New rules, old habits: across seven team sports, each league keeps its own way of using the rules

arXiv:2609.05584 · physics.soc-ph, stat.AP · Submitted 2026-09-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "New rules, old habits".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Every team sport that lets a team replace players rations the replacements, and the ration settles who plays and for how long Every code that lets a team replace players writes a budget into its rulebook: how many may come on, whether anyone may come back, and how many are on the field to begin with The answer can be said before any number Rules fixed = 0 still water.

Kai: (6) The Core Equation and Its Components Every law in this paper is a term of one equation or a relation that closes it The equation is written the way the Navier–Stokes equation is written: one line whose terms are named, the conditions that close it beneath, and each term then read on its own The continuity condition is the budget identity, ρ = uB/N, which holds in every one-way code with short substitution chains and marks its own boundary in baseball The left-hand side and its three terms are exact: the level law and the decomposition hold to machine precision on every raw panel Allocation of Playing Time The allocation equation obeys one equation The continuity condition is the budget identity, ρ = uB/N, which holds in every one-way code with short substitution chains and marks its own boundary in baseball The pooled workload gradient decomposes exactly into behaviour within roles and the composition of roles, composition carrying most of it, while a player’s own minutes barely track their own load The sorting term carries the larger share in nine of ten panels Scarcity and Freedom Effects Under scarcity every league behaves alike, and freedom lets them differ Under three substitutions the retention coefficient is one constant across fifteen cells on four continents (θ = −0.35) Under five substitutions the retention coefficient is no longer one constant and both the mean clause and the timing cell fail one raw (p = 0.0030 and 0.0011) until the pricing law is subtracted What a league expresses under freedom is a persistent trait: the era’s opening utilisation ordering predicts its latest across twelve leagues (Spearman +0.73) The Role of Culture and Norms The culture term is a measured trait, not a residual named after the fact: a league’s place in the utilisation ordering at the start of the fivesubstitution era predicts its place at the end across the twelve European leagues The temperament is a league culture in the plain sense: the norms of the competition, carried by every club regardless of its resources The Ledger and Its Tiers The ledger’s statuses are law, strained, exception, explained and unlawed The tier formula keeps the paper honest about which of its claims are which One Tier 1 claim is the pricing law Open Problems and Future Directions The two quantities that remain without a rule share one structure The gradient’s response to a rule change is the purest absence: seven AFL rule levels, four codes and every candidate model dead by pre-specified test The rotational recount is a complete census with no law The culture part is each competition’s own and persists across regimes Data Sources and Methodology Every panel is built from public match records All sources are public and free to read, none required a licence or a fee, and no third party processed anything on the authors’ behalf The analysis is Python 3.12.10 with pandas 2.3.3, NumPy 2.3.5, SciPy 1.16.3 and statsmodels 0.14.5 The paper shows three things about the people who spend the ration First, the allocation of playing time in eight team sports obeys one equation Second, scarcity makes leagues alike and freedom lets them differ Third, what a league expresses under freedom is a persistent trait The rulebook part is universal and, where it is arithmetic, exact: the identity and its re-entry form The culture part is each competition’s own and persists across regimes The speed limit was the rulebook’s; what the road carries is the habitual speed of the people who drive it, which sits a little below the limit, differs country to country Table 1: The Ledger Table 1 carries sixteen laws, two explained exceptions and the two rows where two quantities still have no rule RS-1 budget identity withdrawal rate, one-way codes association football; rugby union; Gaelic football; hurling law RS-2 domain law who finishes a match one-way football against capped Australian rules, seventeen to sixty times apart on the share of appearances; rugby league under eight interchanges finishes like a one-way code, so the general form is withdrawn association football; Australian rules law RS-15 exposure identity exposure identity, re-entry codes a team-game’s exposure sums to field × length, the NHL’s penalty-dented vessel included five rotational codes law RS-3 retention constant who comes off, three subs one retention constant θ per full match of prior play association football law RS-4 preference principle who comes off, five subs the same constant, broken: the break is the preference association football explained RS-11 sorting reduction the sorting slope reduces to θ through the hazard geometry with one attenuation constant, fifteen panels association football law RS-5a mean clause, cell form when they come off, three subs one product constant per cell association football law continued overleaf RS-6 pricing law positive departures, men g = C/ρ + λ(P − P¯): the five-substitute departure is priced near one-for-one by the league’s workload-pricing coefficient association football law RS-7 women’s constant positive departures, women one constant per full match across seven leagues; what sets it is not claimed association football law RS-12 necessity constant necessity constant C5 = rf5 κ5, both parts measured across seven reason-complete league-seasons association football law RS-8 gradient decomposition gradient, pooled γpooled = γ∗+ composition (exact) association football; rugby union law RS-9 two-term band gradient, within-role one band at steady rules across three codes association football; rugby union; Australian rules law RS-10 level law gradient, within-role level γ∗ = −slope of (withdrawal × log cost); sorting + timing, gaps under 8 per cent association football; rugby union law RS-13 still-water law gradient in still water one level while the rulebook holds still, across fifteen rule-still seasons; what sets the level is not claimed rugby union law RS-14 eighty-minute clause timing clause, 80-minute codes one timing-gap constant across nine sound cells and three league systems rugby union law RS-16 utilisation law utilisation’s level u5 = (f + d)/5: f universal, d one constant per league, rank-stable across seasons; what sets a league’s d is not claimed association football law — (unlawed) gradient under rule change no form for γ(rules): seven AFL rule levels measured and every model — level, direction, change — refused by pre-specified test Australian rules; rugby league; rugby union unlawed rotational budgets ρ recounted in rotations per named player: a 41-fold family range with no ordering rule five rotational codes unlawed Extended Data Table 4 Extended Data Table 4 carries every constant, with its uncertainty and its test The interval column names what produced the interval, so a spread across cells is never mistaken for a standard error; a row reading at the raw cells’ weights pools cells whose point estimate is adjusted but whose weights are the raw cells’ own, and is named so that it is not read as the same pooling as the rows above it Extended Data Fig.

Mira: 1 Extended Data Fig.

Kai: 1 shows continuity in the re-entry codes The AFL and the AFLW sit two to three orders of magnitude inside it, the NRL one, and the NHL closest to it at 0.984 of six sixties, the shortfall its own penalty time Extended Data Fig.

Paper summary: Kai: To recap what we've seen so far, this paper "New rules, old habits: across seven team sports, each league keeps its own way of using the rules" is proposing one core equation for playing time allocation in competitive team sports >

Mira: The thesis is that this equation separates the arithmetic fixed by the rulebook from the choices made by each specific competition >

Kai: It claims that under scarcity, every league behaves similarly because they are all kept on at the same rate on four continents, and under freedom, they start to express preferences >

Lev: I'm interested in the specifics of that budget identity ρ equals uB over N; how does it scale when we look at real-world scheduling constraints for something like a video game server or a complex simulation >

Kai: The continuity condition is the budget identity, and this holds in every one-way code with short substitution chains, marking its boundary in baseball >

Mira: And the pooled workload gradient decomposes into behavior within roles and the composition of those roles, emphasizing composition over individual minutes >

Lev: So when you're trying to build an error-correction scheme for this, do you think focusing on that role decomposition is more efficient than tracking every single player minute >

Kai: The paper states that the measured sorting slope reduces to a hazard geometry with one attenuation constant of zero point eight one >

Mira: And the sorting term in the equation also includes a term for who is kept on plus a minus rho times the change in mean log cost over time, plus rho times g times composition >

Lev: That decomposition sounds like something you could try to model with dynamic programming, but I need to know if that works for all eight codes they measure >

Kai: The paper also details how the withdrawal rate is the budget’s arithmetic times the fraction of it a league habitually spends, which is a universal forced demand plus an increment that is each league’s own >

Mira: And that increment, which represents what each league habitually spends, is what makes them different under freedom >

Lev: If we're talking about building real hardware for this, the uncertainty around that fraction spent sounds like it could introduce significant noise into your prediction of when a change will happen >

Kai: The paper shows that rule changes move the workload gradient through a splash and then back to a level where the code holds while its rules hold still >

Mira: It’s about how those rules, which are the geometry of the competition, interact with that persistent habit of spending that fraction >

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at this paper, "New rules, old habits: across seven team sports, each league keeps its own way of using the rules," it seems to be saying that there's a deep structure here between the universal arithmetic and the specific habits of each sport >

Mira: The authors are essentially arguing that the rulebook provides the fixed framework, but what truly dictates performance and outcome is how each league chooses to use that framework based on its culture >

Lev: From my side, it suggests that for any real-world system you try to model, you can’t just rely on a single universal model; you need to account for those specific cultural biases or habits when predicting long-term behavior >

Kai: The implication is that the budgeting and allocation aren't just about numbers; they are about how a culture settles into those rules over time >

Mira: The paper emphasizes that the culture part is measured, not just something you name after the fact; it’s about where a league starts in its utilization ordering predicting where it ends across different eras >

Lev: If we're building this for actual hardware, it means your initial calibration needs to be sensitive to those structural differences between leagues rather than assuming uniformity from the start >

Kai: The rulebook part is universal and arithmetic, but the culture part is unique to each competition and persists across regimes >

Mira: So what we're left with is that you can predict the budget arithmetic precisely, but predicting the long-term cultural trajectory requires knowing that specific league’s history >

physics.soc-ph, stat.AP

Submitted: 2026-09-04

Updated: 2026-11-15

Comments: 22 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables; 80-page supplement included as an ancillary file. Replication record (manuscript, pipeline, tests and derived tables as one object): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24261327

Code: https://github.com/Gustolandia/team-sport-allocationlaw

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Every team sport that lets a team replace players rations the replacements, and the ration settles who plays and for how long Every code that lets a team replace players writes a budget into its…

Key concepts

Continuity Condition (Budget Identity)
This mathematical identity ($ ho = uB/N$) acts as a budget constraint in one-way codes like baseball. It defines the fundamental relationship between the number of players, their usage, and the total workload, setting a boundary for how many players can be on the field.
Culture Term
This measures a league's inherent norms and temperament—the unwritten rules carried by every club. This trait is not just a leftover from past events but predicts where a league will sit in utilization rankings across different eras, showing its persistent influence.
Tier Formula
This formula organizes the paper's claims into tiers, with Tier 1 being the pricing law. It serves to distinguish which rules are considered universal arithmetic identities versus specific, explained exceptions or laws that require separate consideration.

Terminology

Summary

Every team sport that lets a team replace players rations the replacements, and the ration settles who plays and for how long Every code that lets a team replace players writes a budget into its rulebook: how many may come on, whether anyone may come back, and how many are on the field to begin with The answer can be said before any number Rules fixed = 0 still water. p. 0 (6)

The Core Equation and Its Components

Every law in this paper is a term of one equation or a relation that closes it The equation is written the way the Navier–Stokes equation is written: one line whose terms are named, the conditions that close it beneath, and each term then read on its own The continuity condition is the budget identity, ρ = uB/N, which holds in every one-way code with short substitution chains and marks its own boundary in baseball The left-hand side and its three terms are exact: the level law and the decomposition hold to machine precision on every raw panel

Allocation of Playing Time

The allocation equation obeys one equation The continuity condition is the budget identity, ρ = uB/N, which holds in every one-way code with short substitution chains and marks its own boundary in baseball The pooled workload gradient decomposes exactly into behaviour within roles and the composition of roles, composition carrying most of it, while a player’s own minutes barely track their own load The sorting term carries the larger share in nine of ten panels

Scarcity and Freedom Effects

Under scarcity every league behaves alike, and freedom lets them differ Under three substitutions the retention coefficient is one constant across fifteen cells on four continents (θ = −0.35) Under five substitutions the retention coefficient is no longer one constant and both the mean clause and the timing cell fail one raw (p = 0. p. 10030 and 0. p. 10011) until the pricing law is subtracted What a league expresses under freedom is a persistent trait: the era’s opening utilisation ordering predicts its latest across twelve leagues (Spearman +0. p. 173)

The Role of Culture and Norms

The culture term is a measured trait, not a residual named after the fact: a league’s place in the utilisation ordering at the start of the fivesubstitution era predicts its place at the end across the twelve European leagues The temperament is a league culture in the plain sense: the norms of the competition, carried by every club regardless of its resources

The Ledger and Its Tiers

The ledger’s statuses are law, strained, exception, explained and unlawed The tier formula keeps the paper honest about which of its claims are which One Tier 1 claim is the pricing law

Open Problems and Future Directions

The two quantities that remain without a rule share one structure The gradient’s response to a rule change is the purest absence: seven AFL rule levels, four codes and every candidate model dead by pre-specified test The rotational recount is a complete census with no law The culture part is each competition’s own and persists across regimes

Data Sources and Methodology

Every panel is built from public match records All sources are public and free to read, none required a licence or a fee, and no third party processed anything on the authors’ behalf The analysis is Python 3.12.10 with pandas 2. p. 93.3, NumPy 2. p. 93.5, SciPy 1. p. 916.3 and statsmodels 0. p. 914.5

Summary of Findings

The paper shows three things about the people who spend the ration First, the allocation of playing time in eight team sports obeys one equation Second, scarcity makes leagues alike and freedom lets them differ Third, what a league expresses under freedom is a persistent trait The rulebook part is universal and, where it is arithmetic, exact: the identity and its re-entry form The culture part is each competition’s own and persists across regimes The speed limit was the rulebook’s; what the road carries is the habitual speed of the people who drive it, which sits a little below the limit, differs country to country

Table 1: The Ledger

Table 1 carries sixteen laws, two explained exceptions and the two rows where two quantities still have no rule RS-1 budget identity withdrawal rate, one-way codes association football; rugby union; Gaelic football; hurling law RS-2 domain law who finishes a match one-way football against capped Australian rules, seventeen to sixty times apart on the share of appearances; rugby league under eight interchanges finishes like a one-way code, so the general form is withdrawn association football; Australian rules law RS-15 exposure identity exposure identity, re-entry codes a team-game’s exposure sums to field × length, the NHL’s penalty-dented vessel included five rotational codes law RS-3 retention constant who comes off, three subs one retention constant θ per full match of prior play association football law RS-4 preference principle who comes off, five subs the same constant, broken: the break is the preference association football explained RS-11 sorting reduction the sorting slope reduces to θ through the hazard geometry with one attenuation constant, fifteen panels association football law RS-5a mean clause, cell form when they come off, three subs one product constant per cell association football law continued overleaf RS-6 pricing law positive departures, men g = C/ρ + λ(P − P¯): the five-substitute departure is priced near one-for-one by the league’s workload-pricing coefficient association football law RS-7 women’s constant positive departures, women one constant per full match across seven leagues; what sets it is not claimed association football law RS-12 necessity constant necessity constant C5 = rf5 κ5, both parts measured across seven reason-complete league-seasons association football law RS-8 gradient decomposition gradient, pooled γpooled = γ∗+ composition (exact) association football; rugby union law RS-9 two-term band gradient, within-role one band at steady rules across three codes association football; rugby union; Australian rules law RS-10 level law gradient, within-role level γ∗ = −slope of (withdrawal × log cost); sorting + timing, gaps under 8 per cent association football; rugby union law RS-13 still-water law gradient in still water one level while the rulebook holds still, across fifteen rule-still seasons; what sets the level is not claimed rugby union law RS-14 eighty-minute clause timing clause, 80-minute codes one timing-gap constant across nine sound cells and three league systems rugby union law RS-16 utilisation law utilisation’s level u5 = (f + d)/5: f universal, d one constant per league, rank-stable across seasons; what sets a league’s d is not claimed association football law — (unlawed) gradient under rule change no form for γ(rules): seven AFL rule levels measured and every model — level, direction, change — refused by pre-specified test Australian rules; rugby league; rugby union unlawed rotational budgets ρ recounted in rotations per named player: a 41-fold family range with no ordering rule five rotational codes unlawed

Extended Data Table 4

Extended Data Table 4 carries every constant, with its uncertainty and its test The interval column names what produced the interval, so a spread across cells is never mistaken for a standard error; a row reading at the raw cells’ weights pools cells whose point estimate is adjusted but whose weights are the raw cells’ own, and is named so that it is not read as the same pooling as the rows above it

Extended Data Fig. 1

Extended Data Fig. 1 shows continuity in the re-entry codes The AFL and the AFLW sit two to three orders of magnitude inside it, the NRL one, and the NHL closest to it at 0. p. 3984 of six sixties, the shortfall its own penalty time

Extended Data Fig. 2

Extended Data Fig. 2 shows scarcity and freedom Under three substitutions one constant is not rejected (Cochran’s Q(14) = 17. p. 18, p = 0.22, two-sided) Under five it is (Q(14) = 56. p. 90; p = 6 × 10−7)

Extended Data Fig. 3

Extended Data Fig. 3 shows the composition term at the level of players The shaded band is the within-player range [−0. p. 3011, +0.016] that the pre-specified clause demanded, and every breach of the within-role band sits in the composition rather than in the players

Extended Data Fig. 4

Extended Data Fig. 4 shows still water is the code’s, and the level is each division’s own The Pro D2’s +0. p. 5057 does not transfer from the Top 14’s +0. p. 5046

Extended Data Fig. 5

Extended Data Fig. 5 shows the French experiment left no signature Three clauses were pre-specified before the counts were read: no team-match records a ninth replacement (none does), the change count takes no step at the dispensation (it does not: z = 0. p. 58 and 1.0 on a trend fitted with inverse-variance weights, two-sided p = 0. p. 942 and 0.30), and the excess of starters withdrawn over replacements used rises by less than 0. p. 445 changes per team-match (it rises by at most 0. p. 002)

Discussion

The laws of the substitution budget are one equation and its closures, and every constant in it divides the same way The rulebook part is universal and, where it is arithmetic, exact: the identity and its re-entry form The culture part is each competition’s own and persists across regimes The speed limit was the rulebook’s; what the road carries is the habitual speed of the people who drive it, which sits a little below the limit, differs country to country The culture term is a measured trait, not a residual named after the fact: a league’s place in the utilisation ordering at the start of the fivesubstitution era predicts its place at the end across the twelve European leagues The reading that survives is the plain one: the norms of a competition are carried by every club in it, whatever it can afford The tier formula keeps the paper honest about which of its claims are which The one Tier 1 claim is the pricing law

Open Problems

The two quantities that remain without a rule share one structure The gradient’s response to a rule change is the purest absence: seven AFL rule levels, four codes and every candidate model dead by pre-specified test The rotational recount is a complete census with no law The culture part is each competition’s own and persists across regimes The boundary — the gradient responds to rules only where the minutes ledger prices rotation

Conclusion

The equation separates, term by term, what can be moved from what a league has learned to do with its rules The budget arithmetic is forecastable and the identity sizes it: a sixth substitution would raise the withdrawal rate from 0.388 to 0.465 of a league’s starters while its utilisation held, and say nothing about which The rest is the league’s — a first-season splash that settles within three seasons, an allowance a league does not use, and a settled displacement nobody can yet predict The rulebook part is universal and, where it is arithmetic, exact: the identity and its re-entry form The culture part is each competition’s own and persists across regimes

Table 1: The Ledger (Continued)

RS-1 budget identity withdrawal rate, one-way codes association football; rugby union; Gaelic football; hurling law RS-2 domain law who finishes a match one-way football against capped Australian rules, seventeen to sixty times apart on the share of appearances; rugby league under eight interchanges finishes like a one-way code, so the general form is withdrawn association football; Australian rules law RS-15 exposure identity exposure identity, re-entry codes a team-game’s exposure sums to field × length, the NHL’s penalty-dented vessel included five rotational codes law RS-3 retention constant who comes off, three subs one retention constant θ per full match of prior play association football law RS-4 preference principle who comes off, five subs the same constant, broken: the break is the preference association football explained RS-11 sorting reduction the sorting slope reduces to θ through the hazard geometry with one attenuation constant, fifteen panels association football law RS-5a mean clause, cell form when they come off, three subs one product constant per cell association football law continued overleaf RS-6 pricing law positive departures, men g = C/ρ + λ(P − P¯): the five-substitute departure is priced near one-for-one by the league’s workload-pricing coefficient association football law RS-6b pricing law, its shadow when they come off, five subs the raw five-substitution cell, restored by the pricing law association football explained RS-7 women’s constant positive departures, women one constant per full match across seven leagues; what sets it is not claimed association football law RS-12 necessity constant necessity constant C5 = rf5 κ5, both parts measured across seven reason-complete league-seasons association football law RS-8 gradient decomposition gradient, pooled γpooled = γ∗+ composition (exact) association football; rugby union law RS-9 two-term band gradient, within-role one band at steady rules across three codes association football; rugby union; Australian rules law RS-10 level law gradient, within-role level γ∗ = −slope of (withdrawal × log cost); sorting + timing, gaps under 8 per cent association football; rugby union law RS-13 still-water law gradient in still water one level while the rulebook holds still, across fifteen rule-still seasons; what sets the level is not claimed rugby union law RS-14 eighty-minute clause timing clause, 80-minute codes one timing-gap constant across nine sound cells and three league systems rugby union law RS-16 utilisation law utilisation’s level u5 = (f + d)/5: f universal, d one constant per league, rank-stable across seasons; what sets a league’s d is not claimed association football law — (unlawed) gradient under rule change no form for γ(rules): seven AFL rule levels measured and every model — level, direction, change — refused by pre-specified test Australian rules; rugby league; rugby union unlawed rotational budgets ρ recounted in rotations per named player: a 41-fold family range with no ordering rule five rotational codes unlawed

Extended Data Table 3

Extended Data Table 3 carries every panel, its size and its provider All sources are public and free to access; nothing deposited names a player

**Extended Data Fig.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved understanding of allocation dynamics by modeling playing time as an equation where the rulebook sets the arithmetic and the league sets the habit. This allows AI systems to predict how a change in a rulebook (a dose) moves the workload gradient through a splash and then, where the record is long enough to see it, back to a level the code holds while its rules hold still.

  2. Enhanced competitive strategy modeling by incorporating cultural persistence into predictions. The system can use the finding that what a league expresses under freedom is a persistent trait, meaning the era’s opening utilisation ordering predicts its latest across twelve leagues (Spearman +0.73), allowing AI to predict long-term league performance based on initial conditions rather than just current metrics.

  3. Better prediction of rule change impact by separating rulebook effects from competition effects. The system can forecast that the gradient’s response to a rule change is the purest absence, specifically noting that every candidate form for the gradient’s response — level, direction, change — died by pre-specified test. This prevents over-fitting to hypothetical responses and focuses on what the record does say rather than what a model assumes.

  4. More robust analysis of league behavior under scarcity versus freedom. The system can distinguish between conditions where scarcity makes leagues alike (like the retention coefficient being one constant across fifteen cells) and freedom where leagues differ, enabling better forecasting of competitive outcomes based on whether the environment is constrained or expressive.

Sources

Related papers