Cosmic Evolution of the Standard Model Flavor Charges
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Cosmic Evolution of the Standard Model Flavor Charges".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Since all the Standard Model (SM) parameters have been measured to precision at the percent level or smaller, one would aim to have a framework which describes baryogenesis as precise as possible, where the measured SM parameters are used as inputs <ref:2608.19562#pg2>.
Kai: Framework Development The paper introduces a complete flavor-covariant Boltzmann equations to describe the evolution of Standard Model quark and lepton flavor charges using measured SM parameters as inputs <ref:2608.19562#pg4>.
Mira: To achieve flavor-basis independence for physical observables, it requires five density matrices in flavor spaces: three for quarks and two for leptons <ref:2608.19562#pg2>.
Kai: This framework incorporates quantum chromodynamics, electroweak sphaleron interactions, and all Yukawa interactions to obtain the complete flavor-covariant Boltzmann equations <ref:2608.19562#pg4>.
Paper summary: Kai: So we're wrapping up on Cosmic Evolution of the Standard Model Flavor Charges, and looking at what it means for us as a whole. This paper is essentially about creating a framework that describes baryogenesis with high precision using the Standard Model parameters we already have measured.
Mira: The authors show that by using this complete flavor-covariant approach, they can describe the evolution of all fifteen Standard Model flavor charges in a way that is independent of our chosen flavor basis, which is a big deal for making predictions about physical observables.
Lev: They also gave us the effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism, which is useful when we assume chemical equilibrium in the lepton sector at a given temperature to simplify the study of quark sector baryogenesis.
Kai: The results show that this framework works consistently across different scenarios, like type-I and type-II leptogenesis, and for cloistered baryogenesis involving quarks, with deviations only around four percent.
Mira: It means we have a more rigorous way to handle the interplay between quarks and leptons during these processes than we had before when using simpler approximations.
Lev: The BOLEH code is a tangible output here; it’s a generic tool that lets other researchers plug in different particle models and see how their asymmetries evolve numerically using this formalism.
Kai: So, the authors are giving us not just a set of equations, but a complete toolkit for calculating these asymmetries based on our current best measurements of the Standard Model parameters.
Mira: The implication is that we can push our precision in understanding baryogenesis models much further by using this flavor-covariant structure as the foundation.
Lev: And they’ve shown how to handle the complexities of incorporating all those Standard Model interactions correctly into these calculations, which is what makes this paper important for connecting theory to potential experimental signatures.
Conclusion: Kai: So this paper, "Cosmic Evolution of the Standard Model Flavor Charges," it really wraps up by showing how to model baryogenesis using all those Standard Model parameters we measure so precisely.
Mira: Right, it's about taking that precision and building a framework—a complete set of Boltzmann equations—to describe how those quark and lepton flavor charges evolve over time.
Lev: From my side, the main thing is that they’ve got this full formalism, which is super complex with all the QCD and electroweak stuff included. We need to know if that complexity actually translates to something we can simulate on real hardware.
Kai: Yeah, it shows consistency between their complete formalism and these effective versions they derived for the quark sector. It even gives us a reduced system for just quark-sector baryogenesis.
Mira: The implication is that we can test these scenarios—like type-I or type-II leptogenesis—with much less approximation than before, using the constraints from our measured Standard Model parameters.
Lev: If this framework holds up when you try to run it on real hardware, then it gives us a way to see if these theoretical asymmetries match any potential experimental hints we might find later.
Kai: It’s about putting all those pieces together into one coherent picture of how the universe gets its matter-antimatter imbalance.
Mira: And that's what this work really is—a unified description of flavor dynamics in the early universe that connects different types of processes.
Lev: The code they released, BOLEH, it’s a testbed for that whole thing, mapping all those matrices into something you can numerically integrate.
Kai: So we've got the theory here, and now we have a tool to actually run the numbers and see what happens.
Chee Sheng Fong, Sergio Manuel Cubides Pérez
Centro de Ciências Naturais e Humanas, Universidade Federal do ABC · Center for Theoretical Underground Physics and Related Areas (CETUP) · Institute for Underground Science at Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF)
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-08-20
Updated: 2026-08-20
Comments: 28 pages, 9 figures; comments are welcome!
DOI: 10.1103/5jxc-7fxb
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
Importance score: 79/100
The gist: Since all the Standard Model (SM) parameters have been measured to precision at the percent level or smaller…
Key concepts
- Flavor-Covariant Boltzmann Equations
- These are equations that track the change in the distribution of quark and lepton flavor charges as the universe cools. The 'flavor-covariant' aspect ensures that physical results remain independent of how you choose to group or label different quark and lepton flavors, making the description robust.
- Effective Quark Formalism (effQ)
- This simplified approach relates the asymmetry of a single particle species to its total charges through temperature-dependent coefficients. It provides useful expressions for effective charges across different temperature regimes, allowing researchers to handle various thermal conditions more easily.
- Baryogenesis Scenarios
- The paper tests its framework against two main processes: leptogenesis (generating asymmetry via leptons) and cloistered baryogenesis (generating asymmetry primarily in the quark sector). The consistency shown across these distinct scenarios validates the comprehensive nature of the developed formalism.
Terminology
Summary
Since all the Standard Model (SM) parameters have been measured to precision at the percent level or smaller, one would aim to have a framework which describes baryogenesis as precise as possible, where the measured SM parameters are used as inputs <ref:2608. p. 0 Cosmic Evolution of the Standard Model Flavor Charges
Chee Sheng Fong1, ∗ and Sergio Manuel Cubides Pérez1, †
1Centro de Ciências Naturais e Humanas,
Universidade Federal do ABC, 09. 210-170, Santo André, SP, Brazil
Abstract
Since all the Standard Model (SM) parameters have been measured to precision at the percent
level or smaller, one would aim to have a framework which describes baryogenesis as precise as
possible, where the measured SM parameters are used as inputs.Where the paper says it
Framework Development
The paper introduces a complete flavor-covariant Boltzmann equations to describe the evolution of Standard Model quark and lepton flavor charges using measured SM parameters as inputs <ref:2608.19562#pg4>. To achieve flavor-basis independence for physical observables, it requires five density matrices in flavor spaces: three for quarks and two for leptons <ref:2608. p. 0 At high temperature before
the electroweak symmetry breaking, the SM contains 15 approximate U(1) symmetries with the
associated flavor charges. To describe the evolutions of these flavor charges in a flavor-basiscovariant manner such that physical observables are flavor-basis-independent, a total of five density
matrices in flavor spaces are required: three for quarks and two for leptons. To describe the evolutions of these flavor charges in a flavor-basiscovariant manner such that physical observables are flavor-basis-independent, a total of five density
matrices in flavor spaces are required: three for quarks and two for leptons. Taking into account
the quantum chromodynamics and electroweak sphaleron interactions together with all the Yukawa
interactions, we obtain the complete flavor-covariant Boltzmann equations.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Formalism Derivations
The authors derive a new effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism applicable when baryogenesis occurs through number asymmetry generation in the quark sector, assuming chemical equilibrium in the lepton sector at a given temperature <ref:2608.19562#pg4>. This involves generalizing the study to include the evolutions of three quark flavor charges, n∆Q, n∆U and n∆D <ref:2608. p. 2 [7] shows that in order to describe
evolution of lepton flavor charges in a flavor-basis-independent manner, we need to follow
the evolutions of both n∆ℓ and n∆E while the effects of quark Yukawa interactions can
be captured effectively through temperature-dependent coefficients, obtained by assuming
quark chemical equilibrium at a given temperature. In this work, we first generalize the
study to include also the evolutions of three quark flavor charges n∆Q, n∆U and n∆D. To verify the consistency of this complete formalism, we first apply it to leptogenesis
scenarios, reproducing previous results which utilize the effective lepton-flavor-covariant formalism
up to small corrections due to the quark chemical equilibrium approximations used in the latter
formalism. Then, for the first time, we apply the complete formalism as well as the effective
quark-flavor-covariant formalism to a cloistered baryogenesis scenario where number asymmetries
are generated in the quark sector, showcasing the good agreement between the results from the
two formalisms.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Effective Quark Formalism
The effective quark-flavor-covariant (effQ) formalism is derived by relating the asymmetry of a particle species Y∆i to charges Y∆x through a set of relations involving temperature-dependent coefficients <ref:2608.19562#pg10>. This results in expressions for the effective charges at different temperature regimes, summarized in Table I <ref:2608. p. 9 (30) for cQ1
, cQ2
, cH1 and cH2
, and the results are summarized in Table I. The transitions between the temperature regime of the coefficients are well described by
3 Since B − L is conserved in the SM, they are not independent conditions and one only has to impose
either baryon or lepton number conservation. Then,
we further derive a new effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism which is applicable to
baryogenesis mechanism that generates number asymmetries in the quark sector, while the
lepton sector is assumed to be in chemical equilibrium at a given temperature. To verify the complete formalism, we first apply it to the well-established leptogenesis
scenarios [9, 10] and compare the results against those obtained from the effective leptonflavor-covariant formalism of ref.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Applications and Verification
The complete formalism and the effL formalism are applied to type-I and type-II leptogenesis scenarios, showing good agreements with results obtained under approximations where quarks achieve chemical equilibrium at various temperatures <ref:2608.19562#pg4>. For cloistered baryogenesis involving quarks, the complete formalism and the effQ formalism show very good agreement, with deviations from the complete result leading to only a ∼ 4% difference in final baryon asymmetries <ref:2608. p. 0 Then, for the first time, we apply the complete formalism as well as the effective
quark-flavor-covariant formalism to a cloistered baryogenesis scenario where number asymmetries
are generated in the quark sector, showcasing the good agreement between the results from the
two formalisms. Finally, we release the first generic baryogenesis public code BOLEH (BaryOn and
Lepton charge Evolution in the Hot big bang) where all the SM interactions are taken into
account.Where the paper says it
Code Release
The work culminates in the release of a generic baryogenesis public code named BOLEH (BaryOn and Lepton charge Evolution in the Hot big bang), which implements all three formalisms: (i) the complete formalism, (ii) the effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism, and (iii) the effective lepton-flavor-covariant formalism <ref:2608.19562#pg4>. The code maps 3 × 3 Hermitian matrices representing quark and lepton asymmetries into a vector state for numerical integration <ref:2608. p. 2 Then,
we further derive a new effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism which is applicable to
baryogenesis mechanism that generates number asymmetries in the quark sector, while the
lepton sector is assumed to be in chemical equilibrium at a given temperature. To verify the complete formalism, we first apply it to the well-established leptogenesis
scenarios [9, 10] and compare the results against those obtained from the effective leptonflavor-covariant formalism of ref.Where the paper says it
Conclusions
The study presents the first consistent treatment of all relevant Standard Model interactions in leptogenesis and cloistered baryogenesis <ref:2608.19562#pg4>. The authors demonstrate the consistency between the complete and effL formalisms in describing leptogenesis, yielding a final baryon asymmetry of Y final B = 1. p. 0 To verify the consistency of this complete formalism, we first apply it to leptogenesis
scenarios, reproducing previous results which utilize the effective lepton-flavor-covariant formalism
up to small corrections due to the quark chemical equilibrium approximations used in the latter
formalism. Then, for the first time, we apply the complete formalism as well as the effective
quark-flavor-covariant formalism to a cloistered baryogenesis scenario where number asymmetries
are generated in the quark sector, showcasing the good agreement between the results from the
two formalisms. Nonzero YB−L can be generated by introducing new physics processes which violate B−L,
as source terms in any of the Boltzmann equations (14)–(18). When the EW sphaleron
interaction freezes out at T = 132 GeV [18], the final B asymmetry is given by [12, 19]
Y
final
B = 0. manuel@ufabc. br
1
arXiv:2608. To verify the consistency of this complete formalism, we first apply it to leptogenesis
scenarios, reproducing previous results which utilize the effective lepton-flavor-covariant formalism
up to small corrections due to the quark chemical equilibrium approximations used in the latter
formalism. Then, for the first time, we apply the complete formalism as well as the effective
quark-flavor-covariant formalism to a cloistered baryogenesis scenario where number asymmetries
are generated in the quark sector, showcasing the good agreement between the results from the
two formalisms. Then, for the first time, we apply the complete formalism as well as the effective
quark-flavor-covariant formalism to a cloistered baryogenesis scenario where number asymmetries
are generated in the quark sector, showcasing the good agreement between the results from the
two formalisms. Finally, we release the first generic baryogenesis public code BOLEH (BaryOn and
Lepton charge Evolution in the Hot big bang) where all the SM interactions are taken into
account.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge support from the Center for Theoretical Underground Physics and Related Areas (CETUP) and the Institute for Underground Science at Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF) <ref:2608.19562#pg24>. The authors also acknowledge support by Fundacão de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP) Contract No. 2019/11197-6 and Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq) under Contract No. 304917/2023-6 and SMCP acknowledges the support by FAPESP Contract No. 2024/17752-0 <ref:2608. p. 0 manuel@ufabc. br
1
arXiv:2608.Where the paper says it
Appendix Details
Appendix A collects relevant equations for the effective lepton-flavor-covariant formalism, including the Boltzmann equation for Y∆˜ and relations defining Y∆l and Y∆H <ref:2608.19562#pg25>. Appendix B describes the generic baryogenesis code BOLEH, detailing its structure with physics, solver, and interface modules <ref:2608. p. 2 Finally, we conclude in Section VI. In Appendix B, we
describe the generic baryogenesis code BOLEH. INTRODUCTION
All the parameters of the Standard Model (SM) at some specific scales have now been
measured to precision at percent level or better and have served as inputs for further
experimental predictions. In cosmology, the SM will then serve as the benchmark particle
physics model. manuel@ufabc. br
1
arXiv:2608. manuel@ufabc. br
1
arXiv:2608. where we have used the one-loop renormalization group equation (RGE) running of the SM
gauge couplings at energy scale µ = 2πT with T = 1012 GeV for EW and T = 1013 GeV for
QCD. Considering the Yukawa interactions in eq. where we have used the one-loop renormalization group equation (RGE) running of the SM
gauge couplings at energy scale µ = 2πT with T = 1012 GeV for EW and T = 1013 GeV for
QCD. Considering the Yukawa interactions in eq. manuel@ufabc. br
1
arXiv:2608. Then,
we further derive a new effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism which is applicable to
baryogenesis mechanism that generates number asymmetries in the quark sector, while the
lepton sector is assumed to be in chemical equilibrium at a given temperature. To verify the complete formalism, we first apply it to the well-established leptogenesis
scenarios [9, 10] and compare the results against those obtained from the effective leptonflavor-covariant formalism of ref. asymmetries, directly reproduces YB−L,
YB−L = TrY∆˜ QL +
1
3
TrY∆U +
1
3
TrY∆D. (28)
Notice that we only have to follow the evolution of Y∆˜ QL in place of the evolutions of Y∆ℓ
and Y∆E, thereby reducing the variables of total system by 2 × 9 = 18, corresponding to
that of the two Hermitian matrices Y∆ℓ and Y∆E.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved system can perform precise baryogenesis modeling by integrating all Standard Model interactions, including QCD and electroweak sphaleron interactions, using flavor-covariant Boltzmann equations to describe quark and lepton flavor charges as inputs from measured SM parameters.
