Comparison-Based Fair Division of Indivisible Chores
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.
Tom: I'm Tom.
Jane: And I'm Jane, here with Lu, Meng and our in-house large language model, Lalam.
Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Comparison-Based Fair Division of Indivisible Chores".
Paper summary: Tom: Okay so they start by looking at proportionality up to one item or PROP one, and they design an algorithm using something called a top trading envy graph that computes those allocations in O of n cubed log m comparison queries.
Jane: That’s a lot of queries for the proportional split, but then when the chores are arranged in a specific order and we need contiguous allocations, they can do it with O of n cubed log two m comparison queries.
Lu: The real focus, though, is on their main result concerning the maximin share or MMS guarantee, showing that for any fixed number of agents n and any constant epsilon greater than zero, a (thirteen over eleven plus epsilon) maximin share allocation can be computed with a query complexity logarithmic in m.
Meng: Logarithmic in m compared to O of n cubed log m for the proportional split sounds like a big win if that logarithmic dependence on the number of chores is what we need for scaling up.
Lalam: It’s about being able to compute this MMS allocation with comparison queries, which means we don't need those exact numbers from agents to get a nearly optimal fair share.
Tom: Exactly, and they achieve this by using a chore compression technique that shrinks the instance down to a bounded size meta instance where they can work on it.
Jane: So, even though you aren't seeing the actual costs, you reduce the problem size while keeping the benchmark for MMS distortion controlled at thirteen over eleven.
Lu: They also showed that for three agents specifically, they can compute EF one allocations using only O of log m comparison queries and this relies on combining a contiguous identical cost EF one partition with a staircase search.
Meng: Three agents getting logarithmic complexity is pretty impressive if we're talking about actual deployment scenarios where the number of people involved isn't fixed to just three.
Conclusion: Tom: So, looking at this paper "Comparison-Based Fair Division of Indivisible Chores," it really shows that you can get a very good approximation of fair division using only comparison access instead of needing exact cost information from the agents.
Jane: The core finding is that for a fixed number of agents, they found a way to compute a (thirteen over eleven plus epsilon) maximin share allocation with query complexity logarithmic in m, which is much better than the O of n cubed log m they used for the general proportional split.
Lu: It’s important because it proves that this logarithmic dependence on the number of chores is unavoidable for several standard fairness guarantees like PROP one, MMS, and EF one when you only have comparison access to the agents.
Meng: From a deployment standpoint, this means that if we're dealing with many chores but a relatively small team of agents, we might be able to approximate fairness without demanding perfect cost reporting from everyone.
Lalam: The paper also points out some limitations they found themselves; for instance, they showed that comparison queries are not enough on their own to implement PROP or PROP one oracles in the chores setting because the proportional threshold depends on a hidden value that comparisons can't reveal alone.
Tom: So, the implication is that while we can get close to fair division with these specific guarantees, you still need more than just pairwise comparisons if you want perfect results for things like PROP one.
Jane: It’s a practical result because it tells us exactly what kind of fairness guarantee you can actually achieve given the limitations of how agents communicate their preferences.
University of Macau Harbin Institute of Technology, Shenzhen · Shanghai Jiao Tong University Nanyang Technological University
cs.GT
Submitted: 2026-09-08
Updated: 2026-11-17
Comments: 46 pages and 4 figures. A preliminary version has been accepted to SODA 2027. This version improves the contiguous PROP1 query complexity to the optimal $O(\log m)$ for fixed $n$ and the MMS distortion lower bound to $31/30$
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 85/100
The gist: We investigate the query complexity of fairly allocating m indivisible chores among n agents with additive cost functions.
Key concepts
- Comparison Access
- This model restricts an algorithm to only asking which of two bundles is less costly, never seeing the actual numerical costs. This lack of numerical information severely limits standard algorithms that rely on sorting or direct computation of proportional shares, forcing the use of comparison-based techniques.
- MMS Guarantee
- The maximin share (MMS) guarantee means finding an allocation where every agent receives at least a certain fraction (the MMS value) of the total cost. The paper focuses on achieving a specific approximation of this guarantee, showing it can be done efficiently even with limited information access.
- Chore Compression
- This technique reduces the size of the problem instance by grouping or compressing chores into meta-chores. By reducing the number of items to consider while maintaining a controlled distortion in fairness guarantees, it allows algorithms to run in time that is logarithmic with respect to the total number of chores (m).
- PROP1 Allocation
- PROP1 refers to a specific type of fair allocation where agents receive bundles such that no agent's bundle is significantly worse than another's. The paper shows how these allocations can be computed in O(n^3 log m) comparisons, though for contiguous cases, the complexity improves slightly.
Terminology
Summary
We investigate the query complexity of fairly allocating m indivisible chores among n agents with additive cost functions. p. 0 Our main result concerns the maximin share (MMS) guarantee, showing that for any fixed number of agents n and constant ε > 0, a (13/11 + ε)-MMS allocation can be computed with a comparison complexity logarithmic in m. p. 0
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The paper investigates the query complexity of fairly allocating m indivisible chores among n agents with additive cost functions. The authors depart from the standard cardinal model and assume only comparison access, where an algorithm may ask an agent which of two bundles is less costly but never observes numerical costs. p. 0 This restriction rules out many standard algorithmic tools, such as direct computation of proportional shares or MMS values. p. 1 The challenge is to understand which fairness guarantees can still be achieved and with how many comparisons. p. 1
How the training signal is built
The authors present three main results concerning different fairness notions: PROP1, MMS, and EF1. For PROP1 allocations, they design an algorithm using a top-trading envy graph that computes them in O(n cubed log m) comparison queries. p. 6 They also show that contiguous PROP1 allocations can be computed using O(n cubed log2 m) comparison queries. p. 6 The MMS guarantee is addressed via a chore compression technique that reduces the instance to a bounded-size meta-instance, yielding a (13/11 + ε)-MMS allocation with query complexity logarithmic in m. p. 3 Finally, for three agents, they show that EF1 allocations can be computed using O(log m) comparison queries. p. 0
Where the gains come from
The complexity of computing PROP1 allocations is bounded by O(n cubed log m) comparisons. The contiguous variant achieves a better bound of O(n cubed log2 m) comparison queries. p. 0 For the MMS guarantee, the compression technique bypasses the need for sorting chores by reducing the instance size to f(n, ε) meta-chores. p. 3 The distortion of comparison access for MMS is shown to be at most 13/11, with a lower bound of 44/43 established via indistinguishable cardinal instances. p. 3 For EF1 in the three-agent setting, the O(log m) complexity relies on combining a contiguous identical-cost EF1 partition with a staircase search. p. 3
The paper demonstrates that for fixed n, logarithmic dependence on m is unavoidable for several standard fairness guarantees, including PROP1, MMS, and EF1. The lower bound for deterministic comparison-based algorithms guaranteeing a PROP1 allocation is shown to be Ω(log(m/n)) comparisons in the worst case. p. 4 A similar lower bound of Ω(log m) holds when n is constant. p. 2
The authors establish that for three agents, EF1 allocations can be computed using O(log m) queries. This result is achieved by identifying a transition point along a monotone staircase using O(log m) comparisons. p. 4 The construction of the witness EF1 partition itself requires O(log m) queries. p. 7
The authors show that a (13/11 + ε)-MMS allocation can be computed with query complexity logarithmic in m. This is achieved by using chore compression to reduce the instance size while preserving the MMS benchmark up to a controlled loss. p. 3 p. 3 The distortion of comparison access for MMS is bounded by 13/11, with a lower bound of 44/43 established via indistinguishable cardinal instances. p. 3 p. 3 The EF1 allocation for three agents is achieved using O(log m) comparisons. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0
The paper establishes that comparison queries are insufficient to implement PROP, PROP1, or PROP1-nonPROP oracles in the chores setting. A common comparison lower bound shows that any deterministic algorithm guaranteeing a PROP1 allocation requires Ω(log(m/n)) comparisons in the worst case. p. 4
The authors provide a counterexample showing that comparison queries are insufficient to implement PROP, PROP1, or PROP1-nonPROP oracles in the chores setting. This example shows that for identical additive costs, the proportional threshold depends on a hidden value x, which cannot be determined by comparisons alone. p. 2
The authors provide a lower bound of 44/43 for the MMS distortion using an indistinguishability construction involving two boundary cost profiles. This lower bound is established by showing that every allocation is 44/43-MMS for at least one of the two boundary profiles. p. 5 p. 5 The EF1 allocation for three agents is achieved using O(log m) queries. p. 0
The paper shows that the residual algorithm faces an intrinsic barrier of 2n/(n + 2), even with access to cardinal information. This barrier prevents the residual Hall approach from guaranteeing an α-MMS allocation when n is constant.
The authors prove that a three-partition (X1, X2, X3) can be computed using O(log m) queries. This is achieved by adapting the MinBundleKept and moving-knife framework to obtain the witness EF1 guarantee needed for chores. p. 5 The query complexity of this construction is O(log m). p. 4
The paper provides a lower bound of 44/43 for the MMS distortion using an indistinguishability construction involving two boundary cost profiles. This lower bound is established by showing that every allocation is 44/43-MMS for at least one of the two boundary profiles. The EF1 allocation for three agents is achieved using O(log m) comparisons.
The authors show that a (13/11 + ε)-MMS allocation can be computed with query complexity logarithmic in m. This is achieved by using chore compression to reduce the instance size while preserving the MMS benchmark up to a controlled loss. The distortion of comparison access for MMS is bounded by 13/11, with a lower bound of 44/43 established via indistinguishable cardinal instances. The EF1 allocation for three agents is achieved using O(log m) comparisons.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved algorithms for fair division of indivisible chores can compute Proportionality up to one item (PROP1) allocations using O(n 3 log m) comparison queries, which is a significant improvement over linear or higher dependence on m.
-
A compression framework can be used to compute approximate maximin share (MMS) allocations with a guaranteed loss of at most 13/11, achieving this in query complexity logarithmic in m rather than requiring full cardinal access and potentially exponential queries.
-
For three agents, an envy-free up to one item (EF1) allocation can be computed using only O(log m) comparison queries by combining a contiguous identical-cost EF1 partition with a staircase search, providing a highly efficient solution for small agent counts.
-
The distortion of the comparison model for MMS is bounded by 13/11, which provides a tighter theoretical understanding of the performance gap when moving from cardinal utilities to ordinal rankings compared to previous bounds.
-
A lower bound construction shows that any deterministic comparison-based algorithm guaranteed to compute PROP1, EF1, or an alpha-MMS allocation for a fixed nontrivial approximation factor 1 less than n requires at least log m comparisons in the worst case.
Sources
Related papers
- How Many Votes is a Lie Worth? Measuring Strategyproofness through Resource Augmentation
- Effective Horizons for Prophet Inequalities with Discounted I.I.D. Rewards
- Truthful-in-Expectation Mechanism with Constant Maximin-Share Guarantee
- The Power of Recruiting the Smaller Side: Two Additional Traders Suffice in Two-Sided Markets
- From signaling to interviews in random matching markets
- Optimizing Social Utility in Sequential Experiments