On the Complexity of Finding Fixed Points for Set-Valued Contractions
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.
Tom: We're looking at the paper: "On the Complexity of Finding Fixed Points for Set-Valued Contractions".
Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. In this paper, we study the computational complexity of finding fixed points for set-valued contractions and establish that a specific problem related to Nadler’s theorem is CLS-complete, providing a tool to analyze convergence rates for set-valued basic iteration procedures The main result establishes that ProjectedNadler is CLS-complete by showing its equivalence to Continuous-LocalOpt Computational Complexity of Nadler's Problem The paper formulates a computational problem for Nadler’s fixed-point theorem called ProjectedNadler, proving it is CLS-complete by showing its equivalence to Continuous-LocalOpt The formulation involves a correspondence with an exact projection circuit and defines a total search problem where valid outputs include conditions related to residual descent or violation of regularity bounds The complexity is established by showing that ProjectedNadler ≡p Continuous-LocalOpt ≡p CLS-complete Converse Theorems and Metric Change The authors establish a stronger converse for Nadler’s fixed point theorem that can be applied to analyze the convergence rate of set-valued basic iteration procedure They show that under specific robust global convergence hypotheses, there exists a complete metric that makes the correspondence a Hausdorff contraction and transfers small distances back to the original metric This new converse is shown to hold for random-permutation cyclic coordinate descent, providing a pathwise convergence theorem for adaptive sequences of coordinate orderings Reduction to Large-Margin Triplet Stationarity The paper reduces the large-margin triplet stationarity problem to ProjectedNadler, yielding CLS-completeness for this problem This reduction is achieved by pairing the objective’s projectedgradient update with a singleton correspondence and an ultrametric built from the normalized loss function The final result shows that Large-Margin-Triplet-FOSP is CLS-complete Technical Tools for Complexity Proofs The proof of CLS-membership relies on a Hölder interpolation theorem that turns an n-dimensional Hölder circuit into a Lipschitz one using only n + 1 grid values per simplex The hardness reduction uses an ultrametric construction where the distance between distinct points is defined as 1 + max of their potentials Furthermore, the paper introduces a rank-weighted distance that separates distinct points and generates a metric equivalent to the original one under certain conditions Quantitative Analysis of Convergence The strong converse to Nadler’s theorem provides a quantitative convergence result for coordinate descent, showing that the residual error is bounded by a factor related to the worst-order epoch Hausdorff contraction factor This leads to an estimate on the distance from an initial point to the fixed point in terms of this contraction factor The analysis confirms that every admissible trajectory satisfies a bound derived from the worst one-step factor Further Research Directions
Paper summary: Tom: We’ve looked at what this paper, "On the Complexity of Finding Fixed Points for Set-Valued Contractions," is actually about. The main thesis is that they formulate a computational problem called ProjectedNadler, which they prove is CLS-complete by showing it’s equivalent to Continuous-LocalOpt.
Jane: So if you boil it down, what does that mean for the listener who isn't reading the math? It means they are taking a concept from Nadler’s fixed-point theorem—which is about finding stable solutions—and turning it into a computational problem that has been classified as CLS-complete.
Lu: The significance lies in how they connect this to an exact projection circuit and define a total search problem where valid outputs include conditions related to residual descent or violations of regularity bounds, which sets up the complexity proof.
Meng: So they are saying that analyzing convergence rates for set-valued basic iteration procedures is fundamentally hard because of this underlying complexity class. That sounds like it might affect how we design the solvers for complex machine learning models that use these kinds of iterations.
Tom: Exactly; they established a stronger converse to Nadler’s theorem that lets us analyze those convergence rates, and they reduce the large-margin triplet stationarity problem to ProjectedNadler, which yields CLS-completeness for that optimization problem too.
Jane: So the whole point is showing that finding these fixed points isn't just a theoretical curiosity; it’s tied to solving hard problems in optimization and search theory, giving us a formal tool to analyze how fast things settle down during iterative processes.
Conclusion: Tom: To wrap up this discussion on "On the Complexity of Finding Fixed Points for Set-Valued Contractions," the authors successfully established that ProjectedNadler is CLS-complete by showing its equivalence to Continuous-LocalOpt, and they also provided a stronger converse theorem for Nadler’s fixed point theorem.
Jane: So what does this mean in plain terms? It means we now have a formal complexity class—CLS—that we can use to measure how hard it is to find stable solutions when those solutions are defined as set-valued maps, which is super useful for understanding the limits of our iterative methods.
Lu: It gives us a way to rigorously analyze convergence rates by showing that under specific robust global convergence hypotheses, we can find a complete metric that makes the correspondence behave like a Hausdorff contraction.
Meng: So for production deployment, it means when we are looking at set-valued algorithms, we have to be careful about the underlying search problem because it's known to be hard, and the convergence guarantees depend heavily on those specific hypotheses.
Tom: The paper really shows how finding these fixed points isn't just a simple numerical task; it’s tied deeply into sophisticated geometric and computational structures, which is what makes this research interesting for machine learning engineers as well.
University of Wisconsin-Madison
cs.CC, math.GN
Submitted: 2026-09-12
Updated: 2026-11-03
Comments: 58 pages, 4 figures
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: In this paper, the authors study the computational complexity of finding fixed points for set-valued contractions and establish that Projected-Nadler is CLS-complete by reducing large-margin triplet…
Key concepts
- ProjectedNadler
- This is a computational problem formulated based on Nadler's fixed-point theorem. It involves finding valid outputs related to residual descent or violations of regularity bounds, and its complexity is shown to be CLS-complete.
- CLS-complete
- This complexity class indicates that the ProjectedNadler problem is among the hardest problems in the CLS class. This suggests that solving this specific fixed-point problem is computationally difficult and serves as a benchmark for analyzing convergence rates.
- Strong Converse to Nadler's Theorem
- The authors establish a stronger version of Nadler's theorem that can be used to analyze the convergence speed of set-valued basic iteration procedures. Under certain conditions, this new converse allows them to define a complete metric that relates distances back to the original metric.
- Large-Margin Triplet Stationarity
- This is another problem that is shown to be CLS-complete by reduction from ProjectedNadler. It involves finding solutions related to objective's projected gradient updates paired with singleton correspondences and an ultrametric built from the normalized loss function.
Terminology
Summary
In this paper, the authors study the computational complexity of finding fixed points for set-valued contractions and establish that Projected-Nadler is CLS-complete by reducing large-margin triplet stationarity to it. p. 0
Computational Characterization of Nadler's Problem
The authors formulate a computational problem for Nadler’s fixed-point theorem called ProjectedNadler and prove that it is CLS-complete by showing its equivalence to Continuous-LocalOpt. They define an instance consisting of a complete metric, a correspondence, a nearest-point projection circuit, and claimed regularity bounds. p. 3 The problem is shown to be equivalent to Continuous-LocalOpt under the fixed rational exponent beta. p. 8
Analytical Universality of the Theorem
The paper establishes a stronger converse for Nadler’s theorem that can be applied as a tool to analyze the convergence rate of set-valued basic iteration procedure. This converse shows that under specific robust global convergence hypotheses, one can change the metric so that the dynamics becomes a contraction. p. 1 Furthermore, they prove a Hölder-to-Lipschitz interpolation theorem that operates in polynomial dimension and preserves succinctness. p. 3
Complexity of Large-Margin Triplet Loss Minimization
The authors show that Projected-Nadler is a computational primitive that applies directly to finding an approximate first-order stationary point of a large-margin triplet loss. They reduce the large-margin triplet stationarity problem to Projected-Nadler, yielding CLS-completeness for Large-Margin-Triplet-FOSP. p. 0
Robust Convergence of Coordinate Descent
The authors study random-permutation cyclic coordinate descent on strongly convex quadratics and show that the full epoch correspondence contracts uniformly over all n! orderings in the energy norm induced by the objective's Hessian. This yields a pathwise convergence theorem that holds for deterministic, adaptive, randomized, or even adversarial sequences of epoch orderings alike. p. 4
Strong Converse to Nadler's Theorem
The authors prove a strong converse to Nadler’s theorem under robust global convergence conditions by constructing an equivalent complete metric that also transfers approximation guarantees back to the original metric. This construction involves a Lyapunov-type formulation and a geodesic distance derived from a rank function. p. 4
Metric Construction and Convergence Analysis
The proof of Theorem 4.3 details the construction of the equivalent metric D, which involves a Hausdorff-nonexpansive closure, a dynamical rank that increases under every admissible transition, and the geodesic distance of the resulting rank-weighted distance. p. 4 This construction ensures that approximation in the constructed metric still yields a quantitative guarantee under the original metric. p. 4
Complexity of Hölder-LocalOpt
The authors prove that the problem beta-Hölder-LocalOpt is CLS-complete for any fixed rational beta ∈ (0, 1]. This is done by reducing Continuous-LocalOpt to it and showing membership in CLS. p. 0
Hardness of Hölder-LocalOpt
The authors prove that the problem beta-Hölder-LocalOpt is CLS-hard for every fixed rational beta ∈ (0, 1]. This is achieved by reducing Continuous-LocalOpt to it and showing that any solution of the constructed instance can be decoded in polynomial time. p. 5
Completeness of the Metric Space
The authors prove that the constructed metric D generates the same topology as d and d, and (X, D) is compact and complete. This is shown by proving that every nonzero distance belongs to [1, 2]. p. 4
Robust Convergence Certificate
The authors show that the worst-order epoch factor ρ˜ is a sharp one-epoch Hausdorff contraction factor of the full correspondence under the energy metric. This factor yields the convergence estimate with factor ρ˜2t. p. 4 The result should be interpreted as a certificate for robust convergence (or as a topological perspective for the convergence) rather than as an improvement of the convergence rate for RPCD. p. 1
Sharp Dependence on the Hölder Exponent
The authors analyze how precision loss scales with beta, noting that natural instances force beta → 0, and they investigate if their polynomial dependence on 1∕beta is tight.
Set-Valued Equilibrium Computation
The paper discusses the computational status of best-response maps and quasi-variational inequalities with point-dependent feasible regions. It asks under what proximal or Tikhonov-type regularization a generalized Nash best-response correspondence becomes a genuine Hausdorff contraction. p. 1
Beyond Triplet Loss
The authors suggest that the reduction needs only two facts: large margin forces global smoothness, and one projected-gradient step supplies potential decrease. They note that quadruplet losses, margin-based pairwise ranking losses, and localized softmax contrastive losses share both these properties. p. 4
Sharper Dependence on the Hölder Exponent
The authors investigate how precision loss scales with beta, noting that natural instances force beta → 0, and they investigate if their polynomial dependence on 1∕beta is tight.
Polynomial-Time Circuit Construction
The authors detail the construction of the interpolation circuit, showing that it has a description and construction time polynomial in n, r, m, S. This proves the computational claim in part (i) and completes the construction. p. 5
Membership of Projected-Nadler
The authors show that Projected-Nadler admits a polynomial-time reduction to beta-Hölder-LocalOpt. This is done by defining the functions fH and pH based on the projection and residual. p. 3
CLS-Membership of Projected-Nadler
The authors prove that Projected-Nadler admits a polynomial-time reduction to beta-Hölder-LocalOpt. This is done by constructing an instance of beta-HölderLocalOpt from a well-formed instance of Projected-Nadler. p. 7
CLS-Hardness of Projected-Nadler
The authors prove that the problem beta-Projected-Nadler is CLS-hard for every fixed rational beta ∈ (0, 1]. This is done by reducing Continuous-LocalOpt to it and showing that any solution of the constructed instance can be decoded in polynomial time. p. 5
Final Complexity Result
The authors conclude that the problem beta-Projected-Nadler is CLS-complete for any fixed rational beta ∈ (0, 1]. This is established by combining the CLS-membership and CLS-hardness results. p. 0
The Large-Margin-Triplet-FOSP is CLS-complete. This is established by combining the CLS-membership of ProjectedNadler and the CLS-hardness of exact triplet-loss stationarity. p. 5
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Robust convergence analysis for set-valued algorithms can be performed by constructing an equivalent complete metric that contracts correspondences under a factor of c less than 1, even when the original Euclidean distance does not contract (Theorem 4.3). This allows AI systems using coordinate descent or alternating minimization to guarantee convergence across all possible sequences of choices, including adversarial ones.
-
Computational fixed-point problems for set-valued maps can be solved in polynomial time by formulating them as a problem called B ProjectNadler which is CLS complete (Theorem 3.1). This allows for the verification of complex iteration convergence properties within the complexity class CLS, providing a formal computational guarantee for algorithms involving best-response maps or feasible action maps.
-
Optimization problems related to large-margin triplet loss can be solved by reducing them to B ProjectNadler (Theorem 5.2 and Corollary 5.3). This enables AI systems dealing with contrastive learning objectives to find approximate first-order stationary points efficiently, as finding an approximate Nadler fixed point is necessarily finding an exact first-order stationary point under the large margin regime.
-
Convergence rates for adaptive algorithms can be certified by analyzing the energy metric induced by coordinate descent (Proposition B.2). This provides a pathwise convergence theorem that holds for every deterministic, adaptive, or even adversarial sequence of epoch orderings, offering a rigorous certificate of progress for stochastic optimization methods like random-permutation coordinate descent.
-
The relationship between approximate first-order stationary points and KKT points in quadratically formulated problems can be exploited to find solutions for quadratic programs using the projected gradient update (Lemma E.1). This allows AI systems to convert inexact FOSP certificates into exact KKT point certificates for optimization over box-constrained domains, ensuring high precision in constrained learning tasks.
Related papers
- The Proof Analysis Problem for Constant-Depth Frege
- Hardness of Counting Orderings: Taking Gadget Amplification to the Limit
- Rigorous Low-Degree Implications for Planted Subgraph Detection: Noise and Treewidth
- Parameterized Hardness of Zonotope Containment and Neural Network Verification
- From Block Orthogonality to Decidability in Complex-Weighted Counting CSP
- Random Clocks on Computation Paths: How Far Can They Reach, and When Does Stepping Back Help?