Tropical Matsusaka and Matsusaka--Ran Criteria

arXiv:2608.30148 · math.AG · Submitted 2026-08-31 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: I'm Ada.

Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Tropical Matsusaka and Matsusaka--Ran Criteria".

Paper summary: Ada: So we're looking at the paper titled "Tropical Matsusaka and Matsusaka--Ran Criteria," and it tackles the tropical version of the Schottky problem. This problem is about figuring out when a given principally polarized tropical abelian variety is actually a tropical Jacobian variety, which means it comes from some smooth curve.

Emmy: Exactly. The core idea here is establishing an equivalence between two different sets of conditions for this to happen: the Matsusaka criterion and the Matsusaka--Ran criterion. The paper proves these are equivalent, and by combining this with the tropical Poincaré formula from Gross–Shokrieh, they offer a geometric solution to that problem.

Kolya: I'm curious about what that equivalence actually means for someone who isn't deep in algebraic geometry or number theory. What is the big picture here?

Ada: Well, essentially, they show that if you have an effective tropical one-cycle C on this abelian variety X and it spans it with a certain intersection number, there are three equivalent ways to describe that situation. One way is if the polarization Theta is principal and a specific cycle relationship holds. Another way is if you can find some smooth tropical curve Gamma, and mapping that curve into X gives you an isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties.

Emmy: That last condition, finding that smooth tropical curve Gamma and that map, seems like the most structural part of the argument. It connects the cycle C directly to a geometric object—a tropical curve whose Jacobian is isomorphic to our variety X.

Kolya: Does this mean we can now use methods from classical geometry on these tropical objects? Like, if we know something about those cycles or curves, does that translate into something concrete about the shape of the abelian variety X itself?

Ada: That's exactly what they're aiming for. They develop some tools to prove this equivalence. They establish Hodge-type inequalities for ample tropical Cartier divisors on these abelian varieties and they prove a splitting criterion for principally polarized tropical abelian varieties, which is used to show that if the polarization condition holds, you can indeed find that smooth curve Gamma.

Emmy: The structure of the proof shows how they build up from one condition to the next. For instance, proving that if you have that cycle C spanning X with a specific intersection number, then it forces the polarization Theta to be principal and sets up the condition for finding Gamma.

Paper summary: Kolya: So, if I'm thinking about this from a probabilistic side, what does this criterion imply about the behavior of these cycles or curves in terms of their distribution? Are there bounds on how complex these structures can get?

Ada: Kolya is right. The tools they use allow them to control the homological equivalence classes and intersection numbers using tropical homology theory, which helps them manage those cycle relationships systematically. The whole setup relies on the fact that this cycle relationship forces a very specific geometric structure onto the variety X, tying it back to its origins as a Jacobian.

Emmy: The Matsusaka criterion itself gives an affirmative answer to a question posed by Brannetti–Melo–Viviani, which is pretty significant because it settles a long-standing conjecture about Jacobians. It's not just proving one thing; it connects the tropical geometry directly to the classical theory of abelian varieties.

Kolya: I see. So for someone who just cares about how these structures behave, this paper tells us that these cycles aren't arbitrary; they have to respect a very strict geometric structure imposed by the principal polarization. It's not just any cycle, it has to be related to a smooth curve in a specific way.

Ada: Precisely. The main result is Theorem eight point one two, which states that if you start with an effective tropical one-cycle C on X and it meets those criteria—the spanning condition and the intersection number relationship—then you are guaranteed that there exists that smooth tropical curve Gamma and the isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties Jac(Gamma) to X <ref:2608.30148#pg3,isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties Jac>.

Emmy: That's the payoff. It’s a geometric characterization. Instead of just saying "this variety is a Jacobian," they provide a constructive way to see *why* it is one, by showing how it maps from a simpler object, the smooth curve Gamma.

Kolya: So, if we think about the implications for other areas, does this give any hints for studying non-principal polarizations or perhaps moving away from tropical settings? What are the limitations of this specific result?

Ada: The paper states their tools establish Hodge-type inequalities and a splitting criterion. Their limitation is that they focus on principally polarized varieties. They don't immediately show how these criteria generalize smoothly to cases where the polarization isn't principal, or if you move away from the tropical setting entirely.

Emmy: It’s important to remember that this result specifically addresses the canonical principal polarizations. The structure they find is tightly bound to that specific setup. They prove the equivalence of conditions (i), (ii), and (iii) using tools like the splitting criterion, which helps bridge those implications effectively.

Paper summary: Kolya: I think what's most relevant for practical application is that this provides a concrete framework for identifying these objects. If you encounter a tropical abelian variety, you can check if it satisfies these conditions to determine if it has the structure of a tropical Jacobian. It gives a test.

Ada: That's the practical utility I see. The entire effort was to provide this geometric solution by proving that all three conditions—the cycle spanning condition, the polarization condition, and the existence of that mapping curve—are actually the same thing under these specific constraints on X and C.

Emmy: So, to wrap up on this paper "Tropical Matsusaka and Matsusaka--Ran Criteria," it’s a piece of work that solidifies how tropical geometry can be used to solve classical problems in algebraic geometry by linking cycles directly to the structure of abelian varieties.

Kolya: And it does that by showing that the existence of certain cycles forces a very specific geometric realization, which is pretty powerful when you are trying to understand the underlying shape of these objects.

Ada: So, looking at "Tropical Matsusaka and Matsusaka--Ran Criteria," we've seen how they proved that for a principally polarized tropical abelian variety X and an effective tropical one-cycle C, three conditions are equivalent. These are: the cycle C spanning X with a specific intersection number; the polarization Theta being principal with a certain cycle relationship; and finally, the existence of a smooth tropical curve Gamma that maps to X in an isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties Jac(Gamma) to X.

Emmy: The title itself points to this equivalence between the Matsusaka and Ran criteria, which are key results here. Essentially, the paper proves that these two distinct approaches—one based on cycle properties and one based on polarization structure—lead to the same geometric conclusion about when a variety is a tropical Jacobian.

Kolya: It’s about taking something algebraic, like a Jacobian of a curve, and translating it into the world of tropical geometry, where you can use intersection theory to verify that structure. The implication for us is that we have a clear roadmap now for testing these tropical objects.

Ada: Exactly. It gives us a geometric test. If you have a tropical abelian variety, you can check if it satisfies these conditions to see if it has the structure of a tropical Jacobian from the start. That's the main thing this paper delivers for the field right now about characterizing these varieties geometrically.

Conclusion: Ada: So we’re wrapping up on "Tropical Matsusaka and Matsusaka--Ran Criteria," and basically, they proved that three different ways of looking at this problem—the cycle conditions, the polarization conditions, and finding that smooth curve—are all actually describing the exact same thing.

Emmy: That’s right. The paper shows how these two criteria align perfectly for principally polarized tropical abelian varieties. It connects the geometry of cycles directly to the existence of curves whose Jacobians match our variety X.

Kolya: So, what does that mean in practice? If you’re looking at a tropical abelian variety, this tells you exactly what structure it *must* have if it came from a curve. It gives you a real test.

Ada: It gives you a geometric test that works for the principal polarization case. The authors found the bridge between the classical Schottky problem and this tropical setting using these equivalences to give us that geometric solution we were looking for.

Emmy: It’s about proving that the structure of the polarization dictates exactly how those curves must map into X if they are to be related by an isomorphism. That mapping is a very strong condition, and it forces everything else into place.

Kolya: I think what’s interesting is that this whole setup relies on these Hodge-type inequalities and some splitting criterion to bridge the gap between the cycle counts and the actual existence of those curves. It’s a solid way to manage the complexity.

Ada: Exactly, Kolya, they use those tools to control all those homological classes and intersection numbers in a way that makes this whole equivalence hold true for any effective tropical one-cycle C on X with connected support.

Emmy: Ultimately, this work settles the question about characterization for these specific objects. It shows exactly what it means for a tropical variety to be a Jacobian variety when you’re working with principal polarizations and looking at cycles.

Kolya: And it sets the stage for what’s next, I guess? If we want to look beyond just principal polarizations or maybe look at more general types of cycles, this paper gives us the foundation for those generalizations.

ZHIJIE JI

math.AG

Submitted: 2026-08-31

Updated: 2026-11-16

Comments: 50 pages

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: The tropical Matsusaka criterion and Matsusaka–Ran criterion provide a geometric solution to the tropical Schottky problem by establishing equivalences between conditions on effective tropical…

Key concepts

Tropical Schottky Problem
This is a classical problem asking how to characterize abelian varieties that are Jacobians of smooth curves with their canonical polarizations. The tropical version asks for the same characterization in the setting of tropical geometry.
Spanning Curve and Polarization Condition
This refers to a set of equivalent conditions involving an effective tropical 1-cycle C on a variety X. One condition is that C spans X and its intersection with the polarization equals g. Another is that the polarization $\Theta$ is principal, linked to the cycle via a homological relation.
Tropical Jacobian Variety
This concept relates a tropical abelian variety X to the Jacobian of a smooth tropical curve $\Gamma$. The paper investigates when such an isomorphism exists between the induced structures, which is key to solving the Schottky problem in this setting.

Terminology

Summary

The tropical Matsusaka criterion and Matsusaka–Ran criterion provide a geometric solution to the tropical Schottky problem by establishing equivalences between conditions on effective tropical 1-cycles and properties of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The Matsusaka criterion is commonly regarded as a geometric solution to the classical Schottky problem. In tropical geometry, one can similarly consider principally polarized tropical abelian varieties (𝑋, Θ).

Classical Problem Context

The classical Schottky problem asks for a characterization of principally polarized abelian varieties that are Jacobians of smooth projective curves equipped with their canonical principal polarizations. The tropical analogue seeks to characterize principally polarized tropical abelian varieties that are tropical Jacobian varieties equipped with their canonical principal polarizations. p. 0

Where the paper says it

TROPICAL MATSUSAKA AND MATSUSAKA–RAN CRITERIA ZHIJIE JI Abstract The tropical Schottky problem asks which principally polarized tropical abelian varieties are isomorphic to tropical Jacobian varieties equipped with their canonical principal polarizations. We prove the tropical Matsusaka criterion and the tropical Matsusaka–Ran criterion, which are the main results of this paper, and show that their hypotheses are equivalent.

The paper proves the equivalence of the hypotheses for the two main criteria, which together with the tropical Poincaré formula gives a geometric solution to this problem. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We prove the tropical Matsusaka criterion and the tropical Matsusaka–Ran criterion, which are the main results of this paper, and show that their hypotheses are equivalent. Together with the tropical Poincare formula proved by Gross–Shokrieh, these ´ results give a geometric solution to the tropical Schottky problem.

Key Results and Criteria

The central result is Theorem A, which states that for a principally polarized tropical abelian variety (X, Θ) and an effective tropical 1-cycle C with connected support, the following are equivalent: (i) The tropical 1-cycle C is a spanning curve on X, and (Θ · C)X = g. (ii) The polarization Θ is principal, and (g − 1)! p. 0

Where the paper says it

(i) The curve 𝑍 generates 𝐴, and (Θ𝐴 · 𝑍) = 𝑔. (ii) The polarization Θ𝐴 is principal, and (𝑔 − 1)!

p. 0
Where the paper says it

(i) The curve 𝑍 generates 𝐴, and (Θ𝐴 · 𝑍) = 𝑔. (ii) The polarization Θ𝐴 is principal, and (𝑔 − 1)!

C ≡hom ([Θ])g−1. p. 0
Where the paper says it

(ii) The polarization Θ𝐴 is principal, and (𝑔 − 1)! [𝑍] ≡hom ( [Θ𝐴])𝑔−1 .

p. 0
Where the paper says it

(ii) The polarization Θ𝐴 is principal, and (𝑔 − 1)! [𝑍] ≡hom ( [Θ𝐴])𝑔−1 .

(iii) There exist a smooth tropical curve Γ of genus g and a morphism of rational polyhedral spaces chi: Γ → X such that chi∗ [Γ] = C, and the homomorphism f: Jac(Γ) → X induced by chi is an isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties (Jac(Γ), ΘΓ). p. 2
Where the paper says it

3 (iii) There exist a smooth tropical curve Γ of genus 𝑔 and a morphism of rational polyhedral spaces 𝜒 : Γ → 𝑋 such that 𝜒∗ [Γ] = 𝐶, and the homomorphism 𝑓 : Jac(Γ) → 𝑋 induced by 𝜒 is an isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties Jac(Γ), ΘΓ (𝑋, Θ), where ΘΓ denotes the canonical principal polarization on Jac(Γ). Here |𝐶| denotes the support of𝐶, as defined in Definition 2.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

3 (iii) There exist a smooth tropical curve Γ of genus 𝑔 and a morphism of rational polyhedral spaces 𝜒 : Γ → 𝑋 such that 𝜒∗ [Γ] = 𝐶, and the homomorphism 𝑓 : Jac(Γ) → 𝑋 induced by 𝜒 is an isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties Jac(Γ), ΘΓ (𝑋, Θ), where ΘΓ denotes the canonical principal polarization on Jac(Γ). Here |𝐶| denotes the support of𝐶, as defined in Definition 2.

Structural Tools for Proof

Several tools are developed to prove these criteria. These include:

  1. Hodge-type inequalities for ample tropical Cartier divisors on tropical abelian varieties. p. 0

    Where the paper says it

    Several tools are developed for the proofs of the two criteria. In particular, we establish Hodge-type inequalities for ample tropical Cartier divisors on tropical abelian varieties and prove a splitting criterion for principally polarized tropical abelian varieties.

  2. Splitting criterion for principally polarized tropical abelian varieties, which is used to prove the implication (ii)⇒(iii) of Theorem A. p. 0

    Where the paper says it

    Several tools are developed for the proofs of the two criteria. In particular, we establish Hodge-type inequalities for ample tropical Cartier divisors on tropical abelian varieties and prove a splitting criterion for principally polarized tropical abelian varieties.

  3. Tropical intersection theory and homology theory developed in [AR10] and [IKMZ19], which allow for the study of tropical Cartier divisors, cycles, intersection numbers, and homological equivalence classes. p. 1

    Where the paper says it

    In tropical geometry, one can similarly consider principally polarized tropical abelian varieties (𝑋, Θ). On 𝑋, the tropical intersection theory developed in [AR10] and the tropical homology theory, introduced in [IKMZ19] and developed for integral tori in [GS23a], allow one to study tropical Cartier divisors, tropical cycles, intersection numbers, and homological equivalence classes.

The Main Theorem

Theorem 8.12 establishes the main result: Let C be an effective tropical 1-cycle on X such that C is connected. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Theorem A (=Theorem 8. Let (𝑋, Θ) be a 𝑔-dimensional polarized tropical abelian variety with 𝑔 ≥ 2, and let 𝐶 be an effective tropical 1-cycle on 𝑋 such that |𝐶| is connected.

Then (i) The tropical 1-cycle C is a spanning curve on X, and (Θ · C)X = g. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Then the following are equivalent. (i) The tropical 1-cycle 𝐶 is a spanning curve on 𝑋, and (Θ · 𝐶)𝑋 = 𝑔.

(ii) The polarization Θ is principal, and (g − 1)!C ≡hom ([Θ])g−1. (iii) There exist a smooth tropical curve Γ of genus g and a morphism of rational polyhedral spaces chi: Γ → X such that chi∗ [Γ] = C, and the homomorphism f: Jac(Γ) → X induced by chi is an isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties (Jac(Γ), ΘΓ).

Proof Outline

The proof proceeds by showing the equivalence of (i) and (ii), which is Proposition 8.10. The implication (i)⇒(iii) is Theorem 8. p. 2

Where the paper says it

11, and a spanning curve is defined in Definition 2. The implication (ii)=⇒(iii) is the tropical Matsusaka criterion, Theorem 7.

11. The final step involves using the tropical Poincaré formula proved by Gross–Shokrieh to show that the equivalence of hypotheses holds, leading to the conclusion that (ii) follows from (iii), and thus all three conditions are equivalent. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We prove the tropical Matsusaka criterion and the tropical Matsusaka–Ran criterion, which are the main results of this paper, and show that their hypotheses are equivalent. Together with the tropical Poincare formula proved by Gross–Shokrieh, these ´ results give a geometric solution to the tropical Schottky problem.

Conclusion

The paper concludes by proving Theorem 8.11, which states that if C is a spanning curve on X and (Θ · C)X = g, then there exists a smooth tropical curve Γ and an isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties Jac(Γ), ΘΓ (X, Θ). p. 2

Where the paper says it

3 (iii) There exist a smooth tropical curve Γ of genus 𝑔 and a morphism of rational polyhedral spaces 𝜒 : Γ → 𝑋 such that 𝜒∗ [Γ] = 𝐶, and the homomorphism 𝑓 : Jac(Γ) → 𝑋 induced by 𝜒 is an isomorphism of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties Jac(Γ), ΘΓ (𝑋, Θ), where ΘΓ denotes the canonical principal polarization on Jac(Γ). Here |𝐶| denotes the support of𝐶, as defined in Definition 2.

This provides the geometric solution to the tropical Schottky problem. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We prove the tropical Matsusaka criterion and the tropical Matsusaka–Ran criterion, which are the main results of this paper, and show that their hypotheses are equivalent. Together with the tropical Poincare formula proved by Gross–Shokrieh, these ´ results give a geometric solution to the tropical Schottky problem.

The main theorem is Theorem 8. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Tropical Matsusaka criterion 36 8. Tropical Matsusaka–Ran criterion and the main theorem 43 References 49 1.

12.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to solve tropical Schottky problems by providing a geometric solution via an affirmative answer to questions posed by Brannetti–Melo–Viviani, as stated in Theorem A.

  2. Enhanced capacity to distinguish between equivalent conditions for principally polarized tropical abelian varieties, such as the equivalence of the hypotheses of the tropical Matsusaka criterion and the tropical Matsusaka–Ran criterion.

  3. Stronger capability to apply Hodge-type inequalities for ample tropical Cartier divisors on tropical abelian varieties, specifically using Proposition 3.6 and its related results to prove intersection number inequalities.

  4. Improved precision in recognizing when a given effective tropical 1-cycle is a spanning curve by checking the condition (g - 1)!C =hom ([Theta])g-1 against the existence of a smooth tropical curve mapping to it, as detailed in Theorem 7.10 and its proof.

  5. Enhanced reasoning for orthogonal decompositions of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties using tropical Rosati self-adjoint idempotents, leveraging Lemma 6.6 and Proposition 6.9 to establish equality of first Chern classes in the context of the decomposition (Corollary 6.10).

  6. Increased accuracy in determining the structure of the lattice associated with a tropical cycle by utilizing Lemma 7.1(ii) and Proposition 2.24(iii) to compute its Poincaré dual, which is crucial for verifying spanning curve properties in Theorem 7.3 and proving the main theorem (Theorem 8.12).

  7. Greater proficiency in analyzing the structure of homomorphisms between integral tori, specifically using Lemma 6.11 to determine when a homomorphism of integral tori is an isomorphism based on the surjectivity of its lattice homomorphism on the first component.

Abstract

The tropical Schottky problem asks which principally polarized tropical abelian varieties are isomorphic to tropical Jacobian varieties equipped with their canonical principal polarizations. We prove the tropical Matsusaka criterion and the tropical Matsusaka--Ran criterion, which are the main results of this paper, and show that their hypotheses are equivalent. Together with the tropical Poincaré formula proved by Gross--Shokrieh, these results give a geometric solution to the tropical Schottky problem. In particular, we give an affirmative answer to a question posed by Brannetti--Melo--Viviani. Several tools are developed for the proofs of the two criteria. In particular, we establish Hodge-type inequalities for ample tropical Cartier divisors on tropical abelian varieties and prove a splitting criterion for principally polarized tropical abelian varieties.

Sources

Related papers