phase space Hamiltonian can be constructed in theories where some fields have gauge freedoms The addition to the action of boundary terms that guarantee the well-posedness of a variational principle and its exact gauge invariance for the prescribed boundary conditions turn out to be essential in this construction These same ingredients are essential in the use of the action in Gibbons and Hawking’s Euclidean approach to Quantum Gravity, where the on-shell action can be expressed in terms of the covariant phase space Hamiltonian The paper provides a closed expression for this Hamiltonian for a generic diffeomorphism-invariant field theory and works out several examples with Dirichlet boundary conditions, including one with Chern–Simons terms.
Kai: Derivation of Conserved Charges The paper reviews the basics of classical field theories and the construction of conserved charges associated with the symmetries of a Lagrangian through Noether's theorems.
Mira: The derivation involves relating the variation of the Lagrangian to total derivatives, leading to off-shell identities known as gauge or Noether identities.
Kai: These identities imply that the theory contains less degrees of freedom than fields.
Paper summary: Kai: To summarize what this paper is about, it shows how you can construct a covariant phase space Hamiltonian in theories with gauge freedoms. The thesis is that adding specific boundary terms makes the variational principle well-posed and keeps the gauge invariance exact for your chosen boundary conditions.
Mira: The claim they make is that these same boundary terms are crucial because they are essential ingredients in Gibbons and Hawking’s Euclidean approach to quantum gravity, allowing them to express the on-shell action using this covariant phase space Hamiltonian.
Lev: They then compute this Hamiltonian for several theories, including one with Chern–Simons terms, and they show that when applied to black hole backgrounds, it directly yields the quantum statistical relation.
Kai: So what this matters is that it connects the standard tools from Euclidean gravity with a phase space structure that handles gauge freedoms nicely. It’s showing how to handle those fields properly in a quantum setting.
Mira: It’s also important because they show that this approach works for Einstein-Maxwell theories, even when you include Chern–Simons terms, which is where we often need these specific structures.
Lev: The method relies on relating the variation of the Lagrangian to total derivatives, leading to off-shell identities called gauge or Noether identities. This implies the theory has fewer degrees of freedom than you might think.
Kai: And they establish that the conservation of Noether currents is guaranteed by the algebraic Poincaré lemma, which lets you write those currents as a total derivative even without solving for the Hamiltonian explicitly on-shell.
Mira: That structure is key because it allows them to recover the quantum statistical relation using previous results where the Euclidean path integral relates to an integral of these conserved charges constructed in Section three <ref:2610.13377#pg2>.
Lev: The on-shell Euclidean action with Dirichlet boundary conditions gives you the leading term in the saddle point approximation of the path integral, which they then show is equal to a linear combination of charges associated with the Killing vector generating your horizon.
Kai: It’s a direct bridge between finding conserved charges and deriving thermodynamic relations for black holes through this Hamiltonian formalism.
Conclusion: Mira: Looking at the title, "On the quantum statistical relation and the covariant phase space Hamiltonian," it sounds like they are focusing on how to link these two major concepts together in a formal way.
Kai: The paper shows that by constructing this covariant phase space Hamiltonian, you can directly derive the quantum statistical relation in black hole backgrounds, including terms for non-gravitational charges and chemical potentials.
Lev: In simple terms, it means you use this Hamiltonian to get the thermodynamic relations you expect when dealing with black holes. It’s a way to see how gauge freedoms interact with those physical charges.
Mira: They are essentially showing that the structure of the phase space formalism, when paired with the right boundary terms and constraints from gauge invariance, is powerful enough to capture these quantum statistical features.
Kai: The authors provide a closed-form expression for this covariant phase space Hamiltonian and show it's consistent with the quantum statistical relation in Einstein-Maxwell theories that have Chern–Simons terms.
Lev: One thing they flag as a limitation is that the ambiguity in defining charges and boundary terms can change the Hamiltonian only by a total derivative, meaning you get an exactly invariant result when you integrate over a specific dimension, like d minus two dimensions.
