The instantaneous mass accretion rate of novae in quiescence: - an archival ultraviolet optical spectral analysis
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The instantaneous mass accretion rate of novae in quiescence".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. We present the first results of our archival spectral analysis to derive the quiescent instantaneous mass transfer rates M˙ in novae, using synthetic disk spectra generated with tlusty, white dwarf (WD) masses estimates from the literature, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and updated color excess values.
Vera: Our results for nine novae, based on ultraviolet spectra and on a number of optical spectra, yield mass accretion rates that are higher than those derived from simple integration of the UV and optical luminosity.
Jocelyn: System Findings The study analyzes archival UV-optical spectra for nine novae in quiescence using realistic accretion disk models generated with tlusty/synspec, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and WD mass estimates.
Vera: The derived mass accretion rates vary significantly across the sample, ranging from M˙ ∼ 10−12M⊙/yr to M˙ ≈ 4 × 10−7M⊙/yr.
Paper summary: Vera: So, to recap this paper "The instantaneous mass accretion rate of novae in quiescence: - an archival ultraviolet optical spectral analysis," they used old ultraviolet and optical data to figure out the quiescent mass transfer rates for nine novae. The main point is that their derived rates are often higher than what you get from just looking at the UV or optical luminosity.
Jocelyn: They used synthetic disk spectra made with tlusty, white dwarf mass estimates from literature, Gaia parallax distances, and color excess values to do this analysis. It’s a detailed setup for finding these instantaneous rates.
Subrahmanyan: The thesis is that these derived mass accretion rates vary quite a bit across the sample, ranging from one to the power of minus twelve solar masses per year up to four times ten to the power of minus seven solar masses per year <ref:2608.18037#pg4>.
Vera: That range is wide, and they give us a specific example for HR Del, where they find a mass transfer rate of four point two times ten to the power of minus seven solar masses per year for a white dwarf mass estimate of zero point six eight plus zero point twelve solar masses <ref:2608.18037#pg4>.
Jocelyn: And they also mention that BK Lyn has the lowest mass accretion rate in their sample, with a value around ten to the power of minus ten solar masses per year <ref:2608.18037#pg4>.
Subrahmanyan: This variation shows that the instantaneous rates are not uniform, which points toward some complex physical processes happening within these systems post-eruption <ref:2608.18037#pg4>.
Conclusion: Vera: So, looking at the paper "The instantaneous mass accretion rate of novae in quiescence: - an archival ultraviolet optical spectral analysis," the title tells us exactly what they did. They looked at quiescent mass transfer rates using archival UV and optical spectral analysis.
Jocelyn: The authors found that their results show a dependence on the system's state after the nova eruption, suggesting complex accretion dynamics involving things like self-sustained feedback loops or outer disk heating <ref:2608.18037#pg4>.
Subrahmanyan: It really emphasizes the discrepancy between what they derived from detailed spectral modeling and what you get from just integrating the UV and optical luminosity, which means simple models aren't enough for these systems <ref:2608.18037#pg4>.
Vera: Essentially, this work suggests that we need to consider these complex dynamics when we try to understand the long-term evolution of nova binaries <ref:2608.18037#pg4>.
Jocelyn: It pushes us to look for follow-up observations that can settle whether these high instantaneous rates are sustained or just temporary states <ref:2608.18037#pg4>.
Villanova University · University of Exeter · California State University, Fresno
astro-ph.SR
Submitted: 2026-08-18
Updated: 2026-11-16
Comments: Published in the Open Journal of Astrophysics
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 70/100
The gist: We present the first results of our archival spectral analysis to derive the quiescent instantaneous mass transfer rates M˙ in novae, using synthetic disk spectra generated with tlusty…
Key concepts
- Mass Accretion Rate (Ṁ)
- This measures how much matter is being transferred onto a white dwarf from its companion star per unit of time. The study derived these rates using detailed spectral modeling, which often yields different results than simple luminosity calculations.
- Accretion Disk Model
- A mathematical model used to describe the structure and behavior of the gas orbiting a white dwarf. The researchers used standard (alpha) disk models, assuming the disk is optically thick and in a steady state with nearly Keplerian orbital velocities.
- Outer Disk Heating
- The study found that for lower accretion rates, the outer edge of the accretion disk needs to be heated to about 12,000 K. This heating comes from various processes like irradiation from the white dwarf and tidal interactions, which affects how the disk appears in UV and optical light.
Terminology
Summary
We present the first results of our archival spectral analysis to derive the quiescent instantaneous mass transfer rates M˙ in novae, using synthetic disk spectra generated with tlusty, white dwarf (WD) masses estimates from the literature, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and updated color excess values. p. 0 Sion
Department of Physics and Planetary Science, Villanova University, Villanova, PA 19085, USA
Tim Naylor
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Exeter, Exeter, EX4 4QL, UK
Frederick A. Ringwald
Department of Physics, California State University, Fresno, CA 93740, USA
Version August 19, 2026
ABSTRACT
We present the first results of our archival spectral analysis to derive the quiescent instantaneous
mass transfer rates M˙
in novae, using synthetic disk spectra generated with tlusty, white dwarf
(WD) masses estimates from the literature, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and updated color excess
values. Ringwald
Department of Physics, California State University, Fresno, CA 93740, USA
Version August 19, 2026
ABSTRACT
We present the first results of our archival spectral analysis to derive the quiescent instantaneous
mass transfer rates M˙
in novae, using synthetic disk spectra generated with tlusty, white dwarf
(WD) masses estimates from the literature, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and updated color excess
values. Our results for nine novae, based on ultraviolet spectra and on a number of optical spectra,
yield mass accretion rates that are higher than those derived from simple integration of the UV and
optical luminosity.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
System Findings
The study analyzes archival UV-optical spectra for nine novae in quiescence using realistic accretion disk models generated with tlusty/synspec, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and WD mass estimates. The derived mass accretion rates vary significantly across the sample, ranging from M˙ ∼ 10−12M⊙/yr to M˙ ≈ 4 × 10−7M⊙/yr. p. 0 V1974 Cyg and V533 Her, with an accretion rate of ∼ 3×10−9M⊙/yr,
have an even flatter spectrum. As to V446 Her and BK Lyn, they were caught in a state of low
accretion and have the lowest mass accretion rates in our sample: M˙ ∼ 10−9 and ∼ 10−10M⊙/yr
respectively. Our results for nine novae, based on ultraviolet spectra and on a number of optical spectra,
yield mass accretion rates that are higher than those derived from simple integration of the UV and
optical luminosity. Twenty one years after its eruption, HR Del, with a mass transfer rate of 4 × 10−7M⊙/yr, must
have been burning the H-rich material as it accreted onto the WD. 2016; Shafter 2017) since all novae are likely
to be recurrent. The inter-eruption period depends upon
the WD mass (Mwd) and mass accretion rate1
(M˙ ): RNe
with a large Mwd and high M˙ exhibit the shortest recurrence periods (Schaefer 2010) as the pressure at the base
of the accreted layer increases more rapidly due to the
larger WD gravity and/or the larger accumulating mass. The novae were chosen for their relatively
good quality UV spectra obtained late enough after the
nova eruption to ensure they were all disk-dominated at
the time of the observations. They all have distances derived from Gaia DR3 parallaxes, known extinction, and
(almost all) known WD masses and orbital inclination. V1974 Cyg and V533 Her, with an accretion rate of ∼ 3×10−9M⊙/yr,
have an even flatter spectrum. As to V446 Her and BK Lyn, they were caught in a state of low
accretion and have the lowest mass accretion rates in our sample: M˙ ∼ 10−9 and ∼ 10−10M⊙/yr
respectively.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Modeling Techniques
The analysis employs a suite of codes including tlusty, synspec, rotin, and disksyn to generate synthetic spectra of stellar atmosphere and disks. The accretion disk is assumed to be optically thick, vertically thin, axi-symmetric, and in steady state using the standard (alpha) disk model with a nearly Keplerian velocity. p. 8 Accretion Disk Spectra. The disk is assumed to be optically thick, vertically
thin, axi-symmetric, and in steady state. synspec is run for a given
set of inclinations for which the emerging intensities are
computed. And last, disksyn is run to integrate all the
rings outputs over a set of azimuthal segments with the
rings projected Doppler velocity into a disk spectrum,
taking into account the projected area of the disk for
each given inclination angles.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Disk Structure and Heating
The results suggest that for systems with M˙ of the order of 10−8M⊙/yr and lower, the outer disk is better fitted when it is heated to ∼ 12,000 K. This heating mechanism is attributed to irradiation from the heated WD and inner disk, together with tidal interaction, the bright spot, and material overflowing the disk edge and falling back onto the disk near phase 0. p. 0 We find the higher mass transfer rate systems, with M˙ ≈∼ 10−7M⊙/yr, agree with the standard
disk model, while the remaining systems, with M˙ of the order of 10−8M⊙/yr and lower, are better
fitted when the outer disk is heated to ∼ 12, 000 K. We suggest that irradiation from the heated WD
and inner disk, together with tidal interaction, the bright spot, and material overflowing the disk
edge and falling back onto the disk near phase 0. 5, can increase the temperature of the outer disk to
∼ 12, 000 K. The relative contribution of this component to the UV and optical spectra increases with
decreasing accretion rate.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Comparison with Theory
The high mass transfer rates, M˙ ∼ 10−7M⊙/yr, are consistent with the standard disk model. However, for systems like RR Pic and CP Lac, a large disk model augmented with an outer isothermal (T = 12,000 K) region provides a much better fit to both UV and optical spectra than the standard disk model alone. p. 0 RR Pic, with M˙ ≈ 3 × 10−8M⊙/yr, was better fitted with an accretion disk in which
the outer disk is heated up to a temperature of 12,000 K, in agreement with H and He emission lines
coming from the outer disk and a large emission region on the leading side of the disk. Such a disk,
augmented with a heated outer disk, also gives a good fit to the spectra of CP Lac, and DI Lac with
M˙ ∼ 4.Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Accretion Dynamics
The mass accretion rates derived using the standard disk model are on average 3 times larger than those derived based on the observed UV and optical luminosity. For HR Del, the large mass accretion we derived leads to stable burning on the WD surface (self-sustained feedback loop SSS phase), and possibly at a rate slower than the matter is accreted. p. 2 As the transferred mass is accreted onto the WD
surface it undergoes stable nuclear burning and ‘closes
the loop’. Such a self-sustained high M˙
loop would significantly increase the duration of the SSS phase of a
nova. For a review see (Warner 1995). With time, as the accreted matter piles up onto the
WD, gravity compresses the accreted envelope until a
critical pressure is reached at the base of the accreted
layer above the electron-degenerate core, triggering a
brief and powerful thermonuclear runaway (TNR) of the
accreted H-rich material on the WD surface: the nova
eruption (Starrfield et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Comparison of WD Masses
The comparison of nova WD masses from the literature shows that the masses from Shara et al. (2018, denoted by MSh) are systematically larger for MSG ≲ 1. p. 1 3 × 10−8M⊙/yr, four times larger than that derived
by Selvelli & Gilmozzi (2019) by simply integrating the
observed flux. In this paper we present the first results from our
archival spectroscopic analysis of ultraviolet (and to
some extent optical) spectra for nine novae in quiescence using realistic accretion disk models generated
with tlusty/synspec (Hubeny & Lanz 2017a,b,c),
Gaia parallax-derived distances (Schaefer 2018), and WD
mass estimates (Shara et al. As to V446 Her and BK Lyn, they were caught in a state of low
accretion and have the lowest mass accretion rates in our sample: M˙ ∼ 10−9 and ∼ 10−10M⊙/yr
respectively. We find the higher mass transfer rate systems, with M˙ ≈∼ 10−7M⊙/yr, agree with the standard
disk model, while the remaining systems, with M˙ of the order of 10−8M⊙/yr and lower, are better
fitted when the outer disk is heated to ∼ 12, 000 K.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Summary
The study successfully derived quiescent instantaneous mass transfer rates for nine novae using archival UV-optical spectral analysis and realistic accretion disk models. The derived rates show a dependence on the system's state post-eruption, suggesting complex accretion dynamics involving self-sustained feedback loops or outer disk heating. The analysis highlights discrepancies between rates inferred from simple luminosity integration and those derived from detailed spectral modeling. p. 0 Ringwald
Department of Physics, California State University, Fresno, CA 93740, USA
Version August 19, 2026
ABSTRACT
We present the first results of our archival spectral analysis to derive the quiescent instantaneous
mass transfer rates M˙
in novae, using synthetic disk spectra generated with tlusty, white dwarf
(WD) masses estimates from the literature, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and updated color excess
values. Our results for nine novae, based on ultraviolet spectra and on a number of optical spectra,
yield mass accretion rates that are higher than those derived from simple integration of the UV and
optical luminosity.Where the paper says it
Table 4
The results for all the systems are listed in Table 4. The table summarizes the WD masses, mass accretion rates, and inclination angles for nine novae. p. 0 Ringwald
Department of Physics, California State University, Fresno, CA 93740, USA
Version August 19, 2026
ABSTRACT
We present the first results of our archival spectral analysis to derive the quiescent instantaneous
mass transfer rates M˙
in novae, using synthetic disk spectra generated with tlusty, white dwarf
(WD) masses estimates from the literature, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and updated color excess
values. Our results for nine novae, based on ultraviolet spectra and on a number of optical spectra,
yield mass accretion rates that are higher than those derived from simple integration of the UV and
optical luminosity.Where the paper says it
Table 3
The UV spectra used for the spectroscopic analysis are listed in Table 2. The optical spectra used for analysis are listed in Table 3. p. 3 1996a) and
have optical spectra that can be used with the UV spectra for our analysis. These are listed in Table 3.Where the paper says it
Table 1
The system parameters, including orbital period, distance, and WD mass estimates, are listed in Table 1. The table lists parameters for nine novae. p. 3 THE SYSTEMS AND THEIR ARCHIVAL DATA
In an attempt to further elucidate the problem of the
mass accretion rate in novae, we have been carrying out
an UV-optical spectral analysis of archival data of nova
in quiescence. In Table 1 we list nine novae from our ongoing archival study which includes a much larger number of systems. THE SYSTEMS AND THEIR ARCHIVAL DATA
In an attempt to further elucidate the problem of the
mass accretion rate in novae, we have been carrying out
an UV-optical spectral analysis of archival data of nova
in quiescence. In Table 1 we list nine novae from our ongoing archival study which includes a much larger number of systems.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Table 2
The UV spectra used for the spectroscopic analysis are listed in Table 2. The UV spectra cover both the far-UV (FUV) and the NUV with the IUE SWP segment from ∼1150˚A to ∼2000˚A, and IUE LWP (or LWR) segment from ∼1850˚A to ∼3200˚A. p. 3 In Table 2 we list the UV spectra (for the systems
listed in Table 1) that we use for our spectroscopic analysis. The IUE spectra cover both the far-UV (FUV) and
the NUV with the IUE SWP segment from ∼1150 ˚A
to ∼2000 ˚A, and IUE LWP (or LWR) segment from
∼1850 ˚A to ∼3200 ˚A. In Table 2 we list the UV spectra (for the systems
listed in Table 1) that we use for our spectroscopic analysis. The IUE spectra cover both the far-UV (FUV) and
the NUV with the IUE SWP segment from ∼1150 ˚A
to ∼2000 ˚A, and IUE LWP (or LWR) segment from
∼1850 ˚A to ∼3200 ˚A.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Table 5
The UV and Optical Spectra used for the spectroscopic analysis are listed in Table 2. The table lists the UV spectra (for the systems listed in Table 1) that we use for our spectroscopic analysis. p. 3 (2018), except for DI Lac for which we use
the value given in Selvelli & Gilmozzi (2019). In Table 2 we list the UV spectra (for the systems
listed in Table 1) that we use for our spectroscopic analysis.Where the paper says it
Table 6
The Optical Spectra used for the spectroscopic analysis are listed in Table 3. The optical spectra have a steeper slope than the UV spectrum. p. 4 1996b) showing that the continuum flux
level varies by a factor of two, a possible indication that
it was already on its way to transiting from NL to DN. The optical spectra have a steeper slope than the UV
spectrum. 1996b) showing that the continuum flux
level varies by a factor of two, a possible indication that
it was already on its way to transiting from NL to DN. The optical spectra have a steeper slope than the UV
spectrum.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Spectral Analysis Results are listed in Table 4. This table lists the results for all the systems, where for clarity we have rounded up (or down) some of the values. p. 9 — Same as Fig. For clarity, only a few E(B −V ) values
are shown, straight lines have been drawn, and we staggered the
spectra vertically on an arbitrary scale.Where the paper says it
The UV Spectra are listed in Table 2. The UV spectra cover both the far-UV (FUV) and the NUV with the IUE SWP segment from ∼1150˚A to ∼2000˚A, and IUE LWP (or LWR) segment from ∼1850˚A to ∼3200˚A.
The Optical Spectra are listed in Table 3. The optical spectra have a steeper slope than the UV spectrum.
The System Parameters are listed in Table 1. The table lists parameters for nine novae.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced spectral fitting capability allows AI systems to derive instantaneous mass transfer rates M˙ in novae by generating synthetic disk spectra using tlusty models, Gaia parallax distances, and updated color excess values. This enables a more accurate assessment of accretion processes than simple integration of UV and optical luminosity.
-
Improved understanding of the thermal structure of accretion disks allows AI systems to model outer disk heating to 12,000 K based on irradiation from the WD and inner disk, which is crucial for fitting spectra like those of RR Pic and CP Lac. This capability helps differentiate between standard disk models and large disk models in spectral fitting.
-
The ability to compare different mass transfer rate derivations (e.g., M˙ derived from observation versus theoretical predictions) enables AI systems to test complex feedback loops, such as the self-sustained enhanced mass transfer rate loop, which can explain high accretion rates like those seen in HR Del and T Pyx.
-
The analysis of spectral fitting techniques, including the least chi squared method and scaling of theoretical disk spectra to observed spectra for distance validation, allows AI systems to rigorously assess uncertainties related to WD mass, inclination, and color excess E(B-V). This leads to quantified error propagation for derived accretion rates M˙.
-
The system parameter comparison framework enables AI systems to systematically compare results from different literature sources (e.g., Shara et al., Selvelli & Gilmozzi) by analyzing systematic differences in WD mass estimates, which helps constrain the physical models used in the analysis.
Abstract
Based on archival spectra, we derive the quiescent instantaneous mass transfer rates in novae using synthetic disk spectra generated with tlusty, Gaia parallax-derived distances, and updated color excess values. Our results for nine novae, based on ultraviolet spectra and on a number of optical spectra, yield mass accretion rates that are higher than those derived from simple integration of the UV and optical luminosity. HR Del, 20 years after its eruption, has a mass transfer rate of 4 times 10-7M /yr, and is likely burning the accreting H-rich material. V842 Cen, thought to be a low mass transfer system, has a comparable mass accretion rate. For both novae, the enhanced mass transfer must be self-sustained by a feedback loop. RR Pic, with M dot about 5 times 10-8M /yr, is better fitted with an accretion disk where the outer region is heated up to 12,000 K, in agreement with H and He emission lines coming from the outer disk and a large emission region on the leading side of the disk. Such a heated disk also gives a good fit to the spectra of CP Lac, and DI Lac with M dot about4.5 and 9 times 10-9M /yr. V1974 Cyg and V533 Her, with an accretion rate of about 3 times 10-9M /yr, have a rather flat spectrum. V446 Her and BK Lyn, caught in a state of low accretion, have the lowest mass accretion rates with M dot about 10-9 and about 10-10M /yr respectively. The higher mass transfer rate systems, with M dot about about 10-7M /yr, agree with the standard disk model; the remaining systems are better fitted when the outer disk is heated to about 12,000 K. We suggest that irradiation from the heated WD, inner disk, together with tidal interaction, the bright spot, and material overflowing the disk edge, can increase the temperature of the outer disk.
Sources
- A brief introductory guide to TLUSTY and SYNSPEC
- TLUSTY User's Guide II: Reference Manual
- TLUSTY User's Guide III: Operational Manual
Related papers
- He-star donor pathway for the hypervelocity star D6-2
- The ASPIICS solar coronagraph aboard the Proba-3 formation flying mission. Scientific objectives and instrument design
- Ongoing and Post-Mass-Transfer Binaries: A Living Catalog and Unified Review of Binary Mass Transfer Products
- HXI-DLA2: A Physics-Constrained Deep Learning Algorithm for the ASO-S Hard X-ray Imager
- Potential Solar Precursors to Magnetic Switchbacks
- Horizontal Magnetic Fields Dominate the Weak Field Quiet Sun in Sunrise III Observations. Evidence from Traditional and Transformer-Based Inversions