Reassessing the Connection Between the Color Glass Condensate and TMD PDFs
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Reassessing the Connection Between the Color Glass Condensate and TMD PDFs".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper reassesses the connection between the Color Glass Condensate (CGC) and Transverse Momentum Dependent (TMD) PDFs by arguing that standard CGC formulations omit collinear exchanges required for a meaningful comparison with TMD factorization.
Kai: Missing Collinear Sector The authors argue that in its standard formulation, the CGC does not contain the collinear sector necessary for a meaningful comparison with TMD factorization.
Mira: They propose that the Wilson lines usually identified as part of the proton matrix element should instead be interpreted as equivalent to a soft factor.
Kai: Restoring these missing collinear exchanges leads to a new definition of small-x PDFs derived from an explicit calculation of the DIS cross section using CGC Feynman rules.
Title and authors: Kai: So Mira, we're looking at this paper called "Reassessing the Connection Between the Color Glass Condensate and TMD PDFs." It sounds like they are trying to fix a gap between two big ways of looking at small-x physics.
Mira: Yeah, that’s what it is. They’re taking the standard Color Glass Condensate, or CGC, and comparing it to Transverse Momentum Dependent PDFs, or TMD PDFs. The title suggests they are questioning how well these two connect right now.
Lev: I wonder what the actual issue is with the connection? Is it just a mathematical mismatch, or is there something physical missing from one side of the equation?
Kai: Exactly that’s what this paper addresses. It argues that in its standard formulation, the CGC doesn't have all of the necessary components for a proper comparison with TMD factorization.
Mira: So what does that mean in practice? Are we just ignoring some details when we use CGC calculations for things like semi-inclusive deep-inelastic scattering or SIDIS?
Lev: It means they believe the standard way of building the CGC doesn't include the collinear sector that TMD factorization has built into its structure by construction.
Kai: Right, so they’re saying what you usually call Wilson lines in the proton matrix element should actually be treated more like a soft factor instead.
Mira: That would fundamentally change how we define those small-x PDFs that we use to predict cross sections.
Lev: If you restore those missing collinear exchanges, they get a brand new way of defining the small-x PDFs by calculating the DIS cross section explicitly using CGC Feynman rules.
The paper's summary: Kai: So the main takeaway here is this new definition of small-x PDFs, which they call Eq. (twenty-three) <ref:2610.10189#pg3>. They show how you can calculate a cross section, Eq. (twenty-one), that looks somewhat like TMD factorization but isn't actually equivalent to it <ref:2610.10189#pg3>.
Mira: I see why that’s important for theorists—if it’s not equivalent, then the standard CGC way of thinking about these PDFs is incomplete. They are claiming the standard CGC formulation omits collinear exchanges that are present by construction in TMD factorization.
Lev: So they are essentially showing what a CGC calculation looks like once you include those missing terms that TMD factorization naturally accounts for.
Kai: It’s not just a small adjustment, though; they also talk about how these new PDFs evolve with respect to the rapidity cutoff Lambda and the Bjorken variable xb.
Mira: And they make a distinction there: while the CGC logic itself stays pretty similar, physical cross sections don't depend on renormalization scales. The dependence on Lambda can be moved into either the hard factor hT,L(Q2; µ) or in the function c(u, ξ/xb, k⊥, Q2; Λ).
Lev: So it’s not that they have to change how we think about evolution entirely; it’s just where the dependence lands. The variable xb enters directly through that collinear sector and doesn't follow a standard small-x evolution equation by itself.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So what are these improvements they are proposing? They suggest a way to get a more explicit calculation of the DIS cross section using CGC Feynman rules, which is how they get that new definition of small-x PDFs.
Mira: The real improvement, for me, is the conceptual shift about those Wilson lines. They argue that treating them as soft factors instead of matrix element parts resolves the tension between CGC and TMD factorization.
Lev: If we are building real hardware for error correction, this means the overhead we expect from the CGC sector needs to account for these missing collinear exchanges when modeling things like small-x behavior.
Kai: And they show that even though their resulting expression resembles TMD factorization, it’s not equivalent to it because of those missing pieces. It’s a form sharing similarities but not matching up perfectly.
Mira: They also point out that this new definition of PDFs is process dependent because the structure of the Wilson lines depends on the specific process you are looking at. That’s a big deal for experimental comparison.
Lev: For running simulations, that means we have to track how those dependencies on xb and Lambda shift around depending on what process we are actually studying in a collision.
Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping it up, the paper "Reassessing the Connection Between the Color Glass Condensate and TMD PDFs" basically says that you can't always ignore collinear exchanges between virtual photons or final-state partons and the proton in small-x formalisms for DIS or SIDIS.
Mira: And they conclude that their resulting PDFs are different from those in earlier seminal work, like thirteen, because the classical soft gluon field is identified with an operator entering the proton matrix element, whereas here it plays a role closer to that of a soft factor <ref:2610.10189#pg2>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, what they’re saying is that the CGC soft factor they construct carries target dependence on the side of things, while the TMD soft factor is just a vacuum matrix element and target independent.
Kai: So for us in hardware development, it suggests that when we model these high-energy processes with CGC tools, we need to be very careful about whether we’re treating those gluon fields as matrix elements or just external factors.
Mira: Exactly. The paper provides a first-principles way to resolve issues raised in previous work by showing how the construction of Eq. (twenty-three) has similarities with the factorization formula from eight and it possesses both DGLAP and small-x evolutions, which is something that’s been sought after in other papers <ref:2610.10189#pg3>.
Lev: I just think it solidifies why we need these more rigorous definitions when we are trying to translate these theories down to models that have to run on real hardware.
Departamento de F࿚ s, Universidad Tnica Federico Santa Mar궡
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-10-07
Updated: 2026-10-28
Comments: 17 pages, 4 figures
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 79/100
The gist: The paper reassesses the connection between the Color Glass Condensate (CGC) and Transverse Momentum Dependent (TMD) PDFs by arguing that standard CGC formulations omit collinear exchanges required…
Key concepts
- Color Glass Condensate (CGC)
- A theoretical framework used to describe the high-energy limit of hadronic collisions, particularly at small x. It models the proton as a dense, coherent state of gluons that behaves like a classical field. Standard formulations in this area are being challenged by this work.
- Transverse Momentum Dependent (TMD) PDFs
- These are parton distribution functions that depend not only on the longitudinal momentum fraction (x) but also on the transverse momentum of the parton. They are crucial for describing processes where the transverse motion of partons is important, like in semi-inclusive deep-inelastic scattering.
- Collinear Exchanges
- These are specific interactions involving particles that travel nearly parallel to each other (collinear). The authors argue that standard CGC models omit these exchanges, which are present in TMD factorization. Restoring them leads to a more complete description of the physics.
- Soft Factor vs. Collinear Wilson Line
- The paper distinguishes between two types of Wilson lines used in calculations. In standard CGC, these are treated as a soft factor; however, the authors propose that they should be interpreted as equivalent to collinear exchanges for a proper comparison with TMD factorization.
Terminology
Summary
The paper reassesses the connection between the Color Glass Condensate (CGC) and Transverse Momentum Dependent (TMD) PDFs by arguing that standard CGC formulations omit collinear exchanges required for a meaningful comparison with TMD factorization. p. 0
Missing Collinear Sector
The authors argue that in its standard formulation, the CGC does not contain the collinear sector necessary for a meaningful comparison with TMD factorization. They propose that the Wilson lines usually identified as part of the proton matrix element should instead be interpreted as equivalent to a soft factor. p. 0 Restoring these missing collinear exchanges leads to a new definition of small-x PDFs derived from an explicit calculation of the DIS cross section using CGC Feynman rules. p. 0
A Revisited Definition of Small-x PDFs
The main result is a new definition of small-x PDFs, Eq. (23) and the corresponding expression for the cross section, Eq. p. 2 (21). The resulting expression can be cast in a form sharing some similarities with TMD factorization but is not equivalent to it. p. 2 The authors claim that the CGC as standardly formulated omits collinear exchanges present by construction in TMD factorization. p. 2
Wave Function with Collinear Insertion
The calculation for the wave function involves computing the amplitude using specific conventions, such as working in a wrong
light-cone gauge A− = 0. The amplitude reads M = eef g 2π Z d 2x⊥d 2 y⊥ e −ip1⊥. p. 8x⊥ e −i(p2⊥−k⊥).y⊥ CLONLO. p. 8 After Fourier transform, the NLO expression is obtained in terms of a modified Bessel function K1. p. 9
Evolution of Small-x PDFs
The evolution of the resulting PDFs depends on the rapidity cutoff Λ and the Bjorken variable xb. The authors show that while the CGC logic remains unchanged, physical cross sections do not depend on renormalization scales. p. 1 The dependence on Λ can be included in either the hard factor hT,L(Q2; µ) or in the function c(u, ξ/xb, k⊥, Q2; Λ). p. 7 The variable xb enters directly through the collinear sector and does not obey a small-x evolution equation on its own. p. 0
Discussion
The authors conclude that the CGC soft factor differs fundamentally from the one in TMD factorization because what they call the CGC soft factor is not obtained by explicitly subtracting regions from a general Feynman diagram. Their construction provides a first-principles resolution to issues raised in [30]. p. 8 The construction of Eq. p. 1 (23) shows similarities with the factorization formula of [8] and possesses both DGLAP and small-x evolutions, which is a feature long called for in [39]. p. 6
Conclusion
The main message is that collinear exchanges between the virtual photon or final-state partons and the proton cannot always be neglected in small-x formalisms applied to DIS or SIDIS. The resulting PDFs differ from those in seminal work [13] because the classical soft-gluon field is identified with an operator entering the proton matrix element, whereas they play a role closer to that of a soft factor. p. 0 The two objects differ by construction, as SCGC carries a target dependence while the TMD soft factor is vacuum matrix element and target independent. p. 3
Acknowledgments
This work received support from Fondecyt (Chile) grants 1251322 and from ANID CCTVal CIA250027.
References
[1] S. Catani, M. Ciafaloni and F. Hautmann, Gluon contributions to small x heavy flavour production, Phys. p. 4 Lett. B 242 (1990) 97–102
[2] S. Catani, M. Ciafaloni and F. Hautmann, High energy factorization and small-x heavy flavour production, Nucl. p. 3 Phys. B 366 (1991) 1 135–188
[3] J. Collins and R. Ellis, Heavy-quark production in very high energy hadron collisions, Nucl. Phys. B 360 (1991) 3–30
[4] E. M. Levin, M. G. Ryskin, Y. M. Shabelski and A. G. Shuvaev, Heavy quark production in semihard nucleon interactions, Soviet Journal of Nuclear Physics 53 (1991) 657
[5] L. McLerran and R. p. 3 p. 3 Venugopalan, Computing quark and gluon distribution functions for very large nuclei, Phys. p. 6 Rev. D 49 (1994) 2233
[6] L. McLerran and R. Venugopalan, Gluon distribution functions for very large nuclei at small transverse momentum, Phys. p. 6 Rev. D 49 (1994) 3352
[7] E. Iancu, A. Leonidov and L. p. 3 p. 3 McLerran, Nonlinear gluon evolution in the color glass condensate: I, Nucl. p. 0 Phys. A 692 (2001) 583–645
[8] D. Neill, A. Pathak and I. W. Stewart, Small-x factorization from effective field theory, JHEP 2023 (2023) 9
[9] P. Kotko et al., Improved TMD factorization for forward dijet production in dilute-dense hadronic collisions, JHEP 2015 (2015) 9
[10] A. van Hameren et al., Searching for saturation in forward dijet production at the LHC, Eur. p. 4 Phys. J. C 83 (2023) 10
[11] P. Caucal and E. Iancu, Evolution of the transverse-momentum dependent gluon distribution at small x, PRD 111 (2025) 7 074008
[12] P. Caucal, E. Iancu, F. Salazar and F. Yuan, Gluon splitting at small x: a unified derivation for the JIMWLK, DGLAP and CSS equations, JHEP 2026 (2026) 3
[13] F. Dominguez, C. Marquet, B.-W. Xiao and F. Yuan, Universality of unintegrated gluon distributions at small x, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011) 105005
[14] X. Ji, J.-P. Ma and F. Yuan, QCD factorization for spin-dependent cross sections in DIS and Drell–Yan processes at low transverse momentum, Phys. p. 4 Lett. B 597 (2004) 3–4 299–308
[15] X. Ji, J.-P. Ma and F. Yuan, QCD factorization for semi-inclusive deep-inelastic scattering at low transverse momentum, Phys. p. 5 Rev. D 71 (2005) 3 034005
[16] J. Collins, Foundations of Perturbative QCD, Cambridge University Press (2023), ISBN 9781009401821
[17] E. Avsar, TMD factorization and the gluon distribution in high energy QCD (2012), arXiv:1203.1916 [hep-ph]
[18] F. Gelis, E. Iancu, J. Jalilian-Marian and R. p. 3 Venugopalan, The Color Glass Condensate, Ann. p. 0 Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 60 (2010) 463
[19] E. Iancu, A. Leonidov and L. McLerran, The Colour Glass Condensate: An Introduction (2002)
[20] E. Iancu and R. p. 3 Venugopalan, THE COLOR GLASS CONDENSATE AND HIGH ENERGY SCATTERING IN QCD, Quark-gluon plasma 4, pages 249–3363 (2003)
[21] I. Balitsky, Operator expansion for high-energy scattering, Nucl. p. 3 Phys. B 463 (1996) 99–157
[22] J. Jalilian-Marian, A. p. 3 Kovner, A. Leonidov and H. p. 3 Weigert, The BFKL equation from the Wilson renormalization group, Nucl. p. 4
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved ability to model small-x physics in Deep Inelastic Scattering (DIS) by providing a new definition of small-x PDFs based on restored collinear exchanges. This allows AI systems to make more accurate predictions for cross sections in regions where standard Color Glass Condensate calculations are incomplete, as noted by the authors:
Restoring the missing collinear exchanges, we obtain a new definition of small-x PDFs from an explicit calculation of the DIS cross section using CGC Feynman rules.
-
Enhanced understanding of factorization formalism by distinguishing between different types of Wilson lines. The AI can now correctly interpret whether a correlator should be treated as a
collinear Wilson line
or asoft factor,
which is crucial for comparing predictions with TMD factorization, as the paper argues:The CGC Wilson lines usually identified as part of the proton matrix element should instead be interpreted as the equivalent of a soft factor.
-
Capability to perform process-dependent calculations for small-x PDFs. The system can now calculate PDF definitions that explicitly depend on the process, unlike previous models, by using Eq. (23) which introduces a
process dependent
soft function:Our small-x PDFs are process dependent because the structure of Wilson lines depends on the process.
-
Improved handling of kinematic dependencies in cross sections. The AI can accurately calculate DIS cross sections that include both soft multiple scatterings and collinear exchanges, leading to a result that shares similarities with TMD factorization while not being equivalent, as shown in Eq. (21):
The resulting expression can be cast in a form resembling TMD factorization without being equivalent to it.
-
Better constraint handling for evolution equations. The AI can correctly identify that the dependence on the rapidity cutoff Lambda and Bjorken variable xb is governed by different dynamics, allowing for the correct choice of renormalization scale treatment:
Λ governs the CGC sector and its JIMWLK evolution, while xb enters directly through the collinear sector.
Sources
- TMD factorization and the gluon distribution in high energy QCD
- The origin of Bjorken- x dependence in DIS: a case for a z-dependent correlator in the CGC
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses