Common invariant measures for beta-transformations: affine relations and squared bases

arXiv:2609.31156 · math.DS · Submitted 2026-09-25 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Common invariant measures for beta-transformations".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. Common invariant measures for beta-transformations with rational affine relations classify common invariant probabilities for two beta-transformations with a rational affine relation between their bases This paper classifies common invariant probabilities for two beta-transformations with a rational affine relation between their bases The singular rigidity result shows that every finite nonnegative measure that is singular with respect to Lebesgue measure and invariant under both maps is a multiple of the point mass at zero Combining this result with the known classification of coincident absolutely continuous invariant probabilities gives all common invariant probabilities in this family Singular Rigidity and Classification Theorem 1.1 establishes that for a family of rational affine relations between the bases, every singular common invariant probability is the point mass at zero The proof constructs a finite signed measure invariant under an irrational rotation and relates its mass to the first moment of the original measure The construction involves clearing denominators and showing that if a finite nonnegative common invariant measure µ is singular, then its first moment vanishes, forcing µ to be supported at zero Classification of Absolutely Continuous Measures Theorem 1.2 provides the classification for the absolutely continuous part of the measures based on whether the bases are related in a specific way If b+ = b− + 1 and b− ∈ E, then common invariant probabilities are exactly a convex combination of two Rényi–Parry measures In every other case, the point mass δ0 is the only common invariant probability Corollary 1.4 provides an explicit classification for rational gaps, stating that the common measure is either a mixture or just δ0 Relation to Existing Literature The study connects to earlier work on multiplication maps by using the difference between compositions to obtain an irrational rotation The authors use the classification of Huang and Wang

4, Theorem 1.1: for the absolutely continuous part and Theorem 1.1 controls the singular part Their results extend previous work by covering measures with zero entropy, which is beyond what some earlier theorems contained Scope and Exceptional Cases The excluded relation a + c = 1 corresponds to the case where (γ − 1)/(β − 1) is rational In this case, common fixed points are classified by Proposition 5.1, which describes the set Fix(Tβ) ∩ Fix(Tγ) This suggests that the excluded relation cannot be added to Theorem 1.1 as stated because it allows for finite sets on which the two maps act as nontrivial permutations The paper also addresses whether common singular probabilities can be classified when 1, β, γ are linearly independent over Q The Exceptional Density Proposition A.1 verifies the classical two-step Parry density from earlier work using the transfer operator The formula derived for the density of (Tb)∗(fλ) shows that for b = β, Lβh(y) = h(y) This verification confirms the density formula given in (A.1), which is important for the classification The final step shows that dividing hλ by this mass proves the claim.

Ada: Finite Cyclic Averaging The paper introduces an equivalent form of the quotient construction using finite cyclic averaging operators The operator Σ satisfies WΣ = Σ, and its total mass is qDm Since β/q is irrational, Lemma 2.2 implies that Σ = qDmλ This construction yields the same first-moment obstruction as the previous method.

Emmy: Acknowledgements and Funding The author acknowledges that GPT-6 (OpenAI) was used to assist with extending the argument to rational gaps and checking calculations This work was partially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No.

Ada: 123B2006).

Title and authors: Ada: So we're looking at this paper called "Common invariant measures for beta-transformations: affine relations and squared bases" by Hang Zhao, and it deals with finding common invariant probabilities when you have two different beta transformations that are related by a rational affine relation between their bases.

Emmy: It’s about taking these two maps, let's call them T-beta and T-gamma, which are defined by their bases, and figuring out what the common invariant measures look like for both of them.

Kolya: So it seems the authors are focusing on cases where those bases have a rational relationship between them. Is that what this paper is really about?

Ada: Exactly. They set up conditions where you have an irrational beta, and then another base gamma that's related to it by a rational linear combination, specifically gamma equals a times beta plus c, where a and c are rational numbers and their sum isn't equal to one.

Emmy: So the main point is classifying all the common invariant probabilities for this family of transformations. It’s about finding all the possible ways two such systems can share a measure that stays the same under both maps.

Kolya: I wonder what that means in practice for understanding these dynamical systems, since we usually focus on single invariant measures first, right?

