Two-loop RI/SMOM- matching factors for the renormalization of bi-local operators contributing to epsilon K
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Two-loop RI/SMOM- matching factors for the renormalization of bi-local operators contributing to epsilon K".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents two-loop RI/SMOM-MS matching factors necessary to renormalize bi-local operators contributing to epsilon K, which is an important precision test of the Standard Model Context and Motivation The measure of indirect CP violation in the neutral kaon system, ǫK, is an important precision test of the Standard Model This work focuses on the parameter ǫK which describes indirect CP violation in K → ππ decays A first-principles Standard Model prediction of this long-distance contribution with controlled systematic errors is at present only possible using a lattice QCD simulation The authors address the incomplete knowledge of the RI-MS matching factors for the bi-local operator at O(αs) because this process proceeds via two ∆S = 1 operators Theoretical Framework The study utilizes a basis of ∆S = 1 and ∆S = 2 operators to describe the relevant physics The authors define the ∆S = 1 operator basis using current-current operators and QCD penguin operators, which are categorized by their colour structure The relevant ∆S = 2 local operators are QLL and Q˜∆S=2 LL, which are related by a Fierz transformation Regularization-independent renormalization is achieved using the RI/SMOM scheme, which imposes a condition on Green’s functions to coincide with their tree level value The calculation employs a specific momentum configuration and tree-level amplitudes to construct the necessary matrix elements The two-loop strategy involves enumerating and classifying diagrams using QGRAF The projected amplitudes are reduced to master scalar integrals using TARCER and LiteRed interfaces with FIRE6 The matching factors are determined by applying the RI projector Pγµ to the amplitude, leading to the determination of coefficients Ci,a Key Findings and Results The authors present results for one-loop amplitudes and two-loop matching factors for both four-quark operators and bi-local operators The one-loop RI/SMOM-MS matching factors for the QLL operator are determined, yielding finite amplitudes The two-loop matching factors for several values of µMS and µRI are reported, showing corrections between −13% and +17% relative to the leading order matching factors The calculated results remove the O(αs) uncertainty in the renormalization of the bi-local operator in RBC/UKQCD calculations of ǫK The numerical results for P ij CiCjYij should be used as a shifted Wilson coefficient for the ∆S = 2 operator The final results are reported in terms of Y MS ij = Y(0) + αs/4π Y(1) The agentic AI system Claude Code facilitated a much more rapid completion of this calculation References
1: Z.
Kai: Bai, N.
Mira: H.
Kai: Christ, J.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now titled "Two-loop RI/SMOM- matching factors for the renormalization of bi-local operators contributing to epsilon K". It's about those long-distance contributions to epsilon K.
Mira: Yeah, and the authors are tackling how to handle the renormalization of these specific bi-local operators at two loops using a scheme called RI/SMOM.
Lev: What does that mean practically? Are we talking about something we can actually run on real hardware right now, or is this just theory?
Kai: It’s about getting the numbers right for those lattice QCD calculations they've done for epsilon K. They are focusing on the two loop, alpha-sub s corrections needed to handle these bi-local operators.
Mira: Essentially, they are providing the necessary matching factors to take those lattice calculations and translate them into a standard scheme like MS.
Lev: So this isn't just theoretical math; it’s a tool for making the lattice results meaningful in the context of Standard Model predictions for kaon mixing.
Kai: Exactly. It’s about controlling systematic errors so we can get a better idea of indirect CP violation in kaons, which is a big test for the Standard Model.
Mira: Right, it sets up the next part: what exactly is this paper trying to achieve in terms of calculation?
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to summarize what this paper does with "Two-loop RI/SMOM- matching factors for the renormalization of bi-local operators contributing to epsilon K," they are looking at the long-distance contribution to epsilon K.
Mira: They focus on how that process happens via two separate three s equals one operators being joined by a closed quark loop, which is a subdominant part but still important.
Lev: So they're dealing with these bi-local operators, which are tricky because they involve those interactions at lower energy scales where the effects are more complex than just a single operator.
Kai: Exactly. The authors address the incomplete knowledge of the RI-MS matching factors for this bi-local operator up to two loops in alpha-sub s.
Mira: They use a basis of three s equals one and three s equals two operators, defining the three s equals one set using current current operators and QCD penguin operators categorized by their color structure.
Lev: And they are looking at specific bi-local ones, like QLL and Qtilde D S equal two LL, which are related by a Fierz transformation.
Kai: The method they use is regularization independent renormalization through the RI/SMOM scheme, where they set conditions on Green's functions to match their tree level value.
Mira: They then do the calculation using a specific momentum configuration and tree-level amplitudes, reducing them to master scalar integrals using tools like TARCER and LiteRed with FIRE6.
Lev: The core of the work is applying the RI projector P gamma mu to these amplitudes to determine those coefficients Ci a.
Kai: And what they found is that they present results for one loop and two loop matching factors for both four-quark operators and bi-local operators.
The paper's improvements: Mira: Now, moving on to the actual findings of the paper, they report results for one loop amplitudes and two loop matching factors for both four quark operators and bi-local operators.
Kai: They determined the one-loop RI/SMOM-MS matching factors for the QLL operator and found that these yield finite amplitudes.
Lev: So, that’s a good starting point; getting those one loop pieces to be finite is always a step forward in perturbative calculations.
Mira: But they also report the two loop matching factors for several values of mu MS and mu RI, showing corrections between negative thirteen percent and plus seventeen percent relative to the leading order matching factors.
Kai: That correction range, from negative thirteen percent up to positive seventeen percent, that’s what they found when comparing their two loop results against the leading order ones.
Lev: That range is quite significant; it tells us how much uncertainty we have when we try to shift those Wilson coefficients for the three s equals two operator.
Mira: The authors state that these calculated results remove the alpha-sub s uncertainty in renormalizing the bi-local operator in RBC UKQCD calculations of epsilon K.
Kai: And they suggest that you should use the numerical results for P i j Ci C j Y i j as a shifted Wilson coefficient for the three s equals two operator.
Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this discussion on "Two-loop RI/SMOM- matching factors for the renormalization of bi-local operators contributing to epsilon K." The main implication is that we now have a way to control those O alpha sub s uncertainties in lattice QCD calculations for epsilon K.
Mira: They are providing those shifted Wilson coefficients, which means when you plug them into the lattice results, they are corrected by these two loop terms.
Lev: So it’s a systematic correction to the three s equals two operator that helps make those long-distance contributions more reliable when we look at experimental measurements of kaon decays.
Kai: And Lev, from an engineering standpoint, this means the numerical pipeline for running these lattice calculations gets a bit cleaner because we have better control over these perturbative corrections.
Mira: And for us theorists, it gives us a concrete way to handle those subdominant contributions that you can't just ignore when calculating epsilon K.
Lev: Yeah, and Kai, remember the paper itself mentions that the meaningful quantity isn't just the individual elements of Y i j themselves but rather the quantity Y contracted with the Wilson coefficients P i j Ci C j Y i j.
Kai: Right, that’s a crucial distinction because those specific combinations are what you really need to use when applying these results in your final calculations.
Mira: So, for the listener, this paper means we have refined a tool to get more precise Standard Model predictions for indirect CP violation in kaons by systematically accounting for two loop effects.
Erik Lundstrum
Physics Department, Columbia University
hep-ph, hep-lat
Submitted: 2026-10-05
Updated: 2026-11-02
Comments: 34 pages, 5 figures, 13 tables
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 76/100
The gist: The paper presents two-loop RI/SMOM-MS matching factors necessary to renormalize bi-local operators contributing to epsilon K…
Terminology
Summary
The paper presents two-loop RI/SMOM-MS matching factors necessary to renormalize bi-local operators contributing to epsilon K, which is an important precision test of the Standard Model
Context and Motivation
The measure of indirect CP violation in the neutral kaon system, ǫK, is an important precision test of the Standard Model This work focuses on the parameter ǫK which describes indirect CP violation in K → ππ decays A first-principles Standard Model prediction of this long-distance contribution with controlled systematic errors is at present only possible using a lattice QCD simulation The authors address the incomplete knowledge of the RI-MS matching factors for the bi-local operator at O(αs) because this process proceeds via two ∆S = 1 operators
Theoretical Framework
The study utilizes a basis of ∆S = 1 and ∆S = 2 operators to describe the relevant physics The authors define the ∆S = 1 operator basis using current-current operators and QCD penguin operators, which are categorized by their colour structure The relevant ∆S = 2 local operators are QLL and Q˜∆S=2 LL, which are related by a Fierz transformation Regularization-independent renormalization is achieved using the RI/SMOM scheme, which imposes a condition on Green’s functions to coincide with their tree level value
Methodology
The calculation employs a specific momentum configuration and tree-level amplitudes to construct the necessary matrix elements The two-loop strategy involves enumerating and classifying diagrams using QGRAF The projected amplitudes are reduced to master scalar integrals using TARCER and LiteRed interfaces with FIRE6 The matching factors are determined by applying the RI projector Pγµ to the amplitude, leading to the determination of coefficients Ci,a
Key Findings and Results
The authors present results for one-loop amplitudes and two-loop matching factors for both four-quark operators and bi-local operators The one-loop RI/SMOM-MS matching factors for the QLL operator are determined, yielding finite amplitudes The two-loop matching factors for several values of µMS and µRI are reported, showing corrections between −13% and +17% relative to the leading order matching factors
Conclusion
The calculated results remove the O(αs) uncertainty in the renormalization of the bi-local operator in RBC/UKQCD calculations of ǫK The numerical results for P ij CiCjYij should be used as a shifted Wilson coefficient for the ∆S = 2 operator The final results are reported in terms of Y MS ij = Y(0) + αs/4π Y(1) The agentic AI system Claude Code facilitated a much more rapid completion of this calculation
References
[1] Z. Bai, N. H. Christ, J. M. Karpie, C. T. Sachrajda, A. Soni, and B. Wang, Long-distance contribution to εK from lattice QCD
[2] Y. Huo, N. H. Christ, and B. Wang, Enhanced Lattice QCD Studies on εK and ∆MK
[3] Y. Huo, Enhanced Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Studies of the Neutral Kaon Mass Difference and Indirect Charge-Parity Violation
[4] G. Buchalla, A. J. Buras, and M. E. Lautenbacher, Weak Decays beyond Leading Logarithms
[5] G. Martinelli, C. Pittori, C. T. Sachrajda, M. Testa, and A. Vladikas, A general method for non-perturbative renormalization of lattice operators
[6] Anthropic, Claude Code (5.1 Fable) [Large language model], https://claude. p. 3ai (2026), accessed: 2026-07
[7] E. Lundstrum, Agentic AI for QCD perturbation theory (2026), to appear
[8] M. Gorbahn, S. p. 1 J¨ager, and S. Kvedarait˙e, RI-(S)MOM to MS conversion for BK at two-loop order
[9] C. Lehner and E. Lundstrum, Four-flavour matching factors for ∆S = 1 four-quark operators in RI/SMOM schemes, in preparation (2026)
[10] Y. Aoki et al., Nonperturbative renormalization of quark bilinear operators and BK using domain wall fermions
[11] C. Sturm, Y. Aoki, N. H. Christ, T. Izubuchi, C. T. C. Sachrajda, and A. Soni, Renormalization of quark bilinear operators in a momentum-subtraction scheme with a nonexceptional subtraction point
[12] C. Allton et al., (RBC-UKQCD), Physical Results from 2+1 Flavor Domain Wall QCD and SU(2) Chiral Perturbation Theory
[13] Y. Aoki et al., (RBC, UKQCD), Continuum Limit Physics from 2+1 Flavor Domain Wall QCD
[14] M. Gorbahn and S. p. 1 Jager, Precise MS-bar light-quark masses from lattice QCD in the RI/SMOM scheme
[15] L. G. Almeida and C. Sturm, Two-loop matching factors for light quark masses and threeloop mass anomalous dimensions in the RI/SMOM schemes
[16] J. A. Gracey, RI’/SMOM scheme amplitudes for quark currents at two loops
[17] C. Lehner and C. Sturm, Matching factors for Delta S=1 four-quark operators in RI/SMOM schemes
[18] J. Brod and M. p. 1 Gorbahn, ǫK at Next-to-Next-to-Leading Order: The Charm-Top-Quark Contribution
[19] S. Herrlich and U. Nierste, Evanescent operators, scheme dependences and double insertions, Nuclear Physics B 455, 39 (1995)
[20] V. Shtabovenko, R. Mertig, and F. Orellana, FeynCalc 10: Do multiloop integrals dream of computer codes?, Comput. Phys. Commun. 306, 109357 (2025)
[21] V. Shtabovenko, R. Mertig, and F. Orellana, FeynCalc 9.3: New features and improvements, Comput. p. 0 Phys. Commun. 256, 107478 (2020)
[22] V. Shtabovenko, R. Mertig, and F. Orellana, New Developments in FeynCalc 9. p. 00, Comput. Phys. Commun. 207, 432 (2016)
[23] R. Mertig, M. B¨ohm, and A. Denner, Feyn calc - computer-algebraic calculation of feynman amplitudes, Computer Physics Communications 64, 345 (1991)
[24] R. N. Lee, Presenting LiteRed: a tool for the Loop InTEgrals REDuction, arXiv:1212. p. 02685 [hep-ph] (2012)
[25] P. Nogueira, Automatic feynman graph generation, Journal of Computational Physics 105, 279 (1993)
[26] M. Jamin and M. E. Lautenbacher, Tracer version 1.1: A mathematica package for γ-algebra in arbitrary dimensions, Computer Physics Communications 74, 265 (1993)
[27] A. V. Smirnov and F. S. Chukharev, FIRE6: Feynman Integral REduction with modular arithmetic, Comput. p. 9 Phys. Commun. 247, 106877 (2020)
[28] S. Borowka, G. Heinrich, S. Jahn, S. P. Jones, M. Kerner, J. Schlenk, and T. Zirke, pySecDec: A toolbox for the numerical evaluation of multi-scale integrals
[29] K. G. Chetyrkin, J. H. Kuhn, and M. Steinhauser, RunDec: A Mathematica package for running and decoupling of the strong coupling and quark masses
[30] S. Herrlich and U. Nierste, The Complete ∆S = 2 Hamiltonian in the next-to-leading order, Nucl. p. 6 Phys. B 476, 27 (1996)
[31] J. C. Collins, Renormalization: An Introduction to Renormalization, the Renormalization Group and the Oper Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics, Vol. p. 1 26 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1984)
Tables
Table I shows the matrix Bil = Πi(hQli) that appears in Eq. (66) Table II gives the one-loop coefficients entering Eq. p. 9 (72) at the momentum configuration described in Sec. p. 0 III A Table III presents the one-loop RI/SMOM→ MS matching factors for QLL at the momentum configuration of Sec. p. 9III A, in units of αs/4π, with p squared = -µ 2 RI Table IV shows the coefficients of QLL in the counterterm of [QiQj] entering Eq. p. 6 (83) Table V lists evanescent counterterms entering Eq. p. 3 (83) Table VI gives the finite, one-loop amplitudes for the bi-local operator Table VII shows the (γµ)-projected finite amplitudes χj Table XII gives the matching factors contracted with the Wilson coefficients C MS i(µMS) of Table XIII for the nine (µMS, µRI) combinations of Ref. p. 9 [3] in units of m2c(µMS)/4π squared and in Landau gauge Table XIII lists NDR-MS Wilson coefficients of the ∆S = 1 operators at the three scales µMS, taken from Table 4. p. 83 of Ref. [3], where they are obtained at next-to-leading order following Ref. p. 6 [4]
Summary of Results
The authors find corrections between −13% and +17% for µRI = µMS relative to the leading order matching factors The meaningful quantity is not the individual elements of Y ij themselves, but rather the quantity Y contracted with the Wilson coefficients: P ij CiCjY ij In Table XII, many of the elements of (αs/4π)Y(1) are of the same size as the one-loop values Y(0) The two-loop contributions in the parameter ranges µMS ≤ µRI take their expected size of an O(10%) correction to the one-loop result In the ranges µMS > µRI, NLO corrections grow to become large relative to the LO pieces, even becoming 241% of LO piece for µMS = 2.644 GeV and µRI = 1. p. 8322 GeV The results are used as a shifted Wilson coefficient for the ∆S = 2 operator The final results are reported in Table X, where Y'(1) is evaluated in the GJK evanescent scheme at several values of µMS The numerical results for P i,j CiCjYij given in Table XII should be used in Eq.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve agentic AI for perturbative QCD calculations by integrating it with existing programs used for perturbative calculations to ensure correctness of many intermediate steps, as noted in "We found that perturbative QFT calculations are an ideal use case for agentic AI, since many of the intermediate steps can be offloaded to existing programs used for perturbative calculations, thereby ensuring the correctness of many intermediate steps."
-
Enhance the ability to perform various checks on calculation results by using agentic AI to compare final results against previous literature and check intermediate steps throughout the paper. This ensures a
high degree of confidence that the results presented here are correct.
-
Improve strategy for handling complex momentum configurations in lattice QCD calculations by leveraging agentic AI to manage the non-exceptional momentum routing, which is necessary to control unwanted infra-red effects. The AI can assist in selecting the appropriate momentum configuration, such as
p1 + p4 = p2 + p3,
and verifying its suitability. -
Strengthen the process for determining RI/SMOM-MS matching factors by using agentic AI to guide the calculation strategy, as seen in
all of the code required for this calculation was produced by prompting the agentic AI system Claude Fable 5.1 [6]. This was done under the close supervision of the author who also dictated the strategy.
-
Increase efficiency in managing scheme conversions by using agentic AI to assist in calculating conversion factors between renormalization schemes, such as
the factors which relate the RI scheme to the MS scheme are calculated in QCD perturbation theory
and "the lattice to MS conversion factor Z lat->MS LL should be evaluated in the BG scheme."
Sources
- Long-distance contribution to $\epsilon_K$ from lattice QCD
- Weak Decays Beyond Leading Logarithms
- A General Method for Non-Perturbative Renormalization of Lattice Operators
- RI-(S)MOM to $\overline{\rm MS}$ conversion for $B_K$ at two-loop order
- Non-perturbative renormalization of quark bilinear operators and B_K using domain wall fermions
- Renormalization of quark bilinear operators in a momentum-subtraction scheme with a nonexceptional subtraction point
- Physical Results from 2+1 Flavor Domain Wall QCD and SU(2) Chiral Perturbation Theory
- Continuum Limit Physics from 2+1 Flavor Domain Wall QCD
- Precise MS-bar light-quark masses from lattice QCD in the RI/SMOM scheme
- Two-loop matching factors for light quark masses and three-loop mass anomalous dimensions in the RI/SMOM schemes
- RI'/SMOM scheme amplitudes for quark currents at two loops
- Matching factors for Delta S=1 four-quark operators in RI/SMOM schemes
- Epsilon_K at Next-to-Next-to-Leading Order: The Charm-Top-Quark Contribution
- FeynCalc 10: Do multiloop integrals dream of computer codes?
- FeynCalc 9.3: New features and improvements
- New Developments in FeynCalc 9.0
- Presenting LiteRed: a tool for the Loop InTEgrals REDuction
- FIRE6: Feynman Integral REduction with Modular Arithmetic
- pySecDec: a toolbox for the numerical evaluation of multi-scale integrals
- RunDec: a Mathematica package for running and decoupling of the strong coupling and quark masses
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses