Trinity of Carrollian Gravity: Dynamically Equivalent Formulations of Magnetic Carrollian Gravity

arXiv:2610.01976 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-10-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Trinity of Carrollian Gravity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In this paper, we extend the paradigm of the Geometrical Trinity of Gravity to the Carrollian geometry to construct a comprehensive framework of dynamically equivalent theories for Magnetic Carrollian gravity.

Kai: The results establish a geometric dictionary translating Carrollian gravitational dynamics into the language of tensor gauge theories, electromagnetism, and dilaton theory The paper aims to merge the paradigms of standard geometric formulations with Carrollian geometry to establish an equivalent dictionary for Magnetic Carrollian gravity.

Mira: By systematically relaxing the metric-compatibility and zerotorsion constraints of the rigid magnetic sector, it proves that the curvature of a Magnetic Carrollian universe can be dynamically traded for isolated kinetic energy densities of torsion and non-metricity The Carrollian equivalences map spacetime geometry to non-gravitational theories, such as Electric Carrollian gravity via intrinsic torsion.

Kai: Mapping Curvature to Torsion and Non-Metricity The authors demonstrate that the curvature of Magnetic Carroll Gravity can be recast into distinct manifestations of torsion and non-metricity.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now, "Trinity of Carrollian Gravity: Dynamically Equivalent Formulations of Magnetic Carrollian Gravity." It’s tackling how to translate the physics of magnetic Carrollian gravity into other theories.

Mira: That sounds dense. The title suggests they're building a bridge, like a dictionary, between gravity in this specific geometry and things we already understand like electromagnetism or gauge theories.

Lev: I wonder what that means for us on the hardware side if we’re trying to simulate or even build anything based on these concepts. We need to know what kind of physics this translates into when we look at kinetic energy densities.

Kai: Exactly, Lev, it's about those kinetic energy densities you mentioned. They’re showing that the curvature of a Magnetic Carrollian universe can be traded for isolated kinetic energy terms related to torsion and non-metricity.

Mira: So instead of just having spacetime curves in the standard way, they show you can have those same dynamics described by these specific fields—torsion and non-metricity.

Lev: That’s interesting because if we were building a toy model for error correction, knowing how to map that curvature to torsion might simplify the constraints we have to manage on the actual system.

Kai: Right, so it's not just mapping gravity to gravity; it's mapping it into these non-gravitational descriptions, which is what’s making this work for us.

The paper's summary: Mira: They summarize by saying they extend the standard geometric trinity of gravity to Carrollian geometry and find a way to create equivalent theories for Magnetic Carrollian gravity. It essentially shows that the geometry is flexible enough to swap its curvature out for torsion and non-metricity.

Kai: That’s what I mean when I say it trades curvature for kinetic energy densities of torsion and non-metricity. They map the magnetic sector—which has rigid spatial geometry—to these other things in a very systematic way.

Lev: So they're taking the magnetic Carroll gravity and breaking its strict metric compatibility and zerotorsion rules to see what happens when you relax them. That’s like testing the limits of our connection constraints.

Mira: Right, and they show that intrinsic torsion recovers Electric Carrollian gravity as a teleparallel equivalent of Magnetic Carrollian gravity, which is a pretty big link between the two sectors.

Kai: And they also map purely spatial torsion to kinetic terms that look like the magnetic Hamiltonian for a scalar-charge Fracton gauge theory. That’s quite specific mapping, tying geometry directly into particle physics models.

Lev: If you're thinking about error correction, those Fracton gauge theories sound like something we might try to model if we want to introduce some non-trivial dynamics beyond the standard kinetic terms.

Mira: And they also have temporal torsion sectors that map independently to U(one) Maxwell electric fields and Carroll-Weyl conformal dilaton theories <ref:2610.01976#pg2>. That shows how different parts of the geometry can yield completely different physical descriptions.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest a few key improvements to this idea, mostly by constructing four dynamically equivalent theories by isolating distinct torsion sectors based on the most general metric compatible Carrollian connection.

Mira: They also construct four distinct theories: Electric Carrollian Gravity through intrinsic torsion, Tensor Gauge Theory through spatial torsion, Dilatonic scalar theory through temporal vector torsion, and Maxwell Electric Theory via Carrollian clock torsion.

Lev: That’s a lot of distinct mappings for one starting point. It means we have to check each one individually to see which assumption—like metric compatibility or zerotorsion—is actually required for the physics we want to model.

Kai: They also formulate a Symmetric Teleparallel Carroll connection with minimal non-metricity, and this is where they claim their Magnetic Carrollian Lagrangian becomes dynamically equivalent to an ultralocal, isotropic Electric Carrollian gravity.

Mira: That final construction seems like the cleanest result, showing equivalence down to a simple isotropic model governed only by a tracesquared kinetic Lagrangian. It’s very focused on simplifying the description.

Lev: If it's truly ultralocal and isotropic, that suggests we might be able to manage the dynamics with fewer degrees of freedom than if we were dealing with the full magnetic sector.

Kai: The paper also shows that a universe characterized by fully curved spacetime but a rigid spatial metric where the spatial metric is zero is dynamically indistinguishable from a flat universe where the spatial geometry expands and shears over time.

Conclusion: Mira: So, to wrap up, the paper proves that this geometric trinity admits a sub-trinity in Carrollian geometry. The core idea is that the intrinsic curvature of the Magnetic sector can be traded for fundamentally different kinetic interactions.

Kai: They establish a geometric dictionary translating these dynamics into gauge field and condensed matter theories. It’s about using the inherent ambiguities in degenerate geometry as actual physical degrees of freedom to generate equivalent formulations.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means we can look at gravity problems not just as curvature, but also as complex kinetic terms in other systems, which could guide how we structure our error correction codes.

Mira: And they show that the equivalence between curved rigid spacetime and flat spacetime with a varying local rate of time is established by showing temporal torsion acts like a scalar potential or a dilaton field.

Kai: It’s really about seeing that the Carrollian Trinity is much richer than its Lorentzian counterpart, showing that equivalent theories often cross over into non-gravitational domains.

Lev: Yeah, it suggests the mathematical structure itself is providing those extra degrees of freedom we need to handle complex dynamics without adding more explicit fields.

Mira: So they’re mapping gravitational dynamics into gauge field and condensed matter theories using this dictionary, which is a big step for unifying these concepts.

Department of Physics, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad · School of Physics, Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences (IPM)

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-10-01

Updated: 2026-11-07

Comments: 48 pages, 2 figures, 3 tables, v2: references added,typos corrected,

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: In this paper, we extend the paradigm of the Geometrical Trinity of Gravity to the Carrollian geometry to construct a comprehensive framework of dynamically equivalent theories for Magnetic…

Key concepts

Geometrical Trinity
This refers to a set of three core geometric concepts (like curvature, torsion, and non-metricity) used to describe gravity. The paper extends this idea into Carrollian geometry to show how these elements can be traded for kinetic energy in other physical theories.
Magnetic Carrollian Gravity (MCG)
This is the specific gravitational theory being studied. It describes gravity in a non-Lorentzian spacetime where the spatial metric is rigid, meaning it does not change over time, yet its curvature can still be dynamically traded for other physical quantities.
Torsion and Non-metricity
These are geometric properties that describe how spacetime deviates from being perfectly flat or symmetric. The paper shows that the curvature of Magnetic Carrollian gravity can be recast into these torsion and non-metricity terms, which correspond to kinetic energy in other physical theories.
Geometric Dictionary
This is a translation tool developed by the authors. It maps the mathematical language of Carrollian gravitational dynamics directly onto the language of other physics, such as tensor gauge theories and electromagnetism, allowing researchers to study gravity through different lenses.

Terminology

Summary

In this paper, we extend the paradigm of the Geometrical Trinity of Gravity to the Carrollian geometry to construct a comprehensive framework of dynamically equivalent theories for Magnetic Carrollian gravity. p. 0 The results establish a geometric dictionary translating Carrollian gravitational dynamics into the language of tensor gauge theories, electromagnetism, and dilaton theory

Introduction to the Trinity Extension

The paper aims to merge the paradigms of standard geometric formulations with Carrollian geometry to establish an equivalent dictionary for Magnetic Carrollian gravity. By systematically relaxing the metric-compatibility and zerotorsion constraints of the rigid magnetic sector, it proves that the curvature of a Magnetic Carrollian universe can be dynamically traded for isolated kinetic energy densities of torsion and non-metricity The Carrollian equivalences map spacetime geometry to non-gravitational theories, such as Electric Carrollian gravity via intrinsic torsion. p. 0

Mapping Curvature to Torsion and Non-Metricity

The authors demonstrate that the curvature of Magnetic Carroll Gravity can be recast into distinct manifestations of torsion and non-metricity. Specifically, intrinsic torsion recovers Electric Carrollian gravity as the Teleparallel equivalent of Magnetic Carroll gravity. p. 0 Purely spatial torsion reproduces kinetic terms structurally similar to the magnetic Hamiltonian of scalar-charge Fracton gauge theory Temporal torsion sectors map independently to U(1) Maxwell electric fields and Carroll-Weyl conformal dilaton theories. p. 0

Equivalent Theories Derived from Metric Compatibility

The analysis constructs four dynamically equivalent theories by isolating distinct torsion sectors based on the most general metric-compatible Carrollian connection. These include Electric Carrollian Gravity via intrinsic torsion, Tensor Gauge Theory via spatial torsion, Dilatonic scalar theory via temporal vector torsion, and Maxwell Electric Theory via Carrollian clock torsion Furthermore, by formulating a Symmetric Teleparallel Carroll connection with minimal non-metricity, the Magnetic Carrollian Lagrangian is dynamically equivalent to an ultralocal, isotropic Electric Carrollian gravity. p. 0

Physical Interpretations and Dualities

The findings reveal that the geometric trinity admits a structural sub-trinity in Carrollian geometry. The equivalence between Magnetic Carroll gravity and Electric Carroll gravity shows that a universe characterized by fully curved spacetime but a rigid, nonevolving spatial metric (Kµν = 0, R˜ ̸= 0) is dynamically indistinguishable from a flat universe where the spatial geometry dynamically expands and shears over time (Kµν ̸= 0). p. 2 The equivalence between Magnetic Carroll gravity and spatial torsion reveals that the kinetic penalty of having spatial torsion mirrors the magnetic Hamiltonian of a vector-charge Fracton gauge theory

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study establishes a geometric dictionary translating Carrollian gravitational dynamics into the language of tensor gauge theories, electromagnetism, and dilaton theory. The work provides a framework for researchers across different fields by exploiting the inherent ambiguities of degenerate geometry as fundamental degrees of freedom Future research directions include exploring the full parameter space of Carrollian non-metricity and introducing matter couplings, such as studying how Carrollian fermions couple to the spatial torsion via the spin connection. The framework allows for mapping Carrollian gravitational dynamics into gauge field and condensed matter theories

Table Summary of Equivalences

Table 3 summarizes the transformation properties of the kinetic fields associated with the different theories under local Carroll boosts. It shows that Magnetic Carroll Gravity (MCG) has no native boost invariance, while Electric Carrollian Gravity (TEMCG) and STEMCG Cosmology exhibit Yes for Kµν and K2 respectively The spatial Torsion Aρµν sector achieves native invariance without auxiliary multipliers The Maxwell Electric Theory Eµ = Lvτµ does not possess boost invariance, while Dilaton Scaling sµ ∼ Lvτµ also lacks it

Gauging Carroll Algebra Formalism

Carroll gravity can be formulated as a gauge theory of the Carroll algebra. Introducing a connection Aµ valued in the Carroll algebra allows for the construction of the curvature 2-form Fµν which decomposes into components related to different generators of the algebra The spatial part of the connection is shown to be exactly the spatial Christoffel symbol when torsion-free conditions are imposed

Torsionless Connection and Ricci Scalar

Imposing the torsion-free conditions Rµν(H) = Rµν a(P) = 0 yields solutions for the connection parameters. The resulting scalar curvature expression closely aligns with the second-order Magnetic Carroll Ricci scalar, differing by a factor of 2 between first-order and second-order formalisms

Symmetric Teleparallel Equivalent Formulation

The Symmetric Teleparallel Equivalent of Magnetic Carroll Gravity (STEMCG) is constructed by enforcing a torsion-free connection with minimal non-metricity. This choice of minimal non-metricity, rooted in physical geometric considerations, ensures that the spacetime admits a torsion-free connection even in situations where the spatial volume is undergoing shear or expansion The resulting equivalent action is shown to be dynamically equivalent to an isotropic, shear-free Electric Carroll gravity model governed exclusively by a tracesquared kinetic Lagrangian

Final Equivalence and Physical Meaning

The study demonstrates that the intrinsic curvature of the Magnetic sector R˜ can be dynamically traded for fundamentally distinct kinetic interactions. This geometric dictionary translates Carrollian gravitational dynamics into gauge field and condensed matter theories The equivalence between the curved rigid spacetime and the flat spacetime with a varying local rate of time is established by showing that temporal torsion acts as a scalar potential or Dilaton The results suggest that the Carrollian Trinity is far richer than its Lorentzian counterpart, revealing that equivalent theories frequently cross the boundary into non-gravitational domains

References

[2] R. Ruzziconi, “Carrollian physics and holography,” Phys. p. 1 Rept. 1182 (2026) 1–87, 2602. p. 002644 [3] K. Nguyen, “Lectures on Carrollian holography,” Eur. p. 1 Phys. J. C 86 (2026), no. p. 0 6, 733, 2511.10162 [4] A. Bagchi, P. Dhivakar, and S. Dutta, “Holography in flat spacetimes: the case for Carroll,” JHEP 08 (2024) 144, 2311. p. 111246 [5] L. Ciambelli, C. Marteau, A. C. Petkou, P. M. Petropoulos, and K. Siampos, “Flat holography and Carrollian fluids,” JHEP 07 (2018) 165, 1802. p. 106809 [7] C. Duval, G. W. Gibbons, and P. A. Horvathy, “Conformal Carroll groups and BMS symmetry,” Class. p. 0 Quant. Grav. 31 (2014) 092001, 1402.5894 [8] J. Figueroa-O’Farrill, A. Pérez, and S. Prohazka, “Carroll/fracton particles and their correspondence,” JHEP 06 (2023) 207, 2305. p. 006730 [9] M. M. Ahmadi-Jahmani and A. p. 0 Parvizi, “Fracton and non-Lorentzian particle duality: gauge field couplings and geometric implications,” JHEP 08 (2025) 157, 2503. p. 021660 [10] D. Hansen, N. A. Obers, G. Oling, and B. T. Søgaard, “Carroll Expansion of General Relativity,” SciPost Phys. p. 2 13 (2022), no. 3, 055, 2112.12684 [11] J. Musaeus, N. A. Obers, and G. Oling, “Setting the connection free in the Galilei and Carroll expansions of gravity,” Phys. p. 4 Rev. D 109 (2024), no. 10, 104040, 2312.13924 [12] L. Ciambelli and P. Jai-akson, “Foundations of Carrollian geometry,” Phys. p. 0 Rept. 1188 (2026) 1–51, 2510. p. 021651 [13] M. Ahmadi-Jahmani and H. p. 0 R. Afshar, “Scaling symmetry and Carrollian gravity,” JHEP 08 (2026) 075, 2512. p. 120736 [14] H. Adami, A. Parvizi, M. p. 0 M. Sheikh-Jabbari, V. Taghiloo, and H. Yavartanoo, “Carrollian structure of the null boundary solution space,” JHEP 02 (2024) 073, 2311. p. 103515 [15] A. Bagchi, A. Banerjee, and P. Parekh, “Tensionless Path from Closed to Open Strings,” Phys. p. 2 Rev. Lett. 123 (2019), no. 11, 111601, 905.

[26] J.-M. Nester and H.-J. Yo, “Symmetric teleparallel general relativity,” Chin. p. 2 J. Phys. 37 (1999) 113, gr-qc/9809049 [27] W. J. Wolf, J. Read, and Q. Vigneron, “The non-relativistic geometric trinity of gravity,” Gen. p. 2 Rel. Grav. 56 (2024), no. 10, 126, 2308.07100 [28] Q. Vigneron, H. Barzegar, and J. Read, “Affine connections for Galilean and Carrollian structures: a unified perspective,” Class. p. 8 Quant. Grav. 42 (2025), no. 17, 175018, 2506.03936 [29] M. Henneaux and P. Salgado-Rebolledo, “Carroll contractions of Lorentz-invariant theories,” JHEP 11 (2021) 180, 2109. p. 906708 [30] M. H. Christensen, J. Hartong, N. A. Obers, and B. Rollier, “Torsional Newton-Cartan Geometry and Lifshitz Holography,” Phys. p. 7 Rev. D 89 (2014) 061901, 1311.4794 [31] C. Duval, G. Gibbons, P. Horvathy, and P. Zhang, “Carroll versus newton and galilei: two dual non-einsteinian concepts of time,” Classical and Quantum Gravity 31 (2014), no. p. 7 8, 085016 [32] L. Ciambelli, R. G. Leigh, C. Marteau, and P. M. Petropoulos, “Carroll Structures, Null Geometry and Conformal Isometries,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 100 (2019), no. 4, 046010 [33] C. Duval, G. Gibbons, and P. Horvathy, “Conformal carroll groups and bms symmetry,” Classical and Quantum Gravity 31 (2014), no. p. 0 9, 092001 [34] A. Campoleoni, M. Henneaux, S. Pekar, A. Pérez, and P. Salgado-Rebolledo, “Magnetic Carrollian gravity from the Carroll algebra,” JHEP 09 (2022) 127, 2207. p. 114167 [35] E. Bergshoeff, J. Gomis, B. Rollier, J. Rosseel, and T. ter Veldhuis, “Carroll versus Galilei Gravity,” JHEP 03 (2017) 165, 1701. p. 006156 [36] G. Dautcourt, “On the ultrarelativistic limit of general relativity,” Acta Phys. p. 2 Polon. B 29 (1998) 1047–1055, gr-qc/9801093 [37] C. Duval, G. W. Gibbons, P. A. Horvathy, and P. M. Zhang, “Carroll versus Newton and Galilei: two dual non-Einsteinian concepts of time,” Class. p. 7 Quant. Grav. 31 (2014) 085016 [38] J. Figueroa-O’Farrill, “Non-lorentzian spacetimes,” Differ. p. 0 Geom. Appl. 82 (2022) 101894, 2204.13609 [39] J. Figueroa-O’Farrill, “On the intrinsic torsion of spacetime structures,” 2009. p. 001948 [40] S. Baiguera, G. Oling, W. Sybesma, and B. T. Søgaard, “Conformal Carroll scalars with boosts,” SciPost Phys. p. 0 14 (2023), no. 4, 086, 2207.03468 [41] A. Guerrieri and R. F. Sobreiro, “Carroll limit of four-dimensional gravity theories in the first order formalism,” Class. p. 1 Quant. Grav. 38 (2021), no. 24, 245003, 2107.10129 [42] J. de Boer, J. Hartong, N. A. Obers, W. Sybesma, and S. Vandoren, “Carroll stories,” JHEP 09 (2023) 148, 2307. p. 0

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced mapping of gravitational dynamics: The improved system can translate Magnetic Carrollian gravity into non-gravitational theories such as Electric Carrollian gravity, Hamiltonian of a scalar-charge Fracton gauge theory, Maxwell electric theory, or ultralocal scalar dilaton theory.

  2. Explicit geometric dictionary construction: The system will be able to construct a geometric dictionary that translates Carrollian gravitational dynamics directly into the language of tensor gauge theories and condensed matter physics.

  3. Analysis of geometric ambiguities: The system can systematically exploit the inherent ambiguities in degenerate geometry, treating them as fundamental degrees of freedom to generate dynamically equivalent formulations.

  4. Investigation of torsion sectors: It can analyze how intrinsic torsion, spatial torsion, and temporal torsion reorganize when the underlying Lorentzian structure becomes degenerate, revealing that magnetic Carroll curvature is traded for distinct manifestations of these fields.

  5. Connection between rigidity and expansion: The system will demonstrate that a universe characterized by a fully curved spacetime but rigid spatial metric (Kmu nu = 0) is dynamically indistinguishable from a globally flat universe with dynamic spatial expansion (Kmu nu != 0).

  6. Mapping to physical potentials: The AI can map temporal torsion to embedding a Newtonian gravitational potential into the Carrollian geometry, showing that the temporal torsion smu acts as an equivalent scalar potential or Dilaton field.

  7. Identification of gauge symmetries: The system can identify that the clock form tau mu acts as a U(1) gauge potential, where its freedom is constrained by its normalization condition to ensure physical invariance under arbitrary local clock synchronization choices.

Sources

Related papers