A counterexamples to the Polishchuk--Van den Bergh conjecture on curves
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.
Ada: I'm Ada.
Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.
Ada: We're looking at the paper: "A counterexamples to the Polishchuk--Van den Bergh conjecture on curves".
Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. For every h ≥ 1, an explicit S3 action on the smooth projective model of y squared = t(12h−5 + t) has quotient of genus h and exactly one ramification orbit, with inertia of order three.
Ada: This construction provides counterexamples to Conjecture A of Polishchuk and Van den Bergh by showing that the conclusion fails for effective actions on smooth projective curves.
Emmy: Counterexamples to the Conjecture The paper constructs an explicit S3 action on a smooth projective model of y squared = t(12h−5 + t) where the genus of the curve is 6h − 3 and the genus of its quotient is h.
Ada: This action exhibits exactly one nonfree orbit with a stabilizer of order three, and its fixed quotient for the three-cycle class consists of two points, but this category admits no C-linear exact fully faithful embedding into the equivariant derived category.
Paper summary: Ada: To summarize what this paper does, they build these explicit examples for every h greater than or equal to one. They take the smooth projective model of y squared equals t raised to the power of twelve h minus five plus t, and apply an S3 action.
Emmy: The key feature they highlight is that this action results in a quotient curve whose genus is exactly h, and there's only one ramification orbit involved in this setup, which has an inertia order of three.
Kolya: So it’s not just any curve; it’s tied to this specific power of t and S3 symmetry. What's the main claim they are pushing against?
Ada: The paper claims that for every h greater than or equal to one, there is an explicit S3 action on this curve model that has exactly one ramification orbit with inertia order three.
Emmy: And the result of this construction is a quotient curve of genus h, and the authors show that its derived category simply admits no C-linear exact fully faithful embedding into the equivariant derived category.
Kolya: So they’re saying that even when all the setup conditions for their conjecture are met, this specific type of structure—this one with inertia order three—is impossible in terms of derived categories.
Ada: Exactly. They show that this failure happens for every h greater than or equal to one, and they prove more generally that the maximum number of pairwise completely orthogonal exceptional objects is P i floor(ei over two), where ei are the inertia orders.
Emmy: This is really pointing towards a structural limitation in how these derived categories can interact with these group actions on curves. It suggests a constraint on what kind of collections we can have.
Kolya: And they also characterized when a conjugacy-class decomposition with embeddings linear over the coarse quotient exists, stating it only happens if the number of elements from the conjugacy class that hit every branch inertia group is less than or equal to floor(ei over two).
Conclusion: Ada: So, looking at this paper, "A counterexamples to the Polishchuk--Van den Bergh conjecture on curves," it’s clear that this work tackles a deep question about the structure of derived categories associated with group actions on curves.
Emmy: The authors are using these specific S3 actions on curves with inertia order three to show that Conjecture A of Polishchuk and Van den Bergh is false. They achieve this by finding a specific curve, like the genus three curve y squared equals t raised to the power of seven plus t, whose quotient is an elliptic curve b squared equals u cubed minus four u.
Kolya: For someone who just listens to the show, what does this mean in practice? It’s not just abstract math about derived categories; it means there are specific geometric objects where these expected structural properties don't hold.
Ada: Right. The implication is that the conditions for a linear action decomposition might be more restrictive than previously thought, or that the simple assumption of smoothness and effectivity isn't enough to guarantee the conclusion of their conjecture.
Emmy: They also point out that these counterexamples don't apply to linear reflection-group actions, which is a bit nuanced. They show this failure occurs specifically in the context of non-linear actions, like the S3 action they built.
Kolya: So what’s the takeaway for how we think about these kinds of geometric objects? It suggests we have to be much more careful when we assume certain properties about fixed quotients and their derived categories.
Ada: That's right. This paper gives us a concrete family of counterexamples, proving that the conclusion of Conjecture A doesn't hold in those cases, even when the setup looks perfect on the surface.
Beijing Jiaotong University
math.AG, math.CT
Submitted: 2026-10-07
Updated: 2026-11-04
Comments: All comments are welcome!
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 82/100
The gist: For every h ≥ 1, an explicit S3 action on the smooth projective model of y squared = t(12h−5 + t) has quotient of genus h and exactly one ramification orbit, with inertia of order three.
Key concepts
- S3 action
- This refers to an explicit action of the symmetric group on three elements (S3) on a geometric object. The paper uses this specific type of action to construct curves where the conjecture's conclusion does not hold, specifically showing that certain embeddings into derived categories are impossible.
- Conjecture A
- This is a conjecture by Polishchuk and Van den Bergh concerning the existence of certain types of embeddings (C-linear exact fully faithful embeddings) related to group actions on smooth projective curves. The paper demonstrates that their conclusion does not always follow, even under the stated hypotheses.
- Inertia order
- This describes a property related to how an element in the inertia group acts on the curve's structure during a covering or ramification process. The paper focuses on actions with exactly one ramification orbit and an inertia of order three, which is crucial for their counterexample construction.
- Perf(Y)-linear embeddings
- These are specific types of embeddings between derived categories related to the geometry of the curve Y. Theorem 5.3 provides a condition under which these embeddings can be realized, linking them to inequalities involving genus and inertia groups.
Terminology
Summary
For every h ≥ 1, an explicit S3 action on the smooth projective model of y squared = t(12h−5 + t) has quotient of genus h and exactly one ramification orbit, with inertia of order three. p. 0 We construct effective finite group actions on smooth projective complex curves for
which Conjecture A of Polishchuk and Van den Bergh fails. For every h ≥ 1, an explicit S3 action on
the smooth projective model of y
2 = t
12h−5 + t has quotient of genus h and exactly one ramification
orbit, with inertia of order three. COUNTEREXAMPLES TO THE POLISHCHUK–VAN DEN BERGH
CONJECTURE ON CURVES
SHENGYONG PAN
Abstract. We construct effective finite group actions on smooth projective complex curves for
which Conjecture A of Polishchuk and Van den Bergh fails.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Counterexamples to the Conjecture
The paper constructs an explicit S3 action on a smooth projective model of y squared = t(12h−5 + t) where the genus of the curve is 6h − 3 and the genus of its quotient is h. This action exhibits exactly one nonfree orbit with a stabilizer of order three, and its fixed quotient for the three-cycle class consists of two points, but this category admits no C-linear exact fully faithful embedding into the equivariant derived category. p. 0 For every h ≥ 1, an explicit S3 action on
the smooth projective model of y
2 = t
12h−5 + t has quotient of genus h and exactly one ramification
orbit, with inertia of order three. The fixed quotient for the three-cycle class consists of two points,
but its derived category admits no C-linear exact fully faithful embedding into the equivariant
derived category. 2 SHENGYONG PAN
(4) there is no C-linear exact fully faithful functor
Db
(Spec C ⨿ Spec C) −→ Db
S3
(Ch). Consequently, all the smoothness and effectivity hypotheses of Conjecture 1. Consequently, all the smoothness and effectivity hypotheses of Conjecture 1. 1 hold, but its conclusion
fails.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Bounds on Exceptional Objects
Theorem 5.3 proves that Conjecture 1. p. 1 Let Hi be an inertia group at that orbit and ei = |Hi
|. 3 proves that
Conjecture 1. 3 proves that
Conjecture 1. 1 admits a realization by Perf(Y )-linear embeddings if and only if
|[g] ∩ Hi
| ≤ j
ei
2
k
for every i and [g] ̸= [1]. 1 admits a realization by Perf(Y )-linear embeddings if and only if
|[g] ∩ Hi
| ≤ j
ei
2
k
for every i and [g] ̸= [1]. This criterion has no genus assumption and applies to smooth connected quasiprojective complex
curves. (4)
Lemma 2. Among the exceptional objects supported on D, the maximum number that can be
pairwise completely orthogonal is ⌊e/2⌋.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Decomposition Structure
The ordered curve decomposition is known to consist of the coarse-curve category together with ei − 1 exceptional objects at each branch orbit. The decomposition DbG(C) = Dπ∗Db(Y), B1,. p. 0 More generally, when the coarse quotient has positive genus, we prove that the
maximum number of pairwise completely orthogonal exceptional objects is P
i
⌊ei/2⌋, where ei are
the inertia orders. We also characterize conjugacy-class decompositions with embeddings linear
over the coarse quotient: such a decomposition exists if and only if |[g] ∩ Hi| ≤ ⌊ei/2⌋ for every
nonidentity conjugacy class and every branch inertia group Hi. Each exceptional subcategory here is admissible: Hom to and from its generator has finitedimensional total cohomology because the generator has proper finite support. The exceptional
projection triangles, together with the established orthogonality and generation, yield the semiorthogonal decomposition (7). The ramification subcategory is Db
(mod CA2). It contains an ordered exceptional pair, whereas its
two generators are not completely orthogonal.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Criterion for Linear Embeddings
Theorem 5.3 provides the necessary and sufficient condition for a conjugacy-class decomposition with embeddings linear over the coarse quotient to exist, which is [g] ∩ Hi ≤ j ei/2k for every branch orbit Di. p. 0 More generally, when the coarse quotient has positive genus, we prove that the
maximum number of pairwise completely orthogonal exceptional objects is P
i
⌊ei/2⌋, where ei are
the inertia orders. We also characterize conjugacy-class decompositions with embeddings linear
over the coarse quotient: such a decomposition exists if and only if |[g] ∩ Hi| ≤ ⌊ei/2⌋ for every
nonidentity conjugacy class and every branch inertia group Hi. (11)
When these conditions hold, the identity block may be chosen as π
∗Db
(Y ), and the nonidentity blocks
may occur in any prescribed total order. All embeddings can be given by G-equivariant kernels on
the natural fibre products
(C
g
/CG(g)) ×Y C. For a linear action on a vector space V , the variety V
g/CG(g) is irreducible, being a
finite quotient of a vector space. Thus the original and connected-component formulations coincide
in that setting.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Connected Component Formulation
Conjecture 4.2 states that there is a total order on I(X, G) and a semiorthogonal decomposition of DbG(X) with subcategories A([g],Z) ≃ Db(Z), one for each pair in I(X, G). p. 7 2 (Connected-component formulation). There is a total order on I(X, G) and a
semiorthogonal decomposition of Db
G(X) with subcategories A([g],Z) ≃ Db
(Z), one for each pair in
I(X, G). COUNTEREXAMPLES TO THE POLISHCHUK–VAN DEN BERGH
CONJECTURE ON CURVES
SHENGYONG PAN
Abstract. We construct effective finite group actions on smooth projective complex curves for
which Conjecture A of Polishchuk and Van den Bergh fails. Conjecture 4. 2 holds for every effective finite group action on a smooth connected
quasiprojective complex curve C.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Categorical Grouping
Theorem 5.3 states that the following conditions are equivalent: (1) Conjecture 1. p. 8 Let a finite group G act
effectively on a smooth connected quasiprojective complex curve C. The following conditions are
equivalent:
(1) Conjecture 1. 1 admits a realization whose embeddings are Perf(Y )-linear for the natural
maps of the fixed quotients to Y = C/G. (2) For every branch inertia group Hi and every nonidentity conjugacy class,
|[g] ∩ Hi
| ≤ j
ei
2
k
. (2) For every branch inertia group Hi and every nonidentity conjugacy class,
|[g] ∩ Hi
| ≤ j
ei
2
k
. (11)
When these conditions hold, the identity block may be chosen as π
∗Db
(Y ), and the nonidentity blocks
may occur in any prescribed total order. □
Thus the local inequalities characterize the existence of a conjugacy-class decomposition with
linear embeddings. The construction allows the exceptional generators within each branch block to
change; it does not require grouping the original objects Mi,l without modification.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Linearity and Conclusion
Corollary 5.4 states that if [g] ∩ Hi ≤ 1 for every branch inertia group Hi and every nonidentity conjugacy class [g], then Conjecture 1. p. 9 Suppose that |[g] ∩ Hi
| ≤ 1 for every branch inertia group Hi and every nonidentity
conjugacy class [g]. Then Conjecture 1. Then Conjecture 1. 1 holds, with Perf(Y )-linear embeddings given by kernels on
the natural fibre products. 1 holds, with Perf(Y )-linear embeddings given by kernels on
the natural fibre products. In particular, this applies to finite abelian groups acting effectively on
smooth connected quasiprojective complex curves. For an abelian group, every conjugacy class is a singleton. □
Thus the local inequalities characterize the existence of a conjugacy-class decomposition with
linear embeddings.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can detect failures of Conjecture A by constructing effective finite group actions on smooth projective complex curves for which Conjecture A fails, specifically by finding cases where
the fixed quotient for the three-cycle class consists of two points, but its derived category admits no C-linear exact fully faithful embedding into the equivariant derived category.
-
Improved AI can calculate the maximum number of pairwise completely orthogonal exceptional objects in a given equivariant derived category using Theorem 1.4, which states that
ocDbG(C) = X b i=1 j ei/2k
when genus(Y) >= 1, and this bound is attained bythe simples with indices 0, 2,..., 2⌊e/2⌋ − 2.
-
Improved AI can characterize conjugacy-class decompositions with embeddings linear over the coarse quotient by checking if
[g]∩Hi ≤ j ei/2k for every nonidentity conjugacy class and every branch inertia group Hi,
as stated in Theorem 5.3, which is equivalent to Conjecture 1.1 admitting a realization whose embeddings are Perf(Y)-linear for the natural maps of the fixed quotients to Y = C/G. -
Improved AI can implement a connected-component formulation for semiorthogonal decompositions by applying Conjecture 4.2, which states that
There is a total order on I(X, G) and a semiorthogonal decomposition of DbG(X) with subcategories A([g],Z) ≃ Db(Z), one for each pair in I(X, G).
-
Improved AI can verify the sufficiency of the connected-component formulation by checking if
the identity fixed quotient is the connected curve Y
and ifevery connected component of a nonidentity fixed quotient is a point,
matching them withthe exceptional objects Mi,ei−1,..., Mi,1.
-
Improved AI can determine when Conjecture 1.1 holds for finite abelian groups by using Corollary 5.4, which states that if
[g]∩Hi ≤ 1 for every branch inertia group Hi and every nonidentity conjugacy class [g],
thenConjecture 1.1 holds, with Perf(Y)-linear embeddings given by kernels on the natural fibre products.
Abstract
We construct an effective S 3 action on the smooth projective model of y 2=t 12h-5+t for every h at least1. Its quotient has genus h, and the fixed quotient for the three-cycle class consists of two points. We prove that the derived category of these two points admits no-linear exact fully faithful embedding into the equivariant derived category. This gives a counterexample to Conjecture A of Polishchuk and Van den Bergh. More generally, for a positive-genus quotient we compute the maximum number of completely orthogonal exceptional objects as i e i/2, where e i are the inertia orders. We also give a necessary and sufficient condition for conjugacy-class decompositions with embeddings linear over the quotient, and construct kernels on the natural fibre products. For genus-zero quotients we obtain Euler-form bounds and exact capacities for all-two ramification with at least four branch points and for types (2,3,3), (2,3,4) and (2,3,5).
Sources
- Semi-Orthogonal Decompositions for Rank Two Imprimitive Reflection Groups
- Note on Motivic Semiorthogonal Decompositions for Elementary Abelian 2-Group Actions
- Semiorthogonal decompositions of equivariant derived categories of invariant divisors
- Holomorphic bundles on 2-dimensional noncommutative toric orbifolds
Related papers
- K-unstable Toric Varieties and Secondary Polytopes
- The commuting scheme of g 2 and a degree formula for commuting schemes
- Stacky geometry and logarithmic topology of transversely affine foliations
- Monodromy and vanishing cycles for complete intersection curves
- Characteristic cycles and Gevrey irregularity in hypergeometric families
- Tautological classes on KSBA spaces