Multi-Species Multi-Reaction Model Parametrization of a Commercial NCA Positive Electrode from Half-Cell Open-Circuit Potential Data

arXiv:2608.24922 · physics.chem-ph, cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2026-08-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Multi-Species Multi-Reaction Model Parametrization of a Commercial NCA Positive Electrode from Half-Cell Open-Circuit Potential Data".

Paper summary: Kai: So we’re diving into the paper's core idea now. The thesis is that physics-based models of lithium-ion batteries need to account for the open-circuit potential of each electrode as it lithiates. They propose the multi-species multi-reaction model, or MSMR model, to do this in a compact way.

Mira: This model represents every insertion reaction by a standard potential, a site fraction, and a disorder parameter. It’s designed to be thermodynamically grounded for describing that relationship between open-circuit potential and lithiation.

Lev: The paper focuses specifically on parametrizing this MSMR model for nickel-cobalt-aluminum oxide, or NCA, using data from the positive electrode of a commercial silicon graphite/NCA cell.

Kai: What they claim is they use this framework to extract the MSMR parameters from half-cell open-circuit potential measurements. They use a systematic pipeline to address issues like missing data and making sure we can mathematically describe the open-circuit potential curve at all values of absolute stoichiometry.

Mira: The key finding that matters is about aging: they analyze differential capacity curves across different aging states and find that the cathode thermodynamic signature is essentially unchanged by aging.

Lev: Why this matters for the real world, it supports a common modeling practice where you keep the intrinsic parameters fixed at their beginning-of-life values, and then you only adjust cell-level quantities like capacities and alignments to capture degradation.

Kai: This separation keeps the aging model simple and suitable for on-line state estimation strategies in battery management systems. It relies on the assumption that the shape of each electrode open-circuit potential curve is invariant under aging.

Mira: So, this work provides experimental support for holding those intrinsic gallery parameters fixed across aging and attributing all cell voltage changes to capacity and alignment shifts.

Lev: It gives us a concrete way to connect the physical chemistry happening inside the electrode with the measurable electrochemical behavior of the cell in a way that is computationally tractable.

Conclusion: Kai: Looking at the title, "Multi-Species Multi-Reaction Model Parametrization of a Commercial NCA Positive Electrode from Half-Cell Open-Circuit Potential Data," it really tells you exactly what they did: they took real data from a commercial NCA cell to build a specific mathematical description of how that electrode behaves when it charges.

Mira: It’s about making the abstract concepts of multi-species reactions and potentials concrete by fitting them to physical measurements. The authors are essentially defining the parameters for this MSMR model for NCA cathodes based on half-cell OCP data.

Lev: The implication is that this detailed parametrization allows engineers to move beyond just general battery models and start using ones that are tuned specifically to the chemistry of a nickel-rich cathode like NCA.

Kai: It means we can use simpler, more accurate models for things like state estimation on real batteries because we know the underlying thermodynamic behavior isn't changing as much during cycling as some might think.

Mira: Ultimately, this work gives us a tool to better predict how those electrode intrinsic parameters evolve over time by separating the chemistry from the physical degradation of the cell structure.

Lev: For hardware designers, it means less uncertainty when you have to estimate battery health because you have a more physically informed way to model what's happening at that electrochemical level.

Michele Galasso, Petr Cech č, Ivo Horstkürter, Simon Schwunk, žuzana VlŬkovŪ ZivcovŪ, Vϡclav Knap

Department of Electrotechnology, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Czech Technical University in Prague · Heyrovskƭy Institute of the CAS · Department of Physical and Macromolecular Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Charles University · Chair of Vehicle Mechatronics, Dresden University of Technology · Department of Storage System Cell and Control at F. Porsche AG

physics.chem-ph, cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2026-08-18

Updated: 2026-11-18

Comments: 24 pages, 7 figures, 3 tables, plus Supplementary Information (7 pages, 2 figures, 3 tables)

Journal ref: J. Power Sources 700 (2027) 241902

DOI: 10.1016/j.jpowsour.2026.241902

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

The gist: Physics-based models of lithium-ion batteries require the open-circuit potential (OCP) of each electrode as a function of its lithiation The multi-species multi-reaction (MSMR) model provides a…

Key concepts

Multi-Species Multi-Reaction (MSMR) Model
This is a mathematical framework that treats battery insertion as several independent chemical reactions, or 'galleries'. Each gallery has specific parameters like a standard potential, site fraction, and disorder factor. It offers a compact way to describe how different lithium ions enter the material during charging and discharging.
Open-Circuit Potential (OCP)
The OCP is the electrical potential of an electrode when no current is flowing. In this study, it is used as a key measurement to determine the lithiation state of the NCA cathode material. The MSMR model relates this potential directly to how much lithium has been inserted into the material.
Aging Invariance
This finding suggests that the fundamental thermodynamic characteristics of the NCA cathode material do not significantly change over time during battery cycling. This supports a common modeling approach where aging effects are attributed to changes in electrode capacity or physical alignment rather than intrinsic chemical shifts within the cathode structure.

Terminology

Summary

Physics-based models of lithium-ion batteries require the open-circuit potential (OCP) of each electrode as a function of its lithiation The multi-species multi-reaction (MSMR) model provides a compact, thermodynamically grounded description of this relationship, representing each insertion reaction by a standard potential, a site fraction and a disorder parameter Here, we parametrize the MSMR model for nickel-cobalt-aluminum oxide (NCA), a cathode chemistry widespread in automotive cells, using the positive electrode of a commercial silicon-graphite/NCA cell

Model Framework and Application

The MSMR model treats intercalation as a set of independent reactions, or “galleries”, each described by three parameters: a standard potential U0j, a site fraction Xj and a disorder factor ωj Beyond its simplicity, the model has the advantage of providing analytically differentiable expressions for both the OCP and the differential capacity, making possible a simple and lightweight software implementation In this model, each U0j marks a phase transition that appears as a peak in the differential capacity curve, which both aids the diagnosis of electrode behavior and provides a natural way to initialize a parameter fit by inspection This model has been parametrized for a range of active materials, including graphite, silicon, lithium iron phosphate (LFP), spinel manganese oxide (LMO) and layered nickel-manganese-cobalt oxide (NMC)

Data Processing Pipeline

The authors utilized a systematic processing pipeline to extract MSMR parameters from half-cell data This pipeline addresses the “data-quality” problem, the “missing-data” problem, and the “inaccessible-lithium” problem The process involves several steps:

  1. Obtaining smooth differential-capacity curves using histogram counting. p. 0

    Where the paper says it

    Cathode material was harvested from a pristine cell and from cells cycle-aged to the end of life under two state-of-charge windows, and its half-cell OCP was measured by slow galvanostatic cycling. Smooth differential-capacity curves were obtained by histogram counting, and the charge and discharge branches were fitted with a constrained, scale-invariant optimization that keeps every reaction anchored to a visible peak.

  2. Using a separate-branch MSMR fit to recover absolute-stoichiometry OCP relationship. p. 3

    Where the paper says it

    Following the pipeline of Lu et al. , we use the histogram-counting method to obtain smooth differential-capacity curves and the separate-branch MSMR fit (their “Method 5”) to recover the absolute-stoichiometry OCP relationship.

  3. Solving the “inaccessible-lithium” problem by fitting the MSMR model to obtain a mathematical description of the OCP curve defined at all values of the absolute stoichiometry

Key Findings on Aging Invariance

Through a peak analysis of differential-capacity curves across different aging states, the authors show that the cathode thermodynamic signature is essentially unchanged by aging This finding supports the common modeling practice of holding the electrode’s intrinsic parameters fixed and ascribing aging to electrode-level capacity and alignment changes Specifically, for NCA, they report that the cathode thermodynamic signature is essentially unchanged by aging.

Optimization Strategy and Constraints

The optimization procedure uses a trust-region constrained algorithm (trust-constr) to determine the MSMR model parameters Key methodological choices included:

  1. Constraining each U0j to lie within ±30 mV of an initial guess read directly from the differential capacity peaks. p. 3

    Where the paper says it

    Second, through a peak analysis of the differential-capacity curves at different aging states, we show that the cathode thermodynamic signature is essentially unchanged by aging, providing direct support, for NCA, to the common practice of keeping the gallery parameters constant across aging and attributing the whole-cell OCV variations to electrode-level capacity and alignment changes, in the same spirit as the NMC results of Schmitt et al. Third, we improve the robustness of the fit by constraining each U 0 j to lie within ±30 mV of an initial guess read directly from the differential capacity peaks and by enforcing site conservation.

  2. Enforcing site conservation, Pj Xj = 1, and imposing bounds on ωj ∈ [0. p. 3

    Where the paper says it

    Second, through a peak analysis of the differential-capacity curves at different aging states, we show that the cathode thermodynamic signature is essentially unchanged by aging, providing direct support, for NCA, to the common practice of keeping the gallery parameters constant across aging and attributing the whole-cell OCV variations to electrode-level capacity and alignment changes, in the same spirit as the NMC results of Schmitt et al. Third, we improve the robustness of the fit by constraining each U 0 j to lie within ±30 mV of an initial guess read directly from the differential capacity peaks and by enforcing site conservation.

    001, 6.0).

  3. Using a scale-invariant cost function to prevent the optimizer from collapsing the accessible-stoichiometry window. p. 3

    Where the paper says it

    This anchors every gallery to an observed feature, which resolves the degeneracy between broad, nearly flat galleries and the accessible-stoichiometry window, and it is what gives the fitted parameters their interpretation: only a gallery that corresponds to a phase transition can be expected to survive aging unchanged, as the analysis of Section 4 assumes. In addition, we use an improved, scale-invariant cost function to prevent the optimizer from collapsing the accessible-stoichiometry window.

Conclusion and Implications

The study reports the first MSMR model parametrization of an NCA positive electrode, obtained from half-cell OCP measurements on cathode material harvested from a commercial silicon-graphite/NCA cell at beginning of life and at the end of life of two distinct cycle-aging paths The results provide direct experimental support, for NCA, to the widespread modeling practice of holding the intrinsic gallery parameters fixed across aging and attributing the whole-cell OCV changes to electrode-level capacity and alignment shifts The study also has clear limitations, such as confining the analysis to only four galleries at EOL.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can reliably estimate battery open-circuit voltage as a function of state of charge by using a physics-based multi-species multi-reaction model that anchors every gallery to a visible differential capacity peak. This allows for accurate modeling even when electrode OCP curves change slightly due to aging, by attributing OCV variations to electrode capacity and alignment changes.

  2. The improved system can perform robust parameter extraction from noisy half-cell data by employing a systematic processing pipeline that addresses the data-quality, missing-data, and inaccessible-lithium problems. This includes using histogram counting for smoothing differential capacity curves and enforcing physical constraints like site conservation during optimization to prevent non-physical local minima.

  3. The system gains the ability to quantify aging effects on electrode chemistry by comparing models fitted at beginning of life (BOL) against those fitted at end of life (EOL) under different state-of-charge windows. This provides direct experimental support for holding intrinsic gallery parameters fixed across aging and attributing whole-cell OCV variations to electrode-level capacity and alignment shifts.

Abstract

Physics-based models of lithium-ion batteries require the open-circuit potential (OCP) of each electrode as a function of its lithiation. The multi-species multi-reaction (MSMR) model provides a compact, thermodynamically grounded description of this relationship, representing each insertion reaction by a standard potential, a site fraction and a disorder parameter. Here, we parametrize the MSMR model for nickel-cobalt-aluminum oxide (NCA), a cathode chemistry widespread in automotive cells, using the positive electrode of a commercial silicon-graphite/NCA cell. Cathode material was harvested from a pristine cell and from cells cycle-aged to the end of life under two state-of-charge windows, and its half-cell OCP was measured by slow galvanostatic cycling. Smooth differential-capacity curves were obtained by histogram counting, and the charge and discharge branches were fitted with a constrained, scale-invariant optimization that keeps every reaction anchored to a visible peak. We report the first MSMR parameter set for an NCA cathode and show, through a differential-capacity peak analysis across aging states, that its thermodynamic signature is essentially unchanged by aging. This finding supports the common modeling practice of holding the electrode's intrinsic parameters fixed and ascribing aging to electrode-level capacity and alignment changes.

Related papers