Atomic structure calculations for constraining new electron-electron forces

arXiv:2608.26532 · hep-ph, physics.atom-ph · Submitted 2026-08-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Atomic structure calculations for constraining new electron-electron forces".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We present a general approach for calculating new electron-electron interactions with atomic structure theory, include dominant many-body effects, and extract bounds for parity-odd cases Theoretical Framework The paper introduces a general theoretical framework for performing atomic structure calculations in the presence of electron-electron (ee) interactions and demonstrates their utility by extracting and reporting new bounds on their mediators’ coupling constants The interaction-specific contributions are described by the effective interaction Lagrangian where a sum is over all fermions and possible boson-fermion interactions New interactions introduce a potential to the atomic Hamiltonian which is described in general and provides expressions for its inclusion in many-body Dirac-HartreeFock (DHF) atomic structure calculations The new potential takes the form of a Yukawa potential, where Vαβ0 = ħc 8π X j!=k e−µrjk rjk γ0j γ0k Γαβjk, which is valid for all possible electronelectron interactions mediated by scalar (S = 0) or vector (S = 1) bosons Constraints from Scalar-Pseudoscalar Interactions Scalar-pseudoscalar interactions are highlighted as a promising example of new physics because their mediators (axion-like particles) are popular dark-matter candidates They can be unambiguously constrained by their induced atomic electric dipole moments (EDMs) since atoms have no EDM within the Standard Model The authors perform calculations to extract bounds on the interaction from experimental EDMs in 133Cs and 205Tl, producing limits on the interaction’s coupling strength for all mediator masses These new bounds are less stringent than existing diamagnetic and molecular limits but account for important many-body effects Constraints from Vector-Axial Vector Interactions The paper also performs vector-axial vector (S = 1, P-odd) calculations and reports new bounds for previously unconstrained mass regions These interactions mediate E1-forbidden transitions, such as E6s→7s PNC in cesium, for which the ee contribution has received less attention than the dominant eN interaction The authors calculate the Standard Model ee interaction due to Z0 exchange and then generalize to other masses within the contact limit to extract new constraints on the interaction strength of an arbitrary leptophilic vector boson by comparison with existing measurements of E6s→7s PNC These are the first direct bounds obtained outside of the ultralight region The calculations use the program ampsci which begins by applying the DHF procedure to produce Slater-determinant wavefunctions of Dirac orbitals Corrections accounting for electron correlations are included using the all-orders correlation potential method and extension to the divalent 199Hg system with CI+MBPT For P-odd interactions, many-body corrections are found by self-consistently solving the Dirac equation with perturbed wavefunctions using the TDHF equations The results show that P-even potentials yield energy shifts, while P-odd mix states of opposite parity induce otherwise forbidden matrix elements of atomic operators The paper concludes by presenting a comprehensive method for calculating the atomic effects of any scalar or vector electronelectron interaction and extracting new physics bounds The VA limits provide new bounds for heavy mediator masses which were previously unconstrained The authors note that P-even interactions should be investigated in light systems where many-body effects are small enough to discern such new physics signals They also report an updated calculation of the regular (Standard Model) electronelectron Z0 exchange contribution to the 6s-7s PNC transition amplitude EPNC in cesium The VA limits yield an extracted bound, for mX ≳ 10 MeV, of g e Vg e A/m2 X ≤ 10−11 MeV−2 These are the first atomic bounds for a leptonic VA interaction and the first direct probe of the highmass sector The SP results are in line with previous constraints, while the VA limits provide new bounds for heavy mediator masses which were previously unconstrained The authors also provide an updated estimate for the neutral weak electron-electron contribution to the 6s→7s transition in Cs Acknowledgments This work was supported by the UQ Fellowship of the Big Questions Institute, by Australian Research Council through DECRA DE210101026 and Discovery Project DP230101685, by the Commonwealth through an Australian Government Research Training Program Scholarship [DOI: https://doi.org/10.

Title and authors: Kai: We’re talking about the paper "Atomic structure calculations for constraining new electron-electron forces" by Cameron J. West and Benjamin M. Roberts <ref:2608.26532#pg1>, which lays out a general approach for calculating new electron interactions with atomic structure theory <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Mira: It’s about taking these theoretical ideas and turning them into something we can actually test using atoms, specifically looking at how the atomic electric dipole moments and parity non-conserving transitions are affected by these new forces <ref:2608.26532#pg3>.

Lev: What I find interesting is that they aren't just doing a simple calculation; they are including dominant many-body effects right from the start using time-dependent Hartree-Fock to get an improved picture of how these interactions behave in a real atom <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Kai: And that’s important because simply ignoring those correlations means you miss how the interaction actually manifests in the measured quantities <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Mira: They are using this framework to extract bounds on coupling constants for both scalar-pseudoscalar and vector-axial vector interactions, which is a big step forward for constraining new physics <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Lev: The paper also tackles the idea of how these P-even cases, the ones that cause energy shifts, are more relevant in light systems where those many-body corrections aren't as huge <ref:2608.26532#pg2>.

Kai: So they’re connecting the fundamental theory of electron interactions to specific experimental observables like EDMs and PNC transitions <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Mira: To summarize, the core contribution of this paper is presenting a general approach for calculating new electron-electron interactions using atomic structure theory, and importantly, including dominant many-body effects in those calculations <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Kai: They show how to use this framework to extract bounds on the coupling constants for scalar-pseudoscalar and vector-axial vector interactions by comparing their predictions against experimental data on electric dipole moments and parity non-conserving transitions <ref:2608.26532#pg1>, <ref:2608.26532#pg3>.

Lev: A key part is that they calculate the Standard Model electron electron interaction due to Z zero exchange, and they include an improved many-body contribution for that calculation too <ref:2608.26532#pg2>.

Mira: Then they generalize those calculations to other masses within the contact limit to extract new constraints on the strength of an arbitrary leptophilic vector boson by comparing it with existing measurements of E6s→7s PNC transitions <ref:2608.26532#pg2> <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Kai: And they specifically find new bounds for heavy mediator masses, which were previously unconstrained because they were outside the ultralight region <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Lev: So what this means for us is that these are the first direct bounds on a leptonic vector interaction and a probe into the high-mass sector, which is something we needed <ref:2608.26532#pg2>.

Mira: They also report an updated calculation for the regular Standard Model electron electron Z zero exchange contribution to the six s seven p non conserving transition amplitude in cesium <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest several improvements to this approach, including using time-dependent Hartree-Fock methods to incorporate many-body corrections for the new interaction itself <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Mira: They also point out that for P-odd interactions, the mixing of states of opposite parity changes how the spatial contribution behaves, so you can't just assume the space like contribution is small <ref:2608.26532#pg3>.

Lev: That’s a crucial technical detail for anyone trying to run this on real hardware; it means we have to go beyond just looking at time-like terms alone for P-odd interactions <ref:2608.26532#pg2>.

Kai: And they mention that for P-even cases, the Breit equivalence is exact because those interactions only induce energy shifts, which is different from the parity odd stuff <ref:2608.26532#pg3>.

Mira: So the way they handle these different parity cases—the energy shifts versus the mixing states—is what makes this method robust enough to constrain a wide range of interactions <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Lev: It’s good to see them address those complexities, because if you miss that mixing, your bound on the coupling constant won't be right <ref:2608.26532#pg3>.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, the paper "Atomic structure calculations for constraining new electron-electron forces" gives us a general method to calculate atomic effects from any scalar or vector electron interaction and extract new physics bounds <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Mira: They successfully provide constraints on both scalar-pseudoscalar and vector-axial vector interactions by looking at EDMs and PNC transitions, including some really interesting bounds for heavy mediator masses <ref:2608.26532#pg1>, <ref:2608.26532#pg2>.

Lev: The updated calculation for the Standard Model Z zero exchange contribution to the six s seven p non conserving transition amplitude in cesium is also useful for understanding the baseline we're comparing against <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Kai: The main implication is that these VA limits provide new bounds for heavy mediator masses, which were previously unconstrained because they were outside the ultralight region <ref:2608.26532#pg2>.

Mira: They also note that P-even interactions should be investigated in light systems where many-body effects are small enough to see those signals <ref:2608.26532#pg2>.

Lev: I'd say these results give us a solid starting point for what we need to run on real hardware, showing us where the bounds actually land in terms of coupling strengths <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

Kai: That’s the summary of this paper, "Atomic structure calculations for constraining new electron-electron forces" <ref:2608.26532#pg1>.

School of Mathematics and Physics, The University of Queensland

hep-ph, physics.atom-ph

Submitted: 2026-08-27

Updated: 2026-11-02

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures

DOI: 10.1103/s326-3nvs

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: We present a general approach for calculating new electron-electron interactions with atomic structure theory, include dominant many-body effects…

Key concepts

Effective Interaction Lagrangian
This mathematical description summarizes all possible ways new forces can interact with electrons. It sums up contributions from different fermions and their interactions with hypothetical force-carrying particles (bosons), defining the potential that changes the atomic Hamiltonian.
Scalar-Pseudoscalar Interactions
These interactions are promising because their mediators, like axion-like particles, are dark matter candidates. They can be tested by looking for induced electric dipole moments (EDMs) in atoms, which are zero in the Standard Model.
Vector-Axial Vector Interactions
These interactions mediate transitions that are normally forbidden, such as E1-forbidden ones. By comparing these effects to known parity non-conserving (PNC) transition measurements, the study sets new limits on the coupling strength of hypothetical vector bosons in high-mass regions.

Terminology

Summary

We present a general approach for calculating new electron-electron interactions with atomic structure theory, include dominant many-body effects, and extract bounds for parity-odd cases

Theoretical Framework

The paper introduces a general theoretical framework for performing atomic structure calculations in the presence of electron-electron (ee) interactions and demonstrates their utility by extracting and reporting new bounds on their mediators’ coupling constants The interaction-specific contributions are described by the effective interaction Lagrangian where a sum is over all fermions and possible boson-fermion interactions New interactions introduce a potential to the atomic Hamiltonian which is described in general and provides expressions for its inclusion in many-body Dirac-HartreeFock (DHF) atomic structure calculations The new potential takes the form of a Yukawa potential, where Vαβ0 = ħc 8π X j!=k e−µrjk rjk γ0j γ0k Γαβjk, which is valid for all possible electronelectron interactions mediated by scalar (S = 0) or vector (S = 1) bosons

Constraints from Scalar-Pseudoscalar Interactions

Scalar-pseudoscalar interactions are highlighted as a promising example of new physics because their mediators (axion-like particles) are popular dark-matter candidates They can be unambiguously constrained by their induced atomic electric dipole moments (EDMs) since atoms have no EDM within the Standard Model The authors perform calculations to extract bounds on the interaction from experimental EDMs in 133Cs and 205Tl, producing limits on the interaction’s coupling strength for all mediator masses These new bounds are less stringent than existing diamagnetic and molecular limits but account for important many-body effects

Constraints from Vector-Axial Vector Interactions

The paper also performs vector-axial vector (S = 1, P-odd) calculations and reports new bounds for previously unconstrained mass regions These interactions mediate E1-forbidden transitions, such as E6s→7s PNC in cesium, for which the ee contribution has received less attention than the dominant eN interaction The authors calculate the Standard Model ee interaction due to Z0 exchange and then generalize to other masses within the contact limit to extract new constraints on the interaction strength of an arbitrary leptophilic vector boson by comparison with existing measurements of E6s→7s PNC These are the first direct bounds obtained outside of the ultralight region

Methodology and Results

The calculations use the program ampsci which begins by applying the DHF procedure to produce Slater-determinant wavefunctions of Dirac orbitals Corrections accounting for electron correlations are included using the all-orders correlation potential method and extension to the divalent 199Hg system with CI+MBPT For P-odd interactions, many-body corrections are found by self-consistently solving the Dirac equation with perturbed wavefunctions using the TDHF equations The results show that P-even potentials yield energy shifts, while P-odd mix states of opposite parity induce otherwise forbidden matrix elements of atomic operators

Conclusion and Outlook

The paper concludes by presenting a comprehensive method for calculating the atomic effects of any scalar or vector electronelectron interaction and extracting new physics bounds The VA limits provide new bounds for heavy mediator masses which were previously unconstrained The authors note that P-even interactions should be investigated in light systems where many-body effects are small enough to discern such new physics signals They also report an updated calculation of the regular (Standard Model) electronelectron Z0 exchange contribution to the 6s-7s PNC transition amplitude EPNC in cesium The VA limits yield an extracted bound, for mX ≳ 10 MeV, of g e Vg e A/m2 X ≤ 10−11 MeV−2 These are the first atomic bounds for a leptonic VA interaction and the first direct probe of the highmass sector The SP results are in line with previous constraints, while the VA limits provide new bounds for heavy mediator masses which were previously unconstrained The authors also provide an updated estimate for the neutral weak electron-electron contribution to the 6s→7s transition in Cs

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the UQ Fellowship of the Big Questions Institute, by Australian Research Council through DECRA DE210101026 and Discovery Project DP230101685, by the Commonwealth through an Australian Government Research Training Program Scholarship [DOI: https://doi.org/10.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Automated bound extraction for new interactions: The system can automatically compare theoretical calculations of atomic electric dipole moments (EDMs) and parity non-conserving (PNC) transitions against experimental limits to extract bounds on coupling constants for scalar-pseudoscalar and vector-axial vector interactions.

  2. Intermediate mass region constraint identification: The AI can identify regions of insensitivity to new bosons with intermediate masses by analyzing the convergence of results between the massless and contact limits, highlighting areas where current constraints are weakest.

  3. New constraint generation for heavy mediators: The system can generate specific bounds on coupling constants for leptophilic vector bosons in the high-mass sector, ruling out coupling-mass ratios greater than 10-11 MeV-2 above mX 10 MeV based on E6s→7s PNC transitions.

  4. Z boson contribution update: The system can provide an updated calculation of the regular Standard Model electronelectron Z exchange contribution to the 6s-7s PNC transition amplitude EPNC in cesium, including an improved manybody contribution.

  5. Many-body effect modeling for new physics: The AI can incorporate many-body corrections through time-dependent Hartree-Fock (TDHF) methods to account for first-order corrections induced by new electron-electron interactions, improving the accuracy of predictions beyond simple approximations.

Abstract

We present a general approach for calculating new electron-electron interactions with atomic structure theory, include dominant many-body effects, and extract bounds for parity-odd cases. The procedure is valid for any mediator mass and improves previous calculations by including many-body corrections to the new interaction through the time-dependent Hartree-Fock method. Bounds on coupling strengths are then extracted for scalar-pseudoscalar and vector-axial vector interactions by comparison with experimental atomic electric dipole moments and parity non-conserving (PNC) transitions respectively. In the latter case, our calculations rule out any coupling-mass ratio g e V g e A/m X squared greater than 10-11 MeV-2 above m X 10 MeV, covering a previously unconstrained mass region. We also report an updated calculation of the regular (Standard Model) electron-electron Z 0 exchange contribution to the 6s-7s PNC transition amplitude E PNC in cesium.

Sources

Related papers