Addendum: Production of pi+ pi- pairs in diffractive photon-proton and in proton-proton collisions revisited, in particular concerning the Drell-S"oding contribution

arXiv:2609.01285 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-09-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Addendum: Production of pi+ pi- pairs in diffractive photon-proton and in proton-proton collisions revisited, in particular concerning the Drell-S"oding contribution".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We update our analyses concerning the non-resonant (Drell-Söding) contribution to the reaction γ(∗)p → π+π− p, now including general vertex functions for the coupling of pomeron, f2R, and ρR, to pions <ref:2609.01285#pg2> This takes into account the off-shellness of the pions <ref:2609.01285#pg4> We present a comparison of our tensor-pomeron model, including our new Drell-Söding and ρ, ω vector-meson contributions, with data for the γp → π+π− p reaction measured by the ZEUS and H1 Collaborations <ref:2609.01285#pg5> We find very good agreement of our theory with the experimental data for the π+π− invariant mass (Mππ) and for angular distributions <ref:2609.01285#pg5>.

Kai: Updated Drell-Söding Amplitudes The authors generalize their model by allowing for off-shell effects in the Pππ, f2Rππ, and ρRπpp vertices <ref:2609.01285#pg4> They start with the Pππ vertex by replacing the form factor FM

(˜k′ − ˜k)2: with F

(˜k′ − ˜k)2, ˜k'2 − m2π, ˜k2 − m2π: <ref:2609.01285#pg5>.

Mira: This leads to new amplitudes denoted by N(a,b), N(a), and N(0,b) <ref:2609.01285#pg5>.

Kai: The gauge-invariance relation (2.11) of

1: is used to calculate the expression for the diagram of figure 1(c) <ref:2609.01285#pg5>.

Title and authors: Kai: Let's talk about who wrote this, so it's Piotr Lebiedowicz, Otto Nachtmann, and Antoni Szczurek from the Institute of Nuclear Physics at the Polish Academy of Sciences in Kraków. They’re deep in the nuclear physics side.

Mira: And they are continuing work on this reaction after previous studies, building on what was done before with reference to paper <ref:2609.01285#pg1> and page two which set up the initial QFT treatment of that non-resonant term.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it means they are refining the theoretical inputs for this process so that if we build a detector later, we have the right parameters to test against.

Kai: The title itself tells us they are revisiting this reaction in diffractive photon-proton and proton-proton collisions, focusing on that Drell-Söding contribution.

Mira: It’s not just a simple look back; they are actively updating the model by incorporating new physics into the vertices involving the pomeron, f2R, and rhoR couplings to pions.

Lev: What's interesting is that they are specifically looking at how these new vertex functions affect the amplitudes of figure one(a) and one(b), which are crucial for their calculation in section two <ref:2609.01285#pg1>.

Kai: So the core idea is that by allowing off-shell effects, they generate new amplitudes denoted as N of a, b, and zero b, which they then use to calculate things like diagram one three.

The paper's summary: Kai: So in terms of what the paper summarizes, they are presenting a comparison of their updated tensor-pomeron model against real data from the ZEUS and H1 Collaborations.

Mira: They are using this model, which now has those new Drell-Söding and vector meson contributions, to test its accuracy for the pi plus pi minus invariant mass M pi pi distribution.

Lev: The summary points out that they find very good agreement between their theory and the experimental data for M pi pi up to around one point two giga electron volts.

Kai: They also mention that the model's results show a skewing in the M pi pi distribution, and this skewing gets smaller as you increase the value of t, which is related to momentum transfer squared.

Mira: That finding about the skewing shape is important because it addresses a puzzle regarding how these distributions look when you compare photoproduction to electron plus positron annihilation results.

Lev: So they’re showing that even with these new complex off-shell effects included, the overall shape of the data still aligns quite well with their prediction for the tensor-pomeron model.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Now let's talk about the improvements they suggest. They generalize their model by allowing off-shell effects in three key vertices: P pi pi, f2R pi pi, and rhoR pi pp.

