Special Loci in the Moduli of Curves
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.
Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Special Loci in the Moduli of Curves".
Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper introduces new techniques for studying mixed-characteristic special loci within moduli spaces, with a particular focus on the moduli space M g of curves.
Ada: These methods yield several applications, including Zariski density results for split Jacobians, non-density results for supersingular loci, and lifting results for algebraic cycles under appropriate numerical conditions.
Emmy: The techniques generalize to more-or-less arbitrary moduli spaces mapping to Hodge-type Shimura varieties (and some settings beyond the Shimura case), relating to questions raised by Oort and de Jong.
Ada: Key theorems establish density results in various contexts: Theorem 1.2 asserts that for a partition of genus g prime-to- p of splitting type g with a specific codimension condition delta pgq at most 3g - 3, there exists an r such that for every prime p > r, the locus SP g,p: t M F p ts J Jac q is Zariski dense in M F p.
Paper summary: Ada: So wrapping up on "Special Loci in the Moduli of Curves", we've seen how they use mixed characteristic tools to establish density results for certain loci and non-density results for others. The authors are focusing on getting a handle on the structure of special places within moduli spaces, particularly through symmetry.
Emmy: They tackle these problems by generalizing methods that work in positive characteristic, and they manage to apply these ideas across more general spaces that map to Hodge-type Shimura varieties too. It seems like this work connects deep arithmetic questions with geometric structure in a way we hadn't explored before.
Kolya: What does this mean practically? It means we have better tools for understanding the distribution of points on these spaces, and when things deviate from what's expected, we can pinpoint exactly where those deviations are happening.
Ada: Exactly. For someone listening, the implication is that in these moduli spaces, you can use number theory to tell you where the most interesting geometric features are located without having to check every single point individually.
Emmy: It’s about building a more detailed map of these spaces, showing us exactly how they are structured, especially around those special symmetries that Oort and de Jong were interested in.
Conclusion: Ada: So we've been looking at these new techniques for studying special loci in moduli spaces of curves, and now we get to talk about what this specific paper, "Special Loci in the Moduli of Curves," is actually trying to accomplish.
Emmy: It’s about taking these complicated shapes and finding the places that have a special symmetry or structure, like points that are highly constrained by number theory.
Kolya: The main thing they show is how to prove things about where these special points are located—specifically, whether they cover the whole space or just some small pieces of it.
Ada: They use mixed characteristic methods to establish some density results for splitting types, meaning they can find lots of special curves in a certain family.
Emmy: And they also show non-density results for supersingular loci, which means even there are places where these special structures don't fill up the whole space.
Kolya: So what this means is we get clearer boundaries on how dense these interesting geometric features can be in these moduli spaces.
Ada: It’s about understanding the distribution of arithmetic information across these complex geometric landscapes, and it gives us some concrete tools for that analysis.
math.AG, math.NT
Submitted: 2026-10-06
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 59 pages, minor revision, comments welcome!
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 86/100
The gist: The paper introduces new techniques for studying mixed-characteristic special loci within moduli spaces, with a particular focus on the moduli space M g of curves.
Key concepts
- Zariski Density
- This means that a subset of a space is so large that it covers the entire space when viewed through algebraic geometry. In this context, it shows that certain geometric loci are not just isolated points but form a dense structure within the larger moduli space.
- Supersingular Loci
- These are specific subsets within moduli spaces where certain arithmetic conditions related to prime characteristics hold, often linked to supersingular objects. The paper investigates whether these sets are dense or sparse, finding that they are generally not dense in relevant contexts.
- Mixed Characteristic Techniques
- These are advanced mathematical methods used to study geometric objects when the underlying field has a mix of characteristic zero (like complex numbers) and positive characteristic (like finite fields). These techniques allow the authors to prove density results by analyzing boundary strata and expected dimension inequalities.
- Special Loci in Moduli Spaces
- These are specific subsets within moduli spaces, like $\mathcal{M}_g$, that possess particular arithmetic or geometric properties. The paper focuses on characterizing these loci—determining if they are dense, non-dense, or contained within smaller subvarieties.
Terminology
Summary
The paper introduces new techniques for studying mixed-characteristic special loci within moduli spaces, with a particular focus on the moduli space M g of curves. p. 0 Special Loci in the Moduli of Curves
David Urbanik and Ziquan Yang
October 7, 2026
Abstract
We introduce new techniques to study mixed-characteristic special loci in moduli spaces and
give several applications, focusing in particular on the moduli space Mg of curves. These applications include Zariski density results for split Jacobians, non-density results for supersingular
loci, and lifting results for algebraic cycles, all under appropriate numerical conditions. Special Loci in the Moduli of Curves
David Urbanik and Ziquan Yang
October 7, 2026
Abstract
We introduce new techniques to study mixed-characteristic special loci in moduli spaces and
give several applications, focusing in particular on the moduli space Mg of curves. These applications include Zariski density results for split Jacobians, non-density results for supersingular
loci, and lifting results for algebraic cycles, all under appropriate numerical conditions. These applications include Zariski density results for split Jacobians, non-density results for supersingular
loci, and lifting results for algebraic cycles, all under appropriate numerical conditions. Our
methods generalize to more-or-less arbitrary moduli spaces mapping to Hodge-type Shimura
varieties (and even some settings beyond the Shimura case), and relate to questions raised by
Oort and de Jong.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Key theorems establish density results in various contexts: Theorem 1. p. 1 A locus in Mg of such special curves is called a special
locus of Mg. In this paper we mostly focus on the symmetry of “splitting up to isogeny” and prove
various density and non-density results, though as we will explain, the techniques generalize to
other kinds of symmetries and special loci as well. Suppose that g is a partition of g P N such that δpgq ă 3g ´ 3. Then there exists
rg P N such that for every prime p ą rg, the locus
SPg,p :“ ts P Mg,Fp
: JacpCsq is prime-to-p of splitting type gu (2)
is Zariski dense in Mg,Fp
. (The situation where one does not pass to
reduced subschemes is more subtle. )
(iv) Similarly if R “ Fp, naïve analogues of the André-Oort conjecture are false: every abelian
variety mod p carries a large enough endomorphism ring to force the Frobenius action on its
Tate module to factor through a torus, and so in particular such “CM-like” points are dense
in Mct
g
. Let M be the moduli space of smooth cubic threefolds over SpecpZq, and let X be
the universal family over M. Then there exists an r such that for all p ą r, the locus
ts P MFp
: IJpXsq is prime-to-p of splitting type p1, 1, 1, 1, 1qu (4)
is Zariski dense in MFp
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The paper also provides non-density results for supersingular loci. p. 1 A locus in Mg of such special curves is called a special
locus of Mg. In this paper we mostly focus on the symmetry of “splitting up to isogeny” and prove
various density and non-density results, though as we will explain, the techniques generalize to
other kinds of symmetries and special loci as well. We do not give a full answer to Oort’s question, but we can prove that τ pMct
g,Fp
q X A
ss
g,Fp
is ď 0
dimensional for large g away from a Zariski closed locus independent of p. When g ě 16, the union over all primes
ď
pPSpecpZq
rτ pMct
g,Fp
q X A
ss
g,Fp
s
ą0
is not Zariski dense in τ pMct
g
q. 3 Consequences for Flatness . 27
5 Proof of Theorem 1. 3 Consequences for Flatness . 27
5 Proof of Theorem 1. Write S
ss,σ0
Fp
for the supersingular locus with Artin invariant σ0. Then the union of positive-dimensional atypical
components
ď
pPSpecpZr1{Nsq
rTFp X S
ss,σ0
Fp
s
atyp,ą0
is not Zariski dense in T, and the C-fiber of the Zariski closure of this union is contained in a finite
union of Shimura subvarieties strictly contained in S pLqC.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The proof strategies are multifaceted: density proofs utilize mixed characteristic techniques applied to non-density results obtained in large positive characteristic, relying on analyzing boundary strata and the expected dimension inequality, which reduces to an unlikely intersection problem for expected-dimensional intersections with M F p reducing to a question of nondensity for unlikely-dimensional intersections with M'1,2,F p. Supersingular locus proofs employ atypical intersection techniques, leveraging the fact that the characteristic p condition is intrinsically positive-characteristic and does not require transcendence results for complex period maps. p. 8 These results arise from a somewhat different application of the atypicalintersection techniques used above, which is perhaps more surprising in the following sense. Supersingularity is an intrinsically positive-characteristic condition, defined in terms of Frobenius on
crystalline cohomology, and there is no reason a priori to expect transcendence results for complex
period maps to constrain supersingular loci in characteristic p. 3 Flatness and Lifting . 22
4 Flatness Results (for Mg,2 and Hg,2) 23
4. Suppose that g is a partition of g P N such that δpgq ă 3g ´ 3. Then there exists
rg P N such that for every prime p ą rg, the locus
SPg,p :“ ts P Mg,Fp
: JacpCsq is prime-to-p of splitting type gu (2)
is Zariski dense in Mg,Fp
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Specific results for general moduli spaces are presented: Section 4 shows that similar arguments apply to special cases like T = M 2 and X = A g, yielding density away from a strict closed subscheme E. p. 6 We note that nothing in points (i) through (vi) depended on us working with Mct
g
, and one can
carry out a similar analysis for any locally closed locus T Ă Ag with Hodge-generic complex fibre
TC, provided that one adjusts the dimension conditions accordingly. Similarly, although we focus
on loci T Ă Ag in this paper, we expect our techniques to apply to any sufficiently general locus in
any Hodge-type Shimura variety, or even to more general parameter spaces T for smooth projective
algebraic varieties. Suppose that g is a partition of g P N such that δpgq ă 3g ´ 3. Then there exists
rg P N such that for every prime p ą rg, the locus
SPg,p :“ ts P Mg,Fp
: JacpCsq is prime-to-p of splitting type gu (2)
is Zariski dense in Mg,Fp
. 3 Consequences for Flatness . 27
5 Proof of Theorem 1. 3 Consequences for Flatness . 27
5 Proof of Theorem 1.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The paper also details results for specific partitions and cases. p. 6 In these more
general cases one replaces the atypical locus of Mct
g,C with an atypical locus associated to a natural
variation of Hodge structure on TC. 3 Proof Strategy for Density Our results in this paper will be obtained by applying the
mixed characteristic techniques of (vi) to deduce novel density and non-density results in large
positive characteristic. We construct a descending sequence E1 Ě E2 Ě ¨ ¨ ¨ where
Er is the Zariski closure of the points s P T for which, for a suitable choice of frame, there exists
a non-degenerate jet j : D
d
r Ñ T based at s whose period jet factors through J
d
r Z. Since T is
Noetherian, E8 :“ Xrě1Er stabilizes at some finite order. 2 over C is attributed to unpublished work of Harris; we do not know whether
his proof was valid in positive characteristic. )
It turns out that making the Ciliberto-Harris-Miranda approach for density work for Mct
g naturally leads to unlikely-intersection-type non-density questions for special intersections with boundary components. 4 Proof of the Elliptic Factor Case . 5 Proof of the General Case . We note that nothing in points (i) through (vi) depended on us working with Mct
g
, and one can
carry out a similar analysis for any locally closed locus T Ă Ag with Hodge-generic complex fibre
TC, provided that one adjusts the dimension conditions accordingly. Similarly, although we focus
on loci T Ă Ag in this paper, we expect our techniques to apply to any sufficiently general locus in
any Hodge-type Shimura variety, or even to more general parameter spaces T for smooth projective
algebraic varieties.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The proof structure for density often involves induction and leveraging results from previous sections, such as Theorem 5. p. 6 In these more
general cases one replaces the atypical locus of Mct
g,C with an atypical locus associated to a natural
variation of Hodge structure on TC. 3 Proof Strategy for Density Our results in this paper will be obtained by applying the
mixed characteristic techniques of (vi) to deduce novel density and non-density results in large
positive characteristic. If in fact this intersection pBφq
˚
pBYFp
q
contains the entirety of the intersection of Mg,Fp with Y Fp
, then this means that the locus pBφq
˚
pBYFp
q
has larger-than-expected dimension. If such loci with larger-than-expected dimension are not dense
in Mg´1,2,Fp
, then necessarily (10) cannot happen away from a strict closed locus in Mg´1,2,Fp
, and
one obtains the desired density in Mg,Fp by deforming out from the boundary. We construct a descending sequence E1 Ě E2 Ě ¨ ¨ ¨ where
Er is the Zariski closure of the points s P T for which, for a suitable choice of frame, there exists
a non-degenerate jet j : D
d
r Ñ T based at s whose period jet factors through J
d
r Z. Since T is
Noetherian, E8 :“ Xrě1Er stabilizes at some finite order.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
In the context of Shimura varieties, Theorem 6. p. 0 These applications include Zariski density results for split Jacobians, non-density results for supersingular
loci, and lifting results for algebraic cycles, all under appropriate numerical conditions. Our
methods generalize to more-or-less arbitrary moduli spaces mapping to Hodge-type Shimura
varieties (and even some settings beyond the Shimura case), and relate to questions raised by
Oort and de Jong. Write S
ss,σ0
Fp
for the supersingular locus with Artin invariant σ0. Then the union of positive-dimensional atypical
components
ď
pPSpecpZr1{Nsq
rTFp X S
ss,σ0
Fp
s
atyp,ą0
is not Zariski dense in T, and the C-fiber of the Zariski closure of this union is contained in a finite
union of Shimura subvarieties strictly contained in S pLqC. This produces the
horizontal sections needed for the jet argument; see Proposition 6. 10 and Corollary 6. When g ě 16, the union over all primes
ď
pPSpecpZq
rτ pMct
g,Fp
q X A
ss
g,Fp
s
ą0
is not Zariski dense in τ pMct
g
q. Moreover, the image in Ag,C of the C-fiber of the Zariski closure of
this union lands inside finitely many strict Shimura subvarieties of Ag,C.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can perform Zariski density results for split Jacobians in moduli spaces like Mg,Fp under appropriate numerical conditions, as stated in Theorem 1.2, which generalizes previous AIM conjecture evidence to a broader class of special loci.
-
Improved AI can prove non-density results for supersingular loci by adapting core techniques from split Jacobian density proofs to the context of positive characteristic and Frobenius actions, as suggested in the text regarding Question 1.5 (Oort).
-
Improved AI can provide structural results for arithmetic special loci inside moduli spaces over Shimura varieties by using mixed characteristic techniques, specifically Theorem 1.11, which establishes that certain restricted pullbacks of maps factor through a strict Zariski closed locus E whose components are special subvarieties of the target space.
-
Improved AI can analyze p-isogenies as well as density results for split Jacobians by applying the paper's methods to study supersingular loci, noting that
every supersingular abelian variety is isogenous to a product of supersingular elliptic curves
and relating this to prime-to-p splitting. -
Improved AI can determine whether a locus in Mg,Fp has the expected codimension by analyzing intersection properties using an
all or nothing
principle derived from Hodge theory and Kleiman's theorem, as seen in Theorem 5.17 for general partitions g. -
Improved AI can detect prime-to-p splittings from the abelian part of log 1-motifs by examining the structure of the associated log 1-motif Q, leveraging Lemma 5.7 and Proposition 5.8 to relate rank conditions to annihilation by integers prime to p.
-
Improved AI can analyze infinitesimal period maps using jet schemes and refined jet correspondence, allowing for the algebraic parameterization of
infinitesimal period maps
(r-limp) and studying their behavior on non-constant jets as described in Section 2. -
Improved AI can construct atypical loci with respect to a given subscheme Z by defining specific loci Md r pZq based on the constancy or non-constancy of jets, where the resulting scheme Ed r stabilizes to a finite union of special subvarieties of T, as detailed in Construction 3.3 and Proposition 4.3.
-
Improved AI can analyze the geometry of atypical loci along Ag by constructing families g: F over B whose fibers have constant dimension m and applying Proposition 4.5 to show that the resulting locus Ed r is not Zariski dense in T, as detailed in Proposition 4.1 and its proof steps.
-
Improved AI can establish flatness results for special loci inside moduli spaces over Shimura varieties by using Theorem 3.11, which implies that certain fibre products are flat over R if the corresponding sub-Shimura datum is of type Z, as shown in the proof of Theorem 3.3 and its consequences (1.12, 1.13).
Abstract
We introduce new techniques to study mixed-characteristic special loci in moduli spaces and give several applications, focusing in particular on the moduli space g of curves. These applications include Zariski density results for split Jacobians, non-density results for supersingular loci, and lifting results for algebraic cycles, all under appropriate numerical conditions. Our methods generalize to more-or-less arbitrary moduli spaces mapping to Hodge-type Shimura varieties (and even some settings beyond the Shimura case), and relate to questions raised by Oort and de Jong.
Sources
- Effective atypical intersections and applications to orbit closures
- The moduli space of cubic threefolds via degenerations of the intermediate Jacobian
- Hecke orbits on Shimura varieties of Hodge type
- The Tate conjecture for surfaces of geometric genus one -- embracing singularities
- Algebraic Cycle Loci at the Integral Level
Related papers
- K-unstable Toric Varieties and Secondary Polytopes
- The commuting scheme of g 2 and a degree formula for commuting schemes
- Stacky geometry and logarithmic topology of transversely affine foliations
- Monodromy and vanishing cycles for complete intersection curves
- Characteristic cycles and Gevrey irregularity in hypergeometric families
- Tautological classes on KSBA spaces