Ada: Right. The implication is that they are providing a complete picture of the set of common invariant probabilities for this specific setup, which is something that’s hard to do when you have two different maps interacting like this.

Emmy: It sets up a framework where you can predict exactly what kind of common measure exists based on the structure of those affine relations between the bases.

The paper's summary: Ada: This paper, "Common invariant measures for beta-transformations: affine relations and squared bases," summarizes a classification effort for these common invariant probabilities. They start by stating that they are looking at two beta transformations where the relationship between their bases is rational and affine.

Emmy: The core result they establish is that they classify these common measures by separating them into what’s absolutely continuous, which relates to the density of the measure, and what’s singular.

Kolya: Singular measures are tricky because they are supported on sets where the Lebesgue measure is zero, so you can't just look at a smooth density function for them. What does the paper say about those?

Ada: The key result there is that every finite nonnegative measure that is singular with respect to Lebesgue measure and invariant under both maps has to be a multiple of the point mass at zero.

Emmy: That means any singular common probability you find must just be the point mass at zero, which is basically a Dirac delta function concentrated at zero. It simplifies things a lot for the singular part of the problem.

Kolya: So they handle the singular stuff by showing it's very restricted, but what about the absolutely continuous part? That’s where we usually find densities, right?

Ada: Right. For that, they rely on known classifications of coincident absolutely continuous invariant probabilities and then show how this fits into their family of maps.

Emmy: They use a parameter condition to simplify things, which is about whether the relation between the bases from one side has some specific structure. This helps them narrow down exactly when you get those non-zero density solutions.

The paper's improvements: Ada: One thing they suggest improving is making the classification more explicit for rational gaps, which they connect to a problem called M-beta,c. They show that for a positive rational number c, the set of common invariant probabilities M-beta,c can be described precisely.

Emmy: They give us this formula: it’s either a mixture of the point mass at zero and the Rényi–Parry measure for beta, or just the point mass at zero in certain cases.

Kolya: That's useful because it gives us a clear structure for what kind of density solutions we can expect when dealing with those rational gaps between bases. It moves beyond just saying a solution exists to actually telling you what it looks like.

Ada: And they provide an explicit density formula in one specific exceptional case, when the bases satisfy a certain condition and the relation is met. It's d-nu-beta over lambda equals one plus beta minus one times the interval from zero to 'a' times x over one plus a over beta.

Emmy: That formula is concrete because it gives you the exact density of that common measure when those specific conditions hold, which helps us actually compute something instead of just identifying its existence.

Kolya: So, they are moving from abstract classification to explicit computation in certain instances where the structure allows for it. That’s a big step toward applying these results to concrete dynamical systems.

Conclusion: Ada: To wrap up, the paper "Common invariant measures for beta-transformations: affine relations and squared bases" shows that they have classified all common invariant probabilities for this family of transformations. They established that every singular common invariant probability is just the point mass at zero, and they provided a complete classification for the absolutely continuous part based on those specific rational affine relations between the bases.

Emmy: So what this means overall is that we now have a comprehensive tool to predict what kind of common measure exists when you have two beta transformations linked by these types of rational affine relations between their bases.

Kolya: From my side, I just think the explicit density formula they provide in case one point five is very important because it gives us a handle on the actual shape of the invariant measure when things line up perfectly for that specific structure <ref:2609.31156#pg3>.

Ada: And that’s right, Kolya, we're getting concrete information about those measures instead of just abstract existence proofs, and that’s what makes this work so valuable for our field.

Emmy: It’s a solid piece of classification work because it handles both the singular part and the absolutely continuous densities in a very systematic way.

Kolya: I think this paper sets a good benchmark for how we should approach problems involving multiple maps, which is exactly what we need to keep doing in ergodic theory.

