The fraction of periodic SN Ib/c light curves

arXiv:2608.18207 · astro-ph.HE · Submitted 2026-08-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The fraction of periodic SN Ib/c light curves".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Periodic luminosity modulations have been recently identified for the stripped-envelope supernovae SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, motivating a systematic search for a similar behavior in a larger sample.

Vera: This paper performs the first systematic search for periodic modulation in a sample of 34 Type Ib/c supernovae with high quality photometry from the Zwicky Transient Facility.

Jocelyn: The results suggest that periodically modulated SN 2022jli-like events may represent a significant sub-population of strippedenvelope supernovae rather than being exceptionally rare events.

Vera: The authors developed and applied a statistically rigorous pipeline for detecting periodic modulation in light curves.

Title and authors: Vera: So Jocelyn, this paper is titled "The fraction of periodic SN Ib/c light curves," and the authors are Asaf Horowicz, Eran O. Ofek, and Avishay Gal-Yam. It's about searching for periodic modulations in stripped-envelope supernovae like SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, which we've already heard about <ref:2608.18207#pg1,SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa>.

Jocelyn: Yeah, and the title tells us they are focusing on how common this periodicity actually is across a bigger sample of these types of supernovae. It suggests they're trying to figure out if these periodic events are just one weird outlier or something that happens more often than we thought.

Subrahmanyan: If this paper confirms a higher fraction, say twenty percent or more, it means we might be seeing a whole sub-population of stripped-envelope supernovae that have some kind of binary system influence on their explosions, rather than just isolated rare events.

Vera: Exactly. The core idea is to systematically search for this behavior in a large sample using Zwicky Transient Facility photometry. They're motivated by those initial detections in SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, but now they want to see if it's a general trend or just noise <ref:2608.18207#pg1,SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa>.

Jocelyn: So the search itself is pretty rigorous, trying to find these modulations by fitting a specific kind of mathematical model to the light curves. It sounds like they're not just looking for random wiggles in the data but something more structured.

Subrahmanyan: That structure would be key. If we can prove it's a statistically significant signal in a large sample, that points toward an underlying physical mechanism, like repeated common envelope interactions in binary systems after the supernova explodes.

The paper's summary: Vera: Basically, the paper does the systematic search and they find some interesting results. They developed a statistically rigorous pipeline to look for these modulations, which is quite sophisticated.

Jocelyn: And they managed to recover the light curves of SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa again, plus they also found another promising candidate, SN 2020sgf <ref:2608.18207#pg1,of SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa>. That's a solid start for them.

Subrahmanyan: The key takeaway from their summary is that these periodic modulations may represent a significant sub-population of stripped-envelope supernovae rather than just being exceptionally rare events as the initial detections hinted at.

Vera: They compare what they found with some population synthesis models, specifically those by A. Ercolino et al. from two thousand twenty-six which predict variability from repeated common envelope interactions in binary systems that survive the explosion <ref:2608.18207#pg1>.

Jocelyn: And they test whether those theoretical predictions would produce at least three detections when you look through the selection effects of their survey data. This is a nice way to tie theory and observation together.

Subrahmanyan: So, they're not just finding signals; they're testing if the theoretical models can actually explain the observed frequency and amplitude distributions in a statistically plausible way, given their specific survey limitations.

The paper's improvements: Vera: One of the main methodological points they highlight is how they improve on common approaches to periodicity searches. They use a method where they fit a sixth-degree polynomial together with two additional sinusoidal parameters simultaneously at each trial frequency.

Jocelyn: And that simultaneous fitting is what makes it better because it avoids constraining the periodic component through prior detrending, which is a common way to get those signals out of the data. It lets them naturally account for correlations between the trend and the oscillatory terms.

Subrahmanyan: That's significant because it means their statistical significance for each detection comes directly from how much better that fit is, measured by the improvement in chi-squared with those sinusoidal terms.

