Comparison of the Neutron Star Birth Function from Core-Collapse Supernova Simulations with Observations
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: I'm Vera.
Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Comparison of the Neutron Star Birth Function from Core-Collapse Supernova Simulations with Observations".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Using the mapping between progenitor core structure and the gravitational mass of neutron stars derived from sophisticated 3D supernova simulations, we determine the theoretical mass distribution of neutron stars at birth and compare it with neutron star mass function measurements In summary, we suggest that supernova theory can now be used to explain, however provisionally, various measured attributes of the population of compact objects and that an era of productive engagement between supernova theory and observation is at hand Theoretical Framework for Birth Mass Derivation The paper establishes a method to derive a theoretical neutron star mass function by combining the mapping between progenitor ZAMS mass to the “compactness index” of core structure and of core structure to neutron star birth mass derived from supernova theory This derivation involves using the compactness parameter ξM = M/M⊙ (R(M)/1000 km) and mapping it to a gravitational birth mass The process weights each progenitor model according to an initial mass function, such as Salpeter, and deposits the entire normalized interval weight at the single mapped birth mass mi Comparison with Measured Distributions The default theoretical neutron-star birth-mass function is compared against observed distributions from two samples: the full set of neutron stars with measured masses and a restricted subset containing only objects with measured spin periods The comparison reveals that the observed distribution peaks in the 1.3 − 1.4 M⊙ bin, whereas the theoretical birth function peaks at lower masses, in the 1.2 − 1.3 M⊙ bin Corrections for Physical Effects The analysis explores several physical effects that modify the default birth mass function, including black hole formation and subsequent mass accretion Black Hole Formation: The effect of black-hole formation is incorporated by treating the removal fractions in relevant channels as free parameters and constraining them through a likelihood-based optimization to best agreement with the accretion-corrected observed neutron-star mass distribution Channel 4 masking produces the largest and most broadly distributed modification to the theoretical birth function, affecting several bins between 1.4 and 1.7 M⊙ Accretion Correction: Accretion corrections are applied to the observed mass distribution using prescriptions from Zhang et al.
Vera: (2011) and You et al.
Jocelyn: (2025), which generally redistribute probability from observed masses toward lower inferred birth masses The You et al.
Vera: (2025) prescription is adopted for the remainder of the work when comparing the theoretical neutron-star birth function with the accretion-corrected observations Final Aggregate Fit and Conclusions The final aggregate fit combines both black-hole masking and natal-kick removal to determine the best combination of fractions that reproduces the observed mass distribution The resulting model shows that while it broadly reproduces the shape of the accretion-corrected observed distribution across the full mass range, it retains a sharp lower cutoff near 1.2 M⊙ and exhibits residual excesses in certain intermediate and high-mass bins The final black hole fraction of progenitors for the best-fit black-hole masking is 20.7%, implying that 79.3% of the progenitors form neutron stars Outstanding Issues and Future Directions The paper notes that selection corrections, potential metallicity dependence, and pre-explosion binarity remain unaddressed topics It is suggested that the scarcity of observed neutron stars below 1.2 M⊙ motivates a reduced neutron-star formation efficiency between 8 and 9 M⊙ The findings suggest that any observed masses below 1.
Paper summary: Vera: So, to go deeper into this paper, they set up this mapping between progenitor core structure and the gravitational mass of neutron stars derived from three dee supernova simulations <ref:2608.18198#pg1,mapping between progenitor core structure and the gravitational mass of neutron stars>. They use the compactness parameter, which is defined as the mass divided by solar mass multiplied by the radius in kilometers divided by one thousand kilometers.
Jocelyn: And then they map that compactness to a birth mass, and they weight each progenitor model based on an initial mass function like Salpeter to get this theoretical birth function. They are comparing this theoretical distribution against observed distributions from two samples: the full set of neutron stars with measured masses, and a restricted subset focusing only on objects with measured spin periods.
Subrahmanyan: The main finding they highlight is that the default theoretical birth-mass function peaks at lower masses, specifically in the bin between one point two and one point three solar masses, while the observed distribution peaks higher up in that range, around one point three to one point four solar masses <ref:2608.18198#pg3>. That’s a direct tension they are trying to reconcile with their model of how neutron stars are born >
Vera: It's a classic discrepancy then, where the theory predicts one mass and the observation points to another peak location for the birth mass function >
Jocelyn: They also look at corrections for physical effects like black hole formation and subsequent mass accretion, which they find modify the default distribution. For instance, black hole formation affects several bins between one point four and one point seven solar masses, and they constrain the removal fractions using a likelihood-based optimization > <ref:2608.18198#pg3>
Subrahmanyan: And then there's the accretion correction applied to observed masses using prescriptions from Zhang et al. for those lower inferred birth masses, but they use You et al.'s prescription for the rest of the comparison to see how that shifts probability >
Vera: So what this means for us on a data side is that we need to be careful about selection bias and accretion effects when interpreting these mass measurements >
Jocelyn: And overall, their final aggregate fit shows that while it broadly matches the shape of the accretion-corrected distribution across the whole mass range, it still keeps a sharp lower cutoff near one point two solar masses and some extra bumps in certain intermediate and high-mass bins > <ref:2608.18198#pg3>
Subrahmanyan: The final result is that for their best black hole masking, they find a progenitor black hole fraction of twenty point seven percent, meaning about seventy-nine point three percent of the progenitors actually form neutron stars >
Conclusion: Vera: So, looking at this paper, "Comparison of the Neutron Star Birth Function from Core-Collapse Supernova Simulations with Observations," it really boils down to testing whether our understanding of core collapse supernovae can accurately predict the mass distribution of neutron stars we find today.
Jocelyn: The authors are using sophisticated three dee simulations to build a theoretical birth function based on progenitor structure, and they're showing that this function doesn't perfectly match what we measure from real neutron star samples <ref:2608.18198#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: The main implication is that even though there’s a mismatch in the peak locations, the overall shape of the distribution is broadly reproduced once you account for effects like black hole formation and mass accretion >
Vera: It means that supernova theory isn't entirely wrong; it just needs these extra physics adjustments to get it right for describing compact objects >
Jocelyn: The paper suggests that there’s a clear path forward, pointing toward an era where we can use supernova theory to explain more of the population attributes of these compact objects >
Subrahmanyan: They also point out some outstanding issues, like selection corrections and whether metallicity matters, and they suggest that the lack of neutron stars below one point two solar masses might imply a lower efficiency for neutron star formation in progenitors between eight and nine solar masses >
Vera: It’s a call to action, then. If we want to get better constraints on these populations, we need to look at those selection effects and try to pin down the physics of the birth process more precisely >
University of Rochester · Princeton University · University of Idaho
astro-ph.HE
Submitted: 2026-08-18
Updated: 2026-11-12
Comments: 28 pages, 11 figures, 2 tables. Accepted at ApJ
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 86/100
The gist: Using the mapping between progenitor core structure and the gravitational mass of neutron stars derived from sophisticated 3D supernova simulations…
Terminology
Summary
Using the mapping between progenitor core structure and the gravitational mass of neutron stars derived from sophisticated 3D supernova simulations, we determine the theoretical mass distribution of neutron stars at birth and compare it with neutron star mass function measurements In summary, we suggest that supernova theory can now be used to explain, however provisionally, various measured attributes of the population of compact objects and that an era of productive engagement between supernova theory and observation is at hand
Theoretical Framework for Birth Mass Derivation
The paper establishes a method to derive a theoretical neutron star mass function by combining the mapping between progenitor ZAMS mass to the “compactness index” of core structure and of core structure to neutron star birth mass derived from supernova theory This derivation involves using the compactness parameter ξM = M/M⊙ (R(M)/1000 km) and mapping it to a gravitational birth mass The process weights each progenitor model according to an initial mass function, such as Salpeter, and deposits the entire normalized interval weight at the single mapped birth mass mi
Comparison with Measured Distributions
The default theoretical neutron-star birth-mass function is compared against observed distributions from two samples: the full set of neutron stars with measured masses and a restricted subset containing only objects with measured spin periods The comparison reveals that the observed distribution peaks in the 1.3 − 1.4 M⊙ bin, whereas the theoretical birth function peaks at lower masses, in the 1. p. 9 In the observed distribution, the
primary peak lies in the 1. 4 M⊙ bin, whereas the
theoretical birth function peaks at lower masses, in the
1.Where the paper says it
Corrections for Physical Effects
The analysis explores several physical effects that modify the default birth mass function, including black hole formation and subsequent mass accretion
** Black Hole Formation:**
The effect of black-hole formation is incorporated by treating the removal fractions in relevant channels as free parameters and constraining them through a likelihood-based optimization to best agreement with the accretion-corrected observed neutron-star mass distribution Channel 4 masking produces the largest and most broadly distributed modification to the theoretical birth function, affecting several bins between 1.4 and 1.7 M⊙
** Accretion Correction:**
Accretion corrections are applied to the observed mass distribution using prescriptions from Zhang et al. (2011) and You et al. p. 7 2011; Antoniadis et al. 2016; You et al. All measured masses are for neutron stars in binaries, so there
is an overarching selection bias that is generally not well
characterized. Nevertheless, several studies have applied
Bayesian statistical methods to neutron star mass observations and inferred distribution functions ((Zhang
et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Aggregate Fit and Conclusions
The final aggregate fit combines both black-hole masking and natal-kick removal to determine the best combination of fractions that reproduces the observed mass distribution The resulting model shows that while it broadly reproduces the shape of the accretion-corrected observed distribution across the full mass range, it retains a sharp lower cutoff near 1.2 M⊙ and exhibits residual excesses in certain intermediate and high-mass bins The final black hole fraction of progenitors for the best-fit black-hole masking is 20. p. 9 An example of the black-hole masking effect
on the theoretical neutron-star birth-mass function. Panels
(a)–(d) vary the masking fraction, fBH, within the Channel 1 low-mass, Channel 1 high-mass, Channel 2, and Channel 4 black-hole-forming regions identified by Burrows et al.Where the paper says it
Outstanding Issues and Future Directions
The paper notes that selection corrections, potential metallicity dependence, and pre-explosion binarity remain unaddressed topics It is suggested that the scarcity of observed neutron stars below 1.2 M⊙ motivates a reduced neutron-star formation efficiency between 8 and 9 M⊙ The findings suggest that any observed masses below 1. p. 4 The upshot is the expectation that supernovae leave a broad spectrum of neutron star gravitational masses and this is what recent supernova theory
finds (Burrows et al. It is this finding that in part
motivates this paper.Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve theoretical predictions for neutron star birth mass by combining mappings from progenitor ZAMS mass to compactness and compactness to gravitational mass, allowing for a theoretically derived distribution based on an initial mass function like Salpeter (1955). This allows the system to calculate a
theoretical neutron star birth function
that can be compared with measured distributions. -
Develop a mechanism to account for black hole formation effects by treating the removal fractions associated with different progenitor channels as free parameters constrained through likelihood-based optimization against the accretion-corrected observed distribution. This enables the AI to infer the fraction of black hole-forming progenitors, such as
the final black hole fraction of progenitors for the best-fit black-hole masking is 20.7%.
-
Implement a correction step to account for subsequent mass accretion by applying prescriptions from Zhang et al. (2011) and You et al. (2025) to observed mass distributions, which allows the system to
shift the dominant peak from the 1.3−1.4 M⊙ bin to the 1.2−1.3 M⊙ bin.
-
Incorporate a method for natal kick effects by treating them as a fractional removal of remnants from specific mass ranges, such as removing
a fraction fkick of the remnants with birth masses between 1.5 and 2.0 M⊙
to obtain a better fit to the accretion-corrected observed distribution, leading to a final model wherethe secondary peak between 1.5 and 1.7 M⊙ is no longer present.
-
Enable the AI to perform an aggregate fit by jointly estimating black hole removal fractions and natal kick removal fractions, resulting in
the final fraction of progenitors that form black holes, for the best-fit black-hole masking and kick correction, is 20.7%.
Abstract
Using the mapping between progenitor core structure and the gravitational mass of neutron stars derived from sophisticated 3D supernova simulations, we construct the theoretical mass distribution of neutron stars at birth and investigate how it might comport with neutron star mass function measurements. In the process, we explore the effects of islands of black hole formation and subsequent mass accretion. We show that supernova theory can explain the observed neutron star mass function from its lower-mass peak near about 1.35 M to its higher-mass tail. Moreover, we suggest, but do not prove, that the lower predicted kick speeds expected during the birth of lower-mass neutron stars and the higher expected kick speeds expected on average for higher mass neutron stars may together sculpt the observed mass function in desired directions. The upshot of all these influences is to imprint upon the measured neutron star mass function features that reflect the varied physics of both neutron star origins and the neutron-star/black-hole dichotomy. Very approximately, we derive a black hole birth fraction of about 19.6%. In summary, we suggest that supernova theory can now be used to explain, however provisionally, various measured attributes of the population of compact objects and that an era of productive engagement between supernova theory and observation is at hand.
Sources
- The millisecond pulsar mass distribution: Evidence for bimodality and constraints on the maximum neutron star mass
- A Theory for Neutron Star and Black Hole Kicks and Induced Spins
- Maximum gravitational mass $M_{\rm TOV}=2.25^{+0.08}_{-0.07}M_\odot$ inferred at about $3\%$ precision with multimessenger data of neutron stars
- High-mass X-ray Binaries
- Mass distribution of neutron stars in binary systems
- Three-Dimensional Simulations of Neutrino-Driven Core-Collapse Supernovae from Low-Mass Single and Binary Star Progenitors
- Unveiling the Milky Way with a Gaia DR3 census of OB-type stars within 2 kpc. I. Tracing local Galactic structure, massive star-forming regions and core-collapse supernova progenitors
- Surprisingly Similar: The Mass Function of Gaia Neutron Stars and First-Born Double Neutron Stars
Related papers
- Low- T/W instabilities in differentially rotating neutron stars resembling merger remnants
- The imprint of individual neutron star spins on ejecta, r-process nucleosynthesis, and kilonovae in binary neutron star mergers
- Early panchromatic spectra reveal helium in the thermonuclear supernova 2024kce
- The Double-Peaked Calcium-Strong SN 2025coe: Progenitor Constraints from Early Interaction and Ejecta Asymmetries
- The pulsar population of Omega Centauri: New TRAPUM searches, timing, and cluster dynamics with MeerKAT and Parkes
- One year of broadband radio monitoring of the enigmatic transient GRB 250702B reveals the evolution of the relativistic jet