Hang Zhao

School of Mathematics and Big Data, Neijiang Normal University

math.DS

Submitted: 2026-09-25

Updated: 2026-11-16

Comments: v2: 8 pages; title revised. Adds a new theorem: for every irrational base, every common singular invariant measure of the base and its square is supported at zero

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: Common invariant measures for beta-transformations with rational affine relations classify common invariant probabilities for two beta-transformations with a rational affine relation between their…

Key concepts

Singular Invariant Probability
A measure that is invariant under both maps but is singular with respect to Lebesgue measure (meaning it lives on a set of zero area). The paper proves that for these specific beta-transformations, the only such probability is the point mass at zero ($\delta_0$).
Rényi–Parry Measure
The unique absolutely continuous invariant probability associated with a single beta-transformation. These measures describe how points are distributed under repeated applications of the transformation and form the basis for classifying common invariant probabilities.
Rational Affine Relation
A condition where the bases ($eta$ and $\gamma$) of two beta-transformations are related by a linear equation with rational coefficients, such as $\gamma = a\beta + c$. This relation dictates the structure of the common invariant measures.
Exceptional Case Exclusion
The condition $a+c=1$ is excluded because it allows for common fixed points that are not just zero. This exclusion ensures that the main theorems regarding singular and absolutely continuous parts hold true without these specific, more complex scenarios.

Terminology

Summary

Common invariant measures for beta-transformations with rational affine relations classify common invariant probabilities for two beta-transformations with a rational affine relation between their bases This paper classifies common invariant probabilities for two beta-transformations with a rational affine relation between their bases The singular rigidity result shows that every finite nonnegative measure that is singular with respect to Lebesgue measure and invariant under both maps is a multiple of the point mass at zero Combining this result with the known classification of coincident absolutely continuous invariant probabilities gives all common invariant probabilities in this family

Singular Rigidity and Classification

Theorem 1.1 establishes that for a family of rational affine relations between the bases, every singular common invariant probability is the point mass at zero The proof constructs a finite signed measure invariant under an irrational rotation and relates its mass to the first moment of the original measure The construction involves clearing denominators and showing that if a finite nonnegative common invariant measure µ is singular, then its first moment vanishes, forcing µ to be supported at zero

Classification of Absolutely Continuous Measures

Theorem 1.2 provides the classification for the absolutely continuous part of the measures based on whether the bases are related in a specific way If b+ = b− + 1 and b− ∈ E, then common invariant probabilities are exactly a convex combination of two Rényi–Parry measures In every other case, the point mass δ0 is the only common invariant probability Corollary 1. p. 34 provides an explicit classification for rational gaps, stating that the common measure is either a mixture or just δ0

Relation to Existing Literature

The study connects to earlier work on multiplication maps by using the difference between compositions to obtain an irrational rotation The authors use the classification of Huang and Wang [4, Theorem 1.1] for the absolutely continuous part and Theorem 1. p. 51 controls the singular part Their results extend previous work by covering measures with zero entropy, which is beyond what some earlier theorems contained

Scope and Exceptional Cases

The excluded relation a + c = 1 corresponds to the case where (γ − 1)/(β − 1) is rational In this case, common fixed points are classified by Proposition 5.1, which describes the set Fix(Tβ) ∩ Fix(Tγ) This suggests that the excluded relation cannot be added to Theorem 1. p. 81 as stated because it allows for finite sets on which the two maps act as nontrivial permutations The paper also addresses whether common singular probabilities can be classified when 1, β, γ are linearly independent over Q

The Exceptional Density

Proposition A.1 verifies the classical two-step Parry density from earlier work using the transfer operator The formula derived for the density of (Tb)∗(fλ) shows that for b = β, Lβh(y) = h(y) This verification confirms the density formula given in (A. p. 91), which is important for the classification The final step shows that dividing hλ by this mass proves the claim. p. 9

Finite Cyclic Averaging

The paper introduces an equivalent form of the quotient construction using finite cyclic averaging operators The operator Σ satisfies WΣ = Σ, and its total mass is qDm Since β/q is irrational, Lemma 2.2 implies that Σ = qDmλ This construction yields the same first-moment obstruction as the previous method. p. 8

Acknowledgements and Funding

The author acknowledges that GPT-6 (OpenAI) was used to assist with extending the argument to rational gaps and checking calculations This work was partially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 123B2006). The data availability statement confirms that no new data were created or analyzed in this study. p. 0

References

[1] A. Rényi, Representations for real numbers and their ergodic properties, Acta Math. p. 3 Acad. Sci. Hungar., 8 (1957), 477–493, doi:10.1007/BF02020331

[2] W. Parry, On the β-expansions of real numbers, Acta Math. p. 0 Acad. Sci. Hungar., 11 (1960), 401–416, doi:10.1007/BF02020954

[3] G. Brown and Q. p. 3 Yin, β-transformation, invariant measure and uniform distribution, J. p. 0 Austral. Math. Soc. Ser., A 66 (1999), no. 3, 418–428, doi:10.1017/S1446788700036703

[4] Y. Huang and Z. p. 3 Wang, The coincidence of Rényi–Parry measures for β-transformation, Int. p. 3 Math. Res. Not., IMRN 2025 (2025), no. 8, rnaf089, doi:10.1093/imrn/rnaf089

[5] H. Furstenberg, Disjointness in ergodic theory, minimal sets, and a problem in Diophantine approximation, Math. Systems Theory 1 (1967), 1–49, doi:10. p. 31007/BF01692494

[6] D. J. Rudolph, ×2 and ×3 invariant measures and entropy, Ergodic Theory Dynam. p. 3 Systems 10 (1990), no. p. 3 2, 395–406, doi:10.1017/S0143385700005629

[7] A. S. A. Johnson, Measures on the circle invariant under multiplication by a nonlacunary subsemigroup of the integers, Israel J. p. 3 Math., 77 (1992), no. 1–2, 211–240, doi:10.1007/BF02808018

[8] A. Bertrand-Mathis, Sur les mesures simultanément invariantes pour les transformations x 7→ λx et x 7→ βx, Acta Math. p. 3 Hungar., 78 (1998), no. 1–2, 71–78, doi:10.1023/A:1006570520267

[9] M. Hochman and P. p. 3 Shmerkin, Equidistribution from fractal measures, Invent. p. 3 Math., 202 (2015), no. 1, 427–479, doi:10.1007/s00222-014-0573-5

[10] K. Dajani and N. Langeveld, Coincidence of invariant measure for the alternate base transformations, preprint (2026), arXiv:2603. p. 312877

[11] Y. Huang and Y. p. 3 Sun, Negative β-transformations: invariant measures, subshifts of finite type and matching property, preprint (2026), arXiv:2603. p. 314862

--- Page 1 ---

Common invariant measures for beta-transformations with rational affine relations

Hang Zhao

School of Mathematics and Big Data, Neijiang Normal University

Neijiang, Sichuan 641100, China

E-mail: hangzhaoscu@163.com

ORCID: 0009-0003-2445-3477

Abstract

We classify common invariant probabilities for two beta-transformations with a rational affine relation between their bases Let β > 1 be irrational and γ = aβ + c > 1, where a, c ∈ Q and a + c!= 1 Every finite nonnegative measure that is singular with respect to Lebesgue measure and invariant under both maps is a multiple of the point mass at zero No entropy, ergodicity or multiplicative independence assumption is needed The proof constructs a finite signed measure invariant under an irrational rotation and relates its mass to the first moment of the original measure

--- Page 2 ---

Write λ for Lebesgue probability measure on X and P(X) for the Borel probability measures on X. For a Borel map F, write F∗ for pushforward, so F∗µ(E) = µ(F−1E) The invariance condition is F∗µ = µ Each Tb has a unique absolutely continuous invariant probability νb, called the Rényi–Parry measure, and νb is equivalent to λ [1, 2] The point mass δ0 is invariant under every Tb A classification of common invariant probabilities must therefore account for singular measures as well as densities Here singular means supported on a set of Lebesgue measure zero; such a measure need not be atomic Classifying when two Rényi–Parry measures coincide does not by itself settle this question

--- Page 3 ---

We prove that, for a family of rational affine relations between the bases, every singular common invariant probability is δ0 The maps need not commute Their two compositions instead differ by rotations on a finite partition, and this difference is the main ingredient of the proof

--- Page 4 ---

The parameter condition excludes the case in which the same rational relation holds between the distances of the bases from one

--- Page 5 ---

Let E = [b > 1: b squared − ub − v = 0 for some u, v ∈ N, 1 ≤ v ≤ u], where N = (1, 2,...), (1.3)

--- Page 6 ---

The bases in (1.2) are distinct: equality would force a = 1, c = 0, contrary to a+c! p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1= 1

--- Page 7 ---

Remark 1.3 (A symmetric parameter condition). p. 2 The parameter assumptions can also be stated as follows: 1, β, γ are linearly dependent over Q, at least one base is irrational, and γ − 1 / β − 1 ∈/ Q Indeed, after choosing β to be irrational, rational dependence gives a unique relation γ = aβ + c with a, c ∈ Q Since γ − 1 / β − 1 = a + (a + c - 1) / β - 1, this ratio is irrational exactly when a + c! p. 2= 1

--- Page 8 ---

For comparison with the rational-gap problem, define Mβ,c = [µ ∈ P(X): (Tβ)∗µ = (Tβ+c)∗µ = µ] Theorem 1.2 has the following explicit consequence

--- Page 9 ---

Corollary 1.4 (Complete classification for rational gaps). p. 2 Let β > 1 be irrational and let c ∈ Q>0, then Mβ,c = [(1 − t)δ0 + tνβ: 0 ≤ t ≤ 1], c = 1 and β ∈ E

--- Page 9 ---

In the exceptional case, νβ = νβ+1 If β squared − uβ − v = 0 with 1 ≤ v ≤ u, set a = β − u = v/β ∈ (0, 1) The common measure has density dνβ dλ (x) = 1 + β−1[0,a)(x) / 1 + a/β

--- Page 9 ---

The mixing parameter in (1.4) is unique and equals 1 − µ(0) The only singular common invariant probability measure is δ0

--- Page 9 ---

Corollary 1.5 (Further parameter families). p. 2 Each of the following pairs has δ0 as its only common invariant probability

  1. β and kβ + c, where β > 1 is irrational, k ≥ 2 is an integer, and c ∈ Q≥0

  2. an irrational base β > 1 and a rational base γ > 1

--- Page 9 ---

The gap (k − 1)β + c is irrational, so the exceptional case of Theorem 1.2 cannot occur

--- Page 9 ---

The only purely atomic common invariant probability is δ0 Every finite common invariant measure is a nonnegative multiple of one of the classified probabilities

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The parameter condition excludes the case in which the same rational relation holds between the distances of the bases from one The bases in (1.2) are distinct: equality would force a = 1, c = 0, contrary to a+c!= 1

How the training signal is built

The parameter condition excludes the case in which the same rational relation holds between the distances of the bases from one The bases in (1.2) are distinct: equality would force a = 1, c = 0, contrary to a+c!= 1

Where the gains come from

The parameter condition excludes the case in which the same rational relation holds between the distances of the bases from one The bases in (1.2) are distinct: equality would force a = 1, c = 0, contrary to a+c!= 1

The parameter condition excludes the case in which the same rational relation holds between the distances of the bases from one The bases in (1.2) are distinct: equality would force a = 1, c = 0, contrary to a+c!

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Precise classification of singular common invariant probabilities can be achieved by showing that every finite nonnegative measure that is singular with respect to Lebesgue measure and invariant under both maps is a multiple of the point mass at zero. This allows AI systems to immediately discard any candidate measures lacking this form, significantly reducing search space for singular solutions.

  2. Development of an algorithm to determine if a pair of irrational bases has a common absolutely continuous invariant probability by checking the condition b+ = b− + 1 and b− ∈ E. This speeds up the identification of non-zero density solutions in rational affine relations.

  3. Implementation of a procedure to compute the explicit common measure density formula dνβ/dλ (x) = 1 + β−11[0,a)(x) / 1 + a/β when bases satisfy the condition where b+ = b− + 1 and b− ∈ E. This allows for exact calculation of the invariant density rather than just identifying its existence.

  4. Creation of a function to check if the ratio γ − 1 / β − 1 is rational to determine if the excluded relation holds, which dictates whether common fixed points exist away from zero using Proposition 5.1. This prevents unnecessary computation for cases where no such fixed points are relevant.

Sources

Related papers