Vera: And they use injection-recovery simulations to quantify survey sensitivity as a function of period and modulation amplitude. This helps them understand what kind of signal they need to see to be real versus just noise in their survey data.

Jocelyn: That simulation shows that the probability of detecting a periodic signal goes up with the amplitude, but it decreases for longer periods because there are fewer supernovae that have enough baseline time to probe those longer signals.

Conclusion: Vera: So, to wrap up, the paper suggests these periodic stripped-envelope supernovae are unlikely to be exceptionally rare. Under the theoretical period distributions they considered, the observations are compatible with intrinsic periodic fractions of order twenty percent or higher.

Jocelyn: That means that these periodically modulated supernovae could be a significant sub-population in our universe rather than just isolated peculiar objects we stumbled upon by chance.

Subrahmanyan: From my side, this suggests that the underlying physical processes causing these modulations are probably happening frequently enough to produce a population fraction of around twenty percent or more. It moves us away from thinking about them as anomalies and toward thinking about them as a standard feature in stripped-envelope supernovae progenitors.

Vera: So, the main result is that this search is sensitive to relatively short periods, on the order of a few tens of days. Everything they found points toward these events being part of a larger population rather than something extremely rare.

Jocelyn: It's good work because it sets up the next step: understanding if we can find these signals in more supernovae or if we can refine the search to look for longer periods that might be present.

Subrahmanyan: Indeed, this pushes us toward better models that predict not just whether a fraction of twenty percent is possible, but what those actual physical mechanisms are that drive that distribution.

Department of Particle Physics and Astrophysics, Weizmann Institute of Science

astro-ph.HE

Submitted: 2026-08-18

Updated: 2026-11-10

Code: https://github.com/hoasaf3/sne

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Periodic luminosity modulations have been recently identified for the stripped-envelope supernovae SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, motivating a systematic search for a similar behavior in a larger sample.

Key concepts

Periodic Modulation
This refers to repeating patterns in a supernova's brightness over time. The authors modeled this using a sixth-degree polynomial combined with two sinusoidal terms to mathematically detect these subtle, repeating variations in the light curve data.
Injection-Recovery Simulations
These simulations test how sensitive the survey is by artificially adding synthetic periodic signals to real supernova light curves. This helps quantify the probability of detecting a signal based on its amplitude and period, showing how well the survey can find these events.
Population Synthesis Models
These are theoretical models predicting how many periodic events should exist in a population based on physical processes, like repeated collisions in binary systems. Comparing observed detections to these models helps constrain the actual fraction of periodic supernovae in nature.

Terminology

Summary

Periodic luminosity modulations have been recently identified for the stripped-envelope supernovae SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, motivating a systematic search for a similar behavior in a larger sample. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 The fraction of periodic SN Ib/c light curves Asaf Horowicz , 1 Eran O. Ofek , 1 and Avishay Gal-Yam 1 1Department of Particle Physics and Astrophysics, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel ABSTRACT Periodic luminosity modulations have been recently identified for the stripped-envelope supernovae SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, motivating a systematic search for a similar behavior in a larger sample.

This paper performs the first systematic search for periodic modulation in a sample of 34 Type Ib/c supernovae with high quality photometry from the Zwicky Transient Facility. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Such modulations may indicate the explosions arise in binary progenitor systems. We perform the first systematic search for periodic modulation in a sample of 34 Type Ib/c supernovae with high quality photometry from the Zwicky Transient Facility.

The results suggest that periodically modulated SN 2022jli-like events may represent a significant sub-population of strippedenvelope supernovae rather than being exceptionally rare events. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Comparing the observed detections with recent population synthesis models shows that, under the adopted assumptions, models predicting intrinsic periodic fractions of order ∼ 20% are consistent with the observations. Our results suggest that periodically modulated SN 2022jli-like events may represent a significant sub-population of strippedenvelope supernovae rather than being exceptionally rare events, while demonstrating a methodology suitable for future wide-field transient surveys.

