The VariableTNG project: mass-dependent regulation of galaxy morphology by baryonic feedback
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The VariableTNG project".
Title and authors: Vera: So we're looking at the paper "The VariableTNG project: mass-dependent regulation of galaxy morphology by baryonic feedback," and it’s about how changing the physics inside a simulation suite can fundamentally change how galaxies look, even when they start off in exactly the same spot.
Jocelyn: It’s interesting because they used this VariableTNG suite to test eight different knobs—four for stellar stuff and four for active galactic nuclei feedback—to see exactly which ones control the shape of a galaxy.
Subrahmanyan: And what they found is that this control isn't universal; it shifts depending on how big the galaxy is, which directly connects to how much mass you're talking about in structure formation models.
Vera: Exactly, and for those lower-mass galaxies under ten to eleven billion solar masses, the main thing controlling the look of a galaxy is this supernova temperature, or TSN.
Jocelyn: Higher TSN values in these smaller galaxies are linked to larger core sizes and a bigger disc fraction because that feedback delays early star formation and helps build up a denser gas reservoir that supports rotation.
Subrahmanyan: That tells us that for those systems, stellar feedback is the dominant force dictating how discs form and survive before any other big factors come into play.
Vera: But then when you look at the most massive systems, those over ten to eleven billion solar masses, things change dramatically because AGN feedback takes over as the key driver of structural evolution.
Jocelyn: Specifically, they looked at a parameter called the quasar-mode coupling efficiency, or epsilon f high, and found that larger values in this parameter tend to be associated with more disc-like massive galaxies.
Subrahmanyan: That suggests a strong early quasar-mode feedback suppresses black hole growth and then reduces the later radio-mode feedback that usually depletes central gas reservoirs and kills rotational support.
Vera: So, the paper shows that morphology is tied to these mass-dependent pathways, not just when mergers happen or what the initial conditions are—it’s all about how feedback scales with stellar mass.
Jocelyn: And they also looked at how this relates to size evolution and found that stellar feedback governs size variation at low masses, while AGN feedback dominates the massive end.
Subrahmanyan: If we think about this for structure formation, it means our models need to account for this mass-dependent switch in physics because the dominant regulator changes depending on whether you are looking at a small galaxy or a very large one.
Vera: They also pointed out that size evolution is tied to these feedback regimes too; stellar feedback governs size variation at low masses, and AGN feedback dominates the massive end.
Jocelyn: Their method, using ten thousand two hundred forty-three dark matter particles and ten thousand two hundred forty-three gas cells across eight varied parameters, gives us a really controlled way to map out how these physical processes affect structure formation on different scales.
Subrahmanyan: The paper's limitation is that it relies on this specific simulation suite and fixed initial conditions, so it doesn't fully capture the complexity of an entire universe evolving randomly over time.
Vera: That’s fair; a single realization study has its limits when trying to model the full cosmic tapestry, but what they do here provides a crucial baseline for understanding how baryonic physics sets the initial structural rules before mergers take over.
Jocelyn: So, we've seen how testing these systematic variations in baryonic feedback regulates morphological diversity across mass scales using this VariableTNG project. We’ll be looking at new work soon.
The paper's summary: Vera: So, to recap what we just talked about, this paper shows that when you keep the starting conditions exactly the same in a simulation, changing how much feedback—whether from stars or from black holes—we use really changes how a galaxy ends up looking.
Jocelyn: Exactly. They used this VariableTNG suite with ten thousand two hundred forty-three dark matter particles and ten thousand two hundred forty-three gas cells to systematically tweak eight different knobs controlling the physics, and they found that morphology really responds strongly to those variations across different mass scales.
Subrahmanyan: The main point is that the engine driving a galaxy's structure changes depending on its stellar mass. At low masses, it's all about stellar feedback controlling disc formation. But at higher masses, you switch gears and AGN feedback takes over as the main thing shaping the final structure.
Vera: And for those smaller galaxies, they pinpoint the supernoval temperature, that TSN value, as a key control because it dictates how early star formation starts and builds up that gas reservoir that supports rotation.
Jocelyn: Higher TSN in those low-mass systems means larger core sizes and a bigger disc fraction, so stellar feedback is what's building those structures.
Subrahmanyan: But then for the biggest galaxies, where you’re way past ten billion solar masses, the sensitivity shifts to AGN feedback parameters like that quasar-mode coupling efficiency.
Vera: That means a stronger early quasar-mode feedback tends to suppress black hole growth and then reduces the later radio-mode feedback that usually clears out the gas and destroys rotational support.
Jocelyn: It’s about how the energy is injected over time, not just one quick burst from the black hole. The paper also looked at size evolution, and they found stellar feedback governs how size varies at low masses while AGN feedback dominates at high masses.
Subrahmanyan: If you think about this for structure formation models, it means we need to account for this mass-dependent switch in physics because the dominant regulator changes depending on whether you are looking at a small galaxy or a very large one.
Vera: They also pointed out that size evolution is tied to those feedback regimes too; stellar feedback governs size variation at low masses, and AGN feedback dominates the massive end.
Jocelyn: The paper's limitation is that it relies on this specific simulation suite and fixed initial conditions, so it doesn't fully capture the complexity of an entire universe evolving randomly over time.
Subrahmanyan: That’s fair; a single realization study has its limits when trying to model the full cosmic tapestry, but what they do here provides a crucial baseline for understanding how baryonic physics sets the initial structural rules before mergers take over.
Vera: So, we've seen how testing these systematic variations in baryonic feedback regulates morphological diversity across mass scales using this VariableTNG project. We’ll be looking at new work soon.
The paper's improvements: Subrahmanyan: So, we're talking about the suggested improvements for this VariableTNG work on mass-dependent feedback and morphology regulation.
Vera: They suggest using machine learning models to incorporate those mass-dependent pathways directly into them to make predictions for galaxy morphology based on stellar mass and black hole mass.
Jocelyn: That's a big step because it means we can use these simulations not just to see what happens, but we can build tools that can predict the morphology of new galaxies just by knowing their basic properties.
Subrahmanyan: And they propose a better physical way to interpret how supernova temperature, that TSN value, affects cold gas dynamics in low-mass galaxies by integrating it into gas cycle models.
Vera: That's important because now they can actually separate the simple idea of star formation being suppressed from the more complex process of how the gas accumulates, cools down, and settles before stars actually form within those smaller systems.
Jocelyn: And for the massive galaxies, they refined their assessment of structural evolution by using time-integrated AGN feedback metrics to predict final morphology at different redshifts.
Subrahmanyan: That’s a way to better distinguish between the effect where a larger quasar-mode coupling efficiency couples more thermal energy to surrounding gas in that early phase versus the later impact of radio-mode feedback on gas depletion and destroying rotational support.
Vera: They also found a way to predict galaxy size evolution more accurately by linking how far the gas reservoir extends to how much stellar component grows under those different feedback regimes.
Jocelyn: So, if you think about these improvements, it’s moving us from just describing what happens in one simulation run to creating predictive models for what we see out there in actual telescopes.
Subrahmanyan: It really solidifies the idea that the physics of galaxy formation isn't a single fixed rule; it's a set of rules that change based on mass, and these new methods help us map those changing rules better.
Conclusion: Vera: So we've covered how testing eight different parameters in VariableTNG shows that galaxy morphology really responds strongly to mass-dependent feedback when we hold the initial conditions fixed across different scales, and that's what this paper is all about.
Jocelyn: Basically, stellar feedback controls disc formation in lower-mass galaxies, but AGN self-regulation and radio-mode feedback dominate the structural evolution of massive systems.
Subrahmanyan: If you think about this for cosmology, it means structure formation models need to account for this mass-dependent switch in physics because the dominant regulator changes depending on whether you are looking at a small galaxy or a very large one.
Vera: And they also point out that size evolution is tied to those regimes too; stellar feedback governs size variation at low masses, and AGN feedback dominates the massive end.
Jocelyn: The paper’s limitation is that it relies on this specific simulation suite and fixed initial conditions, so it doesn't fully capture the complexity of an entire universe evolving randomly over time.
Subrahmanyan: That’s fair; a single realization study has its limits when trying to model the full cosmic tapestry, but what they do here provides a crucial baseline for understanding how baryonic physics sets the initial structural rules before mergers take over.