-
The system can accurately simulate leptogenesis scenarios by applying the complete formalism or the effective lepton-flavor-covariant formalism to reproduce previous results with high precision, even when considering small corrections due to approximations like quark chemical equilibrium.
-
The system can execute cloistered baryogenesis simulations where number asymmetries are generated in the quark sector by employing a new effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism, demonstrating good agreement between the complete and effective formalisms for this specific scenario.
-
The system can generate a generic baryogenesis public code BOLEH that implements all three formalisms (complete, effective quark-flavor-covariant, and effective lepton-flavor-covariant), allowing for the application to other new physics models by specifying additional dynamical degrees of freedom and source/washout terms.
-
The system can determine the relevant temperature regimes for various effective charges based on the evolution of coefficients like cQ1(T), cQ2(T), cH1(T) and cH2(T), which are parameterized by exponential functions derived from RGE running of gauge couplings and Yukawa interactions.
Abstract
Since all the Standard Model (SM) parameters have been measured to precision at the percent level or smaller, one would aim to have a framework which describes baryogenesis as precise as possible, where the measured SM parameters are used as inputs. At high temperature before the electroweak symmetry breaking, the SM contains 15 approximate U(1) symmetries with the associated flavor charges. To describe the evolutions of these flavor charges in a flavor-basis-covariant manner such that physical observables are flavor-basis-independent, a total of five density matrices in flavor spaces are required: three for quarks and two for leptons. Taking into account the quantum chromodynamics and electroweak sphaleron interactions together with all the Yukawa interactions, we obtain the complete flavor-covariant Boltzmann equations. By imposing chemical equilibrium in the lepton sector, we further derive a new effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism which can be used when baryogenesis occurs through number asymmetry generation in the quark sector. To verify the consistency of this complete formalism, we first apply it to leptogenesis scenarios, reproducing previous results which utilize the effective lepton-flavor-covariant formalism up to small corrections due to the quark chemical equilibrium approximations used in the latter formalism. Then, for the first time, we apply the complete formalism as well as the effective quark-flavor-covariant formalism to a cloistered baryogenesis scenario where number asymmetries are generated in the quark sector, showcasing the good agreement between the results from the two formalisms. Finally, we release the first generic baryogenesis public code BOLEH (BaryOn and Lepton charge Evolution in the Hot big bang) where all the SM interactions are taken into account.
Sources
- BICEP / Keck XIII: Improved Constraints on Primordial Gravitational Waves using Planck, WMAP, and BICEP/Keck Observations through the 2018 Observing Season
- A Matter-Antimatter Universe?
- Computing the Strong Sphaleron Rate
- Cosmic Evolution of Lepton Flavor Charges
- Baryogenesis in the Standard Model and its Supersymmetric Extension
- Leptogenesis in the Universe
- Cloistered Baryogenesis
- Baryogenesis from Symmetry Principle
- Wash-In Leptogenesis
- Sphaleron rate in the symmetric electroweak phase
- Do We Understand the Sphaleron Rate?
- Spectator Effects during Leptogenesis in the Strong Washout Regime
- Scattering Rates For Leptogenesis: Damping of Lepton Flavour Coherence and Production of Singlet Neutrinos
- The Sphaleron Rate in the Minimal Standard Model
- Leptogenesis in SO(10) with Minimal Yukawa sector
- Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters
- Leptogenesis with heavy neutrino flavours: from density matrix to Boltzmann equations
- One Phase to Rule Them All: Spontaneous CP Violation and Leptogenesis in SO(10)
- ULYSSES: Universal LeptogeneSiS Equation Solver
- Spectator processes and baryogenesis
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses