Boundaries and defects in conformal field theories at finite temperature
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Boundaries and defects in conformal field theories at finite temperature".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We consider conformal boundaries and defects in Euclidean conformal field theory (CFT) at finite temperature and infinite volume.
Kai: We distinguish between defects that wrap the thermal circle and those localized at a point on it.
Mira: In both set-ups, for any dimension and co-dimension, we classify bulk one-point functions of scalar, vector and spin-2 primaries.
Kai: We relate the low-temperature expansion of bulk scalar one-point functions to zero-temperature defect CFT data and new finite-temperature data of defect primaries.
Paper summary: Kai: So, this paper we're looking at is called "Boundaries and defects in conformal field theories at finite temperature". It tackles how boundaries and defects show up in Euclidean conformal field theory, but specifically when the temperature is finite and the volume is infinite.
Mira: Exactly. The core idea here is to look at two types of defects: those that wrap around the thermal circle, and those that are just localized right on that circle itself.
Kai: In both cases, they classify all the one-point functions for scalar, vector, and spin-two primaries in both bulk and defect setups <ref:2609.38130#pg1,scalar, vector, and spin-2 primaries>. And they connect the low-temperature behavior of bulk scalar one-point functions to zero-temperature data and new finite temperature data for these defect primaries.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, relating low temperature expansions to zero temperature data is useful because it gives us a way to use existing knowledge about vacuum physics to predict what happens when you add thermal effects or defects.
Kai: For the localized defects, they derive one-point bootstrap sum rules using periodicity and the defect operator expansion. That's a new set of rules for how those localized things behave thermally.
Mira: It’s interesting because in free bulk CFTs—like unitary or non-unitary ones—they manage to determine all this thermal data for various examples, including a wrapping monodromy defect and a magnetic line defect localized on the circle.
Lev: Getting thermal data for those specific examples is important because it tells us what kind of constraints we have when we try to build real hardware, where you need these finite temperature properties to match up with your cooling cycles.
Kai: For the wrapping defects, they compute thermodynamic observables directly from that data. For the localized ones, they find a Hurwitz zeta function decomposition for the one-point functions which suggests some kind of underlying dispersion relation.
Mira: So, basically, this paper is using conformal symmetry and thermal constraints to extract concrete numerical data for these defects across different field theories and boundary conditions at finite temperature.
Lev: It’s an application of QFT machinery to constrain physical behavior under real-world conditions, which is always a good use of the tools we have.
Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the whole paper "Boundaries and defects in conformal field theories at finite temperature", it seems the main point is using these conformal constraints to map out how thermal effects modify systems with boundaries or defects.
Mira: Right, they aren't just studying abstract math; they are connecting zero-temperature data with finite-temperature properties for these defect systems, which is a crucial link.
Kai: The implications seem to be that we can use these bootstrap sum rules and the extracted thermal one-point functions to find concrete thermodynamic quantities like energy density and free energy density.
Lev: From my side, it means if you were designing some kind of quantum system with topological defects, you have a formal way to calculate how the thermal environment affects its properties.
Mira: It tells us that all these thermodynamic quantities coincide with the no-boundary results in this context, which is a pretty strong statement about the structure of these theories at these limits.
Kai: It’s about using symmetry to pin down the thermal behavior of things that are physically real, like boundaries or impurities in a field theory.
Dipartimento SMFI, Università di Parma · INFN Gruppo Collegato di Parma · Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Torino · INFN Sezione di Torino
hep-th
Submitted: 2026-09-29
Updated: 2026-10-28
Comments: 1+92+16 pages, 14 figures, 4 tables. v2: typos fixed, added clarifications and references
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: We consider conformal boundaries and defects in Euclidean conformal field theory (CFT) at finite temperature and infinite volume.
Key concepts
- Conformal Field Theory (CFT)
- A type of quantum field theory where the physics remains unchanged under conformal transformations. This symmetry is crucial in describing the behavior of particles and fields at specific energy scales, allowing for precise calculations at finite temperatures.
- Defects
- These are localized disturbances or boundaries within the CFT setup, such as defects wrapping a thermal circle or being fixed at a point on it. The paper analyzes how these structural features affect the field theory's properties and correlations.
- KMS Condition
- This condition acts as a bootstrap equation for the two-point function in thermal CFT. It imposes constraints on the correlators, similar to crossing symmetry in zero-temperature theories, helping to determine the structure of thermal correlation functions.
- Bootstrap Sum Rules
- These are mathematical relationships derived from physical principles (like periodicity and operator expansions) that constrain the coefficients of correlation functions. The paper uses these rules to derive new constraints on thermal data for bulk one-point functions.
Terminology
Summary
We consider conformal boundaries and defects in Euclidean conformal field theory (CFT) at finite temperature and infinite volume. We distinguish between defects that wrap the thermal circle and those localized at a point on it. In both set-ups, for any dimension and co-dimension, we classify bulk one-point functions of scalar, vector and spin-2 primaries. We relate the low-temperature expansion of bulk scalar one-point functions to zero-temperature defect CFT data and new finite-temperature data of defect primaries. For localized defects, we derive one-point bootstrap sum rules using periodicity and the defect operator expansion. We consider several examples in free bulk CFTs: unitary and non-unitary boundary CFTs, a wrapping monodromy defect, and a localized magnetic line. We determine thermal defect CFT data in all examples. For defects wrapping the thermal circle, we compute thermodynamic observables. For localized defects, we observe a Hurwitz zeta function decomposition of one-point functions suggestive of an underlying dispersion relation.
The paper is organized as follows:
"In section 2 we fix our conventions and briefly review zero-temperature DCFT and thermal CFT. Section 3 develops the kinematics of both defect configurations. We classify the one-point functions of defect and bulk primaries, identify the thermal DCFT data and derive Euclidean inversion formulas that extract them. In section 4 we turn to the constraints imposed by the KMS condition. We derive novel bootstrap sum rules for bulk one-point functions in the presence of defects localized on the thermal circle. The remaining sections are devoted to examples."
The paper discusses:
"Higher-dimensional defects wrapping the thermal circle. We consider conformal defects of arbitrary dimension and co-dimension. Using the preserved symmetries, we classify the constant thermal one-point functions of defect-local operators."
"Localised defects and a one-point function bootstrap. We extend the analysis to defects localised on a fixed Euclidean time slice. We classify the thermal one-point functions of defect primaries and identify the corresponding thermal DCFT data."
"Explicit examples and thermodynamics. We illustrate these results in free-field examples of increasing complexity: scalar, fermion, hypermultiplet and higher-derivative scalar BCFTs, a monodromy defect wrapping the thermal circle, and a magnetic line defect localized on the thermal circle. We extract thermal DCFT data from these correlators and comment on their analytic structure."
The paper also details:
A Endpoint derivation of the KMS sum rules
Monodromy defect thermal one-point functions of all Tµν components
Line defects in scalar CFTs at finite temperature
Relevant excerpts include:
"In both set-ups, and for any dimension and co-dimension, we classify bulk one-point functions of scalar, vector and spin-2 primaries. We relate the low-temperature expansion of bulk scalar one-point functions to zero-temperature defect CFT data and new finite-temperature data of defect primaries."
For localized defects, we observe a Hurwitz zeta function decomposition of one-point functions suggestive of an underlying arXiv:2609.38130v1 [hep-th] 29 Sep 2026 dispersion relation.
"The KMS condition plays the role of a bootstrap equation for the thermal CFT two-point function. It is similar to the crossing equation for the bulk two-point function in zero-temperature DCFT in that it does not involve positive-definite coefficients."
We derive a set of sum rules for the coefficients entering the thermal block expansion of the one-point function.
The paper concludes with discussions on thermodynamic quantities derived from the stress tensor one-point function, such as energy density, entropy density, and free energy density. For example:
Defining dimensionless energy, entropy and free energy densities as in eqs. (5.19), (5.25) and (5.24), we find for any d E = 2 1 − 2 1−d d κf ζ(d)
The paper also discusses boundary effects, such as:
"We will compute thermal one-point functions of simple bulk operators from which we extract some thermal DCFT data. One of the operators that we consider is the stress tensor, through which we can compute certain thermodynamic quantities."
The boundary contribution to the energy as E∂ = A β d−1 Z ∞ 0 dz E(z) + d − 1 d bT, which is manifestly finite.
The paper's structure covers:
Section 5.1 Free scalar field,
Section 5.2 Free Dirac fermion,
Section 5.3 Free hypermultiplet,
and Section 5.4 Free higher-derivative scalar.
The paper's focus is on how conformal symmetry and the KMS condition constrain thermal observables in the presence of defects (boundaries or impurities). The key results involve deriving bootstrap sum rules for thermal DCFT data, extracting thermal one-point functions of bulk operators using Euclidean inversion formulas, and computing thermodynamic quantities like energy density and free energy density.
The paper is organized as follows:
"In section 2 we fix our conventions and briefly review zero-temperature DCFT and thermal CFT. Section 3 develops the kinematics of both defect configurations. We classify the one-point functions of defect and bulk primaries, identify the thermal DCFT data and derive Euclidean inversion formulas that extract them. In section 4 we turn to the constraints imposed by the KMS condition. We derive novel bootstrap sum rules for bulk one-point functions in the presence of defects localized on the thermal circle. The remaining sections are devoted to examples."
"Section 5 studies free BCFTs at finite temperature: free scalars, free fermions, a 4d hypermultiplet and a non-unitary higher-derivative scalar. For each of them, we extract thermal BCFT data and compute thermodynamic quantities."
The paper is organized as follows:
In section 1 Introduction,
Section 2 Review,
Section 3 Kinematics of conformal defects at finite temperature,
Section 4 Bootstrap sum rules,
Section 5 Boundaries in CFTs at finite temperature.
We consider conformal boundaries and defects in Euclidean conformal field theory (CFT) at finite temperature and infinite volume.
"In both set-ups, and for any dimension and co-dimension, we classify bulk one-point functions of scalar, vector and spin-2 primaries. We relate the low-temperature expansion of bulk scalar one-point functions to zero-temperature defect CFT data and new finite-temperature data of defect primaries."
For localized defects, we derive one-point bootstrap sum rules using periodicity and the defect operator expansion.
"We determine thermal defect CFT data in all examples. For defects wrapping the thermal circle, we compute thermodynamic observables. For localized defects, we observe a Hurwitz zeta function decomposition of one-point functions suggestive of an underlying arXiv:2609.38130v1 [hep-th] 29 Sep 2026 dispersion relation."
The KMS condition plays the role of a bootstrap equation for the thermal CFT two-point function.
We find that all thermodynamic quantities coincide with the no-boundary results.
We consider conformal boundaries and defects in Euclidean conformal field theory (CFT) at finite temperature and infinite volume.
"In both set-ups, and for any dimension and co-dimension, we classify bulk one-point functions of scalar, vector and spin-2 primaries.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved system can perform thermal one-point function calculations for bulk scalar operators in free field examples like scalar, fermion, hypermultiplet, and higher-derivative scalar theories using point splitting regularisation (eq. 5.4) and extracting boundary thermal one-point functions from the resulting series expansions (eq. 5.14).
-
Improved system can derive bootstrap sum rules for bulk one-point functions in the presence of defects localized on the thermal circle by treating the KMS condition as a crossing equation, which allows for constraints on coefficients entering the thermal block expansion (eq. 4.6).
-
Improved system can compute thermodynamic observables like dimensionless energy density E, entropy density s, and free energy density f for various CFTs at finite temperature using expressions derived from the stress tensor one-point function (eq. 5.20) and related relations (eq. 5.21), including results for d=6 higher-derivative scalar theories.
-
Improved system can extract thermal boundary one-point functions for bulk operators by dividing out the zero-temperature bulk boundary two-point functions, providing an infinite amount of thermal BCFT data (eq. 5.15).
-
Improved system can analyze the behavior of correlation functions under KMS constraints, specifically showing that for a scalar with bosonic statistics localized on the thermal circle, the KMS condition implies FO(w, z) = FO(1 - w, z) (eq. 3.22).
-
Improved system can determine the tensor structures appearing in one-point functions of spin-2 primary operators in the presence of a defect wrapping the thermal circle by analyzing Table 4 and its associated constraints imposed by KMS and parity symmetries (Page 17).
-
Improved system can compute the thermal one-point function of a vector current for a conserved symmetry, showing that c q=1 J must equal the defect thermal one-point function of the tilt operator (eq. 3.9) when q = 1.
-
Improved system can determine the functional form of bulk correlation functions for specific defects, such as a magnetic line defect, by observing Hurwitz zeta function decompositions analogous to those of thermal two-point functions (Page 16).
Abstract
We consider conformal boundaries and defects in Euclidean conformal field theory (CFT) at finite temperature and infinite volume. We distinguish defects that wrap the thermal circle and defects that are localised at a point on it. In both set-ups, and for any dimension and co-dimension, we classify bulk one-point functions of scalar, vector and spin-2 primaries. We relate the low-temperature expansion of bulk scalar one-point functions to zero-temperature defect CFT data and new finite-temperature data of defect primaries. For localised defects, we derive one-point bootstrap sum rules using periodicity and the defect operator expansion. We consider several examples in free bulk CFTs: unitary and non-unitary boundary CFTs, a wrapping monodromy defect, and a localised magnetic line. We determine thermal defect CFT data in all examples. For defects wrapping the thermal circle, we compute thermodynamic observables. For localised defects, we observe a Hurwitz zeta function decomposition of one-point functions suggestive of an underlying dispersion relation.
Sources
- OPE Convergence in Conformal Field Theory
- Bounding scalar operator dimensions in 4D CFT
- Carving Out the Space of 4D CFTs
- A Semidefinite Program Solver for the Conformal Bootstrap
- The Analytic Bootstrap and AdS Superhorizon Locality
- Convexity and Liberation at Large Spin
- Analyticity in Spin in Conformal Theories
- A Conformal Dispersion Relation: Correlations from Absorption
- Dispersive CFT Sum Rules
- A Basis of Analytic Functionals for CFTs in General Dimension
- Solving the 3D Ising Model with the Conformal Bootstrap
- Precision Islands in the Ising and $O(N)$ Models
- Defects in conformal field theory
- Spinning operators and defects in conformal field theory
- Radial coordinates for defect CFTs
- The Bootstrap Program for Boundary CFT_d
- Bootstrapping the 3d Ising twist defect
- Boundary and Interface CFTs from the Conformal Bootstrap
- Universality at large transverse spin in defect CFT
- Analytic Bootstrap for Boundary CFT
Related papers
- Inverse KLT kernel of AdS string integrals from the intersection matrix
- Exact WKB analysis of inverted triple-well: resonance, PT-symmetry breaking, and resurgence
- Ten-dimensional localization
- Twisted scattering from Chern-Simons theory
- Orientifold and Integrability: N=4 Super-Yang-Mills on RP 4
- An Infinite Family of Non-Rational VOAs from Strongly Coupled 4d Higgsless SCFTs