Vera: So, we've seen how testing these systematic variations in baryonic feedback regulates morphological diversity across mass scales using this VariableTNG project. We’ll be looking at new work soon.
Yikai Liu, Hong Guo, Volker Springel, Kexin Liu, Luis C. Ho, BoCheng Zhu
Shanghai Astronomical Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences · University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China · Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, Karl-Schwarzschild-Straße 1, 85740 Garching bei München · Kavli Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Peking University, Beijing 100871 China · Department of Astronomy, School of Physics, Peking University, Beijing 100871 China · Institute of Astrophysics, School of Physics, Zhengzhou University China · Key Laboratory for Computational Astrophysics, National Astronomical Observatories Chinese Academy of Sciences
astro-ph.GA
Submitted: 2026-08-20
Updated: 2026-08-20
Journal ref: A&A 715, A342 (2026)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202661456
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 94/100
The gist: Galaxy morphology is shaped by mass-dependent feedback pathways in addition to merger-driven evolution> This paper uses the VariableTNG (VTNG) simulation suite to quantify how systematic variations…
Key concepts
- Stellar Feedback (TSN)
- This refers to how the temperature of supernovae influences early star formation. In lower-mass galaxies, this temperature is key to forming dense, rotationally supported gas reservoirs and determining if a galaxy develops a disc structure.
- AGN Feedback ($\epsilon_{f,high}$)
- At high masses, feedback from the central supermassive black hole (AGN) becomes crucial. The efficiency of this early quasar-mode coupling dictates whether the resulting massive galaxy will be disc-like or more spheroidal by suppressing growth and later radio-mode effects.
- Radio-Mode Feedback
- This refers to feedback from the central black hole that occurs later in a galaxy's life. It is primarily responsible for depleting central gas reservoirs and actively destroying rotational support, which is a key factor in shaping the final structure of massive galaxies.
Terminology
Summary
Galaxy morphology is shaped by mass-dependent feedback pathways in addition to merger-driven evolution> This paper uses the VariableTNG (VTNG) simulation suite to quantify how systematic variations in baryonic feedback regulate the morphological diversity of galaxies while keeping initial conditions fixed> The results show that galaxy morphology responds strongly to mass-dependent feedback pathways under controlled initial conditions
Quantifying Morphological Regulation
The VTNG simulation suite was designed to explore how eight parameters governing stellar and AGN feedback regulate galaxy morphology while adopting identical initial conditions across all realizations This controlled design, together with the numerical resolution of the suite, makes VTNG well suited to studying internal galaxy morphology and stellar kinematics The simulation volume is a periodic box of side length 50 h −1 Mpc, resolved with 10243 dark matter particles and 10243 gas cells The eight VTNG parameters varied in this work, which include four that regulate star formation and stellar feedback, and four that govern black-hole growth and AGN feedback
Mass-Dependent Feedback Pathways
The dominant regulating mechanism depends strongly on stellar mass, with stellar feedback primarily driving the morphological response in lower-mass galaxies For M∗ ≲ 1011 M⊙, morphology is primarily controlled by the supernoval temperature TSN, which delays early star formation and promotes the buildup of a denser and more rotationally supported gas reservoir Higher TSN is associated with larger κco and a larger disc fraction In low- and intermediate-mass galaxies, morphology is most strongly sensitive to the supernova temperature TSN Higher TSN is associated with higher κco and a larger disc fraction
AGN Dominance at High Mass
At higher masses, morphology becomes increasingly sensitive to AGN feedback, especially the quasar-mode coupling efficiency ϵf,high In the most massive systems, M∗ > 1011 M⊙, the dominant sensitivity shifts to AGN-related parameters, especially the quasar-mode coupling efficiency ϵf,high A larger ϵf,high tends to be associated with more disc-like massive galaxies This suggests that stronger early quasar-mode feedback suppresses black hole growth and thereby reduces the later radio-mode feedback that more efficiently depletes central gas reservoirs and suppresses rotational support The cumulative radio-mode energy correlates much more directly with morphology than the quasar-mode energy Morphology therefore responds primarily to the time-integrated regulation of the gas reservoir rather than to short-timescale AGN variability
Structural and Size Evolution
The mass–size relation is also strongly affected by feedback, with stellar feedback governing size variation at low masses and AGN feedback dominating at high masses At high masses, the much larger scatter in the VTNG mass-size relation suggests that size evolution reflects the Article number, page 10>
Conclusion on Feedback Roles
The results show that galaxy morphology in VTNG is regulated by mass-dependent feedback pathways in addition to merger-driven evolution Stellar feedback primarily governs how discs form and survive in lower-mass galaxies, whereas AGN self-regulation and subsequent radio-mode feedback dominate the structural evolution of massive systems Stellar feedback primarily governs how discs form and survive in lower-mass galaxies, whereas AGN self-regulation and subsequent radio-mode feedback dominate the structural evolution of massive systems Stellar feedback primarily governs how discs form and survive in lower-mass galaxies, whereas AGN self-regulation and subsequent radio-mode feedback dominate the structural evolution of massive systems
Final Summary of Findings
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced morphology prediction capability for galaxies by incorporating mass-dependent feedback pathways into machine learning models. The improved system can now predict galaxy morphology based on stellar mass and black hole mass by utilizing partial rank correlation coefficients and random forest regression importance, as shown in Figure 2 and 3 of the paper.
-
Improved physical interpretation of feedback effects on cold gas dynamics in low-mass galaxies by integrating the effect of supernova temperature TSN into gas cycle models. The system can now differentiate between the suppression of star formation and the regulation of how
gas accumulates, cools, and settles before forming stars,
as suggested by Figure 6. -
Refined assessment of massive galaxy structural evolution using time-integrated AGN feedback metrics to predict final morphology at different redshifts. The improved model can now distinguish between effects where a
larger ϵf,high couples more thermal energy to the surrounding gas during this early phase
versus the later impact of radio-mode feedback ongas depletion and the destruction of rotational support.
-
More accurate prediction of galaxy size evolution by linking gas reservoir extent to stellar component growth under varying feedback regimes. The system can now predict that
realizations with larger gas discs also tend to host larger stellar components, indicating that feedback can influence not only whether discs survive, but also how far the stellar distribution grows.
Abstract
Galaxy morphology is shaped by both assembly history and baryonic processes, but their relative roles remain uncertain. We use the VariableTNG (VTNG) simulation suite to investigate how variations in baryonic feedback regulate galaxy morphology while keeping the initial conditions fixed. VTNG consists of cosmological magnetohydrodynamic simulations performed with the moving-mesh code AREPO, varying eight parameters governing stellar and AGN feedback. At z=1, we characterize morphology using κ co, v/σ, and the axis ratio c/a. We find substantial morphological diversity across feedback models, with the dominant mechanism strongly dependent on stellar mass. For M 10 11, M, morphology is primarily controlled by the supernova temperature T SN: larger T SN delays early star formation, promotes a denser and more rotationally supported gas reservoir, and favours subsequent disc growth through in-situ star formation. At higher masses, morphology becomes increasingly sensitive to AGN feedback, particularly the quasar-mode coupling efficiency ε f,high. Higher ε f,high suppresses early black hole growth, thereby weakening subsequent radio-mode feedback associated with gas depletion and loss of rotational support. The resulting morphology--mass relation is non-monotonic, with maximum rotational support at intermediate stellar masses. Our results demonstrate that baryonic feedback regulates galaxy morphology through distinct mass-dependent pathways, with stellar feedback dominating at lower masses and AGN self-regulation becoming increasingly important at the massive end.
Related papers
- The Pristine survey XXVIII. Journey to the Galactic outskirts: Mapping the outer halo red giant stars down to the very metal-poor end
- Origins of Extreme Emission-Line Ratios in z > 3 Galaxies: Insights from the Lumen Model
- The Kinematically Hot, Extremely Metal-Poor C-19 Stellar Stream in DESI DR2
- UV slopes of Starforming Galaxies in Strong Lensing fields at the Epoch of Reionization with JWST
- Evolution of Binaries Under Stochastic Perturbations
- The hydrodynamical response of cold circumgalactic clouds to quasar radiation