Reconciling the Lack of a Robust Anvil Cloud Amount Response to Warming

arXiv:2609.00429 · physics.ao-ph · Submitted 2026-08-31 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Reconciling the Lack of a Robust Anvil Cloud Amount Response to Warming".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Tropical anvil clouds are important for regulating Earth’s climate, but it remains uncertain how they will change as the planet warms <ref:2609.00429#pg16>.

Kai: The ensemble of RCEMIP simulations verifies that the stability increase is robust yet arises from the air density reduction, and hence is not accompanied by a robust response in anvil amount, convectively driven water convergence into anvil levels, or the efficiency with which this convergence produces cloudiness <ref:2609.00429#pg3>.

Mira: Overall, these findings dispel the expectation of a systematic reduction in anvil amount with warming arising from basic physical arguments <ref:2609.00429#pg2>.

Kai: Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The stability-iris hypothesis proposes that tropical anvil cloud amount decreases with warming as anvils rise into environments of greater static stability <ref:2609.00429#pg4>.

Title and authors: Mira: To summarize this part of "Reconciling the Lack of a Robust Anvil Cloud Amount Response to Warming," the authors are summarizing their simulation results and how they reconcile the stability-iris hypothesis with what they actually saw in their data.

Kai: They’re saying that even though warming causes a robust increase in static stability, this doesn't translate into a measurable change in the anvil cloud amount or how much water gets channeled into those high levels.

Lev: So they are essentially showing that the mechanism proposed by Bony et al. is not physically realized as a simple control on anvil volume when you look at these ensemble simulations.

Mira: That’s right, and they do this by checking several things: the stability increase itself, the water convergence into those levels, and how effective that convergence is at making cloudiness.

Kai: The key finding is that even with a robust stability increase driven by air density reduction, there is no robust response in anvil amount or water convergence.

Lev: That means the authors are proving that the physical mechanism they were testing—the density reduction causing stability change—isn't doing what the theory predicted it would.

Mira: They also analytically show that along an isotherm, the main sensitivity cancels out, meaning w is expected to be invariant to surface warming in first order.

Kai: So they are showing that the link between static stability and anvil amount isn't as direct or systematic as previously thought when you look at these pressure-coordinate formulations.

Lev: If we were trying to build an error correction system for a climate model, this tells us that the input from stability changes alone isn't enough to predict output changes in cloud structure.

Mira: The paper is essentially saying that the stability-iris mechanism doesn't hold up as a primary physical argument for predicting anvil thinning under warming.

Kai: So where does this leave us? It leaves us needing to look at other factors, like ice microphysics and convective aggregation, to explain any actual changes we might see in those clouds.

The paper's summary: Lev: Now for the improvements they suggest. They aren't just saying the mechanism doesn't work; they are suggesting what *should* be looked at next if we want to understand why anvil amounts might change.

Kai: The authors suggest shifting attention away from stability toward more complex physical controls on anvil formation and persistence, specifically mentioning ice microphysics and convective aggregation.

Mira: They are pushing the field to focus on those smaller scale processes because they think those are what actually drive the observed cloud responses in some systems.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means that if you want to build a better model, you can’t just focus on the large-scale stability gradients; you need to incorporate how water aggregates into clouds on a finer scale.

Kai: The paper suggests that the authors should look at those details—the way ice forms and how water aggregates—to find the real controls on anvil amount.

Mira: They are implying that these smaller, more detailed processes are where the dynamic constraints actually live, rather than just the large-scale change in static stability.

Lev: It’s a call to look at those finer details because those are where you’ll find the physical mechanism that actually dictates how much anvil you get.

Kai: So they're suggesting that we stop looking for a simple link between stability and amount, and start looking for the more intricate physics governing the cloud itself.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So to wrap up "Reconciling the Lack of a Robust Anvil Cloud Amount Response to Warming," the main conclusion is that there isn't a straightforward reason to expect an anvil cloud reduction based on simple physical arguments.

Mira: The RCEMIP-I simulations confirm this by showing no clear response in convective water flux, water convergence, or the efficiency with which that water source produces anvils.

Lev: It means the stability-iris mechanism doesn't provide a physical basis for anvil reduction when you look at these results.

Kai: The paper shifts focus away from stability toward more complex physical controls on anvil formation and persistence, particularly ice microphysics and convective aggregation.

Mira: So in short, the authors found that while stability changes robustly, they don't drive the cloud amount change they expected.

Lev: We need to keep building models that incorporate those microphysical details because that seems to be where the actual physical constraint lies.

Kai: That’s it for this paper today. We'll take a quick break before we look at what else is on arXiv.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve looked at "Reconciling the Lack of a Robust Anvil Cloud Amount Response to Warming" and it seems like even when you have a robust increase in static stability due to air density dropping, that doesn't translate into a measurable change in how much anvil cloud there is.

Mira: Exactly. The simulations showed that the water convergence into those high levels doesn't respond strongly, and the efficiency with which that water makes clouds isn't changing either.

Lev: From an error-correction standpoint, this means if we were modeling this for real hardware, just relying on the stability change wouldn't be enough input to predict a change in cloud structure.

Kai: That’s the point. They show that the stability-iris hypothesis doesn't really provide a physical basis for predicting anvil thinning under warming.

Mira: They are suggesting we need to look at other things, like ice microphysics and how water aggregates, because those seem to be the actual controls on anvil amount.

Lev: If you were trying to build a better model, you’d want to focus on those fine details rather than just the large-scale stability gradients.

Kai: So what this paper really means is that we need more complex physics in our models if we want to understand why clouds respond to climate change.

Mira: It shifts the focus from stability toward those smaller, more intricate physical controls on anvil formation and persistence.

Lev: I think that's right. It’s a call for higher resolution physics where things actually happen.

Kai: So that wraps up our look at "Reconciling the Lack of a Robust Anvil Cloud Amount Response to Warming." We're going to take a quick break now before we look at those papers on spectral solvers and image reconstruction.

Department of Meteorology and Geophysics, University of Vienna · Department of Meteorology, University of Bonn

physics.ao-ph

Submitted: 2026-08-31

Updated: 2026-11-10

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: Tropical anvil clouds are important for regulating Earth’s climate, but it remains uncertain how they will change as the planet warms <ref:2609.00429#pg16>.

Key concepts

Stability-Iris Hypothesis
This hypothesis suggests that as tropical anvils rise into more stable air, their amount should decrease due to increased stability. The study tested this idea but found that this mechanism does not systematically alter how much moist air reaches the anvil levels.
Air Density Reduction
Warming causes the air aloft to become less dense. This density change is what drives an increase in static stability, which is a key part of the stability-iris hypothesis. The study found that this density change does not lead to a robust response in anvil amount.
Water Convergence Efficiency
This measures how effectively water transported convectively (from rising air) actually forms clouds at the anvil level. The simulations showed no clear change in this efficiency along isotherms, meaning the source of moist air into anvils is not systematically altered by warming.

Terminology

Summary

Tropical anvil clouds are important for regulating Earth’s climate, but it remains uncertain how they will change as the planet warms <ref:2609. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Overall, these findings dispel the expectation of a systematic reduction in anvil amount with warming arising from basic physical arguments. Plain Language Summary Tropical anvil clouds are important for regulating Earth’s climate, but it remains uncertain how they will change as the planet warms.

00429#pg16>. The ensemble of RCEMIP simulations verifies that the stability increase is robust yet arises from the air density reduction, and hence is not accompanied by a robust response in anvil amount, convectively driven water convergence into anvil levels, or the efficiency with which this convergence produces cloudiness <ref:2609. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We demonstrate analytically that identified sensitivities of static stability and pressure velocity to surface warming arise from decreasing air density aloft, which enters pressure-coordinate formulations but does not represent a process that dynamically constrains anvil formation. An ensemble of RCEMIP simulations verifies that the stability increase is robust yet arises from the air density reduction, and hence is not accompanied by a robust response in anvil amount, convectively driven water convergence into anvil levels, or the efficiency with which this convergence produces cloudiness.

00429#pg3>. Overall, these findings dispel the expectation of a systematic reduction in anvil amount with warming arising from basic physical arguments <ref:2609. p. 1
Where the paper says it

An ensemble of RCEMIP simulations verifies that the stability increase is robust yet arises from the air density reduction, and hence is not accompanied by a robust response in anvil amount, convectively driven water convergence into anvil levels, or the efficiency with which this convergence produces cloudiness. Overall, these findings dispel the expectation of a systematic reduction in anvil amount with warming arising from basic physical arguments.

00429#pg2>.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The stability-iris hypothesis proposes that tropical anvil cloud amount decreases with warming as anvils rise into environments of greater static stability <ref:2609.00429#pg4>. The authors demonstrate analytically that identified sensitivities of static stability and pressure velocity to surface warming arise from decreasing air density aloft, which enters pressure-coordinate formulations but does not represent a process that dynamically constrains anvil formation <ref:2609. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Here we show that there is no clear theoretical or simulated link between increasing static stability and anvil amount. We demonstrate analytically that identified sensitivities of static stability and pressure velocity to surface warming arise from decreasing air density aloft, which enters pressure-coordinate formulations but does not represent a process that dynamically constrains anvil formation.

00429#pg2>. An ensemble of RCEMIP simulations verifies that the stability increase is robust yet arises from the air density reduction, and hence is not accompanied by a robust response in anvil amount, convectively driven water convergence into anvil levels, or the efficiency with which this convergence produces cloudiness <ref:2609. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We demonstrate analytically that identified sensitivities of static stability and pressure velocity to surface warming arise from decreasing air density aloft, which enters pressure-coordinate formulations but does not represent a process that dynamically constrains anvil formation. An ensemble of RCEMIP simulations verifies that the stability increase is robust yet arises from the air density reduction, and hence is not accompanied by a robust response in anvil amount, convectively driven water convergence into anvil levels, or the efficiency with which this convergence produces cloudiness.

00429#pg3>.

How the training signal is built

The study examines simulations from Phase I of the Radiative-Convective Equilibrium Model Intercomparison Project (RCEMIP-I; Wing et al., 2018a, 2020) to test the theoretical relationships proposed by Bony et al. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Here we reinterpret the original theoretical arguments and examine radiative-convective simulations, showing that the basis for this hypothesis does not hold. Methods To assess anvil cloud responses to warming and test the theoretical relationships proposed by Bony et al.

(2016) <ref:2609. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The most widely accepted hypothesis for an altered anvil cloud amount is the stability-iris mechanism of Bony et al. (2016), which was based on earlier work by Zelinka and Hartmann (2010, 2011).

00429#pg5>. RCEMIP-I models were run with uniform sea surface temperatures (Ts) of 295, 300, and 305 K, enabling quantification of sensitivities to warming <ref:2609. p. 3
Where the paper says it

, 2020), and RCE simulations have also been used in other studies investigating the stability-iris mechanism (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Jeevanjee, 2022). Each RCEMIP-I model performed simulations with uniform sea surface temperatures (Ts) of 295, 300, and 305 K, enabling quantification of sensitivities to warming; here we analyze the 295 and 305 K simulations.

00429#pg5>. The methodology for quantifying convective air and water transport followed the approach of Williams and Jeevanjee (2025). p. 3
Where the paper says it

Each RCEMIP-I model performed simulations with uniform sea surface temperatures (Ts) of 295, 300, and 305 K, enabling quantification of sensitivities to warming; here we analyze the 295 and 305 K simulations. To quantify convective air and water transport, we follow the methodology of Williams and Jeevanjee (2025) for calculating convective mass flux in the same ensemble.

Where the gains come from

The analysis focused on small-domain RCEMIP-I simulations, which use approximately 100 km × 100 km horizontal domains, 1 km horizontal grid spacing, and 74 vertical levels extending to 33 km. These domains suppress convective self-aggregation, isolating processes central to the analysis. p. 4

Where the paper says it

We focus on the RCEMIP-I small-domain simulations, which use approximately 100 km × 100 km horizontal domains, 1 km horizontal grid spacing, and 74 vertical levels extending to 33 km. These domains suppress convective self-aggregation, isolating processes central to our analysis, following the argument of Bony et al.

The results showed that along isotherms there is no clear change in the efficiency with which uplifted water generates anvils. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We find that the apparent increase in atmospheric stability as anvil clouds rise with warming is largely a consequence of reduced air density at higher altitudes, rather than a change that constrains the upward motions or water supply that form anvil clouds. Consistent with this finding, the simulations show no clear response in anvil amount, the supply of water to anvil levels, or the efficiency with which that water produces cloudiness.

Breakdown of the stability-iris hypothesis

The authors show that along an isotherm, both Qr and Γd – Γ will increase in response to surface warming, as the isotherms move into lower density air in which each unit of radiative and latent energy has an enhanced influence on temperature. Because w is controlled by both Qr and Γd – Γ (Eqn. p. 8

Where the paper says it

8 Hence, along isotherms both Qr and Γd – Γ will increase in response to surface warming, as the isotherms move into lower density air in which each unit of radiative and latent energy has an enhanced influence on temperature. Because w is controlled by both Qr and Γd – Γ (Eqn.

3), and the main sensitivity of each directly cancels, w along an isotherm is to first-order expected to be invariant to surface warming. p. 9
Where the paper says it

and the main sensitivity of each directly cancels, w along an isotherm is to first-order expected to be invariant to surface warming: ( w )T ≈ invariant Eqn. 9 Quantifying w across RCEMIP-I by calculating convective mass fluxes as in Jeevanjee and Williams (2025), but without multiplying by ρ, likewise shows no clear response to surface warming at any isotherm (Fig.

This implies that the increase in static stability as anvils rise does not systematically alter the source of moist air into anvil levels, breaking the stated control on anvil amount. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We find that the apparent increase in atmospheric stability as anvil clouds rise with warming is largely a consequence of reduced air density at higher altitudes, rather than a change that constrains the upward motions or water supply that form anvil clouds. Consistent with this finding, the simulations show no clear response in anvil amount, the supply of water to anvil levels, or the efficiency with which that water produces cloudiness.

Conclusion

The results demonstrate that there is no straightforward reason to expect an anvil cloud reduction, and the RCEMIP-I simulations confirm this by showing no clear response in convective water flux, water convergence, or the efficiency with which the water source produces anvils. The study concludes that the stability-iris mechanism does not provide a physical basis for anvil reduction. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The idealized configuration of RCE simulations and their explicit resolution of convective motions provide a useful framework for examining the physical basis of the stability-iris hypothesis. RCEMIP-I has previously been found to exhibit mixed support for a reduction in anvil cloud amount with warming (Wing et al.

The results shift attention from stability toward more complex physical controls on anvil formation and persistence, particularly ice microphysics and convective aggregation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

mcgraw@univie. at Key Points • Although anvil clouds rise into more stable air with warming, this does not directly influence convective air convergence or anvil amount • Responses of stability and pressure velocity overwhelmingly reflect reduced density in air aloft, whereas key anvil controls are invariant • RCEMIP-I models exhibit no robust change in anvil volume, water convergence into anvil levels, or efficiency of anvil formation 1

References

Bohren, C. F., & Albrecht, B. p. 7

Where the paper says it

3 following Jeevanjee (2022): w = Qr Γd−Γ Eqn. 4 If we assume the environment to follow a moist adiabatic profile, a standard formula (Bohren and Albrecht, 1998) can be rearranged to give 8

A., Atmospheric Thermodynamics. p. 7
Where the paper says it

amount changes using the simplest possible framework. Crucially, we avoid quantities that vary simply because rising isotherms encounter lower dry-air density, thereby isolating the thermodynamics governing convection and clouds, which are primarily controlled by water.

Bony, S., Stevens, B., Coppin, D., Becker, T., Reed, K. A., Voigt, A. p. 2

Where the paper says it

It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al. , 2024; Voigt et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al. , 2024; Voigt et al.

, & Medeiros, B., Thermodynamic control of anvil cloud amount. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Lack of a clear anvil amount response to warming across models We first examine how anvil cloud amount responds to warming across simulations. If the stability-iris mechanism represents a fundamental control on anvil amount, its predicted reduction should emerge consistently in models that capture relevant radiative-convective processes while minimizing complicating influences such as large-scale circulation.

Choi, Y. S., Kim, W., Yeh, S. W., Masunaga, H., Kwon, M. J., Jo, H. S., & Huang, L., Revisiting the iris effect of tropical cirrus clouds with TRMM and A Train satellite data. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Abstract The stability-iris hypothesis proposes that tropical anvil cloud amount decreases with warming as anvils rise into environments of greater static stability. Here we show that there is no clear theoretical or simulated link between increasing static stability and anvil amount.

Cronin, T. W., & Wing, A. p. 2

Where the paper says it

From this, they propose that Dr controls anvil cloud amount, and that increased stability thereby will reduce anvil cloud amount as surface temperature increases. Several subsequent studies have reported support for the stability-iris hypothesis in observations and models (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Saint-Lu 2020; 2022).

p. 2
Where the paper says it

From this, they propose that Dr controls anvil cloud amount, and that increased stability thereby will reduce anvil cloud amount as surface temperature increases. Several subsequent studies have reported support for the stability-iris hypothesis in observations and models (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Saint-Lu 2020; 2022).

A., Clouds, circulation, and climate sensitivity in a radiative convective equilibrium channel model. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Methods To assess anvil cloud responses to warming and test the theoretical relationships proposed by Bony et al. (2016), we examine simulations from Phase I of the Radiative-Convective Equilibrium Model Intercomparison Project (RCEMIP-I; Wing et al.

Deutloff, J. p. 3

Where the paper says it

, 2020) or have identified a weak response (McKim et al. , 2024; Deutloff et al.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

, 2020) or have identified a weak response (McKim et al. , 2024; Deutloff et al.

, Buehler, S. A., Brath, M., & Naumann, A. K., Insights on tropical high‐cloud radiative effect from a new conceptual model. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Methods To assess anvil cloud responses to warming and test the theoretical relationships proposed by Bony et al. (2016), we examine simulations from Phase I of the Radiative-Convective Equilibrium Model Intercomparison Project (RCEMIP-I; Wing et al.

Deutloff, J., Buehler, S. A., Windmiller, J. M., & Naumann, A. K., Facets of the tropical high-cloud feedback in a global storm-resolving model. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Abstract The stability-iris hypothesis proposes that tropical anvil cloud amount decreases with warming as anvils rise into environments of greater static stability. Here we show that there is no clear theoretical or simulated link between increasing static stability and anvil amount.

Forster, P. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Introduction Tropical anvil clouds are regarded as a key influence on Earth’s temperature sensitivity, owing to their extensive coverage, strong radiative influence, and uncertain response to warming (Sherwood et al. , 2020; Forster et al.

, Storelvmo, T., Armour, K., Collins, W., Dufresne, J.-L., Frame, D., Lunt, D. J., Mauritsen, T., Palmer, M. D., Watanabe, M., Wild, M., & Zhang, H.,The Earth’s energy budget, Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis.

Gasparini, B. p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

, Blossey, P. N., Hartmann, D. p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

L., Lin, G., & Fan, J., What drives the life-cycle of tropical anvil clouds? p. 1
Where the paper says it

Overall, these findings dispel the expectation of a systematic reduction in anvil amount with warming arising from basic physical arguments. Plain Language Summary Tropical anvil clouds are important for regulating Earth’s climate, but it remains uncertain how they will change as the planet warms.

Gasparini, B., Mandorli, G., Stubenrauch, C., & Voigt, A. p. 2

Where the paper says it

It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al. , 2024; Voigt et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al. , 2024; Voigt et al.

, Basic physics predicts stronger high cloud radiative heating with warming. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The hypothesis proposes that warming decreases anvil amount by raising the anvils into layers of stronger static stability. This framework combines the approximate isothermal rise of anvils (Hartmann and Larson, 2002) with the constraint that, in subsiding regions, atmospheric radiative cooling (Qr, in K/s) is balanced by adiabatic subsidence warming, such that ω=−Qr /S Eqn.

Gasparini, B., Atlas, R., Voigt, A., Krämer, M., & Blossey, P. N., Tropical cirrus evolution in a kilometer-scale model with improved ice microphysics.

Hartmann, D. L., & Larson, K. p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

, An important constraint on tropical cloud climate ‐feedback. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Overall, these findings dispel the expectation of a systematic reduction in anvil amount with warming arising from basic physical arguments. Plain Language Summary Tropical anvil clouds are important for regulating Earth’s climate, but it remains uncertain how they will change as the planet warms.

Holton, J. R., An Introduction to Dynamic Meteorology (4th ed. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Reconciling the Lack of a Robust Anvil Cloud Amount Response to Warming Zachary McGraw1 , Blaž Gasparini1 , Wouter Mol1 , Aiko Voigt1* 1 Department of Meteorology and Geophysics, University of Vienna, Austria * Now at Department of Meteorology, University of Bonn, Germany Corresponding author: Zachary McGraw, zachary. mcgraw@univie.

), An Introduction to Dynamic Meteorology (4th ed. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Reconciling the Lack of a Robust Anvil Cloud Amount Response to Warming Zachary McGraw1 , Blaž Gasparini1 , Wouter Mol1 , Aiko Voigt1* 1 Department of Meteorology and Geophysics, University of Vienna, Austria * Now at Department of Meteorology, University of Bonn, Germany Corresponding author: Zachary McGraw, zachary. mcgraw@univie.

).

Jeevanjee, N. p. 3

Where the paper says it

RCEMIP-I has previously been found to exhibit mixed support for a reduction in anvil cloud amount with warming (Wing et al. , 2020), and RCE simulations have also been used in other studies investigating the stability-iris mechanism (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Jeevanjee, 2022).

p. 3
Where the paper says it

RCEMIP-I has previously been found to exhibit mixed support for a reduction in anvil cloud amount with warming (Wing et al. , 2020), and RCE simulations have also been used in other studies investigating the stability-iris mechanism (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Jeevanjee, 2022).

, & Romps, D. p. 8
Where the paper says it

6 that will change as an isotherm rises, and so the response of the actual Γd – Γ is likely to be largely proportional to that of rs. Because rs = ρv,s / ρ, where ρv,s is vapor density at saturation, and the atmosphere’s vapor density structure rises with surface warming to stay closely invariant along isotherms (Jeevanjee & Romps, 2018), this yields Γd−Γ ∝ 1 ρ Eqn.

M., Mean precipitation change from a deepening troposphere. p. 9
Where the paper says it

It is thus apparent that the simulated transport of water to anvil levels does not change systematically as the surface is warmed. Any response in anvil cloud amount must therefore arise from changes in what happens to this transported water: it may go toward generating anvil cloud, or instead be removed by precipitation before or after detrainment.

Jeevanjee, N., Three rules for the decrease of tropical convection with global warming. p. 1

Where the paper says it

A leading hypothesis proposes that warming makes the atmosphere more stable where anvil clouds form, suppressing the upward motion that supplies these clouds and causing their amount to decrease. We test this idea using basic physical relationships and simulations from several convection-resolving models.

Li, R. L., Studholme, J. H., Fedorov, A. V., & Storelvmo, T., Precipitation efficiency constraint on climate change. p. 9

Where the paper says it

It is thus apparent that the simulated transport of water to anvil levels does not change systematically as the surface is warmed. Any response in anvil cloud amount must therefore arise from changes in what happens to this transported water: it may go toward generating anvil cloud, or instead be removed by precipitation before or after detrainment.

Lin, B., Wielicki, B. A., Chambers, L. H., Hu, Y., & Xu, K. M.,The iris hypothesis: A negative or positive cloud feedback?, Journal of Climate.

Lindzen, R. p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 2024; McGraw et al. Yet the potential for climate feedbacks due to anvil amount responses has been debated for decades (Lindzen et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2024; McGraw et al. Yet the potential for climate feedbacks due to anvil amount responses has been debated for decades (Lindzen et al.

S., Chou, M. D., & Hou, A. Y.,Does the earth have an adaptive infrared iris?, Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society.

Lindzen, R. S., & Choi, Y. p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 2001; Lin et al. , 2002; Lindzen and Choi, 2022; McKim et al.

S.,The Iris Effect: A Review: RS Lindzen, Y.-S Choi, Asia-Pacific Journal of Atmospheric Sciences.

Lutsko, N. J., & Cronin, T. p. 2

Where the paper says it

From this, they propose that Dr controls anvil cloud amount, and that increased stability thereby will reduce anvil cloud amount as surface temperature increases. Several subsequent studies have reported support for the stability-iris hypothesis in observations and models (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Saint-Lu 2020; 2022).

W., Increase in precipitation efficiency with surface warming in radiative convective equilibrium. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Methods To assess anvil cloud responses to warming and test the theoretical relationships proposed by Bony et al. (2016), we examine simulations from Phase I of the Radiative-Convective Equilibrium Model Intercomparison Project (RCEMIP-I; Wing et al.

McGraw, Z., Polvani, L. M., Gasparini, B. p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

, Van de Koot, E. K., & Voigt, A.,The Cloud radiative response to surface warming weakens hydrological sensitivity, Geophysical Research Letters.

McKim, B., Bony, S. & Dufresne, JL., Weak anvil cloud area feedback suggested by physical and observational constraints. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The resulting sensitivity is weak and inconsistent: only 2–3 models show a clear reduction in anvil amount at equivalent levels, while most of the seven models lack a substantial response to warming. 1 | Vertical profiles along altitudes of cloud fraction (a) and along isotherms of cloud fraction (b), cloud volume (d) and shaded area fraction (f) across RCEMIP-I, alongside the corresponding percent-per-Kelvin sensitivity to surface warming along isotherms (c,e,g).

Mischell, E. p. 4

Where the paper says it

As a robustness check, we also briefly examine the corresponding large-domain simulations (3 km resolution; 6000 km × 400 km domains), which do contain self-aggregation. We use the same set of RCEMIP-I models analyzed by Williams and Jeevanjee (2025), except that we exclude MESONH because of a known issue with its humidity diagnostics (Mischell, 2026), leaving seven models in our ensemble: CM1, DAM, SAM_CRM, SCALE, UCLA-CRM, UKMOi-vn11.

, Perspectives on Storm Dynamics and Precipitation in the General Circulation of the Atmosphere (Doctoral dissertation, University of Miami). p. 7
Where the paper says it

3 where w is the geometric analogue of ω, representing the flux of air by volume that is transported vertically in convective regions (having SI units of m3 lifted air per second and m 2 area, or equivalently m/s), here defined as positive for upward motion. Ch measures the rate at which this upward volume flux decreases with height, representing the loss of upward motion from the convective circulation through detrainment into the surrounding atmosphere and compensating subsidence.

Ohno, T., & Satoh, M. p. 3

Where the paper says it

found simulations to lack a robust anvil reduction (Ohne & Satoh, 2018; Wing et al. , 2020) or have identified a weak response (McKim et al.

, Roles of cloud microphysics on cloud responses to sea surface temperatures in radiative convective equilibrium experiments using a high resolution‐ ‐18 global nonhydrostatic model. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Methods To assess anvil cloud responses to warming and test the theoretical relationships proposed by Bony et al. (2016), we examine simulations from Phase I of the Radiative-Convective Equilibrium Model Intercomparison Project (RCEMIP-I; Wing et al.

Saint Lu, M. p. 2

Where the paper says it

From this, they propose that Dr controls anvil cloud amount, and that increased stability thereby will reduce anvil cloud amount as surface temperature increases. Several subsequent studies have reported support for the stability-iris hypothesis in observations and models (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Saint-Lu 2020; 2022).

, Bony, S., & Dufresne, J. L., Observational evidence for a stability iris effect in the tropics. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Abstract The stability-iris hypothesis proposes that tropical anvil cloud amount decreases with warming as anvils rise into environments of greater static stability. Here we show that there is no clear theoretical or simulated link between increasing static stability and anvil amount.

Saint-Lu, M. p. 2

Where the paper says it

From this, they propose that Dr controls anvil cloud amount, and that increased stability thereby will reduce anvil cloud amount as surface temperature increases. Several subsequent studies have reported support for the stability-iris hypothesis in observations and models (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Saint-Lu 2020; 2022).

, Bony, S., & Dufresne, J. L.,Clear-sky control of anvils in response to increased CO2 or surface warming or volcanic eruptions, npj climate and atmospheric science.

Sherwood, S. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Introduction Tropical anvil clouds are regarded as a key influence on Earth’s temperature sensitivity, owing to their extensive coverage, strong radiative influence, and uncertain response to warming (Sherwood et al. , 2020; Forster et al.

C., Webb, M. J., Annan, J. D., Armour, K. C., Forster, P. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Introduction Tropical anvil clouds are regarded as a key influence on Earth’s temperature sensitivity, owing to their extensive coverage, strong radiative influence, and uncertain response to warming (Sherwood et al. , 2020; Forster et al.

M., Hargreaves, J. C., An assessment of Earth's climate sensitivity using multiple lines of evidence, Reviews of geophysics.

Sokol, A. B., Wall, C. J., & Hartmann, D. p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

L., Greater climate sensitivity implied by anvil cloud thinning. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Abstract The stability-iris hypothesis proposes that tropical anvil cloud amount decreases with warming as anvils rise into environments of greater static stability. Here we show that there is no clear theoretical or simulated link between increasing static stability and anvil amount.

Stauffer, C. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Yet Wing et al. (2020) and Stauffer and Wing (2022) found inconsistent anvil fraction responses across RCEMIP-I models.

L., & Wing, A. A.,Properties, changes, and controls of deep convecting ‐clouds in radiative convective equilibrium, Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems.

Voigt, A., North, S., Gasparini, B., & Ham, S. H., Atmospheric cloud-radiative heating in CMIP6 and observations and its response to surface warming. p. 2

Where the paper says it

From this, they propose that Dr controls anvil cloud amount, and that increased stability thereby will reduce anvil cloud amount as surface temperature increases. Several subsequent studies have reported support for the stability-iris hypothesis in observations and models (Cronin & Wing, 2017; Saint-Lu 2020; 2022).

Wing, A. A., Reed, K. A., Satoh, M. p. 3

Where the paper says it

found simulations to lack a robust anvil reduction (Ohne & Satoh, 2018; Wing et al. , 2020) or have identified a weak response (McKim et al.

, Stevens, B., Bony, S., & Ohno, T.,Radiative–convective equilibrium model intercomparison project, Geoscientific Model Development.

Wing, A. A., Stauffer, C. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Yet Wing et al. (2020) and Stauffer and Wing (2022) found inconsistent anvil fraction responses across RCEMIP-I models.

L., Becker, T., Reed, K. A., Ahn, M.-S., Arnold, N. P., et al.,Radiative-Convective Equilibrium Model Intercomparison Project (RCEMIP) Simulation Dataset [Data set], World Data Center for Climate (WDCC).

Zelinka, M. p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2020; Forster et al. It is established that anvil clouds amplify warming by rising to altitudes at which they more effectively trap outgoing radiation (Hartmann and Larson, 2002; Zelinka and Hartmann, 2011; Gasparini et al.

D., & Hartmann, D. L., Why is longwave cloud feedback positive? p. 7
Where the paper says it

In the geometric framework, Ch=− ∂w ∂ z with w= gQr T N 2 Eqn. 3 where w is the geometric analogue of ω, representing the flux of air by volume that is transported vertically in convective regions (having SI units of m3 lifted air per second and m 2 area, or equivalently m/s), here defined as positive for upward motion.

, Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres.

Zelinka, M. D., & Hartmann, D. L.,The observed sensitivity of high clouds to mean surface temperature anomalies in the tropics, Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can be trained to distinguish between physical responses in pressure coordinates versus geometric coordinates when analyzing stability-related quantities like static stability and convective convergence. This allows for a more accurate assessment of whether observed changes are due to density reduction or dynamic constraints, as noted by Our reconciliation of the stability-iris hypothesis underscores the advantage of using coordinates that readily convey the physical meaning of the quantities being compared.

  2. Improved AI systems can be designed to identify and isolate components in pressure-coordinate formulations that introduce artificial dependencies on air density, such as those described in Equations 1 and 2. This capability will help researchers accurately separate physical processes from artifacts created by coordinate choices, addressing the finding that the basis for this hypothesis does not hold when using geometric coordinates instead of pressure-coordinate ones.

  3. Improved AI systems can perform automated sensitivity analysis across multiple metrics of anvil amount to detect inconsistencies in model responses. This system can flag cases where models show inconsistent anvil fraction responses across RCEMIP-I models, enabling faster identification of the lack of a robust response in anvil amount mentioned in Section 3.1.

  4. Improved AI systems can be equipped to correlate changes in water transport with cloud production efficiency using the defined metrics AEl and AEO (Equations 10). This will allow researchers to quantify how effectively convectively transported water contributes to anvil cloudiness, providing a more direct measure of feedback than conventional precipitation efficiency metrics.

  5. Improved AI systems can be trained to recognize that the key controls on anvil amount are approximately invariant along isotherms when density-sensitive pressure-coordinate quantities are replaced by their geometric-coordinate counterparts. This will help researchers avoid the conflation of coordinate-dependent changes with physical responses, aligning analysis with the conclusion that all assessed controls on anvil amount are approximately invariant along isotherms when density-sensitive pressure-coordinate quantities are replaced by their geometric-coordinate counterparts.

Abstract

The stability-iris hypothesis proposes that tropical anvil cloud amount decreases with warming as anvils rise into environments of greater static stability. Here we show that there is no substantial theoretical or simulated link from increased static stability to reduced anvil amount. We demonstrate analytically that the sensitivities of static stability and pressure velocity to surface warming arise mainly from decreasing air density, which does not weaken the detrainment supplying anvils. Convectively driven motion stays nearly fixed along isotherms, so detrainment changes little where anvils rise. An ensemble of RCEMIP simulations confirms that stability increases robustly but is not accompanied by a robust reduction in the detrainment of air or water at anvil levels. Overall, these findings dispel the expectation of a systematic reduction in anvil amount with warming arising from basic thermodynamic arguments.

Related papers