Methodology for Searching Periodicity

The authors developed and applied a statistically rigorous pipeline for detecting periodic modulation in light curves. A common approach involves fitting a sixth-degree polynomial together with two additional sinusoidal parameters to model the magnitude as m(t) = A sin(2πf t) + B cos(2πf t) + Xd k=0 ckt˜k (1), where the polynomial degree is chosen to be 3 for the entire sample. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We model the magnitude as m(t) = A sin(2πf t) + B cos(2πf t) +X d k=0 ckt˜k , (1) where: • d is the polynomial degree, • t˜ is the time coordinate shifted to zero mean and scaled to the interval [−1, 1] for numerical stability, • f is a trial frequency, • A and B parameterize the sinusoidal component. The polynomial degree is chosen to be 3 for the entire sample, to avoid overfitting signals by higher-degree polynomials.

The search is restricted to periods such that P ≤ 2. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The frequency grid is defined individually for each LC according to its time baseline T = tmax − tmin. We restrict the search to periods that are both physically meaningful and sufficiently sampled within the data.

5 T, or Pmin = 3 days, and fmax = 1/3 < f (3). p. 2
Where the paper says it

5 T: fmin = 5 2T . (2) The minimum searchable period is set to Pmin = 3 days, but theoretically could be shorter.

The frequency grid spacing is chosen as ∆f = 1/5T (4). p. 2
Where the paper says it

The corresponding maximum frequency is fmax = 1 3 . (3) The frequency grid spacing is chosen as ∆f = 1 5T , (4) which oversamples the frequency resolution 1/T by a factor of five.

Detection Criteria and Significance Assessment

A “hit” is defined as a LC with pf < 10−4, and a “double-hit” is defined as a SN for which both bands exhibit statistically significant periodicities within a tolerance of P2/T. The single-frequency p-value is calculated using the formula pf = 1 − Fχ2(2)(∆χ squared f) (9). p. 3

Where the paper says it

4 Since the alternative model introduces two additional parameters (A and B) per frequency, we expect ∆χ 2 f ∼ χ 2 (2) (8) under the null hypothesis of no periodic modulation. The single-frequency p-value is therefore pf = 1 − Fχ2(2)(∆χ 2 f ), (9) where Fχ2(2) is the cumulative distribution function of the χ 2 distribution with two degrees of freedom.

Furthermore, a minimal detectable amplitude (MDA) check is applied, requiring a detected amplitude greater than AMDA ∼ σres √N to distinguish physically meaningful signals from noise. p. 3
Where the paper says it

A ”hit” must also have a detected amplitude greater than AMDA. This allows us to distinguish between periodic signals whose amplitudes are physically meaningful relative to the intrinsic scatter of the light curve, and those who could have arised from noise.

Comparison with Population Synthesis Models

The observed detections are compared with population synthesis models of A. Ercolino et al. p. 0

Where the paper says it

il envelope SNe (SESNe) might show that behavior (A. Ercolino et al.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

il envelope SNe (SESNe) might show that behavior (A. Ercolino et al.

(2026) which predict periodic variability arising from repeated CCI in binary systems that remain bound after the SN explosion. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Ercolino et al. (2026), which predict periodic variability arising from repeated CCI in binary systems that remain bound after the SN explosion.

The analysis tests whether the population predicted by each model would plausibly produce at least three detections when observed through the selection effects of our survey. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Each model predicts both a distribution of post-SN periods for SN 2022jli-like systems and an intrinsic fraction of SESNe expected to exhibit such variability. Our analysis tests these two predictions jointly by determining whether the population predicted by each model would plausibly produce at least three detections when observed through the selection effects of our survey.

The inferred minimum fraction compatible with observations, f5, is not an independent measurement but rather the minimum fraction compatible with observations, given the adopted theoretical period distribution and the sensitivity of our survey. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Intrinsic periodic fractions below f5 reproduce the observed number of detections in fewer than 5% of realizations and are therefore disfavored by our observations under the adopted model assumptions. Thus, f5 is not an independent measurement of the intrinsic periodic fraction, but rather the minimum fraction compatible with observations, given the adopted theoretical period distribution and the sensitivity of our survey, as well as the assumed amplitude distribution.

Survey Sensitivity and Limitations

Injection-recovery simulations were performed using observed ZTF LCs to quantify survey sensitivity. The resulting recovery map shows that the probability of detecting a periodic signal increases with increasing amplitude and decreases toward longer periods because fewer SNe have sufficiently long baselines to probe such signals. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The resulting recovery map is shown in Figure 6. As expected, the recovery probability increases with increasing amplitude and decreases toward longer periods, reflecting the reduced number of candidates with baselines sufficiently long to probe long-period variability.

The survey sensitivity alone is insufficient to infer the intrinsic fraction of periodic SESNe, since the observed number of detections depends both on the period distribution of such events and their fraction in the population. p. 9
Where the paper says it

This survey is insensitive to such long periods. The survey sensitivity alone is therefore insufficient to infer the intrinsic fraction of periodic SESNe, since the observed number of detections depends both on the period distribution of such events and their fraction in the population.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

This survey is insensitive to such long periods. The survey sensitivity alone is therefore insufficient to infer the intrinsic fraction of periodic SESNe, since the observed number of detections depends both on the period distribution of such events and their fraction in the population.

Conclusion on Sub-population Prevalence

The three periodic SESNe identified demonstrate that such events are unlikely to represent an exceptionally rare phenomenon. Under the theoretical period distributions considered here, the observations are compatible with intrinsic periodic fractions of order ∼ 20% or higher, indicating that periodically modulated SESNe could represent a significant sub-population rather than isolated peculiar events. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Comparing the observed detections with recent population synthesis models shows that, under the adopted assumptions, models predicting intrinsic periodic fractions of order ∼ 20% are consistent with the observations. Our results suggest that periodically modulated SN 2022jli-like events may represent a significant sub-population of strippedenvelope supernovae rather than being exceptionally rare events, while demonstrating a methodology suitable for future wide-field transient surveys.

The present search is therefore primarily sensitive to relatively short periods, of order a few tens of days. p. 8
Where the paper says it

5, progressively longer signals can be tested in progressively fewer objects. The present search is therefore primarily sensitive to relatively short periods, of order a few tens of days.

All polynomial fits can be shared by request. p. 2
Where the paper says it

If only two cycles are present, the polynomial may effectively absorb one of them, leaving only a single cycle to constrain the sinusoidal component. In this regime, long-period sinusoids can resemble smooth polynomial curvature, potentially yielding artificially improved fits at large periods.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

If only two cycles are present, the polynomial may effectively absorb one of them, leaving only a single cycle to constrain the sinusoidal component. In this regime, long-period sinusoids can resemble smooth polynomial curvature, potentially yielding artificially improved fits at large periods.

Summary

The authors developed and applied a statistically rigorous pipeline to search for periodic modulation in SESNe LCs. The pipeline successfully recovered the two previously reported periodic SNe, SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, and identified SN 2020sgf as an additional promising periodic candidate. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We develop and apply a statistically rigorous pipeline for detecting periodic modulation in light curves. The pipeline successfully recovers the previously reported periodic undulations of SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, and identifies SN 2020sgf as an additional promising periodic candidate.

Using injection-recovery simulations, they quantified the sensitivity of their search and compared the observed detections with the population synthesis models of A. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Injection-recovery simulations are used to quantify the survey sensitivity as a function of period and modulation amplitude. Comparing the observed detections with recent population synthesis models shows that, under the adopted assumptions, models predicting intrinsic periodic fractions of order ∼ 20% are consistent with the observations.

Ercolino et al. (2026). Under the assumptions adopted in this work, models predicting intrinsic periodic fractions of order ∼ 20% are consistent with our observations. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Injection-recovery simulations are used to quantify the survey sensitivity as a function of period and modulation amplitude. Comparing the observed detections with recent population synthesis models shows that, under the adopted assumptions, models predicting intrinsic periodic fractions of order ∼ 20% are consistent with the observations.

More generally, their results suggest that 2022jlilike events may constitute a non-negligible fraction of the stripped-envelope SN population rather than representing exceptionally rare objects. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Comparing the observed detections with recent population synthesis models shows that, under the adopted assumptions, models predicting intrinsic periodic fractions of order ∼ 20% are consistent with the observations. Our results suggest that periodically modulated SN 2022jli-like events may represent a significant sub-population of strippedenvelope supernovae rather than being exceptionally rare events, while demonstrating a methodology suitable for future wide-field transient surveys.

All polynomial fits can be shared by request. The code used in this work is publicly available at //github. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this work we aim to systematically search for similar signals across a large sample of SESNe and assess the prevalence of this phenomena. In Section 2 we describe the data set and the methodology used to search for periodic modulation.

com/hoasaf3/sne periodicity search. p. 4
Where the paper says it

RESULTS After applying the quality cuts described in 2. 1, we applied the periodicity search described in Section 2 to a total of 118 light curves corresponding to 84 unique SNe, 34 of them with both g- and r- band LCs.

The authors thank Andreas Ercolino for generously sharing the population synthesis model data used in this work. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this work we aim to systematically search for similar signals across a large sample of SESNe and assess the prevalence of this phenomena. In Section 2 we describe the data set and the methodology used to search for periodic modulation.

They also thank Avshalom Badash and Erez A. Zimmerman for helpful discussions.

How the training signal is built

The authors extract decline detections starting from the peak magnitude 3 and up to either the first gap of 50 days, or until an epoch of 1000 days after the peak. They model the magnitude as m(t) = A sin(2πf t) + B cos(2πf t) + Xd k=0 ckt˜k (1), where d is the polynomial degree, and t˜ is the time coordinate shifted to zero mean and scaled to the interval [−1, 1] for numerical stability. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Model and Fitting Procedure For each light curve we extract the decline detections, starting from the peak magnitude 3 and up to either the first gap of 50 days, or until an epoch of 1000 days after the peak. We model the magnitude as m(t) = A sin(2πf t) + B cos(2πf t) +X d k=0 ckt˜k , (1) where: • d is the polynomial degree, • t˜ is the time coordinate shifted to zero mean and scaled to the interval [−1, 1] for numerical stability, • f is a trial frequency, • A and B parameterize the sinusoidal component.

The polynomial degree is chosen to be 3 for the entire sample, to avoid overfitting signals by higher-degree polynomials. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We model the magnitude as m(t) = A sin(2πf t) + B cos(2πf t) +X d k=0 ckt˜k , (1) where: • d is the polynomial degree, • t˜ is the time coordinate shifted to zero mean and scaled to the interval [−1, 1] for numerical stability, • f is a trial frequency, • A and B parameterize the sinusoidal component. The polynomial degree is chosen to be 3 for the entire sample, to avoid overfitting signals by higher-degree polynomials.

Where the gains come from

The method of fitting the polynomial baseline and sinusoidal terms simultaneously at each trial frequency avoids constraining the periodic component through prior detrending and naturally accounts for correlations between the trend and the oscillatory terms. This framework allows them to define the statistical significance of each detection in a transparent and well-controlled manner, directly from the improvement in χ squared associated with the inclusion of the sinusoidal terms. p. 1

Where the paper says it

By adjusting all parameters together, we avoid constraining the periodic component through prior detrending and naturally account for correlations between the trend and the oscillatory terms. In addition, this framework allows us to define the statistical significance of each detection in a transparent and well-controlled manner, directly from the improvement in χ 2 associated with the inclusion of the sinusoidal terms.

The injection-recovery simulations quantify survey sensitivity by injecting a synthetic sinusoidal signal directly into measured magnitudes minj(t) = mobs(t) + A sin (2πt/P + ϕ) (18). p. 7
Where the paper says it

For each candidate and ZTF band, we injected a synthetic sinusoidal signal directly into the measured magnitudes, minj(t) = mobs(t) + A sin (2πt/P + ϕ), (18) where A is the injected semi-amplitude, P is the injected period, and ϕ is a random phase drawn independently for each realization. All dual-band candidates were included in the simulations, including objects with detected periodicity, in order to characterize the sensitivity of the full analyzed sample.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The authors note that the proximity to the lunar synodic period may introduce spurious periodicities through the survey window function or varying sky background affecting image subtraction. The survey sensitivity is limited by the requirement that the observations span several cycles of the putative signal. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The probability of detecting a periodic modulation depends strongly on its period and amplitude, as well as on the cadence, photometric precision, and temporal baseline of each LC. In particular, our sensitivity is limited by the requirement that the observations span several cycles of the putative signal.

Because they restrict searched periods to P ≲ T /2. p. 8
Where the paper says it

In particular, our sensitivity is limited by the requirement that the observations span several cycles of the putative signal. Because we restrict the searched periods to P ≲ T /2.

5, progressively longer signals can be tested in progressively fewer objects. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Because we restrict the searched periods to P ≲ T /2. 5, progressively longer signals can be tested in progressively fewer objects.

The survey sensitivity alone is insufficient to infer the intrinsic fraction of periodic SESNe, since the observed number of detections depends both on the period distribution of such events and their fraction in the population. This survey is insensitive to such long periods. p. 9
Where the paper says it

(2026) of periods extending up to ∼ 103 days. This survey is insensitive to such long periods.

The recovery map shows that sensitivity increases with increasing amplitude and decreases toward longer periods because fewer SNe have sufficiently long baselines to detect such signals. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The three detected candidates are overplotted in the corresponding period–amplitude bins for visual reference only; their locations do not influence the values of Pij . Sensitivity increases with increasing amplitude and decreases toward longer periods because fewer SNe have sufficiently long baselines to detect such signals.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can perform a systematic search for periodic modulation in large transient surveys by developing and applying a statistically rigorous pipeline for detecting periodicity in light curves, as described in Section 2.

  2. The improved system can quantify survey sensitivity as a function of period and modulation amplitude using injection-recovery simulations, which allows it to predict the probability that a periodic event would be recovered if it occurred in a randomly selected supernova from the sample.

  3. The AI can compare observed detections with theoretical population models, such as those of A. Ercolino et al. (2026), to constrain the intrinsic fraction of periodic stripped-envelope supernovae by determining the smallest value of X for which more than 5 percent of realizations recover at least three detections.

  4. The system can perform dual-band detection analysis, identifying double-hits by requiring that both bands exhibit statistically significant periodicities within a tolerance defined as up to one cycle shift throughout the entire baseline.

Abstract

Periodic luminosity modulations have been recently identified for the stripped-envelope supernovae SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, motivating a systematic search for a similar behavior in a larger sample. Such modulations may indicate the explosions arise in binary progenitor systems. We perform the first systematic search for periodic modulation in a sample of 34 Type Ib/c supernovae with high quality photometry from the Zwicky Transient Facility. We develop and apply a statistically rigorous pipeline for detecting periodic modulation in light curves. The pipeline successfully recovers the previously reported periodic undulations of SN 2022jli and SN 2022esa, and identifies SN 2020sgf as an additional promising periodic candidate. Injection-recovery simulations are used to quantify the survey sensitivity as a function of period and modulation amplitude. Comparing the observed detections with recent population synthesis models shows that, under the adopted assumptions, models predicting intrinsic periodic fractions of order ~20% are consistent with the observations. Given that this inference rests on only three dual-band detections out of 34 candidates, we regard this fraction as illustrative rather than a precise measurement. Our results suggest that periodically modulated SN 2022jli-like events may represent a non-negligible sub-population of stripped-envelope supernovae rather than being exceptionally rare events, while demonstrating a methodology suitable for future wide-field transient surveys.

Sources

Related papers