Mira: So while they give us this powerful connection, it stops short of giving us everything; we still need to explore extensions, like incorporating scalar fields or adding a cosmological constant to see how the whole structure holds up.
Instituto de Física Teórica UAM/CSIC · University of Amsterdam · CSIC
hep-th, gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-10-09
Updated: 2026-11-02
Comments: latex file, 42 pages, no figures. References added
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: On the quantum statistical relation and the covariant phase space Hamiltonian, this paper shows how to construct a covariant phase space Hamiltonian in theories with gauge freedoms and demonstrates…
Key concepts
- Covariant Phase Space Hamiltonian
- This is a mathematical tool used to describe the dynamics of field theories, especially those with gauge freedoms. It's constructed by modifying the action with boundary terms that ensure the variational principle is well-posed and respects gauge invariance. It allows for a direct link between the action and conserved charges.
- Quantum Statistical Relation (QSR)
- The QSR is a fundamental relation in quantum gravity that connects thermodynamic quantities, like entropy, to geometric properties of black holes. The paper shows that the Hamiltonian derived from their construction directly expresses this relation in black-hole backgrounds by relating it to charges associated with the horizon's Killing vector.
- Gauge Invariance and Boundary Terms
- The paper emphasizes that adding specific boundary terms is crucial for fixing the variational problem and ensuring exact gauge invariance, especially when fields have gauge freedoms. These boundary terms are not arbitrary; they are necessary ingredients that allow the construction of a consistent Hamiltonian and its subsequent relation to physical observables.
- Chern-Simons Terms
- These are specific types of terms added to the Lagrangian in field theories, such as those studied in this paper. The authors demonstrate that their general construction method works successfully even when these terms are present, providing a concrete example where the resulting Hamiltonian correctly reproduces the expected quantum statistical relations.
Summary
On the quantum statistical relation and the covariant phase space Hamiltonian, this paper shows how to construct a covariant phase space Hamiltonian in theories with gauge freedoms and demonstrates that this Hamiltonian gives directly to the quantum statistical relation in black-hole backgrounds
Construction of the Covariant Phase Space Hamiltonian
The authors show how the covariant phase space Hamiltonian can be constructed in theories where some fields have gauge freedoms The addition to the action of boundary terms that guarantee the well-posedness of a variational principle and its exact gauge invariance for the prescribed boundary conditions turn out to be essential in this construction These same ingredients are essential in the use of the action in Gibbons and Hawking’s Euclidean approach to Quantum Gravity, where the on-shell action can be expressed in terms of the covariant phase space Hamiltonian The paper provides a closed expression for this Hamiltonian for a generic diffeomorphism-invariant field theory and works out several examples with Dirichlet boundary conditions, including one with Chern–Simons terms.
Derivation of Conserved Charges
The paper reviews the basics of classical field theories and the construction of conserved charges associated with the symmetries of a Lagrangian through Noether's theorems. The derivation involves relating the variation of the Lagrangian to total derivatives, leading to off-shell identities known as gauge or Noether identities. p. 5 8)
and, since the first term in the right-hand side cannot be rewritten as a total derivative,
it must identically vanish
NA[φ] = 0 . 9)
These off-shell identities are known as gauge or Noether identities. 9)
These off-shell identities are known as gauge or Noether identities. They are non-trivial
relations between the equations of motion, implying that they are not all independent
and that the theory contains less degrees of freedom than fields. The off-shell closedness is characteristic of the local nature of the symmetry, and
it prevents us from extracting any dynamical conservation law. However, by virtue of
the algebraic Poincaré lemma [18, 19], J[Λ] can be written off-shell as a total derivative
J[Λ] = dQ[Λ] , (2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Extension to Matter Theories and Boundary Conditions
The goals of the paper include extending Harlow and Wu’s results to theories of gravity coupled to matter, treating all matter fields properly due to their gauge freedoms. The construction leads to a Hamiltonian charge that is defined over a (d − 2)-dimensional boundary and is consistent with the quantum statistical relation in Einstein-Maxwell theories including Chern–Simons terms. p. 0 The same ingredients are essential in the
use of the action in the framework of Gibbons and Hawking’s Euclidean approach
to Quantum Gravity and we show how the on-shell action constructed with a Lagrangian with those properties can be expressed in terms of the covariant phase
space Hamiltonian. We compute the Hamiltonian of several theories, one of which
has Chern–Simons terms using our prescription and show that, in black-hole backgrounds, the Hamiltonian gives directly the quantum statistical relation including
terms related to non-gravitational charges and chemical potentials, as expected. The addition to the
action of boundary terms that guarantee the well-posedness of a variational principle and its exact gauge invariance for the prescribed boundary conditions turn
out to be essential in this construction. The same ingredients are essential in the
use of the action in the framework of Gibbons and Hawking’s Euclidean approach
to Quantum Gravity and we show how the on-shell action constructed with a Lagrangian with those properties can be expressed in terms of the covariant phase
space Hamiltonian.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Recovery of the Quantum Statistical Relation
The paper shows that one can recover the quantum statistical relation using previous results, where the Euclidean path integral is related to an integral of conserved charges constructed in Section 3. The on-shell Euclidean action with Dirichlet boundary conditions gives the leading term in the saddle point approximation of the path integral, which is shown to be equal to a linear combination of charges associated with the Killing vector generating the horizon. p. 3 At the same time, it allows us to compute
explicitly the Euclidean action as a boundary integral. In this direction, we show that
the result is always related to the so-called quantum statistical relation when Dirichlet
boundary conditions are used. The same ingredients are essential in the
use of the action in the framework of Gibbons and Hawking’s Euclidean approach
to Quantum Gravity and we show how the on-shell action constructed with a Lagrangian with those properties can be expressed in terms of the covariant phase
space Hamiltonian. We compute the Hamiltonian of several theories, one of which
has Chern–Simons terms using our prescription and show that, in black-hole backgrounds, the Hamiltonian gives directly the quantum statistical relation including
terms related to non-gravitational charges and chemical potentials, as expected.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusions and Future Directions
The paper concludes by presenting a closed-form expression for the Covariant Phase Space Hamiltonian and showing its consistency with the quantum statistical relation in Einstein-Maxwell theories including Chern–Simons terms. The authors suggest several extensions, such as considering theories with scalar fields and scalar charges, or adding a cosmological constant. Future work will focus on deriving the Hamiltonian with other boundary conditions and evaluating it for relevant classes of solutions to find explicit expressions for thermodynamic quantities. p. 9 by adding appropriate total
derivatives/boundary terms to it. These additional terms, however, are relevant in the
construction of the phase space and the Hamiltonian and, obviously, when evaluating
the (Euclidean) action.Where the paper says it
A The proof of Eq. p. 1 1 Minimal 5-dimensional supergravity . 32
6 Conclusions 33
A The proof of Eq.Where the paper says it
The proof proceeds by particularizing the first variational formula to gauge transformations with gauge parameter δΛξ, leading to an identity involving the total derivative C[φ, δΛξ]. Using the consistency condition and performing integration by parts, one arrives at the desired identity on-shell and on the boundary. p. 0 The same ingredients are essential in the
use of the action in the framework of Gibbons and Hawking’s Euclidean approach
to Quantum Gravity and we show how the on-shell action constructed with a Lagrangian with those properties can be expressed in terms of the covariant phase
space Hamiltonian. We compute the Hamiltonian of several theories, one of which
has Chern–Simons terms using our prescription and show that, in black-hole backgrounds, the Hamiltonian gives directly the quantum statistical relation including
terms related to non-gravitational charges and chemical potentials, as expected.Where the paper says it
B The proof of Eq. p. 1 1 Minimal 5-dimensional supergravity . 32
6 Conclusions 33
A The proof of Eq.Where the paper says it
To prove Eq. (3.11), an alternative expression for C[φ, δΛξ] over the boundary is obtained using the consistency condition. p. 2 As we
are going to see, this classically unnecessary requirement will allow us to δ-integrate
the equation defining the Hamiltonian. We will be able to provide a closed expression
for it for a generic diff-invariant field theory and we will work out explicitly several examples with Dirichlet boundary conditions, including one with Chern–Simons terms. an action extremized by the solutions to the classical equations of motion for certain boundary conditions. This result is a bit surprising
since, classically, the action is just an extremely convenient way to encode equations of
motion that are well behaved under certain symmetry groups. We refrain from denoting these transformations with the standard symbol δξ because, as discussed at length in Refs. [9–11],
those transformations must include induced or compensating gauge transformation δΛξ
whose gauge parameter Λξ depends on the vector field ξ.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
C Ambiguities of the Hamiltonian
The authors study the effect of ambiguities in the definitions of charges and boundary terms on the Hamiltonian, showing that it only changes by a total derivative, meaning the Hamiltonian obtained by integration over a (d − 2)-dimensional boundary is exactly invariant.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved Hamiltonian Construction for Gauge Theories: The AI system can construct a well-defined covariant phase space Hamiltonian for theories with gauge freedoms by incorporating boundary terms that guarantee
the well-posedness of a variational principle and its exact gauge invariance for the prescribed boundary conditions.
-
Quantum Statistical Relation Computation: The improved system can compute the quantum statistical relation by expressing the on-shell Euclidean action in terms of the covariant phase space Hamiltonian, which is consistent with Gibbons and Hawking’s Euclidean approach to Quantum Gravity.
-
Generalized Charge Calculation: The system can calculate generalized Komar charges for solutions admitting Killing vectors using the derived expression K[k] equal to
-QNW[k] + wK
and its relation to Page charges.
Abstract
We show how the covariant phase space Hamiltonian can be constructed in theories in which some of the fields have gauge freedoms. The addition to the action of boundary terms that guarantee the well-posedness of a variational principle and its exact gauge invariance for the prescribed boundary conditions turn out to be essential in this construction. The same ingredients are essential in the use of the action in the framework of Gibbons and Hawking's Euclidean approach to Quantum Gravity and we show how the on-shell action constructed with a Lagrangian with those properties can be expressed in terms of the covariant phase space Hamiltonian. We compute the Hamiltonian of several theories, one of which has Chern--Simons terms, using our prescription and show that, in black-hole backgrounds, the Hamiltonian gives directly the quantum statistical relation including terms related to non-gravitational charges and chemical potentials, as expected.
Sources
- Conserved Charges in Extended Theories of Gravity
- Advanced Lectures on General Relativity
- Covariant canonical formulations of classical field theories
- The First Law of Black Hole Mechanics for Fields with Internal Gauge Freedom
- The first law of black hole mechanics in the Einstein-Maxwell theory revisited
- The first law of heterotic stringy black hole mechanics at zeroth order in alpha prime
- The first law and Wald entropy formula of heterotic stringy black holes at first order in alpha prime
- Covariant phase space with boundaries
- General theory of Lie derivatives for Lorentz tensors
- The local moduli space of the Einstein-Yang-Mills system
- Covariant Lie Derivatives and (Super-)Gravity
- Noether-Wald charge in supergravity: the fermionic contribution
- Noether-Wald and Komar charges in supergravity, fermions, and Killing supervectors in superspace
- Komar charge of N = 2 supergravity and its superspace generalization
- Black hole entropy and Lorentz-diffeomorphism Noether charge
- The Komar charges of type II supergravity and supersymmetric localization
- Smarr Formula for Lovelock Black Holes: a Lagrangian approach
- Komar integrals for theories of higher order in the curvature and black-hole chemistry
- Komar integral and Smarr formula for axion-dilaton black holes versus S duality
- Black hole chemistry, the cosmological constant and the embedding tensor
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions