Edge observables in Maxwell theory on null boundaries
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Edge observables in Maxwell theory on null boundaries".
Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper about edge observables in Maxwell theory on null boundaries. Essentially, they are using a Hamiltonian formulation that fits null foliations to see what happens when you look at radiative degrees of freedom <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Mira: The main thesis here is that these null foliations have this characteristic zero mode ambiguity, and it turns out this ambiguity gives rise to extra soft charges or central extensions of the boundary symmetry algebra <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Lev: It seems like they're taking something that's usually just a mathematical artifact of how you slice spacetime, and they’re finding that it has real physical consequences for the charges we measure <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Kai: They test this across three different backgrounds: Minkowski spacetime, the BTZ black hole, and de Sitter space <ref:2609.16400#pg1>. That's pretty broad territory for a study like this.
Mira: In all three cases, they find that besides the standard U(one) charge you expect from electromagnetism, there's a second edge observable associated with an intrinsic symmetry on the null boundary <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Kai: And these two charges are well defined quasilocally <ref:2609.16400#pg1>, which is important because it means they're not just local measurements.
Lev: Quasilocal is good, but what does this mean for the actual dynamics? If these charges exist, they must be related to some conserved quantity in a way that depends on the boundary geometry <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Mira: The paper explains that these two charges form a centrally extended algebra, and when you look at them in Fourier modes, this algebra becomes two independent Abelian Kac–Moody algebras with opposite levels <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Kai: That's the structure they're finding in the Fourier modes. It suggests a deeper symmetry than just a simple U(one) charge, something more complex arising from the null structure itself <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if this algebra is real, it means the phase space of your system isn't just simple canonical variables; there’s this extra structure that dictates how things evolve <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Mira: Now, they look at how this changes depending on the background. In Minkowski spacetime, for example, these two charges form two independent Abelian Kac–Moody algebras with opposite levels <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Paper summary: Kai: And then they extend it to finite distance null boundaries, looking at things like the BTZ black hole or de Sitter space <ref:2609.16400#pg1>. They find that the algebra has a common structure across all these cases.
Lev: The paper notes that for the BTZ background, they see kappa plus equals kappa over square root r plus, which shows how the horizon radius affects this level <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Mira: They also point out that these geometry dependent factors can be handled by rescaling the current modes, which suggests that the underlying mechanism is universal <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Kai: So, to summarize the core finding of "Edge observables in Maxwell theory on null boundaries," they found two independent quasilocal charges, or edge observables <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Lev: The first is the electric charge Q epsilon, which you associate with large U(one) gauge transformations <ref:2609.16400#pg3>. That's the familiar part.
Mira: But the second one, QS eta, comes from this zero mode sector of a constraint characteristic of the null foliation <ref:2609.16400#pg1>. It generates an intrinsic canonical symmetry on the null boundary phase space by shifting the angular component of the gauge field <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Kai: That shift charge, QS eta, is interesting because it doesn't need to be conserved under the full bulk Hamiltonian evolution, which involves things like transverse derivatives <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Lev: That makes sense. If a symmetry isn't conserved by the main dynamics, it means it’s an internal structure of the boundary phase space itself rather than something that gets lost during propagation <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Mira: They interpret this shift charge QS with constant eta zero as being related to the magnetic flux through the holonomy integral of the asymptotic boundary gauge field A zero <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Kai: So, this means we can relate a canonical structure on the null boundary to something that looks like magnetic flux through an integral of the field at that boundary <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Lev: It's a connection between abstract symmetry and concrete flux, which is what we need to see in real systems, right?
Mira: Exactly. And they also look at how the zero mode multiplier W acts as a boundary source <ref:2609.16400#pg3>. Q zero remains conserved, but the higher electric modes are sourced by the corresponding angular modes of W <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Kai: This is structurally similar to flux-balance laws we see at null infinity, like the Bondi mass-loss equation, but here W is a boundary multiplier instead of radiative data <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Paper summary: Lev: So the paper shows that this zero mode mechanism applies whenever the null constraint structure admits zero modes and you can choose boundary conditions so these charges are finite and integrable <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Mira: The real implication is that these charges are quasilocal in all three cases, which means they don't just depend on some arbitrary point, but on a region defined by the null boundary itself <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Kai: What this really changes for us is how we think about the boundary of spacetime when we look at radiation <ref:2609.16400#pg2>. It suggests that there are internal symmetries baked into the geometry of those null boundaries, not just external ones like BMS symmetry <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Lev: For hardware design, this tells us that when we model systems near a boundary, we need to account for these intrinsic symmetries because they dictate how the soft modes behave <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Mira: The paper also touches on geometric differences between the finite distance cases. The BTZ horizon is an inner boundary of the exterior region, whereas the cosmological horizon is the outer boundary of a static patch <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Kai: And they mention that edge modes on stretched de Sitter horizons have also been studied from a different viewpoint in another paper <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Lev: So the background dependence is geometric, not just an arbitrary parameter we plug in, which suggests this mechanism should hold for other backgrounds too if the constraint structure allows it <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Mira: This work also opens up possibilities to extend this zero mode mechanism to other theories and rotating black holes, provided the null constraint structure is right <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Kai: So, the main point of "Edge observables in Maxwell theory on null boundaries" is that we find these two independent quasilocal charges that form a centrally extended algebra across Minkowski, BTZ, and de Sitter backgrounds <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Lev: It really shows how the zero mode sector of a constraint can generate an intrinsic canonical symmetry on a phase space boundary without needing to be conserved by the full bulk evolution <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Mira: This is important because it links the structure of the null foliation directly to these new soft degrees of freedom we find at the boundary <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Conclusion: Kai: So, we're looking at the paper "Edge observables in Maxwell theory on null boundaries," and what they found is that there are two distinct kinds of measurable quantities you can get at a null boundary <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Mira: They found these charges come from the way the Hamiltonian formulation handles those null foliations, specifically that ambiguity in how you slice spacetime <ref:2609.16400#pg3> generates extra symmetry structures.
Lev: And across Minkowski space, the BTZ black hole, and de Sitter space <ref:2609.16400#pg1>, these two observables—the electric charge and this second shift charge—have a consistent underlying algebraic structure <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Kai: So it means this isn't just some arbitrary mathematical trick with null coordinates; there's a real physical symmetry that shows up on the boundary of spacetime itself <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Mira: Exactly. The key thing is that the second charge, which we call QS eta, doesn't have to be conserved by the full bulk evolution, which is a big deal for how we think about dynamics <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Lev: For me, it means if you're building hardware that models these systems, you can’t just focus on the conserved charges; you have to account for this intrinsic canonical symmetry of the null boundary phase space <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Kai: That's what I mean. It suggests that when we look at radiation, we need to include these internal symmetries because they dictate how the soft modes behave near a boundary <ref:2609.16400#pg2>.
Mira: And this paper lays out how this zero mode mechanism works, and it hints that it might extend to other theories and even rotating black holes if the underlying null constraint structure has those zero modes <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Lev: I'm interested in how the geometry of the background—like a black hole horizon versus a cosmological horizon—affects the normalization of these charges, because that’s where we see the geometry directly <ref:2609.16400#pg1>.
Kai: That’s right. And that geometric dependence is what keeps things interesting, because it shows that the physics isn't just universal; it's tied to the shape of the spacetime we're in <ref:2609.16400#pg3>.
Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade · Instituto de Física, Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Valparaiso · DISAT, Politecnico di Torino · Facultad de Ingenieríria Civil, Universidad Michoacana de San Nicolća Hidalgo
hep-th
Submitted: 2026-09-14
Updated: 2026-11-18
Importance score: 74/100
The gist: Edge observables in Maxwell theory on null boundaries study how zero modes in Hamiltonian formulations adapted to null foliations give rise to additional soft charges and centrally extended boundary…
Key concepts
- Null Foliations
- These are surfaces that follow the direction of wave propagation. They are useful because they naturally describe radiative degrees of freedom and carry boundary data relevant to asymptotic symmetries. A key feature is that they often contain a zero mode ambiguity, which can lead to physical consequences like extra charges.
- Edge Observables
- These are two independent quasilocal charges found on null boundaries in Maxwell theory. The first is the electric charge Q[ε], related to large gauge transformations. The second, QS[η], arises from a zero mode constraint and generates an intrinsic canonical symmetry of the boundary phase space.
- Kac–Moody Algebras
- The Fourier mode algebra of these edge observables takes the form of two independent Abelian Kac–Moody algebras with opposite levels. The level κ+ is geometry-dependent, specifically depending on the horizon radius in a BTZ black hole, reflecting how the background geometry influences the boundary symmetry.
- Zero Mode Multiplier
- This multiplier acts as a boundary source. It ensures that while the conserved charge Q0 remains constant, higher electric modes are sourced by the corresponding angular modes of W. This mechanism is analogous to flux-balance laws but here involves a boundary multiplier instead of traditional radiative data.
Terminology
Summary
Edge observables in Maxwell theory on null boundaries study how zero modes in Hamiltonian formulations adapted to null foliations give rise to additional soft charges and centrally extended boundary symmetry algebras in three-dimensional Maxwell theory across Minkowski spacetime, the BTZ black hole, and de Sitter space <ref:2609. p. 016400#pg30>.
Introduction to Null Foliations
Null hypersurfaces provide a natural setting for describing radiative degrees of freedom. They are adapted to wave propagation and carry the boundary data on which asymptotic symmetries act. p. 1 Null foliations generally contain a characteristic zero mode ambiguity. p. 1 This ambiguity may have physical consequences, giving rise to additional soft charges or central extensions of the boundary symmetry algebra. p. 1 The purpose of this work is to investigate this structure in three-dimensional Maxwell electrodynamics. p. 1
Edge Modes in Minkowski Spacetime
In Minkowski spacetime, the relevant asymptotic boundaries are future and past null infinity, I ±. The metric describes two independent coordinate patches with the same canonical structure for the Maxwell field. p. 4 The constraint χ ≈ 0 is characteristic of the null foliation because the kinetic term of a second order Lagrangian becomes linear in the relevant velocity in the null coordinates. p. 5 This suggests the existence of families of boundary configurations related by transformations acting only on the soft degrees of freedom, in analogy with the Goldstone interpretation of soft photon modes associated with asymptotic gauge symmetries. p. 2
Edge Modes on Curved Backgrounds
The same pair of edge observables arises in all three cases, and their centrally extended algebra has a common structure. The examples show that the additional soft sector is an intrinsic feature of the canonical formulation on null hypersurfaces. p. 3 In Minkowski spacetime, the two charges form two independent Abelian Kac–Moody algebras with opposite levels. p. 0
Finite Distance Null Boundaries
The same Hamiltonian mechanism occurs at finite distance null boundaries. On a fixed BTZ background, the black hole horizon supports the same pair of charges and centrally extended algebra, with κ+ = κ/√r+. p. 3 In the dS static patch, the cosmological horizon gives the same algebra with κc = κ/√l. p. 0 These geometry dependent factors can be absorbed by rescaling the current modes. p. 9
Conclusion on Edge Observables
The main result is that null boundaries support two independent quasilocal charges, or edge observables. The first is the electric charge Q[ε], associated with large U(1) gauge transformations. p. 2 The second, QS[η], arises from the zero mode sector of a constraint characteristic of the null foliation and generates an intrinsic canonical symmetry of the null boundary phase space, shifting the angular component of the gauge field. p. 2
Algebra in Fourier Modes
The Fourier mode algebra becomes two independent Abelian Kac–Moody algebras with opposite levels. The level κ+ depends on the BTZ background through the horizon radius, κ+ = κ/√r+. p. 0 This reflects the fact that the horizon acts as an effective quasilocal boundary whose symplectic structure depends on the background geometry. p. 3
Role of the Zero Mode Multiplier
The zero mode multiplier W acts as a boundary source: Q0 remains conserved, while the higher electric modes are sourced by the corresponding angular modes of W. This is structurally similar to familiar flux-balance laws at null infinity, such as the Bondi mass-loss equation, although here W is a boundary multiplier rather than radiative data.
Interpretation of the Shift Charge
An interesting interpretation of the shift charge QS with constant η(0) is that it can be related to the magnetic flux through the holonomy integral of the asymptotic boundary gauge field A(0). It generates a canonical transformation associated with an intrinsic symmetry of the null boundary and does not need to be conserved under the full bulk Hamiltonian evolution, which also involves transverse derivatives and flux terms that are not intrinsic to the null surface. p. 0 p. 0
Geometric Differences in Edge Modes
The difference between the two finite distance cases is geometric: the BTZ horizon is an inner boundary of the exterior region, whereas the cosmological horizon is the outer boundary of the static patch. Edge modes on stretched dS horizons have also been studied from a different viewpoint in [61]. p. 2
General Mechanism for Edge Observables
The zero mode mechanism should also hold beyond the backgrounds considered here whenever the null constraint structure admits zero modes and boundary conditions can be chosen such that the corresponding charges are finite and integrable. The charges are quasilocal in all three cases. p. 0 The background dependence therefore resides in the normalization of the physical edge observables. p. 2
Memory Effects and Soft Theorems
The shift charge QS with constant η(0) can be related to the magnetic flux through the holonomy integral of the asymptotic boundary gauge field A(0). It generates a canonical transformation associated with an intrinsic symmetry of the null boundary and does not need to be conserved under the full bulk Hamiltonian evolution, which also involves transverse derivatives and flux terms that are not intrinsic to the null surface.
Extension to Other Theories
The zero mode mechanism should also hold beyond the backgrounds considered here whenever the null constraint structure admits zero modes and boundary conditions can be chosen such that the corresponding charges are finite and integrable. A natural example is the rotating BTZ black hole. p. 1 The extremal case requires an independent analysis, since N2 develops a double zero at the horizon and the near-horizon expansion and regularity conditions change qualitatively. p. 3
Final Remarks on Quasilocal Charges
The probe field analysis keeps the background geometry fixed and does not introduce analogous geometric edge variables. One could also investigate whether a similar phase space map exists for the electromagnetic zero mode sector. p. 3 Finally, the present analysis can be extended by including backreaction and by considering non-Abelian gauge theories or gravity. p. 2
Acknowledgments and References
We thank Felipe Diaz, Oscar Fuentealba, Ayan Mukhopadhyay and Radouane Gannouji for their valuable comments and suggestions, which helped improve this manuscript. The work of D. p. 1D. was supported by the funding provided by the Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade, through grant number 451-03-137/2025-03/200162 by the Ministry of Science, Technological Development and Innovations of the Republic of Serbia. p. 0 The references listed are [1] through [69] to [25].
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved Hamiltonian formulation for null foliations allows for a systematic framework to identify symmetries and their charges, which can be used to study edge observables in three-dimensional Maxwell theory on different backgrounds like Minkowski spacetime, BTZ black holes, and de Sitter space.
-
The system can now distinguish between asymptotic symmetries (like those at null infinity) and intrinsic boundary symmetries (associated with the zero mode sector of a constraint), which is crucial for understanding where additional soft charges arise.
-
The AI system can calculate the Fourier mode algebra as two independent Abelian Kac–Moody algebras with opposite levels, allowing for the identification of edge observables in terms of electric flux modes Qn and shift symmetry modes Sn.
-
The system can determine that the zero mode W acts as a boundary source, driving balance equations for higher electric modes, providing an analogous interpretation to Bondi mass-loss evolution driven by radiative data.
-
The AI can analyze the effect of background geometry on the level of the Kac–Moody algebras, showing how geometric factors like horizon radius r+ or dS radius l determine the normalization of physical edge observables.
-
The system can differentiate between boundary conditions, such as those proposed by Shimizu and Sugishita, and more general asymptotic falloffs that lead to a vanishing electric charge at null infinity.
-
The AI can identify that the shift charge QS is an intrinsic horizon observable that generates an intrinsic canonical symmetry of the null boundary phase space, which is not conserved under the full bulk Hamiltonian evolution but can be related to magnetic flux through holonomy integrals.
-
The system can perform mode analysis to show that for a given mode, its conservation depends on whether its associated source mode vanishes, structurally similar to familiar flux-balance laws at null infinity.
Sources
- Hamiltonian Analysis of SL(2,R) Symmetry in Liouville Theory
- Light-Cone Dynamics of Particles and Fields
- First order gravity on the light front
- Kac-Moody symmetry in the light front of gauge theories
- Note on asymptotic symmetry of massless scalar field at null infinity
- Asymptotic structure of scalar-Maxwell theory at the null boundary
- Asymptotic symmetry and confinement in three-dimensional QED
- Lectures on the Infrared Structure of Gravity and Gauge Theory
- New Symmetries of Massless QED
- New Symmetries of QED
- Asymptotic Symmetries of Yang-Mills Theory
- Note on asymptotic symmetries and soft gluon theorems
- Asymptotic symmetries of electromagnetism at spatial infinity
- Soft charges and zero modes at null boundaries
- Asymptotic symmetries of QED and Weinberg's soft photon theorem
- Can scalars have asymptotic symmetries?
- Linking Past and Future Null Infinity in Three Dimensions
- Asymptotic Symmetries of Maxwell Theory in Arbitrary Dimensions at Spatial Infinity
- Residual gauge symmetry in light-cone electromagnetism
- Local subsystems in gauge theory and gravity
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions