Prospects for testing Lorentz symmetry with highly charged ions

arXiv:2609.20953 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-09-17 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Prospects for testing Lorentz symmetry with highly charged ions".

Paper summary: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper on "Prospects for testing Lorentz symmetry with highly charged ions," it seems like highly charged ions offer a promising avenue for testing Lorentz symmetry through these specific energy shifts. It’s really about using the large momentum in hydrogen-like ions to probe those k equals four coefficients.

Mira: And it also shows that B-like ion spectroscopy provides a way to get competitive sensitivity to certain other SME coefficients that are otherwise inaccessible through ground state studies of hydrogen-like ions.

Lev: The paper suggests that the advantage of the H-like system is most evident when you compare the two charge states of the same isotope, which could provide constraints on nonrelativistic coefficients with j greater than one and m not equal to zero.

Kai: So, for someone just listening, what does this mean? It means we're looking at a way to potentially constrain some of the most complex terms in Lorentz violation that are hard to see elsewhere.

Mira: It means that HCI spectroscopy experiments have the potential to improve existing bounds on those k equals four coefficients and open up new areas for testing nonrelativistic SME coefficients.

Lev: From an engineering view, it suggests that these systems could provide the first constraints on those nonrelativistic coefficients with j greater than one and m not equal to zero, which is a big deal for pushing the limits of what we can build in a lab.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this paper "Prospects for testing Lorentz symmetry with highly charged ions," it’s about how we can actually test Lorentz symmetry using these heavy ions in a lab.

Mira: Right, it shows that we’re looking at energy shifts in Zeeman and hyperfine transitions within hydrogen-like ions and also B-like ions to see if they deviate from what relativity predicts.

Lev: The key finding seems to be that the large momentum of the electron in hydrogen-like ions gives us sensitivity for certain terms with a four power scaling, which is way better than what we might get from lighter atoms.

Kai: And B-like ions offer another angle, probing different SME coefficients through their ground state fine structure splitting where you can't look in H-like ions.

Mira: So it’s not just one way to test it but two different spectroscopic methods both giving us access to different parts of the Lorentz violation landscape.

Lev: It suggests that these experiments could actually provide the first constraints on some nonrelativistic coefficients with j greater than one and m not equal to zero.

Kai: That means we might be able to get a handle on those terms that are currently really hard to pin down with our existing tests.

Mira: And it points toward a future where high-precision spectroscopy on these ions could actually test the core assumptions of quantum gravity theories in a very tangible way.

Lev: It’s interesting because it moves the discussion from just looking at neutral atoms to using these highly charged systems which have much more accessible momentum scales.

Kai: So, if we can get the sensitivity they're talking about, what does that actually change for our understanding of physics?

Laboratory of Theoretical Physics, Department of Physics, University of Puerto Rico

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-09-17

Updated: 2026-11-17

Importance score: 68/100

The gist: Prospects for testing Lorentz symmetry with highly charged ions investigates the prospects for testing Lorentz symmetry using highly charged ions by deriving Lorentz-violating energy shifts relevant…

Key concepts

Standard Model Extension (SME)
The SME is an effective field theory that extends the Standard Model and General Relativity by adding terms that violate Lorentz symmetry. Experimental searches for Lorentz violation are interpreted as measurements or bounds on specific combinations of SME coefficients, providing a unified framework for testing these theories.
Lorentz-violating energy shift
This is the change in energy observed in a laboratory frame due to the presence of Lorentz-violating electron operators. These shifts are used to derive signals like frequency changes in atomic transitions, which can be compared against theoretical predictions derived from SME coefficients.
H-like and B-like Ions
H-like ions (e.g., hydrogenic ions) and B-like ions (e.g., helium-like ions) are specific types of highly charged atoms used in this research. Their unique electronic structures allow them to be sensitive to different combinations of SME coefficients, offering distinct advantages for testing Lorentz symmetry.

Terminology

Summary

Prospects for testing Lorentz symmetry with highly charged ions investigates the prospects for testing Lorentz symmetry using highly charged ions by deriving Lorentz-violating energy shifts relevant to Zeeman and Zeeman-hyperfine transitions within H-like ions and to Zeeman and Zeeman-fine transitions within the ground state of B-like ions. p. 0 The resulting signals include sidereal variations through the first harmonic of the sidereal frequency for H-like ions and through the third harmonic for B-like ions. p. 0 For certain SME coefficients whose contributions scale with the fourth power of the electron momentum, the large electron momentum in H-like ions can provide sensitivity competitive with the best existing bounds at the precision achievable in H-like-ion spectroscopy. p. 0 We also find that B-like-ion spectroscopy can provide competitive sensitivity to certain SME coefficients. p. 0

Theoretical Framework and SME Coefficients

Lorentz violation has been proposed as a possible low-energy signature of candidate theories of quantum gravity, including string theory. The Standard-Model Extension (SME) is an effective field theory that extends the conventional Lagrangian densities of the Standard Model and General Relativity by including operators that violate Lorentz symmetry. p. 0 Experimental searches for signals of Lorentz violation can be interpreted as measurements of, or bounds on, combinations of SME coefficients. p. 0 The SME provides both a theoretical description of possible Lorentz violation and a common framework for organizing and comparing the diverse experimental searches for such effects. p. 0

Energy Shift Formulation

The general form of the Lorentz-violating energy shift in the laboratory frame is described by equation (1). The energy shift arising from Lorentz-violating electron operators takes the form of equation (1). p. 1 The coefficients VeNRkjm are defined by equations (3). p. 2 These nonrelativistic (NR) coefficients are linear combinations of the standard SME coefficients appearing in the SME Lagrangian density. p. 2 The NR coefficients are associated with Lorentz-violating electron operators, as indicated by the subscript e. p. 2

Laboratory Frame to Sun-Centered Frame Transformation

The SME coefficients can be interpreted as the components of Lorentz-violating background tensor fields that couple to the usual field operators. The NR coefficients are spherical coefficients, and the indices j and m specify their transformation properties under observer rotations. p. 3 The relation between the laboratory-frame and Sun-centered-frame coefficients is obtained by performing an observer Lorentz transformation. p. 4 The relation between a generic laboratory-frame NR coefficient KeNRkj0 and the corresponding Sun-centered-frame coefficients KeNR,Sunkjm, distinguished by the superscript Sun, is given by equation (8). p. 4

H-like Ion Spectroscopy Prospects

The expected advantage of testing Lorentz symmetry using Zeeman-hyperfine transitions within the ground state of H-like HCIs, compared with hydrogen, lies in their enhanced sensitivity to coefficients with k = 4 due to the higher magnitude of the momentum of the electron. The sensitivity to these coefficients is proportional to the ratio between the experimental sensitivity to the Lorentz-violating energy shift δν and the expectation value ⟨pk⟩. p. 6 The best constraints on the T-type NR coefficients with k = 4 were obtained from the results of a hydrogen-maser experiment [30] with a sensitivity of approximately 0. p. 64 mHz to a Lorentz-violating frequency shift. p. 7

B-like Ion Spectroscopy Prospects

The ground-state fine-structure splitting of B-like ions is sensitive to SME coefficients that cannot be studied through transitions within the ground state of H-like ions. The Lorentzviolating energy shifts of the J = 3/2 states are sensitive to T -type coefficients with j = 3 and V -type coefficients with j = 2, which do not contribute to the energy shifts associated with the ground-state hyperfine structure of hydrogen. The appearance of these coefficients results from the larger electronic angular momentum. p. 9

Outlook and Summary

HCIs offer promising and potentially competitive opportunities for testing Lorentz symmetry, particularly through searches involving the k = 4 coefficients. The expectation values of powers of the electron momentum used in this work were evaluated by postprocessing DHF wave functions obtained with the DIRAC program. p. 6 HCIs could provide the first constraints on NR coefficients with j > 1 and m! p. 0= 0.

Where the gains come from

The expectation values of |p|k are significantly larger for the electron in an H-like ion than for the valence electron in a B-like ion. This enhancement can make HCI experiments more sensitive to these NR coefficients than experiments involving neutral atoms. p. 2 The advantage of B-like-ion experiments is that the J = 3/2 manifold provides sensitivity to coefficients with j > 1 that cannot be accessed through studies of ground-state splittings in H-like ions. p. 9 p. 9

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The sidereal-variation signal described by (15) has the same form as that investigated in the hydrogen-maser experiment [30], which found no evidence of sidereal variations at the level of 0.4 mHz. Searches for sidereal variations are, however, insensitive to coefficients with m = 0, such as those contributing to the constant term A0 in (15). p. 8

How the training signal is built

The general form of the Lorentz-violating frequency shift in terms of Sun-centered-frame coefficients, (15), is valid only at zeroth-boost order. The most obvious signal of Lorentz violation arising from (15) is a sidereal variation of the transition frequency. p. 8

The constant term depends on the relative orientation of the magnetic field and the Earth’s rotation axis through the factor cos ϑ. Measurements performed with different magnetic-field orientations can therefore be used to constrain the m = 0 coefficients. p. 8

The Lorentz-violating energy shifts of the J = 1/2 and J = 3/2 states are presented in (18) and (19), respectively. Despite their smaller momentum enhancement, B-like ions offer the important advantage that the J = 3/2 states are sensitive to NR coefficients with j = 2 and j = 3, which do not contribute to any energy level within the ground state of an H-like ion. p. 9

The comparison between the results in Tables I and III shows that, even for ions with similar ionic charges, the expectation values ⟨pk⟩ are significantly larger for the electron in an H-like ion than for the valence electron in a B-like ion. The advantage of B-like-ion experiments is that the J = 3/2 manifold provides sensitivity to coefficients with j > 1 that cannot be accessed through studies of ground-state splittings in H-like ions.

The most obvious signal of Lorentz violation arising from (15) is a sidereal variation of the transition frequency. The sensitivity to these coefficients depends on the relative orientation of the magnetic field and the Earth’s rotation axis through the factor sin ϑ appearing in Ac and As. p. 8

The constraints derived from direct comparisons between theory and experiment will be limited by the largest between the uncertainty of the theoretical prediction or experimental result. The current bounds on the NR coefficients with j > 1 and m = 0 were derived from measurements of the 1S − 2P transition in antihydrogen, for which an absolute uncertainty of the order of 100 MHz was achieved. p. 6

The situation is similar for B-like ions, where the enhancement associated with the larger electron momentum is less pronounced for B-like ions than for H-like ions. The Lorentzviolating energy shifts of the J = 1/2 and J = 3/2 states are presented in (18) and (19), respectively. p. 2

HCIs offer promising and potentially competitive opportunities for testing Lorentz symmetry, particularly through searches involving the k = 4 coefficients. The analysis indicates that the recent high-precision measurement of the ground-state fine-structure splitting in Ar13+ [62] is close to being competitive with leading optical clocks [67] in sensitivity to anisotropic NR coefficients with k = 4. p. 1

The uncertainty achieved in a recent Penning-trap measurement of Sn49+ [59] could improve the existing bounds on these coefficients. The precision of measurements of ground-state hyperfine transitions and Zeeman transitions within the ground-state hyperfine manifold of HCIs is expected to improve significantly in the coming years through the ARTEMIS and SPECTRAP experiments at GSI and the ALPHATRAP experiment at MPIK. p. 7

The sensitivity required to improve the bounds on the k = 4 coefficients using storage-ring spectroscopy is beyond that achieved even in the most successful experiments of this type, such as the Bi82+ experiments. An experiment using Sn49+ could be competitive when the relativistic calculation employing a Gaussian nuclear model is used, although it would fall short under the more conservative estimate obtained using the nonrelativistic wave function. p. 7

The advantage of H-like system is most evident when the two charge states of the same isotope are compared. HCI experiments could provide the first constraints on NR coefficients with j > 1 and m! p. 7= 0. The potential of HCI spectroscopy experiments to improve the existing bounds on the k = 4 coefficients is highlighted. p. 7

The Lorentz-violating perturbation considered in this work does not include corrections to the interactions of electrons with external fields or with one another. This perturbation was developed in the context of searches for Lorentz and CPT violation using Penning traps. p. 0

The analysis based only on the individual Zeeman-pair averages could retain the high precision of the Ar13+ experiment. p. 7 A sidereal-variation search could compare one of the Zeeman-pair averages with the four-transition average, which, within the model considered here, should not contain any Lorentz-violating sidereal variation and could therefore serve as a reference frequency. p. 8

HCIs offer promising and potentially competitive opportunities for testing Lorentz symmetry, particularly through searches involving the k = 4 coefficients. The analysis based only on the individual Zeeman-pair averages could retain the high precision of the Ar13+ experiment.

The sensitivity to these coefficients depends on the relative orientation of the magnetic field and the Earth’s rotation axis through the factor sin ϑ appearing in Ac and As.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can perform a systematic comparison of experimental sensitivities to different SME coefficients by mapping them onto a common framework using Sun-centered frame coefficients derived from laboratory frame observables (Equation 8).

  2. The improved system can predict the specific sidereal variation signals that arise at linear-boost order, including annual variations and harmonics up to the second harmonic of the sidereal frequency, based on the Lorentz-violating energy shift form in Equation 17.

  3. The AI can determine which SME coefficients are constrained by which experimental setups by analyzing Table IV, identifying that V-type coefficients with j = 2 contribute only up to the second harmonic and T-type coefficients with j = 3 contribute up to the third harmonic.

  4. The system can identify constraints on constant terms A0 in Equation 15 by comparing measurements performed at different magnetic field orientations, which is useful for constraining m = 0 coefficients that do not produce sidereal variations at zeroth-boost order.

  5. The AI can estimate the required precision to achieve a given constraint on k = 4 coefficients by calculating the ratio of sensitivity to the Lorentz-violating frequency shift and the expectation value of electron momentum, as shown in Equation 14.

Sources

Related papers