Mira: That means they are replacing a simple form factor with something more complex for the P plus pion pair vertex, specifically using F of the difference of momenta squared and mass squared terms.

Lev: This change is significant because it directly affects how the amplitudes N of a, b, and zero b are calculated in section two. It moves them away from a simpler approximation to something more physically realistic regarding pion interactions.

Kai: And they use gauge-invariance constraints to figure out the expression for diagram one three using these new off-shell vertex functions.

Mira: That specific calculation allows them to derive the simplest solution for N of c mu s prime s prime by referencing equation two point sixteen, which is a very specific result derived from those constraints.

Lev: If you were building this on real hardware, incorporating these kinds of vertex functions means you need more complex matrix elements to calculate the scattering amplitudes, increasing the computational overhead significantly.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper is essentially showing how updating the Drell-Söding amplitudes with off-shell pion effects leads to a tensor-pomeron model that matches ZEUS and H1 data well for the invariant mass distributions.

Mira: They confirm that their new contributions, including the rho and omega vector mesons, fit the experimental data for M pi pi up to one point two giga electron volts in a satisfactory way.

Lev: From an execution standpoint, this means their model is robust enough that it should be a good starting point for interpreting future data from ultraperipheral collisions at the LHC or future electron proton ion colliders.

Kai: It’s interesting that they also compared their results to Pumplin's ansatz, and they found that when you include those non-trivial off-shell pion effects, their results diverge quite a bit from Pumplin’s high-energy limit approximation.

Mira: That comparison is important because it proves that the high-energy approximations used in previous analyses aren't sufficient when you introduce these kinds of detailed off-shell corrections.

Lev: So they're essentially showing where the limitations are—the model works well up to a certain energy scale, and beyond that, those off-shell effects become unavoidable and change the picture significantly.

Kai: That’s it for this paper on the Addendum: Production of pi+ pi- pairs in diffractive photon-proton and in proton-proton collisions revisited, in particular concerning the Drell-Söding contribution.

Piotr Lebiedowicz, Otto Nachtmann, Antoni Szczurek

Institute of Nuclear Physics Polish Academy of Sciences · Institut für Theoretische Physik, University Heidelberg · Institute of Physics, Faculty of Exact and Technical Sciences, University of Rzeszś

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-09-01

Updated: 2026-10-30

Comments: 16 pages, 7 figures, Addendum to JHEP 06 (2026) 015 (arXiv:2508.06334v2 [hep-ph])

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: We update our analyses concerning the non-resonant (Drell-Söding) contribution to the reaction γ(∗)p → π+π− p, now including general vertex functions for the coupling of pomeron, f2R…

Key concepts

Drell-Söding contribution
This refers to a non-resonant mechanism in the reaction where the photon interacts with the proton, leading to pion pair production. The paper updates how this term is calculated by allowing for off-shell effects in the relevant vertices, providing a more realistic description of this process.
Tensor-pomeron model
This is a theoretical framework used to describe the reaction dynamics. It combines contributions from both resonant (like rho and omega mesons) and non-resonant (Drell-Söding) mechanisms to explain the observed production of pion pairs in photon-proton collisions.
Off-shell effects
In particle physics, 'off-shell' means that a particle is not at its mass shell, meaning its energy and momentum do not satisfy the standard relativistic energy-momentum relation. Including these effects makes the theoretical calculations more accurate by accounting for how particles behave when they are not strictly on their expected mass lines.
Pumplin's ansatz
This is an alternative theoretical approach used to compare results, specifically concerning the Drell-Söding term for real photons. The paper shows that while this ansatz works well in the high-energy limit with simple form factors, it differs significantly when off-shell pion effects are properly included.

Terminology

Summary

We update our analyses concerning the non-resonant (Drell-Söding) contribution to the reaction γ(∗)p → π+π− p, now including general vertex functions for the coupling of pomeron, f2R, and ρR, to pions <ref:2609. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Szczurek@ifj. pl ABSTRACT: We update our analyses concerning the non-resonant (Drell-Söding) contribution to the reaction γ (∗)p → π +π − p, now including general vertex functions for the coupling of pomeron, f2R, and ρR, to pions.

01285#pg2> This takes into account the off-shellness of the pions <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl ABSTRACT: We update our analyses concerning the non-resonant (Drell-Söding) contribution to the reaction γ (∗)p → π +π − p, now including general vertex functions for the coupling of pomeron, f2R, and ρR, to pions. This takes into account the off-shellness of the pions.

01285#pg4> We present a comparison of our tensor-pomeron model, including our new Drell-Söding and ρ, ω vector-meson contributions, with data for the γp → π+π− p reaction measured by the ZEUS and H1 Collaborations <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This takes into account the off-shellness of the pions. We present a comparison of our tensor-pomeron model, including our new Drell-Söding and ρ, ω vector-meson contributions, with data for the γp → π +π − p reaction measured by the ZEUS and H1 Collaborations.

01285#pg5> We find very good agreement of our theory with the experimental data for the π+π− invariant mass (Mππ) and for angular distributions <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We present a comparison of our tensor-pomeron model, including our new Drell-Söding and ρ, ω vector-meson contributions, with data for the γp → π +π − p reaction measured by the ZEUS and H1 Collaborations. We find very good agreement of our theory with the experimental data for the π +π − invariant mass (Mππ) and for angular distributions.

01285#pg5>.

Updated Drell-Söding Amplitudes

The authors generalize their model by allowing for off-shell effects in the Pππ, f2Rππ, and ρRπpp vertices <ref:2609.01285#pg4> They start with the Pππ vertex by replacing the form factor FM[(˜k′ − ˜k)2] with F[(˜k′ − ˜k)2, ˜k'2 − m2π, ˜k2 − m2π] <ref:2609.01285#pg5>. This leads to new amplitudes denoted by N(a,b), N(a), and N(0,b) <ref:2609. p. 3

Where the paper says it

52) of [1], by F(. In this way we get new amplitudes denoted by N (a,b) µ,s ′ ,s as follows.

01285#pg5>. The gauge-invariance relation (2. p. 3
Where the paper says it

the corresponding new amplitudes which take into account the generalized form factors in the Pππ, f2Rππ, and ρRππ vertices. The gauge-invariance relation (2.

11) of [1] is used to calculate the expression for the diagram of figure 1(c) <ref:2609. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In the present paper we generalize our model by allowing for off-shell effects in the Pππ, f2Rππ, and ρRππ vertices occurring in figures 1(a) and 1(b). As we did in [1] we shall then use the gauge-invariance constraints to calculate the expressions for the diagram of figure 1(c).

01285#pg5>. The simplest solution for N(c)µ,s′sP is given by equation (2. p. 4
Where the paper says it

5) and no singularity for k1 = k2 which implies tπ,1 = tπ,2. The simplest solution of (2.

16) <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

1Corresponding author. arXiv:2609.

01285#pg5>.

Model Comparison with Experimental Data

The tensor-pomeron model, including both resonant (ρ0 and ω) and non-resonant (DS) contributions, gives a very satisfactory description of the data for invariant π+π− masses Mππ ≲ 1.2 GeV <ref:2609. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1Corresponding author. arXiv:2609.

01285#pg5>. The model results are compared with the H1 data from [8] <ref:2609. p. 5
Where the paper says it

We show the model results for the resonant (ρ 0 and ω) and the DS contributions. Our results are compared with the H1 data from [8].

01285#pg5>. Figure 3 shows that the π+π− invariant mass distribution is skewed and the amount of skewing decreases with increasing t <ref:2609. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Our results are compared with the H1 data from [8]. From figures 3 and 4 we clearly see that the π +π − invariant mass distribution is skewed and the amount of skewing decreases with increasing |t|.

01285#pg5>. Furthermore, the model with default parameters is also in good agreement with the ZEUS data <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We present a comparison of our tensor-pomeron model, including our new Drell-Söding and ρ, ω vector-meson contributions, with data for the γp → π +π − p reaction measured by the ZEUS and H1 Collaborations. We find very good agreement of our theory with the experimental data for the π +π − invariant mass (Mππ) and for angular distributions.

01285#pg5>.

Comparison to Pumplin's Approach

The authors compare their results for the DS term for real photons to Pumplin’s ansatz [9] <ref:2609.01285#pg5>. When form factors are set to 1, Pumplin’s ansatz works as an approximate relation in the high-energy limit <ref:2609. p. 3

Where the paper says it

the corresponding new amplitudes which take into account the generalized form factors in the Pππ, f2Rππ, and ρRππ vertices. The gauge-invariance relation (2.

01285#pg5>. However, when off-shell pion effects are included via non trivial form factors Fπ(tπ,i), their results and those of Pumplin’s ansatz are very different <ref:2609. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Contents 1 Introduction 1 2 Updated Drell-Söding amplitudes taking into account off-shell pion effects 2 3 Results for the γp → π +π − p reaction and a comparison with data from HERA 5 4 Conclusions 10 A Comparison of our model for the DS contribution with Pumplin’s approach 11 1 Introduction In this note we continue our investigation of the production of π +π − pairs in diffractive photon-proton collisions. In [1] we have given a detailed discussion of this reaction for real and slightly virtual photons at high energies, using and extending the results of [2].

01285#pg5>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can now perform theoretical predictions for pion plus pion pair production in diffractive photon-proton collisions by incorporating off-shell effects in P pi pi, f2R pi pi, and rhoR pi pi vertices. This allows the system to predict experimental observables across a range of photon virtualities Q squared up to 0.5 GeV squared.

  2. Improved AI can accurately model the skewing of the rho resonance contribution in photoproduction by comparing its predictions against data from ZEUS and H1 Collaborations for pion plus pion invariant mass M pi pi distributions. This capability addresses a long-standing puzzle regarding the shape differences in M pi pi distributions between e+e- annihilation and photoproduction.

  3. Improved AI can calculate the full tensor-pomeron model amplitudes including non-resonant Drell-Söding and vector meson contributions for real and virtual photons with 0 less than Q squared less than 0.5 GeV squared. This comprehensive model allows for detailed comparison with experimental data from HERA experiments across various kinematic regions.

  4. Improved AI can predict the differential cross sections d2sigma/dtdM pi pi for the reaction gamma p to pi plus pion minus p at fixed center-of-mass energies W gamma p by varying parameters such as Lambda pi and Lambda V. This enables high-precision data interpretation for ultraperipheral collisions at the LHC and future electron proton ion colliders.

  5. Improved AI can compare its results to alternative theoretical approaches, specifically Pumplin's ansatz, while accounting for non trivial form factors F pi(t pi i) with off-shell pion effects included. This provides a rigorous check on the validity of the high-energy approximations used in previous analyses.

Abstract

We update our analyses concerning the non-resonant (Drell-Söding) contribution to the reaction γ(*) p to π+ π- p, now including general vertex functions for the coupling of pomeron, f 2 R, and ρ R, to pions. This takes into account the off-shellness of the pions. We present a comparison of our tensor-pomeron model, including our new Drell-Söding and ρ, ω vector-meson contributions, with data for the γp to π+ π- p reaction measured by the ZEUS and H1 Collaborations. We find very good agreement of our theory with the experimental data for the π+ π- invariant mass (M ππ) and for angular distributions. Here we restrict our analysis to the region M ππ 1.2 GeV. For higher values of M ππ we will have to consider production of higher-mass mesons. The purpose of the present article is to show that our tensor-pomeron model gives a very good fit to the so-called skewing of the ρ-resonance contribution in photoproduction. In fact, it is an old problem/puzzle to understood the difference of the shapes of the M ππ distributions in the region of the ρ(770) resonance in e+ e- annihilation and photoproduction. We think that with our results we have obtained for this problem a solution which is very satisfactory from the Quantum-Field-Theory point of view. Our results are also relevant for central-exclusive π+ π- production in ultraperipheral pp, A p, and AA collisions at the LHC and for photo- and electroproduction of π+ π- at future electron-proton/ion colliders, EIC and LHeC.

Sources

Related papers